A new functional classification of tumor-suppressing genes and its therapeutic implications

Cell fusion studies have demonstrated that malignancy can be suppressed by a single dose of malignancy suppressor genes (MSGs), indicating that malignancy is a recessive phenotype. Correspondingly, it is widely believed that mutational inactivation of both alleles of tumor suppressor genes (TSGs), in familial and sporadic tumors, is the formal proof of the recessive nature of malignancy. Evidence presented here, however, shows that unlike MSGs, identified solely through cell fusion studies with no gene of this class yet cloned, many well-known TSGs have gene dosage effects and inhibit cellular growth in vitro. Moreover, homozygous inactivation of a growth-inhibitory TSG (GITSG) is not directly correlated with malignancy. An alternative interpretation is provided for the loss of wild-type alleles of these genes in the tumors. It is concluded that the MSGs and the GITSGs do not belong to the same class of genes. The functional classification of tumor-suppressing genes has important implications for developing effective cancer therapies.     

Convergence of mutation and epigenetic alterations identifies common genes in cancer that predict for poor prognosis

Background

The identification and characterization of tumor suppressor genes has enhanced our understanding of the biology of cancer and enabled the development of new diagnostic and therapeutic modalities. Whereas in past decades, a handful of tumor suppressors have been slowly identified using techniques such as linkage analysis, large-scale sequencing of the cancer genome has enabled the rapid identification of a large number of genes that are mutated in cancer. However, determining which of these many genes play key roles in cancer development has proven challenging. Specifically, recent sequencing of human breast and colon cancers has revealed a large number of somatic gene mutations, but virtually all are heterozygous, occur at low frequency, and are tumor-type specific. We hypothesize that key tumor suppressor genes in cancer may be subject to mutation or hypermethylation.

Methods and Findings

Here, we show that combined genetic and epigenetic analysis of these genes reveals many with a higher putative tumor suppressor status than would otherwise be appreciated. At least 36 of the 189 genes newly recognized to be mutated are targets of promoter CpG island hypermethylation, often in both colon and breast cancer cell lines. Analyses of primary tumors show that 18 of these genes are hypermethylated strictly in primary cancers and often with an incidence that is much higher than for the mutations and which is not restricted to a single tumor-type. In the identical breast cancer cell lines in which the mutations were identified, hypermethylation is usually, but not always, mutually exclusive from genetic changes for a given tumor, and there is a high incidence of concomitant loss of expression. Sixteen out of 18 (89%) of these genes map to loci deleted in human cancers. Lastly, and most importantly, the reduced expression of a subset of these genes strongly correlates with poor clinical outcome.

Conclusions

Using an unbiased genome-wide approach, our analysis has enabled the discovery of a number of clinically significant genes targeted by multiple modes of inactivation in breast and colon cancer. Importantly, we demonstrate that a subset of these genes predict strongly for poor clinical outcome. Our data define a set of genes that are targeted by both genetic and epigenetic events, predict for clinical prognosis, and are likely fundamentally important for cancer initiation or progression.     

Retention of wild-type p53 in tumors from p53 heterozygous mice: reduction of p53 dosage can promote cancer formation.

Tumor suppressor genes are generally viewed as being recessive at the cellular level, so that mutation or loss of both tumor suppressor alleles is a prerequisite for tumor formation. The tumor suppressor gene, p53, is mutated in approximately 50% of human sporadic cancers and in an inherited cancer predisposition (Li-Fraumeni syndrome). We have analyzed the status of the wild-type p53 allele in tumors taken from p53-deficient heterozygous (p53+/-) mice. These mice inherit a single null p53 allele and develop tumors much earlier than those mice with two functional copies of wild-type p53. We present evidence that a high proportion of the tumors from the p53+/- mice retain an intact, functional, wild-type p53 allele. Unlike p53+/- tumors which lose their wild-type allele, the tumors which retain an intact p53 allele express p53 protein that induces apoptosis following gamma-irradiation, activates p21(WAF1/CIP1) and Mdm2 expression, represses PCNA expression (a negatively regulated target of wild-type p53), shows high levels of binding to oligonucleotides containing a wild-type p53 response element and prevents chromosomal instability as measured by comparative genomic hybridization. These results indicate that loss of both p53 alleles is not a prerequisite for tumor formation and that mere reduction in p53 levels may be sufficient to promote tumorigenesis.     

Effect of three suppressors on the expression of powdery mildew resistance genes in barley

Three recessive mutagen-induced alleles that partially suppress the phenotypic expression of the semidominant powdery mildew resistance gene Mla12 have been studied. When each suppressor is present in homozygous condition, the infection type 0, conferred by gene Mla12 when homozygous, is changed to intermediate infection types. The three suppressor lines were crossed with seven near-isogenic lines with different powdery mildew resistance genes and one, M100, was crossed with nine additional lines. Seedlings of parents and from the F1and F2 generations were tested with powdery mildew isolates that possessed the appropriate avirulence and virulence genes. The segregation of phenotypes in the F2 generation disclosed that the three suppressors affected the phenotypic expression of three resistance genes, whereas that of four resistance genes remained unaffected. The suppressor in mutant M100 affected the phenotypic expression of 9 of the 10 additional resistance genes present. It is suggested that the three suppressors are mutationally modified genes involved in host defence processes. This implies that different resistance genes employ different, but overlapping, spectra of defence processes, or signal transduction pathways. Key words : barley, Hordeum vulgare, powdery mildew, Erysiphe graminis hordei, mutation, resistance, suppressor.     

brca2 and tp53 Collaborate in Tumorigenesis in Zebrafish

Germline mutations in the tumor suppressor genes BRCA2 and TP53 significantly influence human cancer risk, and cancers from humans who inherit one mutant allele for BRCA2 or TP53 often display loss of the wildtype allele. In addition, BRCA2-associated cancers often exhibit mutations in TP53. To determine the relationship between germline heterozygous mutation (haploinsufficiency) and somatic loss of heterozygosity (LOH) for BRCA2 and TP53 in carcinogenesis, we analyzed zebrafish with heritable mutations in these two genes. Tumor-bearing zebrafish were examined by histology, and normal and neoplastic tissues were collected by laser-capture microdissection for LOH analyses. Zebrafish on a heterozygous tp53^M214K background had a high incidence of malignant tumors. The brca2^Q658X mutation status determined both the incidence of LOH and the malignant tumor phenotype. LOH for tp53 occurred in the majority of malignant tumors from brca2 wildtype and heterozygous mutant zebrafish, and most of these were malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors. Malignant tumors in zebrafish with heterozygous mutations in both brca2 and tp53 frequently displayed LOH for both genes. In contrast, LOH for tp53 was uncommon in malignant tumors from brca2 homozygotes, and these tumors were primarily undifferentiated sarcomas. Thus, carcinogenesis in zebrafish with combined mutations in tp53 and brca2 typically requires biallelic mutation or loss of at least one of these genes, and the specific combination of inherited mutations influences the development of LOH and the tumor phenotype. These results provide insight into cancer development associated with heritable BRCA2 and TP53 mutations.     

Antagonistic functional duality of cancer genes

Cancer evolution is a stochastic process both at the genome and gene levels. Most of tumors contain multiple genetic subclones, evolving in either succession or in parallel, either in a linear or branching manner, with heterogeneous genome and gene alterations, extensively rewired signaling networks, and addicted to multiple oncogenes easily switching with each other during cancer progression and medical intervention. Hundreds of discovered cancer genes are classified according to whether they function in a dominant (oncogenes) or recessive (tumor suppressor genes) manner in a cancer cell. However, there are many cancer “gene-chameleons”, which behave distinctly in opposite way in the different experimental settings showing antagonistic duality. In contrast to the widely accepted view that mutant NADP⁺-dependent isocitrate dehydrogenases 1/2 (IDH1/2) and associated metabolite 2-hydroxyglutarate (R)-enantiomer are intrinsically “the drivers” of tumourigenesis, mutant IDH1/2 inhibited, promoted or had no effect on cell proliferation, growth and tumorigenicity in diverse experiments. Similar behavior was evidenced for dozens of cancer genes. Gene function is dependent on genetic network, which is defined by the genome context. The overall changes in karyotype can result in alterations of the role and function of the same genes and pathways. The diverse cell lines and tumor samples have been used in experiments for proving gene tumor promoting/suppressive activity. They all display heterogeneous individual karyotypes and disturbed signaling networks. Consequently, the effect and function of gene under investigation can be opposite and versatile in cells with different genomes that may explain antagonistic duality of cancer genes and the cell type- or the cellular genetic/context-dependent response to the same protein. Antagonistic duality of cancer genes might contribute to failure of chemotherapy. Instructive examples of unexpected activity of cancer genes and “paradoxical” effects of different anticancer drugs depending on the cellular genetic context/signaling network are discussed.     

Promoters of genes MTHFR from patients with hyperhomocysteinemia and PTEN from patients with malignant and benign endometrial and ovarian tumors

Mutational changes in the promoter regions of MTHFR genes from patients with hyperhomocysteinemia and PTEN genes from patients with endometrial and ovarian tumors were studied. An increased level of homocysteine was found in a part of the patients with a heterozygous C677T mutation in the MTHFR gene, although a moderate hyperhomocysteinemia is usually associated with homozygous mutation. We hypothesized that, in this case, the allele lacking the C677T mutation may be inactivated by the promoter mutation. The sequencing of both DNA strands of the minimal promoter region of the MTHFR gene in ten patients did not reveal any mutation, which implied another mechanism of the development of hyperhomocysteinemia in these patients. A PCR analysis of the minimal promoter region of the tumor suppressor PTEN in the presence of 2-pyrrolidone in 101 patients from Moscow clinics revealed changes in it in patients with endometrial (56%) or ovarian (29%) cancer, as well as in patients with endometrial hyperplasia and benign ovarian tumors (34.6 and 29%, respectively). It was presumed that the found PTEN gene promoters may arise from epigenetic alterations (erroneous methylation) or may (more rarely) be induced by mutations. As a result of the studies, new molecular markers associated with endometrial and ovarian tumors were revealed and a simple and effective method of detection of these markers was developed.     

Expression of Wild-Type Rp1 Protein in Rp1 Knock-in Mice Rescues the Retinal Degeneration Phenotype

Mutations in the retinitis pigmentosa 1 (RP1) gene are a common cause of autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa (adRP), and have also been found to cause autosomal recessive RP (arRP) in a few families. The 33 dominant mutations and 6 recessive RP1 mutations identified to date are all nonsense or frameshift mutations, and almost exclusively (38 out of 39) are located in the 4(th) and final exon of RP1. To better understand the underlying disease mechanisms of and help develop therapeutic strategies for RP1 disease, we performed a series of human genetic and animal studies using gene targeted and transgenic mice. Here we report that a frameshift mutation in the 3(rd) exon of RP1 (c.686delC; p.P229QfsX35) found in a patient with recessive RP1 disease causes RP in the homozygous state, whereas the heterozygous carriers are unaffected, confirming that haploinsufficiency is not the causative mechanism for RP1 disease. We then generated Rp1 knock-in mice with a nonsense Q662X mutation in exon 4, as well as Rp1 transgenic mice carrying a wild-type BAC Rp1 transgene. The Rp1-Q662X allele produces a truncated Rp1 protein, and homozygous Rp1-Q662X mice experience a progressive photoreceptor degeneration characterized disorganization of photoreceptor outer segments. This phenotype could be prevented by expression of a normal amount of Rp1 protein from the BAC transgene without removal of the mutant Rp1-Q662X protein. Over-expression of Rp1 protein in additional BAC Rp1 transgenic lines resulted in retinal degeneration. These findings suggest that the truncated Rp1-Q662X protein does not exert a toxic gain-of-function effect. These results also imply that in principle gene augmentation therapy could be beneficial for both recessive and dominant RP1 patients, but the levels of RP1 protein delivered for therapy will have to be carefully controlled.     

Multiplex polymerase chain reaction amplification and direct sequencing of homologous sequences: point mutation analysis of the ras genes.

ras proto-oncogenes are activated by point mutation in a wide variety of human and animal tumors, making ras gene analysis a major area of clinical and basic cancer research. Activating point mutations, in each of the three ras genes (Ha-, Ki-, or N-ras), usually occur in one of three specific codons (12, 13, or 61). Thus, an adequate assessment of activating ras gene mutations should include the analysis of at least nine codons. We have developed a rapid method for point mutation analysis of the ras genes, which involves simultaneous (multiplex) PCR amplification of all three homologous ras genes (in the regions surrounding codons 12-13 and codon 61) in a single reaction starting with only 1 microgram of genomic DNA. Although multiplex PCR has been previously used for unrelated sequences, we demonstrate here that multiplex PCR can also be used for highly homologous sequences. Importantly, after coamplification, each of the homologous ras genes can be individually and specifically sequenced even though the other two closely related genes are present in the same template mixture, by using high-stringency conditions permitted by Taq DNA polymerase. An automated multicycle DNA sequencing procedure is used to allow the double-stranded PCR products to be sequenced directly without the need to generate single-stranded templates, further simplifying the protocol. Our multiplex PCR amplification and direct DNA sequencing procedures should greatly facilitate more complete analyses of activating ras gene point mutations, particularly in studies involving many tumor samples.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Promoters of genes MTHFR from patients with hyperhomocysteinemia and PTEN from patients with malignant and benign endometrial and ovarian tumors

Mutational changes in the promoter regions of MTHFR genes from patients with hyperhomocysteinemia and PTEN genes from patients with endometrial and ovarian tumors were studied. An increased level of homocysteine was found in a part of the patients with a heterozygous C677T mutation in the MTHFR gene, although a moderate hyperhomocysteinemia is usually associated with homozygous mutation. We hypothesized that, in this case, the allele lacking the C677T mutation may be inactivated by the promoter mutation. The sequencing of both DNA strands of the minimal promoter region of the MTHFR gene in ten patients did not reveal any mutation, which implied another mechanism of the development of hyperhomocysteinemia in these patients. A PCR analysis of the minimal promoter region of the tumor suppressor PTEN in the presence of 2-pyrrolidone in 101 patients from Moscow clinics revealed changes in it in patients with endometrial (56%) or ovarian (29%) cancer, as well as in patients with endometrial hyperplasia and benign ovarian tumors (34 and 29%, respectively). It was presumed that the found modification of PTEN gene promoters may arise from epigenetic alterations (erroneous methylation) or may (more rarely) be induced by mutations. As a result of the studies, new molecular markers associated with endometrial and ovarian tumors were revealed and a simple and effective method of detection of these markers was developed.     

Analysis of Tumor Suppressor Genes Using Transgenic Mice

Identification and analysis of tumor suppressor genes has relied chiefly upon studies of human sporadic tumors and of tumors harvested from familial cancer syndrome patients. One methodology that is proving to be extremely useful both in analyzing the function of these genes and in identifying new tumor suppressor genes involves the creation of transgenic mice that contain targeted mutations that functionally inactivate tumor suppressor genes. Studies using such mice have provided insight into the role of tumor suppressor genes in cell growth and in embryonic development. The creation of mice that harbor mutations in one or both alleles of a targeted gene has permitted anin vivoanalysis of the tumor suppressing properties of the gene and facilitated investigation of cell cycle control and differentiation of multiple cell lineages within the organism. Sophistication of gene targeting techniques will likely result in the creation of more lines of mice bearing genetic modifications in tumor suppressor genes, permitting an even finer detailed analysis of tumor suppressor gene functions.     

Mutations of 60 known causative genes in 157 families with retinitis pigmentosa based on exome sequencing

Retinitis pigmentosa (RP) is the most common and highly heterogeneous form of hereditary retinal degeneration. This study was to identify mutations in the 60 genes that were known to be associated with RP in 157 unrelated Chinese families with RP. Genomic DNA from probands was initially analyzed by whole exome sequencing. Sanger sequencing was used to confirm potential candidate variants affecting the encoded residues in the 60 genes, including heterozygous variants from genes that are related to autosomal dominant RP, homozygous or compound heterozygous variants from genes that are related to autosomal recessive RP, and hemizygous variants from genes that are related to X-linked RP. Synonymous and intronic variants were also examined to confirm whether they could affect splicing. A total of 244 candidate variants were detected by exome sequencing. Sanger sequencing confirmed 240 variants out of the 244 candidates. Informatics and segregation analyses suggested 110 potential pathogenic mutations in 28 out of the 60 genes involving 79 of the 157 (50 %) families, including 31 (39 %, 31/79) families with heterozygous mutations in autosomal dominant genes, 37 (47 %, 37/79) families with homozygous (9) or compound heterozygous (28) mutations in autosomal recessive genes, and 11 (14 %, 11/79) families with hemizygous mutations in X-linked genes. Of the 110 identified variants, 74 (67 %) were novel. The genetic defects in approximately half of the 157 studies families were detected by exome sequencing. A comprehensive analysis of the 60 known genes not only expanded the mutation spectrum and frequency of the 60 genes in Chinese patients with RP, but also provided an overview of the molecular etiology of RP in Chinese patients. The analysis of the known genes also supplied the foundation and clues for discovering novel causative RP genes.