The action of interleukin-4 on antigen-specific IgG1 and IgE production by interaction of in vivo primed B cells and carrier-specific cloned Th2 cells

The production of anti-trinitrophenyl (TNP) antibodies of different isotypes from in vivo primed B cells was studied using the plaque-forming cell method. It was shown that these B cells secrete anti-trinitrophenyl antibodies of different isotypes only in the presence of Th2 cells specific for keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) and the hapten-carrier conjugate TNP-KLH. Lipopolysaccharide-stimulated primed B cells without cells from the Th2 clone did not produce anti-TNP-specific IgG1 or IgE antibodies even in the presence of the hapten-carrier antigen TNP-KLH. Supernatants from these Th2 clones cultured with antigen-presenting cells and the complete antigen were unable to activate primed B cells for antibody secretion. Cognate interaction between primed B cells and carrier-specific Th2 cells is a prerequisite for hapten-specific IgG1 or IgE production. Anti-IL-4 antibody inhibited secretion of anti-hapten IgE antibody. Therefore, for production of anti-hapten antibody of the IgE isotype IL-4 is also necessary.     

Carrier-induced epitopic suppression is initiated through clonal dominance

Injection of mice with an immunogenic dose of carrier followed by immunization with hapten-carrier conjugate selectively suppresses anti-hapten antibody response. Previous studies have proposed that this epitopic suppression is related to the induction of carrier-specific Ts cells which in turn could inhibit selectively anti-hapten response. In the present study, we propose that the epitopic suppression is in fact due to clonal dominance. Immunization with a carrier such as tetanus toxoid induces a clonal expansion of carrier-specific B cells, thus decreasing the probability of hapten-specific B cells to react with the Ag. Increasing the density of the TNP-hapten on the conjugate has totally prevented the induction of the epitopic suppression. Moreover, using low hapten-carrier concentrations to challenge carrier-primed mice has enhanced the induction of the suppression. Finally, priming hapten-specific B cells before carrier/hapten-carrier immunization has also abrogated the suppression. The results of these experiments support the view that epitopic suppression is induced through the expansion of the clones specific for the carrier epitopes and resulted from intra-molecular antigenic competition between hapten and carrier epitopes. Based on these findings a regulatory role is proposed for B cells, where through their capacity to process and present antigen, they would exercise a strong influence on the selection of immune responses.     

Regulation of antibody response in different immunoglobulin classes. II. Induction of in vitro IgE antibody response in murine spleen cells and demonstration of a possible involvement of distinct T-helper cells in IgE and IgG antibody responses.

In vitro induction of anti-DNP IgE as well as IgG1, IgG2a antibody responses was shown in murine spleen cell culture. Spleen cells primed three times with 1 mug of DNP-OA or DNP-Asc produced significant amounts of anti-DNP IgE as well as IgG antibodies by the in vitro stimulation with DNP-OA or DNP-Asc, respectively. Collaboration between DNP-primed B cells and carrier-primed T cells was required for the induction of both IgE and IgG antibodies with DNP-coupled T-dependent antigen. Carrier-specific T cells induced with a low dose of Asc (0.01 mug) showed helper function only on IgE antibody response, whereas T cells primed with a higher dose of Asc (10 mug) cooperated only with IgG-B cells. T cells primed with Asc in CFA showed helper function mainly on IgG antibody response but not on IgE antibody response. The result indicated the presence of a distinct population of T helper cells for IgE and IgG antibody responses. T-independent antigen (DNP-Ficoll) induced both anti-DNP IgE and IgG antibody responses in DNP-primed spleen cell population without the requirement of the collaboration of helper T cells.     

Regulation of IgG responses by helper and suppressor T cells activated by pneumococcal capsular polysaccharides

Type 2 antigens are usually unable to prime the helper T cells (TH) required for secondary IgG antibody responses. However, previous results from this laboratory indicated that low doses of the type 2 antigen polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) could activate T cells which provided help to PVP-primed B cells for the production of PVP-specific IgG antibody. Therefore, it was of interest to determine if other type 2 antigens may also be able to activate TH. Low doses of S19 or S3 (subimmunogenic for a primary IgM response) activated TH capable of providing help to S19- or S3-CRBC-primed B cells for a secondary IgG response. Higher doses of these antigens (optimally immunogenic for a primary IgM response) activated suppressor T cells (TS). Removal of these TS prior to transfer of T cells to recipient mice resulted in expression of TH function. Therefore, the preferential activation of TH versus TS was dependent on the dose of antigen used for priming. TH activated by low doses of S19 expressed Thy 1 and L3T4 and were antigen specific. In contrast to the ability of low doses of PVP to prime B cells for secondary IgG responses, low doses of S3 and S19 did not prime capsular polysaccharide-specific IgG memory B cells. High doses of S3 were able to prime B cells if TS precursors were first removed by treatment of mice with cyclophosphamide (Cy), whereas high doses of S19 did not prime B cells for secondary IgG responses in either Cy-treated or control mice. These results are discussed in relation to the general observations that type 2 antigens may not activate antigen-specific TH.     

Regulation of T15 idiotype dominance. III. Phosphocholine-specific B-cell activation in vivo requires major histocompatibility complex-restricted T-cell help

We have examined the requirement for major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted T-cell help in the secondary in vivo antibody response to phosphocholine (PC). The memory response to PC has been demonstrated previously to be comprised of T15-dominant IgM and IgG3 plaque-forming cells (PFC) derived primarily from the Lyb-5+ B-cell subset, and IgG1 and IgG2 PFC, few of which bear the T15 idiotype and are predominantly derived from the Lyb-5- B-cell subset. Using carrier-primed (A X B)F1 T cells which have matured in a parentA chimeric environment so that "self" recognition is of the MHC determinants of parentA but not parentB, we have found that parentA PC-primed B cells, but not parentB PC-primed B cells, are activated. Even in the presence of an ongoing parentA anti-PC response, parentB PC-primed B cells were not activated, indicating that the restriction was between the helper T cell and the B cell, not between T-helper and accessory cells. MHC-restricted T-cell help was required by B cells producing T15+ and T15- IgM, IgG3, IgG1, and IgG2 responses.     

Clonal anergy of memory B cells in epitope-specific regulation.

Immunization of carrier (keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH)) primed mice with the hapten-carrier TNP-KLH induces specific suppression for the IgG anti-TNP-response without interfering with the response to epitopes on the carrier molecule. To examine the status of hapten-specific memory B cells from suppressed mice, highly enriched populations of TNP-specific memory B cells were purified from the spleen of TNP-KLH (control) or KLH/TNP-KLH (suppressed) immunized mice and tested in vitro for their ability to respond to TD or TI (TNP-KLH, TNP-LPS) antigenic challenge in presence of a KLH-specific Th cell line. Similar numbers of TNP-specific B cells with the characteristics of memory B cells were obtained from control and suppressed mice. TNP-specific B cells from suppressed mice could be triggered to IgG production by TNP-LPS but had an impaired ability to differentiate into IgG-secreting cells in response to TNP-KLH. This impaired IgG response to TNP-KLH was not due to an active suppression by a subset of TNP-specific B cells, or to an impedence of memory cells to a class switching but to an intrinsic memory B cell defect. TNP-specific B cells from suppressed mice were as efficient as memory B cells from control mice to present TNP-KLH to KLH-specific Th cells and to proliferate in response to T cell help. Our data support the view that the effector mechanism of epitope specific regulation does not interfere with the development of hapten-specific memory B cells but that these cells have an intrinsic defect that prevents their differentiation into active IgG antibody secreting cells in response to a T-dependent antigenic challenge.     

Antigen-specific sIalo B cells do not secrete IgG2a in response to TH1 cells and antigen: responsiveness can be restored by IL-4

The ability of Th cells, type 1 (TH1), to activate and induce differentiation of B cells into antibody-secreting cells is controversial because 1) some clones of TH1 cells provide help while others do not, and 2) by using the same TH1 clone, different laboratories disagree on whether they provide help to B cells. One possible explanation for the latter is the variability in the activation status of the B cells used in different laboratories. In the present studies, we have used Ag-specific B cells from athymic (nu/nu) mice, or sterilely housed nu/+ mice to study the TH1-mediated activation of B cells that had received little or no prior help from T cells and/or antigen in vivo. These B cells express low levels of surface Ia (sIa) Ag, and fail to secrete IgG2a in response to TH1 cells plus Ag; in contrast, responses to TH2 cells plus Ag are normal. To explore this observation further, we prepared "surface(s) Ia1o" B cells from conventionally housed BALB/c mice by sorting spleen cells on the fluorescence-activated cell sorter. This sIalo population also failed to produce IgG2a in response to TH1 cells plus Ag. In contrast, the sIahi, (presumably more mature) B cells, responded to both the TH1 and TH2 cells. The addition of LPS, TH2 cells or the lymphokine, IL-4, to cultures of sIalo B cells from normal or nu/nu mice (plus Ag and TH1 cells), restored IgG2a responses to control levels. Low sIa levels were not the sole cause of nonresponsiveness of the nu/nu B cells because a 24-h pulse with IL-4 restored sIa to control levels without restoring IgG2a production after activation with TH1 cells plus Ag. These data support the conclusion that sIalo B cells are immature and require an activation/maturation signal from IL-4 in vivo in order to respond to TH1 cells and Ag in vitro.     

Preparation and analysis of antigen-specific memory B cells

A procedure has been developed for the enrichment of TNP-binding memory B cells (TNP-MABC) from spleens of immunized mice. More than 75% of the cells expressed surface IgM (sIgM) and IgD (sIgD) and about 9% expressed surface IgG (sIgG). The TNP-MABC consisted of small resting lymphocytes with high affinity antigen-binding receptors. These cells expressed increased densities of Ia antigens and decreased densities of sIgD. Adoptive transfer of the cells into irradiated, carrier-primed syngeneic recipients resulted in their differentiation into IgG anti-TNP antibody-secreting cells. TNP-MABC secreted high affinity IgG anti-TNP antibodies when cultured in vitro with carrier-primed T cells and antigen. Limiting dilution analysis revealed that TNP-MABC contained a relatively low frequency of precursors for IgG-secreting cells that had an exceptionally large clone size. These results show that a highly enriched population of antigen-specific memory B cells can now be prepared and used to analyze their activation requirements.     

Influence of immunoglobulin-dependent T cells on antibody class switching

Normal and B cell-deficient, carrier-primed mice were irradiated and were adoptively transferred with B cells to evaluate the role of putative Ig- and B cell-dependent T cells in anti-hapten antibody responses. The response was analyzed by using the splenic focus assay, which allowed us to examine the frequency of responding B cells and the production of multiple isotypes by single precursor B cells. This analysis revealed that both primary and secondary B cells were activated at higher frequency in the spleens of normal recipients, and production of isotypes other than IgM and IgG1 was enhanced in normal recipients as compared with anti-mu-treated recipients. Both changes could be restored to control levels by co-transfer of T cells from normal donors primed with an unrelated carrier, provided the free carrier was added to the assay culture. These results are consistent with a role for Ig or B cell-dependent helper T cells in the optimal activation and the resulting isotype expression of both primary and secondary B cells.     

Role of antigen-specific T cell help in the generation of in vivo antibody responses. I. Antigen-specific T cell help is required to generate a polyclonal IgG1 response in anti-IgD antibody-injected mice.

A system in which injection of mice with an antibody to mouse IgD that they recognize as foreign stimulates a large, T cell-dependent IgG response was used to study whether Ag-specific T cell help is required to stimulate polyclonal (non-Ag-specific) IgG production in vivo. Igha x Ighb allotype heterozygous mice were injected with a conjugate of a foreign Ag coupled to a mAb specific for one of the two IgD allotypes expressed in these mice. This conjugate cross-links mIgD on B cells that express the recognized allotype. These cells process the conjugate and present the foreign Ag to Ag-specific T lymphocytes, which become activated. Thus, B cells of the recognized allotype can be stimulated by cross-linking of their mIgD, Ag-specific T cell help, non-Ag-specific cytokines, and non-Ag-specific contact with activated T cells. In contrast, B cells that express the Igh allotype not recognized by the Ag-anti-IgD antibody conjugate (bystander B cells) can be stimulated in this system only by non-Ag-specific cytokines and non-Ag-specific contact with activated T cells. Although both recognized and bystander B cells in conjugate-injected mice demonstrated substantial increases in size and Ia expression, only the recognized B cells were induced to synthesize DNA and to make a substantial polyclonal Ig response. Bystander B cells still failed to secrete IgG when mice were injected with an anti-IgD-Ag conjugate specific for the other Igh allotype as well as a mAb that cross-linked IgD of the bystander B cell allotype. These observations demonstrate that although non-Ag-specific cytokine and contact-mediated T cell help are sufficient to induce B cells to increase in size and Ia expression in anti-IgD antibody-injected mice, Ag-specific T cell help is required to stimulate the generation of an IgG response in these mice.     

Autoreactive B cells in normal humans. Autoantibody production upon lymphocyte stimulation with autoantigen-xenoantigen conjugates

Mononuclear cells (MNC) from the blood of healthy individuals cannot be stimulated in vitro with the soluble autoantigen thyroglobulin (Tg). However, when Tg or pepsin fragments of Tg were coupled with a carrier protein, tetanus toxoid (TT), MNC from four healthy TT vaccinated individuals responded to the carrier-autoantigen conjugates by generating anti-Tg antibody forming cells (AFC), as shown in a spot enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Generation of anti-TT and anti-Tg AFC after stimulation with the conjugates required the donors to be boostered with TT. The autoantibodies were exclusively of the IgM class, in contrast to the carrier-specific anti-TT antibodies, which were predominantly of the IgG isotype. Activation of normal B cells to anti-Tg production was dependent on the presence of T cells in the cultures and required physical linkage of carrier and autoantigen: no anti-Tg AFC could be detected when MNC were stimulated with uncoupled combinations of Tg and TT. The autoreactive and the carrier-reactive B cells exhibited almost identical conjugate dose-response profiles, which suggest that they responded in a similar way to regulatory signals. These findings indicate that normal blood B cells are competent to respond to the autoantigen Tg in conjunction with signals originating from xeno-antigen-stimulated T cells.     

B cells as antigen-presenting cells: antibody production in vitro against a T-dependent antigen

It was examined whether B cells can serve as antigen-presenting cells (APC) in the antibody response to a T-dependent antigen, trinitrophenyl-ovalbumin (TNP-OVA). B cells purified from mice primed with TNP (TNP-B cells) responded to TNP-OVA in the presence of purified T cells sensitized with OVA (OVA-T cells). OVA-T cells required the addition of APC to proliferate in response to TNP-OVA. APC activity of TNP-B cells in the T-cell proliferation was abolished by 4000 R irradiation. Our experiments also revealed that an antibody response requires more adherent cells than the T-cell proliferation. These results indicate that adherent cells possibly accompanying the T- and B-cell preparations were at a less than functional level. There was genetic restriction between T and B cells for the antibody response. B cells in the pellet fraction of 70% Percoll density sedimentation behaved similarly to the unfractionated TNP-B cells in the antibody response. A T-cell clone specific for human gamma-globulin (HGG) also induced an anti-TNP antibody response in B cells from unprimed mice in the presence of TNP-HGG. These results suggest that B cells are able to elicit an antibody response to a T-dependent antigen in the presence of carrier-primed T cells without the participation of macrophages.     

Induction of anti-hapten antibody response by hapten-isologous carrier conjugate. I. Development of hapten-reactive helper cells by hapten-isologous carrier

Anti-hapten antibody production was elicited by the immunization of hapten-isologous carrier conjugate (DNP-MγG) in mice. The spleen and lymph node cells taken from those primed mice were effectively stimulated with hapten-heterologous carrier conjugates (DNP-KLH and DNP-BαA) as well as hapten-homologous carrier conjugate (DNP-MγG) when transferred into X-irradiated recipient mice. The reactivity of DNP-MγG-primed cells to DNP-heterologous carrier conjugates was not due to the mutual crossreactivity of the carrier with MγG on cellular level, since the spleen and lymph node cells primed with DNP-KLH or DNP-BαA could only be stimulated with corresponding hapten-homologous carrier conjugate. The responsiveness of DNP-MγG-primed cells to hapten-heterologous carrier conjugates was due to the result that hapten-reactive helper cells were developed by the immunization of hapten-isologous carrier and these cells cooperated with hapten-specific B cells.The helper activity of the hapten-isologous carrier-primed cells was resistant to 600-R X-irradiation in vitro and sensitive to in vivo ATS treatment. This suggests that the helper activity induced by hapten-isologous carrier is of T cell origin. The helper activity of hapten-isologous carrier-primed cells was also developed by the immunization of PAB-MγG, and clear cooperative interaction between PAB-MγG-primed cells and DNP-specific B cells was demonstrated through DNP-MγG-PAB.The possible mechanism of helper cell development induced by the immunization of hapten-isologous carrier conjugate was discussed in light of the hapten specificity of helper activity.     

Characterization of helper T cells induced by the type 2 antigen polyvinylpyrrolidone

Type 2 antigens are usually unable to prime for IgG memory responses or to activate helper T cells (TH) necessary for memory B cell generation. Previous studies from this laboratory have established that low doses (0.0025 microgram) of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) or a T-dependent form of PVP, PVP-coupled horse red blood cells (PVP-HRBC) can activate PVP-specific TH. The present study was undertaken in order to determine some of the characteristics of the TH activated by PVP and to compare their properties with those of classical TH1 and of TH2 cells described in many T-dependent systems. TH activated with either 0.0025 microgram of PVP or PVP-HRBC were characterized with respect to cell surface antigens, Igh restriction and generation in mice expressing an X-linked immune defect (xid mice). PVP-specific TH are similar to TH1 cells in that they are required for the production of IgG subclasses absent in primary responses and have the Lyt-1+, L3T4+, I-J-surface phenotype. These TH may not be identical with TH1 cells, however, since they are I-A+ and Igh restricted. PVP-specific TH can be generated in xid mice which do not produce antibody in a primary anti-PVP response and do not develop a memory response to PVP, regardless of whether it is presented as a type 2 or T-dependent antigen.     

Studies on the kinetics of hemopoietic stem cells and immune responses to the hapten-carrier conjugate.

The correlation between the kinetics of hemopoietic stem cells and immune responses to the hapten-carrier conjugate was investigated. The numbers of both pluripotent stem cells (CFU-S) and myeloid stem cells (CFU-C) in the spleen from mice immunized with the hapten-carrier conjugate were significantly greater than those of the control and the activity of colony-stimulating factor (CSF) in the serum of these mice was markedly elevated. The supernatant of short-term incubation of splenic T lymphocytes from these mice, when stimulated with carrier protein, had high levels of both activities of CSF and helper T cell factors. The study by gel chromatography showed that these factors are similar m.w. substances of 35,000 to 45,000 daltons. But analysis by ion-exchange chromatography demonstrated that they do not have identical biochemical properties. The present studies suggest that biologically active factors produced by T cells stimulated with carrier protein may induce the enhancing effect on the proliferation and differentiation of hemopoietic stem cells and immune responses to the hapten-carrier conjugate.     

In vitro activation of specific helper and suppressor T cells by the type 2 antigen polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP)

Although type 2 antigens, such as PVP, generally do not activate specific TH, previous studies have established that low doses of PVP (0.0025 microgram) can activate TH in vivo which provide help in primed B cells for PVP-specific IgG responses. Doses of PVP that are optimally immunogenic for IgM antibody production (0.25 to 25 micrograms) preferentially activate PVP-specific TS, which suppress IgG antibody production. In the studies reported here, TH and TS that regulate PVP-specific IgG antibody responses were activated in vitro by culturing normal spleen cells for 4 days with PVP. Induction of the TH and TS is dependent upon the amount of PVP in culture: 10(-4) micrograms PVP activates TH, whereas 10(-2) micrograms PVP preferentially activates TS. TH induced in vitro express Thy-1, L3T4, and I-A determinants and help provided by these TH is similar in magnitude to that provided by TH from mice primed with 0.0025 microgram PVP in vivo. TH can also be activated in vitro if donor mice are treated with Cy before culture of their spleen cells with 10(-2) micrograms PVP. Cy pretreatment prevents TS activation, and TH are then induced in these cultures. The presence of TS does not prevent activation of TH by 10(-2) micrograms PVP, because removal of TS by treatment of T cells with anti-Lyt-2 + complement at the end of culture uncovers TH activity. This TH activity is comparable with that of TH obtained after culture with 10(-4) micrograms PVP. The ability to activate PVP-specific TH and TS in vitro should allow determination of the mechanisms involved in activation of T cells by type 2 antigens and the mechanisms by which TS and TH interact with one another.     

Radiosensitivity of the helper cell function.

The helper function of T cells primed and irradiated in vivo was tested in vitro by the Mishell-Dutton technique. Spleen cells from mice carrier-primed with HRBC and exposed to 50 to 2000 rads of x-radiation were assayed for their ability to help syngeneic normal spleen cells to mount an in vitro anti-hapten antibody response after stimulation with the conjugate TNP-HRBC. The anti-TNP response was evaluated by the Jerne technique. The helper activity was titrated by adding graded numbers of carrier-primed spleen cells to a constant number of normal spleen cells. The slope of the initial linear portion of the response-cell dose titration curve was taken as an estimated of the helper activity and found to decrease with increasing the x-ray dose. The curve describing the remaining helper activity as a function of the radiation dose shows the presence of two components, one radiosensitive, the other, radioresistant. This suggests the existence either of helper cells at different stages of activation or of two cell subpopulations participating in the helper function.     

Interleukin 2 regulates antigen-specific immunoglobulin response of naive murine B cells

Activation of mouse B cells with lipopolysaccharide in conjunction with anti-immunoglobulin (Ig) antibodies results in interleukin 2 (IL2) receptor (IL2-R) expression and IL2 responsiveness. In most studies on the effect of IL2 on antibody production by B cells, polyclonally activated normal B cells or B cell lines established in vitro have been used as indicator cells, thus allowing no direct correlation between the experimental findings and the actual physiological mechanism of IL2 action in antigen-specific B cell response. We employed the splenic fragment culture technique, which measures antibody response on the clonal level, to analyze the effect of purified human recombinant IL2 (rIL2) on the primary antigen-specific Ig response of mouse B cells. Here we report that rIL2 increased the frequency of dinitrophenyl (DNP)-responsive splenic B cells and the amount of Ig secreted per clone. The anti-DNP antibody response was dependent upon interaction of naive B cells with carrier-primed T cells, which apparently provided the signal for IL2-R expression. Recombinant IL2 also facilitated Ig isotype switching by individual clones, suggesting a role for IL2 in activation, maturation, and differentiation of antigen-specific naive B cells in their response to T-dependent antigens.