Differential growth dependency of normal and habituated sugarbeet cell lines upon endogenous ethylene production and exogenous ethylene application

A fully habituated (auxin‐ and cytokinin‐independent) nonorganogenic (HNO) sugarbeet ( Beta vulgaris ) callus produces very little ethylene as compared with a normal (N) hormone‐requiring callus of the same strain. Both callus types react by growth changes to application of inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis and ethylene action, of 1‐aminocyclopropane‐1‐carboxylic acid (ACC) as the immediate precursor of ethylene, to transfer from light to darkness, and also to application of exogenous ethylene or an ethylene trapper. This indicates their growth dependency upon their endogenously biosynthesized ethylene and also their sensitivity to exogenous gas. However, the sensitivity was generally higher for the HNO callus producing naturally less ethylene. The weaker reaction of the HNO callus to the exogenous ethylene was attributed to its hyperhydric status (a water layer surrounding the cells). Because low ethylene production appears as a general characteristic of habituated cell lines, the causal and/or consequential relationships of this low ethylene production with other characteristics of habituated tissues (absence of exogenous hormones in the culture media, deficiency of cell differentiation, accumulation of polyamines in neoplastic tissues) are discussed.     

Mesophyll protoplasts ofAvena sativa: Characterization of the first cell cycles

Summary Cells from a fully habituated nonorganogenic sugarbeet callus line show very large nuclei, that are very irregular in shape, with deep invaginations and many nucleoli. Micronuclei can also be seen. Fluorimetric analyses of the DNA content in the habituated cells show an abnormal distribution indicating polyploidy and aneuploidy. Such features closely resemble those observed in animal cancer cells.     

Protective systems against activated oxygen species compared in normal and fully habituated nonorganogenic sugarbeet calluses

Summary The levels of the water-soluble reductants ascorbic acid and glutathione and the activities of the enzymatic antioxidants superoxide dismutase, catalase, ascorbate peroxidase, monodehydroascorbate and dehydroascorbate reductases and glutathione reductase were determined in a fully habituated nonorganogenic sugarbeet callus line (considered a neoplasm) compared with a normal hormone-dependent callus of the same plant. Ascorbic acid was not recovered from either of the two calluses, irrespective of the technique used. Glutathione was titrated at a slightly higher level in the normal callus. Catalase activity was almost nonexistent in the habituated callus. The other enzymes (superoxide dismutase, glutathione reductase, monodehydroascorbate reductase, dehydroascorbate reductase, and ascorbate peroxidase) were found to have higher activities in the habituated callus. The results are interpreted as a higher protection of the neoplastic habituated cells against oxygen-free radicals and hydroperoxide-dependent oxidations. Such strong scavenging properties of the habituated cell line could explain previous results already reported, namely the stimulation of cell division at the expense of cell differentiation.     

Shemin pathway and peroxidase deficiency in a fully habituated and fully heterotrophic non-organogenic sugarbeet callus: an adaptative strategy or the consequence of modified hormonal balances and sensitivities in these cancerous cells? A review and reassessment

There are many arguments for considering a specific fully habituated (auxin and cytokinin-independent) and fully heterotrophic non-organogenic (HNO) sugarbeet callus cell line as terminating a neoplastic progression, and thus to be made of cancerous cells. The similarities with animal tumour and cancer cells are recalled. All types of habituated tissues examined in the literature share at least three common biochemical characteristics: low apparent peroxidase activity, high content of polyamines (PAs) and low production of ethylene. However, results concerning their auxin and cytokinin levels are not consistent. Peroxidase synthesis in the achlorophyllous HNO callus appears to arise from aminolevulinic acid (ALA) synthesis through the Shemin pathway, commonly used by animals and fungi. This pathway is limited by disturbed nitrogen metabolism that diverts glutamate (directly used for ALA synthesis in green higher plants) from the Kreb's cycle into PA synthesis. There is no argument to suggest that the low ethylene production is caused by a competition with PAs for their common precursor, S-adenosylmethionine. The results we report here indicate modified anabolic and catabolic pathways of auxins and cytokinins but also the possibilities of unusual compounds playing similar roles (dehydrodiconiferyl alcohol glucosides, for instance). A higher turnover of PAs is shown in the HNO callus, which could suggest a role for H2O2 and gamma-aminobutyric acid, products or intermediates in the PA catabolic pathway, as secondary messengers. The habituated cells retain some sensitivity towards exogenous auxins and cytokinins. Their increased sensitivity to PAs and ethylene suggests modified hormonal balances for the control of these actively dividing cells.     

Nuclear DNA content and phytohormone requirements of normal, crown gall and habituated tissues of Nicotiana tabacum var. White Burley

Determination of the nuclear DNA content of leaves and normal, habituated and Crown gall callus tissues of Nicotiana tabacum var. White Burley were performed using cytophotometry on Feulgen stained preparations. Several aspects concerning the reliability of the Feulgen technique for DNA determinations were investigated.Crown gall callus tissue used in this study had both a higher nuclear DNA content and chromosome number than normal callus (3.2C versus 2.5C). Both have a higher DNA content than the diploid tobacco leaf cells (2C).The normal callus tissue failed to grow on medium without indole acetic acid and kinetin when cultured in tubes. From this normal callus two habituated lines growing without both phytohormones were selected by culturing the normal callus first in the absence of either indole acetic acid or kinetin. Changing the culture conditions of the normal callus by using culture flasks instead of tubes resulted in a remarkably faster growth rate of the tissue. This was accompanied by an acquisition of the habituation characteristics since it was possible now to grow this tissue also directly on medium lacking both phytohormones. All habituated tissues showed a higher nuclear DNA content compared to the normal callus tissue from which they were derived. Interestingly, one of the tissues acquired a nuclear DNA content not different from that of Crown gall tissue. By changing the culture conditions of Crown gall callus tissue no concomitant change in nuclear DNA content occurred.The results suggest a correlation between the acquisition of a special chromosome complement and the loss of phytohormone requirement resulting in autonomous growth.     

Comparative study of respiratory metabolism in three types of sugarbeet calli,a normal and two habituated ones (organogenic and non-organogenic)

The respiratory metabolism was studied in three types of sugarbeet (Beta vulgaris L. var. altissima) calli: a normal callus (N) and two fully habituated (auxin- and cytokinin-independent) calli, organogenic (HO) and non-organogenic (HNO). Except for the HO callus at day 14, the oxygen consumption rates of the habituated calli were always higher than that of the normal callus throughout the cycle of culture. The maximum activity of the cyanide-resistant pathway (alternative pathway) was much higher in the two habituated calli than in the normal one. By contrast, important differences were found in HNO and HO calli concerning the activity of the cytochrome pathway. In HNO cells, the high activity of this pathway was correlated with a high ATP level while the inverse situation was observed in HO cells. The physiological significance of these results is discussed.     

Actin-filled nuclear invaginations indicate degree of cell de-differentiation

For years the existence of nuclear actin has been heavily debated, but recent data have clearly demonstrated that actin, as well as actin-binding proteins (ABPs), are located in the nucleus. We examined live EGFP-actin-expressing cells using confocal microscopy and saw the presence of structures strongly resembling actin filaments in the nuclei of MDA-MB-231 human mammary epithelial tumor cells. Many nuclei had more than one of these filamentous structures, some of which appeared to cross the entire nucleus. Extensive analysis, including fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP), showed that all EGFP-actin in the nucleus is monomeric (G-actin) rather than filamentous (F-actin) and that the apparent filaments seen in the nucleus are invaginations of cytoplasmic monomeric actin. Immunolocalization of nuclear pore complex proteins shows that similar invaginations are seen in cells that are not overexpressing EGFP-actin. To determine whether there is a correlation between increased levels of invagination in the cell nuclei and the state of de-differentiation of the cell, we examined a variety of cell types, including live Xenopus embryonic cells. Cells that were highly de-differentiated, or cancerous, had an increased incidence of invagination, while cells that were differentiated had few nuclear invaginations. The nuclei of embryonic cells that were not yet differentiated underwent multiple shape changes throughout interphase, and demonstrated numerous transient invaginations of varying sizes and shapes. Although the function of these actin-filled invaginations remains speculative, their presence correlates with cells that have increased levels of nuclear activity.     

Effet du Chlorure de Sodium sur la Croissance et le Potentiel Osmotique de Cals Normaux et Habitués de Betterave Sucrière

NaCl (0 to 274 mM) was added to the culture media of normal and habituated (auxin and cytokinin independent) sugarbeet calli and its effect on growth (estimated by the increase of dry and organic matters), water content and osmotic potential was tested. Growth of normal callus was stimulated by 68 mM NaCl after a lag period of two weeks. This callus tolerated up to 137 mM NaCl without growth reduction and maintained its hydric status by readjustment of its osmotic potential in 24 h. NaCl quantities under 34 mM stimulated growth of the habituated callus from the 3rd day on; higher NaCl concentrations (68 to 274 mM) inhibited growth or were lethal. NaCl sensitivity of this habituated callus was not due to its inability to adjust its osmotic potential: this adjustment occurred from the 4th h of culture whatever the media. From the 3rd day on, however, this callus presented a water deficit which depended on NaCl concentration. It is suggested that the lowering of osmotic potential corresponds to an important water loss in relation to changes in membrane permeability. This study finally shows that mechanisms of salt tolerance may have developed at the cellular level. Lower growth and lower salt tolerance of the habituated callus need further investigation in relation to cell structure and hormone autonomy.      

Tissue-Specific Variation in the Cytokinin Habituation of Cultured Tobacco Cells

Cells of tobacco pith parenchyma sometimes lose their requirement for an exogenous supply of a cell division factor usually supplied as the synthetic cytokinin, kinetin. This change in phenotype, known as cytokinin habituation, is inherited by individual cells and appears to result from epigenetic changes rather than from rare, random, genetic mutations. We have found that tissues from different regions of the tobacco plant exhibit different states of habituation in culture. Pith tissues, as reported earlier, are usually cytokinin requiring and rapidly shift to the habituated state in culture. Leaf tissues are very slightly habituated and require kinetin for optimal rates of growth. Tissues from the stem-cortex are initially habituated. Both the leaf and cortex phenotypes are inherited by individual cells and persist for many cell generations in culture. These results show that certain tissue-specific phenotypes persist in culture and provide evidence that a process akin to habituation leading to different stable states of cytokinin requirement occurs in normal development.     

Polyamine levels in relation to growth and NaCl concentration in normal and habituated sugarbeet callus cultures

Abstract. The concentrations of putrescine, spermidine and spermine, the only polyamines detectable in normal and habituated calli of Beta vulgaris L. ssp. altissima , were much higher in the habituated callus than the normal callus, irrespective of experimental conditions. These results suggest that, in normal (tolerant to NaCl) and habituated (sensitive to NaCl) calli, there exists a competition for the common precursor of ethylene and polyamine biosynthesis viz. S-adenosylmethionine. A disequilibrium favouring the synthesis of putrescine and spermidine in the habituated callus might be linked to structural deterioration of the cell membrane following extended culture or severe osmotic stress (68 mol m⁻¹ NaCl). The maintenance of membrane integrity by the normal callus coincides with ethylene production at the expense of polyamine synthesis. In contrast to the habituated callus, the salinity tolerance of the normal callus is accompanied by the accumulation of proline under hypersaline conditions (274mol m⁻³). The important osmoregulatory role played by quaternary ammonium compounds in the-aerial parts of Chenopodiaceae, especially the sugarbeet, is not observed in the calli, these compounds being found in very low concentrations in saline conditions.     

Peroxidase as a developmental marker in plant tissue culture.

Peroxidase was studied as a developmental marker in pumpkin (Cucurbita pepo L.) callus lines and horse-radish (Armoracia lapathifolia Gilib) transformants. Embryogenic callus lines DE grown on MS medium with 2.4-D and NA-3 grown on medium with NAA and adenine sulfate showed about a 20 times higher enzyme activity than the habituated non-embryogenic line Z5b/T grown on medium without hormones. A rise in peroxidase activity indicated that somatic embryogenesis was triggered in a few habituated tissue cultures. Separated globular embryoids had a manifold lower enzyme activity than the callus from which they originated. SDS-electrophoresis showed distinct polypeptide patterns between the horse-radish leaves and crown galls, but the tumor characteristic protein bands failed to be identified. In horse-radish crown galls and short bushy plants regenerated from hairy roots an enhanced peroxidase activity was registered. Due to its high peroxidase level and abundant biomass production horse-radish transformants should facilitate enzyme production.     

Calcium-controlled peroxidase secretion by sugarbeet cell suspensions in relation to habituation

Sugarbeet cells from normal and habituated callus released peroxidases in liquid cultures, in proportion to their endogenous level. Calcium promoted this release more in the normal than in the habituated line. Treatment of the cells with sodium azide, sodium hydrogenarsenate or phenothiazine inhibited the calcium effect, which indicated a dependence on metabolic energy and on calmodulin regulation. The Ca ionophore Ro (bromolasalocid ethanolate) restricted peroxidase release.Research partly supported by the Belgian FRFC grant 2.9009 to T.G. and by the Swiss FNSR grant 3.624-0.80 to C.P. and H.G.     

The Effects of Agitated Liquid Medium on in vitro Cultures of Hevea brasiliensis

The initiation and prolonged growth of callus, from stem explants of young plants of Hevea brasilienies on solid medium yielded a heterogeneous callus, with areas which are the result of compact growth interspersed with brown necrotic tissue and soft white tissue formations. Subculturing this callus (O callus) to agitated liquid medium and returning it to solid medium resulted in the production of a homogeneous friable and rapidly growing callus (Rl callus) The two established lines O and Rl have remained stable over one year in culture and differ in gross morphology, anatomy, growth and auxin content. Both were maintained on Murashige and Skoog's medium, with 2 mg/1 2,4-D and 0.5 mg/I kinetin. R 1 but not O showed enhanced growth at the lower 2,4-D level of 0.2 mg/l: both lines failed to continue growing when 2,4-D was omitted. It is suggested that the changes resulting from subculture in agitated liquid medium are related to those undergone by callus cultures which become habituated. Thus the Rl callus line is regarded as partially habituated. Subculture in agitated liquid medium also resulted in the production of large numberr of polyploid cells but these did not persist over the long periods of subsequent growth on agar medium, Enhanced auxin production by the establihed Rl callus line was thus observed in the absence of a detectable level of polyploidy.     

Disturbed sugar metabolism in a fully habituated nonorganogenic callus of Beta vulgaris (L.)

Habituated (H) nonorganogenic sugarbeet callus was found to exhibit a disturbed sugar metabolism. In contrast to cells from normal (N) callus, H cells accumulate glucose and fructose and show an abnormal high fructose/glucose ratio. Moreover, H cells which have decreased wall components, display lower glycolytic enzyme activities (hexose phosphate isomerase and phosphofructokinase) which is compensated by higher activities of the enzymes of the hexose monophosphate pathway (glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase and 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase). The disturbed sugar metabolism of the H callus is discussed in relation to a deficiency in H₂O₂ detoxifying systems.Abbreviations 6PG-DH 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase - G6P-DH glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase - H fully habituated callus - HK hexokinase - HMP hexoses monophosphate - HPI hexose phosphate isomerase - N normal callus - PFK phosphofructokinase     

Soluble and cell-wall peroxidases and auxin destruction in normal and habituated tobacco callus

Summary A comparison of the soluble and cell-wall-bound isoperoxidases of normal auxin-requiring and auxin-independent (habituated) tobacco callus revealed that normal tissues contained a higher level of isoperoxidases. There were also qualitative differences in these isoperoxidases. Partially purified soluble and ionically bound isoperoxidases of normal callus likewise exhibited higher auxin-oxidase activities. Normal tissues also were found to contain higher levels of auxin-oxidase inhibitors (auxin protectors). Overall, however, the data indicate that there is a higher rate of auxin destruction in normal tobacco callus than in habituated tissue. This presumably leads to insufficient endogenous auxin for growth. This study was supported in part by grants to T.G. from the Center IRSIA d'Etude de la Reproduction végétale and the FRFC Contract No. 2.9009. it Was carried out while T.A.T. was the holder of a senior Fellowship under the NATO senior Scientists Program.     

Disturbed nitrogen metabolism associated with the hyperhydric status of fully habituated callus of sugarbeet

The content of polyamines and proline was much lower in a normal (N) callus of Beta vulgaris L. than in a fully habituated hyperhydric (H) callus. The H callus also contained more glutamate and had a higher glutamate dehydrogenase activity. The excess of glutamate, in this chlorophyll-deficient callus, was linked to accumulation of proline and polyamines. Experiments with α-difluoromethylornithine (DFMO) and α-difluoromethylarginine (DFMA) showed that both ornithine decarboxylase and arginine decarboxylase participated in the synthesis of polyamines (especially spermidine and putrescine) and removal of ammonia. It is hypothesized that the H callus was subjected to ammonia stress from the start of the culture. Experiments with gabaculine, an inhibitor of ornithine aminotransferase, showed that this enzyme linked proline degradation to polyamine synthesis through the production of ornithine. This disturbed nitrogen metabolism appeared to be characteristic of the fully habituated callus and might explain the low growth of this hyperhydric tissue.     

Evidence for a Mendelian factor controlling the cytokinin requirement of cultured tobacco cells

Cultured leaf tissues of Nicotiana tabacum L. cv. “Havana 425” normally require an exogenous source of cytokinin for rapid growth; stem-cortex tissues do not—ie, they exhibit the cytokinin-habituated phenotype. We found that plants regenerated from cloned cortex and leaf tissues from one particular plant differed in leaf-tissue phenotype: Leaf tissues derived from leaf cells exhibited the normal, nonhabituated phenotype, whereas leaf tissues derived from cortex cells were cytokinin-habituated. This difference in leaf phenotype was not found using leaf and cortex cells from six other donor plants. The inheritance of the habituated leaf trait was studied in tissues from cortex-derived plants and hybrids between these plants and normal plants. F₁ hybrids were intermediate between the parental types in degree of habituation. No differences were found between reciprocal hybrids. These results suggest that the habituated leaf trait is an incompletely dominant, nuclear trait. Both parental and intermediate phenotypes were recovered in the F₂ progeny. The frequency of habituated leaf progeny in the F₂ and backcross populations provide evidence that the trait is regulated at a single genetic locus.     

A comparison between ethylene production, ACC and mACC contents, and hydroperoxide level in normal and habituated sugar beet calli

In contrast to normal hormone, requiring sugar beet callus, habituated auxin- and cytokinin-independent callus of the same plant produces very little ethylene, contains less 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) and malonyl-ACC (mACC), has a low capacity to convert ACC into ethylene and has lower levels of hydroperoxides. The low ethylene production is apparently controlled by the rate of ACC synthesis and conversion to mACC, as well as by the activity of the ethylene forming enzyme. The interactions between ethylene and polyamine metabolism are discussed, as well as the possible causal relation between the low level of ethylene and the low degree of differentiation of the habituated cells.     

Somatic embryogenesis in Asparagus officinalis can be an in vitro selection process leading to habituated and 2,4-D dependent embryogenic lines

Long-term embryogenic lines were repeatedly obtained from nine asparagus (Asparagus officinalis L.) genotypes by the selection of rare events, which consisted of the emergence of either a few somatic embryos or an embryogenic callus from a restricted area of a primary callus. In the first case, somatic embryos emerged from 1 % of calli induced with naphtaleneacetic acid and transferred to a medium without auxin. Isolated and subcultured on hormone free medium, these embryos developed habituated embryogenic lines (H lines) growing by adventive embryogenesis. In the second case, 3 % of primary calli developed then subcultured on 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) produced a new type of friable and yellowish-white callus, constituted of clusters of globular somatic embryos which can be continuously maintained on 2,4-D (2,4-D lines). Among 2,4-D lines, two types were identified by subculturing them on hormone–free medium. Half of the 2,4-D lines were habituated and half were 2,4-D dependent. Most plants regenerated from H lines exhibited a strong increase in embryogenic capacity compared to control plants, unlike plants regenerated from the 2,4-D dependent lines. This increased embryogenic capacity was transmitted to the progeny as a monogenic dominant trait. H lines would therefore be issued from mutation(s) occurring in vitro, conferring both the embryogenic and habituated phenotypes. On the contrary, in the 2,4-D dependent lines, the embryogenic processes appeared to remain under exogenous auxin control and no evidence of a mutational origin could be inferred from the behaviour of regenerated plants.     

Sterol composition of normal and habituated sugarbeet callus (Beta vulgaris L.Altissima)

Summary A detailed qualitative and quantitative analysis of the sterol content of normal (auxin and cytokinin requiring) and habituated (auxin and cytokinin independent) sugarbeet callus (Beta vulgaris L.altissima) was made using mass spectrometry with gas chromatography. The total sterol content of the two lines did not differ significantly. Δ⁷-Sterols were the most important class of sterols in the two sugarbeet callus lines, as in allChenopodiaceae. Elevated levels of Δ⁸-sterols were found in the habituated callus. These sterols are considered to be badly integrated in the membrane of eucaryotic cells. A partial blocking of Δ⁸-Δ⁷-isomerase is hypothesized in the habituated cell line.