Slicing a protease: structural features of the ATP-dependent Lon proteases gleaned from investigations of isolated domains

ATP-dependent Lon proteases are multi-domain enzymes found in all living organisms. All Lon proteases contain an ATPase domain belonging to the AAA(+) superfamily of molecular machines and a proteolytic domain with a serine-lysine catalytic dyad. Lon proteases can be divided into two subfamilies, LonA and LonB, exemplified by the Escherichia coli and Archaeoglobus fulgidus paralogs, respectively. The LonA subfamily is defined by the presence of a large N-terminal domain, whereas the LonB subfamily has no such domain, but has a membrane-spanning domain that anchors the protein to the cytoplasmic side of the membrane. The two subfamilies also differ in their consensus sequences. Recent crystal structures for several individual domains and sub-fragments of Lon proteases have begun to illuminate similarities and differences in structure-function relationships between the two subfamilies. Differences in orientation of the active site residues in several isolated Lon protease domains point to possible roles for the AAA(+) domains and/or substrates in positioning the catalytic residues within the active site. Structures of the proteolytic domains have also indicated a possible hexameric arrangement of subunits in the native state of bacterial Lon proteases. The structure of a large segment of the N-terminal domain has revealed a folding motif present in other protein families of unknown function and should lead to new insights regarding ways in which Lon interacts with substrates or other cellular factors. These first glimpses of the structure of Lon are heralding an exciting new era of research on this ancient family of proteases.     

The N-terminal sequence after residue 247 plays an important role in structure and function of Lon protease from Brevibacillus thermoruber WR-249

Previous studies on the N-terminal domain of Lon proteases have not clearly identified its function. Here we constructed randomly chosen N-terminal-truncated mutants of the Lon protease from Brevibacillus thermoruber WR-249 to elucidate the structure-function relationship of this domain. Mutants lacking amino acids from 1 to 247 of N terminus retained significant peptidase and ATPase activities, but lost ∼90% of protease activity. Further truncation of the protein resulted in the loss of all three activities. Mutants lacking amino acids 246-259 or 248-256 also lost all activities and quaternary structure. Our results indicated that amino acids 248-256 (SEVDELRAQ) are important for the full function of the Lon protease.     

Cryo-EM structure of hexameric yeast Lon protease (PIM1) highlights the importance of conserved structural elements

Lon protease is a conserved ATP-dependent serine protease composed of an AAA+ domain that mechanically unfolds substrates and a serine protease domain that degrades these unfolded substrates. In yeast, dysregulation of Lon protease (PIM1) attenuates lifespan and leads to gross mitochondrial morphological perturbations. Although structures of the bacterial and human Lon protease reveal a hexameric assembly, yeast PIM1 was speculated to form a heptameric assembly and is uniquely characterized by a ∼50-residue insertion between the ATPase and protease domains. To further understand the yeast-specific properties of PIM1, we determined a high-resolution cryo-electron microscopy structure of PIM1 in a substrate-translocating state. Here, we reveal that PIM1 forms a hexamer, conserved with that of bacterial and human Lon proteases, wherein the ATPase domains form a canonical closed spiral that enables pore loop residues to translocate substrates to the protease chamber. In the substrate-translocating state, PIM1 protease domains form a planar protease chamber in an active conformation and are uniquely characterized by a ∼15-residue C-terminal extension. These additional C-terminal residues form an α-helix located along the base of the protease domain. Finally, we did not observe density for the yeast-specific insertion between the ATPase and protease domains, likely due to high conformational flexibility. Biochemical studies to investigate the insertion using constructs that truncated or replaced the insertion with a glycine-serine linker suggest that the yeast-specific insertion is dispensable for PIM1’s enzymatic function. Altogether, our structural and biochemical studies highlight unique components of PIM1 machinery and demonstrate evolutionary conservation of Lon protease function.     

A membrane-bound archaeal Lon protease displays ATP-independent proteolytic activity towards unfolded proteins and ATP-dependent activity for folded proteins

In contrast to the eucaryal 26S proteasome and the bacterial ATP-dependent proteases, little is known about the energy-dependent proteolysis in members of the third domain, Archae. We cloned a gene homologous to ATP-dependent Lon protease from a hyperthermophilic archaeon and observed the unique properties of the archaeal Lon. Lon from Thermococcus kodakaraensis KOD1 (Lon(Tk)) is a 70-kDa protein with an N-terminal ATPase domain belonging to the AAA(+) superfamily and a C-terminal protease domain including a putative catalytic triad. Interestingly, a secondary structure prediction suggested the presence of two transmembrane helices within the ATPase domain and Western blot analysis using specific antiserum against the recombinant protein clearly indicated that Lon(Tk) was actually a membrane-bound protein. The recombinant Lon(Tk) possessed thermostable ATPase activity and peptide cleavage activity toward fluorogenic peptides with optimum temperatures of 95 and 70 degrees C, respectively. Unlike the enzyme from Escherichia coli, we found that Lon(Tk) showed higher peptide cleavage activity in the absence of ATP than it did in the presence of ATP. When three kinds of proteins with different thermostabilities were examined as substrates, it was found that Lon(Tk) required ATP for degradation of folded proteins, probably due to a chaperone-like function of the ATPase domain, along with ATP hydrolysis. In contrast, Lon(Tk) degraded unfolded proteins in an ATP-independent manner, suggesting a mode of action in Lon(Tk) different from that of its bacterial counterpart.     

A novel view on the architecture of the non-catalytic N-terminal region of ATP-dependent LonA proteases

ATP-Dependent Lon-proteases are components of the protein quality control system, which maintains cellular proteome. The Lon family consists of two subfamilies A and B, differing in subunit architecture and intracellular location. We propose here a reinterpretation of the domain organization of the non-catalytic N-terminal region of LonA proteases. Using Escherichia coli LonA protease (EcLon) as an example, it has been shown that a fragment (αN domain) located between the N-terminal domain and the AAA⁺ module is similar to the α1 domain of the first AAA⁺ module of chaperone-disaggregase ClpB. A coiled-coil (CC) region included in the αN domain of LonA is similar to the M domain of ClpB chaperones, which is inserted into the α1 domain. This region is suggested to adopt the structure similar to the propeller-like (PL) domain. The typical architecture of the N-terminal region of LonA proteases is postulated to be characterized by the obligatory presence of a PL domain, included in the αN domain, but may vary in the length and topology of the preceding N-terminal domain, which can have in some cases a more complex structure than in EcLon.     

The Thermoplasma acidophilum Lon protease has a Ser-Lys dyad active site.

A gene with significant similarity to bacterial Lon proteases was identified during the sequencing of the genome of the thermoacidophilic archaeon Thermoplasma acidophilum. Protein sequence comparison revealed that Thermoplasma Lon protease (TaLon) is more similar to the LonB proteases restricted to Gram-positive bacteria than to the widely distributed bacterial LonA. However, the active site residues of the protease and ATPase domain are highly conserved in all Lon proteases. Using site-directed mutagenesis we show here that TaLon and EcLon, and probably all other Lon proteases, contain a Ser-Lys dyad active site. The TaLon active site mutants were fully assembled and, similar to TaLon wild-type, displayed an apparent molar mass of 430 kDa upon gelfiltration. This would be consistent with a hexameric complex and indeed electron micrographs of TaLon revealed ring-shaped particles, although of unknown symmetry. Comparison of the ATPase activity of Lon wild-type from Thermoplasma or Escherichia coli with respective protease active site mutants revealed differences in Km and V values. This suggests that in the course of protein degradation by wild-type Lon the protease domain might influence the activity of the ATPase domain.     

Limited proteolysis of E. coli ATP-dependent protease Lon - a unified view of the subunit architecture and characterization of isolated enzyme fragments

We carried out chymotryptic digestion of multimeric ATP-dependent Lon protease from Escherichia coli. Four regions sensitive to proteolytic digestion were located in the enzyme and several fragments corresponding to the individual structural domains of the enzyme or their combinations were isolated. It was shown that (i) unlike the known AAA(+) proteins, the ATPase fragment (A) of Lon has no ATPase activity in spite of its ability to bind nucleotides, and it is monomeric in solution regardless of the presence of any effectors; (ii) the monomeric proteolytic domain (P) does not display proteolytic activity; (iii) in contrast to the inactive counterparts, the AP fragment is an oligomer and exhibits both the ATPase and proteolytic activities. However, unlike the full-length Lon, its AP fragment oligomerizes into a dimer or a tetramer only, exhibits the properties of a non-processive protease, and undergoes self-degradation upon ATP hydrolysis. These results reveal the crucial role played by the non-catalytic N fragment of Lon (including its coiled-coil region), as well as the contribution of individual domains to creation of the quaternary structure of the full-length enzyme, empowering its function as a processive protease.     

Crystal Structure of the MecA Degradation Tag

MecA is an adaptor protein that regulates the assembly and activity of the ATP-dependent ClpCP protease in Bacillus subtilis. MecA contains two domains. Although the amino-terminal domain of MecA recruits substrate proteins such as ComK and ComS, the carboxyl-terminal domain (residues 121–218) has dual roles in the regulation and function of ClpCP protease. MecA-(121–218) facilitates the assembly of ClpCP oligomer, which is required for the protease activity of ClpCP. This domain was identified to be a non-recycling degradation tag that targets heterologous fusion proteins to the ClpCP protease for degradation. To elucidate the mechanism of MecA, we determined the crystal structure of MecA-(121–218) at 2.2 Å resolution, which reveals a previously uncharacterized α/β fold. Structure-guided mutagenesis allows identification of surface residues that are essential for the function of MecA. We also solved the structure of a carboxyl-terminal domain of YpbH, a paralogue of MecA in B. subtilis, at 2.4 Å resolution. Despite low sequence identity, the two structures share essentially the same fold. The presence of MecA homologues in other bacterial species suggests conservation of a large family of unique degradation tags.     

Forms of LonB protease from Archaeoglobus fulgidus devoid of the transmembrane domain: The contribution of the quaternary structure to the regulation of enzyme proteolytic activity

Deletion of the transmembrane domain (TM-domain) of Archaeoglobus fulgidus LonB protease (Archaeoglobus fulgidus (AfLon)) was shown to result in uncontrollable activation of the enzyme proteolytic site and in vivo autolysis yielding a stable and functionally inactive fragment consisting of both α-helical and proteolytic domains (αP). The ΔTM-AfLon-S509A enzyme form, obtained by site-directed mutagenesis of the catalytic Ser residue, is capable of recombination with the αP fragment. The mixed oligomers were shown to be proteolytically active, which indicates a crucial role of subunit interactions in the activation of the AfLon proteolytic site. The thermophilic nature of AfLon protease was found to be due to the special features of the enzyme activity regulation, the structure of ATPase domain, and the quaternary structure.     

Functional domains of Brevibacillus thermoruber lon protease for oligomerization and DNA binding: role of N-terminal and sensor and substrate discrimination domains

Lon protease is a multifunctional enzyme, and its functions include the degradation of damaged proteins and naturally short lived proteins, ATPase and chaperone-like activities, as well as DNA binding. A thermostable Lon protease from Brevibacillus thermoruber WR-249 (Bt-Lon) has been cloned and characterized with an N-terminal domain, a central ATPase domain that includes a sensor and substrate discrimination (SSD) domain, and a C-terminal protease domain. Here we present a detailed structure-function characterization of Bt-Lon, not only dissecting the individual roles of Bt-Lon domains in oligomerization, catalytic activities, chaperone-like activity, and DNA binding activity but also describing the nature of oligomerization. Seven truncated mutants of Bt-Lon were designed, expressed, and purified. Our results show that the N-terminal domain is essential for oligomerization. The truncation of the N-terminal domain resulted in the failure of oligomerization and led to the inactivation of proteolytic, ATPase, and chaperone-like activities but retained the DNA binding activity, suggesting that oligomerization of Bt-Lon is a prerequisite for its catalytic and chaperone-like activities. We further found that the SSD is involved in DNA binding based on gel mobility shift assays. On the other hand, the oligomerization of Bt-Lon proceeds through a dimer <--> tetramer <--> hexamer assembly model revealed by chemical cross-linking experiments. The results also showed that hydrophobic interactions may play important roles in the dimerization of Bt-Lon, and ionic interactions are mainly responsible for the assembly of hexamers.     

Isolation and characterization of fragments of ATP-dependent protease Lon from Escherichia coli obtained by limited proteolysis

Conditions of limited proteolysis of the protease Lon from Escherichia coli that provided the formation of fragments approximately corresponding to the enzyme domains were found for studying the domain functioning. A method of isolation of the domains was developed, and their functional characteristics were compared. The isolated proteolytic domain (LonP fragment) of the enzyme was shown to exhibit both peptidase and proteolytic activities; however, it cleaved large protein substrates at a significantly lower rate than the full-size protease Lon. On the other hand, the LonAP fragment, containing both the ATPase and the proteolytic domains, retained almost all of the enzymatic properties of the full-size protein. Both LonP and LonAP predominantly form dimers unlike the native protease Lon functioning as a tetramer. These results suggest that the N-terminal domain of protease Lon plays a considerable role in the process of the enzyme oligomerization.     

Characterization of three putative Lon proteases of Thermus thermophilus HB27 and use of their defective mutants as hosts for production of heterologous proteins

In the genome of a thermophilic bacterium, Thermus thermophilus HB27, three genes, TTC0418, TTC0746 and TTC1975, were annotated as ATP-dependent protease La (Lon). Sequence comparisons indicated that TTC0418 and TTC0746 showed significant similarities to bacterial LonA-type proteases, such as Escherichia coli Lon protease, especially in regions corresponding to domains for ATP-binding and hydrolysis, and for proteolysis, but TTC1975 exhibited a similarity only at the C-terminal proteolytic domain. The enzymatic analyses, using purified recombinant proteins produced by E. coli, revealed that TTC0418 and TTC0746 exhibited peptidase and protease activities against two synthetic peptides and casein, respectively, in an ATP-dependent manner, and at the same time, both the enzymes had significant ATPase activities in the presence of substrates. On the other hand, TTC1975 possessed a protease activity against casein, but addition of ATP did not enhance this activity. Moreover, a T. thermophilus mutant deficient in both TTC0418 and TTC0746 showed a similar growth characteristic to an E. coli lon mutant, i.e., a growth defect lag after a nutritional downshift. These results indicate that TTC0418 and TTC0746 are actually members of bacterial LonA-type proteases with different substrate specificities, whereas TTC1975 should not be classified as a Lon protease. Finally, the effects of mutations deficient in these proteases were assessed on production of several heterologous gene products from Pyrococcus horikoshii and Geobacillus stearothermophilus. It was shown that TTC0746 mutation was more effective in improving production than the other two mutations, especially for production of P. horikoshii α-mannosidase and G. stearothermophilus α-amylase, indicating that the TTC0746 mutant of T. thermophilus HB27 may be useful for production of heterologous proteins from thermophiles and hyperthermophiles.     

Biological roles of the Podospora anserina mitochondrial Lon protease and the importance of its N-domain

Mitochondria have their own ATP-dependent proteases that maintain the functional state of the organelle. All multicellular eukaryotes, including filamentous fungi, possess the same set of mitochondrial proteases, unlike in unicellular yeasts, where ClpXP, one of the two matricial proteases, is absent. Despite the presence of ClpXP in the filamentous fungus Podospora anserina, deletion of the gene encoding the other matricial protease, PaLon1, leads to lethality at high and low temperatures, indicating that PaLON1 plays a main role in protein quality control. Under normal physiological conditions, the PaLon1 deletion is viable but decreases life span. PaLon1 deletion also leads to defects in two steps during development, ascospore germination and sexual reproduction, which suggests that PaLON1 ensures important regulatory functions during fungal development. Mitochondrial Lon proteases are composed of a central ATPase domain flanked by a large non-catalytic N-domain and a C-terminal protease domain. We found that three mutations in the N-domain of PaLON1 affected fungal life cycle, PaLON1 protein expression and mitochondrial proteolytic activity, which reveals the functional importance of the N-domain of the mitochondrial Lon protease. All PaLon1 mutations affected the C-terminal part of the N-domain. Considering that the C-terminal part is predicted to have an α helical arrangement in which the number, length and position of the helices are conserved with the solved structure of its bacterial homologs, we propose that this all-helical structure participates in Lon substrate interaction.     

Polypeptide stimulators of the Ms-Lon protease

Both the peptidase activity against small fluorescent peptide substrates and the ATPase activity of Lon (La) proteases are stimulated by unstructured proteins such as alpha-casein. This stimulation reveals the simultaneous interaction of Lon with two proteolytic substrates--alpha-casein and the peptide substrate. To understand the cellular function of this stimulation, it is important to determine the physical properties of Lon stimulators. The abilities of compositionally simple random copolymers of amino acids (rcAAs) to stimulate the peptidase and ATPase activities of the Lon protease from Mycobacterium smegmatis (Ms-Lon) and its N-terminal truncation mutant (N-E226) were determined. We report that cationic but not anionic rcAAs stimulated Ms-Lon's peptidase activity but were themselves poor substrates for the enzyme. Peptidase stimulation by rcAAs correlated approximately with the degree of hydrophobicity of these polypeptides and reached levels >10-fold higher than observed previously for Ms-Lon stimulators such as alpha-casein. In contrast to alpha-casein, which stimulates Ms-Lon's peptidase activity by 40% and ATPase activity by 150%, rcAAs stimulated peptidase activity without concomitant stimulation of ATPase activity. Active site labeling experiments suggested that both rcAAs and ATP increased peptidase activity by increasing accessibility to the peptidase active site. Peptidase activity assays in the presence of both alpha-casein and rcAAs revealed that interactions of rcAAs and alpha-casein with Ms-Lon are extremely complex and not mutually exclusive. Specifically, (1) additions of low concentrations of alpha-casein (<50 microg/mL) caused a further stimulation of Ms-Lon's rcAA-stimulated peptidase activity; (2) additions of higher concentrations of alpha-casein inhibited Ms-Lon's rcAA-stimulated peptidase activity; (3) additions of all concentrations of alpha-casein inhibited N-E226's rcAA-stimulated peptidase activity. We conclude the Ms-Lon can interact with an rcAA, alpha-casein, and a substrate peptide simultaneously, and that formation of this quaternary complex requires the N-terminal domain of Ms-Lon. These data support models of Ms-Lon that include two allosteric polypeptide binding sites distinct from the catalytic peptidase site.     

Crystal structure of the N-terminal domain of E. coli Lon protease

We report here the first crystal structure of the N-terminal domain of an A-type Lon protease. Lon proteases are ubiquitous, multidomain, ATP-dependent enzymes with both highly specific and non-specific protein binding, unfolding, and degrading activities. We expressed and purified a stable, monomeric 119-amino acid N-terminal subdomain of the Escherichia coli A-type Lon protease and determined its crystal structure at 2.03 A (Protein Data Bank [PDB] code 2ANE). The structure was solved in two crystal forms, yielding 14 independent views. The domain exhibits a unique fold consisting primarily of three twisted beta-sheets and a single long alpha-helix. Analysis of recent PDB depositions identified a similar fold in BPP1347 (PDB code 1ZBO), a 203-amino acid protein of unknown function from Bordetella parapertussis, crystallized as part of a structural genomics effort. BPP1347 shares sequence homology with Lon N-domains and with a family of other independently expressed proteins of unknown functions. We postulate that, as is the case in Lon proteases, this structural domain represents a general protein and polypeptide interaction domain.     

Crystal structure of Lon protease: molecular architecture of gated entry to a sequestered degradation chamber

Lon proteases are distributed in all kingdoms of life and are required for survival of cells under stress. Lon is a tandem fusion of an AAA+ molecular chaperone and a protease with a serine‐lysine catalytic dyad. We report the 2.0‐Å resolution crystal structure of Thermococcus onnurineus NA1 Lon (TonLon). The structure is a three‐tiered hexagonal cylinder with a large sequestered chamber accessible through an axial channel. Conserved loops extending from the AAA+ domain combine with an insertion domain containing the membrane anchor to form an apical domain that serves as a gate governing substrate access to an internal unfolding and degradation chamber. Alternating AAA+ domains are in tight‐ and weak‐binding nucleotide states with different domain orientations and intersubunit contacts, reflecting intramolecular dynamics during ATP‐driven protein unfolding and translocation. The bowl‐shaped proteolytic chamber is contiguous with the chaperone chamber allowing internalized proteins direct access to the proteolytic sites without further gating restrictions.     

Role of α-helical domains in functioning of ATP-dependent Lon protease of Escherichia coli

Homooligomeric ATP-dependent LonA proteases are bifunctional enzymes belonging to the superfamily of AAA⁺ proteins. Their subunits are formed by five successively connected domains, i.e., N-terminal (N), α-helical (HI(CC)), nucleotide-binding (NB), the second α-helical (H), and proteolytic (P) domains. The presence of the inserted HI(CC) domain determines the uniqueness of LonA proteases among the AAA⁺ proteins. The role of the α-helical domains in the LonA protease functioning was studied with an example of E. coli Lon protease (Ec-Lon). The properties of the intact Ec-Lon and its mutant forms, i.e., Lon-R164A and Lon-R542A bearing the substituted arginine residues at the similar positions in the HI(CC) and H domains, were compared. The H domain was shown to play a crucial role in ATP hydrolysis and enzyme binding to the target protein. The HI(CC) domain is not decisive for the manifestation of the catalytic properties of the enzyme. However, it affects the functioning of Lon ATPase and peptidase sites and is involved in maintaining enzyme stability. The participation of the HI(CC) domain in the formation of three-dimensional structures of LonA proteases and/or their complexes with DNA is suggested.     

Functional and Structural Characterization of Vibrio cholerae Extracellular Serine Protease B,VesB

The chymotrypsin subfamily A of serine proteases consists primarily of eukaryotic proteases, including only a few proteases of bacterial origin. VesB, a newly identified serine protease that is secreted by the type II secretion system in Vibrio cholerae, belongs to this subfamily. VesB is likely produced as a zymogen because sequence alignment with trypsinogen identified a putative cleavage site for activation and a catalytic triad, His-Asp-Ser. Using synthetic peptides, VesB efficiently cleaved a trypsin substrate, but not chymotrypsin and elastase substrates. The reversible serine protease inhibitor, benzamidine, inhibited VesB and served as an immobilized ligand for VesB affinity purification, further indicating its relationship with trypsin-like enzymes. Consistent with this family of serine proteases, N-terminal sequencing implied that the propeptide is removed in the secreted form of VesB. Separate mutagenesis of the activation site and catalytic serine rendered VesB inactive, confirming the importance of these features for activity, but not for secretion. Similar to trypsin but, in contrast to thrombin and other coagulation factors, Na⁺ did not stimulate the activity of VesB, despite containing the Tyr²⁵⁰ signature. The crystal structure of catalytically inactive pro-VesB revealed that the protease domain is structurally similar to trypsinogen. The C-terminal domain of VesB was found to adopt an immunoglobulin (Ig)-fold that is structurally homologous to Ig-folds of other extracellular Vibrio proteins. Possible roles of the Ig-fold domain in stability, substrate specificity, cell surface association, and type II secretion of VesB, the first bacterial multidomain trypsin-like protease with known structure, are discussed.     

Classification of ATP-dependent proteases Lon and comparison of the active sites of their proteolytic domains.

ATP-dependent Lon proteases belong to the superfamily of AAA+ proteins. Until recently, the identity of the residues involved in their proteolytic active sites was not elucidated. However, the putative catalytic Ser-Lys dyad was recently suggested through sequence comparison of more than 100 Lon proteases from various sources. The presence of the catalytic dyad was experimentally confirmed by site-directed mutagenesis of the Escherichia coli Lon protease and by determination of the crystal structure of its proteolytic domain. Furthermore, this extensive sequence analysis allowed the definition of two subfamilies of Lon proteases, LonA and LonB, based on the consensus sequences in the active sites of their proteolytic domains. These differences strictly associate with the specific characteristics of their AAA+ modules, as well as with the presence or absence of an N-terminal domain.