The intracellular events triggered by the self-incompatibility response inPapaver rhoeas

Summary In recent years self-incompatibility (SI) has come to be recognised as an important model system for studying cell-cell interactions and signalling in flowering plants. In this article we discuss the intracellular events associated with the SI response in the field poppy,Papaver rhoeas. The SI response inP. rhoeas is known to involve a Ca²⁺-based signalling pathway, activated following molecular interactions on the surface of incompatible pollen tubes. Evidence demonstrates that, following a transient increase in the concentration of cytosolic free Ca²⁺ ([Ca²⁺];) initiated by the SI response, phosphorylation of certain cytosolic proteins occurs, followed by activation of pollen gene expression. The magnitude of this transient Ca²⁺ wave and the localisation of cytosolic [Ca²⁺]i following the SI response are discussed. We also describe the character of the proteins specifically phosphorylated in the SI response and the nature of the protein kinases involved in their phosphorylation. Finally, we consider the possibility that the end result of the SI response inP. rhoeas may be analogous to programmed-cell-death mechanisms such as those seen in developmental processes and defence responses in various plant cells.     

Molecular analysis of two functional homologues of the S 3 allele of the Papaver rhoeas self-incompatibility gene isolated from different populations

The S ₃ allele of the S gene has been cloned from Papaver rhoeas cv. Shirley. The sequence predicts a hydrophilic protein of 14.0 kDa, showing 55.8% identity with the previously cloned S ₁ allele, preceded by an 18 amino acid signal sequence. Expression of the S ₃ coding region in Escherichia coli produced a form of the protein, denoted S₃e, which specifically inhibited S₃ pollen in an in vitro bioassay. The recombinant protein was ca. 0.8 kDa larger than the native stigmatic form, indicating post-translational modifications in planta, as was previously suggested for the S₁ protein. In contrast to other S proteins identified to date, S₃ protein does not appear to be glycosylated. Of particular significance is the finding that despite exhibiting a high degree of sequence polymorphism, secondary structure predictions indicate that the S₁ and S₃ proteins may adopt a virtually identical conformation. Sequence analysis also indicates that the P. rhoeas S alleles share some limited homology with the SLG and SRK genes from Brassica oleracea. Previously, cross-classification of different populations of P. rhoeas had revealed a number of functionally identical alleles. Probing of western blots of stigma proteins from plants derived from a wild Spanish population which contained an allele functionally identical to the Shirley S ₃ allele with antiserum raised to S₃e, revealed a protein (S ₃ s) which was indistinguishable in pI and M _r from that in the Shirley population. A cDNA encoding S ₃ s was isolated, nucleotide sequencing revealing a coding region with 99.4% homology with the Shirley-derived clone at the DNA level, and 100% homology at the amino acid level.     

Identification and cloning of related self-incompatibility S-genes in Papaver rhoeas and Papaver nudicaule

 The primary goal of this study was to identify, clone and analyse new S-gene sequences in order to provide a basis for identifying amino acid residues that confer S-allele specificity. Three new putative S-alleles from Papaver rhoeas and Papaver nudicaule were identified using immunological and PCR methods. cDNAs encoding full-length open reading frames of the P. rhoeas S ₈ and P. nudicaule Sn ₁ genes were isolated. Nucleotide sequencing of these cDNAs, together with the partial S ₇ sequence obtained by PCR, was used to derive the corresponding amino acid sequences. It is of interest that the P. nudicaule Sn₁ sequence, which is the first S-allele isolated from another species of Papaver, shares a closer sequence identity to the P. rhoeas S₃ amino acid sequence than S₃ does to S₁ from P. rhoeas. The identity of the S₈ allele was confirmed by expressing the coding region in Escherichia coli and demonstrating that the recombinant protein, designated S₈e, specifically inhibited S ₈ pollen in an in vitro bioassay. Information from sequence analysis of the S₈, Sn₁ and partial S₇ amino acid sequences revealed important information about Papaver S-proteins. It confirmed previous observations based on only two S-alleles, that whilst exhibiting a high degree of amino acid sequence polymorphism ranging from 51.3% to 63.7%, these molecules probably share very similar secondary structures. These studies also revealed that, in contrast to the S-proteins from the Solanaceae and Brassica, amino acid sequence variation is not found in hypervariable blocks, but instead, is found throughout the S-proteins, interspersed with numerous short strictly conserved segments. Received: 16 March 1998 / Revision accepted: 19 May 1998     

Towards an in vitro bioassay for the self-incompatibility response in Brassica oleracea

Summary Eluates of stigmas of Brassica oleracea that were known to contain S locus-specific glycoproteins (SLSG) discriminated between self and cross pollen in vitro in three different media. Discrimination was equally evident in experiments that were the in vitro equivalents of reciprocal pollinations. In a TAPS-buffered medium, self eluates depressed pollen germination in a dose-dependent manner. TAPS medium allowed a bioassay of the effects of SLSG in eluates because it optimized germination in a way that eliminated the complicating features of the stimulatory substances in the eluates. Stigma eluates affected percentage pollen germination and optimum calcium concentrations in vitro whether or not SLSG were present in the eluates, but differently in different media, and depending on whether the eluates were cross or self with respect to the pollen tested. Thus, the effect of stigma eluates on the in vitro germination of pollen in Brassica depends on the balance of stimulatory versus inhibitory substances in the eluates.     

Pollination in vitro: effects on the growth of pollen tubes,seed set and gametophytic self-incompatibility in Trifolium pratense L. and T. repens L.

Summary Growth of pollen tubes and seed set were compared after hand pollination in situ and in vitro in two self-incompatible species, Trifolium pratense and Trifolium repens. Adhesion of pollen grains to the stigma was greater in vitro for both species. After cross-pollination, in vitro culture gave a significant increase in the cumulative growth of pollen tubes in pistils of T. pratense compared to in situ conditions. After selfing in T. repens, pollen tube growth was significantly increased by in vitro culture of florets. Seed set after crossing in situ and in vitro was similar for both species. Seed set after selfing in vitro was not increased in T. pratense. Several genotypes of T. repens were classified as very good, good and poor selfers based on their capacity for seed set following selfing in situ. In vitro pollination increased self seed formation by 1.7-, 18.0- and 31.0-fold for each class, respectively. Ovules located nearest to the style were fertilized more often after selfing than after crossing.     

In vitro test of self-incompatibility in Malus domestica

Summary An in vitro assay in which self-incompatible pollen of Malus domestica is selectively inhibited is described. This assay involves heat-labile substances diffusing from the stylar tissues — in particular, glycoproteins found in the protein extract of styles. In the presence of the self-style extract, a dramatic decrease in total protein concentration in the culture medium was revealed at 30-min germination. Pretreatment of the self-pollen with 100 mM glucose prevented this drop in protein level; moreover, tube growth was entirely restored. A possible explanation in terms of protein-carbohydrate complementation is suggested.     

Characteristics of self-incompatibility in Schlumbergera truncata and S. x buckleyi (Cactaceae)

The influence of self-incompatibility (SI) on fruit set, seed set, and pollen tube growth was investigated in Schlumbergera truncata (Haworth) Moran and S.xbuckleyi (T. Moore) Tjaden. Four Schlumbergera clones were crossed in a complete diallel to verify the presence of SI. Fruit did not set when the clones were selfed or when two of the clones were crossed reciprocally, but all other outcrosses yielded fruit which contained 100–200 seeds each. Compatible outcrosses were characterized by large numbers of pollen tubes in the style and ovary cavity at 72 h after pollination. When pistils were selfed or incompatibly crossed, pollen tubes were inhibited in the upper third of the style and few pollen tubes reached the base of the style by 72 h after pollination. Schlumbergera exhibits several characteristics often associated with sporophytic SI systems (tricellular pollen and dry stigmas with elongate papillae), together with those commonly observed in gametophytic SI systems (stylar inhibition of incompatible pollen tubes and absence of reciprocal differences in outcrosses).Publication no. 3174 of the Massachusetts Agricultural Experiment Station     

Quantitatively determined self-incompatibility

Summary It is shown by simulation that a hypothetical multilocus, quantitatively determined self-incompatibility system, whether gametophytic or sporophytic, should maintain variability in small populations at a higher level than would panmixia. Studies of more than 20 isozyme loci show that borage has almost no variability.     

Quantitatively determined self-incompatibility

Summary It has been reported that incomplete self-incompatibility could be determined in Borago officinalis by many genes. Simple ten-gene models for such enforced cross-fertilization have been developed and their properties examined by computer simulation. Mutation rates necessary to maintain a given level of variability in small populations are high, as already determined theoretically for oligogenic self-incompatibility systems. However, the extent of ineffective pollination is very much greater in the ten-gene system. This finding may be verifiable in borage if it is indeed self-incompatible.     

The effect of isolated components of Prunus avium L. styles on in vitro growth of pollen tubes

A number of components isolated from styles of P. avium cv. Napoleon (S ₃ S ₄) have been tested for their capacity to influence in vitro growth of pollen tubes from fresh and stored pollen (cv. Napoleon (S ₃ S ₄)). An antigenic glycoprotein (Antigen S) is a potent inhibitor of in-vitro pollen tube growth, causing a 65% reduction in tube length at a concentration of 20 g/ml. None of the other style components were effective inhibitors of pollen tube growth; neither were proteins of animal origin such as histone, serum albumin, cytochrome C, and the glycoproteins ovalbumin and thyroglobulin, effective inhibitors.     

Quantitatively determined self-incompatibility

Summary It has been claimed that Borage (Borago officInalis L.) has a multifactorial self-incompatibility system. Such systems may have a high level of ineffective pollination, and we show that this is the case in borage. The ranking of seed set from highest to lowest is as follows: bee-pollination; natural pollination in the absence of bees; artificial cross-pollination between unrelated plants; artificial cross-pollination between related plants; artificial self-pollination. In diallel crosses, significant parental effects were detected but no consistent patterns of seed set, which suggest a simple self-incompatibility system, were detected. The level of outcrossing with natural pollination was very variable but greater than 50%. Thus, there appears to be no straightforward self-incompatibility system in borage.     

Evaluating self-incompatibility in Chrysanthemum

Summary The impact of ovule number on seed set calculations for self-incompatible (SI) species was investigated. Diploid Chrysanthemum was chosen for this study because accurate counts of the potential number of ovules could be made. Individuals in populations of C. carinatum, C. coronarium, C. c. subsp. spatiosum, and C. segetum were crossed in complete diallels. All species exhibited similar results. Therefore, only the diallel data from C. coronarium subsp. spatiosum were presented. The seed set data with and without ovule counts were processed by SIGMAS, a computer program designed to analyze SI data. Incorporation of the actual number of ovules into seed set diallels provided the most realistic representation of values for self-incompatibility studies. Data derived from equations excluding ovule counts might lead to inaccurate genetic interpretations. Ovule counts were significant between and within genotypes for self (disc and ray florets), but not cross (ray florets only) pollinations. The disc florets in self-pollinations were found to be responsible for increasing the variability in ovule number. The statistics indicate that the disc and ray florets composed two distinct populations. At the diploid level with a single daisy flower type, the disc floret numbers were variable, whereas ray florets were relatively static. This was not the case with polyploid chrysanthemums, where both ovule populations were dynamic and interactive. The conservative nature of percent pseudo-self-compatibility (%PSC) deems it necessary to obtain an accurate measure of female fertility. Values for this could be obtained using a bulk pollination or a tester with unmatched S alleles.Scientific Journal Series paper no. 15,880 of the Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station.     

In vitro pollination of isolated ovules of Cichorium intybus L.

 A method for the in vitro pollination of chicory (Cichorium intybus L.) ovules was developed. The purpose was to avoid self-incompatibility after in vitro self-pollination of ovules isolated from flower buds before anthesis and from open flower heads. Seedlings were obtained at a low percentage (0.76%), and the results were explained in terms of pollen viability, pollen germination on the ovule, embryogenesis studies and ploidy analysis. Received: 9 April 1997 / Revision received: 23 July 1997 / Accepted: 6 September 1999     

Dry stigmas,water and self-incompatibility in Brassica

The evolution of dry stigmas has been accompanied by the development — in the pollen — of mechanisms for accessing water from the stigmatic epidermis. Development of self- and cross-pollen on the stigmatic surface has been examined in Brassica oleracea, focusing on the hydration of the grains. Unlike self-compatible (SC) Arabidopsis thaliana, pollen hydration of self-incompatible (SI) Brassica oleracea is preceded by a latent period of between 30–90 min, which is significantly shortened by inhibition of protein synthesis in the stigma. Physiological experiments, some with isolated pollen coatings, indicate that during the latent period signals passing from the pollen to the sigma are responsible for readying the stigmatic surface for penetration and — after self-pollination — activation of the SI system. The changes at the stigma surface include the expansion of the outer layer of the cell wall beneath the grain. This expansion does not occur following self-pollination, when coating-derived signals stimulate a stigmatic response which interrupts hydration and arrests grain development. Cell manipulation studies suggest that self grains are not inhibited metabolically, but are physiologically isolated from the subjacent stigmatic papilla. This focusing of the SI response at the pollen-stigma interface ensures that a single papilla can simultaneously accept cross-pollen and reject self-grains. The evolution of this highly efficient SI system is disussed in the perspective of pathogen-defence mechanisms known also to be located in epidermal cells.     

Phosphorylation of style S-RNases by Ca2+-dependent protein kinases from pollen tubes

Solanaceous plants with gametophytic self-incompatibility produce ribonucleases in the transmitting tract of the style that interact with self-pollen and inhibit its growth. These ribonucleases are a series of allelic products of the S-locus, which controls self-incompatibility. Little is known about the pollen components involved in this interaction or whether a signal transduction pathway is activated during the self-incompatibility response. We have partially purified a soluble protein kinase from pollen tubes of Nicotiana alata that phosphorylates the self-incompatibility RNases (S-RNases) from N. alata but not Lycopersicon peruvianum. The soluble protein kinase (Nak-1) has several features shared by the calcium-dependent protein kinase (CDPK) class of plant protein kinases, including substrate specificity, calcium dependence, inhibition by the calmodulin antagonist calmidazolium, and cross-reaction with monoclonal antibodies raised to a CDPK from soybean. Phosphorylation of S ₂-RNase by Nak-1 is restricted to serine residues, but the site(s) of phosphorylation has not been determined and there is no evidence for allele-specific phosphorylation. The microsomal fraction from pollen tubes also phosphorylates S-RNases and this activity may be associated with proteins of M_r60 K and 69 K that cross-react with the monoclonal antibody to the soybean CDPK. These results are discussed in the context of the involvement of phosphorylation in other self-incompatibility systems.     

Analysis of self-incompatibility interactions in 30 resynthesized Brassica napus lines. I. Fluorescence microscopic studies

Thirty Brassica napus lines have been developed through interspecific hybridization of B. oleracea and B. campestris lines with defined S-allele constitutions. These lines, which represent 29 different S-allele combinations, were tested in a diallel of test-pollinations to determine the activity of the introgressed S-alleles and intergenomic dominance relationships. Some consistent trends were observed: B. oleracea S-alleles high in the dominance series (e.g. S₈, S₁₄, S₂₉) were always active in the resynthesized B. napus lines, whereas recessive S-alleles (S₂, S₁₅) lost their activity in some test combinations. The B. campestris S-alleles were active in most cases, although 2 alleles were partially inactivated by the recessive B. oleracea allele S₁₅.     

Inheritance and genetic mapping of self-incompatibility in Coffea canephora Pierre

Cross-compatibility behaviour of doubled haploid (DH) and hybrid genotypes of Coffea camphora was established using both phenotypic bioassay and in situ seed-set examination. The availability of DHs provided the opportunity of working with genetically homogenous pollen and female parents. The aniline blue fluorescence (ABF) method was applied to detect callose accumulation in pollen and pistil. Clear cross-compatibility/incompatibility situations were observed and confirmed by in situ seed-set analysis. Cross-compatibility analysis of hybrid combinations involving different DHs corroborated the crossing behaviour observed at the DH level. Expression of the self-incompatibility system did not appear to be affected by the low vigour of the DH. The crossing-behaviour distribution observed within DHs derived from clone IF200 confirmed that self-incompatibility in C. canephora is a gametophytic self-incompatibility system controlled by a single locus (S-locus). Reduced seed-set developments following incompatible crosses may indicate the occurrence of pseudo-incompatibility. Molecular marker linkage analysis showed that the S-locus is associated with an RFLP marker on linkage group 9. The availability of a linked DNA marker should facilitate the genetic analysis of self-incompatibility in relation to coffee breeding programmes.     

Isolation and partial characterization of components of Prunus avium L. styles,including an antigenic glycoprotein associated with a self-incompatibility genotype

Several components of buffer extracts of Prunus avium L. styles (cv. Lambert, S ₃ S ₄) have been isolated and partially characterized: the major component is a glycoprotein (molecular weight approx. 90,000; 95% protein, 5.4% carbohydrate). A sticky uronic-acid-containing component and an arabinogalactan are also present. Two minor components are an antigenic glycoprotein associated with the self-incompatibility genotype (Antigen S) and a component found in styles of all Prunus species (Antigen P). The isolated glycoproteins have a substantial carbohydrate content (Antigen P 17.2%; Antigen S 16.3%), and have apparent molecular weights of 32,000 (Antigen P) and 37,000–39,000 (Antigen S). They are antigenically quite distinct. Material corresponding to Antigen S is secreted into the medium of suspension-cultured callus cells raised from both leaf and stem of P. avium.Abbreviations DEAE diethylaminoethyl - SDS-PAGE sodium dodecylsulphate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis     

Changes in pollen tube behaviour induced by carbon dioxide and their role in overcoming self-incompatibility in Brassica

Summary Comparative studies on self-pollination after the application of high concentrations of CO₂ gas, which is known to overcome the self-incompatibility reaction in Cruciferous species, have revealed significant changes in the pollen tubes of germinating grains prior to their penetration into the papilla cells. A remarkable increase in the width of the pollen tube was induced by treating the stigmatic papillae with high CO₂ concentrations. The width of the pollen tube appeared to be greatest with CO₂ concentrations ranging from 3% to 5%; these concentrations were also optimal for tube penetration. Callose accumulation was extensively induced in the stigmatic papilla with 10%–20% of CO₂, although a typical callosic reaction remained through the ranges appropriate for blocking self-incompatibility. Observations using the scanning electron microscope (SEM) after pollination revealed that compatible pollen tubes in cross-pollinations fused completely to the papular surface during tube penetration, while in self-pollination, pollen tubes remained on the papilla with some additional diffusate. In the case of CO₂ treatment for self-pollination, some pollen tubes behaved very similarly to the incompatible or compatible ones already described, while others were different from both of them: they showed a complete fusion, similar to compatible ones, with additional diffusate, similar to incompatible ones. These responses of the pollen and stigma to high CO₂ concentrations are discussed with respect to their effect upon the expression of self-incompatibility.