The effect of dose fractionation on the frequency of ethylnitrosourea-induced dominant cataract and recessive specific locus mutations in germ cells of the mouse

A combined dominant cataract-recessive specific locus mutation experiment for fractionated exposure to ethylnitrosourea (2 X 80 mg/kg, 24-h fractionation interval) was designed to determine if lower doses of ethylnitrosourea are more effective in inducing dominant cataract mutations as suggested by previous results. This observation was not confirmed by the present experiment. The extensive, statistically more reliable specific locus results indicate an additive effect of fractionated ethylnitrosourea treatment. A saturable repair system for ethylnitrosourea-induced DNA damage has been previously documented (Karran et al., 1979; Sega et al., 1986; Van Zeeland et al., 1985). Two parameters inherent to a saturable system, the minimal time required for the saturated system to recover and the minimal dose to saturate the system are important, and results of experiments employing a fractionation exposure protocol must be interpreted relative to these two parameters. Longer fractionation intervals or smaller doses result in a reduced mutagenic effect. Due to the inherently lower experimental variability of the specific locus mutation assay as compared to the dominant cataract assay, the specific locus assay is the test of choice to determine factors affecting the mammalian germ cell mutation rate. The dominant cataract test requires a larger investment of experimental resources to achieve a comparable degree of accuracy. The dominant cataract mutation test is important in assessing the mutation rate to dominant alleles in germ cells of mammals. Due to the immediate expression of the mutant phenotype in newly occurring dominant mutations, a dominant mutation assay screens a genetically relevant endpoint in an assessment of the mutagenic hazard for man in mouse experiments. A multi-endpoint design screening specific locus, dominant cataract, and biochemical mutational endpoints (Ehling et al., 1985) allows a systematic comparison of mutagenic results for different classes of mutations in the same animals.     

The mutagenic activity of ethylnitrosourea at low doses in spermatogonia of the mouse as assessed by the specific-locus test

Ethylnitrosourea is the most efficient chemical mutagen in spermatogonial stem cells of the mouse and its mutagenic activity has been intensively studied. The pertinent specific-locus mutation test results for a discussion of low dose–effect studies have been summarized and indicate: (1) A threshold dose response best characterizes the relationship between dose and mutation rate. (2) The reduced effectiveness of ethylnitrosourea in the low dose range is likely due to a saturable repair process. (3) The recovery of the saturable repair process as assessed in fractionated dose experiments is long (ca. 168 h). The dynamics of stem cell spermatogonia suggests a long time interval before the cell population passes through at least one cell division and this may be relevant to an interpretation of the fractionation effects. (4) There is a slight but important discrepancy between the predicted and observed mutagenic activity of ethylnitrosourea in the low dose range. This is interpreted to be due to the differences between a mathematical abstraction and the biological realities of the system being studied.     

The frequency of dominant cataract and recessive specific-locus mutations and mutation mosaics in F1 mice derived from post-spermatogonial treatment with ethylnitrosourea

The frequency of dominant cataract and recessive specific-locus mutations and mutation mosaics was determined in F1 mice derived from post-spermatogonial germ-cell stage treatment with 2 X 80, 160 or 250 mg/kg ethylnitrosourea. A total of 5 dominant cataract mutations, 3 dominant cataract mutation mosaics, 1 specific-locus mutation and 9 specific-locus mutation mosaics were recovered in 15,542 screened F1 offspring. Results indicate that ethylnitrosourea treatment increases the mutation rate of dominant cataract and recessive specific-locus alleles in post-spermatogonial germ-cell stages of the mouse and that the mutations occur mainly as mosaics. Genetic confirmation of newly induced mutations occurring as mosaics is more problematical for induced recessive alleles than for induced dominant alleles and should be considered when evaluating such mutagenicity results.     

The frequency of dominant cataract and recessive specific-locus mutations in mice derived from 80 or 160 mg ethylnitrosourea per kg body weight treated spermatogonia

A systematic comparison of the frequency of dominant cataract and recessive specific-locus mutations in mice has been extended to include results for 80 and 160 mg ethylnitrosourea per kg body weight spermatogonial treatment. The frequency of confirmed dominant cataract mutations in the historical control, 80 and 160 mg/kg ethylnitrosourea treatment groups was 1/22594, 8/5090 and 14/6435, respectively. The frequency of recessive specific-locus mutations in the same dose groups was, respectively, 19/227805, 20/13274 and 35/8658. These present results confirm previous results, which indicate that ethylnitrosourea is effective in inducing both recessive specific-locus and dominant cataract mutations although the per locus mutation rate to recessive alleles was observed to be approximately 6 times greater than the per locus mutation rate to dominant alleles. The exclusion of certain classes of lens opacity variant phenotypes, previously demonstrated not to be due to a dominant mutation, from the group of suspected dominant cataract mutations subjected to a genetic confirmation test has greatly improved the efficiency of the test. A total of 23 dominant cataract mutations were confirmed from a group of 67 phenotypic variants. Of the 23 confirmed dominant cataract mutations, 8 were shown to have reduced transmission to the following generation of offspring expressing the mutant phenotype. These results are also consistent with previous results for ethylnitrosourea or radiation treatment in which it was shown that approximately one-third of the recovered mutations have reduced penetrance. One group of dominant cataract mutations, with phenotypic effects on the polar, sub-capsular or corneal regions, is overly represented in the group of recovered mutations with a reduced transmission of offspring expressing the mutant phenotype. Two hypotheses are suggested for this observation, both dependent on the fact that the regions affected indicate that the mutations are expressed later in the development of the eye. Either all carrier individuals have not expressed the phenotype at the time of examination and classification, or later acting mutations are more subject to environmental interactions resulting in more variable expression. Finally, it is argued that a dominant cataract mutation test represents a most practicable protocol to screen for induced dominant mutations in germ cells of the mouse. The imposition of the criterion that suspected variants be subjected to a genetic confirmation test has at least two advantages beside the fact that results represent unambiguous mutational events.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Towards an understanding of the nature and fitness of induced mutations in germ cells of mice: homozygous viability and heterozygous fitness effects of induced specific-locus, dominant cataract and enzyme-activity mutations

A total of 219 specific-locus, 35 dominant cataract and 44 enzyme-activity mutations induced in spermatogonia of mice by radiation or ethylnitrosourea (ENU) treatment were characterized for homozygous viability as well as fitness effects on heterozygous carriers. For all 3 genetic endpoints, the frequency of homozygous lethal mutations was higher in the group of radiation-induced mutations than in the ENU-treatment group. These observations are consistent with the hypothesis that radiation-induced mutations recovered in the mouse are mainly due to small deletions while ENU induces mainly intragenic mutations. The overall fitness of mutant heterozygotes was reduced for the group of radiation-induced specific-locus, dominant cataract and enzyme-activity mutations while the ENU-induced mutations exhibited no reduction in fitness. The fitness reduction of heterozygous carriers for a newly occurring mutation in a population is important in determining the persistence of the mutation in a population, and thus the total number of individuals affected before a mutation is eventually eliminated from the population. For the present results a maximal persistence of 12 generations and a minimal persistence of 3 generations is estimated. These results are consistent with the 6-7-generation persistence time assumed by UNSCEAR (1982) in an estimate of the overall effects of radiation-induced mutations in man.     

Induction of specific-locus and dominant lethal mutations in male mice by 1-methyl-1-nitrosourea (MNU)

1-Methyl-1-nitrosourea (MNU) induced specific-locus mutations in mice in all spermatogenic stages except spermatozoa. After intraperitoneal injection of 70 mg/kg body weight of MNU a high yield of specific-locus mutations was observed in spermatids (21.8 × 10⁻⁵ mutations per locus per gamete). The highest mutational yield was induced in differentiating spermatogonia. In 1954 offspring we observed 5 specific-locus mutants (44.8 × 10⁻ mutations per locus per gamete). In addition, 2 mosaics were recovered, which gave a combined mutation rate of 62.7 × 10⁻⁵. In A_s spermatogonia the mutation rate was 3.9 × 10⁻⁵. The same dose of 70 mg/kg of MNU induced dominant lethal mutations 5–48 days post treatment, mainly due to post-implantation loss in spermatids and spermatocytes. It is interesting to compare the induction pattern of mutations by MNU with methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) and ethylnitrosourea (ENU). Based on the different spermatogenic response of the induction of specific-locus mutations we can characterize the 4 mutagens in the following way: EMS = MMS ≠ MNU ≠ ENU.     

Induction of gene mutations in mice: The multiple endpoint approach

The multiple endpoint mammalian mutagenesis approach developed in our institute screens in the same animal for recessive specific-locus alleles at 7 loci, approximately 30 loci coding for dominant-cataract mutations, 23 loci controlling protein-charge changes and 12 loci for enzyme-activity alterations. Experiments to screen for the approximately 70 loci in the same offspring of treated male mice were performed with ethylnitrosourea (ENU), procarbazine and X-ray exposure. Mutations were recovered for each genetic endpoint in all treatment groups where a sufficient number of offspring was scored. ENU treatment is highly effective in inducing mutations to all genetic endpoints. The mutations were confirmed by breeding tests. The mutation rates to specific-locus and enzyme-activity alleles were both higher than the mutation rates to either dominant-cataract or protein-charge alleles. The advantages and possibilities of the multiple endpoint approach are discussed in detail.     

Dominant cataract and recessive specific-locus mutations detected in offspring of procarbazine-treated male mice

The induction of dominant cataract mutations by procarbazine was studied concomitantly with the induction of specific-locus mutations in treated male mice. The most effective dose in the specific-locus test, 600 mg/kg of procarbazine, and a fractionated dose of 5 X 200 mg/kg were used. The frequencies of dominant cataract mutations were higher, but not significantly different from the historical control. The ratio between the number of recovered specific-locus and dominant cataract mutations was in accordance with that found in our experiments with gamma-rays (Ehling et al., 1982; Kratochvilova, 1981) or in experiments with ethylnitrosourea (Favor, 1986). A total of 3 dominant cataract mutations were recovered in the offspring of procarbazine-treated spermatogonial stem cells. Two mutations had complete penetrance while the third exhibited a reduced penetrance of approximately 70%. The viability and fertility of the heterozygotes of all 3 mutations were not affected. Only 1 mutation was shown to be viable as a homozygote.     

Induction of specific locus mutations in mouse spermatogonial stem cells by combined chemical X-ray treatments

Data that demonstrate how the biology of spermatogenesis plays an important role in determining the yield of genetic damage from ionizing radiation are briefly reviewed. It is suggested that for valid extrapolations of data from mouse mutation experiments to man detailed knowledge of the spermatogonial stem cell systems in the two species is required. Two new sets of mouse specific mutation data are presented. (1) When a 2 mg/kg dose of triethylenemelamine (TEM) was used as a conditioning dose and followed 24 h later by 6 Gy X-rays, the mutation yield from spermatogonial stem cells was over twice as high (30.20 X 10(-5)/locus/gamete) as that when the X-ray dose was given alone (13.75 X 10(-5)/locus/gamete). No such effect was found when the TEM was given only 3 h prior to the X-irradiation. Since TEM at the dose used is inefficient at inducing specific-locus mutations, an augmentation of the X-ray response is indicated. It has therefore been concluded that the augmented mutation responses obtained with equal 24 h X-ray fractionations at high doses are attributable to mutation induction by the second dose. The responsive cells would be the formerly resistant component of the stem cell population that had survived the TEM treatment and that had been 'triggered' into a radiosensitive phase by the population depletion. (2) When 2 doses of 500 mg/kg hydroxyurea (HU) were given 3 h apart 3 h prior to 6 Gy X-rays to reduce the numbers of stem cells in the S and G2 phases of the cell cycle exposed to the radiation, the mutation responses was greatly enhanced to a level that is the highest yet recorded per unit X-ray dose (7.10 X 10(-5)/locus/gamete/Gy). No such effect was obtained when the intervals between the HU and X-ray treatments were either shorter (less than 0.5 h) or longer (24 h). It was concluded that X-ray-induced specific-locus mutations derive principally from stem cells in the G1 phase of the cell cycle. The reasons why the X-ray-induced mutation-yields from repopulating stem cells (with a short cell cycle and, hence, short G1 phase) are similar to those from undamaged stem cell populations, in contrast to translocation yields, therefore remains unresolved.     

The effect of dose rate on the frequency of specific-locus mutations induced in mouse spermatogonia is restricted to larger lesions; a retrospective analysis of historical data

A series of 19 large-scale germ-cell mutagenesis experiments conducted several decades ago led to the conclusion that low-LET radiation delivered to mouse spermatogonia at dose rates of 0.8 R/min and below induced only about one-third as many specific-locus mutations as did single, acute exposures at 24 R/min and above. A two-hit origin of the mutations was deemed unlikely in view of the then prevailing evidence for the small size of genetic lesions in spermatogonia. Instead, the dose-rate effect was hypothesized to be the result of a repair system that exists in spermatogonia, but not in more mature male reproductive cells. More recent genetic and molecular studies on the marker genes have identified the phenotypes associated with specific states of the mutant chromosomes, and it is now possible retrospectively to classify individual past mutations as "large lesions" or "other lesions". The mutation-frequency difference between high and low dose rates is restricted to the large lesion mutations, for which the dose-curve slopes differ by a factor exceeding 3.4. For other lesion mutations, there is essentially no difference between the slopes for protracted and acute irradiations; induced other lesions frequencies per unit dose remain similar for dose rates ranging over more than 7 orders of magnitude. For large lesions, these values rise sharply at dose rates >0.8 R/min, though they remain similar within the whole range of protracted doses, failing to provide evidence for a threshold dose rate. The downward bend at high doses that had been noted for X-ray-induced specific-locus mutations as a whole and ascribed to a positive correlation between spermatogonial death and mutation load is now found to be restricted to large lesion mutations. There is a marked difference between the mutation spectra (distributions among the seven loci) for large lesions and other lesions. Within each class, however, the spectra are similar for acute and protracted irradiation.     

Frequency and nature of specific-locus mutations induced in female mice by radiations and chemicals: a review.

The inducibility of heritable mutations in female mammals has been measured in the mouse specific-locus test (SLT). For radiation-induced mutations, a large body of data has been accumulated that includes information about biological and physical factors that influence mutation yields. However, relatively few SLT studies in females have been conducted with chemicals to date. A single estimate of the spontaneous mutation rate in oocytes, 6/536,207, has been derived as the most appropriate one to subtract from experimental rates. This rate is highly significantly below the spontaneous mutation rate in males. Mutations recovered from females mutagenized at any time after about the 12th day post-conception are induced in non-dividing cells. In adult females, most oocytes are arrested in small follicles; maturation from this stage to ovulation takes several weeks. High-dose-rate radiations are more mutagenic in mature and maturing oocytes than in spermatogonia of the male; on the other hand, no clearly induced mutations have been recovered from irradiated arrested oocytes. Efficient repair processes have been invoked to explain the latter finding as well as the upward-curving dose-effect relation for acute irradiation, and the fact that dose protraction drastically reduces mutation yield from mature and maturing oocytes. The dose-protraction effect is much greater than that found in spermatogonia. Radiation-induced mutation rates in embryonic, fetal, and newborn females are overall lower than those in the mature and maturing oocytes of adults. A dose-protraction effect has also been demonstrated at an early developmental stage when the nuclear morphology of mouse oocytes most resembles that of the human. Of only 5 chemicals so far explored for their effect in oocytes, 2 (ethylnitrosourea, ENU, and triethylenemelamine, TEM), and possibly a third (procarbazine hydrochloride, PRC), are mutagenic--with at least one of these (ENU) mutagenic in arrested as well as maturing oocytes. However, the mutation rate is, in each case, lower than for treated male germ cells. By contrast, ENU-induced mutation yield for the maternal genome of the zygote is an order of magnitude higher than that for the zygote's paternal genome or for spermatogonia. A high proportion of mutants derived from chemical treatment of oocytes (including the oocyte genome in zygotes) are mosaics, probably owing to lesions affecting only 1 strand of the DNA. A characteristic of specific-locus mutations induced in oocytes is that they include a considerably higher percentage of large (multi-locus) lesions (LLs) than do mutations induced in spermatogonia.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Bleomycin, unlike other male-mouse mutagens, is most effective in spermatogonia, inducing primarily deletions

Dominant-lethal tests [P.D. Sudman, J.C. Rutledge, J.B. Bishop, W.M. Generoso, Bleomycin: female-specific dominant lethal effects in mice, Mutat. Res. 296 (1992) 205-217] had suggested that Bleomycin sulfate (Blenoxane), BLM, might be a female-specific mutagen. While confirming that BLM is indeed a powerful inducer of dominant-lethal mutations in females that fails to induce such mutations in postspermatogonial stages of males, we have shown in a specific-locus test that BLM is, in fact, mutagenic in males. This mutagenicity, however, is restricted to spermatogonia (stem-cell and differentiating stages), for which the specific-locus mutation rate differed significantly (P<0.008) from the historical control rate. In treated groups, dominant mutations, also, originated only in spermatogonia. With regard to mutation frequencies, this germ-cell-stage pattern is different from that for radiation and for any other chemical studied to date, except ethylnitrosourea (ENU). However, the nature of the spermatogonial specific-locus mutations differentiates BLM from ENU as well, because BLM induced primarily (or, perhaps, exclusively) multilocus deletions. Heretofore, no chemical that induced specific-locus mutations in spermatogonia did not also induce specific-locus as well as dominant-lethal mutations in postspermatogonial stages, making the dominant lethal test, up till now, predictive of male mutagenicity in general. The BLM results now demonstrate that there are chemicals that can induce specific-locus mutations in spermatogonia without testing positive in postspermatogonial stages. Thus, BLM, while not female-specific, is unique, (a) in its germ-cell-stage specificity in males, and (b) in inducing a type of mutation (deletions) that is atypical for the responding germ-cell stages (spermatogonia).     

Induction of specific-locus mutations in male mice by ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS)

Using a sequential mating procedure, the induction of specific-locus mutations by ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) was reinvestigated in male mice. Doses of 175 mg/kg b.w. and 250 mg/kg b.w. of EMS induce gene mutations in the mating intervals 5-8 and 9-12 days post treatment. However, only the frequency of dominant lethal mutations increases with the dose, not the frequency of specific-locus mutations. This observation implies that with a higher dose of EMS a larger fraction of mutagenized spermatozoa and spermatids are selectively eliminated, leading to underestimation of the specific-locus mutation yield at high doses. EMS does not induce specific-locus mutations in spermatogonia.     

Induction of specific-locus and dominant-lethal mutations by cyclophosphamide and combined cyclophosphamide-radiation treatment in male mice

Cyclophosphamide is the most widely used antineoplastic agent. It is also used to condition patients for bone-marrow transplantations. Because of the general interest of this compound we initiated a systematic study of the induction of dominant-lethal and specific-locus mutations in male mice. In addition, we investigated the induction of specific-locus mutations by the combined treatment of cyclophosphamide and ionizing radiation.A dose of 40 mg/kg bw of cyclophosphamide caused dominant-lethal mutations in male mice only in the 1st and 2nd week after treatment. A dose of 120 mg/kg induced dominant-lethal mutations in the mating intervals 1–21 days posttreatment. No dominant lethal mutations were observed after the 3rd week. The same differential spermatogenic response was observed for the induction of specific-locus mutations. Cyclophosphamide induced recessive mutations exclusively in spermatozoa and spermatids. No mutations were recovered from treated spermatocytes and spermatogonia. In contrast to cyclophosphamide, radiation induces specific-locus mutations in all germ-cell stages.The pretreatment with cyclophosphamide 24 h before radiation enhanced the frequency of specific-locus mutations in spermatogonia. The distribution of the observed mutations among the 7 loci and their viability supports the hypothesis that these mutations were induced by radiation rather than by cyclophosphamide. The compound causes an immediate inhibition of DNA and RNA synthesis in spermatogonia. The inhibition very likely interferes with the repair process. The disturbance of the repair process is probably the cause of the synergistic effect for the induction of specific-locus mutations in spermatogonia of mice after pretreatment with cyclophosphamide 24 h before irradiation.     

Mutagenic activity of 2-amino-N6-hydroxyadenine in the mouse spot test.

The base analogue 2-amino-N6-hydroxyadenine (AHA) was mutagenic in the spot test in (T x HT)F1 mouse embryos. Females were injected with single doses of 20 or 40 mg AHA per kg body weight on the 9th day of pregnancy. To rank the mutagenic potency of different compounds, the frequencies of genetically relevant spots induced by 1 mg/kg body weight were calculated. The observed somatic mutation frequency for 1 mg/kg AHA was lower (1.95 x 10(-3)) spots of genetic relevance) than that of mitomycin C (16 x 10(-3)), ethylnitrosourea (6.8 x 10(-3)) and cyclophosphamide (6.4 x 10(-3)) and therefore AHA was not classified as a very potent mutagen in this test system. The doubling dose to induce genetically relevant spots was calculated to be 20 mg/kg b.w. Based on these data, AHA is suggested to be a candidate to induce recessive specific-locus mutations in germ cells of mice.     

DNA damage responses at low radiation doses

Increased cell killing after exposure to low acute doses of X rays (0-0.5 Gy) has been demonstrated in cells of a number of human tumor cell lines. The mechanisms underlying this effect have been assumed to be related to a threshold dose above which DNA repair efficiency or fidelity increases. We have used cells of two radioresistant human tumor cell lines, one that shows increased sensitivity to low radiation doses (T98G) and one that does not (U373), to investigate the DNA damage response at low doses in detail and to establish whether there is a discontinuous dose response or threshold in activation of any important mediators of this response. In the two cell lines studied, we found a sensitive, linear dose response in early signaling and transduction pathways between doses of 0.1 and 2 Gy with no evidence of a threshold dose. We demonstrate that ATM-dependent signaling events to downstream targets including TP53, CHK1 and CHK2 occur after doses as low as 0.2 Gy and that these events promote an effective damage response. Using chemical inhibition of specific DNA repair enzymes, we show that inhibition of DNA-PK-dependent end joining has relatively little effect at low (<1 Gy) doses in hyper-radiosensitive cells and that at these doses the influence of RAD51-mediated repair events may increase, based on high levels of RAD51/BRCA2 repair foci. These data do not support a threshold model for activation of DNA repair in hyper-radiosensitive cells but do suggest that the balance of repair enzyme activity may change at low doses.     

Risk estimation based on germ-cell mutations in animals

The set of mouse germ cell mutation rate results following spermatogonial exposure to high dose rate irradiation have been presented as the most relevant experimental results upon which to extrapolate the expected genetic risk of offspring of the survivors of the Hiroshima and Nagasaki atomic bombings. Results include mutation rates to recessive specific-locus, dominant cataract, protein-charge, and enzyme-activity alleles. The mutability as determined by the various genetic end points differed: the mutation rates to recessive specific-locus alleles and enzyme-activity alleles were similar and greater than the mutation rates to dominant cataract and protein-charge alleles. It is argued that the type of mutation event scored by a particular test will determine the mutability of the genetic end point screened. When the loss of functional gene product can be scored in a particular mutation test, as in the recessive specific-locus and enzyme-activity tests, a wide spectrum of DNA alterations may result in a loss of and a higher mutation rate is observed. When an altered gene product is scored, as in the dominant cataract and protein-charge tests, a narrower spectrum of DNA alterations is screened and a lower mutation rate is observed. The radiation doubling dose, defined as the dose that induces as many mutations as occur spontaneously per generation, was shown to be four times higher in the dominant cataract test than the specific-locus test. These results indicate that to extrapolate to genetic risks in humans using the doubling-dose method, the extrapolation must be based on experimental mutation rate results for the same genetic end point.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Dose-response curves for radiation-induced gene mutations in mouse oocytes and their interpretation

Previous work, in which female mice had been given fractionated doses of 20 X 10 rad X-rays, had confirmed and extended Russell's observations that the dose-response relationship for specific-locus mutations in mature-mouse oocytes is curved at low doses. The present work was intended to study the relationship at relatively high doses. Adult female mice were given doses of 200, 400 or 600 rad x-rays at 52 or 72 rad/min, and mated immediately. Offspring conceived in the first 7 days (i.e. using oocytes which were mature at time of treatment) were scored for specific-locus mutations. The data indicate that the departure from linearity of the dose-response curve is marginally significant at the 5% level. A quadratic dose-response curve (y = c + aD + bD2) and a square-law relationship (y = c + bD2) both give a good fit to the data. Both curves fit data of other authors obtained at low doses or dose-rates. These results could be interpreted either in terms of dose-dependent repair phenomena, or by considering specific-locus mutations as two-track events. In view of knowledge of other phenomena concerning mutation and cell killing in mouse oocytes, such as the variation in sensitivity of different cell stages, the interpretation in terms of repair phenomena is preferred.     

Models and assumptions underlying genetic risk assessment

Various methods employed for estimating the genetic risks of radiation are reviewed. With the doubling-dose method, genetic damage is expressed as an increase in cases of known genetic disease. The actual doubling dose is based on figures obtained with the mouse. There have been no recent data on induced mutation frequencies. Recent results suggest that the prevalence figure for multifactorial disease may be at least one order of magnitude higher than before. Various assumptions underlying the doubling-dose concept are discussed in the light of recent findings on: (1) spontaneous mutations resulting from insertion elements, and (2) the comparability between spontaneous and induced mutations. The so-called direct method makes use of figures for induction of dominant mutations affecting the skeleton and the lens of the eye in the mouse, and of translocation induction in monkeys. Induction rates are converted to overall rates of induced dominant effects in man by applying certain assumptions. The proportionality between dose and effect is the basis for all genetic risk assessments. The possible significance of data on human lymphocytes indicating a threshold below 4 rad and the induction of repair enzymes by low radiation doses is discussed. The parallelogram approach is based on the principle that estimates can be obtained on the amount of genetic damage that cannot always be assessed directly. Thus mutations in mouse germ cells can be predicted by using mutation frequencies in cultured mammalian cells and O6-ethylguanine adducts. Measurement of haemoglobin mutations in human and mouse erythrocytes, and of HPRT-deficient mutations in lymphocytes of man and mouse should make more precise estimates of mutation frequencies in human germ cells possible. The development of a database on mutations in somatic cells of the mouse, their induction frequencies and molecular nature are considered an important priority. Used in combination with mouse germ-cell mutation frequencies, they should enable more precise risk estimates on the basis of mutations in somatic cells of man.     

Studies on DNA repair in early spermatid stages of male mice after in vivo treatment with methyl-, ethyl-, propyl-, and isopropyl methanesulfonate.

In vivo DNA repair occurring in early spermatid stages of the mouse has been studied with four mutagens that are chemical homologs: MMS, EMS, PMS and IMS. Using the well-studied sequence of events that occurs during spermatogenesis and spermiogenesis in the mouse, aatids was measured by the unscheduled incorporation of [3H]dT into these germ cells which were recovered from the caudal epididymides 16 days after chemical treatment. Purification of the caudal sperm DNA at this time verified that the [3H]dT was incorporated into the DNA. For each chemical mutagen a study was made on the level of DNA repair occurring in early spermatids as a function of the administered, in vivo dose. Within experimental errors, all four chemicals produced a linear increase in DNA repair in early spermatids with increasing dose. Only the highest dose of MMS (100 mg/kg) produced a greater repair response than expected for a linear curve. At equimolar doses the most effective chemical in inducing DNA repair was MMS, followed by EMS, IMS and PMS. When testicular injections of [3H]dT were given at the same time as the intraperitoneal injections of the mutagens, the amount of unscheduled incorporation of [3H]dT into the DNA of early spermatids was maximized. Since [3H]dT has been shown to be available for incorporation into germ-cell DNA for only approximately 1 h after injection, all four mutagens must reach the DNA of early spermatids and begin producing "repairable" lesions within 1 h after treatment. The amount of DNA repair occurring at later times after chemical treatment of early spermatids was studied by testicular injections of [3H]dT 1/2, 1, 2 and 3 days after chemical treatment. Repair was still occurring in the early spermatids at 3 days post-treatment; this repair is most likely a manifestation of the finite rate of the repair process rather than resulting from newly alkylated DNA. For MMS and EMS there was a rapid decrease in the level of DNA repair in the first 1/2 day following treatment. This was followed by a much slower, exponential decrease in the level of repair out to 3 days post-treatment. The curves suggest that the amount of repair is proportional to the number of repairable lesions still present in the DNA. For PMS and IMS the level of repair decreases rapidly in the first 1/2 day after treatment and thereafter remains relatively constant through 3 days post-treatment. With all four mutagens, DNA repair in early spermatids was detectable at doses 5 to 10 times lower than those required to observe other genetic end points such as dominant lethals, translocations and specific-locus mutations in any germ-cell stage. The sensitivity of detection of in vivo DNA repair in the germ cells of male mice makes such a system a useful adjunct to other genetic tests for studying chemical mutagenesis in mammals.