Single-parent expression complementation contributes to phenotypic heterosis in maize hybrids

The dominance model of heterosis explains the superior performance of F₁-hybrids via the complementation of deleterious alleles by beneficial alleles in many genes. Genes active in one parent but inactive in the second lead to single-parent expression (SPE) complementation in maize (Zea mays L.) hybrids. In this study, SPE complementation resulted in approximately 700 additionally active genes in different tissues of genetically diverse maize hybrids on average. We established that the number of SPE genes is significantly associated with mid-parent heterosis (MPH) for all surveyed phenotypic traits. In addition, we highlighted that maternally (SPE_B) and paternally (SPE_X) active SPE genes enriched in gene co-expression modules are highly correlated within each SPE type but separated between these two SPE types. While SPE_B-enriched co-expression modules are positively correlated with phenotypic traits, SPE_X-enriched modules displayed a negative correlation. Gene ontology term enrichment analyses indicated that SPE_B patterns are associated with growth and development, whereas SPE_X patterns are enriched in defense and stress response. In summary, these results link the degree of phenotypic MPH to the prevalence of gene expression complementation observed by SPE, supporting the notion that hybrids benefit from SPE complementation via its role in coordinating maize development in fluctuating environments.

The number of single-parent expression complementation patterns is significantly associated with mid-parent heterosis for all surveyed phenotypic traits in maize.     

Prediction of hybrid performance in maize using molecular markers and joint analyses of hybrids and parental inbreds

The identification of superior hybrids is important for the success of a hybrid breeding program. However, field evaluation of all possible crosses among inbred lines requires extremely large resources. Therefore, efforts have been made to predict hybrid performance (HP) by using field data of related genotypes and molecular markers. In the present study, the main objective was to assess the usefulness of pedigree information in combination with the covariance between general combining ability (GCA) and per se performance of parental lines for HP prediction. In addition, we compared the prediction efficiency of AFLP and SSR marker data, estimated marker effects separately for reciprocal allelic configurations (among heterotic groups) of heterozygous marker loci in hybrids, and imputed missing AFLP marker data for marker-based HP prediction. Unbalanced field data of 400 maize dent × flint hybrids from 9 factorials and of 79 inbred parents were subjected to joint analyses with mixed linear models. The inbreds were genotyped with 910 AFLP and 256 SSR markers. Efficiency of prediction (R ²) was estimated by cross-validation for hybrids having no or one parent evaluated in testcrosses. Best linear unbiased prediction of GCA and specific combining ability resulted in the highest efficiencies for HP prediction for both traits (R ² = 0.6–0.9), if pedigree and line per se data were used. However, without such data, HP for grain yield was more efficiently predicted using molecular markers. The additional modifications of the marker-based approaches had no clear effect. Our study showed the high potential of joint analyses of hybrids and parental inbred lines for the prediction of performance of untested hybrids.     

Specific changes in total and mitochondrial proteomes are associated with higher levels of heterosis in maize hybrids

The phenomenon of hybrid vigor (heterosis) has long been harnessed by plant breeders to improve world food production. However, the changes that are essential for heterotic responses and the mechanisms responsible for heterosis remain undefined. Large increases in biomass and yield in high-heterosis hybrids suggest that alterations in bioenergetic processes may contribute to heterosis. Progeny from crosses between various inbred lines vary in the extent of vigor observed. Field-grown maize F(1) hybrids that consistently exhibited either low or high heterosis across a variety of environments were examined for changes in proteins that may be correlated with increased plant vigor and yield. Unpollinated ears at the time of flowering (ear shoots) were selected for the studies because they are metabolically active, rich in mitochondria, and the sizes of the ears are diagnostic of yield heterosis. Total protein and mitochondrial proteomes were compared among low- and higher-heterosis hybrids. Two-dimensional difference gel electrophoresis was used to identify allelic and/or isoform differences linked to heterosis. Identification of differentially regulated spots by mass spectrometry revealed proteins involved in stress responses as well as primary carbon and protein metabolism. Many of these proteins were identified in multiple spots, but analysis of their abundances by label-free mass spectrometry suggested that most of the expression differences were due to isoform variation rather than overall protein amount. Thus, our proteomics studies suggest that expression of specific alleles and/or post-translational modification of specific proteins correlate with higher levels of heterosis.     

Multivariate analysis of polypeptide synthesis in field-grown maize inbreds and hybrids

Summary A leaf disc method is described to permit the localized incorporation of ³⁵S-l-methionine into polypeptides synthesized in individual leaves of maize plants grown in the field. The method of incorporation employs minimal external manipulation of the intact leaf, is simple, repeatable, and may be used at any plant age after leaf emergence. Incorporation (cpm/g protein) in 12 leaves per plant was compared among three inbred (Oh43, W23, M14) and three F₁ hybrid (Oh43/M14, W23/M14, Oh43/W23) genotypes. The incorporation was 40% higher (hybrid versus inbred) in 9 of the 12 leaves studied. Samples from leaf 07 (7th leaf numbered from base of plant) for four inbreds (Oh43, M14, B73, Mol 7) and two pairs of reciprocal F₁ hybrids (Oh43/M14, M14/Oh43; B73/Mo17, Mo17/B73) were labelled in situ using the leaf disc method. Each cultivar was sampled at three different ages in each of 1985, 1986, and 1987. High-resolution, two-dimensional isoelectric focusing sodium-dodecyl-sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and fluorography were used to display the polypeptides synthesized in the samples. Multivariate methods — Principal Coordinate Analysis, Cluster Analysis, and Standard Deviation Distance — were used to analyze variation and to identify trends in the variation for year, genotype, and age sampled. Our analyses disclose a hierarchy to polypeptide synthesis variation in maize leaves: differences in polypeptide synthesis are greater for year-to-year comparisons than differences due to sample age, which in turn are greater than differences for inbred versus hybrid comparisons.     

Genetic diversity for restriction fragment length polymorphisms and heterosis for two diallel sets of maize inbreds

Summary Changes that may have occurred over the past 50 years of hybrid breeding in maize (Zea maize L.) with respect to heterosis for yield and heterozygosity at the molecular level are of interest to both maize breeders and quantitative geneticists. The objectives of this study were twofold: The first, to compare two diallels produced from six older maize inbreds released in the 1950's and earlier and six newer inbreds released during the 1970's with respect to (a) genetic variation for restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) and (b) the size of heterosis and epistatic effects, and the second, to evaluate the usefulness of RFLP-based genetic distance measures in predicting heterosis and performance of single-cross hybrids. Five generations (parents, F₁; F₂, and backcrosses) from the 15 crosses in each diallel were evaluated for grain yield and yield components in four Iowa environments. Genetic effects were estimated from generation means by ordinary diallel analyses and by the Eberhart-Gardner model. Newer lines showed significantly greater yield for inbred generations than did older lines but smaller heterosis estimates. In most cases, estimates of additive x additive epistatic effects for yield and yield components were significantly positive for both groups of lines. RFLP analyses of inbred lines included two restriction enzymes and 82 genomic DNA clones distributed over the maize genome. Eighty-one clones revealed polymorphisms with at least one enzyme. In each set, about three different RFLP variants were typically found per RFLP locus. Genetic distances between inbred lines were estimated from RFLP data as Rogers' distance (RD), which was subdivided into general (GRD) and specific (SRD) Rogers' distances within each diallel. The mean and range of RDs were similar for the older and newer lines, suggesting that the level of heterozygosity at the molecular level had not changed. GRD explained about 50% of the variation among RD values in both sets. Cluster analyses, based on modified Rogers' distances, revealed associations among lines that were generally consistent with expectations based on known pedigree and on previous research. Correlations of RD and SRD with f₁ performance, specific combining ability, and heterosis for yield and yield components, were generally positive, but too small to be of predictive value. In agreement with previous studies, our results suggest that RFLPs can be used to investigate relationships among maize inbreds, but that they are of limited usefulness for predicting the heterotic performance of single crosses between unrelated lines.Joint contribution from Cereal and Soybean Research Unit, USDA, Agricultural Research Service and Journal Paper no. J-13929 of the Iowa Agric and Home Economics Exp Stn, Ames, IA 50011. Projects no. 2818 and 2778A.E.M. is presently at the Iowa State University on leave from University of Hohenheim, D-7000 Stuttgart 70, Federal Republic of Germany     

Assessing probability of ancestry using simple sequence repeat profiles: applications to maize hybrids and inbreds

Determination of parentage is fundamental to the study of biology and to applications such as the identification of pedigrees. Limitations to studies of parentage have stemmed from the use of an insufficient number of hypervariable loci and mismatches of alleles that can be caused by mutation or by laboratory error and that can generate false exclusions. Furthermore, most studies of parentage have been limited to comparisons of small numbers of specific parent-progeny triplets thereby precluding large-scale surveys of candidates where there may be no prior knowledge of parentage. We present an algorithm that can determine probability of parentage in circumstances where there is no prior knowledge of pedigree and that is robust in the face of missing data or mistyped data. We present data from 54 maize hybrids and 586 maize inbreds that were profiled using 195 SSR loci including simulations of additional levels of missing and mistyped data to demonstrate the utility and flexibility of this algorithm.     

Growth rate rather than growth duration drives growth heterosis in maize B104 hybrids

Research in maize is often performed using inbred lines that can be readily transformed, such as B104. However, because the B104 line flowers late, the kernels do not always mature before the end of the growing season, hampering routine seed yield evaluations of biotech traits introduced in B104 at many geographical locations. Therefore, we generated five hybrids by crossing B104 with the early‐flowering inbred lines CML91, F7, H99, Mo17, and W153R and showed in three consecutive years that the hybrid lines proved to be suitable to evaluate seed yield under field conditions in a temperate climate. By assessing the two main processes driving maize leaf growth, being rate of growth (leaf elongation rate or LER) and the duration of growth (leaf elongation duration or LED) in this panel of hybrids, we showed that leaf growth heterosis was mainly the result of increased LER and not or to a lesser extent of LED. Ectopic expression of the transgenes GA20‐oxidase (GA20‐OX) and PLASTOCHRON1 (PLA1), known to stimulate the LER and LED, respectively, in the hybrids showed that leaf length heterosis can be stimulated by increased LER, but not by LED, indicating that LER rather than LED is the target for enhancing leaf growth heterosis.     

Genotype-specific heat shock proteins in two maize inbreds

Summary Leaf blade tissue of maize inbred lines B73 and Mo17 was analyzed for intraspecific genetic variability in the heat shock response. The maize inbreds were characterized for acquired thermal tolerance and patterns of heat shock protein synthesis. The leakage conductivity assay of membrane stability during stress indicated that Mol7 possesses greater potential than B73 to acquire thermal tolerance. Poly(A)⁺ RNA, extracted from leaf blades, was translated in vitro in the presence of ³⁵S-methionine and the translation products separated by twodimensional gel electrophoresis. Major genotypic differences were observed in the translation products. Mo 17 synthesized twelve unique heat shock proteins in the 15–18 kD range, but B73 synthesized only three unique heat shock proteins in the same range. DNA polymorphisms were observed between the maize lines using ³²P labeled heat shock protein gene probes.Abbreviations HKT Heat-killing time - HS Heat shock - HSP Heat shock protein - HMW High molecular weight - LMW Low molecular weight Contribution of the College of Agricultural Sciences, Texas Tech University, Journal No. T-4-333     

Cytology of inbreds and f 1 hybrids of pearl millet

Summary The meiotic behaviour of chromosomes was studied in four inbred lines and their F ₁ hybrids of P. typhoides. The inbred lines showed a decrease in mean chiasma frequency when compared with the population plants, but differed from one another in their mean chiasma frequencies. Together with the decrease in mean chiasma frequency the inbreds showed variation in mean chiasma frequencies. The inbred lines showed a number of meiotic abnormalities such as extra chromosomes, extra fragments, desynapsis, persistent nucleoli and differential condensation of chromosomes. The F ₁ hybrids of these inbreds exhibited heterosis for chiasma frequency. All the F ₁'s had mean chiasma frequencies higher than the means of the respective participating parents. The F ₁'s, however, differed in the degree of heterosis exhibited. In the F ₁ hybrids, the variation in mean chiasma frequency, both between plants and between PMC's within plants, was significantly lower than that of the inbred lines. The effect of environment was studied in the inbred lines and their F ₁ hybrids. The mean chiasma frequencies of the inbred lines were significantly lower, and the variation in mean chiasma frequencies was greater, in the stress season. The mean chiasma frequencies of F ₁'s did not show any significant differences between the two seasons. The F ₁'s exhibited less variation in mean chiasma frequency than the inbred lines, showing that F ₁'s were developmentally more stable. The F ₁'s did not show any meiotic abnormalities in either season.     

Genetic diversity for RFLPs in European maize inbreds

Summary Restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) have been proposed for the prediction of the yield potential of hybrids and the assignment of inbreds to heterotic groups. Such use was investigated in 66 diallel crosses among 6 flint and 6 dent inbreds from European maize (Zea mays L.) germ plasm. Inbreds and hybrids were evaluated for seven forage traits in four environments in the Federal Republic of Germany. Midparent heterosis (MPH) and specific combining ability (SCA) were calculated. Genetic distances (GD) between lines were calculated from RFLP data of 194 clone-enzyme combinations. GDs were greater for flint x dent than for flint x flint and dent x dent line combinations. Cluster analysis based on GDs showed separate groupings of flint and dent lines and agreed with pedigree information, except for 1 inbred. GDs of all line combinations in the diallel were partitioned into general (GGD) and specific (SGD) genetic distances; GGD explained approximately 20% of the variation among GD values. For the 62 diallel crosses (excluding 4 crosses of highly related lines), correlations of GD with F₁ performance, MPH, and SCA for dry matter yield (DMY) of stover, ear, and forage were positive but mostly of moderate size (0.09r0.60) compared with the higher correlations (0.39r0.77) of SGD with these traits. When separate calculations were performed for various subsets, correlations of GD and SGD with DMY traits were generally small (r<0.47) for the 36 flint x dent crosses, significantly positive (r<0.53) for the 14 flint x flint crosses, and inconclusive for the 12 dent x dent crosses because of the lack of significant genotypic variation. Results indicated that RFLPs can be used for assigning inbreds to heterotic groups. RFLP-based genetic distance measures seem to be useful for predicting forage yield of (1) crosses between lines from the same germ plasm group or (2) crosses including line combinations from the same as well as different heterotic groups. However, they are not indicative of the hybrid forage yield of crosses between unrelated lines from genetically divergent heterotic groups.     

Gene expression dynamics in randomly varying environments

A simple model of gene regulation in response to stochastically changing environmental conditions is developed and analyzed. The model consists of a differential equation driven by a continuous time 2-state Markov process. The density function of the resulting process converges to a beta distribution. We show that the moments converge to their stationary values exponentially in time. Simulations of a two-stage process where protein production depends on mRNA concentrations are also presented demonstrating that protein concentration tracks the environment whenever the rate of protein turnover is larger than the rate of environmental change. Single-celled organisms are therefore expected to have relatively high mRNA and protein turnover rates for genes that respond to environmental fluctuations.