High-valent transition metal centers and noninnocent ligands in metalloporphyrins and related molecules: a broad overview based on quantum chemical calculations

Using density functional theory, we have carried out a quantum chemical survey of high-valent transition metal porphyrins and related compounds. Discussed herein are recent developments on metalloporphyrin pi-cation radicals, high-valent manganese and iron porphyrins and heme protein intermediates, nickel(III) porphyrinoids, coenzyme F430, and high-valent transition metal corroles. In particular, we focus on whether the molecules of interest feature "true" high-valent metal centers, whether the ligands are oxidized instead, i.e. are noninnocent, or whether the electronic structures fall somewhere along the continuum between these scenarios.     

High-valent transition metal corrolazines

High-valent metalloporphyrin intermediates have been implicated as key players in numerous mechanistic proposals for both biological (e.g., heme protein) and synthetic porphyrin mediated transformations. However, the direct observation of these species is quite challenging because of the inherently short lifetimes of many of these metalloporphyrin intermediates. This review focuses on our own efforts to synthesize and study a new class of porphyrinoid compounds called corrolazines, which are designed to stabilize high-valent species for direct analysis. These compounds are related to corroles, which also exhibit the unusual ability to stabilize high oxidation states, and the reactivity and physical properties of relevant corrole and porphyrin analogs are compared with the appropriate corrolazines. The chemistry of Cu, Co, V, and Mn are highlighted, with a particular emphasis on the reactivity of high-valent manganese-oxo complexes.     

Spectroscopy and electronic structures of mono- and binuclear high-valent non-heme iron-oxo systems

High-valent iron-oxo intermediates are known or believed to be key oxidizing species in the catalytic mechanisms of many mononuclear and binuclear non-heme iron enzymes. So far only limited experimental data on their electronic structures are available. In this study we extend knowledge from the experimentally well characterized mononuclear Fe(IV)=O (S=1) biomimetic model system to computational insight into the spectroscopy and electronic structures of mono-and binuclear high-valent iron-oxo enzyme intermediates. In the mononuclear Fe(IV)=O complexes, we predict the spectroscopy and energies of the electronic transitions to be very different for the S=1 and S=2 spin states, but the iron-oxo bonding for both spin states to be very similar. A comparison of the S=2 mono- and binuclear high-valent iron-sites predicts similar electronic transitions. However, the bent iron-oxo bridge and interactions with the second iron-center in the dimer shift the transitions to higher energies and splits the d(xz/yz) orbital set. These electronic structure and TD-DFT results provide a basis for understanding the spectroscopy and electronic structures of high-valent intermediates in mono- and binuclear non-heme iron enzymes.     

Structures of the high-valent metal-ion haem-oxygen intermediates in peroxidases, oxygenases and catalases

Peroxidases, oxygenases and catalases have similar high-valent metal-ion intermediates in their respective reaction cycles. In this review, haem-based examples will be discussed. The intermediates of the haem-containing enzymes have been extensively studied for many years by different spectroscopic methods like UV-Vis, EPR (electron paramagnetic resonance), resonance Raman, M?ssbauer and MCD (magnetic circular dichroism). The first crystal structure of one of these high-valent intermediates was on cytochrome c peroxidase in 1987. Since then, structures have appeared for catalases in 1996, 2002, 2003, putatively for cytochrome P450 in 2000, for myoglobin in 2002, for horseradish peroxidase in 2002 and for cytochrome c peroxidase again in 1994 and 2003. This review will focus on the most recent structural investigations for the different intermediates of these proteins. The structures of these intermediates will also be viewed in light of quantum mechanical (QM) calculations on haem models. In particular quantum refinement, which is a combination of QM calculations and crystallography, will be discussed. Only small structural changes accompany the generation of these intermediates. The crystal structures show that the compound I state, with a so called pi-cation radical on the haem group, has a relatively short iron-oxygen bond (1.67-1.76A) in agreement with a double-bond character, while the compound II state or the compound I state with a radical on an amino acid residue have a relatively long iron-oxygen bond (1.86-1.92A) in agreement with a single-bond character where the oxygen-atom is protonated.     

The influence of X-rays on the structural studies of peroxide-derived myoglobin intermediates

In recent years, the awareness of potential radiation damage of metal centers in protein crystals during crystallographic data collection has received increasing attention. The radiation damage can lead to radiation-induced changes and reduction of the metal sites. One of the research fields where these concerns have been comprehensively addressed is the study of the reaction intermediates of the heme peroxidase and oxygenase reaction cycles. For both the resting states and the high-valent intermediates, the X-rays used in the structure determination have given undesired side effects through radiation-induced changes to the trapped intermediates. However, X-rays have been used to generate and trap the peroxy/hydroperoxy state in crystals. In this review, the structural work and the influence of X-rays on these intermediates in myoglobin are summarized and viewed in light of analogous studies on similar intermediates in peroxidases and oxygenases.     

Kinetic solvent isotope effect in steady-state turnover by CYP19A1 suggests involvement of Compound 1 for both hydroxylation and aromatization steps

CYP19A1, or human aromatase catalyzes the conversion of androgens to estrogens in a three-step reaction through the formation of 19-hydroxy and 19-aldehyde intermediates. While the first two steps of hydroxylation are thought to proceed through a high-valent iron-oxo species, controversy exists surrounding the identity of the reaction intermediate that catalyzes the lyase and aromatization reaction. We investigated the kinetic isotope effect on the steady-state turnover of Nanodisc-incorporated human CYP19A1 to explore the mechanisms of this reaction. Our experiments reveal a significant (∼2.5) kinetic solvent isotope effect for the C10–C19 lyase reaction, similar to that of the first two hydroxylation steps (2.7 and 1.2). These data implicate the involvement of Compound 1 as a reactive intermediate in the final aromatization step of CYP19A1.     

High-valent nonheme iron-oxo species in biomimetic oxidations

High valent iron-oxo species are often invoked as the key oxidizing agents in the catalytic cycles of oxygen activating nonheme iron enzymes, and three of these intermediates have in fact been characterized. To gain further insight into such species, a number of biomimetic complexes have been designed and investigated as functional models for these enzymes. Progress since 2000 is summarized in this review. Many of the model complexes discussed in this review carry out oxidative transformations of relevance to the enzymatic reactions; however, the participation of a high-valent iron-oxo species (Fe(IV)O or Fe(V)O) can only be inferred. Arguments in support of a metal-based oxidant (rather than an oxygen radical species) usually hinge on the high conversion for the transformation and the nature of the reaction products, as well as the incorporation of label into these products from H(2)(18)O or related species. Within this time period, the first bona fide nonheme Fe(IV)O complexes have been generated and identified spectroscopically, three of which are crystallographically characterized. Taken together, these studies emphasize the important role the supporting polydentate ligand plays in eliciting the desired high-valent iron-oxo chemistry.     

Rate-limiting step of the iron porphyrin-catalysed oxidation of cyclohexane to adipic acid by DFT method

Deep understanding of the rate-limiting step in the oxidation process of cyclohexane to adipic acid would be useful for improving the activity of catalysts and selectivity of goal products. The rate-limiting step lied in high-valent species generation or C–H bond oxidation remains a controversial topic. In this paper, the mechanism of high-valent species generation and C–H bond activation was investigated by density functional theory. It was observed that the activation barrier of the high-valent species was lower than that of C–H bond activation; thereby the C–H bond oxidation was determined as the rate-limiting step. Calculated geometries and energies were in close agreement with the experimental observations. Furthermore, frontier molecular orbital analysis revealed that the C–H bond interacted with the high-valent species in different orientation and it showed how the reaction was manipulated and controlled by the iron–porphyrin in the catalytic process. Given the calculation correction, experiments were designed to reveal the rate-limiting step. This work provides a clear view of the debut on the rate-limiting step of the alkane oxidation. It should be a significant step forward for understanding the relationship between the porphyrin molecular structures and catalytic activity accurately and for predicting and designing high-activity catalysts.     

How axial ligands control the reactivity of high-valent iron(IV)-oxo porphyrin pi-cation radicals in alkane hydroxylation: a computational study

The push effect of anionic axial ligands of high-valent iron(IV)-oxo porphyrin pi-cation radicals, (Porp)(+.)Fe(IV)(O)(X) (X=OH(-), AcO(-), Cl(-), and CF(3)SO(3)(-)), in alkane hydroxylation is investigated by B3LYP DFT calculations. The electron-donating ability of anionic axial ligands influences the activation energy for the alkane hydroxylation by the iron(IV)-oxo intermediates and the Fe-O bond distance of the iron-oxo species in transition state.     

Enzymatic C-H activation by metal-superoxo intermediates

The mechanisms of four enzymes that initiate oxidation of their substrates by using mid-valent metal-superoxo intermediates, rather than the more frequently described high-valent iron-oxo complexes, to cleave relatively strong C-H bonds have come into focus in the past several years. In two of these reactions, the alternative manifold for O2 and C-H activation enables unique four-electron oxidation reactions, thus significantly augmenting Nature's arsenal for transformation of aliphatic carbon compounds. General principles of this alternative manifold, including common kinetic characteristics and thermodynamic limitations, are emerging. Recent, combined experimental and computational studies on other systems have shown how a more thorough understanding of the structures of the metal-superoxo intermediates and the mechanisms by which they cleave C-H bonds might be achieved.     

Stalking intermediates in oxygen activation by iron enzymes: motivation and method

The study of high-valent-iron enzyme intermediates began in the mid-1900s with the discovery of compounds I (or ES) and II in the heme peroxidases, progressed to non-heme-diiron enzymes in the 1990s with the detection and characterization of the Fe(III)-Fe(IV) complex, X, and the Fe(IV)-Fe(IV) complex, Q, in O(2) activation by ribonucleotide reductase R2 (RNR-R2) and soluble methane monooxygenase (sMMO), respectively, and was most recently extended to mononuclear non-heme-iron oxygenases with the trapping and spectroscopic characterization of the Fe(IV)-oxo intermediate, J, in the reaction of taurine:alpha-ketoglutarate dioxygenase (TauD). Individually, each of these landmark studies helped reveal the chemical logic of that particular enzyme system. Collectively, they have significantly advanced our understanding of Nature's strategies for oxidative transformation of biomolecules (both natural and "xenobiotic"). With high-valent complexes now having been described in representatives of three major classes of iron enzymes, it is an appropriate time to ask whether and what additional insights might be gleaned from further stalking of related intermediates in other systems. In this review, we advocate that there is still much to be learned from this pursuit and summarize the insight provided by two of the landmark discoveries mentioned above (the latter two) and the subsequent studies that they spurred to support our contention. In addition, we attempt to provide, to the extent that it is possible to do so, a "how-to" guide for detection and characterization of such intermediates, focusing primarily on enzymes in which they form by activation of molecular oxygen. In this latter objective, we have drawn from an earlier review by Johnson (Enzymes, third ed. vol. 20, 1992, pp. 1-61) covering, more generally, dissection of enzyme reaction pathways by transient-state kinetic methods. That work elegantly illustrated that, although it may be impossible to develop a true algorithm for the process, a synthesis of guidelines and general principles can be of considerable value.     

The dynamic role of distal side residues in heme hydroperoxidase catalysis. Interplay between X-ray crystallography and ab initio MD simulations

The enzymatic cycle of hydroperoxidases involves the resting Fe(III) state of the enzyme and the high-valent iron intermediates Compound I and Compound II. These states might be characterized by X-ray crystallography and the transition pathways between each state can be investigated using atomistic simulations. Here we review our recent work in the modeling of two key steps of the enzymatic reaction of hydroperoxidases: the formation of Cpd I in peroxidase and the reduction of Cpd I in catalase. It will be shown that small conformational motions of distal side residues (His in peroxidases and His/Asn in catalases), not,or only partially, revealed by the available X-ray structures, play an important role in the catalytic processes examined.     

Deuterium isotope effects in norcamphor metabolism by cytochrome P-450cam: kinetic evidence for the two-electron reduction of a high-valent iron-oxo intermediate

The kinetics of NADH consumption, oxygen uptake, and hydrogen peroxide production have been studied for norcamphor metabolism by cytochrome P-450cam. The kinetic deuterium isotope effects on these processes, with specifically deuteriated norcamphor, are 0.77, 1.22, and 1.16, respectively. Steady-state UV-visible spectroscopy indicates that transfer of the second electron to the dioxy ferrous P-450 is the rate-limiting step, as it is when camphor is the substrate. The inverse deuterium isotope effect for NADH consumption is consistent with an isotope-dependent branching between monooxygenase and oxidase activity, where these reactivities differ in their NADH:oxygen stoichiometries. However, no isotope-dependent redistribution of steady-state intermediates was detected by isotopic difference UV-visible spectroscopy in the presence of norcamphor. The kinetic isotope effects and steady-state spectral results suggest that the high-valent iron-oxo hydroxylating intermediate [FeO]3+ is reduced by NADH and the physiological electron-transfer proteins to afford water.     

High-valent transition metal centers versus noninnocent ligands in metallocorroles: insights from electrochemistry and implications for high-valent heme protein intermediates

For relatively electron-rich corrole ligands, the halfwave potentials for oxidation of Cu(III), Sn(IV)Ph, Fe(IV)Ph, and Fe(IV)-O-Fe(IV) complexes are significantly lower than those of Sn(IV)Cl, Fe(IV)Cl, Mn(IV)Cl, and Cr(V)(O) complexes, suggesting that the corrole ligand is relatively electron-rich or 'innocent' in the former group of complexes and that it is relatively electron-deficient or 'noninnocent' in the latter group. Both the formal charge of the central metal ion and the nature of the axial ligand, if any, appear to be key determinants of the electronic character of the corrole ligand in metallocorrole complexes, a theme that has interesting resonances with recent findings on high-valent heme protein intermediates. However, for very strongly electron-deficient ligands such as meso-tris(pentafluorophenyl)corrole (TPFPC) and beta-octabromo-meso-tris(pentafluorophenyl)corrole (Br(8)TPFPC), which cannot sustain significant radical character, the various metal complexes all exhibit comparable halfwave potentials for oxidation and the ligand may be considered to be relatively innocent.     

Post-translational self-hydroxylation: a probe for oxygen activation mechanisms in non-heme iron enzymes

Recent years have seen considerable evolution in our understanding of the mechanisms of oxygen activation by non-heme iron enzymes, with high-valent iron-oxo intermediates coming to the forefront as formidably potent oxidants. In the absence of substrate, the generation of vividly colored chromophores deriving from the self-hydroxylation of a nearby aromatic amino acid for a number of these enzymes has afforded an opportunity to discern the conditions under which O2 activation occurs to generate a high-valent iron intermediate, and has provided a basis for a rigorous mechanistic examination of the oxygenation process. Here, we summarize the current evidence for self-hydroxylation processes in both mononuclear non-heme iron enzymes and in mutant forms of ribonucleotide reductase, and place it within the context of our developing understanding of the oxidative transformations accomplished by non-heme iron centers.     

Water-soluble rylene dyes as high-performance colorants for the staining of cells

The synthesis of perylene and terrylene chromophores carrying a single poly(ethylene oxide) chain is presented. These chromophores reveal a strong solvatochromic behavior: High fluorescence in nonpolar solvents and weak fluorescence in polar solvents which is mainly attributed to aggregation. Therefore, such chromophores are attractive candidates as sensitive fluorescent probes reflecting the polarity of their environment. In particular, their suitability for the staining of cellular membranes is presented in detail.     

Fe–O versus O–O bond cleavage in reactive iron peroxide intermediates of superoxide reductase

It is generally accepted that the catalytic cycles of superoxide reductases (SORs) and cytochromes P450 involve a ferric hydroperoxo intermediate at a mononuclear iron center with a coordination sphere consisting of four equatorial nitrogen ligands and one axial cysteine thiolate trans to the hydroperoxide. However, although SORs and P450s have similar intermediates, SORs selectively cleave the Fe–O bond and liberate peroxide, whereas P450s cleave the O–O bond to yield a high-valent iron center. This difference has attracted the interest of researchers, and is further explored here. Meta hybrid DFT (M06-2X) results for the reactivity of the putative peroxo/hydroperoxo reaction intermediates in the catalytic cycle of SORs were found to indicate a high-spin preference in all cases. An exploration of the energy profiles for Fe–O and O–O bond cleavage in all spin states in both ferric and ferrous models revealed that Fe–O bond cleavage always occurs more easily than O–O bond cleavage. While O–O bond cleavage appears to be thermodynamically and kinetically unfeasible in ferric hydrogen peroxide complexes, it could occur as a minor (significantly disfavored) side reaction in the interaction of ferrous SOR with hydrogen peroxide.     

Limited proteolysis analysis of the ribosome is affected by subunit association

Our understanding of the structural organization of ribosome assembly intermediates, in particular those intermediates that result from misfolding leading to their eventual degradation within the cell, is limited because of the lack of methods available to characterize assembly intermediate structures. Because conventional structural approaches, such as NMR, X‐ray crystallography, and cryo‐EM, are not ideally suited to characterize the structural organization of these flexible and sometimes heterogeneous assembly intermediates, we have set out to develop an approach combining limited proteolysis with matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI‐MS) that might be applicable to ribonucleoprotein complexes as large as the ribosome. This study focuses on the limited proteolysis behavior of appropriately assembled ribosome subunits. Isolated subunits were analyzed using limited proteolysis and MALDI‐MS and the results were compared with previous data obtained from 70S ribosomes. Generally, ribosomal proteins were found to be more stable in 70S ribosomes than in their isolated subunits, consistent with a reduction in conformational flexibility on subunit assembly. This approach demonstrates that limited proteolysis combined with MALDI‐MS can reveal structural changes to ribosomes on subunit assembly or disassembly, and provides the appropriate benchmark data from 30S, 50S, and 70S proteins to enable studies of ribosome assembly intermediates. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 91: 410–422, 2009. This article was originally published online as an accepted preprint. The “Published Online” date corresponds to the preprint version. You can request a copy of the preprint by emailing the Biopolymers editorial office at biopolymers@wiley.com     

The reaction mechanisms of heme catalases: an atomistic view by ab initio molecular dynamics

Catalases are ubiquitous enzymes that prevent cell oxidative damage by degrading hydrogen peroxide to water and oxygen (2H(2)O(2) → 2H(2)O+O(2)) with high efficiency. The enzyme is first oxidized to a high-valent iron intermediate, known as Compound I (Cpd I, Por(·+)-Fe(IV)=O) which, at difference from other hydroperoxidases, is reduced back to the resting state by further reacting with H(2)O(2). The normal catalase activity is reduced if Cpd I is consumed in a competing side reaction, forming a species named Cpd I*. In recent years, Density Functional Theory (DFT) methods have unraveled the electronic configuration of these high-valent iron species, helping to assign the intermediates trapped in the crystal structures of oxidized catalases. It has been demonstrated that the a priori assumption that the H(+)/H(-) type of mechanism for Cpd I reduction leads to the generation of singlet oxygen is not justified. Moreover, it has been shown by ab initio metadynamics simulations that two pathways are operative for Cpd I reduction: a His-mediated mechanism (described as H·/H(+) + e(-)) in which the distal His acts as an acid-base catalyst and a direct mechanism (described as H·/H·) in which the distal His does not play a direct role. Independently of the mechanism, the reaction proceeds by two one-electron transfers rather than one two-electron transfer, as previously assumed. Electron transfer to Cpd I, regardless of whether the electron is exogenous or endogenous, facilitates protonation of the oxoferryl group, to the point that formation of Cpd I* may be controlled by the easiness of protonation of reduced Cpd I.     

Effect of redox potential of the heme on the peroxidase activity of cytochrome b562

Measurements of peroxidase activities of two site-specific mutants and wild type cytochrome b562 suggest that the enzymatic activity correlates with the redox potential of the metal center. A lower value of the Fe(3+)/Fe(2+) redox potential seems to be important for promoting peroxidase activity of the hemeprotein possibly by stabilization of the high-valent redox intermediate involved in the catalytic function. The results provide an approach towards rational tuning of enzyme function when 'grafted' into a new protein environment.