Arrest of the cell cycle reduces susceptibility of target cells to perforin-mediated lysis

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes secrete a pore-forming cytolysin, perforin, that damages membranes of target cells. They also ligate Fas receptors on target cells and provoke apoptotic death. A20 (B lymphoma) and P815 (mastocytoma) cell lines were examined for their susceptibility to perforin-mediated lysis and to Fas-induced apoptosis after blockade of the cell cycle at the G₁/S interface. Cells were arrested at the G₁/S interface by inhibition of DNA synthesis with thymidine or aphidicolin. Subsequently, the treated cells were incubated either with CTL cytotoxic granules or the Fas-specific monoclonal antibody Jo-2. We show that arrest of the cell cycle at the G₁/S interface markedly reduced the susceptibility of target cells to perforin-mediated lysis. In contrast, growth arrest with thymidine or aphidicolin increased susceptibility of A20 and P815 cells to Fas-mediated apoptosis. Susceptibility to lysis by intact CTLs was not affected significantly by blockade of target cells with aphidicolin or thymidine. When cells surviving exposure to perforin-containing granules were isolated on Ficoll density gradients and cell-cycle profiles were examined by flow cytometry, the ratio of G₁ to G₂cells increased among the survivors exposed to granules in contrast to controls incubated with buffer alone. The data suggest that cells in G₁ phase of the cell cycle are less susceptible to the perforin pathway than cells in G₂and S phases but are more susceptible to the Fas pathway. J. Cell. Biochem. 69:425–435, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Recognition and lysis of target cells by cytotoxic T lymphocytes

A single cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) is capable of performing the two most fundamental functions of an immune response, recognition and elimination of foreign antigens. It is now clear that in a CTL these two functions are linked via the antigen-specific, heterodimeric receptor. We review here some experimental approaches that justify this conclusion and provide the means for further examination of the mechanisms by which CTLs lyse their target cells. When antireceptor antibodies serving as antigen substitutes are attached to various cells, they trigger the lytic activity of particular CTLs, which results in lysis of the antibody-modified cell. In the process, a novel serine esterase, which is located within cytolytic granules of the CTL, is released. The presence of this enzyme and a complement-like protein, perforin, in granules of a CTL has led to the suggestion that CTLs and complement have similar cytolytic mechanisms. However, the resistance of some CTLs to lysis by other CTLs, but not to lysis by antibody-activated complement, suggests fundamental differences between cytolytic mechanisms of CTLs and complement.     

Vasoactive intestinal peptide and pituitary adenylate cyclase-activating polypeptide inhibit T cell-mediated cytotoxicity by inhibiting Fas ligand expression

We reported recently that the neuropeptides vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP) and pituitary adenylate cyclase-activating polypeptide (PACAP) protect CD4+ T cells against Ag-induced apoptosis by down-regulating the expression of Fas ligand (FasL). Because the cytotoxic activity of CD8+ CTLs is mediated through two mechanisms, which involve the perforin/granzyme and the FasL/Fas pathways, in this study we investigated the effects of VIP/PACAP on the generation and activity of allogeneic CTLs, of CD8+ T1 and T2 effector cells and of alloreactive peritoneal exudate cytotoxic T cells (PEL) generated in vivo. VIP/PACAP did not affect perforin/granzyme-mediated cytotoxicity, perforin gene expression, or granzyme B enzymatic activity, but drastically inhibited FasL/Fas-mediated cytotoxicity against allogeneic or syngeneic Fas-bearing targets. VIP/PACAP inhibit CTL generation, but not the activity of competent CTLs. The inhibition is associated with a profound down-regulation of FasL expression, and these effects are mediated through both VPAC1 and VPAC2 receptors. VIP/PACAP inhibit the FasL/Fas-mediated cytotoxicity of T1 effectors and do not affect T2 cytotoxicity, which is entirely perforin/granzyme mediated. Similar effects were observed in vivo. Both the FasL/Fas-mediated cytotoxicity and FasL expression of cytotoxic allogeneic PELs generated in vivo in the presence of VIP or PACAP were significantly reduced. We conclude that, similar to their effect on CD4+ T cells, the two structurally related neuropeptides inhibit FasL expression in CD8+ cytotoxic T cells and the subsequent lysis of Fas-bearing target cells.     

Clonal analysis in the ultrastructure of cell-to-cell interaction between a human glioma cell line and autologous tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes

The clonal analysis in the ultrastructure of tumor-lymphocyte interaction was carried out in order to investigate the precise mechanism responsible for CTL-mediated cytolysis of tumor cells. A glioma-derived cell line (GI-1) and autologous tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones were established. The CTL lines were composed of the morphologically homogeneous lymphocytes with intracytoplasmic electron-dense secretory granules. After the stimulation by GI-1, the size of the CTLs increased, and the intracytoplasmic organellas were developed. It was noted that the intracytoplasmic secretory granules markedly increased in number and size, and many of them exhibited an "immature" appearance. On the other hand, the tumor cells underwent a progressive degeneration. In contrast, the stimulation by other antigens caused only small morphological changes in the CTLs. It is suggested, therefore, that the secretory function of tumor-specific CTLs is activated by the stimulation of the specific antigen, and that soluble factors in the secretory granules in the CTLs may be closely associated with the mechanism of target cell lysis.     

Treatment of melanoma with 5-fluorouracil or dacarbazine in vitro sensitizes cells to antigen-specific CTL lysis through perforin/granzyme- and Fas-mediated pathways

Several factors may influence sensitivity of melanoma cells to CTL lysis. One is the avidity of the CTL TCR. A second is that certain cytotoxic drugs have been reported to sensitize cancer cells to CTL lysis through Fas-mediated apoptosis. In this study, we examined whether antineoplastic agents 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) and dacarbazine (DTIC) sensitize melanoma cells to lysis of G209 peptide-specific CTL. Our results show that CTL generated from PBMC are HLA-A2 restricted and gp100 specific. Treatment with 5-FU or DTIC sensitized melanoma cells to lysis of G209-specific CTL. Most importantly, 5-FU- or DTIC-treated melanoma cells also became sensitive to low-avidity CTL, which per se are less cytolytic to melanomas. We sought to identify apoptotic pathways mediating this effect. The enhanced cytolysis was mediated through the perforin/granzyme pathway. Although 5-FU up-regulated FasR expression on melanoma cells, sensitization was not blocked by anti-Fas Ab, and the G209-specific CTL was Fas ligand (FasL) negative. However, when G209-specific CTL were stimulated to express FasL, FasL signaling also contributed to enhanced cytolysis. DTIC treatment, which did not increase FasR expression, also sensitized FasL-mediated killing induced by neutralizing anti-Fas Ab. For CD95L-positive G209-specific CTL, the sensitization was primarily mediated through the perforin/granzyme pathway regardless of up-regulation of FasR. The findings demonstrate that cytotoxic drug-mediated sensitization primes both perforin/granzyme and Fas-mediated killing by melanoma-specific CTL. Considering that most of autoreactive antitumor CTL are low avidity, the findings provide experimental basis for understanding cytotoxic and immunologic therapeutic synergy in melanoma.     

Expression and function of synaptotagmin VII in CTLs

The Ca(2+) sensor synaptotagmin (Syt) VII regulates the exocytosis of conventional lysosomes in several cell types. In CTLs, the Ca(2+)-regulated exocytosis of lytic granules/secretory lysosomes is responsible for the perforin/granzyme-mediated lysis of target cells. To investigate the role of Syt VII in CTL effector function, the expression and function of Syt VII were examined in wild-type and Syt VII-deficient mice. In comparison with Syt VII(+/+) controls, Syt VII(-/-) animals were impaired in their ability to clear an infection with the intracellular pathogen Listeria monocytogenes. When isolated CTLs were examined, we found that Syt VII is expressed upon CTL activation and localizes to granzyme A-containing lytic granules. Syt VII-deficient CTLs have no defects in proliferation and cytokine production, and their lytic granules contain normal amounts of perforin and granzyme A and polarize normally at the immunological synapse. However, despite normal conjugate formation with target cells, CTLs from Syt VII(-/-) mice exhibit reduced effector activity, when compared with controls. Treatment of Syt VII(+/+) or Syt VII(-/-) CTLs with an inhibitor of the perforin-mediated lytic pathway resulted in comparable levels of cytotoxic activity, suggesting that Syt VII regulates perforin-mediated cytolytic CTL responses.     

Inhibition of heat shock protein synthesis and thermotolerance by cycloheximide

Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells were exposed to a 43 degrees C, 15-min heat shock to study the relationship between protein synthesis and the development of thermotolerance. The 43 degrees C heat shock triggered the synthesis of three protein families having molecular weights of 110,000, 90,000, and 65,000 (HSP). These proteins were synthesized at 37 and 46 degrees C. This heat shock also induced the development of thermotolerance, which was measured by incubating the cells at 46 degrees C 4 h after the 43 degrees C heat treatment. CHO cells were also exposed to 20 micrograms/ml of cycloheximide for 30 min at 37 degrees C, 15 min at 43 degrees C, and 4 h at 37 degrees C. This treatment inhibited the enhanced synthesis of the Mr 110,000, 90,000, and 65,000 proteins. The cycloheximide was then washed out and the cells were incubated at 46 degrees C. HSP synthesis did not recover during the 46 degrees C incubation. This cycloheximide treatment also partially inhibited the development of thermotolerance. These results suggest that for CHO cells to express thermotolerance when exposed to the supralethal temperature of 46 degrees C protein synthesis is necessary.     

Cloned cytotoxic T lymphocyte target cells fail to induce early activation events in effector cytotoxic T lymphocytes

We have explored further the basis for resistance of cloned cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) to cell-mediated cytotoxicity. We find that most cloned CTLs recognized as specific target cells by other cloned CTLs used as effector cells fail to activate three early events that may be critical in triggering lysis in the effector CTLs: Ca2+ influx, microtubule organizing center (MTOC) reorientation, and serine esterase release. To the extent that any or all of these events are involved in activation or expression of the lytic pathway in effector CTLs, our results suggest that in addition to being inherently resistant to cytotoxic granule extracts, many CTLs are also unable to induce lytic function in other (effector) CTLs. We have found one CTL clone that can respond to recognizable cloned CTL target cells with at least MTOC reorientation and serine esterase release, although the target CTLs are still not lysed. In this case, the resistance of the target CTL to lysis may be due solely to its resistance to cytoplasmic granule contents.     

Fas-mediated T cell deletion potentiates tumor antigen-specific tolerance in a mouse model of prostate cancer

A pivotal obstacle to cancer immunotherapy is peripheral T cell tolerance to tumor-associated antigens (TAAs). Tolerance induction among mature T cells in the periphery operates through a variety of mechanisms, including anergy and apoptosis. Although Fas-FasL-mediated apoptosis is a well-defined tolerance inducing mechanism, direct evidence of its interference with TAA-specific immunity in vivo is still lacking. In this report, we used the TRAMP mouse, which expresses SV40 large T antigen (Tag) preferentially in the prostate and develops prostate tumors, as a model system to address the role of Fas-mediated apoptosis in regulating peripheral T cell tolerance. Using RT-PCR and tetramer staining to quantify TAA-specific TCR-expressing cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTLs), we have shown the presence of TAA-specific CTLs at higher levels in TRAMP mice than in syngeneic C57Bl/6 mice. Tag-specific immunization led to the expansion of Tag-specific CTLs in C57Bl/6 mice, and to their elimination in TRAMP mice. Interestingly, in TRAMP mice with deficient Fas (Hybrid TRAMP-lpr/lpr), Tag-specific CTL elimination in response to Tag immunization did not take place. The results of cytolytic-function assays were consistent with induction and elimination patterns of TAA-specific CTLs and those of RT-PCR and tetramer staining. In conclusion, our data show that Fas-mediated TAA-specific CTL apoptosis contributes to T cell tolerance and suggest that such tolerance could be potentiated following TAA-specific immunization.     

Effect of heat shock on function of frozen/thawed bull spermatozoa

Deposition of spermatozoa in the reproductive tract of hyperthermic cows could conceivably result in sperm damage. Accordingly, a series of experiments tested the effects of heat shock on functional characteristics and free radical production of bull spermatozoa. Viability was reduced slightly by short-term (1 to 3 h) culture at 42 and 43 degrees C as compared with culture at 39 degrees C. There was no effect of culture at 42 degrees C on the ability of spermatozoa to undergo swim-up or of 42 degrees C on the percentage of motile spermatozoa. However, exposure to 41 degrees C for 3 h reduced percentage of motile sperm, 41 and 42 degrees C reduced sperm velocity and 43 degrees C decreased the proportion of spermatozoa undergoing swim-up. In other experiments, there was no effect of heat shock (41 or 42 degrees C for 1 to 3 h) on DNA integrity, presence of intact acrosomes, or fertilizing ability of the spermatozoa. Superoxide production by spermatozoa was higher at 42 degrees C than at 39 or 41 degrees C, but there was no detectable hydrogen peroxide production at any temperature. The antioxidant, glutathione, tended to improve the ability of spermatozoa to undergo swim-up at 39 degrees C but not at 43 degrees C. Taken together, these results suggest that heat shock of a magnitude similar to that seen in vivo (41 to 42 degrees C) has little effect on sperm functions that affect fertilizing capability.     

Effects of sodium butyrate and dibutyryl cyclic AMP on thermosensitivity of HeLa cells and their production of heat shock proteins

When HeLa cells were incubated at 42 degrees C for 6 h with 1 mM sodium butyrate or when cells treated with 1 mM dibutyryl cyclic AMP for 24 h were incubated at 42 degrees C for 6 h, they were more thermoresistant than heated control cells without such drugs. The production of heat shock proteins was not enhanced by the drug treatment. These results suggest that there is a factor (or factors) other than heat shock proteins that accounts for the thermoresistance of HeLa cells.     

A stable single-chain variable fragment expressing transfectoma demonstrates induction of idiotype-specific cytotoxic T-cells during early growth stages of a murine B-lymphoma

The idiotypic determinants associated with the variable regions of antibody molecules are known to function as tumor-associated antigens (TAAs). However, there is no clear-cut evidence documenting their efficacy in inducing TAA-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocytes (CTLs). In most previous studies, idiopeptides were implicated in elicitation of TAA-specific CD4+ T-cells. Using a murine B-cell lymphoma, 2C3, we earlier demonstrated induction of splenic CD4+ and CD8+ T-lymphocytes directed to idiotypic Ig of the tumor. In the present study, we provide more direct evidence of the existence of Id-specific CTLs in the spleens of 2C3 bearing BALB/c mice using an scFv-transfectoma, P815A4, as a target. While both P815A4 and 2C3 cells were equally susceptible to cytolysis by the effector cells, lysis was evident only during early tumor progression. Moribund animals at the late stage of tumor growth failed to demonstrate any significant cytotoxic immune response against either tumor. Antibodies to MHC class I alleles Kd, Dd, Ld, beta2m and CD8 molecules all inhibited cytotoxicity. The CTL population from early tumor-bearers recognized 2C3 tumor in the context of all major H-2d alleles; however, in case of P815A4 cells, it was restricted to Kd and Dd alleles only. Based on these antibody inhibition studies, it appears that the idiopeptides generated in both tumors are in some way different, yet they were recognized equally by CTLs not only from the tumor-bearers but also by CTLs from 2C3-hyperimmune mice. It appears that scFv-containing transfectomas expressing antibody variable region epitopes would be useful for both elucidating CTL-defined idiopeptides and monitoring TAA-specific CTL response in tumor-bearing animals.     

Cycloheximide can rescue heat-shocked L cells from death by blocking stress-induced apoptosis.

Cultured mouse L cells undergo apoptosis upon 1 h heat shock at 43 and 45 degrees C. Morphologically characteristic apoptotic cells begin to appear soon after the shock. Immunohistochemistry with anti-transglutaminase antibody shows that in most treated cells the enzyme is induced. Its activation results in the formation of highly cross-linked detergent-resistant apoptotic bodies during recovery. Cycloheximide added during hyperthermic stress inhibits the appearance of apoptotic bodies, showing that heat-shock-induced apoptosis is dependent on protein neosynthesis. The analysis of colony-forming ability of heat-shocked L cells shows a survival of 5% at 43 degrees C and less than 0.02% at 45 degrees C. When protein synthesis is inhibited during heat shock the fraction of surviving cells increases to 23% at 43 degrees C and 0.9% at 45 degrees C. This suggest that part of the cells that die upon heat shock are not heavily damaged and would have survived in the presence of a block in protein synthesis.     

Functional heterogeneity of cytotoxic T cells and tumor resistance to cytotoxic hits limit anti‐tumor activity in vivo

Cytotoxic T cells (CTLs) can eliminate tumor cells through the delivery of lethal hits, but the actual efficiency of this process in the tumor microenvironment is unclear. Here, we visualized the capacity of single CTLs to attack tumor cells in vitro and in vivo using genetically encoded reporters that monitor cell damage and apoptosis. Using two distinct malignant B‐cell lines, we found that the majority of cytotoxic hits delivered by CTLs in vitro were sublethal despite proper immunological synapse formation, and associated with reversible calcium elevation and membrane damage in the targets. Through intravital imaging in the bone marrow, we established that the majority of CTL interactions with lymphoma B cells were either unproductive or sublethal. Functional heterogeneity of CTLs contributed to diverse outcomes during CTL–tumor contacts in vivo. In the therapeutic settings of anti‐CD19 CAR T cells, the majority of CAR T cell–tumor interactions were also not associated with lethal hit delivery. Thus, differences in CTL lytic potential together with tumor cell resistance to cytotoxic hits represent two important bottlenecks for anti‐tumor responses in vivo.     

TCR-independent killing of B cell malignancies by anti-third-party CTLs: the critical role of MHC-CD8 engagement

We previously demonstrated that anti-third-party CTLs (stimulated under IL-2 deprivation against cells with an MHC class I [MHC-I] background different from that of the host and the donor) are depleted of graft-versus-host reactivity and can eradicate B cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia cells in vitro or in an HU/SCID mouse model. We demonstrated in the current study that human allogeneic or autologous anti-third-party CTLs can also efficiently eradicate primary non-Hodgkin B cell lymphoma by inducing slow apoptosis of the pathological cells. Using MHC-I mutant cell line as target cells, which are unrecognizable by the CTL TCR, we demonstrated directly that this killing is TCR independent. Strikingly, this unique TCR-independent killing is induced through lymphoma MHC-I engagement. We further showed that this killing mechanism begins with durable conjugate formation between the CTLs and the tumor cells, through rapid binding of tumor ICAM-1 to the CTL LFA-1 molecule. This conjugation is followed by a slower second step of MHC-I-dependent apoptosis, requiring the binding of the MHC-I α2/3 C region on tumor cells to the CTL CD8 molecule for killing to ensue. By comparing CTL-mediated killing of Daudi lymphoma cells (lacking surface MHC-I expression) to Daudi cells with reconstituted surface MHC-I, we demonstrated directly for the first time to our knowledge, in vitro and in vivo, a novel role for MHC-I in the induction of lymphoma cell apoptosis by CTLs. Additionally, by using different knockout and transgenic strains, we further showed that mouse anti-third-party CTLs also kill lymphoma cells using similar unique TCR-independence mechanism as human CTLs, while sparing normal naive B cells.     

Lysis of Escherichia coli by the bacteriophage phi X174 E protein: inhibition of lysis by heat shock proteins.

Lysis of Escherichia coli by the cloned E protein of bacteriophage phi X174 was more rapid than expected when bacteria were shifted from 30 to 42 degrees C at the time of E induction. Since such treatment also induces the heat shock response, we investigated the effect of heat shock proteins on lysis. An rpoH mutant was more sensitive to lysis by E, but a secondary suppressor mutation restored lysis resistance to parental levels, which suggests that the sigma 32 subunit itself did not directly increase lysis resistance. At 30 degrees C, mutants in five heat shock genes (dnaK, dnaJ, groEL, groES, and grpE) were more sensitive to lysis than were their wild-type parents. The magnitude of lysis sensitivity varied with mutation and strain background, with dnaK, dnaJ, and groES mutants consistently exhibiting the greatest sensitivities. Extended protection against lysis occurred when overproduction of heat shock proteins was induced artificially in cells that contained a plasmid with the rpoH+ gene under control of the tac promoter. This protective effect was completely abolished by mutations in dnaK, dnaJ, or groES but not by grpE or groEL mutations. Altered membrane behavior probably explains the contradiction whereby an actual temperature shift sensitized cells to lysis, but production of heat shock proteins exhibited protective effects. The results demonstrate that E-induced lysis can be divided into two distinct operations which may now be studied separately. They also emphasize a role for heat shock proteins under non-heat-shock conditions and suggest cautious interpretation of lysis phenomena in systems where E protein production is under control of a temperature-sensitive repressor.     

Influence of interferon γ on modulation of Fas expression by human colon carcinoma cells and their subsequent sensitivity to antigen-specific CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocyte attack

The inability of certain neoplastic populations to undergo Fas-mediated death by immune effector mechanisms may confer a selective survival advantage, which may contribute to tumor escape. In this study, we examined the role of Fas-mediated lysis in a human-antigen (Ag)-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL)/colon carcinoma cell model, and the regulation of the lytic phenotype by interferon γ (IFNγ). Previously, we have identified mutated ras peptides reflecting the valine-for-glycine substitution at position 12 as unique HLA-A2-restricted, CD8⁺ CTL neo-epitopes. Peptide-specific CTL, established from both normal and carcinoma-bearing individuals, lysed in vitro a HLA-A2⁺ primary colon adenocarcinoma cell line, SW480, harboring the naturally occurring ras mutation. Pretreatment of SW480 cells with IFNγ was necessary to promote efficient Ag-specific CTL killing, although the mechanisms by which IFNγ influenced the lytic outcome remains to be elucidated. Here, we show, by phenotypic analysis of SW480 cells, a significant up-regulation of HLA-A2, ICAM-1 and Fas molecules after IFNγ pretreatment, which paralleled their sensitivity to lysis with anti-Fas stimuli. Moreover, nearly half of the lytic response to IFNγ-treated SW480 cells was inhibited by neutralizing anti-Fas or anti-Fasligand (FasL) mAb, revealing for the first time an important functional role for Fas/FasL interactions in carcinoma cell killing by human Ag-specific CTL. mAb against HLA-A2, ICAM-1, the αβ T cell receptor (TCR) and Fas molecules inhibited lysis; however, if these CTL were preactivated to express functional FasL and then used as effectors, only anti-Fas mAb efficiently blocked lysis. IFNγ also increased pro-caspase-3 protein expression and its subsequent activation in SW480 cells following Ag-specific CTL attack. Peptide-based caspase inhibitors blocked both caspase-3 activation and CTL-mediated lysis. Overall, these data suggested that IFNγ (a) facilitated both Ag-dependent and Ag-independent events as a prerequisite for efficient CTL/target interactions, FasL up-regulation and triggering of Fas-dependent, as well as Fas-independent lysis (perforin); and (b) enhanced or restored a Fas-sensitive phenotype in SW480 cells, reflecting modulation of cell-surface and intracellular elements of the Fas pathway. Thus, IFNγ may play an important role in the regulation of a human neoplastic cell death phenotype, which may have implications for our understanding of the processes of both tumor evasion and tumor regression following Ag-specific CTL attack. Received: 20 December 1999 / Accepted: 1 February 2000     

Lysis of target cells infected with vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) in the presence of tunicamycin by anti-VSV cytotoxic T lymphocytes

We have analyzed the requirement for the expression of the major surface glycoprotein (G protein) of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) on target cells for recognition and lysis by anti-VSV cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). In addition, we have attempted to determine if the carbohydrate moieties on the G protein are required for recognition and lysis by anti-VSV CTL. When VSV (Orsay) is grown at 30 degrees C in the presence of tunicamycin (TM), glycosylation of G protein is inhibited; however, nonglycosylated G protein is found on the surface of the cell and active virus particles are produced. In contrast, VSV (Orsay) grown at 39 degrees C in the presence of TM produces low titers of virus and the presence of G protein on the surface of cells is not detectable. The susceptibility of these target cells to lysis by anti-VSV CTL was analyzed. The results suggest that expression of the G protein is required for target cell lysis by anti-VSV CTL. However, the presence of the carbohydrate moieties on the G protein are nt an absolute requirement for recognition by anti-VSV CTL. VSV-infected target cells incubated in the presence of TM were lysed by anti-VSV CTL up to 50 to 80% of the infected target cell control. This result suggests either that some clones of anti-VSV CTL recognize carbohydrate moieties or that carbohydrate moieties play some as yet undefined nonantigenic role in the recognition of the target antigen by the CTL receptor.