Selection of proteins with desired properties from natural proteome libraries using mRNA display

mRNA display is a powerful yet challenging in vitro selection technique that can be used to identify proteins with desired properties from both natural proteome and combinatorial polypeptide libraries. The physical conjugation between a protein and its own RNA presents unique challenges in manipulating the displayed proteins at a low nanomolar scale in an RNase-free environment. The following protocol outlines the generation of cDNA libraries derived from natural organisms as well as the steps required for generation of mRNA-protein fusion molecules, in vitro functional selection and regeneration of the selected cDNA library. The selection procedures for the identification of protease substrates and Ca(2+)-dependent calmodulin-binding proteins from natural cDNA libraries are presented as examples. The method can be generally applied to the identification of protein sequences with desired properties from various natural proteome libraries. One round of mRNA display-based selection can be accomplished in ~7 d.     

Identification of Amino Acids Essential for Antibody Binding by mRNA-Display Using a Random Peptide Library: An Anti-Human Tumor Protein p53 Antibody as a Model

Using a synthetic DNA library coding for random 10-amino acid peptides (R10aPL), mRNA-display was applied to the isolation of interactive peptides using a monoclonal antibody against human TP53 (hTP53) as a model. Display molecules consisting of peptides and the nucleotide sequences encoding them were synthesized in vitro and subjected to four to five cycles of affinity selection. Thirty-four clones each isolated in the 4th or 5th round were sequenced. A core sequence, (X)-S-D-L-(Z)-K-L essential for binding was found, in which (X) and (Z), though undefined, were mostly F or Y and W, respectively. Although no peptides that fully matched with hTP53 were found in the clones isolated, the core sequence was found in hTP53. A 10-amino acid peptide containing the core sequence was chemically synthesized to verify its binding with SPR. Its Kd value for the antibody was 6 nM. The amino acids in epitopes essential for binding could be identified by mRNA-display with R10aPL.     

Identification of epitope-like consensus motifs using mRNA display

The mRNA display approach to in vitro protein selection is based upon the puromycin-mediated formation of a covalent bond between an mRNA and its gene product. This technique can be used to identify peptide sequences involved in macromolecular recognition, including those identical or homologous to natural ligand epitopes. To demonstrate this approach, we determined the peptide sequences recognized by the trypsin active site, and by the anti-c-Myc antibody, 9E10. Here we describe the use of two peptide libraries of different diversities, one a constrained library based on the trypsin inhibitor EETI-II, where only the six residues in the first loop were randomized (6.4 x 10(7) possible sequences, 6.0 x 10(11) sequences in the library), the other a linear-peptide library with 27 randomized amino acids (1.3 x 10(35) possible sequences, 2 x 10(13) sequences in the library). The constrained library was screened against the natural target of wild-type EETI, bovine trypsin, and the linear library was screened against the anti-c-myc antibody, 9E10. The analysis of selected sequences revealed minimal consensus sequences of PR(I,L,V)L for the first loop of EETI-II and LISE for the 9E10 epitope. The wild-type sequences, PRILMR for the first loop of EETI-II and QKLISE for the 9E10 epitope, were selected with the highest frequency, and in each case the complete wild-type epitope was selected from the library.     

Simultaneous generation of aptamers to multiple gamma-carboxyglutamic acid proteins from a focused aptamer library using DeSELEX and convergent selection

By using the in vitro selection method SELEX against the complex mixture of GLA proteins and utilizing methods to deconvolute the resulting ligands, we were able to successfully generate 2'-ribo purine, 2'-fluoro pyrimidine aptamers to various individual targets in the GLA protein proteome that ranged in concentration from 10 nM to 1.4 microM in plasma. Perhaps not unexpectedly, the majority of the aptamers isolated following SELEX bind the most abundant protein in the mixture, prothrombin (FII), with high affinity. We show that by deselecting the dominant prothrombin aptamer the selection can be redirected. By using this DeSELEX approach, we were able to shift the selection toward other sequences and to less abundant protein targets and obtained an aptamer to Factor IX (FIX). We also demonstrate that by using an RNA library that is focused around a proteome, purified protein targets can then be used to rapidly generate aptamers to the protein targets that are rare in the initial mixture such as Factor VII (FVII) and Factor X (FX). Moreover, for all four proteins targeted (FII, FVII, FIX, and FX), aptamers were identified that could inhibit the individual protein's activitity in coagulation assays. Thus, by applying the concepts of DeSELEX and focused library selection, aptamers specific for any protein in a particular proteome can theoretically be generated, even when the proteins in the mixture are present at very different concentrations.     

Ca(2+)/Calmodulin-binding proteins from the C. elegans proteome

Calmodulin (CaM) is the primary Ca(2+)-sensor that regulates a wide variety of cellular processes in eukaryotes. Although many Ca(2+)/CaM-binding proteins have been identified, very few such proteins could be found from the genome-wide protein-protein interaction maps of Caenorhabditis elegans constructed by yeast two-hybrid screening. Using a genotype-phenotype conjugation method called mRNA-display, we performed a selection for Ca(2+)/CaM-binding proteins from a proteome library of C. elegans. The method allowed the identification of 9 known and 47 previously uncharacterized Ca(2+)-dependent CaM-binding proteins from the adult worm proteome. The Ca(2+)/CaM-binding properties of these proteins were characterized and their binding motifs were identified. The availability of such information could facilitate our understanding of the signaling pathways mediated by Ca(2+)/CaM in C. elegans. Due to its simplicity and efficiency, the method could be readily applied to examine the Ca(2+)-dependent binding partners of numerous other Ca(2+)-binding proteins, which may play important roles in many signaling pathways in C. elegans.     

Comparison of mRNA-display-based selections using synthetic peptide and natural protein libraries

mRNA display is a genotype-phenotype conjugation method that allows the amplification-based, iterative rounds of in vitro selection to be applied to peptides and proteins. Compared to prior protein selection techniques, mRNA display can be used to select functional sequences from both long natural protein and short combinatorial peptide libraries with much higher complexities. To investigate the basic features and problems of using mRNA display in studying conditional protein-protein interactions, we compared the target-binding selections against calmodulin (CaM) using both a natural protein library and a combinatorial peptide library. The selections were efficient in both cases and required only two rounds to isolate numerous Ca2+/CaM-binding natural proteins and synthetic peptides with a wide range of affinities. Many known and novel CaM-binding proteins were identified from the natural human protein library. More than 2000 CaM-binding peptides were selected from the combinatorial peptide library. Unlike sequences from prior CaM-binding selections that correlated poorly with naturally occurring proteins, synthetic peptides homologous to the Ca2+/CaM-binding motifs in natural proteins were isolated. Interestingly, a large number of synthetic peptides that lack the conventional CaM-binding secondary structures bound to CaM tightly and specifically, suggesting the presence of other interaction modes between CaM and its downstream binding targets. Our results indicate that mRNA display is an ideal approach to the identification of Ca2+-dependent protein-protein interactions, which are important in the regulation of numerous signaling pathways.     

Active-site peptide "fingerprinting" of glycosidases in complex mixtures by mass spectrometry. Discovery of a novel retaining beta-1,4-glycanase in Cellulomonas fimi

New proteomics methods are required for targeting and identification of subsets of a proteome in an activity-based fashion. Here, we report the first gel-free, mass spectrometry-based strategy for mechanism-based profiling of retaining beta-endoglycosidases in complex proteomes. Using a biotinylated, cleavable 2-deoxy-2-fluoroxylobioside inactivator, we have isolated and identified the active-site peptides of target retaining beta-1,4-glycanases in systems of increasing complexity: pure enzymes, artificial proteomes, and the secreted proteome of the aerobic mesophilic soil bacterium Cellulomonas fimi. The active-site peptide of a new C. fimi beta-1,4-glycanase was identified in this manner, and the peptide sequence, which includes the catalytic nucleophile, is highly conserved among glycosidase family 10 members. The glycanase gene (GenBank accession number DQ146941) was cloned using inverse PCR techniques, and the protein was found to comprise a catalytic domain that shares approximately 70% sequence identity with those of xylanases from Streptomyces sp. and a family 2b carbohydrate-binding module. The new glycanase hydrolyzes natural and artificial xylo-configured substrates more efficiently than their cello-configured counterparts. It has a pH dependence very similar to that of known C. fimi retaining glycanases.     

Catalytic Turnover-Based Phage Selection for Engineering the Substrate Specificity of Sfp Phosphopantetheinyl Transferase

We report a high-throughput phage selection method to identify mutants of Sfp phosphopantetheinyl transferase with altered substrate specificities from a large library of the Sfp enzyme. In this method, Sfp and its peptide substrates are co-displayed on the M13 phage surface as fusions to the phage capsid protein pIII. Phage-displayed Sfp mutants that are active with biotin-conjugated coenzyme A (CoA) analogues would covalently transfer biotin to the peptide substrates anchored on the same phage particle. Affinity selection for biotin-labeled phages would enrich Sfp mutants that recognize CoA analogues for carrier protein modification. We used this method to successfully change the substrate specificity of Sfp and identified mutant enzymes with more than 300-fold increase in catalytic efficiency with 3′-dephospho CoA as the substrate. The method we developed in this study provides a useful platform to display enzymes and their peptide substrates on the phage surface and directly couples phage selection with enzyme catalysis. We envision this method to be applied to engineering the catalytic activities of other protein posttranslational modification enzymes.     

Identifying and quantifying proteolytic events and the natural N terminome by terminal amine isotopic labeling of substrates

Analysis of the sequence and nature of protein N termini has many applications. Defining the termini of proteins for proteome annotation in the Human Proteome Project is of increasing importance. Terminomics analysis of protease cleavage sites in degradomics for substrate discovery is a key new application. Here we describe the step-by-step procedures for performing terminal amine isotopic labeling of substrates (TAILS), a 2- to 3-d (depending on method of labeling) high-throughput method to identify and distinguish protease-generated neo-N termini from mature protein N termini with all natural modifications with high confidence. TAILS uses negative selection to enrich for all N-terminal peptides and uses primary amine labeling-based quantification as the discriminating factor. Labeling is versatile and suited to many applications, including biochemical and cell culture analyses in vitro; in vivo analyses using tissue samples from animal and human sources can also be readily performed. At the protein level, N-terminal and lysine amines are blocked by dimethylation (formaldehyde/sodium cyanoborohydride) and isotopically labeled by incorporating heavy and light dimethylation reagents or stable isotope labeling with amino acids in cell culture labels. Alternatively, easy multiplex sample analysis can be achieved using amine blocking and labeling with isobaric tags for relative and absolute quantification, also known as iTRAQ. After tryptic digestion, N-terminal peptide separation is achieved using a high-molecular-weight dendritic polyglycerol aldehyde polymer that binds internal tryptic and C-terminal peptides that now have N-terminal alpha amines. The unbound naturally blocked (acetylation, cyclization, methylation and so on) or labeled mature N-terminal and neo-N-terminal peptides are recovered by ultrafiltration and analyzed by tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS). Hierarchical substrate winnowing discriminates substrates from the background proteolysis products and non-cleaved proteins by peptide isotope quantification and bioinformatics search criteria.     

Identification of Novel Peptide Substrates for Protein Farnesyltransferase Reveals Two Substrate Classes with Distinct Sequence Selectivities

Prenylation is a posttranslational modification essential for the proper localization and function of many proteins. Farnesylation, the attachment of a 15-carbon farnesyl group near the C-terminus of protein substrates, is catalyzed by protein farnesyltransferase (FTase). Farnesylation has received significant interest as a target for pharmaceutical development, and farnesyltransferase inhibitors are in clinical trials as cancer therapeutics. However, as the total complement of prenylated proteins is unknown, the FTase substrates responsible for farnesyltransferase inhibitor efficacy are not yet understood. Identifying novel prenylated proteins within the human proteome constitutes an important step towards understanding prenylation-dependent cellular processes. Based on sequence preferences for FTase derived from analysis of known farnesylated proteins, we selected and screened a library of small peptides representing the C-termini of 213 human proteins for activity with FTase. We identified 77 novel FTase substrates that exhibit multiple-turnover (MTO) reactivity within this library; our library also contained 85 peptides that can be farnesylated by FTase only under single-turnover (STO) conditions. Based on these results, a second library was designed that yielded an additional 29 novel MTO FTase substrates and 45 STO substrates. The two classes of substrates exhibit different specificity requirements. Efficient MTO reactivity correlates with the presence of a nonpolar amino acid at the a₂ position and a Phe, Met, or Gln at the terminal X residue, consistent with the proposed Ca₁a₂X sequence model. In contrast, the sequences of the STO substrates vary significantly more at both the a₂ and the X residues and are not well described by current farnesylation algorithms. These results improve the definition of prenyltransferase substrate specificity, test the efficacy of substrate algorithms, and provide valuable information about therapeutic targets. Finally, these data illuminate the potential for in vivo regulation of prenylation through modulation of STO versus MTO peptide reactivity with FTase.     

Isolation of cross-reacting antigen candidates by mRNA-display using a mixed cDNA library

The identification of cross-reacting antigens is an important process in the characterization of antibodies. We describe here the application of mRNA-display technology with a cDNA library for the isolation of cross-reacting antigens using a monoclonal antibody against human tumor protein p53 (hTP53) as a model. A mixed cDNA library constructed from mRNAs prepared from several human tissues and cell-lines was used for the mRNA-display. After several rounds of panning, five annotated polypeptides, topoisomeraseII-binding protein 1 (TOBP1), RAS protein activator like 2 isoform 1 (RASAL2), endosome-associated FYVE-domain protein (ZFYVE16), and utrophin (UTRN) as well as hTP53, were identified as cross-reactive antigen candidates. All of them had a consensus motif, -S-D-L-( )-K-L-, which was included in the known epitope of the antibody. They were synthesized in vitro, and their binding was compared by conducting a pull-down assay. In cross-activity to the antibody, they ranked as follows: ZYVE16 ≅ hTP53 ≅ TOBP1 > UTRN > RASAL2.     

Utilization of oriented peptide libraries to identify substrate motifs selected by ATM

The ataxia telangiectasia mutated (ATM) gene encodes a serine/threonine protein kinase that plays a critical role in genomic surveillance and development. Here, we use a peptide library approach to define the in vitro substrate specificity of ATM kinase activity. The peptide library analysis identified an optimal sequence with a central core motif of LSQE that is preferentially phosphorylated by ATM. The contributions of the amino acids surrounding serine in the LSQE motif were assessed by utilizing specific peptide libraries or individual peptide substrates. All amino acids comprising the LSQE sequence were critical for maximum peptide substrate suitability for ATM. The DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK), a Ser/Thr kinase related to ATM and important in DNA repair, was compared with ATM in terms of peptide substrate selectivity. DNA-PK was found to be unique in its preference of neighboring amino acids to the phosphorylated serine. Peptide library analyses defined a preferred amino acid motif for ATM that permits clear distinctions between ATM and DNA-PK kinase activity. Data base searches using the library-derived ATM sequence identified previously characterized substrates of ATM, as well as novel candidate substrate targets that may function downstream in ATM-directed signaling pathways.     

Activity profiling of human deSUMOylating enzymes (SENPs) with synthetic substrates suggests an unexpected specificity of two newly characterized members of the family

SENPs [Sentrin/SUMO (small ubiquitin-related modifier)-specific proteases] include proteases that activate the precursors of SUMOs, or deconjugate SUMOs attached to target proteins. SENPs are usually assayed on protein substrates, and for the first time we demonstrate that synthetic substrates can be convenient tools in determining activity and specificity of these proteases. We synthesized a group of short synthetic peptide fluorogenic molecules based on the cleavage site within SUMOs. We demonstrate the activity of human SENP1, 2, 5, 6, 7 and 8 on these substrates. A parallel positional scanning approach using a fluorogenic tetrapeptide library established preferences of SENPs in the P3 and P4 positions that allowed us to design optimal peptidyl reporter substrates. We show that the specificity of SENP1, 2, 5 and 8 on the optimal peptidyl substrates matches their natural protein substrates, and that the presence of the SUMO domain enhances catalysis by 2-3 orders of magnitude. We also show that SENP6 and 7 have an unexpected specificity that distinguishes them from other members of the family, implying that, in contrast to previous predictions, their natural substrate(s) may not be SUMO conjugates.     

Preparation of fluorescence quenched libraries containing interchain disulphide bonds for studies of protein disulphide isomerases

Protein disulphide isomerase is an enzyme that catalyses disulphide redox reactions in proteins. In this paper, fluorogenic and interchain disulphide bond containing peptide libraries and suitable substrates, useful in the study of protein disulphide isomerase, are described. In order to establish the chemistry required for the generation of a split-synthesis library, two substrates containing an interchain disulphide bond, a fluoroescent probe and a quencher were synthesized. The library consists of a Cys residue flanked by randomized amino acid residues at both sides and the fluoroescent Abz group at the amino terminal. All the 20 natural amino acids except Cys were employed. The library was linked to PEGA‒beads via methionine so that the peptides could be selectively removed from the resin by cleavage with CNBr. A disulphide bridge was formed between the bead‒linked library and a peptide containing the quenching chromophore (Tyr(NO₂)) and Cys(pNpys) activated for reaction with a second thiol. The formation and cleavage of the interchain disulphide bonds in the library were monitored under a fluoroescence microscope. Substrates to investigate the properties of protein disulphide isomerase in solution were also synthesized. © 1998 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Ribosome display selection of a metal-binding motif from an artificial peptide library

A new ribosome display system was applied for the in vitro selection of a metal-binding motif from an artificial peptide library. The display system consisted of an mRNA-associating protein, a ribosome, and mRNA. The protein part of this display system was designed to provide a random peptide library and to stabilize the ribosome display. The random peptide library was newly designed to isolate stable metal-binding motifs. We employed the system for in vitro selection and found several new proteins and peptides that bind Co(II)-immobilized resin and Co(II)-complex, respectively. This newly developed system can be conveniently applied to the in vitro selection of peptide aptamers.     

Mapping the human proteome for non-redundant peptide islands

We describe immune-proteome structures using libraries of protein fragments that define a structural immunological alphabet. We propose and validate such an alphabet as i) composed of letters of five consecutive amino acids, pentapeptide units being sufficient minimal antigenic determinants in a protein, and ii) characterized by low-similarity to human proteins, so representing structures unknown to the host and potentially able to evoke an immune response. In this context, we have thoroughly sifted through the entire human proteome searching for non-redundant protein motifs. Here, for the first time, a complete sequence redundancy dissection of the human proteome has been conducted. The non-redundant peptide islands in the human proteome have been quantified and catalogued according to the amino acid length. The library of uniquely occurring n-peptide sequences that was obtained is characterized by a logarithmic decrease of the number of non-redundant peptides as a function of the peptide length. This library represents a highly specific catalogue of molecular protein signatures, the possible use of which in cancer/autoimmunity research is discussed, with a major focus on non-redundant dodecamer sequences.     

Direct measurement via phage titre of the dissociation constants in solution of fusion phage-substrate complexes.

Studies of interactions between filamentous fusion phage particles and protein or nucleic acid molecules have gained increasing importance with recent successes of screening techniques based upon random phage display libraries (biopanning). Since a number of different phage are usually obtained by biopanning, it is useful to compare quantitatively the binding affinities of individual phage for the substrate used for selection. A procedure is described for determination of relative dissociation constants (KdRel) between filamentous phage carrying peptide fusions to the coat protein gpIII and substrates in solution. This novel method is based on the measurement of phage titres. Phage selected from a random fusion phage library for binding to a monoclonal antibody or a viral structural protein exhibited KdRel values in the nanomolar and micromolar ranges for their respective substrates, thus validating the method over a wide range of binding affinities.     

Trapping of peptide-based surrogates in an artificially created channel of cytochrome c peroxidase

As recently described, the deliberate removal of the proposed electron transfer pathway from cytochrome c peroxidase resulted in the formation of an extended ligand-binding channel. The engineered channel formed a template for the removed peptide segment, suggesting that synthetic surrogates might be introduced to replace the native electron transfer pathway. This approach could be united with the recent development of sensitizer-linked substrates to initiate and study electron transfer, allowing access to unresolved issues about redox mechanism of the enzyme. Here, we present the design, synthesis, and screening of a peptide library containing natural and unnatural amino acids to identify the structural determinants for binding this channel mutant. Only one peptide, (benzimidazole-propionic acid)-Gly-Ala-Ala, appeared to interact, and gave evidence for both reversible and kinetically trapped binding, suggesting multiple conformations for the channel protein. Notably, this peptide was the most analogous to the removed electron transfer sequence, supporting the use of a cavity-template strategy for design of specific sensitizer-linked substrates as replacements for the native electron transfer pathway.