Experimental modelling of exine self-assembly

Living and fossil megaspores produced by Selaginella (Lycopsida) and its extinct ancestors form distinctive (and occasionally iridescent) exines. Ultrastructural studies of these spores have provided data that demonstrate a colloidal mode of development which in turn implies a degree of self-assembly in the construction of these exines. We present here experimental evidence in support of the theory of selaginellalean megaspore exine construction by depletion flocculation. Iridescent colloidal flocculations of polystyrene latex particles demonstrate an ultrastructural organization virtually indistinguishable from that of the biological system, and clearly demonstrate that self-assembly of complex Selaginella exines by a relatively simple construction process is plausible.     

Pollen wall ontogeny in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Polemonium caeruleum</Emphasis> (Polemoniaceae) and suggested underlying mechanisms of development

By a detailed ontogenetic study of Polemonium caeruleum pollen, tracing each stage of development at high TEM resolution, we aim to understand the establishment of the pollen wall and to unravel the mechanisms underlying sporoderm development. The main steps of exine ontogeny in Polemonium caeruleum, observed in the microspore periplasmic space, are spherical units, gradually transforming into columns, then to rod-like units (procolumellae), the appearance of the initial tectum, growth of columellae in height and tectum in thickness and initial sporopollenin accumulation on them, the appearance of the endexine lamellae and of dark-contrasted particles on the tectum, the appearance of a sponge-like layer and of the intine in aperture sites, the appearance of the foot layer on the base of the sponge-like layer and of spinules on the tectum, and massive sporopollenin accumulation. This sequence of developmental events fits well to the sequence of self-assembling micellar mesophases. This gives (together with earlier findings and experimental exine simulations) strong evidence that genome and self-assembly probably share control of exine formation. It is highly probable that self-assembly is an intrinsic instrument of evolution.     

Role of genetic control and self-assembly in gametophyte sporoderm ontogeny: Hypotheses and experiment

A review of our own and literature data on the mechanisms of sporoderm (the wall of pollen grains and spores) development is presented in terms of colloidal interactions—the so-called micellar hypothesis (Gabarayeva and Hemsley, 2006; Hemsley and Gabarayeva, 2007), which suggests the participation of self-assembly processes in development. The development of exine (sporopollenin-containing part of the sporoderm) in five plant species from remote taxa has been traced in detail and interpreted as a micellar sequence. An experimental modeling of exine-like structures carried out in vitro, in which physicochemical patterns of colloidal systems (hydrophobic interactions) were the driving force, is strong evidence for the relevance of the micellar hypothesis and the promising nature of these studies. The correlation between the role of genomic control and self-assembly in the development of complex biological walls is discussed.     

Developmental origins of structural diversity in pollen walls of Compositae

Compositae exhibit some of the most complex and diverse pollen grains in flowering plants. This paper reviews the evolutionary and developmental origins of this diversity in pollen structure using recent models based on the behaviour of colloids and formation of micelles in the differentiating microspore glycocalyx and primexine. The developmental model is consistent with observations of structures recovered by pollen wall dissolution. Pollen wall diversity in Compositae is inferred to result from small changes in the glycocalyx, for example ionic concentration, which trigger the self-assembly of highly diverse structures. Whilst the fine details of exine substructure are, therefore, not under direct genetic control, it is likely that genes establish differences in the glycocalyx which define the conditions for self-assembly. Because the processes described here for Compositae can account for some of the most complex exine structures known, it is likely that they also operate in pollen walls with much simpler organisation.     

Exine and tapetum development in Symphytum officinale (Boraginaceae). Exine substructure and its interpretation

After detailing the exine ontogeny, our purpose was to find out whether the sequence of sporoderm developmental events corresponds to self-assembling micellar mesophases, initiated by genomically determined physicochemical parameters and induced by surfactant glycoproteins at increasing concentrations. Indeed, a scaffolding of the future exine, i.e., the glycocalyx, initiates with scattered clots, which then appear as clusters of spherical and worm-like micelles, derived from surface-active glycoproteins. At the middle tetrad stage, a continuous layer of the glycocalyx emerges, consisting of parallel, tightly packed cylinder-like units, which we interpret as a layer of cylindrical micelles, the so-called middle mesophase. These units bear dark-contrasted particles, arranged in strings or columns. These sites of the glycocalyx units?Cmicelles accumulate initial sporopollenin, hence the term ??sporopollenin acceptor particles?? (SAPs). This process leads to the appearance of procolumellae at the late tetrad stage. The glycocalyx units are rooted into callose and into the microspore cytoplasm. After formation of the tectum and the foot layer, the endexine initiates as a thin layer, and the latter develops into a very thick layer in the post-tetrad period. When callose disintegrates, ??bouquets?? of SAPs become evident on the tectum, which were evidently hidden inside the callose layer; these structures self-assemble into supratectal gemmae. An unusual, ??hybrid?? type of tapetum was observed. What is observed in Symphytum exine development allows us to obtain more evidence for the hypothesis of the participation of micellar self-assembly in sporoderm development and to bring together the concepts of micelles and of SAPs.     

An integral insight into pollen wall development: involvement of physical processes in exine ontogeny in Calycanthus floridus L., with an experimental approach

We aimed to understand the underlying mechanisms of development in the sporopollenin-containing part of the pollen wall, the exine, one of the most complex cell walls in plants. Our hypothesis is that distinct physical processes, phase separation and micellar self-assembly, underpinexine development by taking the molecular building blocks, determined and synthesised by the genome, through several phase transitions. To test this hypothesis, we traced each stage of microspore development in Calycanthus floridus with transmission electron microscopy and then generated in vitro experimental simulations corresponding to every developmental stage. The sequence of structures observed within the periplasmic space around developing microspores starts with spherical units, which are rearranged into columns to then form rod-like units (the young columellae) and, finally, white line centred endexine lamellae. Phase separation precedes each developmental stage. The set of experimental simulations, obtained as self-assembled micellar mesophases formed at the interface between lipid and water compartments, was the same: spherical micelles; columns of spherical micelles; cylindrical micelles; and laminate micelles, separated by gaps, resembling white-lined lamellae. Thus, patterns simulating structures observed at the main stages of exine development in C. floridus were obtained from in vitro experiments, and hence purely physicochemical processes can construct exine-like patterns. This highlights the important part played by physical processes that are not under direct genomic control and share influence on the emerging ultrastructure with the genome during exine development. These findings suggest that a new approach to ontogenetic studies, including a consideration of physical factors, is required for a better understanding of developmental processes.     

Pollen morphology of Zehneria s.l. (Cucurbitaceae)

A growing body of experimental data obtained from sporoderm ontogenetic studies led to the appearance of the ‘micellar’ hypothesis. The hypothesis is that the sequence of sporoderm developmental events represents the sequence of self-assembling micellar mesophases, initiated by genomically given physico-chemical parameters, which are then picked up by physico-chemical self-assembly. However, besides morphological evidence, the best proof of this hypothesis would be an experimental modelling of sporoderm-like patterns. The main idea of this study is to remove the influence of the genome, selecting substances and their concentrations for simulations to replace it, and then to trace what ‘pure’ self-assembly is capable of constructing. Our aim in this study was to simulate mainly young structures in sporoderm development, i.e. the glycocalyx and the primexine. Several polysaccharide gels (as a callose substitute) and surfactants (as glycocalyx and sporopollenin monomer substitutes) were mixed at different concentrations and combinations, thermally set and left to condense. A number of patterns were obtained in colloidal solutions in the course of condensation, simulating structures at different stages of exine development. Their structures were observed and analysed with transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Our first experiments on the modelling of biological patterns in vitro have shown encouraging results.     

Pollen wall development in flowering plants

The outer pollen wall, or exine, is more structurally complex than any other plant cell wall, comprising several distinct layers, each with its own organizational pattern. Since elucidation of the basic events of pollen wall ontogeny using electron microscopy in the 1970s, knowledge of their developmental genetics has increased enormously. However, self-assembly processes that are not under direct genetic control also play an important role in pollen wall patterning. This review integrates ultrastructural and developmental findings with recent models for self-assembly in an attempt to understand the origins of the morphological complexity and diversity that underpin the science of palynology.     

Exine development: the importance of looking through a colloid chemistry ``window'

Most biological construction systems operate within the colloidal dimension. In view of this, it seems reasonable to reassess what is known of the early stages of exine development in the light of a brief excursion into colloid and micelle behaviour. The results of this analysis show remarkable similarity of structures and suggest that almost all of the features seen during early pollen wall development can be easily interpreted using simple, established colloidal principles. This study of exine framework and endexine development offers the possibility that growth of the early exine progresses by successive transitory mesophases of a constrained micellar system. The self-assembling micelle mesophases will all be clearly recognized as constituents of the developing exine. They include spherical, cylindrical, continuous layers of hexagonally-packed cylindrical units and lamellar mesophases which most probably correspond to future granules, columellae, complex columellar (and alveolar) microarchitecture and ``white-line-centred' lamellae. Furthermore, the various types of micelle involved have the potential to perform the functions previously loosely assigned to the exine.     

Development of the pollen grain wall: Further work withTradescantia bracteata

Summary Development of the pollen wall inTradescantia is examined between the tetrad stage and maturity, in the light of present controversy concerning the role of the tapetum in exine secretion, and the matter of the control of this process.The view that the exine in this plant is secreted entirely by the microspore protoplast is further substantiated, and is discussed in relation to sporopollenin production in general. An hypothesis is advanced to explain the mode of exine growth observed in all plants.Evidence is presented to support the contention that the sporophyte controls exine secretion through moieties inherited from the mother cell which are present in the spore cytoplasm.The differential phasing of exine development, observed to occur between species, is discussed in relation to general phase differences in pollen development, and the physiological condition of the whole plant.The plasticity of the intine inTradescantia is reported, and its importance considered in relation to the rigidity of the exine and the consequent disruption of that wall during the growth of a pollen grain.     

Aperture development in spores of the moss,Trematodon longicollis Mx.

Summary Young spores of the mossTrematodon longicollis Mx. are highly polar. Immediately after meiotic cytokinesis an extensive system of microtubules associated with the single plastid develops under the entire distal face. Following exine initiation on the distal surface a microtubule system is elaborated at the site of aperture development on the proximal surface. Both plastid and nucleus move from distal to proximal pole and are attached to microtubules of the proximal system. Microtubules underlie the plasma membrane as it withdraws from the exine in the initiation of both the surrounding annulus and central aperture pore. The central pore enlarges to form a bowl-shaped concavity in which a fibrillar plug develops basipetally. The annulus expands into a fibrillar-filled protrusion surrounding the central pore. The mature aperture consists of a central pore plug covered by a thin roof of exine and separated from the surrounding annulus by exine lamellae. The aperture of the mature spore is obscured by development of the ornate exine and is not a prominent feature of the mature spore surface.     

Studies on the Ontogeny of the Pollinium of Goodyera Procera

Using light, transmission and scanning electron microscopy, the development of the pollinium of Goodyera procera (Ker-Gawler) Hooker. was investigated. At the early stage, sporogenous cells inside the microsporangium were seen grouping together into small aggregates each containing few cells. After the aggregates have formed the sporogenous cells inside the aggregates (which could now be called massulae) divide to form numerous pollen mother cells. Later, the pollen mother cells undergo meiosis to form tetrads. The pattern of formation of the exine of tetrads varies according to the location of the tetrads inside the micro- sporangium. Those tetrads that are situated near the outer region of the massulae can form: exine with well developed tectum, bacula and foot layer; and the sequence of events leading to the formation of this type of well developed exine is as follows the original wall and the cyto- plasmic channels associated with the wall become surrounded by a thick layer of callose thus isolating the wall from the plasmalemma. Near the plasmalemma a layer of primexine containing callose and cellulose begins to form. Later, the primexine develops into exine and between the exine and plasmalemma a layer of intine is laid down. Similar type of exine with well developed tectum, bacula and foot layer, is also present in tetrads facing the tapetum. But in this case the original wall of the tedtrad is not retained but undergoes dissolution and in its place a new exine formed. The pattern of formation of exine in the region between tetrads is even more different. Here the original wall also undergoes dissolution but instead of forming a proper exine it only forms a thin foot layer with bulges at places. The pattern of formation of the exine in the cells inside the tetrad is even more different. Here the original wall of the cells only undergoes partial dissolution. The loose fibrils of the partially dissolved wall then become mixed with the callose layer surrounding the cell. Inside this wall-fibril/callose mixture thin sheets of exine appear, but these thin sheets of exine do not develop further into tectum or bacula. In Goodyera a quite substantial amount of callose is retained in the regions between massulae and tetrads, and we believe that it is this callose which is holding the massulae and tetrads together to form pollinium.     

Microspore and tapetal development in Echinodorus cordifolìus (Alismaceae)

In the microspore tetrad period the exine begins as rods that originate from the plasma membrane. These rods are exine units that on further development become columellae as well as part of the tectum, foot layer and “transitory endexine”. The primexine matrix is very thin in the future sites of the pores. At these sites the plasma membrane and its surface coating (glycocalyx) are without exine units and adjacent to the callose envelope. The exine around the aperture margin is characterized by units of reduced height. After the exine units and primexine matrix have become ca 0.2 μm in height a fibrillar zone forms under the aperture margin. It is the exine units around the aperture that are templates for exine processes on apertures of mature pollen. Oblique sections of the early exine show that the tectum consists of the distal portions of close-packed exine units. The exine enlarges in the free microspore period but initially its substructure (tectum, columellae, foot layer and transitory endexine) is not homogeneous and unit structures are visible until after the vacuolate microspore period. There are indications of a commissural line/plane (junction plane) which separates the foot layer from the endexine during early development. Our observations of development in Echinodorus pollen extend a growing number of reports of “transitory endexines” in monocot pollen. The exine unit-structures become 0.2 μm or more in diameter and many columellae are composed of only one exine unit. Spinules become exceptionally tall, many protruding ca 0.7 μm above the level of the tectum as units only ca 0.1 μm in diameter. The outer portion of the tectum fills in around spinules and by maturity they are microechinate with their bases spread out to ca 1 μm or more. Unit structures can be seen with SEM in mature pollen following oxidation by plasma ashing and in the tapetum these units are arranged both radially, as in spinules, and parallel with the tapetal surfaces. There are clear indications of such an arrangement of units in untreated fresh pollen. Units comprising the basal part of the exine are not completely fused by sporopollenin accumulated during development. This would seem to be a characteristic feature, based on published work, of the alismacean pollen. Our use of a tracer shows, however, that there is considerable space within or between exine structure of mature Echinodorus pollen. Based upon the ca 0.1 μm size of exine-units formed early in development and exine components seen after oxidative treatment it seems that the early (primary) accumulated sporopollenin has greater resistance to oxidation than sporopollenin added, secondarily, around and between units later in development. Both primarily and secondarily accumulated sporopollenin are resistant to acetolysis but published work indicates that acetolysis alters exine material. At the microspore tetrad time and until the vacuolate stages tapetal cells are arranged as in secretory tapetums. During early microspore stages there are orbicules at the inner surface of tapetal cells. At free microspore period tapetal cells greatly elongate into the loculus and surround the microspores. By the end of the microspore vacuolate period tapetal cells release their cellular contents and microspores are for a time enveloped by tapetal organelles and translocation material.     

Three-dimensional aspects of EXINE INITIATION AND DEVELOPMENT IN LILIUM LONGIFLORUM (Liliaceae)

Pollen development in Lilium longiflorum was reinvestigated with high resolution scanning electron microscopy, with special attention to three-dimensional conformation in the exine pattern formation. At the early tetrad stage, the invaginated plasma membrane takes the form of a reticulate pattern that corresponds to the mature exine tectum. Protectum is the first exine layer to be deposited on the reticulate-patterned plasma membrane. The initial protectum consists of aggregated fibrous threads and granules. Subsequently, probacules are formed under the protectum on the plasma membrane. At the free microspore stage the developing exine becomes further enlarged and the protectum develops into mature verrucate muri. The present three-dimensional investigation conflicts with the previous studies on exine development in Lilium.     

A new look at sporoderm ontogeny in Persea americana and the hidden side of development

Background and Aims

The phenomenon of self-assembly, widespread in both the living and the non-living world, is a key mechanism in sporoderm pattern formation. Observations in developmental palynology appear in a new light if they are regarded as aspects of a sequence of micellar colloidal mesophases at genomically controlled initial parameters. The exine of Persea is reduced to ornamentaion (spines and gemmae with underlying skin-like ectexine); there is no endexine. Development of Persea exine was analysed based on the idea that ornamentation of pollen occurs largely by self-assembly.

Methods

Flower buds were collected from trees grown in greenhouses over 11 years in order to examine all the main developmental stages, including the very short tetrad period. After fixing, sections were examined using transmission electron microscopy.

Key Results and Conclusions

The locations of future spines are determined by lipid droplets in invaginations of the microspore plasma membrane. The addition of new sporopollenin monomers into these invaginations leads to the appearance of chimeric polymersomes, which, after splitting into two individual assemblies, give rise to both liquid-crystal conical ‘skeletons’ of spines and spherical micelles. After autopolymerization of sporopollenin, spines emerge around their skeletons, nested into clusters of globules. These clusters and single globules between spines appear on a base of spherical micelles. The intine also develops on the base of micellar mesophases. Colloidal chemistry helps to provide a more general understanding of the processes and explains recurrent features of pollen walls from remote taxa.     

Exine formation in the pollinium ofDendrobium

Summary The position of the callose wall is related to the position of the primexine matrix that forms around the peripheral tetrads during microspore development of the compound unit, the pollinium. We report a combined freeze-fracture and freeze-substitution study of the events associated with early exine development. Stage one of exine development is deposition of protosporopollenin that is probably synthesised by the microspore and secreted to the primexine matrix where it is polymerised. Enzymes for the polymerisation of the protosporopollenin may be synthesised by the microspores and then transported, via the endoplasmic reticulum, to the plasma membrane. Stage two of exine development follows callose dissolution and deposition of tapetally derived sporopollenin. Hence exine form and exine deposition inDendrobium appear to be the result of intimate cooperation between the microspore, the plasma membrane, the callose and the tapetum.     

Recovery of exine from mature pollens and spores

A procedure has been devised for isolation and recovery of exine that is generally applicable to pollens and spores from a range of common species. Particles are suspended in an aqueous solution of 4-O-methylmorphine N-oxide and cyclohexylamine which swells them and loosens the exine layer. Gentle pressure in a teflon/glass tissue grinder releases protoplasts from exine and subsequent treatment with a mixture of cellulase and pectinase destroys attachments between intine and exine layers. The suspension is placed on a NaCl/Percoll step gradient to remove protoplasts and then the exine is cleanly separated from other cellular fragments on a step gradient of CsCl. The entire procedure can be accomplished at room temperature which greatly reduces possibility of chemical or physical modification of the exine. Moreover, the method is readily scaled up to production of exine in gram amounts which allows future study of the structural properties of its major biopolymer, sporopollenin.     

POLLEN GRAIN DEVELOPMENT AND TAPETAL CHANGES IN STRELITZIA REGINAE (STRELITZIACEAE)

The proexine that forms within the callosic envelope before the end of the microspore tetrad period is thick (about 1 μm) and exceptionally complex. It has components equatable with tectum, columellae, and a nexine that includes lamellar zones. All these components persist in the exine although late in development they become difficult to recognize because this exine is reduced in thickness, apparently by stretching, to a maximum of 0.2 μm. Strelitzia is an example of an exine template, with receptors for sporopollenin, that is not maintained during development. The Strelitzia microspore surface changes from an exine like that on an interaperture sector to the channeled intinelike system common for the apertures of pollen grains. The exine on sterile grains gives what may be a rare view of a stabilized immature exine. The mature exine on viable pollen grains resembles this early exine only in the most impressionistic way. Tapetal cells go through at least one cycle of hyperactivity, dedifferentiation, mitosis, and then again hyperactivity before they finally decline.     

Antioxidant properties of the pollen exine polymer matrix

The antioxidant properties of exine polymer matrix which forms the outer layer of pollen grain wall were studied. The main component of this matrix is sporopollenin - a unique biopolymer resistant to mechanical and chemical damage. The samples of isolated exine, purified from soluble compounds, were studied with EPR using stable nitroxyl radical TEMPO and DMPO spin trap. At the same time, we analyzed changes in fluorescence of DCFH which detected ROS in the solution. It has been established that exine effectively reduces TEMPO radical and eliminates hydroxyl radical. Also, the fluorometric analysis demonstrated that the exine eliminated H2O2, and this ability significantly decreased after treatment of exine with feruloyl esterase or mild alkaline hydrolysis (1M NaOH), i.e. after hydrolysis of hydroxycinnamic acid esters. After harsh hydrolysis (4M NaOH, 170 degrees C) of ethers bonds a large amount of hydroxycinnamic acids has been released, and exines have lost their antioxidant capacity almost completely. The obtained results point to the ability of extracellular polymer matrix of the exine to eliminate free radicals and H2O2 during crucial periods of male gametophyte development. The participation of ferulic acid and, possibly, of other hydroxycinnamic acids of sporopollenin in these processes has been demonstrated.     

Antioxidant properties of the pollen exine polymer matrix

The antioxidant properties of the polymer matrix of exine, the outer layer of pollen grain wall, were studied. The main component of this matrix is sporopollenin, a unique biopolymer resistant to mechanical and chemical damage. Samples of isolated exine purified from soluble compounds were studied with EPR using a stable nitroxyl radical TEMPO and a spin trap DMPO. At the same time, we analyzed changes in fluorescence of DCFH which detected ROS in the solution. It has been established that exine effectively reduced TEMPO and eliminated the hydroxyl radical. Also, fluorimetric analysis demonstrated that exine decomposed H₂O₂, and this ability significantly decreased after treatment of exine with feruloyl esterase or mild alkaline hydrolysis (1 M NaOH), i.e. after hydrolysis of hydroxycinnamic acid esters. After harsh hydrolysis (4 M NaOH, 170°C) of ether bonds, a large amount of hydroxycinnamic acids was released, and the exine almost completely lost its antioxidant capacity. The obtained results point to the ability of the extracellular polymer matrix of the exine to eliminate free radicals and H₂O₂ during crucial periods of male gametophyte development. The participation of ferulic acid and, possibly, of other hydroxycinnamic acids of sporopollenin in these processes has been demonstrated.