A comparison of three sampling techniques to estimate the population size of caterpillars in trees

Three sampling techniques commonly used to estimate the population size of caterpillars and sawfly larvae in trees (branch samples, frass production, water basins), were compared with respect to sampling error and economic costs. At the level of tree populations (e.g. forests), on an arbitrary date, the mean caterpillar intensity per tree (expressed in numbers of larvae or their biomass per 100 shoots) was predicted from the mean frass production per tree (expressed in mg frass per m² forest floor per day). At the level of the single tree, the frass production on an arbitrary date was related to the population intensity, but, due to the large sampling error, did not provide an accurate prediction. Summing the frass produced over the whole season reduced this error and predicted the seasonal abundance of larvae in single trees, estimated as their maximum intensity or their density (numbers of larvae or their biomass per m² forest floor). The maximum population intensity was not related to the population density. The sampling techniques suffer from large errors unrelated to larval abundance. The main sources of error (i.e. weather or predation of the larvae) usually cause an underestimation of population size. Labour, the main cause of high costs, was low in the basin technique and high in the frass production technique. Possible ways of reducing errors and applications of the three techniques are discussed.     

A study of fungus flies (Dipteral Mycetophilidae) in beech woodland

Abstract. 1. A study was made of larval and adult Mycetophilidae in coppiced beech woodland in southern England. Adult mycetophilids were trapped throughout 1968 using sticky traps at ground level. Larvae inhabiting terrestrial fungi were collected from all sporophores from a defined area of the woodland floor between August and October 1968.
2. Larval mycetophilids were extracted from only 12.6% of all sporophores collected and from fifteen of thirty-eight species of fungi present. Some species of fungi were never inhabited by larval mycetophilids while others appeared to be highly attractive to them. Since it was not possible to identify the larvae beyond the level of tribe it was impossible to ascertain host preferences for different species. Peak numbers of larvae occurred at the beginning of September and the beginning of October.
3. Adult mycetophilids had two peaks of activity, the first in March and April when the dominant species were Boletina gripha and Phronia basalis and the second in autumn when species of the genus Mycetophila were dominant. Phronia basalis is a species whose larvae inhabit dead wood and the abundance of this species (40% of all adults) probably reflects the amount of rotting wood in this type of habitat. The autumn peak of adult activity was due to species known to inhabit agaric sporophores and came about 1 month after the peak of larval numbers in fungi.
4. The adult fauna was rich with 107 species representing about a quarter of the known British fauna. However, only twelve species were trapped in sufficient numbers to allow deductions concerning seasonal activity.
5. The results were discussed with respect to the problems of assessing populations of insects inhabiting fungal sporophores and to the previous work on this neglected group.     

Surveying an endangered saproxylic beetle, Osmoderma eremita, in Mediterranean woodlands: a comparison between different capture methods

Measuring population size is riddled with difficulties for wildlife biologists and managers, and in the case of rare species, it is sometimes practically impossible to estimate abundance, whereas estimation of occupancy is possible. Furthermore, obtaining reliable population size estimates is not straightforward, as different sampling techniques can give misleading results. A mark-recapture study of the endangered saproxylic beetle Osmoderma eremita was performed in central Italy by applying four independent capture methods within a study area where 116 hollow trees were randomly selected to set traps. Detection probability and population size estimates were drawn from each of these four capture methods. There were strong differences in detection probability among methods. Despite using pheromone and beetle manipulation, capture histories were not affected by trap-happiness or trap-shyness. Population size estimates varied considerably in both abundance and precision by capture method. A number of 0.5 and 0.2 adult beetles per tree was estimated using the whole data set by closed and open population models, respectively. Pitfall trap appeared the optimal method to detect the occurrence of this species. Since in the southern part of its distribution range, a single population of O. eremita is widespread in the landscape, and includes beetles from more than one hollow tree, conservation efforts should focus not only on preserving few and isolated monumental hollow trees, but should be extended to large stands.     

Virginity in haplodiploid populations: a comparison of estimation methods

1. The presence of ovipositing virgin females, who are able to produce only male offspring, may have several important consequences for the evolution of reproductive strategies.
2. The prevalence of virginity for five fig wasp species was estimated using three different methods: (1) the proportion of females developing in fruit that contained no conspecific males; (2) dissection of females caught on sticky traps; and (3) dissection of females that had emerged from their galled flowers into the fruit cavity.
3. The estimates obtained by method 1 (females developing in single sex broods) were lower than those obtained by the other methods.
4. Across species, the estimates obtained by method 1 (females developing in single sex broods) were significantly correlated with those obtained by method 2 (sticky trap caught females).
5. Mating with sperm-depleted males is unlikely to occur in these species.     

The growth and mortality of larval herring, Clupea harengus L., in the River Blackwater Estuary, 1978–1980

Herring larvae were sampled in the Outer Thames Estuary and the River Blackwater Estuary in the springs of 1978, 1979 and 1980. Data were collected on larval stage, yolk sac and post yolk sac, larval length and total larval numbers. Newly hatched larvae were 6.8±0.5 mm long and the growth rate of yolk sac larvae was estimated at 0.18 mm d⁻¹ ( L = 6.8±0.186 t ). The growth rate of post yolk sac larvae increased to 0.43mm d⁻¹ ( L = 11±48.0±43 t ). Mortality estimates, derived from total numbers in the summed estuary segments, varied between the years and the cohorts within the year. In 1979 the mortality rates were 0.061 d⁻¹ and 0.074 d⁻¹ for the two cohorts. The mean size of the larval population was estimated at 2.48×10⁹ (1.63–3.77 × 10⁹) which agreed well with population size estimates from egg laying and from catch in numbers at age together with estimated fishing mortality rates.     

Assessment of a trap for measuring larval supply of intertidal barnacles on wave-swept, semi-exposed shores

Larval supply and settlement of Semibalanus balanoides (L.) on a semi-exposed wave-swept shore in E Scotland were assessed by means of a new larval trap design. Two midshore sites were utilised throughout the peak of the 2001 settlement season (May 11–June 3). Larval supply was quantified by 176 ml baffled cylinder traps filled with a 4-M killing solution of urea in seawater. Larval trap washout of urea typically ranged from 25% per day under minimal wave action to a maximum of 39% under heavy wave action during an onshore gale. The maximum capture for a single trap was 334 cyprids over one tide. Significant and consistent positional effects, both on urea retention and larval capture, were found for replicate traps separated by 9 cm. These indicated fine-scale variations in hydrodynamic flow and larval supply over the substratum which will have implications for the quantification of spatial heterogeneity of larval input to the benthos. The retention of urea and larval capture efficiency generally were not compromised by traps being serviced daily, as opposed to tidally, except perhaps for captures at very low larval densities. Larval supply measured on a tidal basis was strongly correlated between sites (r=0.975), but supply at Site C was 5× that at Site T: the reduction at Site T could not be explained by its slightly shorter immersion time and hence ‘availability’ of cyprids alone. At Site C settlement was quantified for 5×5 cm quadrats of natural substratum cleared daily. Settlement on these clearances (subject to possible grazing by limpets) was quantified only from May 20–June 3, after the peak of larval supply on May 17, and the variation in larval supply explained 65% of the variance in settlement. The larval supply/settlement relationship at Site T was quantified using grooved acrylic panels. A high correlation coefficient (0.961) was obtained for the daily supply/settlement relationship for these panels over the period May 15–June 3, which included the peak of supply. Larval supply varied up to 15-fold within a site on consecutive tides and up to 100-fold between sites on the same tide. Although further improvements to both the larval trap and the settlement panels can be made, this larval trap does appear capable of providing high-resolution data on tidal or daily larval supply over a wide range of wave conditions and larval concentrations.     

Habitat and substrate influences on population and production dynamics of a stream caddisfly, Ceraclea ancylus (Leptoceridae)

SUMMARY. Population and production dynamics of Ceraclea ancylus (Vorhies), a leptocerid caddisfly with a univoltine life cycle, five larval instars, and a single cohort population, were examined in Brashears Creek, Kentucky. A systematic sampling approach that included analysis in riffle, pool, and waterwillow bed habitats was used and fourteen sampling transects were taken across Brashears Creek between May 1971 and July 1972. For each of the 70 m² samples taken along a transect, the depth, habitat, and substrate type were recorded. The number of C. ancylus cases and numbers and dry weights of each larval instar were determined. The majority of the C. ancylus population was in the second larval instar in July, the third larval instar in August, the fourth larval instar in September, and the fifth larval instar from October through May. The spring population was 30% of the early instar maximum estimated the previous August. The spatial distribution of C. ancylus reflects a logarithmic pattern with early instar larvae more highly clumped than the late larval instar and pupal populations. Initial standing stock estimates were less than 1% of the standing stock biomass. A production estimate of 9.9 mg/m²·year (dry weight) was determined using the instantaneous growth method, Allen's Curve method, and the Hynes method of estimating secondary production. Turnover ratios (7.0 annual TR, 5.7 cohort TR) were higher than estimates reported as typical for benthic macroinvertebrates because of the low initial to final mean individual weight of the C. ancylus larvae (0.4%). Production estimates calculated for C. ancylus populations in waterwillow bed (4.4 mg/m²·year) and pool (13.7 mg/m²·year) habitats were less than calculated for the riffle population (19.9 mg/m²·year). The annual turnover ratio (10.2) was higher in the pool population than in other habitats because of spring larval migration into the pool from other habitats. A trend of higher production estimates with larger sized substrate particles and increased numbers of particles may reflect the increase in available food sources or attachment sites. The accuracy of production estimates and their applicability to water resource management may be limited by a failure to consider the spatial distributions of the population being sampled and the tendency for sampling procedures to be confined to single habitats.     

Biases in Trapping Larval Amphibians in Playa Wetlands

Abstract: Standardized, effective sampling methods are required to monitor amphibian population trends and community composition. Funnel traps have been used to ostensibly estimate species richness and relative abundance of larval amphibians. We tested whether funnel traps can be used to provide unbiased estimates of amphibian community composition in playa wetlands by comparing seining—dip netting and passive funnel-trapping results. Plains spadefoots (Spea bombifrons) were more prone to be captured in funnel traps whereas New Mexico spadefoots (S. multiplicata) were less likely captured by funnel traps than by seines and dip nets. In playas funnel traps should be used only for collecting specimens and not for estimating amphibian community composition.     

A modification of the Lincoln Index for estimating the population densities of mobile insects

Abstract. 1. To estimate populations of D.oleae in olive groves on Corfu by mark—recapture techniques, McPhail traps had to be used for sampling.
2. The prolonged sampling period (24 h) resulted in a differential loss of marked flies from the area and this biased the population estimates obtained from the standard Lincoln Index.
3. A modification was devised which enabled the rate of loss of marked flies to be calculated and incorporated into the Index as a correction factor.
4. Field comparisons indicated that the modified Index gave more accurate population estimates than the standard Lincoln Index and therefore it may be applicable to other situations when 'instantaneous' sampling of populations is not practicable.     

Evaluation of yellow sticky traps for monitoring the population of thrips (Thysanoptera) in a mango orchard

Populations of several thrips species were estimated using yellow sticky traps in an orchard planted with mango, Mangifera indica L. during the dry and wet seasons beginning in late 2008-2009 on Penang Island, Malaysia. To determine the efficacy of using sticky traps to monitor thrips populations, we compared weekly population estimates on yellow sticky traps with thrips population sizes that were determined (using a CO(2) method) directly from mango panicles. Dispersal distance and direction of thrips movement out of the orchard also were studied using yellow sticky traps placed at three distances from the edge of the orchard in four cardinal directions facing into the orchard. The number of thrips associated with the mango panicles was found to be correlated with the number of thrips collected using the sticky trap method. The number of thrips captured by the traps decreased with increasing distance from the mango orchard in all directions. Density of thrips leaving the orchard was related to the surrounding vegetation. Our results demonstrate that sticky traps have the potential to satisfactorily estimate thrips populations in mango orchards and thus they can be effectively employed as a useful tactic for sampling thrips.     

松墨天牛成虫对幼虫虫粪挥发性物质的触角电位反应及林间驱避试验

为了研制松墨天牛Monochamus alternatus Hope驱避剂,本文利用触角电位技术和田间试验的方法研究了松墨天牛雌雄成虫对幼虫虫粪挥发性物质的触角电位反应及幼虫虫粪己烷提取物、合成化合物混合物的林间驱避作用。结果表明：α-蒎烯、β-蒎烯、3-蒈烯、柠檬烯和长叶烯均能引起松墨天牛雌雄成虫一定的触角电生理反应,而4-甲基-2,6-二叔丁基苯酚不能引起松墨天牛雌雄成虫的触角电生理反应。林间驱避试验结果说明,幼虫虫粪的己烷提取物处理过的树干上的刻槽数明显少于对照树干上的刻槽数,二者具有极显著差异;有合成化合物的混合物存在的诱捕器诱捕到的雌虫数（平均值3.80±1.02）与对照诱捕到的雌虫数（平均值16.80±1.16）差异极显著。结果显示α-蒎烯、β-蒎烯、3-蒈烯、柠檬烯、长叶烯和4-甲基-2,6-二叔丁基苯酚的混合物对松墨天牛雌虫具有驱避作用,有望开发出一类新的驱避剂。     

Testing assumptions of mark–recapture protocols for estimating population size using Australian mound-building, subterranean termites

1. Forager population size of two species of mound-building, subterranean termite ( Coptotermes lacteus , Rhinotermitidae and Nasutitermes exitiosus , Termitidae) was estimated using three mark–recapture protocols. These estimates varied widely within and between colonies (≈ 0.3–200 million for C. lacteus and 0.2–3 million for N. exitiosus ). The variation in the estimates is explained in part by violation of the assumptions of the protocols.
2. The fat-stain markers, although persistent in the laboratory, faded rapidly in the field, and were transferable from marked individuals to unmarked individuals by cannibalism.
3. Marked individuals did not mix randomly or evenly with unmarked foraging individuals in space or time, as marked individuals were recaptured in widely varying numbers at different feeding sites sampled simultaneously. Importantly, foragers displayed feeding site fidelity and avoided disturbed feeding sites.
4. The likelihood of recapture differed between castes and instars; there was a higher recapture rate of large workers and soldiers relative to smaller workers.
5. The mark–recapture protocols provided inaccurate and unreliable forager population estimates, up to two orders of magnitude larger than direct counts of entire mound colonies. Thus the weighted mean estimates from more complex triple-mark–recapture protocols were not necessarily better than Lincoln index estimates from simpler single-mark–recapture protocols.
6. Mark–recapture studies may provide useful information about forager behaviour and foraging territories.     

Dispersal capacity in the Mediterranean corn borer, Sesamia nonagrioides

Corn (Zea mays L.) borers are the primary target of Bacillus thuringiensis Berliner (Bt) transgenic maize. Management of corn borer resistance to Bt requires information on larval and adult dispersal capacities, a feature that is particularly unknown in Sesamia nonagrioides Lefèbvre (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae), the most damaging corn borer in Spain. Larval dispersal was studied over a 3 year period by infesting plants with egg masses and dissecting the neighbouring plants 7, 14, and 32 days later to measure larval dispersal at several ages. The number and age of larvae were recorded in the dissected plants. Only mature larvae dispersed in significant numbers; they moved at least to rows adjacent to those containing the infested plant, and down the row five plants. The percentage of larvae that dispersed from the infested plant was density‐dependent. Adult dispersal was studied with directional light and pheromone uni‐traps over 5 and 3 year periods, respectively. Directional light traps were placed in the margins between Bt and non‐Bt maize fields, half oriented towards each of the two kinds of maize field. Pheromone traps were placed in the Bt and non‐Bt fields at increasing distances (0–100 m) from the border. The numbers of males and females caught in directional light traps were not different in traps oriented towards Bt or non‐Bt fields, but the number of males caught in the third flight in Bt fields was lower than in non‐Bt fields. These results suggest that males from adjacent Bt and non‐Bt fields mate indiscriminately with females emerging in any of the two kinds of maize fields. However, male movement in the third flight may not be sufficient to randomly distribute males between the two fields.     

Zooplankton responses to predation by larval bluegill: an enclosure experiment

SUMMARY 1. Larval fish are gape-limited predators that forage on prey of specific sizes, and thus may be expected to differentially affect members of a zooplankton community, possibly altering the size-structure or species composition.
2. I used an enclosure experiment to look at the effect of predation by larval bluegill on the dynamics of two zooplankton communities, one dominated by large-bodied individuals and the other by small-bodied individuals. Enclosures containing these zooplankton received a zero, low, medium, or high density of larval bluegill predators.
3. Increasing larval density had a negative effect on zooplankton abundance and abundance declined similarly in the large-bodied and small-bodied communities.
4. Zooplankton size-structure, as estimated by the length of the average zooplankton, increased and then decreased during the experiment, decreasing faster at higher larval fish densities. When zooplankton size-structure was estimated as the length of the average cladoceran, size-structure declined in the large-bodied but not in the small-bodied community and the greatest decline in size-structure was seen in the medium and high larval density treatments.
5. Ordination of each community using multidimensional scaling (MDS) indicated that the trajectory of change in species composition differed between the presence and absence of larval fish. In both communities, the degree of response by individual taxa depended on the density of bluegill larvae. This effect on zooplankton abundance, size-structure and community composition suggests that larval fish may make an important contribution to zooplankton dynamics in many lakes and ponds.     

二化螟绒茧蜂对二化螟及其寄主植物挥发物的趋性反应

利用Y-型嗅觉仪研究了二化螟绒茧蜂Cotesia chilonis对寄主植物（水稻或茭白）、二化螟Chilo suppressalis幼虫、虫粪及虫害苗挥发物的行为反应。健康植株、二化螟幼虫和虫粪的挥发物对二化螟绒茧蜂具有显著引诱作用。在虫害苗与健康苗挥发物之间,二化螟绒茧蜂显著地偏好虫害苗,但当去除虫害苗中的幼虫和虫粪后,寄生蜂对去虫苗与机械损伤苗的选择无显著差异;在虫害苗与有虫健康苗之间,寄生蜂显著趋向虫害苗,表明虫害苗本身释放的挥发物对二化螟绒茧蜂引诱作用与机械损伤苗无显著差异,但与二化螟幼虫或虫粪挥发物之间可能具有协同增效作用。水稻苗经机械损伤或损伤后以二化螟幼虫唾液处理,其挥发物对二化螟绒茧蜂的引诱作用无显著改变。二化螟绒茧蜂对不同为害程度水稻挥发物的选择无显著差异。二化螟绒茧蜂对两种寄主植物的健康苗、虫害苗、取食两种植物的幼虫及虫粪的挥发物的选择无显著差异。结果表明,二化螟绒茧蜂栖境定位和寄主选择过程中所利用的挥发物主要来自寄主植物、二化螟幼虫和虫粪以及虫害苗与幼虫和虫粪的协同作用。     

Ecological methods for adult populations of Oryctes rhinoceros (Coleoptera, Scarabaeidae)

ABSTRACT. 1. For comparing assessment methods, O.rhinoceros (L.) populations were monitored in five 30–50 ha plots in southern Luzon, Philippines. No consistent correlations were found between number of beetles caught in traps, amount of palm damage and number of breeding sites. Apparently, plots were too small to account for fast dispersal of beetles.
2. Coconut cap traps baited with ethylchrysanthemumate attracted O.rhinoceros adults searching for breeding sites. Several factors were identified influencing catches but trapping was found to be unsuitable for accurately assessing pest populations.
3. A new method which gives estimates on the monthly number of O.rhinoceros attacks on coconut palms, was tested in the Maldives. Palms are climbed about once a year and the sequence of fronds, the number and the position of beetle cuts are recorded.
4. Reduction with age of the length of three teeth on the fore tibia of O. rhinoceros adults was studied in the Philippines. The data was insufficient to obtain a clear correlation between age and length of teeth.
5. The observations indicated that in the Philippines after leaving their site of pupation, O.rhinoceros adults spend about 5 weeks feeding on coconut palms. This is followed by a period of about 7 weeks in breeding sites and, on occasion, additional visits to palms. With these estimates it was possible to relate palm damage records with numbers of feeding adults.     

Invasion spread of Operophtera brumata in northeastern United States and hybridization with O. bruceata

We used five methods to estimate the rate of spread of the winter moth, Operophtera brumata L., a European Lepidoptera, invading the northeastern USA and occasionally hybridizing with the closely related O. bruceata. These two species utilize the same sex attractant and pheromone traps capture both species. We estimated spread based on the ratio of the two species captured in pheromone-baited traps. Population boundaries were derived from captures in a grid of traps and spread was estimated as 6.6 km/year based on displacement of population boundaries between 2005 and 2008. Radial spread rate was also estimated as 6.9 km/year from the displacement of boundaries using logistic regression of trap captures along a single east–west transect of traps deployed yearly from 2007 to 2011. We also estimated the rate of spread from the expansion of defoliation mapped during aerial surveys. Based on the displacement of defoliation boundaries from 2005 to 2008, spread rate was estimated as 6.0 km/year. Based on the year of first defoliation, spread was estimated as 4.8 km/year and regression of the square-root of the cumulative area/π versus time yielded an estimate of 4.7 km/year. All five estimates were similar, and differences reflect the nuances of the data from which they were derived. We discuss here how the occasional hybridization with O. bruceata may be either retarding or enhancing O. brumata spread.     

Trapping a local population of spruce bark beetles Ips typographus (L.): Population size and origin of trapped beetles

A method of trapping local populations of Ips typographus was investigated in the field. The size of a population emerging from a hibernation site in the forest litter was estimated using tent traps. This estimate was compared with another estimate where beetles from the population were marked and recaptured in pheromone traps. The estimate of population size with mark-recapture was much higher than the estimate with tent traps, indicating a high degree of immigration. According to calculations only a minor part (less than 20%) of the beetles caught in the pipe traps originated in the local population. Re-emerging parent-adults were marked and released during the second flight period. The recapture rate was 29.8%, almost the same as during the first flight. Immigration during the first and second flight periods was estimated to be of similar magnitude. The results show that it is difficult to suppress local populations of highly mobile bark beetles by trapping.     

Hydraulic microdistribution patterns of larval fire salamanders (Salamandra salamandra salamandra) in the Weidlingbach near Vienna, Austria

1. This study examined the longitudinal distribution of larval fire salamanders ( Salamandra salamandra salamandra L.) in the Weidlingbach system, a first- to fourth-order tributary of the Danube near Vienna, Austria. On the microhabitat scale, actual current velocities, Reynolds numbers and Froude numbers at larval locations were measured and larval positions mapped.
2. Larval densities were highest in shallow first- and second-order tributaries where mean current speeds were less than 20 cm s⁻¹, mean Reynolds numbers were less than 12 000 and mean Froude numbers were less than 0.30. Young larvae appeared on 26 April, fully grown larvae were observed from 11 May and larvae started metamorphosis from 27 June. Young adults left the brook between 26 August and 8 September. A severe flood on 25 May significantly reduced larval density, especially at sites near the source.
3. At a given sampling station young larvae favoured microhabitats exposed to only minor hydraulic stress. As larvae grew, they also colonized microhabitats with moderate current velocity (4–15 cm s⁻¹). At sites with generally low discharge, larvae were distributed over a wider range of current velocities than at sites with higher discharge; at the latter, larvae were constricted to sheltered microhabitats.     

Improving the accuracy of population size estimates for burrow‐nesting seabirds

Seabird numbers can change rapidly as a result of environmental processes, both natural and anthropogenic. Informed management and conservation of seabirds requires accurate and precise monitoring of population size. However, for burrow‐nesting species this is rarely achieved due to spatial and temporal heterogeneity in burrow occupancy. Here, we describe a novel method for deriving more accurate population size estimates that employs mark‐recapture methods to correct for unknown variation in nest occupancy throughout a breeding season. We apply it to estimate breeding numbers of a colonial, burrowing seabird, the Little Penguin Eudyptula minor, on the Summerland Peninsula, Phillip Island, Australia. Estimates of active burrow numbers during the September 2008 to February 2009 breeding season were adjusted to numbers of breeding birds based on burrow occupation and modelled population demographics at six, fortnightly monitored reference sites. The population was estimated to be 26 100 (95% CI: 21 100–31 100) and 28 400 (23 800–33 000) breeding Penguins in two temporally separated surveys within one breeding season. We demonstrate using simulation that the method is robust to variation in burrow occupancy throughout the breeding season, providing consistent and more accurate estimates of population size. The advantage of using the corrected method is that confidence intervals will include the true population size. Confidence limits widened as burrow occupancy declined, reflecting the increased uncertainty as larger adjustments for low burrow occupancy were required. In contrast, the uncorrected method that uses burrow occupancy alone as a measure of breeding numbers was inconsistent and significantly underestimated population size across much of the breeding season. Although requiring considerably more survey effort, the corrected approach provides a more accurate means for monitoring population changes in colonially breeding animals while collecting demographic data that can help diagnose the drivers of population change.