Identification of self-incompatibility-related glycoproteins in styles of apple (Malus x domestica)

In this study, stylar proteins of apple (Malus x domestica) which correlate with known intervarietal incompatibility relationships and have similar characteristics to the S-glycoproteins of Japanese pear (Pyrus serotina) were surveyed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2D-PAGE). Varietal differences were detected in a group of glycoproteins having Mrs and pIs similar to those of the S-glycoproteins of Japanese pear. 2D-PAGE profiles of these glycoproteins were correlated with intervarietal incompatibility relationships. These glycoproteins reacted with antiserum raised against the S ⁴-glycoprotein of Japanese pear, a result suggesting that they may be the products of S-alleles in styles of apple. On the basis of the profiles of the putative S-glycoproteins, S-genotypes were proposed for each of the apple cultivars examined.     

Phosphorylation of style S-RNases by Ca2+-dependent protein kinases from pollen tubes

Solanaceous plants with gametophytic self-incompatibility produce ribonucleases in the transmitting tract of the style that interact with self-pollen and inhibit its growth. These ribonucleases are a series of allelic products of the S-locus, which controls self-incompatibility. Little is known about the pollen components involved in this interaction or whether a signal transduction pathway is activated during the self-incompatibility response. We have partially purified a soluble protein kinase from pollen tubes of Nicotiana alata that phosphorylates the self-incompatibility RNases (S-RNases) from N. alata but not Lycopersicon peruvianum. The soluble protein kinase (Nak-1) has several features shared by the calcium-dependent protein kinase (CDPK) class of plant protein kinases, including substrate specificity, calcium dependence, inhibition by the calmodulin antagonist calmidazolium, and cross-reaction with monoclonal antibodies raised to a CDPK from soybean. Phosphorylation of S ₂-RNase by Nak-1 is restricted to serine residues, but the site(s) of phosphorylation has not been determined and there is no evidence for allele-specific phosphorylation. The microsomal fraction from pollen tubes also phosphorylates S-RNases and this activity may be associated with proteins of M_r60 K and 69 K that cross-react with the monoclonal antibody to the soybean CDPK. These results are discussed in the context of the involvement of phosphorylation in other self-incompatibility systems.     

Expression of a fusion protein of Pyrus pyrifolia S-RNase with glutathione-S-transferase in E. coli

S-RNase is a style-specific ribonuclease which is associated with gametophytic self-incompatibility. An expression vector of a fusion protein of Pyrus pyrifolia(Japanese pear) S3-RNase with glutathione-S-transferase (GST) was constructed and transformed into E. coli. Using this system, the fusion protein, GST-S3-RNase, was expressed as an active form and can be used for screening pollen S-gene product(s).     

Polymorphism of <Emphasis Type="Italic">SFBB</Emphasis><Superscript>−γ</Superscript> and its use for <Emphasis Type="Italic">S</Emphasis> genotyping in Japanese pear (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Pyrus pyrifolia</Emphasis>)

Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia) exhibits the S-RNase-based gametophytic self-incompatibility where the pollen-part determinant, pollen S, had long remained elusive. Recent identification of S locus F-box brothers (SFBB) in Japanese pear and apple suggested that the multiple F-box genes are the pollen S candidates as they exhibited pollen specific expression, S haplotype-specific polymorphisms and linkage to the S locus. In Japanese pear, three SFBBs were identified from a single S haplotype, and they were more homologous to other haplotype genes of the same group (i.e., α-, β- and γ-groups). In this study, we isolated new seven PpSFBB ^−γ genes from different S genotypes of Japanese pear. These genes showed S haplotype-specific polymorphisms, however, sequence similarities among them were very high. Based on the sequence polymorphisms of the PpSFBB ^−γ genes, we developed a CAPS/dCAPS system for S genotyping of the Japanese pear cultivars. This new S genotyping system was found to not only be able to discriminate the S ¹–S ⁹, but also be suitable for identification of the mutant S ^4sm haplotype for the breeding of self-compatible cultivars, and detection of new S haplotypes such as S ^k.     

Cloning and mapping multiple S-locus F-box genes in European pear (Pyrus communis L.)

European pear, as well as its close relatives Japanese pear and apple, exhibits S-RNase-based gametophytic self-incompatibility. The male determinant of this self-incompatibility mechanism is a pollen-expressed protein containing an F-box domain; in the genera Petunia (Solanaceae), Antirrhinum (Plantaginaceae), and Prunus (Rosaceae), a single F-box gene determines the pollen S. In apple and Japanese pear, however, multiple S-locus F-box genes were recently identified as candidates for the pollen S, and they were named S-locus F-Box Brothers. These genes were considered good candidates for the pollen S determinant since they exhibit S-haplotype-specific polymorphisms, pollen-specific expression, and linkage to the S-RNase. In the present study, S-locus F-Box Brothers homologs have been cloned from two of the most agronomically important European pear varieties, “Abbé Fétel” (S_104-2/S₁₀₅) and “Max Red Bartlett” (S₁₀₁/S₁₀₂), and they have been mapped on a genetic linkage map developed on their progeny. Our results suggest that the number of F-box genes linked to the S-locus of the European pear is higher than expected according with previous reports for apple and Japanese pear, since up to five genes were found to be linked to a single S-haplotype. Moreover, two of these genes exhibited an incomplete linkage to the S-RNase, allowing the identification of low-frequency recombinant haplotypes, generated by a crossing-over event between the two genes. These F-box genes are most likely placed in close proximity of the S-locus but do not belong to it, and they can thus be excluded from being responsible for the determination of pollen S function.     

Recent developments in the molecular genetics and biology of self-incompatibility

A summary of recent work on molecular aspects of self-incompatibility in Nicotiana alata is presented. The amino acid sequences of style proteins corresponding to different S-alleles of N. alata have a high level of homology in some regions and are variable in other regions. The regions of homology include N-terminal sequences as well as most of the glycosylation sites and cysteine residues. The glycosyl substituents may consist of a number of glycoforms. The isolated style S-glycoproteins inhibit in vitro growth of pollen tubes. The S-glycoproteins tested inhibited the growth of pollen of several S-genotypes, and there was some specificity in the interaction. Heat treatment of the isolated S-glycoproteins dramatically increased their activity as inhibitors of pollen tube growth, although the specificity in the interaction was lost. The nature of the S-allele products in pollen is not yet established.     

Analysis of the S-locus structure in Prunus armeniaca L. Identification of S-haplotype specific S-RNase and F-box genes

The gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) system in Rosaceae has been proposed to be controlled by two genes located in the S-locusan S-RNase and a recently described pollen expressed S-haplotype specific F-box gene (SFB). However, in apricot (Prunus armeniaca L.) these genes had not been identified yet. We have sequenced 21kb in total of the S-locus region in 3 different apricot S-haplotypes. These fragments contain genes homologous to the S-RNase and F-box genes found in other Prunusspecies, preserving their basic gene structure features and defined amino acid domains. The physical distance between the F-boxand the S-RNase genes was determined exactly in the S ₂-haplotype (2.9kb) and inferred approximately in the S ₁-haplotype (< 49kb) confirming that these genes are linked. Sequence analysis of the 5 flanking regions indicates the presence of a conserved region upstream of the putative TATA box in the S-RNase gene. The three identified S-RNase alleles (S ₁, S ₂ and S ₄) had a high allelic sequence diversity (75.3 amino acid identity), and the apricot F-box allelic variants (SFB₁, SFB₂ and SFB₄) were also highly haplotype-specific (79.4 amino acid identity). Organ specific-expression was also studied, revealing that S ₁- and S ₂-RNases are expressed in style tissues, but not in pollen or leaves. In contrast, SFB ₁ and SFB ₂ are only expressed in pollen, but not in styles or leaves. Taken together, these results support these genes as candidates for the pistil and pollen S-determinants of GSI in apricot.     

Trans-specific <Emphasis Type="Italic">S</Emphasis>-RNase and SFB alleles in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Prunus</Emphasis> self-incompatibility haplotypes

Self-incompatibility in the genus Prunus is controlled by two genes at the S-locus, S-RNase and SFB. Both genes exhibit the high polymorphism and high sequence diversity characteristic of plant self-incompatibility systems. Deduced polypeptide sequences of three myrobalan and three domestic plum S-RNases showed over 97% identity with S-RNases from other Prunus species, including almond, sweet cherry, Japanese apricot and Japanese plum. The second intron, which is generally highly polymorphic between alleles was also remarkably well conserved within these S-allele pairs. Degenerate consensus primers were developed and used to amplify and sequence the co-adapted polymorphic SFB alleles. Sequence comparisons also indicated high degrees of polypeptide sequence identity between three myrobalan and the three domestic plum SFB alleles and the corresponding Prunus SFB alleles. We discuss these trans-specific allele identities in terms of S-allele function, evolution of new allele specificities and Prunus taxonomy and speciation. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Biosynthesis of glycoproteins involved in the pollen-stigma interaction of incompatibility in developing flowers of Brassica oleracea L.

De-novo synthesis of the S-allele-specific glycoproteins of Brassica oleracea is demonstrated in stigmas at different developmental stages. Excised stigmas incorporate ¹⁴C-labeled amino acids into their S-glycoproteins early in development and before the self-incompatibility response is acquired, but the rate of synthesis accelerates prior to anthesis, resulting in the accumulation of high levels of the S-glycoproteins in the stigma and coinciding with the acquisition of the pollen-stigma incompatibility response. Since the self-compatible and self-incompatible zones of developing inflorescences are very sharply delineated, a threshold quantity of S-glycoproteins appears to be critical for the onset of self-incompatibility. Incorporation experiments in which [^35Smethionine was applied to intact stigma surfaces indicate that the papillae are the main sites of synthesis of the S-specific glycoproteins.Abbreviations IEF isoelectric focusing - SC self-compatibility - SDS sodium dodecyl sulfate - SI self-incompatibility     

Physical linkage of the SLG and SRK genes at the self-incompatibility locus of Brassica oleracea

Summary In Brassica oleracea, the pollen-stigma interaction of self-incompatibility is controlled by a single genetically defined locus designated S. Molecular studies have identified two genes that are tightly linked to the classically defined S locus: The S-Locus Glycoprotein (SLG) gene and the S-Receptor Kinase (SRK) gene. In previous RFLP linkage analyses with probes specific for SLG and SRK, we were unable to identify any recombination events between SLG, SRK, and self-incompatibility phenotype. In this paper, we use pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) in conjunction with DNA blot analysis to characterize the S-locus region from two highly divergent self-incompatibility genotypes, S ₂ and S ₆. We establish the physical linkage of SLG and SRK in each genotype, and demonstrate that the two genes are separated by a maximum distance of 220 kb in the S ₆ genotype and 350 kb in the S ₂ genotype. Furthermore, a comparison of the data from the two genotypes reveals that a high level of polymorphism exists across the entire S-locus region.     

Identification of <Emphasis Type="Italic">S</Emphasis>-haplotype-specific F-box gene in Japanese plum (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Prunus salicina</Emphasis> Lindl.)

Self-incompatibility has been studied extensively at the molecular level in Solanaceae, Rosaceae and Scrophulariaceae, all of which exhibit gametophytic self-incompatibility controlled by a single polymorphic locus containing at least two linked genes, i.e., the S-RNase gene and the pollen-expressed SFB/SLF (S-haplotype-specific F-box/S-locus F-box) gene. However, the SFB gene in Japanese plum (Prunus salicina Lindl.) has not yet been identified. We determined eight novel sequences homologous to the SFB genes of other Prunus species and named these sequences PsSFB. The gene structure of the SFB genes and the characteristic domains in deduced amino acid sequences were conserved. Three sequences from 410 to 2,800 bp of the intergenic region between the PsSFB sequences and the S-RNase alleles were obtained. The eight identified PsSFB sequences showed S-haplotype-specific polymorphism, with 74–83% amino acid identity. These alleles were exclusively expressed in the pollen. These results suggest that the PsSFB alleles are the pollen S-determinants of GSI in Japanese plum. Nucleotide sequence data reported are available in the NCBI database under the accession numbers DQ849084–DQ849090 and DQ849118.     

Sequence comparison of the 5’ flanking regions of Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia) S-RNases associated with gametophytic self-incompatibility

Genomic clones of 2.8 kb, 4.3 kb and 6.5 kb for the S₂-, S₃- and S₅-RNases of Japanese pear(Pyrus pyrifolia), respectively, were isolated and sequenced. Comparison of the 5’-flanking regions of these genes with the same region of the S₄-RNase gene indicated that a highly similar region of approximately 200 bp exists in the regions just upstream of the putative TATA boxes of the four Japanese pear S-RNase genes. This suggests the presence of cis-regulatory element(s) in this region. Received: 5 October 2000 / Revision accepted: 2 January 2001     

Three members of the S multigene family are linked to the S locus of Brassica

Two self-incompatibility genes in Brassica, SLG and SRK (SLG encodes a glycoprotein; SRK encodes a receptor-like kinase), are included in the S multigene family. Products of members of the S multigene family have an SLG-like domain (S domain) in common, which may function as a receptor. In this study, three clustered members of the S multigene family, BcRK1, BcRL1 and BcSL1, were characterized. BcRK1 is a putative functional receptor kinase gene expressed in leaves, flower buds and stigmas, while BcRL1 and BcSL1 are considered to be pseudogenes because deletions causing frameshifts were identified in these sequences. Sequence and expression pattern of BcRK1 were most similar to those of the Arabidopsis receptor-like kinase gene ARK1, indicating that BcRK1 might have a function similar to that of ARK1, in processes such as cell expansion or plant growth. Interestingly, the region containing BcRK1, BcRL1 and BcSL1 is genetically linked to the S locus and the physical distance between SLG, SRK and the three S-related genes was estimated to be less than 610 kb. Thus the genes associated with self-incompatibility exist within a cluster of S-like genes in the genome of Brassica. Received: 15 April 1997 / Accepted: 13 June 1997     

Self-Incompatibility in Petunia inflata: The Relationship between a Self-Incompatibility Locus F-Box Protein and Its Non-Self S-RNases

The highly polymorphic S (for self-incompatibility) locus regulates self-incompatibility in Petunia inflata; the S-RNase regulates pistil specificity, and multiple S-locus F-box (SLF) genes regulate pollen specificity. The collaborative non-self recognition model predicts that, for any S-haplotype, an unknown number of SLFs collectively recognize all non-self S-RNases to mediate their ubiquitination and degradation. Using a gain-of-function assay, we examined the relationships between S₂-SLF1 (for S₂-allelic product of Type-1 SLF) and four S-RNases. The results suggest that S₂-SLF1 interacts with S₇- and S₁₃-RNases, and the previously identified S₁- and S₃-RNases, but not with S₅- or S₁₁-RNase. An artificial microRNA expressed by the S₂-SLF1 promoter, but not by the vegetative cell-specific promoter, Late Anther Tomato 52, suppressed expression of S₂-SLF1 in S₂ pollen, suggesting that SLF1 is specific to the generative cell. The S₂ pollen with S₂-SLF1 suppressed was compatible with S₃-, S₅-, S₇-, S₁₁-, and S₁₃-carrying pistils, confirming that other SLF proteins are responsible for detoxifying S₅- and S₁₁-RNases and suggesting that S₂-SLF1 is not the only SLF in S₂ pollen that interacts with S₃-, S₇-, and S₁₃-RNases. Petunia may have evolved at least two types of SLF proteins to detoxify any non-self S-RNase to minimize the deleterious effects of mutation in any SLF.     

Cloning and characterization of genomic DNA sequences of four self-incompatibility alleles in sweet cherry (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Prunus avium</Emphasis> L.)

Gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) in sweet cherry is determined by a locus S with multiple alleles. In the style, the S-locus codifies for an allele-specific ribonuclease (S-RNase) that is involved in the rejection of pollen that carries the same S allele. In this work we report the cloning and genomic DNA sequence analysis including the 5 flanking regions of four S-RNases of sweet cherry (Prunus avium L., Rosaceae). DNA from the cultivars Ferrovia, Pico Colorado, Taleguera Brillante and Vittoria was amplified through PCR using primers designed in the conserved sequences of sweet cherry S-RNases. Two alleles were amplified for each cultivar and three of them correspond to three new S-alleles named S ₂₃ , S ₂₄ and S ₂₅ present in 'Pico Colorado', 'Vittoria' and 'Taleguera Brillante' respectively. To confirm the identity of the amplified fragments, the genomic DNA of these three putative S-RNases and the allele S ₁₂ amplified in the cultivar Ferrovia were cloned and sequenced. The nucleotide and deduced amino-acid sequences obtained contained the structural features of rosaceous S-RNases. The isolation of the 5-flanking sequences of these four S-RNases revealed a conserved putative TATA box and high similarity among them downstream from that sequence. However, similarity was low compared with the 5-flanking regions of S-RNases from the Maloideae. S ₆ - and S ₂₄ -RNase sequences are highly similar, and most amino-acid substitutions among these two RNases occur outside the rosaceous hypervariable region (RHV), but within another highly variable region. The confirmation of the different specificity of these two S-RNases would help elucidate which regions of the S-RNase sequences play a role in S-pollen specific recognition.Communicated by H.F. Linskens     

Molecular Determinants and Mechanisms of Gametophytic Self-Incompatibility in Fruit Trees of Rosaceae

Self-incompatibility is an important genetic mechanism that prevents inbreeding and promotes genetic polymorphism and heterosis in flowering plants. Many fruit species in the Rosaceae, including apple, pear, plum, apricot, sweet cherry, Japanese apricot, and almond, exhibit typical gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) controlled by an apparently single multi-allelic locus. This locus encodes at least two components from both the pollen and the pistil, and controls recognition of self- and non-self pollen. Recently, the GSI system has been investigated at the molecular and cellular levels in Rosaceae, and findings have provided some important insights as to how these two genes interact within pollen tubes that lead to specific inhibition of germination and/or growth of self-pollen tubes. In this review, molecular features of S-determinants of both pistil and pollen, identification of S-alleles, mechanisms of self-incompatibility break-down, and evolution of S-alleles are presented. Moreover, hypothetical signal transduction models in a self-incompatible system in Rosaceae are proposed based on recent findings that indicate that several signal factors are involved in GSI responses.     

Characterisation of novel S-alleles from cherry (Prunus avium L.)

In plant populations exhibiting gametophytic self-incompatibility, individuals harbouring rare S alleles are likely to have a reproductive advantage over individuals having more common alleles. Consequently, determination of the self-incompatibility haplotype of individuals is essential for genetic studies and the development of informed management strategies. This study characterises six new S alleles identified in wild cherry (Prunus avium L.). Investigations to determine the S genotype of individuals in recently planted woodland through length polymorphisms of introns associated with the stylar S-RNase gene and the pollen SFB gene revealed six S intron profiles which did not correspond to those of known S alleles. These are now attributed to S ₂₇ to S ₃₂ . Consensus primers, annealing in the S-RNase sequence coding for the signal peptide and C5 regions, were used to isolate the S-RNase alleles associated with the novel S intron profiles. The proteins corresponding to the new alleles were separated by isoelectric focusing from stylar extracts and their pI values determined. Similarities between the deduced amino acid sequence for the new alleles isolated and other cherry S-RNase sequences available on the databases ranged from 40% to 86%. Amplification products for SFB introns ranged from 172 to 208bp. New sequence regions exposed to positive selection were identified and the significance of the PS3 region reinforced. A phylogenetic relationship between P. avium S-RNases for S ₁₀ and S ₁₃ and between corresponding SFB alleles may indicate co-evolution of allele specificities of these two genes. The nucleotide sequences reported in this paper have been submitted to the EMBL/GenBank database under the following accession numbers: S ₂₇ (DQ266439), S ₂₈ (DQ266440), S ₂₉ (DQ266441), S ₃₀ (DQ266442), S ₃₁ (DQ266443), S ₃₂ (DQ266444).     

A cDNA encoding an S-locus specific glycoprotein from Brassica oleracea plants containing the S5 self-incompatibility allele

Summary A cDNA sequence homologous to the Brassica self-incompatibility locus specific glycoprotein (SLSG) sequence was isolated from stigmas of B. oleracea plants homozygous for the S₅ allele. The nucleotide sequence of this cDNA was obtained and compared with the S₆ allelic form of the SLSG. Evidence is presented which indicates that this sequence does not specify the self-incompatibility response of pollen.Abbreviations SDS sodium dodecyl sulphate - PVP polyvinylpyrrolidone - BSA bovine serum albumin - SLSG self-incompatibility locus specific glycoprotein     

Structure and expression of AtS1, an Arabidopsis thaliana gene homologous to the S-locus related genes of Brassica

Summary Genetic and molecular analysis of the self-incompatibility locus (S-locus) of the crucifer Brassica has led to the characterization of a multigene family involved in pollen-stigma interactions. While the crucifer Arabidopsis thaliana does not have a self-incompatibility system, S-related sequences were detected in this species by cross-hybridization with Brassica DNA probes. In this paper, we show that an A. thaliana S-related sequence, designated AtS1, is expressed specifically in flower buds. Sequence analysis suggests that AtS1 encodes a secreted glycoprotein that is most similar to the Brassica S-locus related protein SLR1. As has been proposed for SLR1, this gene may be involved in determining some fundamental aspect of pollen-stigma interactions during pollination. The molecular and genetic advantages of the Arabidopsis system will provide many avenues for testing this hypothesis.     

Evaluation of candidate F-box genes for the pollen S of gametophytic self-incompatibility in the Pyrinae (Rosaceae) on the basis of their phylogenomic context

The recent analysis of the S-locus region of apple and Japanese pear, two species of Pyrinae (Rosaceae), suggested multiple and different F-box genes (called SFBBs) as candidates for the male determinant (pollen S) of RNase-based gametophytic self-incompatibility in these two species. Here, we followed a phylogenetic approach to take advantage of the pattern of molecular evolution of the S-locus of Pyrinae in characterizing SFBB homologs belonging to S-haplotypes of apple and three species of Pyrus (European, Japanese, and Chinese pears). Our results suggested that the S-locus region of Pyrinae contains no less than six SFBB members and that its structure seems to be rather conserved between apple and pear species. In accordance with the prevailing theory on S-haplotype evolution, the pollen S is expected to have coevolved with the S-RNase and to show some common features derived from the long-term evolution under frequency-dependent balancing selection, i.e., high sequence diversity, evidence of positive selection, and shared ancestral polymorphisms. Using this conceptual framework, we present evidence that some SFBB genes may be better candidates for pollen S in Pyrinae than others. Overall, the SFBB genes analyzed exhibited much lower sequence diversity than their associated S-RNases; likewise, they showed little or no evidence of positive selection. However, evidence of coevolution with the S-RNase clearly emerged for two of them. Altogether our results suggested different evolutionary histories for different SFBBs putatively derived from their distinct involvement in self-incompatibility.