Pretreatment of rats with anticollagen IgG renders them resistant to active type II collagen arthritis

Intravenous administration of 24 mg of affinity-purified rat anticollagen IgG induced a polyarthritis in recipient rats within 48 hr. This polyarthritis was transient and hind paw diameters returned to normal values within 12 days. IgG and C3 could be detected on the articular cartilage by immunofluorescence up to 16 days after antibody administration. Administration of 24 mg of rat anticollagen IgG to these antibody-treated rats did not induce a second phase of polyarthritis. In addition, recovered rats that had been pretreated with antibody were resistant to arthritis when Type II collagen was administered intradermally. In these rats, serum anticollagen IgG levels were significantly lower than in control rats which were not treated with antibody. Pretreatment of rats with anticollagen IgG did not have an effect on the severity or the incidence of adjuvant-induced arthritis. In addition, pretreatment of rats with anticollagen IgG did not have an effect on the development of a humoral response to ovalbumin.     

Attenuation of collagen arthritis and modulation of delayed-type hypersensitivity by type II collagen reactive T-cell lines

T-cell lines were established from the lymph node cells of syngeneic Louvain (LOU) rats previously immunized with native chick type II collagen (CII) emulsified in incomplete Freund's adjuvant. The CII lines proliferated in vitro to type II collagen but not to type I collagen, ovalbumin (OV), or PPD. Control lines, developed from LOU rats immunized with OV emulsified in complete Freund's adjuvant, were OV specific because they did not respond to other antigens in vitro. CII line cells could adoptively transfer delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) but did not induce IgG antibody production to collagen. Moreover, the intravenous administration of 2 X 10(7) CII line cells prevented the subsequent induction of collagen arthritis following immunization and suppressed DTH to collagen without affecting antibody responses in the recipients. Spleen cells, but not sera, from these resistant rats decreased CII line reactivity in vitro. OV or irradiated CII lines had no effect on clinical or immunologic parameters in this model. These findings demonstrate protection from arthritis afforded by T-cell line transfer and suggest that the phenomenon results from down-regulation of the recipients' cellular immunity to collagen.     

Type II collagen-induced murine arthritis. I. Induction and perpetuation of arthritis require synergy between humoral and cell-mediated immunity

Immunization of DBA/1 mice with type II collagen resulted in typical and progressive arthritis, which is associated with the production of high titer of anti-collagen antibody and the induction of cell-mediated immunity as exemplified by delayed type hypersensitivity response as well as lymphokine production. In contrast, administration of heat-denatured collagen into DBA/1 mice failed to induce the arthritis. These mice produced only marginal antibody, whereas they developed comparable cell-mediated immunity to that induced by immunization with native collagen, and therefore the inoculation of heat-denatured collagen provided the regimen capable of inducing preferentially cell-mediated immunity without the generation of high level of antibody. Inasmuch as administration of antibody induced only marginal and transient joint swelling not associated with typical histologic lesion, the synergistic effect of humoral and cell-mediated immunities was investigated using antibody preparation and the regimen to induce selectively cell-mediated immunity. The results demonstrate that administration of antibody into DBA/1 mice pre-sensitized with heat-denatured collagen resulted in potent and progressive arthritis. Such synergy was further confirmed by the induction of arthritis in T cell-depleted DBA/1 mice that had been adoptively transferred with antibody and lymphoid cells from heat-denatured collagen-sensitized mice. Moreover, it was revealed that the nature of cells capable of transferring cell-mediated immunity was of Thy-1+ and L3T4+ Lyt-2-. These results indicate that anti-collagen antibody and L3T4+ T cell-mediated cellular immunity are crucially required for the perpetuated development of type II collagen-induced arthritis.     

Collagen-induced arthritis in mice. Relationship of collagen-specific and total IgE synthesis to disease.

The relationship between production of IgE and collagen-induced arthritis in mice was examined. Collagen-specific IgE was produced as a consequence of immunization of DBA/1 mice with chicken type II collagen emulsified in CFA. We observed a rise in collagen-specific IgE antibody levels at the onset of CIA clinical and histologic signs in DBA/1 mice. This rise in IgE paralleled that of IgG2a anticollagen antibodies, an isotype implicated in the pathogenesis of CIA by other laboratories. The collagen-specific IgE contained in the plasma of mice with CIA could arm basophils for Ag- (collagen) dependent degranulation. Collagen-specific IgE may thus contribute to CIA by promoting mast cell degranulation in the synovia of susceptible mice immunized with chick type II collagen; but, further work is required to establish such a role for IgE in CIA. However, genetic differences in disease susceptibility could not be accounted for by quantitative differences in collagen-specific IgE production. Further, comparable levels of IgE anticollagen antibodies were observed in animals with active CIA and after spontaneous remission, thereby confirming that the presence of such antibodies is insufficient for disease. Total IgE levels peaked just before spontaneous remission indicating active production of IL-4. IL-4 was administered to animals with CIA to determine if this lymphokine could be involved in the remission process. IL-4 facilitated remission of CIA. Enhanced total IgE production may thus be a marker for activation of Th2 cells that produce lymphokines such as IL-4 and IL-10, factors that may be involved in the spontaneous remission process.     

Type II collagen-induced murine arthritis: induction of arthritis depends on antigen-presenting cell function as well as susceptibility of host to an anticollagen immune response.

Two sets of ((resistant x susceptible) F1----parent) and (parent----F1) chimeric mice were prepared. In the chimeric combinations involving BALB/c and DBA/1 mice, all (F1----F1) chimeras developed arthritis as well as potent anticollagen responses after immunization with collagen, whereas all (F1----BALB/c) and (BALB/c----F1) chimeras induced neither arthritis nor immune responses. This type of F1 T cells could be activated with APC from DBA/1 but not from BALB/c mice. Thus, the failure of the [F1 in equilibrium with BALB/c] chimeras to mount anticollagen responses was due to a defect at the APC level. Another arthritis-resistant strain, C57BL/6, exhibited adequate APC function, but reduced T cell responsiveness, representing an intermediate responder. In the chimeric combinations involving C57BL/6 and DBA/1 mice, (F1----F1) and (C57BL/6----C57BL/6) chimeras developed very high and very low incidence of arthritis, respectively. (C57BL/6----F1) chimeras developed an appreciable incidence of arthritis under conditions in which this group of chimeras generated intermediate levels of anticollagen responses. In contrast, (F1----C57BL/6) chimeras developed low incidence of disease despite induction of strong responses. Moreover, cells from collagen-immunized (F1----C57BL/6) chimeras, when transferred into T cell-depleted B cell mice of F1 or C57BL/6 strain, produced comparable immune responses in both groups but induced much more severe arthritis in F1 than in C57BL/6 recipients. These results indicate that: i) two types of arthritis-resistant strains can be identified, each of which has anticollagen APC defect as a low responder and reduced T cell responsiveness as an intermediate responder and ii) a discrepancy between the degree of anticollagen responses and clinical arthritis is attributed to the differential susceptibility to anticollagen immune responses.     

Collagen-induced arthritis is exacerbated in IL-10-deficient mice

IL-10 is a potent immunoregulatory cytokine attenuating a wide range of immune effector and inflammatory responses. In the present study, we assess whether endogenous levels of IL-10 function to regulate the incidence and severity of collagen-induced arthritis. DBA/1 wildtype (WT), heterozygous (IL-10+/-) and homozygous (IL-10-/-) IL-10-deficient mice were immunized with type II collagen. Development of arthritis was monitored over time, and collagen-specific cytokine production and anticollagen antibodies were assessed. Arthritis developed progressively in mice immunized with collagen, and 100% of the WT, IL-10+/-, and IL-10-/- mice were arthritic at 35 days. However, the severity of arthritis in the IL-10-/- mice was significantly greater than that in WT or IL-1+/- animals. Disease severity was associated with reduced IFN-gamma levels and a dramatic increase in CD11b-positive macrophages. Paradoxically, both the IgG1 and IgG2a anticollagen antibody responses were also significantly reduced. These data demonstrate that IL-10 is capable of controlling disease severity through a mechanism that involves IFN-gamma. Since IL-10 levels are elevated in rheumatoid arthritis synovial fluid, these findings may have relevance to rheumatoid arthritis.     

Type II collagen arthritis: identification of arthritogenic epitopes using fractionated anticollagen IgG

Affinity-purified anticollagen IgG was fractionated on purified cyanogen bromide-derived collagen peptide Sepharose. The antibody fraction bound to the peptides was eluted and tested for its ability to induce passive arthritis in recipients. Anticollagen IgG bound to peptide 5 (alpha 1(II)-CB8-10 and alpha 1(II)CB11-8) and to peptide 6 (alpha 1(II)CB11) were active in inducing passive arthritis. Other peptide bound fractions were inactive. These observations suggest that the arthritogenic domain in Type II collagen is restricted to alpha 1(II)CB11.     

Type II collagen-induced arthritis in mice. IV. Variations in immunogenetic regulation provide evidence for multiple arthritogenic epitopes on the collagen molecule

Type II collagen from six mammalian species was investigated for the capacity to induce an immune response and collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) in C57/B10 congenic mouse strains. H-2q haplotype mice were susceptible to chick, bovine, deer, rat, and human type II collagen, but were resistant to arthritis induced by porcine type II collagen. H-2r haplotype mice only developed CIA in response to bovine, deer, and porcine collagen. High antibody responses in the absence of disease, directed against a specific type II collagen, were observed in many independent haplotypes. The cross-reactive capacity of different antisera to the various collagen species was studied. The data support the existence of two arthritogenic and multiple nonarthritogenic epitopes on the type II collagen molecule.     

Collagen-induced arthritis is exacerbated in IL-10-deficient mice

IL-10 is a potent immunoregulatory cytokine attenuating a wide range of immune effector and inflammatory responses. In the present study, we assess whether endogenous levels of IL-10 function to regulate the incidence and severity of collagen-induced arthritis. DBA/1 wildtype (WT), heterozygous (IL-10^+/-) and homozygous (IL-10^-/-) IL-10-deficient mice were immunized with type II collagen. Development of arthritis was monitored over time, and collagen-specific cytokine production and anticollagen antibodies were assessed. Arthritis developed progressively in mice immunized with collagen, and 100% of the WT, IL-10^+/-, and IL-10^-/- mice were arthritic at 35 days. However, the severity of arthritis in the IL-10^-/- mice was significantly greater than that in WT or IL-1^+/- animals. Disease severity was associated with reduced IFN-γ levels and a dramatic increase in CD11b-positive macrophages. Paradoxically, both the IgG₁ and IgG_2a anticollagen antibody responses were also significantly reduced. These data demonstrate that IL-10 is capable of controlling disease severity through a mechanism that involves IFN-γ. Since IL-10 levels are elevated in rheumatoid arthritis synovial fluid, these findings may have relevance to rheumatoid arthritis.     

Suppression of collagen arthritis with antibodies to an arthritogenic, oligoclonal T cell line.

Rats immunized with type II collagen (CII) develop an immunologically mediated polyarthritis. T cells have been implicated in the pathogenesis of this model since they can adoptively transfer the disease. A CII-specific T cell line (VA), consisting of three distinct clones by Southern blot analysis, has been shown to be arthritogenic. Antibodies specific for this line were generated by immunizing rabbits. In an attempt to prevent collagen-induced arthritis (CIA), Louvain rats were injected with 1 ml of anti-VA ip on Days -1, +1, +3 and 0.5 ml on Day +5 (early treatment). To evaluate its effect on existing disease, rats received anti-VA on the day of arthritis onset and subsequently on 4 successive alternate days using the same dosage protocol (late treatment). Control rats received no therapeutic injections or were administered normal rabbit serum. All rats were immunized with CII on Day 0 to induce CIA. Rats administered antibodies using the early anti-VA treatment protocol had a significantly diminished incidence of arthritis compared to controls. Established arthritis was significantly diminished compared to controls in rats given the late anti-VA treatment. In both protocols, radiographic evidence of joint destruction was significantly reduced compared to controls. T cell phenotyping using flow cytometry analysis demonstrated that the anti-VA antibody therapy selectively eliminated a small subset of T cells since there was little difference in total T cell counts in the experimental versus control groups. Delayed type hypersensitivity and IgG antibody titers to CII were minimally decreased in the experimental versus control group. These results suggest that antibodies raised to an oligoclonal arthritogenic T cell line can suppress collagen arthritis. This may have implications with respect to 1) the size of the T cell receptor repertoire involved in the pathogenesis of collagen arthritis and 2) immunospecific protocols for CIA and other autoimmune diseases.     

Methylacetylenic putrescine (MAP), an inhibitor of polyamine biosynthesis, prevents the development of collagen-induced arthritis

The objective of the present investigation was to examine the effects of an irreversible inhibitor of ornithine decarboxylase (2R,5R)-6-heptyne-2,5,diamine (methylacetylenic putrescine, MAP) on experimentally induced arthritis in mice. MAP (0.5-0.05%) was administered in drinking water to DBA/1 mice immunized with native chick type II collagen (CII). The development of arthritis was inhibited only in those mice receiving 0.5% MAP; lower doses were ineffective. Putrescine and spermidine levels were decreased and spermine levels were increased in spleen and lymph node cells from drug-treated mice compared to control arthritic mice. Furthermore, when control mice were developing arthritis, serum anti-CII antibody levels were lower in the MAP-treated group. MAP inhibited antibody production early in the immune response to CII; there was an association between inhibition of antibody production and inhibition of the development of arthritis. When MAP was discontinued, the nonarthritic, drug-treated mice did not develop the disease. Late administration of MAP (beginning 19 days after CII immunization) did not affect the incidence or the severity of the arthritis. Cyclophosphamide treatment begun at the same time significantly inhibited the development of the disease. In vitro T cell responses to denatured type II collagen (dCII) in untreated and MAP-treated mice were examined 14 days after immunization with CII. This is a time of peak T cell responsiveness in untreated animals. MAP treatment had no effect on the T cell response to dCII. These results indicate that MAP can prevent the development of CII-induced arthritis, possibly by inhibiting the autoantibody response. Therefore, inhibitors of polyamine biosynthesis deserve further investigation as potential immunosuppressive agents.     

Type II collagen-induced arthritis in mice. III. Suppression of arthritis by using monoclonal and polyclonal anti-Ia antisera

Pretreatment of mice genetically susceptible to type II collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) with monoclonal or polyclonal antisera specific for I region gene products (Ia antigens) suppressed or delayed the onset of CIA, whereas pretreatment with anti-Ia to an irrelevant haplotype was without effect. The humoral response to type II collagen was transiently depressed 14 days after immunization but antibody levels did not differ significantly after 28 days. The peak delayed-type hypersensitivity to type II collagen was unaffected by anti-Ia treatment. Monoclonal antibody of one anti-Ia specificity enhanced both the antibody response and the arthritis incidence in one mouse strain.     

Attenuation of an adjuvant arthritis by type II collagen

Subcutaneous injection of the nonimmunogenic synthetic alkyldiamine, N,N-diotadecyl-N',N'-bis(2-hydroxyethyl) propanediamine (CP-20961), which possesses potent adjuvant properties for cellular sensitization, can induce an inflammatory arthritis in rats. To study whether a host reaction to native type II collagen plays a role in the pathogenesis of the arthritis in this model, CP-20961-injected Lewis rats received i.v. on four occasions native type II collagen coupled to syngeneic spleen cells with ethylcarbodiimide (CDI), native type II collagen added to spleen cells without CDI, or native type II collagen coupled to rat red blood cells (RBC) with glutaraldehyde. There was a significant suppression of the severity of arthritis in all three groups compared with a control group injected with CP-20961 but not receiving cells. In addition, the prevalence of arthritis was decreased in the group receiving native type II collagen-coupled RBC. Injection of cells coupled to denatured type II collagen, native type I collagen, and ovalbumin did not affect significantly the morphologic aspects of this disease. These data provide evidence that material possessing the quaternary epitope(s) of type II collagen functions in an as yet unidentified effector pathway in this adjuvant arthritis.     

Viral IL-10 and soluble TNF receptor act synergistically to inhibit collagen-induced arthritis following adenovirus-mediated gene transfer

Viral IL-10 (vIL-10) and soluble TNF receptor (sTNFR) are anti-inflammatory proteins that can suppress collagen-induced arthritis (CIA). These and related proteins have shown efficacy in the treatment of human rheumatoid arthritis; however, neither alone is able to completely suppress disease. Furthermore, they have short half-lives, necessitating frequent administration. To determine the ability of these proteins to act synergistically following gene transfer, arthritis was induced in DBA/1 male mice by immunization with type II collagen on days 0 and 21. Mice were injected i.v. either before disease onset (day 20) or after disease onset (day 28) with 1010 particles of adenovirus encoding vIL-10, a soluble TNF receptor-IgG1 fusion protein (sTNFR-Ig), a combination of both vectors, or a control vector lacking a transgene. Significant synergism was observed with the combination of vIL-10 and sTNFR-Ig, with a substantial reduction in both the incidence and severity of disease as well as inhibition of progression of established disease. sTNFR-Ig alone had no effect on CIA. vIL-10 alone inhibited disease when given before disease onset, but had minimal effect on established disease. Both proteins inhibited spleen cell proliferation and IFN-gamma secretion in response to stimulation with type II collagen, but only vIL-10 reduced the synovial mRNA levels of the proinflammatory cytokines IL-1beta, TNF-alpha, and IL-6. These findings demonstrate that vIL-10 and sTNFR-Ig act synergistically in suppressing CIA and suggest that gene transfer offers a potential therapeutic modality for the treatment of arthritis.     

A mechanistic approach to understanding conjugated linoleic acid's role in inflammation using murine models of rheumatoid arthritis

A naturally occurring fatty acid, conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), reduces immune-induced TNF and inducible cyclooxygenase (COX-2) expression; key mediators of inflammation in rheumatoid arthritis (RA). On the basis of previous work, it was hypothesized that dietary CLA would act as an anti-inflammatory agent in select animal models of RA. In the collagen antibody-induced arthritis (CAIA) model, mice fed CLA (mixed isomers of c9, t11, and t10, c12-CLA) for 3 wk before anticollagen antibody injection had reduced lipopolysaccharide-induced plasma TNF levels and had arthritic scores that were 60% of mice fed corn oil (CO). In the collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) model, mice fed mixed isomers of CLA for 21 days before immunization had lower IgG(1) titers, earlier signs of joint inflammation, but similar arthritis scores compared with CO fed mice during the remaining 70-day post-injection period. Beginning on day 80 to 133, CLA-fed mice had arthritic scores 70% that of the CO-fed mice. In a second CIA experiment, CLA was fed only after the booster injection. Plasma IgG(1) levels were not reduced and arthritis onset was delayed 4 days in CLA-fed mice compared with the CO-fed mice. Peak arthritis score was similar between CLA and CO-fed mice from day 35 to 56. Because CLA reduced inflammation in the CAIA model, delayed onset of arthritis in the CIA model (CIA experiment 2) and reduced arthritis score after day 80 in the CIA model (CIA experiment 1), we concluded that dietary CLA exhibited anti-inflammatory activity that was dependent on antibody.     

A cross-reactive idiotype on anti-collagen antibodies in collagen-induced arthritis: identification and relevance to disease

Immunization of mice with type II collagen (CII) leads to the production of anti-CII antibodies and, in susceptible strains, to the induction of arthritis. Specifically purified anti-CII antibodies from arthritic DBA/1 mice were used to prepare a rabbit anti-idiotypic antiserum. This antiserum recognizes a cross-reactive idiotype (CRI) present on 20-25% of anti-CII antibodies from DBA/1 mice immunized with bovine CII. The CRI is not present on DBA/1 anti-trinitrophenyl, undetectable in normal Ig and not Igh allotype linked. The presence of this CRI was examined after antigen specific suppression of the anti-CII antibody response by intravenous administration of chick or bovine CII. While intravenous injection of bovine CII, prior to immunization with chick CII, greatly reduces both the incidence of arthritis and the anti-CII response, the fraction of anti-bovine CII which expresses the CRI is increased by this treatment. These findings suggest that the CRI characterizes a disease-unrelated fraction of anti-CII which recognizes bovine and chick CII, but probably not mouse CII. In addition, attempts at idiotypic regulation of arthritis incidence and antibody response by in vivo administration of anti-idiotypic serum also indicate that the CRI-bearing antibody is not important for the induction of arthritis.     

Type II collagen-reactive T cell clones from mice with collagen-induced arthritis

Certain strains of mice develop a symmetrical polyarthritis after immunization with type II collagen. The incidence of arthritis after such immunization is variable. To study the arthritogenic potential of T cells reactive with type II collagen, we isolated draining lymph node cells from mice that had developed arthritis after immunization with bovine type II collagen. From these immune lymph node cells we were able to clone T cells reactive with type II collagen. Two separate sets of T cell clones were isolated. The first set reacted with either native bovine or native chick type II collagen, but did not react with type I collagen. The second set of T cell clones reacted with bovine type II collagen, but did not respond to either native chick type II collagen or type I collagen. These clones will be tested for their influence on the development of arthritis in vivo.     

Immunosuppression of collagen-induced arthritis in mice with an anti-IL-2 receptor antibody

The use of an anti-IL-2R antibody, 7D4, was investigated in vivo in the suppression of collagen-induced arthritis in mice. 7D4 was shown to reduce the incidence of arthritis in a group of mice immunized with type II collagen as compared with a group similarly immunized with collagen and treated with a control isotype matched anti-Forsmann antibody. 7D4 was also shown to reduce the severity of arthritis in the treated mice as compared to the mice in the group treated with the control antibody. Anti-IL-2R antibodies may be useful in the treatment of autoimmune diseases by selectively suppressing activated T cells.     

Complement deficiency ameliorates collagen-induced arthritis in mice

Collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) is an experimental animal model of human rheumatoid arthritis being characterized by synovitis and progressive destruction of cartilage and bone. CIA is induced by injection of heterologous or homologous collagen type II in a susceptible murine strain. DBA/1J mice deficient of complement factors C3 (C3(-/-)) and factor B (FB(-/-)) were generated to elucidate the role of the complement system in CIA. When immunized with bovine collagen type II emulsified in CFA, control mice developed severe arthritis and high CII-specific IgG Ab titers. In contrast, the C3(-/-) and FB(-/-) were highly resistant to CIA and displayed decreased CII-specific IgG Ab response. A repeated bovine collagen type II exposure 3 wk after the initial immunization led to an increase in the Ab response in all mice and triggered arthritis also in the complement-deficient mice. Although the arthritic score of the C3(-/-) mice was low, the arthritis in FB(-/-) mice ranked intermediate with regard to C3(-/-) and control mice. We conclude that complement activation by both the classical and the alternative pathway plays a deleterious role in CIA.     

Studies on the synergy between collagen and adjuvant arthritis in rats

Intravenous administration of subarthritogenic doses of anticollagen IgG and adjuvant-sensitized spleen cells to syngeneic naive rats induces an erosive arthritis in recipients. The onset of the clinical disease in recipients is rapid and the disease is severe when compared to those recipients receiving cells alone. Immunocytochemical analysis of the knee synovium indicates the accumulation in the adipose tissue of Ia+ (ED1+)macrophages, OX-19+ T lymphocytes, and neutrophils. A large proportion of the lining cells of the proliferative synovium are Ia+. The knee synovium is extremely edematous and contains fibrin. If recipient rats are decomplemented, clinical disease is delayed and the number of mononuclear and polymorphonuclear cells accumulating in the synovium is decreased. Similar results are observed if recipient rats are treated with anti-Ia+ antibody. However, anti-Ia+ treatment does not induce depletion of serum complement.