Quantitative analysis of total mitochondrial DNA: competitive polymerase chain reaction versus real-time polymerase chain reaction

An efficient and effective method for quantification of small amounts of nucleic acids contained within a sample specimen would be an important diagnostic tool for determining the content of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) in situations where the depletion thereof may be a contributing factor to the exhibited pathology phenotype. This study compares two quantification assays for calculating the total mtDNA molecule number per nanogram of total genomic DNA isolated from human blood, through the amplification of a 613-bp region on the mtDNA molecule. In one case, the mtDNA copy number was calculated by standard competitive polymerase chain reaction (PCR) technique that involves co-amplification of target DNA with various dilutions of a nonhomologous internal competitor that has the same primer binding sites as the target sequence, and subsequent determination of an equivalence point of target and competitor concentrations. In the second method, the calculation of copy number involved extrapolation from the fluorescence versus copy number standard curve generated by real-time PCR using various dilutions of the target amplicon sequence. While the mtDNA copy number was comparable using the two methods (4.92 +/- 1.01 x 10(4) molecules/ng total genomic DNA using competitive PCR vs 4.90 +/- 0.84 x 10(4) molecules/ng total genomic DNA using real-time PCR), both inter- and intraexperimental variance were significantly lower using the real-time PCR analysis. On the basis of reproducibility, assay complexity, and overall efficiency, including the time requirement and number of PCR reactions necessary for the analysis of a single sample, we recommend the real-time PCR quantification method described here, as its versatility and effectiveness will undoubtedly be of great use in various kinds of research related to mitochondrial DNA damage- and depletion-associated disorders.     

Rapid competitive PCR using melting curve analysis for DNA quantification.

A rapid competitive PCR method was developed to quantify DNA on the LightCycler. It rests on the quantitative information contained in the melting curves obtained after amplification in the presence of SYBR Green I. Specific hybridization probes are not required. Heterologous internal standards sharing the same primer binding sites and having different melting temperatures to the natural PCR products were used as competitors. After a co-amplification of known amounts of the competitor with a DNA-containing sample, the target DNA can be quantified from the ratio of the melting peak areas of competitor and target products. The method was developed using 16S rDNA fragments from Streptococcus mutans and E. coli and tested against existing PCR-based DNA quantification procedures. While kinetic analysis of real-time PCR is well established for the quantification of pure nucleic acids, competitive PCR on the LightCycler based on an internal standardization was found to represent a rapid and sensitive alternative DNA quantification method for analysis of complex biological samples that may contain PCR inhibitors.     

Combination of competitive quantitative PCR and constant-denaturant capillary electrophoresis for high-resolution detection and enumeration of microbial cells

A novel quantitative PCR (QPCR) approach, which combines competitive PCR with constant-denaturant capillary electrophoresis (CDCE), was adapted for enumerating microbial cells in environmental samples using the marine nanoflagellate Cafeteria roenbergensis as a model organism. Competitive PCR has been used successfully for quantification of DNA in environmental samples. However, this technique is labor intensive, and its accuracy is dependent on an internal competitor, which must possess the same amplification efficiency as the target yet can be easily discriminated from the target DNA. The use of CDCE circumvented these problems, as its high resolution permitted the use of an internal competitor which differed from the target DNA fragment by a single base and thus ensured that both sequences could be amplified with equal efficiency. The sensitivity of CDCE also enabled specific and precise detection of sequences over a broad range of concentrations. The combined competitive QPCR and CDCE approach accurately enumerated C. roenbergensis cells in eutrophic, coastal seawater at abundances ranging from approximately 10 to 10(4) cells x ml(-1). The QPCR cell estimates were confirmed by fluorescent in situ hybridization counts, but estimates of samples with <50 cells x ml(-1) by QPCR were less variable. This novel approach extends the usefulness of competitive QPCR by demonstrating its ability to reliably enumerate microorganisms at a range of environmentally relevant cell concentrations in complex aquatic samples.     

Combination of Competitive Quantitative PCR and Constant-Denaturant Capillary Electrophoresis for High-Resolution Detection and Enumeration of Microbial Cells

A novel quantitative PCR (QPCR) approach, which combines competitive PCR with constant-denaturant capillary electrophoresis (CDCE), was adapted for enumerating microbial cells in environmental samples using the marine nanoflagellate Cafeteria roenbergensis as a model organism. Competitive PCR has been used successfully for quantification of DNA in environmental samples. However, this technique is labor intensive, and its accuracy is dependent on an internal competitor, which must possess the same amplification efficiency as the target yet can be easily discriminated from the target DNA. The use of CDCE circumvented these problems, as its high resolution permitted the use of an internal competitor which differed from the target DNA fragment by a single base and thus ensured that both sequences could be amplified with equal efficiency. The sensitivity of CDCE also enabled specific and precise detection of sequences over a broad range of concentrations. The combined competitive QPCR and CDCE approach accurately enumerated C. roenbergensis cells in eutrophic, coastal seawater at abundances ranging from approximately 10 to 10⁴ cells ml⁻¹. The QPCR cell estimates were confirmed by fluorescent in situ hybridization counts, but estimates of samples with <50 cells ml⁻¹ by QPCR were less variable. This novel approach extends the usefulness of competitive QPCR by demonstrating its ability to reliably enumerate microorganisms at a range of environmentally relevant cell concentrations in complex aquatic samples.     

Competitive PCR-ELISA protocols for the quantitative and the standardized detection of viral genomes

Competitive PCR-ELISA combines competitive PCR with an ELISA to allow quantitative detection of PCR products. It is based on the inclusion of an internal standard competitor molecule that is designed to differ from the target by a short sequence of nucleotides. Once such a competitor molecule has been designed and constructed, target and competitor sequences are concurrently PCR-amplified, before hybridization to two different specific probes and determination of their respective OD values by ELISA. The target can be quantified in relation to a titration curve of different dilutions of the competitor. The competitor can alternatively be used at a unique optimal concentration to allow for standardized detection of the target sequence. PCR-ELISA can be performed in 1 d in laboratories without access to a real-time PCR thermocycler. This technique is applied in diagnostics to monitor the course of infections and drug efficacy. Competitive PCR-ELISA protocols for the quantitative and for the standardized detection of parvovirus B19 are detailed here as an example of the technique.     

Image analysis in quantitative PCR. An application for the measurement of c-erbB-2 oncogene amplification in DNA from human tumours

We present an application of image analysis for the direct quantification of PCR products after gel electrophoresis and ethidium bromide staining of DNA. This procedure has been applied to the development of an assay based on competitive PCR for the measurement of the degree of amplification of c-erbB-2 oncogene in DNA from human tumours. In this method two DNA species (genomic and competitor) compete for PCR amplification. Since results are calculated from the final competitor/genomic ratio any variable affecting the rate of PCR amplification has no effect on the accuracy of the ratio measurement. Results are reported which show that even large variations in the experimental conditions (number of PCR cycles, sample volumes and extracted DNA quality) did not interfere with the precision of the measurement of the competitor/genomic ratio.     

Quantification of mRNA expression by competitive PCR using non-homologous competitors containing a shifted restriction site

Despite the recent introduction of real-time PCR methods, competitive PCR techniques continue to play an important role in nucleic acid quantification because of the significantly lower cost of equipment and consumables. Here we describe a shifted restriction-site competitive PCR (SRS-cPCR) assay based on a modified type of competitor. The competitor fragments are designed to contain a recognition site for a restriction endonuclease that is also present in the target sequence to be quantified, but in a different position. Upon completion of the PCR, the amplicons are digested in the same tube with a single restriction enzyme, without the need to purify PCR products. The generated competitor- and target-specific restriction fragments display different sizes, and can be readily separated by electrophoresis and quantified by image analysis. Suboptimal digestion affects competitor- and target-derived amplicons to the same extent, thus eliminating the problem of incorrect quantification as a result of incomplete digestion of PCR products. We have established optimized conditions for a panel of 20 common restriction endonucleases permitting efficient digestion in PCR buffer. It is possible, therefore, to find a suitable restriction site for competitive PCR in virtually any sequence of interest. The assay presented is inexpensive, widely applicable, and permits reliable and accurate quantification of nucleic acid targets.     

Competitive touchdown PCR for estimation of Escherichia coli DNA recovery in soil DNA extraction

Competitive approaches have shown promise for overcoming some of the difficulties in the use of PCR for assessment of specific bacterial species in soil. A competitive touchdown PCR (cTD-PCR) protocol specific for the rrsB gene of Escherichia coli was developed for tracking the organism in environments impacted by human wastes. Regression of product ratios from co-amplification of varying amounts of analyte and competitor DNA templates was linear. To test the robustness of the method, reactions were titrated with an extract of sterilized soil; no significant effect was detected. The cTD-PCR was used to assay recovery of E. coli DNA from soil. Stock DNA was spiked onto two sterilized soils during extraction, and the purified extracts were analyzed by cTD-PCR. Recovery of DNA spiked at a rate of 180 ng g(-1) was 34+/-7% (mean+/-S.D.) for an agricultural silt loam. DNA spiked at 1.8 pg g(-1) was recovered at a mean rate of 6.1+/-1.3%. DNA in these extracts was not directly quantifiable by image analysis. The cTD-PCR method provides a useful means of quantifying small amounts of E. coli DNA, and could be modified for other specific targets in a mixture of DNA from a variety of organisms.     

QUANTITATIVE PCR DATA FALSIFY THE CHROMOSOMAL ENDOREDUPLICATION HYPOTHESIS FOR VOLVOX CARTERI (VOLVOCALES, CHLOROPHYTA)

Two conflicting hypotheses for chromosome replication in the Volvocaceae, one postulating multiple rounds of replication prior to cell division (endoreduplication) and the other claiming a canonical sequence of one round of nuclear DNA replication preceding each cell division, have been tested experimentally. Competitive PCR of the single-copy actin gene (target) of Volvox carteri f. nagariensis Iyengar and a shortened gene version (competitor) containing the same primer binding sites were used to assess the genome equivalents present in a given number of cells. Determining the molar ratio of the PCR products generated from target DNA (extracted from a known number of cells) and defined numbers of competitor molecules revealed that Volvox embryos between the one- and 16-cell stages possess an average of between one and two—but never more than two—copies of the actin gene. This led us to conclude that the number of genome equivalents per nucleus in dividing Volvox embryos varies only between one and two and that, unlike the case predicted by endoreduplication, the nuclear genome undergoes only one round of replication prior to each cell division.     

Microtiter format gene quantification by covalent capture of competitive PCR products: application to HIV-1 detection.

We have developed a simple gene quantification system using the competitive polymerase chain reaction (CPCR) followed by microtiter format analysis. CPCR is carried out using a mutant competitor with the same size as the target DNA product, and a minimal base exchange to insure the same amplification kinetics. One primer is aminated at the 5' end to produce PCR products that are captured onto carboxylated wells of microtiter plates through peptide bond formation. The non-aminated DNA strands are stripped off from the wells by alkali washing, and the remaining aminated strands are hybridized with either a digoxigenin-labeled wild type-specific oligonucleotide probe or a competitor-specific probe. To standardize the hybridization conditions of the probes, a DNA construct containing wild type and mutant competitor sequences in tandem is captured at different concentrations, hybridized with the probes, and used to generate a standard curve. Bound probes are detected by anti-digoxigenin antibody conjugated with peroxidase and chromogen. Optical densities are recorded with a conventional microtiter plate reader and converted to concentrations according to the standard curves. The ratios of wild type DNA to mutant competitor are used to determine the initial amounts of wild type DNA in the samples. This method was used successfully to quantify human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) env gene in human lymphocytes. It only requires a thermal cycler and a conventional microtiter plate reader, and can be readily done on a large scale. Potential applications include detection of other pathogens, diagnosis of genetic disorders and studies of gene expression.     

竞争性RT-PCR测定法及BMP-2mRNA的定量检测

建立竞争性 PCR方法 ,以期用于转录水平基因表达的定量研究 .以检测大鼠颅骨骨细胞总RNA中骨形态发生蛋白 - 2 ( BMP- 2 ,bone morphogenetic protein- 2 ) m RNA含量为例 ,构建大鼠BMP- 2基因的竞争模板 ,以之为内对照进行竞争性 PCR.PCR反应结束后 ,电泳、拍照 ,扫描所扩增条带密度 ,作回归方程 .根据回归方程 ,计算出正常 7d Wistar大鼠颅骨总 RNA中 BMP- 2 m RNA含量为 1 .1 2 5amol/μg RNA.结果显示 ,成功构建了大鼠 BMP- 2基因的竞争模板 ,建立了可以测定大鼠颅骨骨细胞总 RNA中 BMP- 2 m RNA含量的竞争性 PCR方法 .     

Quantification of the carbazole 1,9a-dioxygenase gene by real-time competitive PCR combined with co-extraction of internal standards

The fluorogenic probe assay, competitive polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and co-extraction with internal standard cells were combined to develop a rapid, sensitive, and accurate quantification method for the copy number of a target carbazole 1,9a-dioxygenase gene (carAa) and the cell number of Pseudomonas sp. strain CA10. The internal standard DNA was modified by replacement of a 20-bp long region with one for binding a specific probe in fluorogenic PCR (TaqMan). The resultant DNA fragment was similar to the corresponding region of the intact carAa gene in terms of G+C content. When used as a competitor in the PCR reaction, the internal standard DNA was distinguishable from the target carAa gene by two specific fluorogenic probes with different fluorescence labels, and was automatically detected in a single tube using the ABI7700 sequence detection system. To minimize variations in the efficiency of cell lysis and DNA extraction between the samples, the co-extraction method was combined. A mini-transposon was used to introduce competitor DNA into the genome of other pseudomonads, and the resultant construct was used as the standard cell. After the addition of a fixed amount of the internal standard cells to soil samples, total DNA was extracted (co-extraction). Using this method, the copy number of the carAa gene and the cell number of strain CA10 in soil samples could be quantified rapidly.     

Maximizing signal-to-noise ratio in the random mutation capture assay

The 'Random Mutation Capture' assay allows for the sensitive quantitation of DNA mutations at extremely low mutation frequencies. This method is based on PCR detection of mutations that render the mutated target sequence resistant to restriction enzyme digestion. The original protocol prescribes an end-point dilution to about 0.1 mutant DNA molecules per PCR well, such that the mutation burden can be simply calculated by counting the number of amplified PCR wells. However, the statistical aspects associated with the single molecular nature of this protocol and several other molecular approaches relying on binary (on/off) output can significantly affect the quantification accuracy, and this issue has so far been ignored. The present work proposes a design of experiment (DoE) using statistical modeling and Monte Carlo simulations to obtain a statistically optimal sampling protocol, one that minimizes the coefficient of variance in the measurement estimates. Here, the DoE prescribed a dilution factor at about 1.6 mutant molecules per well. Theoretical results and experimental validation revealed an up to 10-fold improvement in the information obtained per PCR well, i.e. the optimal protocol achieves the same coefficient of variation using one-tenth the number of wells used in the original assay. Additionally, this optimization equally applies to any method that relies on binary detection of a small number of templates.     

Calibration-curve-free quantitative PCR: a quantitative method for specific nucleic acid sequences without using calibration curves

We have developed a simple quantitative method for specific nucleic acid sequences without using calibration curves. This method is based on the combined use of competitive polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and fluorescence quenching. We amplified a gene of interest (target) from DNA samples and an internal standard (competitor) with a sequence-specific fluorescent probe using PCR and measured the fluorescence intensities before and after PCR. The fluorescence of the probe is quenched on hybridization with the target by guanine bases, whereas the fluorescence is not quenched on hybridization with the competitor. Therefore, quench rate (i.e., fluorescence intensity after PCR divided by fluorescence intensity before PCR) is always proportional to the ratio of the target to the competitor. Consequently, we can calculate the ratio from quench rate without using a calibration curve and then calculate the initial copy number of the target from the ratio and the initial copy number of the competitor. We successfully quantified the copy number of a recombinant DNA of genetically modified (GM) soybean and estimated the GM soybean contents. This method will be particularly useful for rapid field tests of the specific gene contamination in samples.     

Development of a competitive polymerase chain reaction assay for the ruminal bacterium Butyrivibrio fibrisolvens OB156 and its use for tracking an OB156-derived recombinant

A competitive polymerase chain reaction assay targeting the 16S rDNA was developed for quantitating the rumen bacterium Butyrivibrio fibrisolvens OB156. A competitor DNA, serving as an internal control in the competitive polymerase chain reaction reaction, was constructed by polymerase chain reaction using a looped oligo longer than the normal primer. Coamplification of the target DNA with known amounts of the competitor DNA allowed quantitation of the target DNA in both pure culture and mixed culture systems, where minimum quantifiable level of OB156 was 1.7x10(2) and 5.6x10(4) cells, respectively. When an erythromycin-resistant recombinant derived from OB156 was inoculated into a rumen fluid culture, its numbers decreased with time. The rate of decrease measured by the competitive polymerase chain reaction assay was much slower than the rate determined by culture enumeration using erythromycin selection. The competitive polymerase chain reaction assay also showed 48 h persistence of the recombinant at 10(4) ml(-1) even after disappearance of culturable recombinant, suggesting maintenance of the target DNA from uncultivable cells. In an in vivo tracking trial, the recombinant became undetectable within 72 h with either assay, indicating rapid hydrolysis and/or outflow of the cells from the rumen.     

High-throughput transgene copy number estimation by competitive PCR

Transgene copy number affects the level and stability of gene expression. Therefore, it is important to determine the copy number of each transgenic line. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is widely employed to quantify amounts of target sequences. Although PCR is not inherently quantitative, various means of overcoming this limitation have been devised. Recent real-time PCR methods are rapid; however, they typically lack a suitable internal standard, limit the size of the target sequence, and require expensive specialized equipment. Competitive PCR techniques avoid these problems, but traditional competitive methods are time consuming. Here we apply mathematical modeling to create a rapid, simple, and inexpensive copy number determination method that retains the robustness of competitive PCR.     

Detection and quantitative measurement of transforming growth factor-beta1 (TGF-beta1) gene expression using a semi-nested competitive PCR assay

A polymerase chain reaction (PCR) technique was optimized for detection and quantification of very low concentrations (down to a few molecules) of transforming growth factor beta1 (TGF-beta1) mRNA. The strategy involved a combination of a competitive PCR assay and a semi-nested PCR. In the present study, the semi-nested PCR technique was tested in several rat organs containing different concentrations of target mRNA. A control fragment for TGF-beta1 was used to correct for differences in amplification of various cDNA samples. TGF-beta1 mRNA levels were also corrected according to the abundance of the "housekeeping" gene glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) mRNA in the same samples. The differences of sensitivity among the standard (one-step) and semi-nested (two-step) competitive PCR assays for the detection of TGF-beta1 are discussed. In conclusion, the semi-nested PCR protocol provides greatly enhanced sensitivity over standard PCR analysis. It is a reproducible and very specific method for quantification of only a few molecules of TGF-beta1 mRNA in a background of non-target molecules.