Solution structure and interdomain interactions of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae "TATA binding protein" (TBP) probed by radiolytic protein footprinting

Although atomic-resolution crystal structures of the conserved C-terminal domain of several species of TBP and their complexes with DNA have been determined, little information is available concerning the structure in solution of full-length TBP containing both the conserved C-terminal and nonconserved N-terminal domains. Quantitation of the amino acid side chain oxidation products generated by synchrotron X-ray radiolysis by mass spectrometry has been used to determine the solvent accessibility of individual residues in monomeric Saccharomyces cerevisiae TATA binding protein (TBP) free in solution and in the TBP-DNA complex. Amino acid side chains within the C-terminal domain of unliganded full-length TBP that are predicted to be accessible from crystal structures of the isolated domain are protected from oxidation. Residues within the N-terminal domain are also protected from oxidation in both the absence and presence of DNA. Some residues within the DNA-binding "saddle" of the C-terminal domain are protected upon formation of a TBP-DNA complex as expected, while others are protected in both the absence and presence of bound DNA. In addition, residues on the upper side of the beta-sheets undergo reactivity changes as a function of DNA binding. These data suggest that the DNA-binding saddle of monomeric unliganded yeast TBP is only partially accessible to solvent, the N-terminal domain is partially structured, and the N- and C-terminal domains form a different set of contacts in the free and DNA-bound protein. The functional implications of these results are discussed.     

Solution structural studies of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae TATA binding protein (TBP)

The intrinsic fluorescence of the six tyrosines located within the C-terminal domain of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae TATA binding protein (TBP) and the single tryptophan located in the N-terminal domain has been used to separately probe the structural changes associated with each domain upon DNA binding or oligomerization of the protein. The unusually short-wavelength maximum of TBP fluorescence is shown to reflect the unusually high quantum yield of the tyrosine residues in TBP and not to result from unusual tryptophan fluorescence. The anisotropy of the C-terminal tyrosines is very high in monomeric, octameric, and DNA-complexed TBP and comparable to that observed in much larger proteins. The tyrosines have low accessibility to an external fluorescence quencher. The anisotropy of the single tryptophan located within the N-terminal domain of TBP is much lower than that of the tyrosines and is accessible to an external fluorescence quencher. Tyrosine, but not tryptophan, fluorescence is quenched upon TBP-DNA complex formation. Only the tryptophan fluorescence is shifted to longer wavelengths in the protein-DNA complex. In addition, the accessibility of the tryptophan residue to the external quencher and the internal motion of the tryptophan residue increase upon DNA binding by TBP. These results show the following: (i) The structure of the C-terminal domain structure is unchanged upon TBP oligomerization, in contrast to the N-terminal domain [Daugherty, M. A., Brenowitz, M., and Fried, M. G. (2000) Biochemistry 39, 4869-4880]. (ii) The environment of the tyrosine residues within the C-terminal domain of TBP is structurally rigid and unaffected by oligomerization or DNA binding. (iii) The C-terminal domain of TBP is uniformly in close proximity to bound DNA. (iv) While the N-terminal domain unfolds upon DNA binding by TBP, its increased correlation time shows that the overall structure of the protein is more rigid when complexed to DNA. A model that reconciles these results is proposed.     

Architecture of Protein and DNA Contacts within the TFIIIB-DNA Complex

The RNA polymerase III factor TFIIIB forms a stable complex with DNA and can promote multiple rounds of initiation by polymerase. TFIIIB is composed of three subunits, the TATA binding protein (TBP), TFIIB-related factor (BRF), and B". Chemical footprinting, as well as mutagenesis of TBP, BRF, and promoter DNA, was used to probe the architecture of TFIIIB subunits bound to DNA. BRF bound to TBP-DNA through the nonconserved C-terminal region and required 15 bp downstream of the TATA box and as little as 1 bp upstream of the TATA box for stable complex formation. In contrast, formation of complete TFIIIB complexes required 15 bp both upstream and downstream of the TATA box. Hydroxyl radical footprinting of TFIIIB complexes and modeling the results to the TBP-DNA structure suggest that BRF and B" surround TBP on both faces of the TBP-DNA complex and provide an explanation for the exceptional stability of this complex. Competition for binding to TBP by BRF and either TFIIB or TFIIA suggests that BRF binds on the opposite face of the TBP-DNA complex from TFIIB and that the binding sites for TFIIA and BRF overlap. The positions of TBP mutations which are defective in binding BRF suggest that BRF binds to the top and N-terminal leg of TBP. One mutation on the N-terminal leg of TBP specifically affects the binding of the B" subunit.     

Dimer dissociation and thermosensitivity kinetics of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae and human TATA binding proteins.

A kinetic analysis of dimer dissociation, TATA DNA binding, and thermal inactivation of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and human TATA binding proteins (TBP) was conducted. We find that yeast TBP dimers, like human TBP dimers, are slow to dissociate in vitro (t(1/2) approximately 20 min). Mild mutations in the crystallographic dimer interface accelerate the rate of dimer dissociation, whereas severe mutations prevent dimerization. In the presence of excess TATA DNA, which measures the entire active TBP population, dimer dissociation represents the rate-limiting step in DNA binding. These findings provide a biochemical extension to genetic studies demonstrating that TBP dimerization prevents unregulated gene expression in yeast [Jackson-Fisher, A. J., Chitikila, C., Mitra, M., and Pugh, B. F. (1999) Mol. Cell 3, 717-727]. In the presence of vast excesses of TBP over TATA DNA, which measures only a very small fraction of the total TBP, the monomer population in a monomer/dimer equilibrium binds DNA rapidly, which is consistent with a simultaneous binding and bending of the DNA. Under conditions where other studies failed to detect dimers, yeast TBP's DNA binding activity was extremely labile in the absence of TATA DNA, even at temperatures as low as 0 degrees C. Kinetic analyses of TBP instability in the absence of DNA at 30 degrees C revealed that even under fairly stabilizing solution conditions, TBP's DNA binding activity rapidly dissipated with t(1/2) values ranging from 6 to 26 min. TBP's stability appeared to vary with the square root of the TBP concentration, suggesting that TBP dimerization helps prevent TBP inactivation.     

Influence of the N-terminal domain and divalent cations on self-association and DNA binding by the Saccharomyces cerevisiae TATA binding protein

The localization of a single tryptophan to the N-terminal domain and six tyrosines to the C-terminal domain of TBP allows intrinsic fluorescence to separately report on the structures and dynamics of the full-length TATA binding protein (TBP) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and its C-terminal DNA binding domain (TBPc) as a function of self-association and DNA binding. TBPc is more compact than the C-terminal domain within the full-length protein. Quenching of the intrinsic fluorescence by DNA and external dynamic quenchers shows that the observed tyrosine fluorescence is due to the four residues surrounding the "DNA binding saddle" of the C-terminal domain. TBP's N-terminal domain unfolds and changes its position relative to the C-terminal domain upon DNA binding. It partially shields the DNA binding saddle in octameric TBP, shifting upon dissociation to monomers to expose the saddle to DNA. Structure-energetic correlations were obtained by comparing the contribution that electrostatic interactions make to DNA binding by TBP and TBPc; DNA binding by TBPc is more hydrophobic than that by TBP, suggesting that the N-terminal domain either interacts with bound DNA directly or screens a part of the C-terminal domain, diminishing its electronegativity. The competition between divalent cations, K+, and DNA is not straightforward. Divalent cations strengthen binding of TBP to DNA and do so more strongly for TBPc. We suggest that divalent cations affect the structure of the bound DNA perhaps by stabilizing its distorted conformation in complexes with TBPc and TBP and that the N-terminal domain mimics the effects of divalent cations. These data support an autoinhibitory mechanism in which competition between the N-terminal domain and DNA for the saddle diminishes the DNA binding affinity of the full-length protein.     

Native human TATA-binding protein simultaneously binds and bends promoter DNA without a slow isomerization step or TFIIB requirement

The association of TATA-binding protein (TBP) with promoter DNA is central to the initiation and regulation of eukaryotic protein synthesis. Our laboratory has previously conducted detailed investigations of this interaction using yeast TBP and seven consensus and variant TATA sequences. We have now investigated this key interaction using human TBP and the TATA sequence from the adenovirus major late promoter (AdMLP). Recombinant native human protein was used together with fluorescently labeled DNA, allowing real time data acquisition in solution. We find that the wild-type hTBP-DNAAdMLP reaction is characterized by high affinity (Kd < or = 5 nm), simultaneous binding and DNA bending, and rapid formation of a stable human TBP-DNA complex having DNA bent approximately 100 degrees. These data allow, for the first time, a direct comparison of the reactions of the full-length, native human and yeast TBPs with a consensus promoter, studied under identical conditions. The general reaction characteristics are similar for the human and yeast proteins, although the details differ and the hTBPwt-induced bend is more severe. This directly measured hTBPwt-DNAAdMLP interaction differs fundamentally from a recently published hTBPwt-DNAAdMLP model characterized by low affinity (microM) binding and an unstable complex requiring either a 30-min isomerization or TFIIB to achieve DNA bending. Possible sources of these significant differences are discussed.