Study of the contribution of the shoot and/or root ofAlnus sp. in the compatibility between the host and a Sp+ Frankia strain using a grafting technique

Two alder species,Alnus glutinosa (L.) Gaertn. andAlnus incana (L) Moench, were inoculated with a Sp⁺ Frankia homogenate obtained fromA. incana root nodules. This inoculum formed effective nodules on the original host plant and ineffective nodules onA. glutinosa. Grafts between the two alder species were made to determine which part of the plant is involved in this phenomenon. The results obtained indicate that the compatibility between Alnus andFrankia is restricted to the root system.     

Glasshouse evaluation of the growth ofAlnus rubra andAlnus glutinosa on peat and acid brown earth soils when inoculated with four sources ofFrankia

The effects of soil type (an acid peat and 2 acid brown earths) andFrankia source (3 spore-positive crushed nodule inocula and spore-negative crushed nodules containing the singleFrankia ArI5) on nodulation, N content and growth ofAlnus glutinosa andA. rubra were determined in a glasshouse pot experiment of two years duration. Plants on all soils required additional P for growth. Growth of both species was very poor on peat withA. glutinosa superior toA. rubra. The former species was also superior toA. rubra on an acid brown earth with low pH and low P content. Some plant-inoculum combinations were of notable effectivity on particular soils but soil type was the major source of variation in plant weight. Inoculation with crushed nodules containingFrankia ArI5 only gave poor infection of the host plant, suggesting that inoculation with locally-collected crushed nodules can be a preferred alternative to inoculation withFrankia isolates of untested effectivity. Evidence of adaptation ofFrankia to particular soils was obtained. Thus, while the growth of all strains was stimulated by mineral soil extracts, inhibitory effects of peat extracts were more apparent with isolates from nodules from mineral soils than from peat, suggesting that survival ofFrankia on peat may be improved by strain selection.     

Effective nodulation ofCoriaria myrtifolia L. induced byFrankia strains fromAlnus glutinosa L. (Gaertn.)

The present contribution covers the cross-inoculation between two actinorhizae belonging to different genera and families, mainlyAlnus glutinosa andCoriaria myrtifolia. Frankia strains isolated fromA. glutinosa received from the Netherlands (LDAgp₁r₁, LDAgn₁) and from Scotland (UGL010708), induced a fully effective nodulation onC. myrtifolia. The same effect was caused by a nodule extract fromA. glutinosa. The reverse, a crushed-nodule inoculum fromC. myrtifolia nodulated all theA. glutinosa seedlings, though nodules formed were less effective than those induced by the other inocula. Re-isolation of thoseFrankia strains from the nodules formed onA. glutinosa was readily obtained, whereas attempts to re-isolate them from the nodules formed onC. myrtifolia failed, suggesting that isolation procedures different to those employed should be tried.     

Variable compatibility of clonedAlnus glutinosa ecotypes against ineffectiveFrankia strains

Nodulation tests onin-vitro propagated clones ofAlnus glutinosa ecotypes (forest ecotype, pioneer ecotype) withFrankia strains originating from both ecotypes indicated differences in host-plant compatibility. Inoculated plants of the pioneer ecotype clone were not infected by strains, that were unable to fix nitrogen in pure culture. Nodulation could only be induced on the clone of the forest ecotype, but no nitrogen-fixing activity could be detected. Ultra-structural observations of the nodules by SEM and TEM indicated that ineffectivity of these strains was correlated with the lack of vesicles in the infected cells. Cells were only filled with hyphae: neither sporangia nor vesicles could be detected. In contrast, effective nodules could be obtained on both alder clones after inoculation with an effective strain, showing normal development of vesicle clusters in infected cells. In pure culture the ineffective strains produced no vesicles; sporangia were found only during early stage of growth. The results demonstrate the existence ofFrankia strains which were either non-infective or ineffective on different clones ofAlnus glutinosa.     

Inoculation and production of container-grown red alder seedlings

Summary The inoculation ofAlnus rubra (red alder) withFrankia sp. can lead to a highly efficient symbiosis. Several factors contribute to the successful establishment of nitrogenfixing nodules: (1) quantity and quality ofFrankia inoculant; (2) time and method of inoculation; (3) nutritional status of the host plant.Frankia isolates were screened for their ability to nodulate and promote plant growth of container-grown red alder. Inoculations were performed on seedlings and seeds. Apparent differences in symbiotic performance could be seen when seeds or seedlings were inoculated. Plants inoculated at planting performed significantly better than those inoculated four weeks later in terms of shoot height, nodule number and shoot dry weight. If inoculation was delayed further, reduction in shoot height, nodule number and shoot dry weight resulted. The effect of fertilizer was also investigated with regard to providing optimal plant growth after inoculation. Plants receiving 1/5 Hoagland's solution minus nitrogen showed maximal plant growth with abundant nodulation. Plants receiving 1/5 Hoagland's solution with nitrogen showed excellent plant growth with significantly reduced nodulation.     

Growth increment ofAlnus glutinosa upon dual inoculation with effective and ineffectiveFrankia strains

Investigations on the ecological function of ineffectiveFrankia strains and their behaviour in competition with effectiveFrankia strains indicated an enhanced plant growth upon dual inoculation with increasing amounts of effective (i.e. N₂-fixing)Frankia strains and simultaneous inoculation with a constant amount of an ineffectiveFrankia strain. Enhanced plant growth was measured as increase in plant height and total dry weight at constant shoot/root ratio. The stimulating effect of the ineffective strain was independent of the plant clone and was obtained with bothAlnus glutinosa clones W I and B II, which were resistant and susceptable, respectively, to the ineffective strain. Stimulation was also independent of the nodulation conditions. Short-term studies (7 weeks) under axenic conditions and greenhouse experiments during 3 months showed comparable results, not only in plant growth but also in nodule formation. Increment in plant growth was not necessarily correlated to higher nodule formation with the effectiveFrankia strains.     

Evolutionary implications of nucleotide sequence relatedness between Alnus nepalensis and Alnus glutinosa and also between corresponding Frankia microsymbionts

Frankia DNAs were isolated directly from root nodules of Alnus nepalensis and Alnus nitida collected from various natural sites in India. For comparison, a nodule sample from Alnus glutinosa was also collected from Tuebingen, Germany. Nucleotide sequence analyses of amplified 16S–23S ITS region revealed that one of the microsymbionts from Alnus nepalensis was closely related to the microsymbiont from Alnus glutinosa. A similar exercise on the host was also carried out. It was found that one sample of Alnus nepalensis was closely related to Alnus glutinosa sequence from Europe. Since both Frankia and the host sequences studied revealed proximity between Alnus glutinosa and Alnus nepalensis, it is hypothesised that the common progenitor of all the alders first entered into an association with Frankia, and the symbiotic association has evolved since.     

The improvement and utilization in forestry of nitrogen fixation by actinorhizal plants with special reference toAlnus in Scotland

Summary Alnus species are used widely in Britain for land reclamation, forestry and other purposes. Rapid juvenile growth of the AmericanAlnus rubra makes it an attractive species for planting on N-deficient soils, particularly those of low organic content. In small plot trials, this species is nodulated by indigenous soil frankiae as effectively asAlnus glutinosa. Over a three year period both species return similar amounts of N to the ecosystem, estimated at up to 10–12 kg N ha^–1. Several strains ofFrankia have been isolated from local (Lennox Forest)A. rubra nodules. These differ morphologically and in their growth on different culture media, both from each other and fromA. glutinosa nodule isolates. AllAlnus isolates, however, have a total cellular fatty acid composition qualitatively similar to some other Group B frankiae. Glasshouse tests in N free culture suggest thatA. rubra nodules formed after inoculation of seedlings with American spore (–) isolates are three times more effective in N fixation than those inoculated with LennoxA. rubra spore (+) nodule homogenates. By contrast, the early growth of seedlings inoculated with spore (–)Frankia strains suggests at best a 35% improvement in N fixing activity over seedlings inoculated with LennoxA. rubra nodule isolates. Nevertheless, this improvement in activity, together with the better performance of seedlings inoculated with isolates compared with those treated with crushed nodule preparations, suggest that it would be worthwhile commercially to inoculate nursery stock with a spore (–)Frankia strain.     

Effect of juglone on growthin vitro ofFrankia isolates and nodulation ofAlnus glutinosa in soil

Summary In vitro growth (total protein content) of 5Frankia isolates was significantly inhibited at 10^–4 M juglone (5-hydroxy-1, 4-napthoquinone) concentration, but the degree of inhibition varied with theFrankia isolate. Isolates fromAlnus crispa [Alnus viridis ssp.crispa (Ait.) Turril] were most tolerant of 10^–4 M juglone relative to controls, while an isolate fromPurshia tridentata (Pursh.) D.C. was most inhibited, displaying a dramatic decrease in growth and greatly altered morphology.Nodulation of black alder [Alnus glutinosa L. (Gaertn.)] in an amended prairie soil inoculated with aFrankia isolate from red alder (Alnus rubra Bong.) was significantly decreased by the addition of aqueous suspensions of 10^–3 M and 10^–4 M juglone. This decrease was partially independent of decreased plant growth. The addition of an equal volume of sand to the soil mixture further decreased nodulation of black alder.Frankia inoculation of the soil mixtures significantly increased the total number of nodules formed per seedling, and the degree of differences in seedling nodulation owing to juglone and soil treatments.     

Morphology,physiology and infectivity of twoFrankia isolates An 1 and An 2 from root nodules ofAlnus nitida

Summary Two different strains, An 1 and An 2, were obtained from root nodules ofAlnus nitida Endl., collected from one locality in the area of its natural habitat near Bahrin, District Swat, Pakistan. The light and electron microscopy of the isolates revealed the occurrence of septate and branched hyphae bearing sporangia and vesicles. The strains differed in their growth requirements, nitrogen-fixing ability and production of extracellular pigments, thus indicating the existence of more than oneFrankia strain in the same locality. In the absence of combined nitrogen in the medium strain An 1 formed vesicles and fixed N₂ (up to 200 nmol C₂H₄. mg protein^–1.h^–1), while strain An 2 under the experimental conditions formed only few vesicles and fixed N₂ at a very low rate (ca 10 nmol C₂H₄. mg protein^–1 .h^–1). The nitrogenase activity of strain An 1 was strongly affected by the O₂ concentration.Frankia An 1 and An 2 were infective and effective onA. nitida andA. glutinosa but not onDatisca cannabina andElaeagnus umbellata. Both An 1 and An 2 strains were more infective and effective onA. glutinosa thanFrankia strains AvcIl and CpI1.     

Distribution of spore-positive and spore-negative nodules in stands ofAlnus glutinosa andAlnus incana in Finland

Summary The distribution of spore positive (Sp⁺) and spore negative (Sp⁻) nodules on the two native alder species (A. incana andA. glutinosa) in Finland was investigated. Nodules were collected throughout the country from different ecosystems (forests, swamps, lake- sea- and riversides, old pastures and fields as well as from alder plantations). OnA. incana Sp⁺ nodules predominated, whereas onA. glutinosa the vast majority of the nodules were of the Sp⁻ type. Sp⁺ nodules onA. glutinosa were found only at sites where the two alder species grew close together. This distribution pattern indicates an association of nodule type with alder species, the reasons for which are discussed. Indications of saprophytic growth in the Sp⁻ strain were also found.     

Nodulation potential of soils from red alder stands covering a wide age range

Red alder (Alnus rubra Bong.) stands in the Pacific Northwest are the common first stage in succession following disturbance. These stands are highly productive and contribute a large amount of N to the soils as a result of their N₂-fixing symbiosis with Frankia. As these alder stands age, the soils not only increase in total N, but concentrations of NO^– ₃ increase and pH decreases as a result of nitrification. The objective of this study was to determine how the nodulation capacity of Frankia varies as red alder stands age and if differences in nodulation capacity are related to changes in soil properties. Nodulation capacity was determined by a red alder seedling bioassay for soils from red alder stands in the Oregon coast range covering a wide range of ages. Six chronosequences were sampled, each containing a young, an intermediate, and an older alder stand. Soil total N, total C, NO^– ₃, NH⁺ ₄, and pH were measured on the same soil samples. These factors as well as alder stand characteristics were compared with nodulation capacity in an attempt to identify soil characteristics typical in developing alder stands that most strongly affect nodulation capacity. Soil pH and NO^– ₃ concentration were highly correlated with nodulation capacity and with each other. Cluster analysis of the sites using these two variables identified two groups with distinctly different nodulation capacities. The cluster with the higher nodulation capacity was lower in NO^– ₃ and higher in pH than the other cluster, which included the majority of sites. There was substantial overlap in the age ranges for the two clusters and there was no significant correlation between age and nodulation capacity. Thus nodulation capacity appears to be most closely related to soil properties than to stand age.     

Influence of inoculation on yield ofAlnus glutinosa in the Netherlands

Summary The occurrence and the infectivity of Frankia, the root-nodule endophyte ofAlnus glutinosa, were studied in different kinds of soil in the Netherlands. Both field and pot experiments indicated that many soils, on which alders have not been grown before, had low numbers of endogenous Frankia or none at all. Inoculation of these soils usually enhanced growth and nodulation of alders.The effect of fertilizer treatments on growth and nodulation ofA. glutinosa were studied in experimental plots. Alders grown in sandy soils, dressed with farmyard manure had the highest yield and the most nodules. The influence of inoculation with homogenates of Sp(+) and Sp(–) nodules and with a pure culture of Frankia AvcIl were studied in pot experiments. The quantity of different kinds of inoculum needed to obtain good growth and nodulation of alder was estimated. The results indicated that addition of a nodule homogenate of 90 g fresh AvcIl Sp(+) nodules is sufficient to inoculate one hectare of nursery soil to produce 10 nodules per plant, while a thousand times larger amount of inoculum is necessary when Sp(–) nodules are used. The limitations and the potentials of using nodule homogenates and pure cultures of Frankia for inoculation in forestry are discussed.     

Heterogeneity withinFrankia sp. LDAgpl studied among clones and reisolates

Summary Frankia sp. LDAgpl, an isolate from spore positive nodules ofAlnus glutinosa, only slowly infects its host plant. Reisolates obtained from occasional nodules caused by infection with LDAgpl, are capable of infecting the alder much more rapidly. A variability analysis of LDAgpl has been performed to obtain more insight into the question whether these reisolates constitute a different genotype within LDAgpl and if the plant is exerting an influence during plant passage. High dilutions of mildly sonicatedFrankia suspensions were plated to obtain genetically homogeneous colonies. Clones thus generated showed differences in growth pattern, sporulation and C₂H₂-reduction on media containing propionic acid as sole C-source (P-medium). Differences in sporulation on P-medium indicate that LDAgpl was a highly heterogeneous strain. Comparisons of sporulation on several different media gave evidence that the differences in sporulation between LDAgpl clones are the result of differences in efficiency of propionic acid utilization.The differences observed between the reisolates and LDAgpl clones indicate that the reisolates constitute a different genotype, which could be selected for by the plant during the infection process. Comparison with similar changes in phenotype occuring in a spore negative type strain fromA. glutinosa is discussed.     

Nitrogen cycling in dense plantings of hybrid poplar and black alder

Summary Nitrogen cycling was studied during the third growing season in pure and mixed plantings (33×33 cm spacing) of hybrid poplar and black alder in southeastern Canada. After 3 years, hybrid poplar growth and N content of living tissues in a plot and of individual hybrid poplar plants increased with the proportion of black alder in a planting. No differences were detected among N contents of individual alder plants regardless of plot treatment. Black alder allocated a larger portion of its N to roots than hybrid poplar. Symbiotic nitrogen fixation was estimated to account for 80% of the nitrogen in aboveground alder tissues in the pure treatment using natural¹⁵N dilution. N return in leaf litter was estimated to be 70kg ha^–1 in the pure alder treatment and decreased to a minimum of 20 kg ha^–1 in the pure hybrid poplar plots. No difference was detected among treatments for throughfall N content. Nitrogen concentration in roots and leaf litterfall of black alder was higher than hybrid poplar. Significant soil N accretion occurred in mixed plantings containing two alders to one poplar and pure black alder plantings. Nitrogen availability (NO₃–N) increased with the amount of black alder in a plot. Results suggest that the early increase in nitrogen accumulation of hybrid poplar in mixed treatments can be attributed to an increase of total soil N availability resulting from the input of large amounts of N from easily mineralizable alder tissue.     

Autumnal changes in tissue nitrogen of autumn olive,black alder and eastern cottonwood

Two experiments were conducted to determine patterns of N change in tissues of autumn olive (Elaeagnus umbellata Thunb.) and black alder (Alnus glutinosa [L.] Gaertn.) during autumn in central Illinois, U.S.A. In the first study leaf nitrogen concentrations of autumn olive decreased 40% at an infertile minespoil site and 39% at a fertile prairie site throughout autumn whereas nitrogen concentrations in respective bark samples increased by 39% and 37%. Salt-extractable protein concentrations increased in bark and decreased in leaves over the sampling period. Free amino acid concentrations of autumn olive leaves decreased over the course of the experiment from peak concentrations in August. Asparagine, glutamic acid and proline were major constituents of the free amino acid pools in leaves. Total phosphorus concentrations of autumn olive leaves declined by 40–46% during autumn while bark concentrations of P did not significantly change.In the second experiment non-nodulated seedlings of alder receiving a low level of N-fertilization did not exhibit net resorption of leaf N during autumn whereas foliar N concentration of contrasting nonactinorhizal cottonwood plants (Populus deltoides Bartr. ex. Marsh) under the same fertilization regime decreased by 27% after the first frost. A gradual but significant decrease of 38% in foliar N concentration of nodulated alder seedlings grown under a low N-fertilization regime was associated with the cessation of nitrogenase activity during autumn in nodules. Compared with the low N fertilization regime, the higher level of N-fertilization resulted in smaller autumnal decreases of foliar N concentration in nodulated alder (17%) and in cottonwood (20%); but there was no decrease in foliar N concentration in non-nodulated alder. The higher level of N-fertilization promoted a greater accumulation of N in the roots than in the bark of both tree species after the first frost.Our results suggest that black alder lackingFrankia symbionts does not exhibit net leaf N resorption and that autumnal decreases in leaf N ofFrankia-nodulated black alder result primarily from declining foliar N import relative to export due to low temperature inhibition of N₂ fixation. In contrast, autumn olive exhibited greater and more precipitous autumnal declines in foliar N concentration than those of alder, and the pattern of N decline was unaffected by site fertility.     

Ineffective Frankia and host resistance in natural populations of Alnus glutinosa (L.) gaertn

Alnus glutinosa (black alder) populations are known to exhibit a variable degree of incompatibility to root nodule formation by ineffective Frankia. The relationship between the occurrence of ineffective Frankia in wet stands of black alder and the degree of resistance to nodulation by ineffective Frankia of seed-lots and clones of alder trees from these particular locations was studied through soil inoculation experiments. The average percentage of resistant plants (R-frequency) among the seed-lots from locations with an ineffective Frankia soil population was equal to, or higher than, the R-frequencies of locations without ineffective Frankia. The mean R-frequency was highest for the seed-lots from the location from which the soil inoculant was taken. These results strongly suggest that ineffective Frankia are not strictly dependent on susceptible A. glutinosa for the maintenance of their population size. The fungus Penicillium nodositatum also nodulated A. glutinosa seedlings. Whereas a negative interaction with the ineffective Frankia nodulation was found, this did not have a significant effect on the R-frequencies of the seed-lots that were tested, suggesting that the ineffective Frankia nodulation adversely affected the myco-nodulation, and not vice versa.     

Frankia-Alnus incana symbiosis: Effect of endophyte on nitrogen fixation and biomass production

The efficiency of different FinnishFrankia strains as symbionts onAlnus incana (L.) Moench was evaluated in inoculation experiments by measuring nitrogen fixation and biomass production. Since all available pure cultures ofFrankia are of the Sp⁻ type (sporangia not formed in nodules), but the dominant nodule endophyte ofA. incana in Finland is of the Sp⁺ type (sporangia formed in nodules), crushed nodules of thisFrankia type were included. The Sp⁻ pure cultures, whether originating fromA. incana orA. glutinosa, produced with one exception, similar biomass withA. incana. The highest biomass was produced with an American reference strain fromA. viridis crispa. Using Sp⁺ nodule homogenates fromA. incana as inoculum, the biomass production was only one third of that produced by Sp⁻ pure cultures from the same host. Hence, through selection of the endophyte it is possible to exert a considerable influence on the productivity ofAlnus incana.     

Preinfection events in the establishment of Alnus-Frankia symbiosis: Development of a spot inoculation technique

Summary The early biochemical and structural events associated with the infection of Alnus byFrankia are still largely unknown. These studies have been hampered by the difficulty of localizing precisely the site of inoculation on the root surface and of standardizing the inoculum dose. To facilitate these investigations, we describe a new spot inoculation method wellsuited to study the Alnus-Frankia system. This method involves the growth ofFrankia in the presence of microcarrier and their subsequent deposition on the alder root surface as an inoculum dose. The ability of this new procedure to induce nodulation close to the point of inoculation has been observed.     

Frankia in the rhizosphere of nonhost plants: A comparison with root-associated N2-fixing Enterobacter,Klebsiella and Pseudomonas

Bacterial growth in the rhizosphere and resulting changes in plant growth parameters were studied in small aseptic seedlings of birch (Betula pendula and B. pubescens) and grasses (Poa pratensis and Festuca rubra). The seedlings were inoculated with three Frankia strains (Ai1a and Ag5b isolated from native Alnus root nodules and Ai17 from a root nodule induced by soil originating from a Betula pendula stand), and three associative N₂-fixing bacteria (Enterobacter agglomerans, Klebsiella pneumoniae and Pseudomonas sp., isolated from grass roots). Microscopic observations showed that all the Frankia strains were able to colonize and grow on the root surface of the plants tested without addition of an exogenous carbon source. No net growth of the associative N₂-fixers was observed in the rhizosphere, although inoculum viable counts were maintained over the experimental period. Changes in both the biomass and morphology of plant seedlings in response to bacterial inoculation were recorded, which were more dependent on the plant species than on the bacterial strain.