Genotypic variation in tetraploid wheat affecting homoeologous pairing in hybrids with Aegilops peregrina.

The Ph1 gene has long been considered the main factor responsible for the diploid-like meiotic behavior of polyploid wheat. This dominant gene, located on the long arm of chromosome 5B (5BL), suppresses pairing of homoeologous chromosomes in polyploid wheat and in their hybrids with related species. Here we report on the discovery of genotypic variation among tetraploid wheats in the control of homoeologous pairing. Compared with the level of homoeologous pairing in hybrids between Aegilops peregrina and the bread wheat cultivar Chinese Spring (CS), significantly higher levels of homoeologous pairing were obtained in hybrids between Ae. peregrina and CS substitution lines in which chromosome 5B of CS was replaced by either 5B of Triticum turgidum ssp. dicoccoides line 09 (TTD09) or 5G of Triticum timopheevii ssp. timopheevii line 01 (TIMO1). Similarly, a higher level of homoeologous pairing was found in the hybrid between Ae. peregrina and a substitution line of CS in which chromosome arm 5BL of line TTD140 substituted for 5BL of CS. It appears that the observed effect on the level of pairing is exerted by chromosome arm 5BL of T turgidum ssp. dicoccoides, most probably by an allele of Ph1. Searching for variation in the control of homoeologous pairing among lines of wild tetraploid wheat, either T turgidum ssp. dicoccoides or T timopheevii ssp. armeniacum, showed that hybrids between Ae. peregrina and lines of these two wild wheats exhibited three different levels of homoeologous pairing: low, low intermediate, and high intermediate. The low-intermediate and high-intermediate genotypes may possess weak alleles of Ph1. The three different T turgidum ssp. dicoccoides pairing genotypes were collected from different geographical regions in Israel, indicating that this trait may have an adaptive value. The availability of allelic variation at the Ph1 locus may facilitate the mapping, tagging, and eventually the isolation of this important gene.     

The effect of B chromosomes on homoeologous pairing in species hybrids

The effect of B chromosomes on meiosis is described in the diploid and tetraploid interspecific hybrid Lolium multiflorum x Lolium perenne. Although the parental species are very closely related, the presence of B chromosomes in the diploid hybrid reduced both chiasma frequency and the number of bivalents at meiosis by a small but significant amount. However at the tetraploid level the presence of B chromosomes did not seem to alter the pairing pattern and chiasma frequency in any way. The use of B chromosomes to stabilize meiosis in amphiploids of this type between closely related outbreeding species is therefore ruled out.     

The effect of B chromosomes on homoeologous pairing in species hybrids

Six diploid populations of Lolium rigidum were used in crosses with a standard homozygous line of Lolium temulentum in order to analyse the variation in the effect of B chromosomes on homoeologous pairing in the interspecific hybrid. — Large differences in chiasma frequency were found, both between the progeny of the different populations and, in one case, between the progeny of different plants from the same population. That this variation was due to differences in B chromosome genotype was ruled out by the use of appropriate 1B Lolium rigidum parents. It is concluded therefore that the effect of B's on homoeologous pairing in this interspecific hybrid can be modified quite substantially by the A chromosome genotype of the parents.     

The effect of B chromosomes on homoeologous pairing in species hybrids

The effect of B chromosomes on chromosome pairing at meiosis was investigated in the species hybrid Lolium temulentum x L. perenne at both the diploid and tetraploid level. The presence of B chromosomes drastically reduced association of homoeologous chromosomes in both the diploids and tetraploids. This was evident from the high frequency of univalents recorded in PMC's of diploid hybrids with B's and from the predominantly bivalent association of homologous chromosomes in tetraploids of this type. In the absence of B's homoeologous pairing was extensive giving a high frequency of bivalents in the diploids and multivalents as well as bivalents and univalents in the tetraploids.     

Comparison of homoeologous chromosome pairing between hybrids of wheat genotypes Chinese Spring ph1b and Kaixian-luohanmai with rye

The ph-like genes in the Chinese common wheat landrace Kaixian-luohanmai (KL) induce homoeologous pairing in hybrids with alien species. In the present study, meiotic phenotypic differences on homoeologous chromosome pairing at metaphase I between hybrids of wheat genotypes Chinese Spring ph1b (CSph1b) and KL with rye were studied by genomic in situ hybridization (GISH). The frequency of wheat-wheat associations was higher in CSph1b×rye than in KL×rye. However, frequencies of wheat-rye and rye-rye associations were higher in KL×rye than in CSph1b×rye. These differences may be the result of different mechanisms of control between the ph-like gene(s) controlling homoeologous chromosome pairing in KL and CSph1b. Wheat-wheat associations were much more frequent than wheat-rye pairing in both hybriods. This may be caused by lower overall affinity, or homoeology, between wheat and rye chromosomes than between wheat chromosomes.     

Effect of a rye B chromosome and its segments on homoeologous pairing in hybrids between common wheat and Aegilops variabilis

Rye B chromosomes, which are supernumerary chromosomes dispensable for the host but increase in number by non-disjunction after meiosis, have been reported to affect meiotic homoeologous pairing in wheat-rye hybrids. The effect of a rye B chromosome (B) and its segments (B-9 and B-10) on homoeologous pairing was studied in hybrids between common wheat (2n=42) and Aegilops variabilis (2n=28), with reference to the Ph1 gene located on wheat chromosome 5B. The B-9 and B-10 chromosomes are derived from reciprocal translocations between a wheat and the B chromosomes, and the former had the B pericentromeric segment and the latter had the B distal segment. Both the B and B-9 chromosomes suppressed homoeologous pairing when chromosome 5B was absent. On the other hand, the B-9 and B-10 chromosomes promoted homoeologous pairing when 5B was present. On pairing suppression, B-9 had a greater effect in one dose than in two doses, and B-9 had a greater effect than B-10 had in one dose. These results suggested that the effect of the B chromosomes on homoeologous pairing was not confined to a specific region and that the intensity of the effect varied depending on the presence or absence of 5B and also on the segment and dose of the B chromosome. The mean chiasma frequency (10.23) in a hybrid (2n=36) possessing 5B and one B-9 was considerably higher than that (2.78) of a hybrid (2n=35) possessing 5B alone, and was comparable with that (14.09) of a hybrid (2n=34) lacking 5B. This fact suggested that the B chromosome or its segment can be used in introducing alien genes into wheat by inducing homoeologous pairing between wheat and alien chromosome.     

Centromeric behaviour in wheat with high and low homoeologous chromosomal pairing

Control of homoeologous chromosomal pairing in hexaploid wheat stems from a balance between a number of suppressor and promoter genes. This study used centromeric behaviour as a tool to investigate the mechanism. Fluorescent in situ hybridization employing centromeric and telomeric sequences as probes was applied to pollen mother cells of wheat and wheat/alien hybrids having different pairing gene combinations. It showed: association of centromeres during pre-meiotic interphase; decondensation of centromeric structure; sister chromatid disjunction of univalent chromosomes in homoeologous pairing situations at anaphase I; and centromeric stretching between univalent sister chromatids in wheat/rye hybrids deficient for pairing genes. The implications of these results are discussed. Received: December 1996 / in revised form: 11 March 1997 / Accepted: 14 March 1997     

Most of the homoeologous pairing at metaphase I in wheat-rye hybrids is not chiasmatic

The use of telomeric C-bands in wheat-rye hybrids has made it possible to distinguish three types of wheat-wheat (1B^L) and wheat-rye associations (a, end-to-end extremely distal; b, end-to-ed distal; and c, interstitial) between homoeologous chromosomes at different metaphase I stages (early, middle and late) and also to estimate the actual recombination frequencies for such associations at anaphase I. There was a decrease of the a and b association frequencies during the different metaphase I stages, whereas the c type remained without variation in all stages. A good fit between the frequencies of c associations at metaphase I and the number of recombinant chromosomes at anaphase I, assuming a maximum of one chiasma per bond, was found; however, there was no correspondence between metaphase I and anaphase I data when all associations (a + b + c) were considered. In addition, rye-rye homologous pairing was observed at metaphase I, but no evidence for rye-rye recombination was found at anaphase I. The results indicate that most of end-to-end (a and b) homoeologous and nonhomologous associations are actually nonchiasmatic and are a remnant of prophase pairing.     

Interaction between rye B-chromosomes and wheat genetic systems controlling homoeologous pairing

The interactive effect on homoeologous pairing of rye B-chromosomes with the absence of both pairing suppressor (3A, 3D, 5B) and promotor (3B, 5A, 5D) chromosomes of common wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) is analyzed by comparison of pairing at Metaphase I of 27-, 27+2B, 28- and 28+2B-chromosome plants. These plants were obtained from crosses between the respective wheat monosomics (2n=41) and rye plants (Secale cereale L.) carrying or not carrying two B-chromosomes (2n=14 or 14+2Bs). —The effect of rye B-chromosomes on pairing depends on the function of the wheat chromosome which is absent in the appropriate hybrids, i.e., rye B-chromosomes have a suppressor effect on pairing when the pairing suppressing wheat chromosomes 3A, 3D or 5B are absent, while they behave as promotors when the pairing promoting chromosomes 3B, 5A or 5D are absent.     

Attempts to induce homoeologous pairing between wheat and Agropyron cristatum genomes.

Agropyron cristatum (2n = 4x = 28, PPPP) possesses potentially valuable traits that could be used in wheat (Triticum aestivum) improvement through interspecific hybridization. Homoeologous pairing between wheat chromosomes and P chromosomes added to wheat in a set of wheat - A. cristatum addition lines was assessed. First, the Ph-suppressing effect of P chromosomes (except 7P) was analyzed. It was concluded that this system is polygenic with no major gene, and consequently, has no prospect in the transfer of alien genes from wild relatives. In a second step, the potential of the deletion ph1b of the Ph1 gene for inducing P-ABD pairing was evaluated. Allosyndetic associations between P and ABD genomes are very rare. This very low level of pairing is likely due to divergence in the repeated sequences between Agropyron and wheat genomes. Development of translocation lines using ionizing radiation seems to be a more suitable technique than homoeologous recombination to exploit the A. cristatum genome in wheat improvement.     

Chromosome pairing in meiosis of partially fertile wheat/rye hybrids

The normal course of meiosis depends on regular pairing of homologous chromosomes. In intergeneric hybrids, including those of wheat, there is no chromosome pairing because there are no homologs. In F₁ wheat/rye hybrids, pairing is largely prevented by the pairing homoeologous1 (Ph1) gene. In its presence, there are only rare instances of pairing; most chromosomes are univalent, and their orientation at metaphase I initiates different pathways of the meiotic cycle. The meiotic-like pathway includes a combination of the reductional and the equational + reductional steps at AI followed by the second division. The resulting gametes are mostly non-functional. The mitotic-like pathway involves equational division of univalents at AI and the absence of the second division. Any fertility of wheat/rye hybrids depends on the production of unreduced gametes arising from meiotic restitution (mitotic-like division). We examined the meiotic pairing in wheat/rye hybrids created from wheat lines with single rye chromosome substitutions and Ph1 present. This guaranteed F₁ meiosis with one pair of rye homologs. All hybrids formed bivalents, but proportions of meiocytes with bivalents varied. In the meiocytes where bivalents were present, there was a higher tendency for the meiotic-like pathway, while in meiocytes where bivalent pairing failed, the tendency was stronger for the mitotic-like pathway. Among the equationally dividing cells, we observed more than 90 % of meiocytes without bivalents, where rye homologs did not form bivalents, too. The data indicate a potential application of wheat/rye lines in producing genetic stocks of amphidiploids with designated genomic constitutions.     

Transfer of Ph I genes promoting homoeologous pairing from Triticum speltoides to common wheat

Diploid-like chromosome pairing in polyploid wheat is controlled by several Ph (pairing homoeologous) genes with major and minor effects. Homoeologous pairing occurs in either the absence of these genes or their inhibition by genes from other species (Ph ^I genes). We transferred Ph ^I genes from Triticum speltoides (syn Aegilops speltoides) to T. aestivum, and on the basis of further analysis it appears that two duplicate and independent Ph ^I genes were transferred. Since Ph ^I genes are epistatic to the Ph genes of wheat, homoeologous pairing between the wheat and alien chromosomes occurs in the F₁ hybrids. Using the Ph ^I gene stock, we could demonstrate homoeologous pairing between the wheat and Haynaldia villosa chromosomes. Since homoeologous pairing occurs in F₁ hybrids and no cytogenetic manipulation is needed, the Ph ^I gene stock may be a versatile tool for effecting rapid and efficient alien genetic transfers to wheat.Contribution no. 93-435-J from the Kansas Agricultural Experiment Station, Kansas State University, Manhattan, KS 66506-5502, USA     

Retention of D genome chromosomes in pentaploid wheat crosses

The transfer of genes between Triticum aestivum (hexaploid bread wheat) and T. turgidum (tetraploid durum wheat) holds considerable potential for genetic improvement of both these closely related species. Five different T. aestivum/T. turgidum ssp. durum crosses were investigated using Diversity Arrays Technology (DArT) markers to determine the inheritance of parental A, B and D genome material in subsequent generations derived from these crosses. The proportions of A, B and D chromosomal segments inherited from the hexaploid parent were found to vary significantly among individual crosses. F(2) populations retained widely varying quantities of D genome material, ranging from 99% to none. The relative inheritance of bread wheat and durum alleles in the A and B genomes of derived lines also varied among the crosses. Within any one cross, progeny without D chromosomes in general had significantly more A and B genome durum alleles than lines retaining D chromosomes. The ability to select for and manipulate this non-random segregation in bread wheat/durum crosses will assist in efficient backcrossing of selected characters into the recurrent durum or hexaploid genotype of choice. This study illustrates the utility of DArT markers in the study of inter-specific crosses to commercial crop species.     

Inducing chromosome pairing through premature condensation: analysis of wheat interspecific hybrids

At the onset of meiosis, chromosomes first decondense and then condense as the process of recognition and intimate pairing occurs between homologous chromosomes. We show here that okadaic acid, a drug known to induce chromosome condensation, can be introduced into wheat interspecific hybrids prior to meiosis to induce chromosome pairing. This pairing occurs in the presence of the Ph1 locus, which usually suppresses pairing of related chromosomes and which we show here delays condensation. Thus the timing of chromosome condensation during the onset of meiosis is an important factor in controlling chromosome pairing.     

Effectiveness of ph gene in inducing homoeologous chromosome pairing in agrotricum

Summary We observed pairing, when the ph gene was present, between wheat (Triticum aestivum L. em. Thell.) chromosome 4B, and an Agropyron intermedium (Host) Beauv. chromosome (Ai) carrying a gene resistant to wheat streak mosaic (WSM). In a monosomic addition polyhaploid [2n = 22 = 19' + 5B' (ph) + 4B' + Ai'], we recorded an average of 4.1 bivalents and 0.3 trivalents per cell. Induced homoeologous pairing was most effective when both 5B chromosomes carrying ph gene were present. Our data suggest that chromosome 4B of wheat and the Agropyron chromosome (Ai) carrying a gene for resistance to WSM are homoeologous and that it is possible to use either ph mutant or nullisomic 5B stock to induce genetic recombination between the two chromosomes.Contribution No. 1657-j, Kansas State Agric. Expt. Sta., Manhattan, KS. The research is partially supported by a grant from Kansas Wheat Commission     

Production of wheat-barley recombinant chromosomes through induced homoeologous pairing

Summary Sears' phlb mutant was used successfully for the first time to induce pairing and recombination between specific barley chromosomes and their wheat homoeologues. Pairing was induced in specially constructed genetic stocks having 19 pairs of wheat chromosomes and triply monosomic for either barley chromosome arm 6HL or 3HL, a related wheat chromosome, and chromosome 5B of wheat carrying the phlb mutation. Wheat-barley recombinant chromosomes were isolated from among the progeny obtained from self-fertilization of the triple monosomic stocks, by screening for dissociation of biochemical markers on the barley arms. Glutamic oxaloacetic transaminase (GOT), aconitase hydratase (ACO), and dipeptidase (DIP) isozymes were used to select recombinants involving the 6HL arm, and esterase (EST) and malate dehydrogenase (MDH) were used for the 3HL arm. Altogether, six recombinants involving 6HL (1.4%) and six involving 3HL (1.1%) were isolated. These wheat-barley recombinant chromosomes are being used to construct a detailed gene order map of barley based on biochemical and molecular markers.     

Mathematical comparison of homologous and homoeologous chromosome configurations and the mode of action of the genes regulating pairing in wheat

Analyses of frequencies of chromosome configurations in wheat and wheat hybrids are extended to include data from hybrids of three chromosome-pairing mutants of wheat with Aegilops variabilis and from autotetraploid Triticum monococcum. These data confirm and extend the theory proposed by Driscoll, Bielig and Darvey (1979). Homoeologous and homologous chromosome pairing are fundamentally identical. The mode of action of the genes regulating pairing in wheat involves either physical alteration in the chromosomes themselves or changes in an enzyme system that monitors pairing.