C4 anatomy can evolve via a single developmental change

C₄ photosynthesis is a complex trait that boosts productivity in warm environments. Paradoxically, it evolved independently in numerous plant lineages, despite requiring specialised leaf anatomy. The anatomical modifications underlying C₄ evolution have previously been evaluated through interspecific comparisons, which capture numerous changes besides those needed for C₄ functionality. Here, we quantify the anatomical changes accompanying the transition between non‐C₄ and C₄ phenotypes by sampling widely across the continuum of leaf anatomical traits in the grass Alloteropsis semialata. Within this species, the only trait that is shared among and specific to C₄ individuals is an increase in vein density, driven specifically by minor vein development that yields multiple secondary effects facilitating C₄ function. For species with the necessary anatomical preconditions, developmental proliferation of veins can therefore be sufficient to produce a functional C₄ leaf anatomy, creating an evolutionary entry point to complex C₄ syndromes that can become more specialised.     

Coleataenia prionitis,a C4-like species in the Poaceae

C₄-like plants represent the penultimate stage of evolution from C₃ to C₄ plants. Although Coleataenia prionitis (formerly Panicum prionitis) has been described as a C₄ plant, its leaf anatomy and gas exchange traits suggest that it may be a C₄-like plant. Here, we reexamined the leaf structure and biochemical and physiological traits of photosynthesis in this grass. The large vascular bundles were surrounded by two layers of bundle sheath (BS): a colorless outer BS and a chloroplast-rich inner BS. Small vascular bundles, which generally had a single BS layer with various vascular structures, also occurred throughout the mesophyll together with BS cells not associated with vascular tissue. The mesophyll cells did not show a radial arrangement typical of Kranz anatomy. These features suggest that the leaf anatomy of C. prionitis is on the evolutionary pathway to a complete C₄ Kranz type. Phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC) and pyruvate, Pi dikinase occurred in the mesophyll and outer BS. Glycine decarboxylase was confined to the inner BS. Ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) accumulated in the mesophyll and both BSs. C. prionitis had biochemical traits of NADP-malic enzyme type, whereas its gas exchange traits were close to those of C₄-like intermediate plants rather than C₄ plants. A gas exchange study with a PEPC inhibitor suggested that Rubisco in the mesophyll could fix atmospheric CO₂. These data demonstrate that C. prionitis is not a true C₄ plant but should be considered as a C₄-like plant.

     

Evolution of the C4 photosynthetic pathway: events at the cellular and molecular levels

The biochemistry and leaf anatomy of plants using C₄ photosynthesis promote the concentration of atmospheric CO₂ in leaf tissue that leads to improvements in growth and yield of C₄ plants over C₃ species in hot, dry, high light, and/or saline environments. C₄ plants like maize and sugarcane are significant food, fodder, and bioenergy crops. The C₄ photosynthetic pathway is an excellent example of convergent evolution, having evolved in multiple independent lineages of land plants from ancestors employing C₃ photosynthesis. In addition to C₃ and C₄ species, some plant lineages contain closely related C₃–C₄ intermediate species that demonstrate leaf anatomical, biochemical, and physiological characteristics between those of C₃ plants and species using C₄ photosynthesis. These groups of plants have been extremely useful in dissecting the modifications to leaf anatomy and molecular biology, which led to the evolution of C₄ photosynthesis. It is now clear that great variation exists in C₄ leaf anatomy, and diverse molecular mechanisms underlie C₄ biochemistry and physiology. However, all these different paths have led to the same destination—the expression of a C₄ CO₂ concentrating mechanism. Further identification of C₄ leaf anatomical traits and molecular biological components, and understanding how they are controlled and assembled will not only allow for additional insights into evolutionary convergence, but also contribute to sustainable food and bioenergy production strategies.     

Photosynthetic pathway alters xylem structure and hydraulic function in herbaceous plants

Plants using the C₄ photosynthetic pathway have greater water use efficiency (WUE) than C₃ plants of similar ecological function. Consequently, for equivalent rates of photosynthesis in identical climates, C₄ plants do not need to acquire and transport as much water as C₃ species. Because the structure of xylem tissue reflects hydraulic demand by the leaf canopy, a reduction in water transport requirements due to C₄ photosynthesis should affect the evolution of xylem characteristics in C₄ plants. In a comparison of stem hydraulic conductivity and vascular anatomy between eight C₃ and eight C₄ herbaceous species, C₄ plants had lower hydraulic conductivity per unit leaf area (K_L) than C₃ species of similar life form. When averages from all the species were pooled together, the mean K_L for the C₄ species was 1.60 × 10^?4 kg m^?1 s^?1 MPa^?1, which was only one‐third of the mean K_L of 4.65 × 10^?4 kg m^?1 s^?1 MPa^?1 determined for the C₃ species. The differences in K_L between C₃ and C₄ species corresponded to the two‐ to three‐fold differences in WUE observed between C₃ and C₄ plants. In the C₄ species from arid regions, the difference in K_L was associated with a lower hydraulic conductivity per xylem area, smaller and shorter vessels, and less vulnerable xylem to cavitation, indicating the C₄ species had evolved safer xylem than the C₃ species. In the plants from resource‐rich areas, such as the C₄ weed Amaranthus retroflexus, hydraulic conductivity per xylem area and xylem anatomy were similar to that of the C₃ species, but the C₄ plants had greater leaf area per xylem area. The results indicate the WUE advantage of C₄ photosynthesis allows for greater flexibility in hydraulic design and potential fitness. In resource‐rich environments in which competition is high, an existing hydraulic design can support greater leaf area, allowing for higher carbon gain, growth and competitive potential. In arid regions, C₄ plants evolved safer xylem, which can increase survival and performance during drought events.     

Linking vein properties to leaf biomechanics across 58 woody species from a subtropical forest

• Leaf venations have elements with relatively lower elasticity than other leaf tissue components, which are thought to contribute to leaf biomechanics. A better mechanistic understanding of relationships between vein traits and leaf mechanical properties is essential for ecologically relevant interpretation of leaf structural variations.
• We investigated 13 major (first to third order) and minor (>third order) vein traits, six leaf mechanical properties and other structural traits across 58 woody species from a subtropical forest to elucidate how vein traits contribute to leaf biomechanics.
• Across species, vein dry mass density (ρ_v), total vein dry mass per leaf area (VMA) and minor vein diameter (VD_min), but not the lower‐order vein density (VLA_1?2), were positively correlated with leaf force to punch (F_p) and force to tear (F_t). Structural equation models showed that ρ_v and VD_min not only contribute to leaf mechanical properties directly (direct pathway), but also had impacts on leaf biomechanics by influencing leaf thickness and leaf dry mass per area (indirect pathway).
• Our study demonstrated that vein dry mass density and minor vein diameter are the key vein properties for leaf biomechanics. We also suggest that the mechanical characteristics of venations are potential factors influencing leaf mechanical resistance, structure and leaf economics spectrum.

     

Genome‐wide transcript analysis of early maize leaf development reveals gene cohorts associated with the differentiation of C4 Kranz anatomy

Photosynthesis underpins the viability of most ecosystems, with C₄ plants that exhibit ‘Kranz’ anatomy being the most efficient primary producers. Kranz anatomy is characterized by closely spaced veins that are encircled by two morphologically distinct photosynthetic cell types. Although Kranz anatomy evolved multiple times, the underlying genetic mechanisms remain largely elusive, with only the maize scarecrow gene so far implicated in Kranz patterning. To provide a broader insight into the regulation of Kranz differentiation, we performed a genome‐wide comparative analysis of developmental trajectories in Kranz (foliar leaf blade) and non‐Kranz (husk leaf sheath) leaves of the C₄ plant maize. Using profile classification of gene expression in early leaf primordia, we identified cohorts of genes associated with procambium initiation and vascular patterning. In addition, we used supervised classification criteria inferred from anatomical and developmental analyses of five developmental stages to identify candidate regulators of cell‐type specification. Our analysis supports the suggestion that Kranz anatomy is patterned, at least in part, by a SCARECROW/SHORTROOT regulatory network, and suggests likely components of that network. Furthermore, the data imply a role for additional pathways in the development of Kranz leaves.     

Characterization of C₃--C₄ intermediate species in the genus Heliotropium L. (Boraginaceae): anatomy, ultrastructure and enzyme activity

Photosynthetic pathway characteristics were studied in nine species of Heliotropium (sensu lato, including Euploca), using assessments of leaf anatomy and ultrastructure, activities of PEP carboxylase and C₄ acid decarboxylases, and immunolocalization of ribulose 1·5‐bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) and the P‐subunit of glycine decarboxylase (GDC). Heliotropium europaeum, Heliotropium calcicola and Heliotropium tenellum are C₃ plants, while Heliotropium texanum and Heliotropium polyphyllum are C₄ species. Heliotropium procumbens and Heliotropium karwinskyi are functionally C₃, but exhibit ‘proto‐Kranz’ anatomy where bundle sheath (BS) cells are enlarged and mitochondria primarily occur along the centripetal (inner) wall of the BS cells; GDC is present throughout the leaf. Heliotropium convolvulaceum and Heliotropium greggii are C₃–C₄ intermediates, with Kranz‐like enlargement of the BS cells, localization of mitochondria along the inner BS wall and a loss of GDC in the mesophyll (M) tissue. These C₃–C₄ species of Heliotropium probably shuttle photorespiratory glycine from the M to the BS tissue for decarboxylation. Heliotropium represents an important new model for studying C₄ evolution. Where existing models such as Flaveria emphasize diversification of C₃–C₄ intermediates, Heliotropium has numerous C₃ species expressing proto‐Kranz traits that could represent a critical initial phase in the evolutionary origin of C₄ photosynthesis.     

Response of plasmodesmata formation in leaves of C4 grasses to growth irradiance

Rapid metabolite diffusion across the mesophyll (M) and bundle sheath (BS) cell interface in C₄ leaves is a key requirement for C₄ photosynthesis and occurs via plasmodesmata (PD). Here, we investigated how growth irradiance affects PD density between M and BS cells and between M cells in two C₄ species using our PD quantification method, which combines three‐dimensional laser confocal fluorescence microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. The response of leaf anatomy and physiology of NADP‐ME species, Setaria viridis and Zea mays to growth under different irradiances, low light (100 μmol m^?2 s^?1), and high light (1,000 μmol m^?2 s^?1), was observed both at seedling and established growth stages. We found that the effect of growth irradiance on C₄ leaf PD density depended on plant age and species. The high light treatment resulted in two to four‐fold greater PD density per unit leaf area than at low light, due to greater area of PD clusters and greater PD size in high light plants. These results along with our finding that the effect of light on M‐BS PD density was not tightly linked to photosynthetic capacity suggest a complex mechanism underlying the dynamic response of C₄ leaf PD formation to growth irradiance.     

Parallelism and diversity in multiple origins of c4 photosynthesis in the grass family

C₄ photosynthesis is thought to be an adaptation to warm environments, involving complex changes in the expression of genes governing photosynthesis, intermediary metabolism, and leaf anatomy and histology. Such complexity should be difficult to evolve, yet the pathway has arisen multiple times in the history of the flowering plants and at least four times in the grass family alone. We have used immunolocalization techniques to compare photosynthetic gene expression across all four origins, to determine which genetic changes occur in parallel and which are unique to a particular lineage. The only gene expression patterns common to all origins of the pathway are up-regulation of PEP carboxylase and down-regulation of RuBisCO in mesophyll cells. Both NAD-malic enzyme and NADP-malic enzyme are expressed in bundle sheaths. Expression patterns of light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b binding proteins and pyruvate orthophosphate dikinase appear to be lineage specific, and may be localized to bundle sheaths or to mesophyll or expressed throughout the photosynthetic tissue of the leaf. We suggest that future studies of parallel origin of the C₄ pathway concentrate on regulation of the two carboxylases, as well as the increased density of vascular tissue, which is the only histological characteristic common to all origins of the pathway.     

A Variation of C(4) Leaf Anatomy in Arundinella hirta (Gramineae)

The species Arundinella hirta L. posseses a striking variation of the leaf anatomy that is characteristic of C₄ grasses. In addition to a sheath of large, bright green cells around the vascular bundles, there are strands of large parenchyma cells which appear identical to the bundle sheath cells and which run parallel to the vascular bundles, but which are not associated with any vascular tissue. This species may be useful for studying the cellular compartmentalization associated with the C₄ pathway and should provide interesting material for determining the role of translocation in the functioning of the C₄ system.     

Transition from C3 to proto-Kranz to C3–C4 intermediate type in the genus Chenopodium (Chenopodiaceae)

The Chenopodiaceae is one of the families including C₄ species among eudicots. In this family, the genus Chenopodium is considered to include only C₃ species. However, we report here a transition from C₃ photosynthesis to proto-Kranz to C₃–C₄ intermediate type in Chenopodium. We investigated leaf anatomical and photosynthetic traits of 15 species, of which 8 species showed non-Kranz anatomy and a CO₂ compensation point (Γ) typical of C₃ plants. However, 5 species showed proto-Kranz anatomy and a C₃-like Γ, whereas C. strictum showed leaf anatomy and a Γ typical of C₃–C₄ intermediates. Chenopodium album accessions examined included both proto-Kranz and C₃–C₄ intermediate types, depending on locality. Glycine decarboxylase, a key photorespiratory enzyme that is involved in the decarboxylation of glycine, was located predominantly in the mesophyll (M) cells of C₃ species, in both M and bundle-sheath (BS) cells in proto-Kranz species, and exclusively in BS cells in C₃–C₄ intermediate species. The M/BS tissue area ratio, number of chloroplasts and mitochondria per BS cell, distribution of these organelles to the centripetal region of BS cells, the degree of inner positioning (vacuolar side of chloroplasts) of mitochondria in M cells, and the size of BS mitochondria also changed with the change in glycine decarboxylase localization. All Chenopodium species examined were C₃-like regarding activities and amounts of C₃ and C₄ photosynthetic enzymes and δ¹³C values, suggesting that these species perform photosynthesis without contribution of the C₄ cycle. This study demonstrates that Chenopodium is not a C₃ genus and is valuable for studying evolution of C₃–C₄ intermediates.

     

Occurrence and ecological characteristics of C4 dicot and Cyperaceae species in the Hungarian flora

The non-graminaceous wild flora of Hungary was screened for C₄ plants by using the stable carbon isotope ratio, the leaf anatomy and the photosynthetic carbon dioxide compensation concentration to determine the photosynthetic pathway type. On the whole, 31 C₄ species (native or naturalized) were found in the Amaranthaceae, Chenopodiaceae, Cyperaceae, Euphorbiaceae, Portulacaceae and Zygophyllaceae families. Together with the 26 C₄ grass species (Poaceae) reported earlier (Kalapos 1991), a total of 57 wild C₄ species occur in Hungary, which forms 2.6 % of the country's angiosperm flora. This figure is somewhat higher than what was expected on climatic grounds, a fact probably due to certain edaphic conditions favouring C₄ plant growth. In Hungary, the C₄ species are predominantly annuals growing in open habitats such as dry grasslands, inland saline areas, temporarily exposed riverbeds and disturbed sites. In comparison with C₃ plants, the C₄ species have higher temperature and light preferences, and their phenology lags behind that of the C₃ plants. These differences might account for C₄ plants being usually excluded from productive biotopes in Hungary, where the C₃ canopy may become closed during the growing season before C₄ plants can start their ontogenetic development. Ecological properties of C₃ and C₄ plants differ considerably in the Cyperaceae, but much less in the Chenopodianceae family. Among C₄ annuals naturalized aliens are common, most of which colonized hungary in the last two centuries. Increasing preponderance of C₄ plants is anticipated in the future as a consequence of possible climate changes and the ever increasing human impact on terrestrial vegetation. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

The effects of intervessel pit characteristics on xylem hydraulic efficiency and photosynthesis in hemiepiphytic and non‐hemiepiphytic Ficus species

Xylem vulnerability to cavitation and hydraulic efficiency are directly linked to fine‐scale bordered pit features in water‐conducting cells of vascular plants. However, it is unclear how pit characteristics influence water transport and carbon economy in tropical species. The primary aim of this study was to evaluate functional implications of changes in pit characteristics for water relations and photosynthetic traits in tropical Ficus species with different growth forms (i.e. hemiepiphytic and non‐hemiepiphytic) grown under common conditions. Intervessel pit characteristics were measured using scanning electron microscopy in five hemiepiphytic and five non‐hemiepiphytic Ficus species to determine whether these traits were related to hydraulics, leaf photosynthesis, stomatal conductance and wood density. Ficus species varied greatly in intervessel pit structure, hydraulic conductivity and leaf physiology, and clear differences were observed between the two growth forms. The area and diameter of pit aperture were negatively correlated with sapwood‐specific hydraulic conductivity, mass‐based net assimilation rate, stomatal conductance (g_s), intercellular CO₂ concentration (C_i) and the petiole vessel lumen diameters (D_v), but positively correlated with wood density. Pit morphology was only negatively correlated with sapwood‐ and leaf‐specific hydraulic conductivity and D_v. Pit density was positively correlated with g_s, C_i and D_v, but negatively with intrinsic leaf water‐use efficiency. Pit and pit aperture shape were not significantly correlated with any of the physiological traits. These findings indicate a significant role of pit characteristics in xylem water transport, carbon assimilation and ecophysiological adaptation of Ficus species in tropical rain forests.     

Leaf anatomy is not correlated to CAM function in a C3+CAM hybrid species,Yucca gloriosa

Background and AimsCrassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) is often considered to be a complex trait, requiring orchestration of leaf anatomy and physiology for optimal performance. However, the observation of trait correlations is based largely on comparisons between C₃ and strong CAM species, resulting in a lack of understanding as to how such traits evolve and the level of intraspecific variability for CAM and associated traits.MethodsTo understand intraspecific variation for traits underlying CAM and how these traits might assemble over evolutionary time, we conducted detailed time course physiological screens and measured aspects of leaf anatomy in 24 genotypes of a C₃+CAM hybrid species, Yucca gloriosa (Asparagaceae). Comparisons were made to Y. gloriosa’s progenitor species, Y. filamentosa (C₃) and Y. aloifolia (CAM).Key ResultsBased on gas exchange and measurement of leaf acids, Y. gloriosa appears to use both C₃ and CAM, and varies across genotypes in the degree to which CAM can be upregulated under drought stress. While correlations between leaf anatomy and physiology exist when testing across all three Yucca species, such correlations break down at the species level in Y. gloriosa.ConclusionsThe variation in CAM upregulation in Y. gloriosa is a result of its relatively recent hybrid origin. The lack of trait correlations between anatomy and physiology within Y. gloriosa indicate that the evolution of CAM, at least initially, can proceed through a wide combination of anatomical traits, and more favourable combinations are eventually selected for in strong CAM plants.     

Effects of an inhibitor of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase on photosynthesis of the terrestrial forms of amphibious Eleocharis species

The leafless amphibious sedge Eleocharis vivipara develops culms with C₄ traits and Kranz anatomy under terrestrial conditions, but develops culms with C₃ traits and non-Kranz anatomy under submerged conditions. The culms of the terrestrial form have high C₄ enzyme activities, while those of the submerged form have decreased C₄ enzyme activities. The culms accumulate ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) in the mesophyll cells (MC) and the bundle sheath cells. The Rubisco in the MC may be responsible for the operation of the C₃ pathway in the submerged form. To verify the presence of the C₃ cycle in the MC, we examined the effects of 3,3-dichloro-2-(dihydroxyphosphinoylmethyl) -propenoate (DCDP), an inhibitor of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC), on photosynthesis in culms of the terrestrial forms of E. vivipara and related amphibious species, E. baldwinii and E. retroflexa ssp. chaetaria. When 1 mM DCDP was fed via the transpiration stream to excised leaves, photosynthesis was inhibited completely in Fimbristylis dichotoma (C₄ control), but by only 20% in potato (C₃ control). In the terrestrial Eleocharis plants, the degree of inhibition of photosynthesis by DCDP was intermediate between those of the C₄ and C₃ plants, at 58–81%. These results suggest that photosynthesis under DCDP treatment in the terrestrial Eleocharis plants is due mainly to fixation of atmospheric CO₂ by Rubisco and probably the C₃ cycle in the MC. These features are reminiscent of those in C₄-like plants. Differential effects of DCDP on photosynthesis of the 3 Eleocharis species are discussed in relation to differences in the degree of Rubisco accumulation and C₃ activity in the MC. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Shifts in leaf vein density through accelerated vein formation in C4 Flaveria (Asteraceae)

Background and Aims

Leaf venation in many C₄ species is characterized by high vein density, essential in facilitating rapid intercellular diffusion of C₄ photosynthetic metabolites between different tissues (mesophyll, bundle sheath). Greater vein density has been hypothesized to be an early step in C₄ photosynthesis evolution. Development of C₄ vein patterning is thought to occur from either accelerated or prolonged procambium formation, relative to ground tissue development.

Methods

Cleared and sectioned tissues of phylogenetically basal C₃ Flaveria robusta and more derived C₄ Flaveria bidentis were compared for vein pattern in mature leaves and vein pattern formation in developing leaves.

Key Results

In mature leaves, major vein density did not differ between C₃ and C₄ Flaveria species, whereas minor veins were denser in C₄ species than in C₃ species. The developmental study showed that both major and minor vein patterning in leaves of C₃ and C₄ species were initiated at comparable stages (based on leaf length). An additional vein order in the C₄ species was observed during initiation of the higher order minor veins compared with the C₃ species. In the two species, expansion of bundle sheath and mesophyll cells occurred after vein pattern was complete and xylem differentiation was continuous in minor veins. In addition, mesophyll cells ceased dividing sooner and enlarged less in C₄ species than in C₃ species.

Conclusions

Leaf vein pattern characteristic to C₄ Flaveria was achieved primarily through accelerated and earlier offset of higher order vein formation, rather than other modifications in the timing of vein pattern formation, as compared with C₃ species. Earlier cessation of mesophyll cell division and reduced expansion also contributed to greater vein density in the C₄ species. The relatively late expansion of bundle sheath and mesophyll cells shows that vein patterning precedes ground tissue development in C₄ species.Key words: Bundle sheath, C₄ photosynthesis evolution, Flaveria, heterochrony, leaf development, mesophyll, vein density, vein pattern formation     

Research into the characteristics of C3 and C4 plants inCeratophyllum demersum L.

Summary The leaf anatomy was investigated with respect to the arrangement of cells involved in photosynthesis. The full-grown leaf has one vascular bundle consisting mainly of phioem cells. In similarity to terrestrial C₄ plants the vascular bundle is surrounded by mesophyll bundle sheath cells. However, in contrast to C₄ plants, these cells do not contain chlorophyll or starch inCeratophyllum. The early products in photosynthesis (10 seconds¹⁴C labelling) were analyzed. Although no complete separation of all radioactivity in the plant extracts was reached, it was clear that malate was the major labelled component, indicating C₄ activity in the plants. No light saturation could be proven inCeratophyllum in several stages of post-dormancy in a statistically significant way, although a tendency to light saturation was observed at intensities higher than 36 Wm^–2. The photosynthetic activity was only slightly depressed by enhancement of the O₂ concentration in the medium.     

Trait differences between grass species along a climatic gradient in South and North America

Question: Are trait differences between grasses along a gradient related to climatic variables and/or photosynthetic pathway? Location: Temperate grassland areas of South and North America. Methods: In a common garden experiment, we cultivated C₃ and C₄ grasses from grasslands under different climatic conditions, and we measured a set of 12 plant traits related to size and resource capture and utilization. We described (1) interspecific plant trait differences along a climatic gradient defined by the precipitation and temperature at the location where each species is dominant and (2) the association between those plant trait differences and the photosynthetic pathway of the species. Results: Trait differences between grasses were related to the precipitation at the area where each species is dominant, and to the photosynthetic pathway of the species. Leaf length, leaf width, plant height, leaf area per tiller, specific leaf area, leaf δ¹³C ratio, and nitrogen resorption efficiency increased while leaf dry matter content and nitrogen concentration in senesced leaves decreased as precipitation increased. A proportion of these changes along the gradient was related to the photosynthetic pathway because dominant grass species in cold areas with low precipitation are mainly C₃ and those from warm and wet areas are C₄. Conclusions: A previous worldwide analysis showed that traits of graminoid species measured in situ changed slightly along climatic gradients (< 10% variance explained). In contrast, under a common environment we observed that (1) grass traits changed strongly along a climatic gradient (30‐85% variance explained) and, (2) a proportion of those changes were related to the association between photosynthetic pathway of the species and precipitation.