Formation of the molten globule-like state of cytochrome c induced by n-alkyl sulfates at low concentrations

The molten globule state of cytochrome c is the major intermediate of protein folding. Elucidation of the thermodynamic mechanism of conformational stability of the molten globule state would enhance our understanding of protein folding. The formation of the molten globule state of cytochrome c was induced by n-alkyl sulfates including sodium octyl sulfate, SOS; sodium decyl sulfate, SDeS; sodium dodecyl sulfate, SDS; and sodium tetradecyl sulfate, STS, at low concentrations. The refolding states of the protein were monitored by spectroscopic techniques including circular dichroism (CD), visible absorbance and fluorescence. The effect of n-alkyl sulfates on the structure of acid-unfolded horse cytochrome c at pH 2 was utilized to investigate the contribution of hydrophobic interactions to the stability of the molten globule state. The addition of n-alkyl sulfates to the unfolded state of cytochrome c appears to support the stabilized form of the molten globule. The m-values of the refolded state of cytochrome c by SOS, SDeS, SDS, and STS showed substantial variation. The enhancement of m-values as the stability criterion of the molten globule state corresponded with increasing chain length of the cited n-alkyl sulfates. The compaction of the molten globule state induced by SDS, as a prototype for other n-alkyl sulfates, relative to the unfolded state of cytochrome c was confirmed by Stokes radius and thermal transition point (T(m)) measured by microviscometry and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), respectively. Thus, hydrophobic interactions play an important role in stabilizing the molten globule state.     

Stabilization of partially folded states of cytochrome c in aqueous surfactant: effects of ionic and hydrophobic interactions

The interaction of submicellar concentrations of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) with horse heart cytochrome c has been found to stabilize two spectroscopically distinct partially folded intermediates at pH 7. The first intermediate is formed by the interaction of SDS with native cytochrome c, and this intermediate retains the majority of the secondary structure while the tertiary structure of the protein is lost. The unfolding of this intermediate with urea leads to the formation of a second intermediate, which is also formed on refolding of the unfolded protein (unfolded by urea) by SDS. The second intermediate retains about 50% of the native secondary structure with no tertiary structure of the protein. The second intermediate was found to be absent at low pH. While induction of helical structure of a protein by SDS in the native condition has been reported earlier, this is possibly the first report of the refolding of a protein in a strongly denaturing condition (in the presence of 10 M urea). The relative contributions of the hydrophobic and the electrostatic interactions of the surfactants with cytochrome c have been determined from the formation of the molten globule species from the acid-induced unfolded protein in the presence of SDS or lauryl maltoside.     

Role of Met80 and Tyr67 in the Low-pH Conformational Equilibria of Cytochrome c

The low-pH conformational equilibria of ferric yeast iso-1 cytochrome c (ycc) and its M80A, M80A/Y67H, and M80A/Y67A variants were studied from pH 7 to 2 at low ionic strength through electronic absorption, magnetic circular dichroism, and resonance Raman spectroscopies. For wild-type ycc, the protein structure, axial heme ligands, and spin state of the iron atom convert from the native folded His/Met low-spin (LS) form to a molten globule His/H(2)O high-spin (HS) form and a totally unfolded bis-aquo HS state, in a single cooperative transition with an apparent pK(a) of ～3.0. An analogous cooperative transition occurs for the M80A and M80A/Y67H variants. This is preceded by protonation of heme propionate-7, with a pK(a) of ～4.2, and by an equilibrium between a His/OH(-)-ligated LS and a His/H(2)O-ligated HS conformer, with a pK(a) of ～5.9. In the M80A/Y67A variant, the cooperative low-pH transition is split into two distinct processes because of an increased stability of the molten globule state that is formed at higher pH values than the other species. These data show that removal of the axial methionine ligand does not significantly alter the mechanism of acidic unfolding and the ranges of stability of low-pH conformers. Instead, removal of a hydrogen bonding partner at position 67 increases the stability of the molten globule and renders cytochrome c more susceptible to acid unfolding. This underlines the key role played by Tyr67 in stabilizing the three-dimensional structure of cytochrome c by means of the hydrogen bonding network connecting the Ω loops formed by residues 71-85 and 40-57.     

Formation of a molten-globule-like state of cytochrome c induced by high concentrations of glycerol.

The effect of glycerol on the structure of cytochrome c was investigated by circular dichroism, absorbance and EPR spectroscopy. The results obtained show that an increasing concentration of the organic solvent (70-99.2%, v/v) in aqueous-polyalcohol mixtures converts native cytochrome c into a new, low spin form through a fully reversible, two-state transition. The glycerol-stabilized form (that we call here the G state) retains native-like amounts of alpha-helix structure while rigid tertiary structure and native Fe(III)-Met(80) axial bond are lost. Analysis of data suggests a molten globule character of the G state; support to this view is afforded by the striking similarities between the spectroscopic (and, thus, structural) properties of the G state with those of the acidic molten globule of the protein (A state).     

Equilibrium titrations of acid-induced unfolding-refolding and salt-induced molten globule of cytochrome c by FT-IR spectroscopy

Despite extensive investigations on the acid-unfolded and acid/salt-induced molten globule(-like) states of cytochrome c using variety of techniques, structural features of the acid-unfolded state in terms of residual secondary structures and the structural transition between the acid-unfolded and acid/salt-refolded states have not been fully characterized beyond the circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. It is unusual that secondary structure(s) of the unfolded state leading to the molten globule state, an important protein folding intermediate, as determined by CD was not fully corroborated by independent experimental method(s). In this study, we carried out an equilibrium titration of acid-induced unfolding and subsequent acid- and salt-induced refolding of cytochrome c using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. The spectral profiles of the equilibrium titration reveal new structural details about the acid-unfolded state and the structural transition associated with the acid/salt-refolded molten globule(-like) states of cytochrome c.     

Changes in the spin state and reactivity of cytochrome C induced by photochemically generated singlet oxygen and free radicals

This work compares the effect of photogenerated singlet oxygen (O(2)((1)Delta(g))) (type II mechanism) and free radicals (type I mechanism) on cytochrome c structure and reactivity. Both reactive species were obtained by photoexcitation of methylene blue (MB(+)) in the monomer and dimer forms, respectively. The monomer form is predominant at low dye concentrations (up to 8 microm) or in the presence of an excess of SDS micelles, while dimers are predominant at 0.7 mm SDS. Over a pH range in which cytochrome c is in the native form, O(2) ((1)Delta(g)) and free radicals induced a Soret band blue shift (from 409 to 405 nm), predominantly. EPR measurements revealed that the blue shift of the Soret band was compatible with conversion of the heme iron from its native low spin state to a high spin state with axial symmetry (g approximately 6.0). Soret band bleaching, due to direct attack on the heme group, was only detected under conditions that favored free radical production (MB(+) dimer in SDS micelles) or in the presence of a less structured form of the protein (above pH 9.3). Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry of the heme group and the polypeptide chain of cytochrome c with Soret band at 405 nm (cytc405) revealed no alterations in the mass of the cytc405 heme group but oxidative modifications on methionine (Met(65) and Met(80)) and tyrosine (Tyr(74)) residues. Damage of cytc405 tyrosine residue impaired its reduction by diphenylacetaldehyde, but not by beta-mercaptoethanol, which was able to reduce cytc405, generating cytochrome c Fe(II) in the high spin state (spin 2).     

Rupture of the hydrogen bond linking two Omega-loops induces the molten globule state at neutral pH in cytochrome c

His26Tyr and His33Tyr mutants were obtained from the Cys102Thr variant of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. Spectroscopic studies show that a mutation at position 26 at pH 7.0 enhances flexibility of the peptide, alters the heme pocket region and the axial coordination to heme-iron, and reduces protein stability. The His26Tyr mutant shows properties typical of the molten globule. Further, formation of an axially misligated minor low spin species occurs with partial displacement of Met80, the axial ligand of the heme-iron in the native protein. The pK(a) determined for the alkaline transition of this mutant is 7.48 (+/- 0.05), approximately 0.5 lower than that of the wild-type protein. Hence, the alkaline conformer is populated at pH 7.0, and the sixth ligand of the misligated species is proposed to be a lysine. Furthermore, a reduction in catalytic activity indicates that the functional properties are altered. The results suggest that the structural and functional changes observed in the His26Tyr mutant are because the mutation frees the two Omega-loops that, in the native protein, are linked by the hydrogen bond between His26 and Glu44. Hence, one may infer that the His26-Glu44 hydrogen bond is essential for the rigidity and stability of the native protein. In its absence, the heightened flexibility of the peptide fold results in conversion of the macromolecule to a molten globule state, even at neutral pH. Ligand exchange at the sixth coordination position of the heme-iron(III) observed as the minor species (i.e., the alkaline conformer) is therefore induced by a long-range effect. This result is of interest since mutations reported to date, which stabilize the alkaline conformer, all occur in the loop including Met80. By contrast, only very minor spectroscopic (and, thus, structural) changes are observed for the His33Tyr mutant. This suggests that His33 does not form intramolecular bonds considered important for the protein structure and stability, and is consistent with the high variability of residues at position 33 in cytochromes c.     

The unfolding of oxidized c-type cytochromes: the instructive case of Bacillus pasteurii

The reversible unfolding of oxidized Bacillus pasteurii cytochrome c(553) by guanidinium chloride under equilibrium conditions has been monitored by NMR and optical spectroscopy. The results obtained indicate that unfolding takes place through a mechanism involving the detachment from heme iron coordination of the sulfur of the Met71 axial ligand and yielding either a high spin (HS) or a low spin (LS(1)) species, depending on the pH value. In the LS(1) form the Met71 is replaced by another protein ligand, possibly Lys. The ligand exchange reaction does not reach completion until the protein backbone reaches a largely unfolded state, as monitored through 1H-15N NMR experiments, thus demonstrating that there is a significant correlation between formation of the Fe-S bond and native structure stability. 1H/2H exchange data, however, show that helix alpha(3), the C-terminal region of helix alpha(4), and helix alpha(5) maintain low exchangeability of the amide protons in the LS(1) form. This finding most likely implies that these regions maintain some ordered non-covalent structure, in which the amide moieties are involved in H-bonds. Finally, a folding mechanism is proposed and discussed in terms of analogies and differences with the larger mitochondrial cytochrome c proteins. It is concluded that the thermodynamic stability of the region around the metal cofactor is determined by the chemical nature of the residues around the axial methionine residue.     

Glycerol-induced formation of the molten globule from acid-denatured cytochrome c: implication for hierarchical folding

At high concentration (98% or higher, v/v), glycerol induces collapse of acid-denatured cytochrome c into a compact state, the G_U state, showing a molten globule character. The G_U state possesses a nativelike -helix structure but a tertiary conformation less packed with respect to the native state. The spectroscopic properties of the G_U state closely resemble those of the molten globule stabilized by the organic solvent from the native protein (called the G_N state), indicating that glycerol can stabilize the molten globule of cytochrome c either from the native or the acid-denatured protein. The G_U and the G_N states show spectroscopic (and, thus, structural) properties and stabilities comparable to those of molten globules stabilized by different effectors, despite the fact that the mechanisms involved in the molten globule formation may significantly differ. This implies in cytochrome c a hierarchy for the rupture (native-to-molten globule) or the formation (unfolded-to-molten globule) of intramolecular interactions leading to the stabilization of the molten globule state of the protein, independently from the effector responsible for the structural transition, in accord with the sequential model proposed by Englander and collaborators.     

Salt‐promoted protein folding,preferential binding,or electrostatic screening?

The extended coil/molten globule conformational equilibrium exhibited by ferricytochrome c in 10 to 20 mM HCl was examined using free boundary capillary electrophoresis. Addition of the osmolyte glucitol, also called sorbitol, to shift the conformational equilibrium toward the molten globule markedly diminished the mobility of the protein. This diminution can be entirely assigned to the relative viscosity of the added glucitol. The insensitivity of the viscosity corrected protein mobility to added glucitol suggests that both the extended coil and molten globule conformations of cytochrome c are free draining in an electrophoresis measurement. Addition of a neutral salt to shift the conformational equilibrium toward the molten globule conformation also markedly diminished the mobility of the protein. This diminution can be entirely assigned to the electrostatic screening afforded by the added salt. The onset of the conformational transition observed by optical measurements and the onset of electrostatic screening observed by mobility measurements appear to be in common for some but not all neutral salts. The exception suggests that preferential binding of the anion of a neutral salt to the molten globule conformation and not electrostatic screening is principally responsible for the shift in the conformational equilibrium of cytochrome c in acidic solutions.     

Salt-induced formation of the A-state of ferricytochrome c--effect of the anion charge on protein structure

Structural information on partially folded forms is important for a deeper understanding of the folding mechanism(s) and the factors affecting protein stabilization. The non-native compact state of equine cytochrome c stabilized by salts in an acidic environment (pH 2.0-2.2), called the A-state, is considered a suitable model for the molten globule of cytochrome c, as it possesses a native-like alpha-helix conformation but a fluctuating tertiary structure. In this article, we extend our knowledge on anion-induced protein stabilization by determining the effect of anions carrying a double negative charge; unlike monovalent anions (which are thought to exert an 'ionic atmosphere' effect on the macromolecule), divalent anions are thought to bind to the protein at specific surface sites. Our data indicate that divalent anions, in comparison to monovalent ions, have a greater tendency to stabilize the native-like M-Fe(III)-H coordinated state of the protein. The possibility that divalent anions may bind to the protein at the same sites previously identified for polyvalent anions was evaluated. To investigate this issue, the behavior of the K88E, K88E/T89K and K13N mutants was investigated. The data obtained indicate that the mutated residues, which contribute to form the binding sites of polyanions, are important for stabilization of the native conformation; the mutants investigated, in fact, all show an increased amount of the misligated H-Fe(III)-H state and, with respect to wild-type cytochrome c, appear to be less sensitive to the presence of the anion. These residues also modulate the conformation of unfolded cytochrome c, influencing its spin state and the coordination to the prosthetic group.     

Targeted cross-linking of a molten globule form of acetylcholinesterase by the virucidal agent hypericin.

The natural product hypericin is a photosensitive polycyclic aromatic dione compound, which has been widely investigated because of its virucidal and antitumor properties. Although it has been suggested that singlet oxygen or a radical species might be responsible for its biological action, its mechanism of action remains unknown. Due to its amphiphilic characteristics, we considered the possibility that it might interact preferentially with partially unfolded proteins which exhibit exposed hydrophobic surfaces. We here demonstrate that hypericin binds to a molten globule species generated from Torpedo acetylcholinesterase, but not to the corresponding native enzyme. Irradiation with visible light, under aerobic conditions, causes chemical cross-linking of the catalytic subunits, to dimers and heavier species, under conditions where no cross-linking is observed for the native enzyme. Both anaerobiosis and sodium azide greatly reduce the extent of cross-linking, suggesting that singlet oxygen is responsible for the phenomenon. This agrees with our observation, using spin traps, that mainly singlet oxygen is produced by the complex of hypericin with the molten globule of acetylcholinesterase. Cross-linking is enhanced in the presence of liposomes to which the molten globule of acetylcholinesterase is quantitatively adsorbed. This may be due to high local concentrations of both hypericin and the protein resulting in close proximity, and hence in a high yield of cross-linking. Molten globule species are believed to be intermediates in both protein folding and translocation through biological membranes. Thus, hypericin may serve as a valuable tool for trapping such intermediates. This might also explain its therapeutic effectiveness toward virus-infected or tumor cells.     

Structural energetics of the molten globule state

Certain partly ordered protein conformations, commonly called “moltenglobule states,” are widely believed to represent protein folding intermediates. Recentstructural studies of molten globule states ofdifferent proteins have revealed features whichappear to be general in scope. The emergingconsensus is that these partly ordered forms exhibit a high content of secondary structure, considerable compactness, nonspecific tertiary structure, and significant structural flexibility. These characteristics may be used to define ageneral state of protein folding called “the molten globule state,” which is structurally andthermodynamically distinct from both the native state and the denatured state. Despite exaatensive knowledge of structural features of afew molten globule states, a cogent thermodynamic argument for their stability has not yetbeen advanced. The prevailing opinion of thelast decade was that there is little or no enthalpy difference or heat capacity differencebetween the molten globule state and the unfolded state. This view, however, appears to beat variance with the existing database of protein structural energetics and with recent estimates of the energetics of denaturation of α-lactalbumin, cytochrome c, apomyoglobin, and T4 lysozyme. We discuss these four proteins at length. The results of structural studies, together with the existing thermodynamic values for fundamental interactions in proteins, provide the foundation for a structural thermodynamic framework which can account for the observed behavior of molten globule states. Within this framework, we analyze the physical basis for both the high stability of several molten globule states and the low probability of other protential folding intermediates. Additionally, we consider, in terms of reduced enthalpy changes and disrupted cooperative interactions, the thermodynamic basis for the apparent absence of a thermally induced, cooperative unfolding transition for some molten globule states. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

A two-process model describes the hydrogen exchange behavior of cytochrome c in the molten globule state with various extents of acetylation

Acetylation of Lys residues of horse cytochrome c steadily stabilizes the molten globule state in 18 mM HCl as more Lys residues are acetylated [Goto and Nishikiori (1991) J. Mol. Biol. 222, 679-686]. The dynamic features of the molten globule state were characterized by hydrogen/deuterium exchange of amide protons, monitored by mass spectrometry as each deuteration increased the protein mass by 1 Da. Electrospray mass spectrometry enabled us to monitor simultaneously the exchange kinetics of more than seven species with a different number of acetyl groups. One to four Lys residue-acetylated cytochrome c showed almost no protection of the amide protons from rapid exchange. The transition from the unprotected to the protected state occurred between five and eight Lys residue-acetylated species. For species with more than nine acetylated Lys residues, the exchange kinetics were independent of the extent of acetylation, and 26 amide protons were protected at 60 min of exchange, indicating the formation of a rigid hydrophobic core with hydrogen-bonded secondary structures. The apparent transition to the protected state required a higher degree of acetylation than the conformational transition measured by circular dichroism, which had a midpoint at about four acetylated residues. This difference in the transitions suggested a two-process model in which the exchange occurs either from the protected folded state or from the unprotected unfolded state through global unfolding. On the basis of a two-process model and with the reported values of the exchange and stability parameters, we simulated the exchange kinetics of a series of acetylated cytochrome c species. The simulated kinetics reproduced the observed kinetics well, indicating validity of this model for hydrogen exchange of the molten globule state.     

Role of electrostatic repulsion in the acidic molten globule of cytochrome c.

The molten globule has been assumed to be a major intermediate state of protein folding. To extend our understanding of protein folding it is important to elucidate the thermodynamic mechanism of conformational stability of the molten globule. To clarify the role of electrostatic charge repulsion in the stability of the acidic molten globule state, we prepared a series of acetylated horse ferricytochrome c species with various degrees of charge repulsion. On the basis of circular dichroism measurement, we show that the stability of the acidic molten globule is determined by a balance of electrostatic repulsions between positive residues, which favor the extended conformation, and the opposing forces, which stabilize the molten globule. These results provide a clear example of charge repulsions producing unfolding of the compact protein structure, and suggest that the reversibly denatured conformation of ferricytochrome c under physiological conditions (i.e. neutral pH, ambient temperature and no denaturant) is the molten globule.     

Stepwise formation of alpha-helices during cytochrome c folding

Two models have been proposed to describe the folding pathways of proteins. The framework model assumes the initial formation of the secondary structures whereas the hydrophobic collapse model supposes their formation after the collapse of backbone structures. To differentiate between these models for real proteins, we have developed a novel CD spectrometer that enables us to observe the submillisecond time frame of protein folding and have characterized the timing of secondary structure formation in the folding process of cytochrome c (cyt c). We found that approximately 20% of the native helical content was organized in the first phase of folding, which is completed within milliseconds. Furthermore, we suggest the presence of a second intermediate, which has alpha-helical content resembling that of the molten globule state. Our results indicate that many of the alpha-helices are organized after collapse in the folding mechanism of cyt c.     

Molten globule-like state of cytochrome c induced by polyanion poly(vinylsulfate) in slightly acidic pH.

The effect of polyanion, poly(vinylsulfate), used as a model of negatively charged surface, on ferric cytochrome c (ferricyt c) structure in acidic pH has been studied by absorbance spectroscopy, circular dichroism (CD), tryptophan (Trp) fluorescence and microcalorimetry. The polyanion induced only small changes in the native structure of the protein at neutral pH, but it profoundly shifted the acid induced high spin state of the heme in the active center of cyt c to a more neutral pH region. Cooperativity of the acidic transition of ferricyt c in the presence of the polyanion was disturbed, in comparison with uncomplexed protein, as followed from different apparent pK(a) values observed in a distinct regions of the ferricyt c electronic absorbance spectrum (4.55+/-0.08 in the 620 nm band region and 5.47+/-0.15 in the Soret region). The ferricyt c structure in the complex with the polyanion at acidic pH (below pH 5.0) has properties of a molten globule-like state. Its tertiary structure is strongly disturbed according to CD and microcalorimetry measurements; however, its secondary structure, from CD, is still native-like and ferricyt c is in a compact state as evidenced by quenched Trp fluorescence. These findings are discussed in the context of the molten globule state of proteins induced on a negatively charged membrane surface under physiological conditions.     

Anion concentration modulates the conformation and stability of the molten globule of cytochrome<Emphasis Type="Italic"> c</Emphasis>

Anions induce collapse of acid-denatured cytochrome c into a compact state, the A-state, showing molten globule character. Since structural information on partially folded forms of proteins is important for a deeper understanding of folding mechanisms and of the factors affecting protein stabilization, in this paper we have investigated in detail the effects of anions on the tertiary conformation of the A-state. We have found that the salt-induced collapse of acid-denatured cytochrome c leads to a number of equilibria between high-spin and low-spin heme states and between two types of low-spin states. The two latter states are characterized by conformations leading to a native-like Met-Fe-His axial coordination and a bis-His configuration. The equilibrium between these two A-states is dependent on the concentration and/or size of the anions (i.e. the bigger the anion, the greater its effect). Further, on the basis of fast kinetic data, a kinetic model of the folding process from the acid-unfolded protein to the A-state (at low and high anion concentration) is described.     

Probing protein structure by limited proteolysis

Limited proteolysis experiments can be successfully used to probe conformational features of proteins. In a number of studies it has been demonstrated that the sites of limited proteolysis along the polypeptide chain of a protein are characterized by enhanced backbone flexibility, implying that proteolytic probes can pinpoint the sites of local unfolding in a protein chain. Limited proteolysis was used to analyze the partly folded (molten globule) states of several proteins, such as apomyoglobin, alpha-lactalbumin, calcium-binding lysozymes, cytochrome c and human growth hormone. These proteins were induced to acquire the molten globule state under specific solvent conditions, such as low pH. In general, the protein conformational features deduced from limited proteolysis experiments nicely correlate with those deriving from other biophysical and spectroscopic techniques. Limited proteolysis is also most useful for isolating protein fragments that can fold autonomously and thus behave as protein domains. Moreover, the technique can be used to identify and prepare protein fragments that are able to associate into a native-like and often functional protein complex. Overall, our results underscore the utility of the limited proteolysis approach for unravelling molecular features of proteins and appear to prompt its systematic use as a simple first step in the elucidation of structure-dynamics-function relationships of a novel and rare protein, especially if available in minute amounts.