Infection of UV-irradiated xeroderma pigmentosum fibroblasts by herpes simplex virus: study of capacity and Weigle reactivation.

The capacity of monolayers of both normal human and xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) filbroblasts to support plaque formation by herpes simplex virus was decreased when the monolayers were ultraviolet (UV) irradiated and infected with virus. Fibroblasts of XP complementation groups A, B, and D were sensitive to UV, being 4-6 fold more sensitive than either fibroblasts of XP complementation group C or fibroblasts from a normal individual. When the monolayers were irradiated 4 days prior to infection, the capacity of normal fibroblasts to support herpes virus growth recovered, whereas the capacity of the XP strains decreased further compared to that measured when infection immediately followed irradiation. Concurrent experiments with UV-irradiated herpes virus showed that the survival of this virus did not increase when infection by irradiated virus immediately followed irradiation of the monolayers. However, if the monolayers were irradiated 4 days prior to infection, the survival of this virus increased by a factor of nearly 2. Such Weigle reactivation (WR) occurred at lower fluences to the XP fibroblasts than to normal fibroblasts, suggesting that WR results from residual cellular DNA damage left after excision repair.     

Host-cell reactivation of UV-irradiated and chemically-treated herpes simplex virus-1 by xeroderma pigmentosum, XP heterozygotes and normal skin fibroblasts

The host-cell reactivation of UV-irradiated and N-acetoxy-2-acetylamino-fluorene-treated herpes simplex virus type 1 strain MP was studied in normal and xeroderma pigmentosum human skin fibroblasts. Virus treated with either agent demonstrated lower survival in XP cells from complementation groups A, B, C and D than in normal fibroblasts. The relative reactivation ability of XP cells from the different genetic complementation groups was found to be the same for both irradiated and chemically treated virus. In addition, the inactivation kinetics for virus treated with either agent in the XP variant were comparable to that seen in normal skin fibroblasts. The addition of 2 or 4 mmoles caffeine to the post-infection assay medium had no effect on the inactivation kinetics of virus treated by either agent in the XP variant or in XP cells from the different genetic complementation groups. Treatment of the virus with nitrogen mustard resulted in equivalent survival in normal and XP genetic complementation group D cells. No apparent defect was observed in the ability of XP heterozygous skin fibroblasts to repair virus damaged with up to 100 μg N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene per ml. These findings indicate that the repair of UV-irradiated and N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene-treated virus is accomplished by the same pathway or different pathways sharing a common intermediate step and that the excision defect of XP cells plays little if any role in the reactivation of nitrogen mustard treated virus.     

Excision repair of UV- or benzo[a]pyrene diol epoxide-induced lesions in xeroderma pigmentosum variant cells is 'error free'

It is known that cells from one class of xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) patients, called XP variants, carry out excision repair of UV-induced DNA damage at a normal rate and are only slightly more sensitive than normal cells to the cytotoxic effect of UV radiation, but are much more sensitive to the mutagenic effect of UV. To see if this hypermutability were the result of an 'error-prone', excision repair process, we irradiated fibroblasts derived from an XP variant patient, XP4BE, under conditions that allowed the cells various lengths of time for excision repair before the onset of DNA synthesis (S phase) and assayed the frequency of 6-thioguanine (TG)-resistant mutants. Cells synchronized by release from confluence (G0 state) and irradiated just prior to S phase showed a dose-dependent increase in mutants at very high frequencies; cells irradiated in early G1, approximately 12 h before the onset of S phase, showed frequencies 4 times lower. Cells irradiated in the G0 state and allowed 24 h or 48 h for excision repair before the onset of S phase showed still lower frequencies. A comparison of the relative rates of decrease in mutant frequency with time for excision repair before the onset of S phase in XP variant cells and normal human fibroblasts after a dose of 4 or 6 J/m2 showed that these were equal. However, for every time point, the frequency of mutants induced per dose of UV was significantly higher in the XP variant population than in the normal, suggesting that the XP variant cells have an abnormally error-prone process of replicating DNA on a template containing unexcised lesions or normal cells are by-passing many of such lesions using an error-free process. A similar comparative study in synchronized populations of XP4BE cells and normal cells, using the anti 7,8-diol-9,10-epoxide of benzo[a]pyrene, showed that excision repair prior to the onset of S phase also decreased the frequency of mutants induced in XP variant cells by this agent. But for every dose and time point, the frequencies induced in XP4BE cells and normal cells were identical. Thus, the hypermutability of the XP4BE cells was specific to UV radiation-induced DNA lesions.     

Resistance of plateau-phase human normal and xeroderma pigmentosum fibroblasts to the cytotoxic effect of ultraviolet light

Clonogenic survival response to 254-nm ultraviolet light was measured in 2 strains of repair-proficient normal human fibroblasts and 4 strains of xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) fibroblasts belonging to complementation groups A, C, D and variant. In all strains except XPA, cells irradiated in plateau phase and subcultured immediately were much more resistant to the lethal effect of UV than cells irradiated in the exponential phase of growth. Typically, 10-20% of plateau-phase cells were extremely resistant. When the cultures were held in plateau phase for 24 h after irradiation and before subculture, there was a further enhance of survival. By use of a UV-specific endonuclease assay, no difference was found in the number of DNA lesions induced in exponentially growing and plateau cultures by the same dose of UV light. Thus plateau-phase cells appear to be more efficient in their DNA-repair capability than cells in exponential growth. XP group A cells were uniquely found to be deficient in the processes which lead to plateau-phase resistance. Since plateau-phase repair was not lacking in XP groups C, D and variant, it may be related to a DNA-repair process different from that which is responsible for the overall UV sensitivity of these cells.     

Repair of UV-endonuclease-susceptible sites in the 7 complementation groups of xeroderma pigmentosum A through G

7 strains of human primary fibroblasts were chosen from the complementation groups A through G of xeroderma pigmentosum; these strains are UV-sensitive and deficient in excision repair of UV damage on the criterion of unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS). They were compared with normal human fibroblasts and one xeroderma pigmentosum variant with regard to their capacity to remove pyrimidine dimers, induced in their DNA by UV at 253.7 nm. The XP variant showed a normal level of dimer removal, whereas 6 of the other XP strains had a greatly reduced capacity to remove this DNA damage, in agreement with their individual levels of UDS. Strain XP230S (complementation group F), however, only showed a 20% reduction in the removal of dimers, which is much less than expected from the low level of UDS in this strain.     

Complementation analysis of xeroderma pigmentosum variants

DNA repair after UV exposure was studied in multinucleate cells, obtained after fusion of excision-defective and variant xeroderma pigmentosum fibroblasts. Optimal fusion conditions were determined, facilitating the measurement of DNA replication in heterokaryons. In unirradiated multikaryons, entry into the S phase was depressed, when compared with unfused cells. The extent of the depression of S phase entry was dependent on the fusion conditions. In heterokaryons obtained after fusion of XP variant (6 different strains) with excision-defective XP (three cell strains from complementation groups A, C and D) both unscheduled DNA synthesis and postreplication repair after UV irradiation were restored to normal levels. In contrast, complementation was not observed after pairwise fusion of the XP variant cell strains. These results suggest that the XP variants comprise a single complementation group, different from complementation groups A, C and D.     

A further definition of characteristics of DNA-excision repair in xeroderma pigmentosum complementation group A strains

The location in the genome of excision repair following exposure to UV (254 nm) of two XP complementation group A strains, XP12BE and XP8LO, that differ considerably in their excision-repair rates, have been determined. Capacity for repair in XP8LO has also been determined. Sites repaired in DNA in a 24-h post-UV period were located relative to the remaining pyrimidine dimers using the M. luteus UV-endonuclease to nick partially repaired DNA and sedimentation in alkaline sucrose to size the resulting DNA. Repair in group A occurs randomly throughout the genome in a manner similar to that observed for normal cells but in contrast to domain-limited repair in group C strains. This observation defines a further similarity of the excision repair detected in group A compared to normal cells that is in addition to the previously reported related characteristics of the respective excision rate curves. A reduced repair capacity in XP8LO relative to normal cells was detected. This strain, which repairs DNA at an initial rate identical to that of normal strains when irradiated with doses of 5 J/m2 or less, repairs DNA at a slower than normal but constant rate at higher doses. This leads to the suggestion that XP8LO is defective in the number of repair enzyme complexes compared to normal cells.     

Complementing xeroderma pigmentosum fibroblasts restore biological activity to UV-damaged DNA.

UV survival curves of adenovirus 2 using fused, complementing xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) fibroblast strains as virus hosts showed a component with an inactivation slope identical to that given by normal cells. This component was not observed when the fibroblasts were not fused or when fusion involved strains in the same complementation group. Extrapolation of this component indicated that at zero dose 3% of the viral plaque-forming units had infected cells capable of normal repair. These results suggest that 3% of the cells were complementing heterokaryons, a value similar to that actually observed by autoradiographic analysis of UV-induced unscheduled DNA synthesis. Thus, heterokaryons formed from XP fibroblasts belonging to different complementation groups are as capable of restoring biological activity to UV-damaged adenovirus 2 as are normal cells.     

Host cell reactivation by excision repair is error-free in human cells

Do host cell repair processes affect the mutagenesis of UV-irradiated virus in human cells? The answer was obtained by investigating the mutagenesis of UV-irradiated herpes simplex virus after the irradiated virus was grown in human cells that possess normal repair capacity (normal) or lack excision repair (XPA) or post-replication repair (XP var). Evidence is presented which indicate that XPA cells express no host cell reactivation, while XP var cells express the normal level. Viral mutagenesis was measured as the fraction of the progeny of the surviving virus capable of plaque formation in the presence of iododeoxycytidine. In the normal and XPA cells mutagenesis of the irradiated virus increased linearly with UV exposure. The UV exposure needed to yield a given mutagenesis level for virus grown in XPA cells was much lower than that for virus grown in normal cells. However, when the mutation frequencies were compared at similar virus survival levels, the data from virus grown in normal cells and in XPA cells were indistinguishable. Mutagenesis in XP var cells increased as dose squared and was similar in magnitude to that in normal cells. Thus the excision repair of normal cells which provided host cell reactivation by removing lethal UV damage also removed mutagenic lesions from the virus with the same efficiency, while the repair deficiency of XP var cells had a minor role in host cell reactivation and in mutagenesis. This demonstrates that in human cells host cell reactivation by excision repair is primarily an error-free process.     

A comparison of the response of unstimulated and stimulated T-lymphocytes and fibroblasts from normal, xeroderma pigmentosum and trichothiodystrophy donors to the lethal action of UV-C.

Unstimulated T-lymphocytes from normal donors are significantly more sensitive to the lethal effects of UV-C than either stimulated T-lymphocytes or fibroblasts as judged by colony-forming ability. Data from other studies suggest that excision repair is more effective in stimulated than unstimulated T-lymphocytes leading to the prediction that these differences in survival should be minimal in cells established from excision defective donors. The prediction was met with XP6BR, a donor of unknown complementation group. For 3 XP's from complementation group D, however, enhanced survival in stimulated T-cells was observed. With cells from an excision-defective TTD who was included in complementation group D of XP both fibroblasts and unstimulated T-lymphocytes were hypersensitive. For a second excision defective TTD patient who was excluded from complementation group D, the unstimulated T-lymphocytes were more resistant than those of normal donors although the fibroblasts were hypersensitive. These results suggest that the in vitro response of stimulated T-lymphocytes or fibroblasts may not reflect the in vivo response of cells, as measured by the response of unstimulated T-lymphocytes.     

Genetic recombination of herpes simplex virus, the role of the host cell and UV-irradiation of the virus

Summary Recombination frequencies for two sets of genetic markers of herpes simplex virus were determined in various host cells with and without ultraviolet irradiation of the virus. UV irradiation increased the recombination frequency in all the cell types studied in direct proportion to the unrepaired lethal damage. In human skin fibroblasts derived from a patient with xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) of complementation group A, a given dose of UV stimulated recombination more than that in fibroblasts from normal individuals. On the other hand, UV stimulation of HSV recombination was slightly less than normal in fibroblasts derived from a patient with a variant form XP and from an ataxia telangiectasia patient. Caffeine, an agent known to inhibit repair of UV damage, reduced recombination in most of the cell types studied but did not suppress the UV-induced increase in recombination. These findings suggest that for virus DNA with the same number of unrepaired UV-lesions, each of the tested cell types promoted HSV-recombination to an equivalent extent.     

DNA excision-repair processes in human cells can eliminate the cytotoxic and mutagenic consequences of ultraviolet irradiation

The ability of DNA excision-repair processes in diploid human fibroblasts to eliminate potentially cytotoxic and mutagenic lesions induced by UV radiation (254 nm) was demonstrated in two ways: (1) Cells with normal rates of excision were compared with cells with an intermediate rate of excision (XP2BE) and cells with an excision rate less than or equal to 1% that of normal (XP12BE) for sensitivity to the killing and mutagenic action of UV radiation. The normal cells proved resistant to doses of UV which reduced the survival of the XP cells to 14% and 0.7%, respectively, and increased the frequency of mutations to 8-azaguanine resistance in the XP cells 5- to 10-fold over background. (2) Cells in confluence were irradiated with cytotoxic and mutagenic doses of UV and allowed to carry out excision repair. After various lengths of time they were replated at lower densities to allow for expression of mutations to 6-thioguanine resistance and/or at cloning densities to assay survival. Normal cells and XP cells with reduced rates of excision repair (from complementation groups C and D) exhibited a gradual increase in survival from an initial level of 15--20% to 100% if held approximately 20 h in confluence. In contrast, XP12BE cells showed no increase from an initial survival of 20% even when held for 7 days. Normal cells irradiated in confluence but prevented from replicating for 7 days exhibited background mutation frequencies, whereas the mutation frequency in XP12BE cells did not change with the time in confluence.     

Enhanced induction of SV40 replication from transformed rat cells by fusion with UV-irradiated normal and repair-deficient human fibroblasts

Fusion of SV40-transformed rat (BRKSV) cells which do not spontaneously produce infectious virus, with permissive monkey cells resulted in a low level of production of infectious virus in the heterokaryons. UV-Irradiation of the BRKSV cells prior to fusion did not result in increased virus production, but irradiation of the monkey cells prior to fusion did result in enhanced induction (EI) of SV40, as compared to control experiments in which neither cell type was irradiated. This indicated that rat cells lack the ability to initiate replication of integrated SV40 upon UV-irradiation and do not contain "permissiveness" factors that are required to support SV40 replication. In contrast, monkey cells do contain such permissiveness factors which seem to be temporally enhanced by UV-irradiation, and thus may be responsible for the EI phenomenon. Expression of EI was dose-dependent and reached maximum values approximately 24 h after UV-irradiation. The kinetics of EI resembled that of EI previously established for SV40 induction in semi-permissive cells, and of enhanced reactivation (ER) and enhanced mutagenesis (EM) of SV40 in monkey cells. Similar kinetics of EI were obtained when human diploid fibroblasts were used for fusion with BRKSV cells. Similar levels of EI were found with normal human cells and repair-deficient xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) cells of complementation groups A and C, and XP variant cells. This suggests that expression of EI is not related to excision repair. Since EI is also normally expressed in XP cells which display an abnormal ER of HSV and in XP variant cells which show a delayed EM of HSV, we conclude that EI may occur independently of ER and EM. Finally it was shown that treatment of human cells with N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea results in similar induction of EI as irradiation with UV-light, and that addition of TPA in fusion experiments has no effect on EI.     

Enhanced reactivation and enhanced mutagenesis of herpes simplex virus in normal human and xeroderma pigmentosum cells.

Enhanced reactivation (ER) and enhanced mutagenesis (EM) of herpes simplex virus type 1 were studied simultaneously in UV-irradiated stationary cultures of diploid normal human and xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) fibroblasts. Mutagenesis was assayed with unirradiated herpes simplex virus type 1 as a probe in a forward mutation assay (resistance to iododeoxycytidine). Dose-response studies showed that ER increased with the UV dose given to the virus. Optimal reactivation levels were obtained when normal cells and XP variant cells were exposed to a UV dose of 8 J . m-2 and the virus was irradiated with 150 J . m-2. Repair-deficient XP cells of complementation groups A, C, and D showed optimal reactivation levels with a UV dose to the cells of 1.0 J . m-2 and a UV dose to the virus of 40 J . m-2. The time course of appearance of ER and EM was also studied, both in the normal and XP cells. In all cell types except the XP variant cells, EM followed similar kinetics of appearance as did ER. Maximal activities occurred when infection was delayed 1 or 2 days after cell treatment. In XP variant cells, however, maximal expression of the EM function was significantly delayed with respect to ER. The results indicate that ER and EM are transiently expressed in normal and repair-deficient XP cells. Although both phenomena may be triggered by the same cellular event, ER and EM appear to be separate processes that occur independently of each other.     

Interaction of human and chick DNA repair functions in UV-irradiated xeroderma pigmentosum-chick erythrocyte heterokaryons

Fusion of chick erythrocytes with human primary fibroblasts results in the formation of heterokaryons in which the inactive chick nuclei become reactivated. The expression of chick DNA repair functions was investigated by the analysis of the DNA repair capacity after exposure to ultraviolet (UV) irradiation of such heterokaryons obtained after fusion of chick erythrocytes with normal human or xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) cells of complementation groups A, B, C and D. Unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) in normal human nuclei in these heterokaryons is suppressed during the first 2–4 days after fusion. The extent and duration of this suppression is positively correlated with the number of chick nuclei in the heterokaryons. Suppression is absent in heterokaryons obtained after fusion of chicken embryonic fibroblasts with XP cells (complementation group A and C).Restoration of DNA repair synthesis is found after fusion in XP nuclei of all complementation groups studied. It occurs rapidly in XP group A nuclei, starting one day after fusion and reaching near normal human levels after 5–8 days. In nuclei of the B, C and D group increased levels of UDS are found 5 days after fusion. At 8 days after fusion the UDS level is about 50% of that found in normal human nuclei. The pattern of UDS observed in the chick nuclei parallels that of the human counterpart in the fusion. A fast complementation pattern is also observed in chick fibroblast-XP group A heterokaryons resulting within 24 h in a UDS level comparable with that in chick fibroblast-normal human heterokaryons. In heterokaryons obtained after fusion of chick fibroblasts with XP group C cells UDS remains at the level of chick cells. These data suggest that reactivation of chick erythrocyte nuclei results in expression of repair functions which are able to complement the defects in the XP complementation groups A, B, C and D.     

Isolation and partial characterization of virus-transformed cell lines representing the A, G and variant complementation groups of xeroderma pigmentosum

We have established viral-transformed, apparently permanent (immortalized) cell lines from diploid fibroblasts representative of normal and xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) A, G and variant individuals. The XP-G and XP-variant cells represent complementation groups not previously available as permanent lines. All the new permanent cell lines exhibit SV40 T-antigen expression. They are also aneuploid and have growth characteristics typical of viral transformants. They have retained the phenotypes of UV sensitivity, reduced repair synthesis or defective 'postreplication repair' appropriate to the XP complementation group they represent. Additionally, the new cell lines are all transfectable with the selectable plasmid pRSVneo. The XP-G and XP-variant cell lines show enhanced transfection with UV-irradiated plasmid DNA; a phenomenon previously reported for normal immortalized cells and for immortalized cells from the A and F complementation groups of XP.     

Differential repair of 1-beta-D-arabinofuranosylcytosine-detectable sites in DNA of human fibroblasts exposed to ultraviolet light and 4-nitroquinoline 1-oxide

The extent of DNA excision repair was determined in dermal fibroblast strains from clinically normal and xeroderma pigmentosum (XP; complementation group A) human donors after single or combined exposures to 254-nm ultraviolet light and 4-nitroquinoline 1-oxide (4NQO). The repair was monitored by incubation of the treated cultures in the presence of 1-beta-D-arabinofuranosylcytosine (araC), a potent inhibitor of long-patch excision repair, followed by quantitation of araC-accumulated DNA single-strand breaks (representing repair events) by velocity sedimentation analysis in alkaline sucrose gradients. The amount of repair in normal fibroblast strains increased as a function of UV fluence and reached a plateau at 15 J/m2; strand breaks were not detected when these same cultures were irradiated with as much as 60 J/m2 UV and incubated in the absence of araC, implying that an initial (incision) step is rate-limiting in the repair of UV damage. In normal fibroblasts (i) the incidence of araC-detectable lesions removed during fixed intervals following exposure to 4NQO (4 microM; 30 min) was approximately 2.5 times greater than that seen following irradiation with repair-saturating fluences (greater than or equal to 15 J/m2) of UV-rays; and (ii) the amount of repair in cultures treated simultaneously with 4NQO (0.5-6 microM; 30 min) and a repair-saturating fluence of UV (20 J/m2) was found to approach the sum of that arising from exposure to each separately. The XP cells (XP12BE) exhibited a deficiency in the removal of araC-detectable DNA lesions following exposure to either of the carcinogens. Since araC is known to inhibit the repair of alkali-stable 4NQO-DNA adducts (i.e., lesions assumed to be removed by the UV-like excision pathway) but not that of alkali-labile sites (i.e., DNA lesions operated on by the X-ray-like repair pathway), our results strongly imply that the multistep excision-repair pathway operative on UV photoproducts in human fibroblasts differs from that responsible for removing alkali-stable (araC-detectable) 4NQO adducts by at least one step, presumably the rate-limiting incision reaction mediated by a lesion-recognizing endonuclease.     

Postreplication repair of DNA in human fibroblasts after UV irradiation or treatment with metabolites of benzo(a)pyrene

We have examined the ability of normal fibroblasts and of excision-deficient xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) and XP variant fibroblasts to perform postreplication DNA repair after increasing doses of either ultraviolet (UV) irradiation or mutagenic benzo(a)pyrene derivatives. XP cells defective in the excision of both UV-induced pyrimidine dimers and guanine adducts induced by treatment with the 7,8-diol-9,10-epoxides of benzo(a)pyrene were partially defective in their ability to synthesize high molecular weight DNA after the induction of both classes of DNA lesions. This defect was more marked in XP variant cells, despite their ability to remove by excision repair both pyrimidine dimers and the diol epoxide-induced lesions to the same degree as observed in normal cells. The benzo(a)pyrene 9,10-oxide had no effect in any of the 3 cell lines. The response of the excision and postreplication DNA repair mechanisms operating in human fibroblasts treated with benzo(a)pyrene 7,8-diol-9,10-epoxides, therefore, appears to resemble closely that seen after the induction of pyrimidine dimers by UV irradiation.     

Repair of ultraviolet radiation damage in xeroderma pigmentosum cells belonging to complementation group F

DNA-repair characteristics of xeroderma pigmentosum belonging to complementation group F were investigated. The cells exhibited an intermediate level of repair as measured in terms of (1) disappearance of T4 endonuclease-V-susceptible sites from DNA, (2) formation of ultraviolet-induced strand breaks in DNA, and (3) ultraviolet-induced unscheduled DNA synthesis during post-irradiation incubation. The impaired ability of XP3YO to perform unscheduled DNA synthesis was restored, to half the normal level, by the concomitant treatment with T4 endonuclease V and ultraviolet-inactivated Sendai virus. It is suggested that xeroderma pigmentosum cells of group F may be defective, at least in part, in the incision step of excision repair.     

Lack of complementation between xeroderma pigmentosum complementation groups D and H

Summary The construction of permanent hybrid cell lines between xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) cells from different complementation groups allows analysis not only of the degree of repair correction but also of the restoration of biological activity to the UV-irradiated cells. With use of an immortal human cell line (HD2) that expresses excision repair defects typical of XP group D, a series of permanent hybrid cells has been produced with XP cells from groups A to H. Excision repair, as measured by incision analysis and unscheduled DNA synthesis, is restored to normal or near normal levels in crosses involving HD2 and cells from XP groups A, B, C, E, F, G, and I. All these hybrids show complementation for the recovery of normal UV restistance. As expected, hybrids expressing poor incision and hypersensitivity to UV were produced in crosses between HD2 and XPD fibroblasts, but they were also produced without exception when XPH was the partner. In the permanent HD2 x XPD or XPH hybrids, analysis of incision capacity reveals abnormally low activity and therefore that there has been no complementation. The true hybrid nature of HD2 x XPH cells has been confirmed by HL-A and -B tissue typing; moreover, detailed kinetic analysis of incision in these cells shows that the XPH phenotype, rather than the XPD, is expressed, i.e. breaks accumulate at low UV fluence of 1 J/m². To help confirm these findings, another immortal XPD cell line was used in fusions involving HD2, XPH, or XPI. Cells resistant to ultraviolet were produced only with XPI fibroblasts. These data are discussed in terms of whether XPD and H mutations are likely to be allelic with respect to incision.