Tandem use of immunofluorescent and DNA staining assays to validate nested PCR detection of mycoplasma

Mycoplasma contamination in cell culture is a serious setback to cell culturists across the world with a very high rate of reported occurrence particularly because of difficult early detection. Out of a variety of detection methods known, the double-step nested polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based detection of mycoplasma in cell culture has been critically viewed upon because of chances of producing reliable results. A nested PCR technique, described to detect a large range of cell-culture-contaminating mycoplasma species, with greater sensitivity to detect as low a contamination as a few organisms, was compared with the results from two cytological techniques employed in tandem. These are DNA staining using Hoechst, the gold standard, and an immunofluorescent assay using a highly specific monoclonal antibody. The study undertaken on randomly collected cell cultures revealed a false-negative and several false-positive results in comparison to the cytological methods employed. The observations were particularly more unambiguous with the immunofluorescent assay employed in the study while simultaneously employed Hoechst staining serving as an indicator of bacterial contamination. There is a general apprehension that genus-specific PCR approaches could be associated with inaccurate outcome and only species-specific PCRs may be satisfactory in routine screening for mycoplasma contamination in cell cultures. At this juncture, it may be suggested that caution must be exercised while adopting the two-step nested PCR-based detection approaches, and the simultaneous employment of cytological methods used in this investigation could prove to be practicable in the proper interpretation of results.     

Mycoplasma contamination of cell cultures: Incidence, sources, effects, detection, elimination, prevention

The contamination of cell cultures by mycoplasmas remains a major problem in cell culture. Mycoplasmas can produce a virtually unlimited variety of effects in the cultures they infect. These organisms are resistant to most antibiotics commonly employed in cell cultures. Here we provide a concise overview of the current knowledge on: (1) the incidence and sources of mycoplasma contamination in cell cultures, the mycoplasma species most commonly detected in cell cultures, and the effects of mycoplasmas on the function and activities of infected cell cultures; (2) the various techniques available for the detection of mycoplasmas with particular emphasis on the most reliable detection methods; (3) the various methods available for the elimination of mycoplasmas highlighting antibiotic treatment; and (4) the recommended procedures and working protocols for the detection, elimination and prevention of mycoplasma contamination. The availability of accurate, sensitive and reliable detection methods and the application of robust and successful elimination methods provide powerful means for overcoming the problem of mycoplasma contamination in cell cultures. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Cross comparison of rapid mycoplasma detection platforms

The use of animal and plant derived raw materials in mammalian cell culture processes may provide a possible route of entry for adventitious contaminants such as mycoplasma. Mycoplasma contaminations of cell culture represent a serious challenge to the production of biotechnology derived therapeutics. The slow growing nature of mycoplasma can disguise their infection of cultures since cells may continue to proliferate, though at reduced levels and with lesser output of engineered protein. Rapid identification of mycoplasma contaminated cell cultures and materials enables a faster response time to prevent the spread of the contamination. We describe here the comparison of different mycoplasma detection methods: two nucleic acid-based technologies, the standard mycoplasma culture procedure, and a hybrid culture-quantitative PCR assay. In this study, a cell line infected with two species of mycoplasma was used to compare the different detection methods. Our data demonstrates that the two nucleic acid-based techniques are robust methods for detection of mycoplasma and have similar detection capability. In contrast, no mycoplasma was detected in the standard culture assay or in a hybrid culture-quantitative PCR assay. This shows a potential limitation of the culture assay that relies on the ability of mycoplasma to grow in broth media.     

The Effects of Mycoplasma Contamination upon the Ability to Form Bioengineered 3D Kidney Cysts

Mycoplasma contamination of cell cultures is a pervasive, often undiagnosed and ignored problem in many laboratories that can result in reduced cell proliferation and changes in gene expression. Unless contamination is specifically suspected, it is often undetected in two dimensional (2D) cultures and the resulting effects of mycoplasma contamination are rarely appreciated and can lead to incorrect conclusions. Three dimensional (3D) tissue cultures are increasingly utilized to explore tissue development and phenotype. However, 3D cultures are more complex than 2D cell cultures and require a more controlled cellular environment in order to generate structures necessary to mimic in vivo responses and are often maintained for longer time periods. Changes to the microenvironment are assumed to have a more extreme effect upon the success of 3D tissue cultures than 2D cell cultures, but the effects of mycoplasma have not been studied. To test this hypothesis, we grew 2D cell cultures and 3D tissues from pig kidney epithelial cells (LLC-PK1) that were contaminated with mycoplasma and the same stock of cells after mycoplasma removal. We did not observe an effect of mycoplasma contamination on proliferation in 2D monolayer cell culture. However, cyst formation in 3D tissues was altered, with effects upon the number, size and structure of cysts formed. These data serve to reinforce the necessity of testing cell stocks for mycoplasma contamination.     

Real-time PCR assay is superior to other methods for the detection of mycoplasma contamination in the cell lines of the National Cell Bank of Iran

Mycoplasmas are the most important contaminants of cell cultures throughout the world. They are considered as a major problem in biological studies and biopharmaceutical economic issues. In this study, our aim was to find the best standard technique as a rapid method with high sensitivity, specificity and accuracy for the detection of mycoplasma contamination in the cell lines of the National Cell Bank of Iran. Thirty cell lines suspected to mycoplasma contamination were evaluated by five different techniques including microbial culture, indirect DNA DAPI staining, enzymatic mycoalert^® assay, conventional PCR and real-time PCR. Five mycoplasma-contaminated cell lines were assigned as positive controls and five mycoplasma-free cell lines as negative controls. The enzymatic method was performed using the mycoalert^® mycoplasma detection kit. Real-time PCR technique was conducted by PromoKine diagnostic kits. In the conventional PCR method, mycoplasma genus-specific primers were designed to analyze the sequences based on a fixed and common region on 16S ribosomal RNA with PCR product size of 425 bp. Mycoplasma contamination was observed in 60, 56.66, 53.33, 46.66 and 33.33 % of 30 different cell cultures by real-time PCR, PCR, enzymatic mycoalert^®, indirect DNA DAPI staining and microbial culture methods, respectively. The analysis of the results of the different methods showed that the real-time PCR assay was superior the other methods with the sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, predictive value of positive and negative results of 100 %. These values were 94.44, 100, 96.77, 100 and 92.85 % for the conventional PCR method, respectively. Therefore, this study showed that real-time PCR and PCR assays based on the common sequences in the 16S ribosomal RNA are reliable methods with high sensitivity, specificity and accuracy for detection of mycoplasma contamination in cell cultures and other biological products.     

Sensitivity of biochemical test in comparison with other methods for the detection of mycoplasma contamination in human and animal cell lines stored in the National Cell Bank of Iran

Mycoplasma contamination in cell culture is considered as serious problem in the manufacturing of biological products. Our goal in this research is to find the best standard and rapid method with high sensitivity, specificity, accuracy and predictive values of positive and negative results for detection of mycoplasma contamination in cell cultures of the National Cell Bank of Iran. In this study, 40 cell lines suspected to mycoplasma contamination were evaluated by three different methods: microbial culture, enzymatic mycoalert^® and molecular. Enzymatic evaluation was performed using the mycoalert^® kit while in the molecular technique, a universal primer pair was designed based on the common and fixed 16SrRNA ribosomal sequences used. Mycoplasma contaminations in cell cultures with molecular, enzymatic and microbial culture methods were determined as 57.5, 52.5 and 40 %, respectively. These results confirmed the higher rate of sensitivity, specificity and accuracy for the molecular method in comparison with enzymatic and microbial methods. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay based on fixed and common sequences in the 16SrRNA, is a useful valuable and reliable technique with high sensitivity, specificity and accuracy for detection of mycoplasma contamination in cell cultures and other biological products. The enzymatic mycoalert^® method can be considered as a substitution for conventional microbial culture and DNA staining fluorochrome methods due to its higher sensitivity, specificity and speed of detection (<20 min).     

The scope of mycoplasma contamination within the biopharmaceutical industry

Mycoplasma is well recognized as one of the most prevalent and serious microbial contaminants encountered within the manufacturing of biopharmaceuticals from the research phase to clinical development and production. The potential for mycoplasma contamination within cell culture systems was first identified by Robinson et al. in 1956 [1]. Presently, contamination rates in established cell cultures have been reported between 15 and 35% with considerably higher occurrence cited in certain selected populations [2]. In the last few years, there has been an expansion of diagnostic approaches for mycoplasma detection with the development and validation of rapid microbiological methods. The objective of this study was to determine current levels of mycoplasma infection of cell cultures, cell substrates and biologicals within a client based population. Retrospective comparison of 40,000 sample results was done to determine total contaminations rates amongst four (4) individual analytical assays. The establishment of reference data, such as existing contamination rates, becomes important in the critical appraisal of rapid microbiological methods for the detection of mycoplasma.     

Detection of mycoplasma contamination in cell cultures by a mycoplasma group-specific PCR.

The suitability of a 16S rRNA-based mycoplasma group-specific PCR for the detection of mycoplasma contamination in cell cultures was investigated. A total of 104 cell cultures were tested by using microbiological culture, DNA fluorochrome staining, DNA-rRNA hybridization, and PCR techniques. A comparison of the results obtained with these techniques revealed agreement for 95 cell cultures. Discrepant results, which were interpreted as false negative or false positive on the basis of a comparison with the results obtained with other methods, were observed with nine cell cultures. The microbiological culture technique produced false-negative results for four cell cultures. The hybridization technique produced false-negative results for two cell cultures, and for one of these cell cultures the DNA staining technique also produced a false-negative result. The PCR may have produced false-positive results for one cell culture. Ambiguous results were obtained with the remaining two cell cultures. Furthermore, the presence of contaminating bacteria interfered with the interpretation of the DNA staining results for 16 cell cultures. For the same reason the hybridization signals of nine cell cultures could not be interpreted. Our results demonstrate the drawbacks of each of the detection methods and the suitability of the PCR for the detection of mycoplasmas in cell cultures.     

一种快速判定细胞培养中支原体污染的方法——瓜氨酸测定法

目的：开发一种简便、快速、能及时发现细胞培养中支原体污染的方法。方法：用HPLC检测细胞培养中瓜氨酸是否存在及其量的大小。结果：当细胞培养被支原体污染时,培养基中精氨酸量明显下降,同时有瓜氨酸出现;当支原体被消除后,瓜氨酸即消失。结论：在细胞培养中瓜氨酸的出现与支原体污染的关系是特异的,用HPLC在2h内即可检出,表明该方法可靠、简便、快速,可作为细胞培养过程中支原体污染的常规监测手段。     

Detection of mycoplasma contaminations in cell cultures by PCR analysis

Mycoplasma contamination is still one of the main problems in using cell cultures in biological and medical research and in the production of bioactive substances, because mycoplasma can alter nearly all parameters and products of the cell. They can persist undetected in the culture if no special detection methods are applied. In recent years, the PCR technology has become a commonly used method to analyze genomic DNA and the expression of genes, with both high specificity and sensitivity. This technique can be effectively employed for the detection and even the identification of mycoplasma contaminations in cell cultures applying primers complementary to the 16S rDNA region. Although this technique, once established, is characterized by simplicity and speed, PCR is still a complex process and its sensitivity and specificity can be influenced by a number of different parameters, e.g. inhibiting compounds originating from the preparation process of the DNA, RNA or cDNA, contamination of the solutions with PCR products, and the selection of a primer pair which does not cover all the mycoplasma species occurring in cell cultures. Thus, adequate controls have to be included to obtain reliable results. The present review examines the use of different primers of the 16S rDNA region including their specificity, the sensitivity applying various DNA or RNA preparation procedures, and the methods to detect finally the amplicons. In conclusion, basic nucleic acid preparation and PCR product detection methods offer a simple, fast and reliable technique for the examination of mycoplasma contaminations in cell cultures, provided that the indispensable control assays are implemented.     

Prolonged hyperthermia eliminates mycoplasma from cultured human and rat brain tumor cell lines

Mycoplasma infection of mammalian cells in culture is a common occurrence that can affect the results of experimental protocols. Current methods of eliminating mycoplasma from cell cultures are usually tedious, time-consuming, and sometimes unsuccessful. In the present study, four cultured brain tumor cell lines (human U-251 MG, U-87 MG, SF-126, and rat 9L) were heavily contaminated with Mycoplasma orale. Heating the cultures to 41 degrees C for at least 96 h eliminated the contamination for up to 7 months, the maximum period of observation. The time chosen to assay for the presence of mycoplasma in cultures was critical: in some cultures heated for less than 96 h that initially appeared to be free of contamination, mycoplasma began to appear after 2 weeks. Heat-treated cells grew at the same rate as unheated control cells. Infected cells were more sensitive to X rays than uncontaminated cells, but the sensitivity reverted to normal after mycoplasma was eliminated by hyperthermia. The heating method does not require a cell cloning procedure or the use of exogenous materials. Treated cell cultures exhibit normal growth and radiation sensitivity, and the technique seems to be reliable and efficient.     

Impacts of intentional mycoplasma contamination on CHO cell bioreactor cultures

Mycoplasma contamination events in biomanufacturing facilities can result in loss of production and costly cleanups. Mycoplasma may survive in mammalian cell cultures with only subtle changes to the culture and may penetrate the 0.2 µm filters often used in the primary clarification of harvested cell culture fluid. Culture cell-based and indicator cell-based assays that are used to detect mycoplasma are highly sensitive but can take up to 28 days to complete and cannot be used for real-time decision making during the biomanufacturing process. To support real-time measurements of mycoplasma contamination, there is a push to explore nucleic acid testing. However, cell-based methods measure growth or colony forming units and nucleic acid testing measures genome copy number; this has led to ambiguity regarding how to compare the sensitivity of the methods. In addition, the high risk of conducting experiments wherein one deliberately spikes mycoplasma into bioreactors has dissuaded commercial groups from performing studies to explore the multiple variables associated with the upstream effects of a mycoplasma contamination in a manufacturing setting. Here we studied the ability of Mycoplasma arginini to persist in a single-use, perfusion rocking bioreactor system containing a Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) DG44 cell line expressing a model monoclonal immunoglobulin G1 (IgG1) antibody. We examined M. arginini growth and detection by culture methods, as well as the effects of M. arginini on mammalian cell health, metabolism, and productivity. We compared process parameters and controls normally measured in bioreactors including dissolved oxygen, gas mix, and base addition to maintain pH, to examine parameter changes as potential indicators of contamination. Our work showed that M. arginini affects CHO cell growth profile, viability, nutrient consumption, oxygen use, and waste production at varying timepoints after M. arginini introduction to the culture. Importantly, how the M. arginini contamination impacts the CHO cells is influenced by the concentration of CHO cells and rate of perfusion at the time of M. arginini spike. Careful evaluation of dissolved oxygen, pH control parameters, ammonia, and arginine over time may be used to indicate mycoplasma contamination in CHO cell cultures in a bioreactor before a read-out from a traditional method.     

Development of a PCR method for mycoplasma testing of Chinese hamster ovary cell cultures used in the manufacture of recombinant therapeutic proteins

Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell cultures used to produce biopharmaceuticals are tested for mycoplasma contamination as part of the ensurance of a safe and pure product. The current U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulatory guideline recommends using two procedures: broth/agar cultures and DNA staining of indicator cell cultures. Although these culture methods are relatively sensitive to most species, theoretically capable of detecting as few as 1-10 cfu/ml of most species, the overall procedure is lengthy (28 d), costly and less sensitive to noncultivable species. The detection of mycoplasma using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) method has been considered an alternative method because it is relatively fast (1-2 d), inexpensive, and independent of culture conditions, however, limitations in sensitivity (limit of detection >/=1000 cfu/ml) and the risk of false positive and false negative results have prevented PCR from replacing the traditional culture methods in the industrial setting. In this report, we describe a new PCR assay for mycoplasma detection that appears to resolve these issues while being sufficiently simple and inexpensive for routine use. This assay applies readily available techniques in DNA extraction together with a modified single-step PCR using a previously characterized primer pair that is homologous to a broad spectrum of mycoplasma species known to infect mammalian cell cultures. Analysis is made easy by the detection of only a single amplification product within a narrow size range, 438-470 bp. A high sensitivity and specificity for mycoplasma detection in CHO cell production cultures is made possible through the combination of three key techniques: 8-methoxypsoralen and UV light treatment to decontaminate PCR reagents of DNA; hot-start Taq DNA polymerase to reduce nonspecific priming events; and touchdown- (TD-) PCR to increase sensitivity while also reducing nonspecific priming events. In extracts of mycoplasma DNA, the limit of detection for eight different mycoplasma species is 10 genomic copies. In CHO cell production cultures containing gentamicin, the limit of detection for a model organism, gentamicin-resistant M. hyorhinis, is 1 cfu/ml. The sensitivity and specificity of this PCR assay for mycoplasma detection in CHO cell production cultures appear similar to the currently used culture methods and thus should be considered as an alternative method by the biopharmaceutical industry.     

Comparative antibiotic eradication of mycoplasma infections from continuous cell lines

Accumulating data implicate mycoplasma contamination as the single biggest problem in the culture of continuous cell lines. Mycoplasma infection can affect virtually every parameter and functional activity of the eukaryotic cells. A successful alternative to discarding infected cultures is to attempt to eliminate the contaminants by treatment with specific and efficient antimycoplasma antibiotics. The addition of antibiotics to the culture medium during a limited period of time (1-3 wk) is a simple, inexpensive, and very practical approach for decontaminating continuous cell lines. Here, we examined the effectiveness of several antibiotic treatment protocols that we have employed routinely in our cell lines bank. On an aggregate, 673 cultures from 236 chronically mycoplasma-positive cell lines were exposed to one of the following five antibiotic regimens: mycoplasma removal agent (quinolone; a 1-wk treatment), enrofloxacin (quinolone; 1 wk), sparfloxacin (quinolone; 1 wk), ciprofloxacin (quinolone; 2 wk), and BM-Cyclin (alternating tiamulin and minocycline; 3 wk). The mycoplasma infection was permanently (as determined by three solid mycoplasma detection assays) eliminated by the various antibiotics in 66-85% of the cultures treated. Mycoplasma resistance was seen in 7-21%, and loss of the culture as a result of cytotoxically caused cell death occurred in 3-11% of the cultures treated. Overall, 223 of the 236 mycoplasma-positive cell lines could be cured in a first round of antibiotic treatment with at least one regimen. Taken together, 95% of the mycoplasma-infected cell lines were permanently cleansed of the contaminants by antibiotic treatment, which validates this approach as an efficient and technically simple mycoplasma eradication method.     

Assessing the prevalence of mycoplasma contamination in cell culture via a survey of NCBI's RNA-seq archive

Mycoplasmas are notorious contaminants of cell culture and can have profound effects on host cell biology by depriving cells of nutrients and inducing global changes in gene expression. Over the last two decades, sentinel testing has revealed wide-ranging contamination rates in mammalian culture. To obtain an unbiased assessment from hundreds of labs, we analyzed sequence data from 9395 rodent and primate samples from 884 series in the NCBI Sequence Read Archive. We found 11% of these series were contaminated (defined as ≥100 reads/million mapping to mycoplasma in one or more samples). Ninety percent of mycoplasma-mapped reads aligned to ribosomal RNA. This was unexpected given 37% of contaminated series used poly(A)-selection for mRNA enrichment. Lastly, we examined the relationship between mycoplasma contamination and host gene expression in a single cell RNA-seq dataset and found 61 host genes (P < 0.001) were significantly associated with mycoplasma-mapped read counts. In all, this study suggests mycoplasma contamination is still prevalent today and poses substantial risk to research quality.     

Prevention of mycoplasma contamination in leukemia-lymphoma cell lines.

The contamination of cell lines with mycoplasmas is certainly one of the major problems occurring in cultured cells. Analyzing more than 460 human leukemia-lymphoma (LL) cell lines, we found that 28% of the cultures were mycoplasma-positive. Mycoplasmas can produce extensive changes, growth arrest and cell death in the infected cultures. While mycoplasma-infected cell lines can be truly cleansed from the contaminants, all the efforts would be in vain when the cells return to a mycoplasma-infested environment or are handled with unsuitable culture practices. Hence, the main focus of mycoplasma control should be on preventing cell culture contamination. Mycoplasmas can be introduced through several routes including culture reagents and laboratory personnel. Cross-contamination from infected cell cultures within one laboratory continues to be the major source for the spread of mycoplasma. Specific technical protocols and cell culturing guidelines may be followed in order to minimize the risk of mycoplasma contamination of cell lines. This "good culture practice" is of utmost importance as faulty cell culture techniques appear to be also the main reason for the high incidence of cross-contaminated LL cell lines which according to our experience using DNA fingerprinting of some 500 LL cell lines is about 15%.     

Rapid detection of mycoplasma contamination in cell cultures using sybr green-based real-time polymerase chain reaction

Summary We have developed a simple method for rapid detection of mycoplasma contamination in cell cultures using SYBR Green-based real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR). To detect eight common contaminant mollicutes, including Mycoplasma (M. arginini, M. fermentans, M. orale, M. hyorhinis, M. hominis, M. salivarium, M. pirum) and Acholeplasma laidlawii, four primers were prepared based on the 23S rRNA regions. Using these primers and a minimum of 100 fg of mycoplasma genomic DNA, the 23S rRNA regions of these eight mycoplasma species were consistently amplified by real-time PCR. In contrast, no specific specific amplification product was observed using DNA templates prepared from various mammalian cell lines. Frozen and cultured samples of several cell lines were tested for mycoplasma contamination to evaluated the utility of this method. Of 25 samples that tested positive for mycoplasma by Hoechst staining, which requires two passages of cell cultures started from frozen samples, mycoplasma was detected by real-time PCR in 24 samples of cell extracts prepared directly from frozen samples. When cultured samples were used for this assay, the accuracy of the diagnoses was further improved. Thus, this technique, which is simple, rapid, and sensitive enough for practical application, in suitable for handling many samples and for routine screening for mycoplasma contamination of cell cultures.     

Efficiency of Plasmocin™ on various mammalian cell lines infected by mollicutes in comparison with commonly used antibiotics in cell culture: a local experience

Mycoplasma contamination is a deleterious event for cell culture laboratories. Plasmocin™ is used to prevent and eradicate mycoplasma infections from cell. In this study, 80 different mammalian cell lines from various sources; human, monkey, mice, hamster and rat were used to study and evaluate plasmocin™ efficiency and compare it to commonly used antibiotics such as BM-cyclin, ciprofloxacin and mycoplasma removal agent (MRA). It was shown that mycoplasma infections were eradicated by plasmocin™, BM-cyclin, ciprofloxacin and MRA in 65%, 66.25%, 20%, and 31.25%, respectively, of infected cell cultures. However, re-infection with mycoplasmas after the period of 4 months occurred in 10–80% of the studied cell lines. Cell cytotoxicity and culture death was observed in 25, 17.5 and 10% of the treated cells, for plasmocin™, BM-cyclin and MRA, respectively. In this study, Plasmocin™ showed strong ability to eradicate mollicutes from our cell lines with minimal percentage of regrowth. However, due to its high cell cytotoxicity it should be used with caution especially when dealing with expensive or hard-to-obtain cell lines. Amongst the antibiotics tested, BM-cyclin was shown to remove mycoplasma with the highest efficiency.     

Elimination of mycoplasmas from cell cultures utilizing hyperimmune sera

Eighteen cell lines contaminated with various mycoplasmas have been treated with hyperimmune sera and mycoplasmas have been eradicated from all. After treatment the cell lines have been observed for a least one year and they are still free from mycoplasma contamination as ascertained by four independent mycoplasma detection assays. The hyperimmune sera used were of high titer, type-specific and growth-inhibiting. These sera were produced by immunization of rabbits with purified membranes from Mycoplasma orale, M. arginini, M. hominis, M. fermentans, M. hyorhinis and Acholeplasma laidlawii. In addition to elimination of mycoplasmas from cell cultures we have successfully used these sera for detection and typing of mycoplasma contamination in cell cultures.     

Rapid detection by transmission electron microscopy of mycoplasma contamination in sera and cell cultures

Transmission electron microscopy has been employed for the rapid detection of mycoplasma in sera and cell cultures. High speed centrifugation of sera or low speed centrifugation of cell debris, followed by negative staining of the resuspended pellet, detected mycoplasma contamination more frequently than a culture method followed by direct fluorescence (DAPI), which was used as a control procedure. The appearance of the mycoplasma cell border and content gives some information about particle viability.