Asymmetric protoplast fusions between wild species and breeding lines of potato – effect of recipients and genome stability

 The objective of this study was to investigate if in asymmetric protoplast fusion experiments the ploidy of the recipient line (di-haploid and tetraploid) has an influence on the extent of the asymmetry of the regenerating fusion products. Nineteen different experiments with the wild species Solanum bulbocastanum and Solanum circaeifolium as donors (irradiated with 210 Gy) and different breeding lines (di-haploid and tetraploid) were carried out. The degree of genome elimination was determined by measuring the relative DNA content using flow cytometry. The data showed that the loss of DNA in hybrid plants was significantly higher for 4x, compared to 2x, plants as recipients. In addition, the stability of asymmetry in the fusion products was studied. For this purpose differences in asymmetry in individual shoots originating from the same callus were analysed. A large variation in the DNA content of individual shoots was detected. Of the 4x to 6x shoots 44% had the same DNA content as another shoot originating from the same callus, 19% had a DNA content between 4x and 6x but different from any other analysed shoot originating from the same callus, 2% were chimeras and 35% had a completely different DNA content (eutetraploid, euhexaploid, eupolyploid or asymmetric with a ploidy level above 6x). RFLP-analysis with single-copy probes of 12 regenerates from six calli (two regenerates per callus) confirmed the assumption that the different regenerates of one callus originate from the same single cell. The analysis of selected regenerates cultivated for a period of more than 1 year demonstrated that the genome of asymmetric regenerates might change during cultivation. Received: 30 April 1998 / Accepted: 24 July 1998     

A method for production of interspecific hybrids within Brassiceae via somatic hybridization,using resynthesis of Brassica napus as a model

A general method for the production of somatic hybrids within Brassiceae has been developed using mesophyll protoplasts from one parent and hypocotyl protoplasts from the other. Fusion products were easily identified by their intermediate phenotype between the parental protoplasts. They could be isolated 24 h after fusion with micropipettes using a micromanipulator. At that time their frequency was about 15%. They were cultured in small volumes, 10 μl, and a plating efficiency of 14% was obtained. Hybrid calli were obtained from the fusion products, which was confirmed by isozyme analysis. Ploidy level of one hybrid shoot was determined by flow cytometric DNA analysis.     

GISH confirmation of somatic hybrids between Solanum melongena and S. torvum: assessment of resistance to both fungal and bacterial wilts

Interspecific somatic hybrids between Solanum melongena L. (2n = 2x = 24) and two accessions of Solanum torvum Sw. (2n = 2x = 24) were produced in view of transferring resistance to two soil-born pathogens, Ralstonia solanacearum and Verticillium dahliae, from the wild species into the cultivated eggplant. All somatic hybrids were phenotypically homogenous and intermediate between the parents. Their hybrid nature was confirmed by analysis of isozymes and RAPDs. They showed reduced pollen viability, and all but one possessed the chloroplasts from either one or the other parent. As S. melongena and S. torvum chromosomes were morphologically indistinguishable, genomic in situ hybridisation (GISH) was applied to recognise the chromosomes from each parent in the hybrids. As expected, the selected tetraploid plants contained one complete set of chromosomes from each fusion partner. On spread preparations, the two parental genomes were not spatially separated at any time of the cell cycle. Translocation or recombinant chromosomes could not be demonstrated in the mitotic metaphase. Tests for resistance performed in vitro by using suspensions of two strains of R. solanacearum (race 1 and 3) and filtrate of culture medium of one strain of V. dahliae, revealed that S. melongena was susceptible, whereas both accessions of S. torvum had high levels of resistance. Except for two hybrid clones, which were found susceptible to race 3, as was S. melongena, all somatic hybrids tested showed good levels of bacterial and fungal resistance, either intermediate or as high as that of the wild parent.     

Electrofusion for the production of somatic hybrid plants of Solanum melongena L. and Solanum khasianum C.B. Clark

Electrofusion has successfully been used for the production of somatic hybrid plants of Solanum melongena (eggplant) and S. khasianum. This fusion was carried out in a movable multi-electrode (2 mm apart) fusion chamber (500–700 μl capacity) containing a mixture (1:1) of mesophyll protoplasts of both species. Following an alignment of protoplasts induced by an A.C. fields of 125 V/cm and 1 Mhz, fusion was initiated by an exposure of the protoplast samples to a train of 3–4 D.C. pulses of 1.2 kV/cm, each 20 μs. The fusion rate was estimated at 30–40%, at least 30% of which were binary fusions. The mixture of fused protoplasts cultured in KM8p medium containing 0.2 mg/l 2,4-D, 0.5 mg/l zeatin, 1 mg/l NAA and 6.5% (w/v) glucose produced abundant calli, some of which gave rise to shoots on regeneration medium. Although no selection methods have been used, a total of 83 somatic hybrid plants were recovered from 83 individual calli in 3 fusion experiments. They accounted for 40–50% of all the regenerated plants. Several traits of the hybrids were intermediate to those of the parents. All the hybrid plants flowered preciously. The pollen viability averaged 12%, but none of them had set fruits. A random sample of the hybrids gave chromosome numbers ranging from 46 to 48. These numbers approximated to the expected tetraploid level ($\text{2n = 4x = 48}\text{chromosomes}$) The hybridity was confirmed by the banding patterns ofperoxidase activities whcih were composed of the bands of both parents.     

Microsporogenesis in three tetraploid somatic hybrids of potato and their di(ha)ploid fusion partners

Summary The microsporogenesis of three somatic hybrids of potato, i.e. one tetraploid Solanum tuberosum (+) S. phureja, one tetraploid and one hypertetraploid S. tuberosum (+) desynaptic mutant, has been examined and compared with the microsporogenesis of the di(ha) ploid fusion partners. The somatic hybrids had a first meiotic division with uni-, bi-, and multivalents like that of tetraploid potatoes, illustrating introgression and dominance over desynapsis. Abnormal spindle orientations at second meiotic division, sporad types with reduced and unreduced cells and viable pollen occurred at various frequencies. Pollen fertility could not be predicted on the basis of pollen fertility of the fusion partners. Pollen sterility was partially due to abnormal chromosome numbers. Only the tetraploid S. tuberosum (+) desynaptic mutant produced normal amounts of viable seeds.     

Regeneration and characterization of somatic hybrids between Brassica napus and Diplotaxis harra

Stem cortex protoplasts of Brassica napus, inactivated with iodoacetate, were fused with cell suspension - derived protoplasts of Diplotaxis harra by polyethylene glycol (PEG) treatment. PEG at 15–18% (w/v) induced 5–9% heterofusions. The hybrid callus selection was based on morphology: D. harra calli were yellow and very fine, while B. napus protoplasts typically produced green, well defined calli. A number of green, large calli were selected after fusion experiments and flowering plants were regenerated from two of these callus lines. The morphological traits as well as cytological and biochemical analysis of four isoenzymes confirmed the hybrid nature of the regenerants.     

Reprogramming of somatic cells induced by fusion of embryonic stem cells using hemagglutinating virus of Japan envelope (HVJ-E)

In this research, hemagglutinating virus of Japan envelope (HVJ-E) was used to reprogram somatic cells by fusion with mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells. Neomycin-resistant mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) were used as somatic cells. Nanog-overexpressing puromycin-resistant EB3 cells were used as mouse ES cells. These two cells were fused by exposing to HVJ-E and the generated fusion cells were selected by puromycin and G418 to get the stable fusion cell line. The fusion cells form colonies in feeder-free culture system. Microsatellite analysis of the fusion cells showed that they possessed genes from both ES cells and fibroblasts. The fusion cells were tetraploid, had alkali phosphatase activity, and expressed stem cell marker genes such as Pou5f1, Nanog, and Sox2, but not the fibroblast cell marker genes such as Col1a1 and Col1a2. The pluripotency of fusion cells was confirmed by their expression of marker genes for all the three germ layers after differentiation induction, and by their ability to form teratoma which contained all the three primary layers. Our results show that HVJ-E can be used as a fusion reagent for reprogramming of somatic cells.     

Variation patterns of parthenogenetic plants derived from “unreduced” embryo-sacs of Solanum tuberosum subspecies andigena (Juz. et Buk.) Hawkes

Summary Parthenogenetic seed induction was performed on one clone of Solanum tuberosum subspecies andigena (2n=4x=48) using S. phureja (2n=2x=24) marker inducer clones. The parthenogenetic population when grown was found to contain both diploid and tetraploid individuals presumably arising from reduced and unreduced gametes, respectively. Variation patterns in the diploid and tetraploid sub-populations, as well as a population obtained by selfing the parental clone, were compared to try and elucidate the origin of the tetraploid parthenotes. From the results of this one generation it appeared that the tetraploid parthenogenetic plants had been produced by a mechanism equivalent to second division restitution (SDR).     

Modulation and direction of the electrofusion response in plant protoplasts

In experiments on electrofusion of protoplasts (from Solanum brevidens, S. tuberosum, Nicotiana plumbaginifolia) the presence of divalent cations (Ca²⁺) at 1 mM in the fusion medium was found to increase the yield of hybrids observed directly after fusion and decrease the duration of pulse needed for fusion. Pretreatment of protoplasts with the polyamine spermine also enhanced fusion yield, and when combined with 1 mM Ca²⁺ the effects were additive. The improvement in fusion yield (2–4 fold) was most marked for protoplast populations (e.g. from suspension cultured cells) that were least responsive to electrofusion in mannitol alone. Short term viability, judged from FDA fluorescence was found to be high at these increased fusion levels. Optimum fusion parameters for electrofusion thus may be determined from short term experiments. Attempts to direct to fusion response between populations of protoplasts of identical properties by pretreatment of one fusion partner with spermine were inconclusive.     

A cytogenetic and phenotypic characterization of somatic hybrid plants obtained after fusion of two different dihaploid clones of potato (Solatium tuberosum L.)

Summary Somatic hybrid plants of various ploidy levels obtained after chemical fusion between two dihaploid clones of potato Solanum tuberosum L. have been analysed by cytological, morphological and molecular methods. The hybrid nature of tetraploid and hexaploid plants and the genome dosage in hexaploid hybrids were confirmed by Giemsa C-banding. Tetraploid and hexaploid hybrids showed numerical as well as structural chromosome mutations. The latter occurred mainly in the nuclear organizing chromosome. The tetraploid hybrids were more vigorous than the dihaploid parents as demonstrated by an increase in height, enlargement of leaves, increase in the number of internodes, restored potential for flowering and increased tuber yield. The grouping of tetraploid somatic hybrids into various classes on the basis of leaf morphology revealed that plants with a full chromosome complement were more uniform than aneuploids. Many hexaploid somatic hybrids were also more vigorous than the dihaploid parents and could be grouped into two different classes on the basis of floral colour and tuber characteristics, the differences being due to their different dosage of parental genomes. Most of the tetraploid somatic hybrids showed pollen development halted at the tetrad stage as one of the parental clones contained a S. Stoloniferum cytoplasm. However, one tetraploid plant produced pollen grains with high viability. The chloroplast genome in the hybrid plants was determined by RFLP analysis. All of the hybrids had a cpDNA pattern identical to one parent, which contained either S. Tuberosum or S. Stoloniferum cpDNA. A slight preference for S. Tuberosum plastids were observed in hybrid plants. No correlation between pollen development and plastid type could be detected.     

Selection and enrichment of plant protoplast heterokaryons of Brassicaceae by flow sorting

The experimental conditions for an efficient and reproducible enrichment of fusion products by flow cytometry, using protoplasts of different Brassica species as hybridization material, have been investigated. The heterokaryons were identified by the endogenous chlorophyll autofluorescencence of mesophyll protoplasts of one parent and the fluorescense of exogenously supplied carboxyfluorescin to the hypocotyl protoplasts of the other parent. By using a low head drive frequency (11 kHz), a large nozzle (110 μm) and a low nozzle pressure (30–35 kPa) good survival of the protoplasts was obtained after sorting. Heterokaryons were sorted using these parameters and on average 80% of the protoplasts were fusion products as judged by microscopy. They were cultured in small volumes, 150 μl, and started to divide after 3–5 days and regenerated calli easily. Isozyme analysis of the calli confirmed that 81% had the pattern typical for a hybrrid. Differentiation into shoots have been obtained from some of the hybrid calli; these shoots were also confirmed to be true hybrids.     

Production of androgenic dihaploid lines of the disomic tetraploid potato species Solanum acaule ssp. acaule

Over 250 dihaploid lines derived from a disomic tetraploid genotype of Solanum acaule ssp. acaule Bitt. (acc. PI 472655) were produced via androgenesis. The anther donor plant had previously shown immunity to bacterial ring rot caused by Clavibacter michiganensis ssp. sepedonicus (Spieck. and Kotth.) Davis et al., and has now been shown to have high embryogenic capacity in anther culture. In total, 370 shoots were regenerated from 4,011 anthers cultured. The ploidy level of the 287 regenerants was determined from greenhouse-grown plants using flow cytometry. Of these plants, 274 (95%) were dihaploids with an average DNA content of 1.68 pg, approximately half that of the tetraploid anther donor (2.95 pg). The remainder of the anther-derived regenerants (5%) were tetraploid, hexaploid or mixoploid. Chromosome counts confirmed the results obtained by flow cytometry. In the greenhouse, none of the 33 dihaploid lines analysed produced berries but showed low (2%) male fertility. This contrasted with five greenhouse-grown tetraploid anther-derived plants which produced berries and seeds. Comparison of the general leaf morphology and floral characteristics of the tetraploid anther donor, S. acaule, and the dihaploids indicated that little variation exists in this species. Received: 28 August 1997 / Revision received: 22 December 1997 / Accepted: 27 July 1998     

Effect of radiation dosage on efficiency of chloroplast transfer by protoplast fusion in Nicotiana

Chloroplasts of Nicotiana tabacum SR1 were transferred into Nicotiana plumbaginifolia by protoplast fusion. The protoplasts of the organelle donor were irradiated with different lethal doses using a ⁶⁰Co source, to facilitate the elimination of their nuclei from the fusion products. After fusion induction, clones derived from fusion products and containing streptomycin-resistant N. tabacum SR1 chloroplasts were selected by their ability to green on a selective medium. When N. tabacum protoplasts were inactivated by iodoacetate instead of irradiation, the proportion of N. plumbaginifolia nuclear segregant clones was low (1–2%). Irradiation markedly increased this value: Using 50, 120, 210 and 300 J kg^-1 doses, the frequency of segregant clones was 44, 57, 84 and 70 percent, respectively. Regeneration of resistant N. plumbaginifolia plants with SR1 chloroplasts indicated that plastids can be rescued from the irradiated cells by fusion with untreated protoplasts. Resistant N. plumbaginifolia plants that were regenerated (43 clones studied) had diploid (2n = 2X = 20) or tetraploid chromosome numbers and were identical morphologically to parental plants. The absence of aneuploids suggests that in these clones irradiation resulted in complete elimination of the irradiated N. tabacum nuclei. Resistance is inherited maternally (five clones tested). The demonstration of chloroplast transfer and the presence of N. tabacum plastids in the N. plumbaginifolia plants was confirmed by chloroplast DNA fragmentation patterns after EcoRI digestion.     

Application of somatic hybrids between dihaploids of potato Solanum tuberosum L. and wild diploid species from Mexico in breeding: Generation and backcrossing of dihaploids of somatic hybrids

The efficiency of an original approach to involvement of the valuable genetic pool of wild diploid potato species from Mexico is estimated. The essence of this method is in generation of dihaploids (2n = 2x = 24) of tetraploid somatic hybrids (2n = 4x = 48) followed by backcrossing with dihaploids of Solanum tuberosum. A haploid producer, S. phureja IvP35, was used to generate ten dihaploids of S. tuberosum + S. pinnatisectum, all of which crossed with fertile S. tuberosum dihaploids and developed plump viable seeds. This gives the possibility of an efficient introgression of the genes valuable for breeding from wild species to the bred plants at a diploid level, which has several advantages compared with the corresponding procedure at a tetraploid level. A part of the dihaploids produced was compatible (the pollen tubes reached the ovary) with diploid and tetraploid forms of S. pinnatisectum; however, no viable seeds were developed. The attempt to generate the dihaploids of S. tuberosum + S. bulbocastanum somatic hydrides using the haploid producer S. phureja IvP35 was unsuccessful.     

Production and characterization of fertile somatic hybrids of eggplant (Solanum melongena L.) with Solanum aethiopicum L.

Summary In order to produce fertile somatic hybrids, mesophyll protoplasts from eggplant were electrofused with those from one of its close related species, Solanum aethiopicum L. Aculeatum group. On the basis of differences in the cultural behavior of the parental and hybrid protoplasts, 35 somatic hybrid plants were recovered from 85 selected calli. When taken to maturity either in the greenhouse or in the field, the hybrid plants were vigorous, all rapidly overtopping parental individuals. The putative hybrids were intermediate with respect to morphological traits, and all of their organs were larger, particularly the leaves and stems. DNA analysis of the hybrids using flow cytometry in combination with cytological analysis showed that 32 were tetraploids, 1 hexaploid and 2 mixoploids. The hybrid nature of the 35 selected plants was confirmed by a comparison of the isoenzyme patterns of isocitrate dehydrogenase (Idh), 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase (6-Pgd) and phosphoglucomutase (Pgm). Chloroplast DNA (ctDNA) restriction analysis using Bam HI revealed that among the 27 hybrid plants analyzed, 10 had S. aethiopicum patterns and the 17 remaining hybrids exhibited bands identical with those of eggplant without any changes. All of the somatic hybrid plants flowered. Both parental plants had 94% stainable pollen, while the hybrids varied widely in pollen viability ranging from 30% to 85%. The somatic hybrids showed high significant variation in fruit production. Nevertheless, there was a tendency for low fertility to be associated often with S. aethiopicum chloroplast type and/or with an abnormal ploidy level, while good fertility was mostly associated with the tetraploid level and eggplant chloroplasts. Interestingly, 2 tetraploid somatic hybrid clones were among the most productive, yielding up to 9 kg/plant. As far as the fertility of the F₁ sexual counterpart was concerned, only 2 fruits of 50 g were obtained. Hybrid fertility in relation to phylogenetic affinities of the fusion partners is discussed.     

Studies on plant recovery from mesophyll protoplasts ofSolatium tuberosum L. andSolanum phureja Juj. et Buk

Plants were regenerated from mesophyll protoplasts of axenically growing plants of four dihaploid clones and five tetraploid cultivars ofSolanum tuberosum L. andSolanum phureja Juz. etBuk.     

Production of potato breeding material using somatic hybrids between <Emphasis Type="Italic">Solanum tuberosum</Emphasis> L. dihaploids and the wild diploid species <Emphasis Type="Italic">Solanum bulbocastanum</Emphasis> Dunal. from Mexico

An original approach to overcome interspecific incompatibility when backcrossing the tetraploid Solanum tuberosum + S. bulbocastanum somatic hybrids with cultivated potato was realized. This method is based on the decrease in their ploidy using anther culture and involvement of the haploid producer S. phureja IvP35. The feasibility of obtaining a diploid progeny from the somatic hybrids carrying genetic material of the wild species S. bulbocastanum and crossable with S. tuberosum dihaploids was demonstrated.     

RFLP Analysis of Chromosomal Segregation in Progeny from an Interspecific Hexaploid Somatic Hybrid between Solanum Brevidens and Solanum Tuberosum

Segregation of restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) loci was monitored to determine the degree of homeologous pairing and recombination in a hexaploid somatic hybrid, A206, the result of protoplast fusion between Solanum tuberosum (PI 203900, a tetraploid cultivated potato) and Solanum brevidens (PI 218228), a diploid, sexually incompatible, distant relative harboring several traits for disease resistance. Somatic hybrid A206 was crossed to Katahdin, a tetraploid potato cultivar, to generate a segregating population of pentaploid progeny. Although the clones of the tetraploid S. tuberosum lines PI 203900 and Katahdin were highly polymorphic, the diploid S. brevidens clone was homozygous at all but two of the tested RFLP loci. Thus, homeologous recombination could be detected only when S. tuberosum and S. brevidens chromosomes paired and the S. brevidens homologs then segregated into separate gametes. A bias toward homologous pairing was observed for all 12 chromosomes. At least four and perhaps six chromosomes participated in homologous pairing only; each of 24 progeny contained all S. brevidens-derived RFLP markers for chromosomes 4, 8, 9 and 10. The remaining six chromosomes paired with their homolog(s) about twice as often as expected if hexaploid pairings were completely random. Where detectable with RFLPs, homeologous recombinations (both single and double) occurred at a frequency of 1.31 per chromosome. Cytological observations of meiosis I in the somatic hybrid indicated that homeologous pairing had occurred. Enhanced recombinational activity was observed for chromosome 2. A specific small deletion from chromosome 4 was detected in A206 and 11 other somatic hybrids out of 14 screened. These hybrids represent 13 independent fusion events between the same clones of S. brevidens and S. tuberosum. In one instance, this deletion occurred in one of two plants resulting from the same callus, indicating that the loss occurred in culture after fusion had taken place. It is possible that this deletion contributes to somaclonal variation.     

Phylogenetic analysis of tetraploid wheat based on nuclear DMC1 gene

Tetraploid wheat (AABB or AAGG, 2n = 4x = 28) holds an important place in Triticum. It includes two allopolyploid species, Triticum turgidum and Triticum timopheevii. Many problems concerning the phylogenetic relationships among tetraploid wheat species remain unresolved. In this study, sequences data for the nuclear DMC1 gene from 61 accessions of Triticum and Aegilops species, representing diploid and tetraploid species, were used to examine the phylogenetic relationships among tetraploid wheat. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using maximum-likelihood and neighbor-joining approaches, and gene flow and genetic differentiation values were computed. The results indicated that the A genome of tetraploid wheat originated from T. urartu rather than T. monococcum, and Aegilops speltoides was the donor of the B and G genomes. Hulled tetraploid wheat accessions formed a subclade, and naked tetraploid wheat got other subclade, indicating that at least two intermediary subspecies were involved in the evolution of T. turgidum. Triticum turgidum and T. timopheevii might have simultaneously originated from a hybridization events. These results indicated that the DMC1 gene sequences are useful for resolution of the molecular phylogenetic relationships of tetraploid wheat.