Technique of Subnormothermic Ex Vivo Liver Perfusion for the Storage,Assessment, and Repair of Marginal Liver Grafts

The success of liver transplantation has resulted in a dramatic organ shortage. In most transplant regions 20-30% of patients on the waiting list for liver transplantation die without receiving an organ transplant or are delisted for disease progression. One strategy to increase the donor pool is the utilization of marginal grafts, such as fatty livers, grafts from older donors, or donation after cardiac death (DCD). The current preservation technique of cold static storage is only poorly tolerated by marginal livers resulting in significant organ damage. In addition, cold static organ storage does not allow graft assessment or repair prior to transplantation.These shortcomings of cold static preservation have triggered an interest in warm perfused organ preservation to reduce cold ischemic injury, assess liver grafts during preservation, and explore the opportunity to repair marginal livers prior to transplantation. The optimal pressure and flow conditions, perfusion temperature, composition of the perfusion solution and the need for an oxygen carrier has been controversial in the past.In spite of promising results in several animal studies, the complexity and the costs have prevented a broader clinical application so far. Recently, with enhanced technology and a better understanding of liver physiology during ex vivo perfusion the outcome of warm liver perfusion has improved and consistently good results can be achieved.This paper will provide information about liver retrieval, storage techniques, and isolated liver perfusion in pigs. We will illustrate a) the requirements to ensure sufficient oxygen supply to the organ, b) technical considerations about the perfusion machine and the perfusion solution, and c) biochemical aspects of isolated organs.     

Resuscitation of Ischemic Donor Livers with Normothermic Machine Perfusion: A Metabolic Flux Analysis of Treatment in Rats

Normothermic machine perfusion has previously been demonstrated to restore damaged warm ischemic livers to transplantable condition in animal models. However, the mechanisms of recovery are unclear, preventing rational optimization of perfusion systems and slowing clinical translation of machine perfusion. In this study, organ recovery time and major perfusate shortcomings were evaluated using a comprehensive metabolic analysis of organ function in perfusion prior to successful transplantation. Two groups, Fresh livers and livers subjected to 1 hr of warm ischemia (WI) received perfusion for a total preservation time of 6 hrs, followed by successful transplantation. 24 metabolic fluxes were directly measured and 38 stoichiometrically-related fluxes were estimated via a mass balance model of the major pathways of energy metabolism. This analysis revealed stable metabolism in Fresh livers throughout perfusion while identifying two distinct metabolic states in WI livers, separated at t = 2 hrs, coinciding with recovery of oxygen uptake rates to Fresh liver values. This finding strongly suggests successful organ resuscitation within 2 hrs of perfusion. Overall perfused livers regulated metabolism of perfusate substrates according to their metabolic needs, despite supraphysiological levels of some metabolites. This study establishes the first integrative metabolic basis for the dynamics of recovery during perfusion treatment of marginal livers. Our initial findings support enhanced oxygen delivery for both timely recovery and long-term sustenance. These results are expected to lead the optimization of the treatment protocols and perfusion media from a metabolic perspective, facilitating translation to clinical use.     

The influence of storage temperature during machine perfusion on preservation quality of marginal donor livers

Background

Although non-heart-beating donors have the potential to increase the number of available organs, the livers are used very seldom because of the risk of primary non-function. There is evidence that machine perfusion is able to improve the preservation of marginal organs, and therefore we evaluated in our study the influence of the perfusate temperature during oxygenated machine perfusion on the graft quality.

Methods

Livers from male Wistar rats were harvested after 60-min warm ischemia induced by cardiac arrest. The portal vein was cannulated and the liver flushed with Lifor® (Lifeblood Medical, Inc.) organ preservation solution for oxygenated machine perfusion (MP) at 4, 12 or 21 °C. Other livers were flushed with HTK and stored at 4 °C by conventional cold storage (4 °C-CS). Furthermore two groups with either warm ischemic damage only or without any ischemic damage serve as control groups. After 6 h of either machine perfusion or cold storage all livers were normothermic reperfused with Krebs–Henseleit buffer, and functional as well as structural data were analyzed.

Results

Contrary to livers stored by static cold storage, machine perfused livers showed independently of the perfusate temperature a significantly decreased enzyme release of hepatic transaminases (ALT) during isolated reperfusion. Increasing the machine perfusion temperature to 21 °C resulted in a marked reduction of portal venous resistance and an increased bile production.

Conclusions

Oxygenated machine perfusion improves viability of livers after prolonged warm ischemic damage. Elevated perfusion temperature of 21 °C reconstitutes the hepatic functional capacity better than perfusion at 4 or 12 °C.     

The Impact of Ischemia/Reperfusion Injury on Liver Allografts from Deceased after Cardiac Death versus Deceased after Brain Death Donors

Background and aims

The shortage of organs for transplantation has led to increased use of organs procured from donors after cardiac death (DCD). The effects of cardiac death on the liver remain poorly understood, however. Using livers obtained from DCD versus donors after brain death (DBD), we aimed to understand how ischemia/reperfusion (I/R) injury alters expression of pro-inflammatory markers ceramides and influences graft leukocyte infiltration.

Methods

Hepatocyte inflammation, as assessed by ceramide expression, was evaluated in DCD (n = 13) and DBD (n = 10) livers. Allograft expression of inflammatory and cell death markers, and allograft leukocyte infiltration were evaluated from a contemporaneous independent cohort of DCD (n = 22) and DBD (n = 13) livers.

Results

When examining the differences between transplant stages in each group, C18, C20, C24 ceramides showed significant difference in DBD (p<0.05) and C22 ceramide (p<0.05) were more pronounced for DCD. C18 ceramide is correlated to bilirubin, INR, and creatinine after transplant in DCD. Prior to transplantation, DCD livers have reduced leukocyte infiltration compared to DBD allografts. Following reperfusion, the neutrophil infiltration and platelet deposition was less prevalent in DCD grafts while cell death and recipients levels of serum aspartate aminotransferase (AST) of DCD allografts had significantly increased.

Conclusion

These data suggest that I/R injury generate necrosis in the absence of a strong inflammatory response in DCD livers with an appreciable effect on early graft function. The long-term consequences of increased inflammation in DBD and increased cell death in DCD allografts are unknown and warrant further investigation.     

Ex Situ Normothermic Machine Perfusion of Donor Livers

In contrast to conventional static cold preservation (0-4 °C), ex situ machine perfusion may provide better preservation of donor livers. Continuous perfusion of organs provides the opportunity to improve organ quality and allows ex situ viability assessment of donor livers prior to transplantation. This video article provides a step by step protocol for ex situ normothermic machine perfusion (37 °C) of human donor livers using a device that provides a pressure and temperature controlled pulsatile perfusion of the hepatic artery and continuous perfusion of the portal vein. The perfusion fluid is oxygenated by two hollow fiber membrane oxygenators and the temperature can be regulated between 10 °C and 37 °C. During perfusion, the metabolic activity of the liver as well as the degree of injury can be assessed by biochemical analysis of samples taken from the perfusion fluid. Machine perfusion is a very promising tool to increase the number of livers that are suitable for transplantation.     

Impact of Donation Mode on the Proportion and Function of T Lymphocytes in the Liver

Background

Liver T-cells respond to the inflammatory insult generated during organ procurement and contribute to the injury following reperfusion. The mode of liver donation alters various metabolic and inflammatory pathways but the way it affects intrahepatic T-cells is still unclear.

Methods

We investigated the modifications occurring in the proportion and function of T-cells during liver procurement for transplantation. We isolated hepatic mononuclear cells (HMC) from liver perfusate of living donors (LD) and donors after brain death (DBD) or cardiac death (DCD) and assessed the frequency of T-cell subsets, their cytokine secretion profile and CD8 T-cell cytotoxicity function, responsiveness to a danger associated molecular pattern (High Mobility Group Box1, HMGB1) and association with donor and recipient clinical parameters and immediate graft outcome.

Results

We found that T-cells in healthy human livers were enriched in memory CD8 T-cells exhibiting a phenotype of non-circulating tissue-associated lymphocytes, functionally dominated by more cytotoxicity and IFN-γ-production in DBD donors, including upon activation by HMGB1 and correlating with peak of post-transplant AST. This liver-specific pattern of CD8 T-cell was prominent in DBD livers compared to DCD and LD livers suggesting that it was influenced by events surrounding brain death, prior to retrieval.

Conclusion

Mode of liver donation can affect liver T-cells with increased liver damage in DBD donors. These findings may be relevant in designing therapeutic strategies aimed at organ optimization prior to transplantation.     

Machine Perfusion versus Cold Storage of Kidneys Derived from Donation after Cardiac Death: A Meta-Analysis

Background

In response to the increased organ shortage, organs derived from donation after cardiac death (DCD) donors are becoming an acceptable option once again for clinical use in transplantation. However, transplant outcomes in cases where DCD organs are used are not as favorable as those from donation after brain death or living donors. Different methods of organ preservation are a key factor that may influence the outcomes of DCD kidney transplantation.

Methods

We compared the transplant outcomes in patients receiving DCD kidneys preserved by machine perfusion (MP) or by static cold storage (CS) preservation by conducting a meta-analysis. The MEDLINE, EMBASE and Cochrane Library databases were searched. All studies reporting outcomes for MP versus CS preserved DCD kidneys were further considered for inclusion in this meta-analysis. Odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated to compare the pooled data between groups that were transplanted with kidneys that were preserved by MP or CS.

Results

Four prospective, randomized, controlled trials, involving 175 MP and 176 CS preserved DCD kidney transplant recipients, were included. MP preserved DCD kidney transplant recipients had a decreased incidence of delayed graft function (DGF) with an odd ration of 0.56 (95% CI = 0.36–0.86, P = 0.008) compared to CS. However, no significant differences were seen between the two technologies in incidence of primary non-function, one year graft survival, or one year patient survival.

Conclusions

MP preservation of DCD kidneys is superior to CS in terms of reducing DGF rate post-transplant. However, primary non-function, one year graft survival, and one year patient survival were not affected by the use of MP or CS for preservation.     

Functional Human Liver Preservation and Recovery by Means of Subnormothermic Machine Perfusion

There is currently a severe shortage of liver grafts available for transplantation. Novel organ preservation techniques are needed to expand the pool of donor livers. Machine perfusion of donor liver grafts is an alternative to traditional cold storage of livers and holds much promise as a modality to expand the donor organ pool. We have recently described the potential benefit of subnormothermic machine perfusion of human livers. Machine perfused livers showed improving function and restoration of tissue ATP levels. Additionally, machine perfusion of liver grafts at subnormothermic temperatures allows for objective assessment of the functionality and suitability of a liver for transplantation. In these ways a great many livers that were previously discarded due to their suboptimal quality can be rescued via the restorative effects of machine perfusion and utilized for transplantation. Here we describe this technique of subnormothermic machine perfusion in detail. Human liver grafts allocated for research are perfused via the hepatic artery and portal vein with an acellular oxygenated perfusate at 21 °C.     

Progress in human hepatocytes: isolation,culture & cryopreservation

The quality of the hepatocytes used for clinical cell transplantation is very important, and depends to a large extent on the nature of the tissue used for isolation. The collagenase perfusion technique to isolate hepatocytes from animal livers has been further developed for isolation of human hepatocytes. As the donor organ pool is a scarce resource, marginal livers unsuitable for transplantation and segments from reduced grafts remain the main source of tissue for cell isolation. Use of livers from non-heart beating donors and foetal livers may further increase the tissue pool. With the limited supply of available tissue, improvements in the cryopreservation protocols are required to maintain cell viability on thawing and establish hepatocyte banks.     

Bile analysis as a tool for assessing integrity of biliary epithelial cells after cold ischemia--reperfusion of rat livers

Previous morphological studies failed to show appreciable injury of biliary epithelial cells (BEC) after cold ischemia of rat liver, although recent evidence indicated that BEC integrity and function were impaired in this model. We tested the hypothesis that analysis of bile for enzymes, such as lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), alanine transaminase (ALT), and aspartate transaminase (AST), can be used for assessing cold ischemic injury of BEC. Furthermore, we examined whether biliary gamma-glutamyltransferase (GGT) reflects warm ischemic injury of BEC and whether normothermic reperfusion aggravates the negative effect of cold ischemia on BEC integrity and function. Rat livers were reperfused after different periods of cold or warm ischemia using a blood-free perfusion model. Compared with controls, perfusate LDH, ALT, and AST levels and parameters of hepatocyte function, including hepatocyte tight junction permeability, were not significantly altered by 18-h cold ischemia. On the other hand, 9-h cold ischemia markedly increased biliary LDH, ALT, and AST levels. However, only LDH release into the bile was strongly dependent on the time of cold storage. Biliary GGT, LDH, and glucose levels decreased during the reperfusion period following 18-h cold ischemia. The results suggest that biliary LDH can be used for assessing injury of BEC in cold-preserved livers and that normothermic reperfusion does not aggravate preservation-induced injury of BEC after cold ischemic storage.     

Ischemia and reperfusion--from mechanism to translation

Ischemia and reperfusion-elicited tissue injury contributes to morbidity and mortality in a wide range of pathologies, including myocardial infarction, ischemic stroke, acute kidney injury, trauma, circulatory arrest, sickle cell disease and sleep apnea. Ischemia-reperfusion injury is also a major challenge during organ transplantation and cardiothoracic, vascular and general surgery. An imbalance in metabolic supply and demand within the ischemic organ results in profound tissue hypoxia and microvascular dysfunction. Subsequent reperfusion further enhances the activation of innate and adaptive immune responses and cell death programs. Recent advances in understanding the molecular and immunological consequences of ischemia and reperfusion may lead to innovative therapeutic strategies for treating patients with ischemia and reperfusion-associated tissue inflammation and organ dysfunction.     

Assessment of hepatic integrity after ischemic preservation by isolated perfusion in vitro: the role of albumin

Isolated perfusion of rat livers (IPRL) represents an attractive set-up to be used as a an evaluative tool in the easy and reproducible assessment of liver injury, allowing for screening of new approaches to organ preservation without the expenditure of actual transplantation experiments. Depending on the pathology under investigation, controversy exists concerning the inclusion of albumin in the IPRL. The present study evaluates the use of bovine serum albumin (BSA), simultaneously comparing its effect on healthy and ischemically challenged livers in the same model. Rat livers were excised, flushed via portal vein with Histidine-Tryptophan-Ketoglutarate (HTK) solution and preserved for up to 18 h in HTK at 4 degrees C. Perfusion was performed with Krebs-Henseleit buffer with or without addition of 3% BSA. Control preparations were perfused without prior ischemic storage. In the described model, stability of the preparations was documented for up to 120 min of isolated perfusion and addition of 3% BSA had no adverse effects on the viability of nonischemic livers. While liver perfusion without albumin was inappropriate to reveal alterations in parenchymal or vascular integrity after 18 h of cold preservation, albumin in the perfusate significantly and gradually unmasked differences between nonischemic liver preparations and livers stored ischemically for 8 or 18 h. It could be shown that BSA did have a significant modulatory effect on hepatic induction of apoptosis after ischemia in reducing cleavage of caspase 3. The implementation of albumin is advocated since experimental results are pivotally influenced by the presence or absence of this physiologically constitutive compound in the perfusate.     

Protective Mechanisms of Hypothermia in Liver Surgery and Transplantation

Hepatic ischemia/reperfusion (I/R) injury is a side effect of major liver surgery that often cannot be avoided. Prolonged periods of ischemia put a metabolic strain on hepatocytes and limit the tolerable ischemia and preservation times during liver resection and transplantation, respectively. In both surgical settings, temporarily lowering the metabolic demand of the organ by reducing organ temperature effectively counteracts the negative consequences of an ischemic insult. Despite its routine use, the application of liver cooling is predicated on an incomplete understanding of the underlying protective mechanisms, which has limited a uniform and widespread implementation of liver-cooling techniques. This review therefore addresses how hypothermia-induced hypometabolism modulates hepatocyte metabolism during ischemia and thereby reduces hepatic I/R injury. The mechanisms underlying hypothermia-mediated reduction in energy expenditure during ischemia and the attenuation of mitochondrial production of reactive oxygen species during early reperfusion are described. It is further addressed how hypothermia suppresses the sterile hepatic I/R immune response and preserves the metabolic functionality of hepatocytes. Lastly, a summary of the clinical status quo of the use of liver cooling for liver resection and transplantation is provided.     

Preservation methods for kidney and liver

With the successful testing of the immunosuppressive effects of cyclosporine in transplant patients in 1978, the field of organ transplants began an exponential growth. With that, the field of organ preservation became increasingly important as the need to increase preservation time and improve graft function became paramount. However, for every patient that receives a transplanted organ, there are 4 more on the waiting list. In addition, a patient dies from the lack of a transplant almost every 1½ hour. To alleviate this donor crisis, there is a need to expand the donor pool to marginal donor organs. The main reason these organs are underutilized is because the current method of static preservation, simple cold storage, is ineffective. This article will provide a general review of the methods of preservation including simple cold storage, hypothermic machine perfusion, normothermic machine perfusion, and oxygen persufflation. In addition, the article will provide a review of how these dynamic preservation methods have improved the recovery and preservation of marginal donor organs including donation after cardiac death and fatty livers.     

Doxycycline Alters the Porcine Renal Proteome and Degradome during Hypothermic Machine Perfusion

Ischemia-reperfusion injury (IRI) is a hallmark for tissue injury in donation after circulatory death (DCD) kidneys. The implementation of hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) provides a platform for improved preservation of DCD kidneys. Doxycycline administration has shown protective effects during IRI. Therefore, we explored the impact of doxycycline on proteolytic degradation mechanisms and the urinary proteome of perfused kidney grafts. Porcine kidneys underwent 30 min of warm ischemia, 24 h of oxygenated HMP (control/doxycycline) and 240 min of ex vivo reperfusion. A proteomic analysis revealed distinctive clustering profiles between urine samples collected at T15 min and T240 min. High-efficiency undecanal-based N-termini (HUNTER) kidney tissue degradomics revealed significantly more proteolytic activity in the control group at T-10. At T240, significantly more proteolytic activity was observed in the doxycycline group, indicating that doxycycline alters protein degradation during HMP. In conclusion, doxycycline administration during HMP led to significant proteomic and proteolytic differences and protective effects by attenuating urinary NGAL levels. Ultimately, we unraveled metabolic, and complement and coagulation pathways that undergo alterations during machine perfusion and that could be targeted to attenuate IRI induced injury.     

Oxygenated machine perfusion mitigates surface antigen expression and improves preservation of predamaged donor livers

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the potential benefit of machine preservation with the Belzer MPS or HTK solution, compared to standard cold storage, after procurement of marginal livers from non-heart beating donors in an experimental pilot study. Livers from male Wistar rats (250-300 g bw) were harvested after 60 min of cardiac arrest, flushed via the portal vein and cold stored submerged in HTK for 24 h at 4 degrees C while other organs were subjected to oxygenated machine perfusion with HTK or Belzer's MPS at 5 ml/min at 4 degrees C. Cold perfusion of livers with the non-colloidal HTK was not compromised by the lack of oncotic agents and there was no rise in vascular resistance during the 24 h of machine preservation with HTK or the colloidal Belzer MPS. Viability of the livers was assessed after the cold preservation period by warm reperfusion in vitro. Oxygenated machine perfusion was found to significantly increase viability of the livers vs simple cold storage with respect to portal vascular resistance upon reperfusion, enzyme release as well as functional recovery of oxygen utilization or bile production. Moreover, tissue antigen expression of ICAM-1 or histocompatibility antigen class II could be markedly reduced by oxygenated perfusion preservation as compared to cold storage. It is concluded that predamaged organs should preferably be preserved by oxygenated machine perfusion thus minimizing functional alterations and immunogenicity of the graft. In this setup HTK appeared equally effective as Belzer's MPS for machine preservation.     

Criteria for Viability Assessment of Discarded Human Donor Livers during Ex Vivo Normothermic Machine Perfusion

Although normothermic machine perfusion of donor livers may allow assessment of graft viability prior to transplantation, there are currently no data on what would be a good parameter of graft viability. To determine whether bile production is a suitable biomarker that can be used to discriminate viable from non-viable livers we have studied functional performance as well as biochemical and histological evidence of hepatobiliary injury during ex vivo normothermic machine perfusion of human donor livers. After a median duration of cold storage of 6.5 h, twelve extended criteria human donor livers that were declined for transplantation were ex vivo perfused for 6 h at 37°C with an oxygenated solution based on red blood cells and plasma, using pressure controlled pulsatile perfusion of the hepatic artery and continuous portal perfusion. During perfusion, two patterns of bile flow were identified: (1) steadily increasing bile production, resulting in a cumulative output of ≥30 g after 6 h (high bile output group), and (2) a cumulative bile production <20 g in 6 h (low bile output group). Concentrations of transaminases and potassium in the perfusion fluid were significantly higher in the low bile output group, compared to the high bile output group. Biliary concentrations of bilirubin and bicarbonate were respectively 4 times and 2 times higher in the high bile output group. Livers in the low bile output group displayed more signs of hepatic necrosis and venous congestion, compared to the high bile output group. In conclusion, bile production could be an easily assessable biomarker of hepatic viability during ex vivo machine perfusion of human donor livers. It could potentially be used to identify extended criteria livers that are suitable for transplantation. These ex vivo findings need to be confirmed in a transplant experiment or a clinical trial.     

Mitochondrial uncoupling protein-2 mediates steatotic liver injury following ischemia/reperfusion

Steatotic livers are not used for transplantation because they have a reduced tolerance for ischemic events with reduced ATP levels and greater levels of cellular necrosis, which ultimately result in total organ failure. Mitochondrial uncoupling protein-2 (UCP2) is highly expressed in steatotic livers and may be responsible for liver sensitivity to ischemia through mitochondrial and ATP regulation. To test this hypothesis, experiments were conducted in lean and steatotic (ob/ob), wild-type, and UCP2 knock-out mice subjected to total warm hepatic ischemi-a/reperfusion. Although ob/ob UCP2 knock-out mice and ob/ob mice have a similar initial phenotype, ob/ob UCP2 knock-out animal survival was 83% when compared with 30% in ob/ob mice 24 h after reperfusion. Serum alanine aminotransferase concentrations and hepatocellular necrosis were decreased in the ob/ob UCP2 knock-out mice when compared with ob/ob mice subjected to ischemia. Liver ATP levels were increased in the ob/ob UCP2 knock-out animals after reperfusion when compared with the ob/ob mice but remained below the concentrations from lean livers. Lipid peroxidation (thiobarbituric acid-reactive substances) increased after reperfusion most significantly in the steatotic groups, but the increase was not affected by UCP2 deficiency. These results reveal that UCP2 expression is a critical factor, which sensitizes steatotic livers to ischemic injury, regulating liver ATP levels after ischemia and reperfusion.     

Function and quality of kidneys after cold storage, machine perfusion, or retrograde oxygen persufflation: Results from a porcine autotransplantation model

Objectives

Especially for preservation of marginal donor organs, machine perfusion (MP) and retrograde oxygen persufflation (ROP) are alternatives to cold storage (CS). Using a porcine kidney autotransplantation model we compared metabolic and morphologic effects of CS, ROP, and MP on kidneys exposed to warm ischemia.

Methods

Kidneys of 21 pigs were exposed in situ to warm ischemia for 60 min. The kidneys were randomly allocated to three experimental groups, each receiving a 4-h treatment of either cold storage, machine perfusion, or retrograde oxygen persufflation. Tissue samples were examined for malondialdehyde and histological changes. Daily blood samples were examined for creatinine levels.

Results

Seven days after transplantation, the plasma creatinine levels in the CS and MP groups were still significantly elevated above the baseline values. In the ROP group, all animals exhibited nearly normal creatinine levels. Malondialdehyde, an indicator of lipidperoxidation, was dramatically increased in the machine perfused kidneys on day 7, whereas the malondialdehyde levels in the other two groups were near normal values. The MP kidneys exhibited the most striking histological changes.

Conclusion

Though MP has been well introduced in organ transplantation, in our opinion, it must still be optimized and standardized. It is necessary to clarify questions such as whether there is a need for oxygenation during perfusion, the length of perfusion, the impact of pressure, and the effects of additional scavengers. The results of the present study suggest the reconsideration of the ROP-technique for the preservation of predamaged donor grafts especially of NHBD and further studies, comparing MP and ROP upon long term preservation are strongly encouraged.