The potential of glycerol in freezing preservation of turbine oil-degrading bacterial consortium and the ability of the revised consortium to degrade petroleum wastes

The turbine oil (TuO)-degrading bacterial consortium Tank-2 (original Tank-2) was preserved as a glycerol stock at −80 °C from 2009 to 2012. Storage methods have been unavailable so far for any TuO-degrading bacterial consortia or isolates. To evaluate the usefulness of glycerol stock, the original Tank-2 consortium frozen in glycerol at −80 °C was thawed and then revived by repeated culture in mineral salts medium (MSM) containing 0.5% (w/w) TuO (revived Tank-2). The revived Tank-2 consortium exhibited a high activity to degrade TuO, which was equivalent to that of original Tank-2. It also degraded car engine oil, used car engine oil, Arabian light and Vityaz crude oils and TuO in wastewater. These results indicated that a glycerol stock at −80 °C was useful for storing Tank-2. PCR-denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) that targeted the V3 regions of 16S rRNA gene sequences showed that the DGGE band profiles of principal bacteria were significantly different between the original and revived Tank-2 consortia and between the revived Tank-2 culture grown in MSM containing TuO and that grown in MSM containing other types of petroleum products. This suggested that bacterial strains inherently residing in Tank-2 could adjust their compositions based on the storage and culture conditions.     

Degradation of Nickel Protoporphyrin Disodium and Vanadium Oxide Octaethylporphyrin by Philippine Microbial Consortia

Microbial degradation of nickel and vanadium porphyrins is an economically important and environment-friendly alternative to physicochemical processes currently used in refining crude oil. This study involved the screening of 23 microbial isolates from crude oil–contaminated soils in the Philippines. Two microbial consortia concocted out of four bacteria and three fungi from Guimaras Island Province degraded significantly higher amounts of nickel protoporphyrin disodium (NiPPDS) and vanadium oxide octaethyl porphyrin (VOOEP) than their corresponding member components. Culture parameters were varied and then optimized by the Taguchi method in assays in minimal salt medium supplemented with metalloporphyrins. Optimal degradations by consortium GI-2,3 (Bacterium megaterium–Enterobacter cloacae) were 79 ± 1.5% for NiPPDS at 40 mg/L, pH 7, 30°C and 89 ± 1.7% for VOOEP at 20 mg/L, pH 6, 30°C. For consortium As-2,P (Aspergillus unguis–Penicillium griseofulvum), optimal degradations w`ere 71 ± 1.3% for NiPPDS at 20 mg/L, pH 5.5, 30°C and 90 ± 2.8% for VOOEP at 20 mg/L, pH 4.5, 40°C.     

Simultaneous hydrocarbon biodegradation and biosurfactant production by oilfield-selected bacteria

Aims: To study the bacterial diversity associated with hydrocarbon biodegradation potentiality and biosurfactant production of Tunisian oilfields bacteria. Methods and Results: Eight Tunisian hydrocarbonoclastic oilfields bacteria have been isolated and selected for further characterization studies. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that three thermophilic strains belonged to the genera Geobacillus, Bacillus and Brevibacillus, and that five mesophilic strains belonged to the genera Pseudomonas, Lysinibacillus, Achromobacter and Halomonas. The bacterial strains were cultivated on crude oil as sole carbon and energy sources, in the presence of different NaCl concentrations (1, 5 and 10%, w/v), and at 37 or 55°C. The hydrocarbon biodegradation potential of each strain was quantified by GC–MS. Strain C450R, phylogenetically related to the species Pseudomonas aeruginosa, showed the maximum crude oil degradation potentiality. During the growth of strain C450R on crude oil (2%, v/v), the emulsifying activity (E24) and glycoside content increased and reached values of 77 and 1·33 g l^?1, respectively. In addition, the surface tension (ST) decreased from 68 to 35·1 mN m^?1, suggesting the production of a rhamnolipid biosurfactant. Crude biosurfactant had been partially purified and characterized. It showed interest stability against temperature and salinity increasing and important emulsifying activity against oils and hydrocarbons. Conclusions: The results of this study showed the presence of diverse aerobic bacteria in Tunisian oilfields including mesophilic, thermophilic and halotolerant strains with interesting aliphatic hydrocarbon degradation potentiality, mainly for the most biosurfactant produced strains. Significance and Impact of the Study: It may be suggested that the bacterial isolates are suitable candidates for practical field application for effective in situ bioremediation of hydrocarbon‐contaminated sites.     

Oil Palm Empty Fruit Bunch and Sugarcane Bagasse Enhance the Bioremediation of Soil Artificially Polluted by Crude Oil

Contamination of soil by petroleum hydrocarbons is becoming prevalent in Malaysia. Infiltration of soil contamination into groundwater poses a great threat to the ecosystem and human health. Bioremediation can occur naturally or can be enhanced with supplementation of microorganisms and fertilizers. However, fertilizers are expensive and therefore alternative nutrient-rich biomaterials are required. In this study, two organic wastes from agricultural industry (i.e., sugarcane bagasse and oil palm empty fruit bunch) were investigated for possible enhanced bioremediation of soil contaminated with Tapis crude oil. Two bacterial strains isolated and characterized previously (i.e., Pseudomonas aeruginosa UKMP-14T and Acinetobacter baumannii UKMP-12T) were used in this study. Sugarcane bagasse (5% and 15%, w/w) and oil palm empty fruit bunch (20%, w/w) were mixed with soil (500 g) spiked with Tapis crude oil (3%, v/w). The treated soils as well as controls were incubated for 20 days under controlled conditions. Sampling was carried out every four days to measure the number of bacterial colonies (CFU/g) and to determine the percentage of oil degradation by gas chromatography. The two biostimulating agents were able to maintain the soil moisture holding capacity, pH, and temperature at 38-40% volumetric moisture content (VMC), 7.0, and 29–30°C; respectively. The growth of bacteria consortium after 20 days in the treatment with sugarcane bagasse and oil palm empty fruit bunch had increased to 10.3 CFU/g and 9.5 CFU/g, respectively. The percentage of hydrocarbon degradation was higher in the soil amended with sugarcane bagasse (100%) when compared to that of oil palm empty fruit bunch (97%) after 20 days. Our results demonstrated the potential of sugarcane bagasse and oil palm empty fruit bunch as good substrates for enhanced bioremediation of soil contaminated with petroleum crude oil.     

Biodegradation of chlorpyrifos by bacterial consortium isolated from agriculture soil

Organophosphorous pesticides are widely used in agriculture to control major insect pests. Chlorpyrifos is one of the major organophosphorous pesticides which is used to control insects including termites, beetles. The widespread use of these pesticides is hazardous to the environment and also toxic to mammals, thus it is essential to remove the same from the environment. From the chlorpyrifos contaminated soil nine morphologically different bacterial strains, one actinomycete and two fungal strains were isolated. Among those isolates four bacterial strains which were more efficient were developed as consortium. The four bacterial isolates namely Pseudomonas putida (NII 1117), Klebsiella sp., (NII 1118), Pseudomonas stutzeri (NII 1119), Pseudomonas aeruginosa (NII 1120) present in the consortia were identified on the basis of 16S rDNA analysis. The intracellular fractions of the consortium exhibited more organophosphorus hydrolase activity (0.171 ± 0.003 U/mL/min). The degradation studies were carried out at neutral pH and temperature 37°C with chlorpyrifos concentration 500 mg L⁻¹. LC-mass spectral analysis showed the presence of metabolites chlopyrifos-oxon and Diethylphosphorothioate. These results highlight an important potential use of this consortium for the cleanup of chlorpyrifos contaminated pesticide waste in the environment.     

一株可乳化降解原油的Compostibacillus的分离及特性

【背景】通过实施多轮次微生物采油,华北油藏产出液菌浓达到了106个/mL以上,油藏内部已经形成了较稳定的微生物发酵场,从其中筛选出能够乳化降解原油的微生物,并在地面对其进行扩大培养,然后再应用到微驱油藏,以进一步提高微生物采油实施效果。【目的】筛选乳化降解原油性能良好的菌株,对其进行多相分类学鉴定和性能评价。【方法】利用原油为底物筛选乳化降解性能良好的菌株,通过形态特征观察、生理生化测定、16S rRNA基因序列分析等确定菌株的分类地位。通过乳化能力、降解率等方法确定菌株的原油乳化降解特性。【结果】从华北油田采集的地层水样品中分离得到一株乳化原油的菌株BLG74,经多相分类鉴定表明其是土壤堆肥芽孢杆菌(Compostibacillus humi)的新菌株,亲源性99.6%。该菌株的生长温度为30-60℃ (最适温度45℃),pH6.5-9.5(最适pH7.0),NaCl浓度0%-7%(质量体积比)。菌株BLG74在玉米浆培养基中培养,其发酵液的表面张力为56.3 mN/m,乳化力约95%,在初始原油质量浓度0.5%、温度45℃的条件下培养20d,对原油的降解率可达40.8%。【结论】菌...     

Isolation of thermotolerant,halotolerant, facultative biosurfactant-producing bacteria

Several facultative bacterial strains tolerant to high temperature and salinity were isolated from the oil reservoir brines of an Iranian oil field (Masjed-I Soleyman). Some of these isolates were able to grow up to 60°C and at high concentration of NaCl (15% w/v). One of the isolates grew at 40°C, while it was able to grow at 15% w/v NaCl. Tolerances to NaCl levels decreased as the growth temperatures were increased. Surfactant production ability was detected in some of these isolates. The use of biosurfactant is considered as an effective mechanism in microbial-enhanced oil recovery processes detected in some of these isolates. The surfactant producers were able to grow at high temperatures and salinities to about 55°C and 10% w/v, respectively. These isolates exhibited morphological and physiological characteristics of the Bacillus genus. The partial sequencing of the 16S ribosomal deoxyribonucleic acid gene of the selected isolates was assigned them to Bacillus subtilis group. The biosurfactant produced by these isolates caused a substantial decrease in the surface tension of the culture media to 26.7 mN/m. By the use of thin-layer chromatography technique, the presence of the three compounds was detected in the tested biosurfactant. Infrared spectroscopy and ¹H nuclear magnetic resonance analysis were used, and the partial structural characterization of the biosurfactant mixture of the three compounds was found to be lipopeptidic in nature. The possibility of use of the selected bacterial strains reported, in the present study, in different sectors of the petroleum industry has been addressed.     

Isolation and Characterization of Novel Hydrocarbon-Degrading Euryhaline Consortia from Crude Oil and Mangrove Sediments

Two novel and versatile bacterial consortia were developed for the biodegradation of hydrocarbons. They were isolated from crude oil from the Cormorant Field in the North Sea (MPD-7) and from sediment associated with mangrove roots (MPD-M). The bacterial consortia were able to degrade both aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons in crude oils very effectively in seawater (35 g/L NaCl) and synthetic media containing 0 to 100 g/L NaCl (1.7 M). Salinities over twice that of normal seawater decreased the biodegradation rates. However, even at the highest salinity biodegradation was significant. Ratios of nC17 to pristane and nC18 to phytane were significantly lowered across the range of salinity. The lowest values were at 0 and 20 g/L (0.34 M). Phytane was degraded in preference to pristane. The degradation of these compounds was constant over the salinity range, with evidence of a slight increase for consortium MPD-M with increasing salinity. In general, the consortium isolated from mangrove root sediments was more efficient in metabolizing North Sea crude oil than the consortium isolated from Cormorant crude oil. The 5 strains that comprise MPD-M have been tentatively identified as species of the genera Marinobacter, Bacillus, and Erwinia. This is the first report of hydrocarbon-degrading consortia isolated from crude oil and mangrove sediments that are capable of treating oily wastes over such a wide range of salinity. Received June 30, 1999; accepted May 29, 2000.     

Towards efficient crude oil degradation by a mixed bacterial consortium

A laboratory study was undertaken to assess the optimal conditions for biodegradation of Bombay High (BH) crude oil. Among 130 oil degrading bacterial cultures isolated from oil contaminated soil samples, Micrococcus sp. GS2-22, Corynebacterium sp. GS5-66, Flavobacterium sp. DS5-73, Bacillus sp. DS6-86 and Pseudomonas sp. DS10-129 were selected for the study based on the efficiency of crude oil utilisation. A mixed bacterial consortium prepared using the above strains was also used. Individual bacterial cultures showed less growth and degradation than did the mixed bacterial consortium. At 1% crude oil concentration, the mixed bacterial consortium degraded a maximum of 78% of BH crude oil. This was followed by 66% by Pseudomonas sp. DS10-129, 59% by Bacillus sp. DS6-86, 49% by Micrococcus sp. GS2-22, 43% by Corynebacterium sp. GS5-66 and 41% by Flavobacterium sp. DS5-73. The percentage of degradation by the mixed bacterial consortium decreased from 78% to 52% as the concentration of crude oil was increased from 1% to 10%. Temperature of 30 degrees C and pH 7.5 were found to be optima for maximum biodegradation.     

Production and characterization of a glycolipid biosurfactant from Bacillus megaterium using economically cheaper sources

Criteria selected for screening of biosurfactant production by Bacillus megaterium were hemolytic assay, bacterial cell hydrophobicity and the drop-collapse test. The data on hemolytic activity, bacterial cell adherence with crude oil and the drop-collapse test confirmed the biosurfactant-producing ability of the strain. Accordingly, the strain was cultured at different temperatures, pH values, salinity and substrate (crude oil) concentration in mineral salt medium to establish the optimum culture conditions, and it was shown that 38°C, 2.0% of substrate concentration, pH 8.0 and 30‰ of salt concentration were optimal for maximum growth and biosurfactant production. Laboratory scale biosurfactant production in a fermentor was done with crude oil and cheaper carbon sources like waste motor lubricant oil and peanut oil cake, and the highest biosurfactant production was found with peanut oil cake. Characterization of partially purified biosurfactant inferred that it was a glycolipid with emulsification potential of waste motor lubricant oil, crude oil, peanut oil, diesel, kerosene, naphthalene, anthracene and xylene.     

Biodegradation of fuel oil hydrocarbons by a mixed bacterial consortium in sandy and loamy soils

The aerobic degradation of light fuel oil in sandy and loamy soils by an environmental bacterial consortium was investigated. Soils were spiked with 1 or 0.1% of oil per dry weight of soil. Acetone extracts of dried soils were analyzed by GC and the overall degradation was calculated by comparison with hydrocarbon recovery from uninoculated soils. In sandy soils, the sum of alkanes n-C(12) to n-C(23) was degraded to about 45% within 6 days at 20 degrees C and to 27-31% within 28 days, provided that moisture and nutrients were replenished. Degradation in loamy soil was about 12% lower. The distribution of recovered alkanes suggested a preferential degradation of shorter chain molecules (n-C(12) to n-C(16)) by the bacterial consortium. Partial 16S rDNA sequences indicated the presence of strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Pseudomonas citronellolis, and Stenotrophomonas maltophilia. Toxicity tests using commercial standard procedures showed a moderate inhibition of bacterial activity. The study showed the applicability of a natural microbial community for the degradation of oil spills into soils at ambient temperatures.     

Development of thermotolerant bacterial consortium,the basis for biopreparation for remediation of petroleum-contaminated soils and waters in hot climates

The consortium of thermotolerant petroleum-oxidizing bacteria containing strains Gordonia sp. 1D VKM Ac-2720 D, Rhodococcus sp. Par7 VKM Ac-2722 D, and R. pyridinivorans L5A-BSU VKM Ac-2721 for destruction of oil and oil products in hot climates was developed for the first time. The consortium was effective in soils and liquid media at temperature as high as 50°C, at salinity up to 7%, and soil moisture of about 10%. The efficiency of petroleum destruction for 21 days was 70 and 59% at 24 and 45°C, respectively. The consortium of thermotolerant petroleum-destructing strains could be used as basis for the biopreparation for remediation of petroleum-contaminated soils and waters in hot climates.     

Use of Experimental Factorial Design for Optimization of Hexavalent Chromium Removal by a Bacterial Consortium: Soil Microcosm Bioremediation

Hexavalent chromium Cr(VI) is regularly introduced into the environment through diverse anthropogenic activities. It is highly toxic, mutagenic and carcinogenic, and because of its solubility in water, chromate contamination can be difficult to contain. Bacteria can reduce chromate to insoluble and less toxic trivalent chromium Cr(III), and thus increasing attention is paid to chromate bioremediation to reduce its ecotoxicological impacts. In this study, the factorial design 2³ was employed to optimize critical parameters responsible for higher Cr(VI) removal by a bacterial consortium. The factors considered were pH, temperature, and inoculum size at two markedly different levels. All three dependent variables have significant effect on Cr(VI) reduction. Optimal Cr(VI) removal by the bacterial consortium occurred at pH 9, temperature 37°C, and inoculum size OD = 3. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) showed a high coefficient of determination (R²) value of 0.984, thus ensuring a satisfactory adjustment of the second-order regression model with the experimental data. In addition, the effect of bioaugmentation of Cr(VI)-polluted soil microcosms with the bacterial consortium was investigated using the best factor levels. Contaminated soil by 20 and 60 mg/Kg of Cr(VI) showed reductions of 83% and 65% of initial Cr(VI) by the bacterial consortium, suggesting that this bacterial consortium might diminish phytoavailable Cr(VI) in soil and be useful for cleaning up chromium-contaminated sites.     

The Potential of Bacterial Isolates for Emulsification with a Range of Hydrocarbons

A study was undertaken to investigate the distribution of biosurfactant producing and crude oil degrading bacteria in the oil contaminated environment. This research revealed that hydrocarbon contaminated sites are the potent sources for oil degraders. Among 32 oil degrading bacteria isolated from ten different oil contaminated sites of gasoline and diesel fuel stations, 80% exhibited biosurfactant production. The quantity and emulsification activity of the biosurfactants varied. Pseudomonas sp. DS10‐129 produced a maximum of 7.5 ± 0.4 g/l of biosurfactant with a corresponding reduction in surface tension from 68 mN/m to 29.4 ± 0.7 mN/m at 84 h incubation. The isolates Micrococcus sp. GS2‐22, Bacillus sp. DS6‐86, Corynebacterium sp. GS5‐66, Flavobacterium sp. DS5‐73, Pseudomonas sp. DS10‐129, Pseudomonas sp. DS9‐119 and Acinetobacter sp. DS5‐74 emulsified xylene, benzene, n‐hexane, Bombay High crude oil, kerosene, gasoline, diesel fuel and olive oil. The first five of the above isolates had the highest emulsification activity and crude oil degradation ability and were selected for the preparation of a mixed bacterial consortium, which was also an efficient biosurfactant producing oil emulsifying and degrading culture. During this study, biosurfactant production and emulsification activity were detected in Moraxella sp., Flavobacterium sp. and in a mixed bacterial consortium, which have not been reported before.     

Use of bacteria-immobilized cotton fibers to absorb and degrade crude oil

Using enrichment culture technique, two isolates that brought a significant degradation and dispersion of crude oil were obtained from contaminated sediments of the Bohai Bay, China. 16S rRNA gene sequencing and phylogenetic analysis indicated that the two bacterial strains affiliated with the genera Vibrio and Acinetobacter. Subsequently, the bacterial cells were immobilized on the surface of cotton fibers. Cotton fibers were used as crude oil sorbent as well as a biocarrier for bacteria immobilization. Among the two isolates, the marine bacteria Acinetobacter sp. HC8-3S showed a strong binding to the cotton fibers, possibly enhanced through extracellular dispersant excreted by Acinetobacter sp. HC8-3S. Both planktonic and immobilized bacteria showed relatively high biodegradation (>60%) of saturated hydrocarbons fraction of crude oil, in the pH range of 5.6–8.6. The degradation activities of planktonic and immobilized bacteria were not affected significantly when the NaCl concentration reached 70 g/L. The immobilized bacterial cells exhibited an enhanced biodegradation of crude oil. The efficiency of saturated hydrocarbons degradation by the immobilized bacterial cells increased about 30% compared to the planktonic bacterial cells.     

Isolation and selection of native microorganisms for the aerobic treatment of simulated dairy wastewaters

Milk fat/protein degrading microorganisms were isolated from different locations of a dairy wastewater treatment system with the goal of developing an inoculum for bioaugmentation strategies. Eight isolates, identified by 16S rRNA gene sequence analysis as belonging to the genera Bacillus, Pseudomonas, and Acinetobacter, were tested for their ability to remove COD and protein from a milk-based medium (3000 mg/L COD) and compared to a commercial bioaugmentation inoculum. The Acinetobacter isolate exhibited a pellet-type growth in liquid culture, a property that could potentially aid in the separation of microbes and liquid phase following treatment. Based on the individual degradation capacity and growth behavior of the isolates, three microorganisms were further selected and tested together. This consortium exhibited a COD removal similar to the commercial inoculum (57% and 63%, respectively), but higher protein (consortium: 93%; commercial inoculum: 54%), and fat removals (consortium: 75%; commercial inoculum: 38%).     

Selection of functional consortium for crude oil-contaminated soil remediation

Microorganisms with high oil-degrading performance are essential for bioremediation of soil contaminated with crude oil. A positive end dilution method was employed for the selection of crude oil-degrading functional consortium from contaminated soil. The selected consortium was consisted of Rhizobiales sp., Pseudomonas sp., Brucella sp., Bacillus sp., Rhodococcus sp., Microbacterium sp. and Roseomonas sp. and removed nearly 52.1% of crude oil at initial concentration of 10,000 mg l⁻¹ at 30 °C within 7 days, with removal of aliphatic hydrocarbons by 71.4% and aromatic hydrocarbons by 36.0%, respectively. The effectiveness of the consortium for bioaugmentation was confirmed with microcosm test by contaminated soil (1.0 kg) from Karemary Oilfield, China. The removal efficiency of crude oil was enhanced to >50% in microcosms with the consortium compared with 8-13% or lower in controls over a 60 day period. The crude oil removal reaction was probably first order reaction and the rate was greatly enhanced by bioaugmentation. Supplementation of nitrogen and phosphate sources had limited effect on the oil removal in the tested soil.     

Nocardia asteroides in the Soil of Kuwait

A pilot study was undertaken to determine the occurrence and distribution of pathogenic nocardiae in Kuwaiti soil. A total of 102 soil samples collected from two localities were investigated by the paraffin bait technique. Nocardia asteroides was the only species isolated from 42 (41%) soil samples. None of the isolates fulfilled the criteria required for identification of N. farcinica or N. nova. Thirty one (73.8%) isolates showed equivalent growth at 45 °C and 35 °C, 17 (40.4%) isolates utilized acetamide for carbon and nitrogen requirements and 3 (7.1%) isolates showed delayed arylsulphatase activity. Only a solitary isolate was resistant to cefamandole. Soil samples originating from the Kuwait University Campus Shuwaikh, which were rich in humus/organic matter, were more productive for N. asteroides (67%) than the samples which were devoid of it but were mixed with crude oil (39%). Sand samples that lacked organic matter and crude oil samples were least productive of N. asteroides. These preliminary findings do not suggest that massive oil contamination of soil in the Ahmadi oil field area during the Gulf war promoted the natural occurrence of N. asteroides. However, isolation of N. asteroides in as many as 41% of the soil sample is a significant observation warranting further epidemiologic studies including its possible role in the operation desert storm sickness syndrome. This is the first report on the natural occurrence of N. asteroides in Kuwait. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Investigation of alkane biodegradation using the microtiter plate method and correlation between biofilm formation, biosurfactant production and crude oil biodegradation

Among 25 crude oil-degrading bacteria isolated from a marine environment, four strains, which grew well on crude oil, were selected for more study. All the four isolated had maximum growth on 2.5% of crude oil and strain BC (Pseudomonas) could remove crude oil by 83%. The drop collapse method and microtiter assay show that this strain produces more biosurfactant, and its biofilm formation is higher compared to other strains. Bacterial adhesions to crude oil for strains CS-2 (Pseudomonas), BC, PG-5 (Rhodococcus) and H (Bacillus) were 30%, 46%, 10% and 1%, respectively. Therefore, strain H with a low production of biosurfactant and biofilm formation had showed the least growth on these compounds. PCR analysis of these four strains showed that all isolates had alk-B genes from group (III) alkane hydroxylase. All isolate strains could utilize cyclohexan, octane, hexadecane, octadecan and diesel fuel oil; however, the microtiter plate assay showed that strain BC had more growth, respiration and biofilm formation on octadecan.     

Analysis of Factors Affecting the Accuracy, Reproducibility, and Interpretation of Microbial Community Carbon Source Utilization Patterns

We determined factors that affect responses of bacterial isolates and model bacterial communities to the 95 carbon substrates in Biolog microtiter plates. For isolates and communities of three to six bacterial strains, substrate oxidation rates were typically nonlinear and were delayed by dilution of the inoculum. When inoculum density was controlled, patterns of positive and negative responses exhibited by microbial communities to each of the carbon sources were reproducible. Rates and extents of substrate oxidation by the communities were also reproducible but were not simply the sum of those exhibited by community members when tested separately. Replicates of the same model community clustered when analyzed by principal-components analysis (PCA), and model communities with different compositions were clearly separated on the first PCA axis, which accounted for >60% of the dataset variation. PCA discrimination among different model communities depended on the extent to which specific substrates were oxidized. However, the substrates interpreted by PCA to be most significant in distinguishing the communities changed with reading time, reflecting the nonlinearity of substrate oxidation rates. Although whole-community substrate utilization profiles were reproducible signatures for a given community, the extent of oxidation of specific substrates and the numbers or activities of microorganisms using those substrates in a given community were not correlated. Replicate soil samples varied significantly in the rate and extent of oxidation of seven tested substrates, suggesting microscale heterogeneity in composition of the soil microbial community.