In vitro conversion of mammalian prion protein into amyloid fibrils displays unusual features

The "protein only" hypothesis of prion propagation postulates that the abnormal isoform of the prion protein, PrP(Sc), acts as a causative and transmissible agent of prion disease. In attempt to reconstitute prion infectivity in vitro, we previously developed a cell-free conversion protocol for generating amyloid fibrils from a recombinant prion protein encompassing residues 89-231 (rPrP 89-230) [Baskakov et al. (2002) J. Biol. Chem. 277, 21140]. When inoculated into transgenic mice, these amyloid fibrils induced prion disease, which can be efficiently transmitted to both wild-type and transgenic mice [Legname et al. (2004) Science 305, 673]. Here we show that the polymerization of rPrPs into the fibrils displays a number of distinctive kinetic features that are not typical for polymerization by other amyloidogenic polypeptides. Specifically, the lag phase of polymerization showed only modest dependence on protein concentration, and the conversion reaction displayed a dramatic volume-dependent threshold effect. To explain these unique kinetic features, we proposed that the conversion reaction is regulated by the dynamics between the rates of multiplication and deactivation of self-propagating fibrillar isoforms. Our further studies demonstrated that surface-dependent sorption of fibrillar isoforms is responsible for their deactivation in vitro, while fibril fragmentation seems to account for the multiplication of the active centers of polymerization. Our findings support the hypothesis that development of prion disease is controlled by a fine dynamic balance between self-propagation and clearance/deactivation of PrP(Sc).     

UV-light exposed prion protein fails to form amyloid fibrils

Amyloid fibril formation involves three steps; structural perturbation, nucleation and elongation. We have investigated amyloidogenesis using prion protein as a model system and UV-light as a structural perturbant. We find that UV-exposed prion protein fails to form amyloid fibrils. Interestingly, if provided with pre-formed fibrils as seeds, UV-exposed prion protein formed amyloid fibrils albeit with slightly different morphology. Atomic force microscopy and electron microscopic studies clearly show the formation of fibrils under these conditions. Circular dichroism study shows loss in helicity in UV-exposed protein. UV-exposed prion protein fails to form amyloid fibrils. However, it remains competent for fibril extension, suggesting that UV-exposure results in loss of nucleating capability. This work opens up possibility of segregating nucleation and elongation step of amyloidogenesis, facilitating screening of new drug candidates for specifically inhibiting either of these processes. In addition, the work also highlights the importance of light-induced structural and functional alterations which are important in protein based therapeutics.     

Optimal atomic-resolution structures of prion AGAAAAGA amyloid fibrils

X-ray crystallography is a powerful tool to determine the protein 3D structure. However, it is time-consuming and expensive, and not all proteins can be successfully crystallized, particularly for membrane proteins. Although nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is indeed a very powerful tool in determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins, it is also time-consuming and costly. To the best of the authors' knowledge, there is little structural data available on the AGAAAAGA palindrome in the hydrophobic region (113-120) of prion proteins due to the noncrystalline and insoluble nature of the amyloid fibril, although many experimental studies have shown that this region has amyloid fibril forming properties and plays an important role in prion diseases. In view of this, the present study is devoted to address this problem from computational approaches such as global energy optimization, simulated annealing, and structural bioinformatics. The optimal atomic-resolution structures of prion AGAAAAGA amyloid fibils reported in this paper have a value to the scientific community in its drive to find treatments for prion diseases.     

Silent prions lying in wait: a two-hit model of prion/amyloid formation and infection

Diseases such as type 2 diabetes, Alzheimer's and Parkinson's are associated with the formation of amyloid. The transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, such as variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, are believed to result from infectious forms of amyloid proteins termed prions. The ability of amyloid to initiate spontaneously and in the case of prions, to transfer successfully from one host to another, has been hard to fully rationalize. In this paper we use a mathematical model to explore the idea that it might be a combination of the presence of the prion/amyloid form and a change in the state of the host that allows the amyloid/prion to successfully initiate and propagate itself. We raise the intriguing possibility that potentially infectious amyloid may lie dormant in an apparently healthy individual awaiting a change in the state of the host or transmittal to a new more susceptible host. On this basis we make an analogy between prion/amyloid disease development and the two-hit model of cancer progression. We additionally raise the possibility that infectious amyloid strains may be characterized by a size distribution of length or radius.     

Full-length prion protein aggregates to amyloid fibrils and spherical particles by distinct pathways

As limited structural information is available on prion protein (PrP) misfolding and aggregation, a causative link between the specific (supra)molecular structure of PrP and transmissible spongiform encephalopathies remains to be elucidated. In this study, high pressure was utilized, as an approach to perturb protein structure, to characterize different morphological and structural PrP aggregates. It was shown that full-length recombinant PrP undergoes beta-sheet aggregation on high-pressure-induced destabilization. By tuning the physicochemical conditions, the assembly process evolves through two distinct pathways leading to the irreversible formation of spherical particles or amyloid fibrils, respectively. When the PrP aggregation propensity is enhanced, high pressure induces the formation of a partially unfolded aggregated protein, Agg(HP), which relaxes at ambient pressure to form amorphous aggregates. The latter largely retain the native secondary structure. On prolonged incubation at high pressure, followed by depressurization, Agg(HP) transforms to a monodisperse population of spherical particles of about 20 nm in diameter, characterized by an essentially beta-sheet secondary structure. When the PrP aggregation propensity is decreased, an oligomeric reaction intermediate, I(HP), is formed under high pressure. After pressure release, I(HP) relaxes to the original native structure. However, on prolonged incubation at high pressure and subsequent depressurization, it transforms to amyloid fibrils. Structural evaluation, using optical spectroscopic methods, demonstrates that the conformation adopted by the subfibrillar oligomeric intermediate, I(HP), constitutes a necessary prerequisite for the formation of amyloids. The use of high-pressure perturbation thus provides an insight into the molecular mechanism of the first stages of PrP misfolding into amyloids.     

Branched chain mechanism of polymerization and ultrastructure of prion protein amyloid fibrils

The discovery of prion disease and the establishment of the protein only hypothesis of prion propagation raised substantial interest in the class of maladies referred to as conformational diseases. Although significant progress has been made in elucidating the mechanisms of polymerization for several amyloidogenic proteins and peptides linked to conformational disorders and solving their fibrillar 3D structures, studies of prion protein amyloid fibrils and their polymerization mechanism have proven to be very difficult. The present minireview introduces the mechanism of branched-chain reaction for describing the peculiar kinetics of prion polymerization and summarizes our current knowledge about the substructure of prion protein amyloid fibrils.     

Optimal molecular structures of prion AGAAAAGA amyloid fibrils formatted by simulated annealing

To date, there is little structural data available on the AGAAAAGA palindrome in the hydrophobic region (113–120) of prion proteins, although many experimental studies have shown that this region has amyloid fibril forming properties. This region belongs to the N-terminal unstructured region (1–123) of prions, the structure of which has proved hard to determine using NMR or X-ray crystallography. This paper reports the successful construction of three amyloid fibril models for this region. The models were formatted by standard simulated annealing using suitable templates from the Protein Data Bank, and were refined using several traditional optimization methods within AMBER. Because the NMR or X-ray structure of the hydrophobic region AGAAAAGA of prion proteins has not yet been determined, these models can be used as a reference for experimental studies on this region. The results presented here confirm standard simulated annealing as an effective tool in molecular modeling. The three constructed models for amyloid fibrils may be useful in furthering the goals of medicinal chemistry in this field.     

Evidence for stepwise formation of amyloid fibrils by the mouse prion protein

The full-length mouse prion protein, moPrP, is shown to form worm-like amyloid fibrils at pH 2 in the presence of 0.15 M NaCl, in a slow process that is accelerated at higher temperatures. Upon reduction in pH to 2, native moPrP transforms into a mixture of soluble β-rich oligomers and α-rich monomers, which exist in a slow, concentration-dependent equilibrium with each other. It is shown that only the β-rich oligomers and not the α-rich monomers, can form worm-like amyloid fibrils. The mechanism of formation of the worm-like amyloid fibrils from the β-rich oligomers has been studied with four different physical probes over a range of temperatures and over a range of protein concentrations. The observed rate of fibrillation is the same, whether measured by changes in ellipticity at 216 nm, in thioflavin fluorescence upon binding, or in the mean hydrodynamic radius. The observed rate is significantly slower when monitored by total scattering intensity, suggesting that lateral association of the worm-like fibrils occurs after they form. The activation energy for worm-like fibril formation was determined to be 129 kJ/mol. The observed rate of fibrillation increases with an increase in protein concentration, but saturates at protein concentrations above 50 μM. The dependence of the observed rate of fibrillation on protein concentration suggests that aggregate growth is rate-limiting at low protein concentration and that conformational change, which is independent of protein concentration, becomes rate-limiting at higher protein concentrations. Hence, fibril formation by moPrP occurs in at least two separate steps. Longer but fewer worm-like fibrils are seen to form at low protein concentration, and shorter but more worm-like fibrils are seen to form at higher protein concentrations. This observation suggests that the β-rich oligomers grow progressively in size to form critical higher order-oligomers from which the worm-like amyloid fibrils then form.     

Polymorphism and ultrastructural organization of prion protein amyloid fibrils: an insight from high resolution atomic force microscopy

Amyloid fibrils were produced from the full-length mouse prion protein (PrP) under solvent conditions similar to those used for the generation of synthetic prions from PrP 89-230. Analysis of the ultrastructure by atomic force microscopy revealed extremely broad polymorphism in fibrils formed under a single growth condition. Fibrils varied with respect to the number of constitutive filaments and the manner in which the filaments were assembled. PrP polymerization was found to show several peculiar features: (i) the higher-order fibrils/ribbons were formed through a highly hierarchical mechanism of assembly of lower-order fibrils/ribbons; (ii) the lateral assembly proceeded stepwise; at each step, a semi-stable fibrillar species were generated, which were then able to enter the next level of assembly; (iii) the assembly of lower into higher-order fibrils occurred predominantly in a vertical dimension via stacking of ribbons on top of each other; (iv) alternative modes of lateral association co-existed under a single growth condition; (iv) the fibrillar morphology changed even within individual fibrils, illustrating that alternative modes of filament assembly are inter-convertible and thermodynamically equivalent. The most predominant fibrillar types were classified into five groups according to their height, each of which was divided in up to three subgroups according to their width. Detailed analysis of ultrastructure revealed that the fibrils of the major subtype (height 3.61(+/-0.28)nm, width 31.1(+/-2.0)nm) were composed of two ribbons, each of which was composed of two filaments. The molecular volume calculations indicated that a single PrP molecule occupied a distance of approximately 1.2 nm within a single filament. High polymorphism in fibrils generated in vitro is reminiscent of high morphological diversity of scrapie-associated fibrils isolated from scrapie brains, suggesting that polymorphism is peculiar for polymerization of PrP regardless of whether fibrils are formed in vitro or under pathological conditions in vivo.     

Amyloid fibrils of mammalian prion protein are highly toxic to cultured cells and primary neurons

A growing body of evidence indicates that small, soluble oligomeric species generated from a variety of proteins and peptides rather than mature amyloid fibrils are inherently highly cytotoxic. Here, we show for the first time that mature amyloid fibrils produced from full-length recombinant mammalian prion protein (rPrP) were highly toxic to cultured cells and primary hippocampal and cerebella neurons. Fibrils induced apoptotic cell death in a time- and dose-dependent manner. The toxic effect of fibrils was comparable with that exhibited by soluble small beta-oligomers generated from the same protein. Fibrils prepared from insulin were not toxic, suggesting that the toxic effect was not solely due to the highly polymeric nature of the fibrillar form. The cell death caused by rPrP fibrils or beta-oligomers was substantially reduced when expression of endogenous PrP(C) was down-regulated by small interfering RNAs. In opposition to the beta-oligomer and amyloid fibrils of rPrP, the monomeric alpha-helical form of rPrP stimulated neurite out-growth and survival of neurons. These studies illustrated that both soluble beta-oligomer and amyloid fibrils of the prion protein are intrinsically toxic and confirmed that endogenously expressed PrP(C) is required for mediating the toxicity of abnormally folded external PrP aggregates.     

Annealing prion protein amyloid fibrils at high temperature results in extension of a proteinase K-resistant core

Amyloids are highly ordered, rigid beta-sheet-rich structures that appear to have minimal dynamic flexibility in individual polypeptide chains. Here, we demonstrate that substantial conformational rearrangements occur within mature amyloid fibrils produced from full-length mammalian prion protein. The rearrangement results in a substantial extension of a proteinase K-resistant core and is accompanied by an increase in the beta-sheet-rich conformation. The conformational rearrangement was induced in the presence of low concentrations of Triton X-100 either by brief exposure to 80 degrees C or, with less efficacy, by prolonged incubation at 37 degrees C at pH 7.5 and is referred to here as "annealing." Upon annealing, amyloid fibrils acquired a proteinase K-resistant core identical to that found in bovine spongiform encephalopathy-specific scrapie-associated prion protein. Annealing was also observed when amyloid fibrils were exposed to high temperatures in the absence of detergent but in the presence of brain homogenate. These findings suggest that the amyloid fibrils exist in two conformationally distinct states that are separated by a high energy barrier and that yet unknown cellular cofactors may facilitate transition of the fibrils into thermodynamically more stable state. Our studies provide new insight into the complex behavior of prion polymerization and highlight the annealing process, a previously unknown step in the evolution of amyloid structures.     

Recovery of functional enzyme from amyloid fibrils

Amyloid deposits, which accumulate in numerous diseases, are the final stage of multi-step protein conformational-conversion and oligomerization processes. The underlying molecular mechanisms are not fully understood, and particularly little is known about the reverse reaction. Here we show that phosphoglycerate kinase amyloid fibrils can be converted back into native protein. We achieved recovery with 60% efficiency, which is comparable to the success rate of the unfolding-refolding studies, and the recovered enzyme was folded, stable and fully active. The key intermediate stages in the recovery process are fibril disassembly and unfolding followed by spontaneous protein folding.     

Copper(II) inhibits in vitro conversion of prion protein into amyloid fibrils

In recent studies, the amyloid fibrils produced in vitro from recombinant prion protein encompassing residues 89-230 (rPrP 89-230) were shown to produce transmissible form of prion disease in transgenic mice (Legname et al., (2004) Science 305, 673-676). Long incubation time observed upon inoculation of the amyloid fibrils, however, suggests that the fibrils generated in vitro have low infectivity titers. These results emphasize the need to define optimal conditions for prion conversion in vitro, under which high levels of infectivity can be generated in a cell-free system. Because copper(II) has been implicated in normal and pathological functions of the prion protein, here we investigated the effect of Cu(2+) on cell-free conversion of recombinant PrP. Our results show that at pH 7.2 and at micromolar concentrations, Cu(2+) inhibited conversion of full-length recombinant PrP (rPrP 23-230) into amyloid fibrils. This effect was most pronounced for Cu(2+), and less so for Zn(2+), while Mn(2+) had no effect on the conversion. Cu(2+)-dependent inhibition of the amyloid formation was less effective at pH 6.0, at which rPrP 23-230 displays lower Cu(2+)-binding capacity. Using rPrP 89-230, we found that Cu(2+)-dependent inhibition occurred even in the absence of octarepeat region; however, it was less effective. Our further studies indicated that Cu(2+) inhibited conversion by stabilizing a nonamyloidogenic PK-resistant form of alpha-rPrP. Remarkably, Cu(2+) also had a profound effect on preformed amyloid fibrils. When added to the fibrils, Cu(2+) induced long-range coiling of individual fibrils and enhanced their PK-resistance. It, however, produced only minor changes in their secondary structures. In addition, Cu(2+) induced further aggregation of the amyloid fibrils into large clumps, presumably, through interfibrillar coordination of copper ions by octarepeats. Taken together, our studies suggest that the role of Cu(2+) in the pathogenesis of prion diseases is complex. Because Cu(2+) may inhibit prion replication, while at the same time stabilize disease-specific isoform against proteolytic clearance, the final outcome of copper-induced effect on progression of prion disease may not be straightforward.     

Molecular structure of amyloid fibrils: insights from solid-state NMR

Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) measurements have made major contributions to our understanding of the molecular structures of amyloid fibrils, including fibrils formed by the beta-amyloid peptide associated with Alzheimer's disease, by proteins associated with fungal prions, and by a variety of other polypeptides. Because solid-state NMR techniques can be used to determine interatomic distances (both intramolecular and intermolecular), place constraints on backbone and side-chain torsion angles, and identify tertiary and quaternary contacts, full molecular models for amyloid fibrils can be developed from solid-state NMR data, especially when supplemented by lower-resolution structural constraints from electron microscopy and other sources. In addition, solid-state NMR data can be used as experimental tests of various proposals and hypotheses regarding the mechanisms of amyloid formation, the nature of intermediate structures, and the common structural features within amyloid fibrils. This review introduces the basic experimental and conceptual principles behind solid-state NMR methods that are applicable to amyloid fibrils, reviews the information about amyloid structures that has been obtained to date with these methods, and discusses how solid-state NMR data provide insights into the molecular interactions that stabilize amyloid structures, the generic propensity of polypeptide chains to form amyloid fibrils, and a number of related issues that are of current interest in the amyloid field.     

Site-specific conformational studies of prion protein (PrP) amyloid fibrils revealed two cooperative folding domains within amyloid structure

Despite the ability of most proteins to form amyloid, very little is know about amyloid fibril structures and the factors that govern their stability. Using amyloid fibrils produced from full-length prion protein (PrP), we describe a reliable approach for determining both site-specific and global conformational stability of the fibrillar form. To measure site-specific stability, we produced six variants of PrP by replacing the residues at positions 88, 98, 127, 144, 196, and 230 with cysteine, labeled the new cysteines with the fluorescent dye acrylodan, and investigated their conformational status within the amyloid form in guanidine hydrochloride-induced denaturation experiments. We found that the fibrils labeled at positions 127, 144, 196, and 230 displayed cooperative unfolding and showed a very high C1/2 value similar to that observed for the global unfolding of the amyloid structure. The unfolding at residue 98 was also cooperative; however, it showed a C1/2 value substantially lower than that of global unfolding, whereas the unfolding of fibrils labeled at residue 88 was non-cooperative. These data illustrate that there are at least two independent cooperative folding domains within the amyloid structure of the full-length PrP. In addition, kinetic experiments revealed only a partial overlap between the region that constituted the fibrillar cross-beta core and the regions that were involved in nucleation. This result illustrates that separate PrP regions accounted for the nucleation and for the formation of the conformationally most stable fibrillar core.     

Mechanical unbinding of abeta peptides from amyloid fibrils

Using the experimental structures of Abeta amyloid fibrils and all-atom molecular dynamics, we study the force-induced unbinding of Abeta peptides from the fibril. We show that the mechanical dissociation of Abeta peptides is highly anisotropic and proceeds via different pathways when force is applied in parallel or perpendicular direction with respect to the fibril axis. The threshold forces associated with lateral unbinding of Abeta peptides exceed those observed during the mechanical dissociation along the fibril axis. In addition, Abeta fibrils are found to be brittle in the lateral direction of unbinding and soft along the fibril axis. Lateral mechanical unbinding and the unbinding along the fibril axis load different types of fibril interactions. Lateral unbinding is primarily determined by the cooperative rupture of fibril backbone hydrogen bonds. The unbinding along the fibril axis largely depends on the interpeptide Lys-Asp electrostatic contacts and the hydrophobic interactions formed by the Abeta C terminal. Due to universality of the amyloid beta structure, the anisotropic mechanical dissociation observed for Abeta fibrils is likely to be applicable to other amyloid assemblies. The estimates of equilibrium forces required to dissociate Abeta peptide from the amyloid fibril suggest that these supramolecular structures are mechanically stronger than most protein domains.     

Ultrastructure of amyloid fibrils in Alzheimer's disease and Down's syndrome

Amyloid fibrils in brains of patients with Alzheimer's disease and Down's syndrome were examined by light and electron microscopy. In addition, replicas of amyloid fibrils produced by a quick freezing method from the brain of a patient with Down's syndrome were examined by electron microscopy. The amyloid fibrils were shown to consist of hollow rods. These were composed of filaments arranged as a tightly coiled helix, each turn of which consisted of five globular subunits. This structure appears to be similar to the prion filament observed in Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD). The possibility therefore arises that amyloid fibrils in Alzheimer's disease and Down's syndrome may be related to the transmissible agents responsible for diseases such as CJD, kuru and Gerstmann-Str?ussler Syndrome (GSS).     

Ultrastructure of perivascular amyloid fibrils in Alzheimer’s disease

Perivascular amyloid fibrils in the brains of patients with Alzheimer's disease have been examined by electron microscopy. The amyloid fibrils showed a hollow rod structure and consisted of globular substances. Each turn appeared to be composed of five globular subunits. These findings coincide with the ultrastructure of amyloid fibrils obtained from replicas made by a rapid freezing method.