Low-molecular-mass purine nucleoside phosphorylase: characterization and application in enzymatic synthesis of nucleoside antiviral drugs

Purine nucleoside phosphorylase (PNP) that catalyzes the reversible phosphorolysis of various purine nucleosides is widely distributed in prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Four pnp genes from Bacillus subtilis 168, Escherichia coli K-12 and Pseudoalteromonas sp. XM2107 were cloned by PCR and expressed in E. coli XL1-Blue. Recombinant PNPs (rPNPs) were purified by Ni²⁺-NTA chromatography. Compared with other rPNPs, PNP₈₁₆ was a low-molecular-mass homotrimer, which exhibited 11-, 4- and 1.5-fold higher values in k _cat/K _m using inosine as the substrate at 37°C. The PNP₈₁₆ or engineered strain XBlue (pQE-816) had a higher catalytic activity than other rPNPs or engineered strains during the enzymatic synthesis of ribavirin, which suggested that the low-molecular-mass homotrimer derived from microorganisms has higher catalytic activity for synthesis of nucleoside antiviral drugs.     

Purine nucleoside phosphorylase from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pseudoalteromonas</Emphasis> sp. Bsi590: molecular cloning,gene expression and characterization of the recombinant protein

The gene encoding purine nucleoside phosphorylase (PNP) from the cold-adapted marine bacterium Pseudoalteromonas sp. Bsi590 was identified, cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli. The gene encodes a polypeptide of 233 amino acids with a calculated molecular weight of 25,018 Da. Pseudoalteromonas sp. Bsi590 PNP (PiPNP) shares 60% amino sequence identity and conservation of amino acid residues involved in catalysis with mesophilic Escherichia coli deoD-encoded purine nucleoside phosphorylase (EcPNP). N-terminal his-tagged PiPNP and EcPNP were purified to apparent homogeneity using Ni²⁺-chelating column. Compared with EcPNP, PiPNP possessed a lower temperature optimum and thermal stability. As for PNP enzymes in general, PiPNP and EcPNP displayed complicated kinetic properties; PiPNP possessed higher K _m and catalytic efficiency (k _cat/K _m ) compared to EcPNP at 37°C. Substrate specificity results showed PiPNP catalyzed the phosphorolytic cleavage of 6-oxopurine and 6-aminopurine nucleosides (or 2-deoxynucleosides), and to a lesser extent purine arabinosides. PiPNP showed a better activity with inosine while no activity toward pyrimidine nucleosides. The protein conformation was analyzed by temperature perturbation difference spectrum. Results showed that PiPNP had lower conformation transition point temperature than EcPNP; phosphate buffer and KCl had significant influence on PiPNP protein conformation stability and thermostability.     

Overexpression and characterization of a thermostable trehalose synthase from Meiothermus ruber

A thermostable trehalose synthase (TreS) gene from Meiothermus ruber CBS-01 was cloned and overexpressed in Escherichia coli. The purified recombinant TreS could utilize maltose to produce trehalose, and showed an optimum pH and temperature of 6.5 and 50°C, respectively. Kinetic analysis showed that the enzyme had a twofold higher catalytic efficiency (k _cat/K _m) for maltose than for trehalose, indicating maltose as the preferred substrate. The TreS also had a weak hydrolytic property with glucose as the byproduct, and glucose was a strong competitive inhibitor of the enzyme. The maximum production of trehalose by the enzyme reached 65% at 20°C. The most importantly the enzyme could maintain very high activity (above 90%) at pH 4.0–8.0 and 60°C 5 h. These results provided that the stable TreS was suitable for the industrial production of trehalose from maltose in a one-step reaction.     

枯草芽孢杆菌嘌呤核苷磷酸化酶酶学性质研究及在利巴韦林酶法合成中的应用

利用PCR技术从枯草芽孢杆菌基因组DNA中扩增出其编码嘌呤核苷磷酸化酶的两种基因deoD和punA,构建工程菌并采用金属螯合层析纯化PNP₇₀₂和PNP₈₁₆,酶学性质研究表明:二者具有一致的最适反应温度(60℃)和最适反应pH值(7~8),PNP₈₁₆磷酸解肌苷的催化效率(k_cat/K_m)比PNP₇₀₂高出11.12倍。底物特异性试验表明:PNP₇₀₂为高分子量的六聚体,而PNP₈₁₆为低分子量的三聚体。分别以纯化酶和工程菌菌体为酶源,以肌苷或鸟苷为核糖基供体,TCA(1,2,4-三氮唑-3-甲酰胺)为底物,酶法合成核苷类抗病毒药物利巴韦林,PNP₈₁₆和工程菌XL-Blue(pPNP₈₁₆)较PNP₇₀₂和工程菌XL-Blue(pPNP₇₀₂)具有更高的催化速度和底物转化率,表明来源于微生物的低分子量的三聚体PNP在核苷类药物和中间体微生物酶法合成中具有更高的应用价值。     

Novel Use for the Osmolyte Trimethylamine N-oxide: Retaining the Psychrophilic Characters of Cold-Adapted Protease Deseasin MCP-01 and Simultaneously Improving its Thermostability

The low thermostability of cold-adapted enzymes is a main barrier for their application. A simple and reliable method to improve both the stability and the activity of cold-adapted enzymes is still rare. As a protein stabilizer, the effect of trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO) on a cold-adapted enzyme or protein has not been reported. In this study, effects of TMAO on the structure, activity, and stability of a cold-adapted protease, deseasin MCP-01, were studied. Deseasin MCP-01 is a new type of subtilase from deep-sea psychrotolerant bacterium Pseudoalteromonas sp. SM9913. Fluorescence and CD spectra showed that TMAO did not perturb the structure of MCP-01 and therefore kept the conformational flexibility of MCP-01. One molar TMAO improved the activity of MCP-01 by 174% and its catalytic efficiency (k _cat /K _m) by 290% at 0°C. In the presence of 1 M TMAO, the thermostability (t _1/2) of MCP-01 increased by two- to fivefold at 60∼40°C. Structural analysis with CD showed that 1 M TMAO could keep the structural thermostability of MCP-01 close to that of its mesophilic counterpart subtilisin Carlsberg when incubated at 40°C for 1 h. Moreover, 1 M TMAO increased the melting temperature (T _m) of MCP-01 by 10.5°C. These results suggest that TMAO can be used as a perfect stabilizing agent to retain the psychrophilic characters of a cold-adapted enzyme and simultaneously improve its thermostability.     

X-Ray Crystallographic and Kinetic Analysis of Human Purine Nucleoside Phosphorylase Complexes with 1-β-D-Ribofuranosyl-1,2,4-triazole-3-carobxamide and 1-β-D-Ribofuranosyl-1,2,4-triazole-3-carboxamidine

Abstract

The three-dimensional structures of the complexes between human erythrocytic purine nucleoside phosphorylase (PNP) and both 1-β-D-ribofuranosyl-1,2,4-triazole-3-carboxamide (ribavirin) and 1-β-D-ribofuranosyl-1,2,4-triazole-3-carboxamidine (TCNR) have been determined using X-ray crystallographic techniques. The structures have been refined at 2.9 Å resolution using simulated annealing and conjugate-gradient minimization techniques to an R value of 21.8% for ribavirin and 20.8% for TCNR. Ribavirin and TCNR are truncated nucleosides corresponding to adenosine and inosine, respectively, and are of potential interest as PNP inhibitors. Kinetic parameters have been determined for recombinant wild-type PNP and for a mutant PNP in which Asn 243 is converted to Asp. The K_i value for ribavirin is 4.9 mM with wild-type PNP and 4.7 mM with the Asn243Asp mutant, while the K_i values for TCNR are 17.6 μM and 3.8 μM with wild-type and mutant, respectively. X-ray crystallographic studies showed that the binding geometry for both of these substrate analogues was similar to that seen for natural substrates. The glycosidic torsion angles (χ) were ?34° for ribavirin and ?39° for TCNR which are in good agreement with values seen for other studied nucleoside complexes with PNP, but which are unusual when compared to those seen for free nucleic acid derivatives. Based upon the three-dimensional structure, interactions of Asn 243 and Glu 201 with a protonated carboxamidine of TCNR explain the stronger inhibition of PNP observed for TCNR over ribavirin.     

A cold-adapted esterase of a novel marine isolate, Pseudoalteromonas arctica: gene cloning, enzyme purification and characterization

A gene encoding an esterase (estO) was identified and sequenced from a gene library screen of the psychrotolerant bacterium Pseudoalteromonas arctica. Analysis of the 1,203 bp coding region revealed that the deduced peptide sequence is composed of 400 amino acids with a predicted molecular mass of 44.1 kDa. EstO contains a N-terminal esterase domain and an additional OsmC domain at the C-terminus (osmotically induced family of proteins). The highly conserved five-residue motif typical for all α/β hydrolases (G × S × G) was detected from position 104 to 108 together with a putative catalytic triad consisting of Ser¹⁰⁶, Asp¹⁹⁶, and His²²⁵. Sequence comparison showed that EstO exhibits 90% amino acid identity with hypothetical proteins containing similar esterase and OsmC domains but only around 10% identity to the amino acid sequences of known esterases. EstO variants with and without the OsmC domain were produced and purified as His-tag fusion proteins in E. coli. EstO displayed an optimum pH of 7.5 and optimum temperature of 25°C with more than 50% retained activity at the freezing point of water. The thermostability of EstO (50% activity after 5 h at 40°C) dramatically increased in the truncated variant (50% activity after 2.5 h at 90°C). Furthermore, the esterase displays broad substrate specificity for esters of short-chain fatty acids (C₂–C₈).     

Screening Escherichia coli, Enterococcus faecalis, and Clostridium perfringens as Indicator Organisms in Evaluating Pathogen-Reducing Capacity in Biogas Plants

This study was conducted to identify an indicator organism(s) in evaluating the pathogen-reducing capacity of biogas plants. Fresh cow manure containing 10⁴ to 10⁵ colony forming unit (CFU) per milliliter of Escherichia coli and Enterococcus faecalis along with an inoculated Clostridium perfringens strain were exposed to 37°C for 15 days, 55°C for 48 h, and 70°C for 24 h. C. perfringens was the most heat-resistant organism followed by E. faecalis, while E. coli was the most heat-sensitive organism. E. coli was reduced below detection limit at all temperatures with log₁₀ reductions of 4.94 (10 s), 4.37 (40 min), and 2.6 (5 days) at 70°C, 55°C, and 37°C, respectively. Maximum log₁₀ reductions for E. faecalis were 1.77 at 70°C (1 day), 1.7 at 55°C (2 days) and 3.13 at 37°C (15 days). For C. perfringens, maximum log₁₀ reduction at 37°C was 1.35 log₁₀ units (15 days) compared to less than 1 unit at 55 and 70°C. Modeling results showed that E. faecalis and C. perfringens had higher amount of heat-resistant fraction than E. coli. Thus, E. faecalis and C. perfringens can be used as indicator organisms to evaluate pathogen-reducing capacity in biogas plants at high temperatures of 55°C and 70°C while at 37°C E. coli could also be included as indicator organism.     

A novel cold-adapted lipase from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Acinetobacter</Emphasis> sp. XMZ-26: gene cloning and characterisation

Acinetobacter sp. XMZ-26 (ACCC 05422) was isolated from soil samples obtained from glaciers in Xinjiang Province, China. The partial nucleotide sequence of a lipase gene was obtained by touchdown PCR using degenerate primers designed based on the conserved domains of cold-adapted lipases. Subsequently, a complete gene sequence encoding a 317 amino acid polypeptide was identified. Our novel lipase gene, lipA, was overexpressed in Escherichia coli. The recombinant protein (LipA) was purified by Ni-affinity chromatography, and then deeply characterised. The LipA resulted to hydrolyse pNP esters of fatty acids with acyl chain length from C2 to C16, and the preferred substrate was pNP octanoate showing a k _cat = 560.52 ± 28.32 s⁻¹, K _m = 0.075 ± 0.008 mM, and a k _cat/K _m = 7,377.29 ± 118.88 s⁻¹ mM⁻¹. Maximal LipA activity was observed at a temperature of 15°C and pH 10.0 using pNP decanoate as substrate. That LipA peaked at such a low temperature and remained most activity between 5°C and 35°C indicated that it was a cold-adapted enzyme. Remarkably, this lipase retained much of its activity in the presence of commercial detergents and organic solvents, including Ninol, Triton X-100, methanol, PEG-600, and DMSO. This cold-adapted lipase may find applications in the detergent industry and organic synthesis.     

Molecular characterization of a novel bacterial aryl acylamidase belonging to the amidase signature enzyme family

In seeking aryl acylamidase (EC 3.5.1.13) acting on an amide bond in p-acetaminophenol (Tylenol™), we identified a novel gene encoding 496 residues of a protein. The gene revealed a conserved amidase signature region with a canonical catalytic triad. The gene was expressed in E. coli and characterized for its biochemical properties. The optimum pH and temperature for the activity on p-acetaminophenol were 10 and 37°C, respectively. The half-life of enzyme activity at 37°C was 192 h and 90% of its activity remained after 3 h incubation at 40°C. Divalent metals was found to inhibit the activity of enzyme. The K _m values for various aryl acylamides such as 4-nitroacetanilide, p-acetaminophenol, phenacetin, 4-chloroacetanilide and acetanilide were 0.10, 0.32, 0.83, 1.9 and 19 mM, respectively. The reverse reaction activity (amide synthesis) was also examined using various chain lengths (C₁∼C₄ and C₁₀) of carboxylic donors and aniline as substrates. These kinetic parameters and substrate specificity in forward and reverse reaction indicated that the aryl acylamidase in this study has a preference for aryl substrate having polar functional groups and hydrophobic carboxylic donors.     

Production of L-malate from fumarate by the yeast Dipodascus magnusii

An alternative microbiological method for the production of malate from fumarate is presented. The yeast Dipodascus magnusii was used for this bioconversion. The optimum cell growth temperature was 28°C and the working volume 120 ml. The highest level of fumarase activity during bioconversion was achieved at a pH of 7.5 and a temperature of 37°C. These conditions were determined as optimal. Using sodium fumarate (1M), the maximum specific productivity of malic acid obtained was 1.72 g/(g_DCW × h) for intact cells. In the case of ammonium fumarate, it was 2.25 g/(g_DCW × h).     

Cloning,expression and characterization of the esterase estUT1 from Ureibacillus thermosphaericus which belongs to a new lipase family XVIII

A new esterase gene from thermophilic bacteria Ureibacillus thermosphaericus was cloned into the pET32b vector and expressed in Escherichia coli BL21(DE3). Alignment of the estUT1 amino acid sequence revealed the presence of a novel canonical pentapeptide (GVSLG) and 41–47% identity to the closest family of the bacterial lipases XIII. Thus the esterase estUT1 from U. thermosphaericus was assigned as a member of the novel family XVIII. It also showed a strong activity toward short-chain esters (C2–C8), with the highest activity for C2. When p-nitrophenyl butyrate is used as a substrate, the temperature and pH optimum of the enzyme were 70–80 °C and 8.0, respectively. EstUT1 showed high thermostability and 68.9 ± 2.5% residual activity after incubation at 70 °C for 6 h. Homology modeling of the enzyme structure showed the presence of a putative catalytic triad Ser93, Asp192, and His222. The activity of estUT1 was inhibited by PMSF, suggesting that the serine residue is involved in the catalytic activity of the enzyme. The purified enzyme exhibited high stability in organic solvents. EstUT1 retained 85.8 ± 2.4% residual activity in 30% methanol at 50 °C for 6 h. Stability at high temperature and tolerance to organic solvents make estUT1 a promising enzyme for biotechnology application.

     

Cloning,Expression, Purification,and Characterization of Cold-Adapted α-Amylase from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pseudoalteromonas arctica</Emphasis> GS230

A cold-adapted α-amylase (ParAmy) gene from Pseudoalteromonas arctica GS230 was cloned, sequenced, and expressed as an N-terminus His-tag fusion protein in E. coli. A recombinant protein was produced and purified with DEAE-sepherose ion exchange chromatography and Ni affinity chromatography. The molecular weight of ParAmy was estimated to be 55 KDa with sodium dodecyl sulfate–polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS–PAGE). With an optimum temperature for activity 30 °C, ParAmy showed 34.5% of maximum activity at 0 °C and its activity decreased sharply at above 40 °C. ParAmy was stable in the range of pH 7–8.5 at 30 °C for 1 h. ParAmy was activated by Mn²⁺, K⁺ and Na⁺, and inhibited by Hg²⁺, Cu²⁺, and Fe³⁺. N-Bromosuccinimid showed a significant repressive effect on enzyme activity. The K _m and V _max values of the α-amylase for soluble starch were 7.28 mg/mL and 13.07 mg/mL min, respectively. This research suggests that Paramy has a good potential to be a cold-stable and alkalitolerant amylase in detergent industry.     

Studies on Isoleucyl-tRNA Synthetase of an Extreme Thermophile,Thermus thermophilus HB8

Isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase (IRS) was partially purified from an extreme thermophile, T. thermophilus HB 8. The molecular weight (11.5 ×10⁴) and some kinetic constants were obtained and compared with IRS from other sources.

The present IRS catalyzed both isoleucine dependent and valine dependent ATP-PPi exchange reactions (optimum at around 80°C) but not valyl-tRNA formation. The optimum temperature for isoleucyl-tRNA formation was 62°C with E. coli tRNA and 75°C with T. thermophilus tRNA.

The enzyme showed a remarkable thermostability. The addition of E. coli or T. thermophilus tRNA enhanced the thermostability of the enzyme, which was shown to be fully active up to 77°C. When E. coli tRNA was used, the loading activity decreased in parallel to the unfolding of the substrate tRNA molecule. From these results the relation is discussed between tRNA conformation and function.     

Statistical medium optimization and biodegradative capacity of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Ralstonia eutropha</Emphasis> toward <Emphasis Type="Italic">p</Emphasis>-nitrophenol

The effect of p-nitrophenol (PNP) concentration with or without glucose and yeast extract on the growth and biodegradative capacity of Ralstonia eutropha was examined. The chemical constituents of the culture medium were modeled using a response surface methodology. The experiments were performed according to the central composite design arrangement considering PNP, glucose and yeast extract as the selected variables whose influences on the degradation was evaluated (shaking in reciprocal mode, temperature of 30°C, pH 7 and test time of about 9 h). Quadratic polynomial regression equations were used to quantitatively explain variations between and within the models (responses: the biodegradation capacity and the biomass formation). The coefficient of determination was high (R _adjusted² = 0.9783), indicating the constructed polynomial model for PNP biodegradative capacity explains the variation between the regressors fairly well. A PNP removal efficiency of 74.5% occurred within 9 h (15 mg/L as the initial concentration of PNP with use of yeast extract at 0.5 g/L).     

A Nonconserved Carboxy-Terminal Segment of GroEL Contributes to Reaction Temperature

The role of the C-terminal segment of the GroEL equatorial domain was analyzed. To understand the molecular basis for the different active temperatures of GroEL from three bacteria, we constructed a series of chimeric GroELs combining the C-terminal segment of the equatorial domain from one species with the remainder of GroEL from another. In each case, the foreign C-terminal segment substantially altered the active temperature range of the chimera. Substitution of L524 of Escherichia coli GroEL with the corresponding residue (isoleucine) from psychrophilic GroEL resulted in a GroE with approximately wild-type activity at 25 °C, but also at 10 °C, a temperature at which wild-type E. coli GroE is inactive. In a detailed look at the temperature dependence of the GroELs, normal E. coli GroEL and the L524I mutant became highly active above 14 °C and 12 °C respectively. Similar temperature dependences were observed in a surface plasmon resonance assay of GroES binding. These results suggested that the C-terminal segment of the GroEL equatorial domain has an important role in the temperature dependence of GroEL. Moreover, E. coli acquired the ability to grow at low temperature through the introduction of cold-adapted chimeric or L524I mutant groEL genes.     

Extensive hydrolysis of raw rice starch by a chimeric α-amylase engineered with α-amylase (AmyP) and a starch-binding domain from Cryptococcus sp. S-2

Recombinant chimeric α-amylase (AmyP-Cr) was constructed by a catalytic core of α-amylase (AmyP) from a marine metagenomic library and a starch-binding domain (SBD_Cr) of α-amylase from Cryptococcus sp. S-2. The molecular fusion did not alter optimum pH, optimum temperature, hydrolysis products, and an ability of preferential and rapid degradation towards raw rice starch, but catalytic efficiency and thermostability were remarkably improved compared with those of the wild-type AmyP. AmyP-Cr achieved the final hydrolysis degree of 61.7 ± 1.2% for 10% raw rice starch and 47.3 ± 0.8% for 15% raw rice starch after 4 h at 40 °C with 1.0 U per mg of raw starch. The catalytic efficiency was very high, with 3.6–4.0 times higher than that of AmyP. The enhanced catalytic efficiency was attributed to the better thermostability and the higher adsorption and disruption to raw rice starch caused by SBD_Cr. The properties of AmyP-Cr open a new way in terms of a new design of raw rice starch processing.

     

Engineering of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Bacillus</Emphasis> lipase by directed evolution for enhanced thermal stability: effect of isoleucine to threonine mutation at protein surface

A lip gene from a Bacillus isolate was cloned and expressed in E. coli. By thermal denaturation analysis, T_1/2 of lipase was observed to be 7 min at 50°C with less than 10% activity after 1 h incubation at 50°C. To expand the functionality of cloned lipase, attempts have been made to create thermostable variants of lip gene. A lipase variant with an isoleucine to threonine amino acid substitution at the protein surface was isolated that demonstrated higher thermostability than its wild type predecessor. To explore the structure–function relationship, the lip gene product of wild type (WT) and mutant was characterized in detail. The mutation enhanced the specific activity of enzyme by 2-folds when compared with WT. The mutant enzyme showed enhanced T_1/2 of 21 min at 50°C. The kinetic parameters of the mutant enzyme were significantly altered. The mutant enzyme displayed higher affinity for substrate (decreased K _m ) in comparison to the wild type. The k _cat and catalytic efficiency (k _cat/K _m ) of mutant were also enhanced by two and five times, respectively, as compared with the WT. The mutation resides on the part of helix which is exposed to the solvent and away from the catalytic triad. The replacement of a solvent exposed hydrophobic residue (Ile) in WT with a hydrophilic residue (Thr) in mutant might impart thermostability to the protein structure.     

Quantifying the heterogeneous heat response of Escherichia coli under dynamic temperatures

Aims: Non‐sigmoid growth curves of Escherichia coli obtained at constant temperatures near the maximum growth temperature (T_max) were previously explained by the coexistence of two subpopulations, i.e. a stress‐sensitive and a stress‐resistant subpopulation. Mathematical simulations with a heterogeneous model support this hypothesis for static experiments at 45°C. In this article, the behaviour of E. coli, when subjected to a linearly increasing temperature crossing T_max, is studied. Methods and Results: Subpopulation dynamics are studied by culturing E. coli K12 MG1655 in brain heart infusion broth in a bioreactor. The slowly increasing temperature (°C h^?1) starting from 42°C results in growth up to 60°C, a temperature significantly higher than the known T_max. Given some additional presumptions, mathematical simulations with the heterogeneous model can describe the dynamic experiments rather well. Conclusions: This study further confirms the existence of a stress‐resistant subpopulation and reveals the unexpected growth of E. coli at temperatures significantly higher than T_max. Significance and Impact of the Study: The growth of the small stress‐resistant subpopulation at unexpectedly high temperatures asks for a revision of currently applied models in food safety and food quality strategies.     

Cold adapted features of Vibrio salmonicida catalase: characterisation and comparison to the mesophilic counterpart from Proteus mirabilis

The gene encoding catalase from the psychrophilic marine bacterium Vibrio salmonicida LFI1238 was identified, cloned and expressed in the catalase-deficient Escherichia coli UM2. Recombinant catalase from V. salmonicida (VSC) was purified to apparent homogeneity as a tetramer with a molecular mass of 235 kDa. VSC contained 67% heme b and 25% protoporphyrin IX. VSC was able to bind NADPH, react with cyanide and form compounds I and II as other monofunctional small subunit heme catalases. Amino acid sequence alignment of VSC and catalase from the mesophilic Proteus mirabilis (PMC) revealed 71% identity. As for cold adapted enzymes in general, VSC possessed a lower temperature optimum and higher catalytic efficiency (k _cat/K _m) compared to PMC. VSC have higher affinity for hydrogen peroxide (apparent K _m) at all temperatures. For VSC the turnover rate (k _cat) is slightly lower while the catalytic efficiency is slightly higher compared to PMC over the temperature range measured, except at 4°C. Moreover, the catalytic efficiency of VSC and PMC is almost temperature independent, except at 4°C where PMC has a twofold lower efficiency compared to VSC. This may indicate that VSC has evolved to maintain a high efficiency at low temperatures.