Antifreeze proteins differentially affect model membranes during freezing

Over the past decade antifreeze proteins from polar fish have been shown either to stabilize or disrupt membrane structure during low temperature and freezing stress. However, there has been no systematic study on how membrane composition affects the interaction of antifreeze proteins with membranes under stress conditions. Therefore, it is not possible at present to predict which antifreeze proteins will protect, and which will damage a particular membrane during chilling or freezing. Here, we analyze the effects of freezing on spinach thylakoid membranes and on model membranes of varying lipid composition in the presence of antifreeze protein type I (AFP I) and specific fractions of antifreeze glycoproteins (AFGP). We find that the addition of galactolipids to phospholipid model membranes changes the effect each protein has on the membrane during freezing. However, the greatest differences observed in this study are between the different types of antifreeze proteins. We find that AFP type I and the largest molecular weight fractions of AFGP induce concentration dependent leakage from, and are fusogenic to the liposomes. This is the first report that an antifreeze protein induces membrane fusion. In contrast, the smallest fraction of AFGP offers a limited degree of protection during freezing and does not induce membrane fusion at concentrations up to 10 mg/ml.     

Positive Darwinian Selection Promotes Heterogeneity Among Members of the Antifreeze Protein Multigene Family

A variety of organisms have independently evolved proteins exhibiting antifreeze activity that allows survival at subfreezing temperatures. The antifreeze proteins (AFPs) bind ice nuclei and depress the freezing point by a noncolligative absorption–inhibition mechanism. Many organisms have a heterogeneous suite of AFPs with variation in primary sequence between paralogous loci. Here, we demonstrate that the diversification of the AFP paralogues is promoted by positive Darwinian selection in two independently evolved AFPs from fish and beetle. First, we demonstrate an elevated rate of nonsynonymous substitutions compared to synonymous substitutions in the mature protein coding region. Second, we perform phylogeny-based tests of selection to demonstrate a subset of codons is subjected to positive selection. When mapped onto the three-dimensional structure of the fish antifreeze type III antifreeze structure, these codons correspond to amino acid positions that surround but do not interrupt the putative ice-binding surface. The selective agent may be related to efficient binding to diverse ice surfaces or some other aspect of AFP function. Received: 27 February 2001 / Accepted: 12 September 2001     

Structural and functional similarity between fish antifreeze proteins and calcium-dependent lectins.

A cDNA for a type II antifreeze protein was isolated from liver of smelt (Osmerus mordax). The predicted protein sequence is homologous to that from sea raven (Hemitripterus americanus) and both show homology to a family of calcium-dependent lectins. Smelt and sea raven belong to taxonomic orders believed to have diverged prior to Cenozoic glaciation. Thus, type II antifreeze proteins appear to have evolved independently in these fish species from pre-existing calcium-dependent lectins. Sequence alignment of the antifreezes and the lectins suggest that these proteins adopt a similar fold, that the sea raven antifreeze has lost its Ca2+ binding sites, and the smelt antifreeze has retained one site. Experiments show that smelt antifreeze protein activity is responsive to Ca2+ but that of sea raven antifreeze protein is not. These results suggest that the type II fish antifreeze proteins and calcium-dependent lectins share a common ancestry, related folding structures, and functional similarity.     

Isolation and characterization of skin-type, type I antifreeze polypeptides from the longhorn sculpin, Myoxocephalus octodecemspinosus

The antifreeze polypeptides (AFPs) are found in several marine fish and have been grouped into four distinct biochemical classes (type I-IV). Recently, the new subclass of skin-type, type I AFPs that are produced intracellularly as mature polypeptides have been identified in the winter flounder (Pleuronectes americanus) and the shorthorn sculpin (Myoxocephalus scorpius). This study demonstrates the presence of skin-type AFPs in the longhorn sculpin (Myoxocephalus octodecemspinosus), which produces type IV serum AFPs. Using polymerase chain reaction-based methods, a clone that encoded for a type I AFP was identified. The clone lacked a signal sequence, indicating that the mature polypeptide is produced in the cytosol. A recombinant protein was produced in Escherichia coli and antifreeze activity was characterized. Four individual Ala-rich polypeptides with antifreeze activity were isolated from the skin tissue. One polypeptide was completely sequenced by tandem MS. This study provides the first evidence of a fish species that produces two different biochemical classes of antifreeze proteins (type I and type IV), and enforces the notion that skin-type AFPs are a widespread biological phenomenon in fish.     

Structural and functional characterization of a C-type lectin-like antifreeze protein from rainbow smelt (Osmerus mordax).

Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) are produced by several cold-water fish species. They depress physiological freezing temperatures by inhibiting growth of ice crystals and, in so doing, permit the survival of these fish in seawater cooler than their normal freezing temperatures. The type II AFP from rainbow smelt (Osmerus mordax), which is a member of the C-type lectin superfamily, was characterized in terms of its Ca2+-binding quaternary structure and the role of its single N-linked oligosaccharide. The protein core of the smelt AFP, shown through sequence homology to be a C-type lectin carbohydrate-recognition domain, was found to be protease resistant. Smelt AFP was also shown to bind Ca2+, as determined by ruthenium red staining and a conformational change on Ca2+ binding detected by intrinsic fluorescence. The N-linked oligosaccharide was found to have no effect on protease resistance, dimerization, or antifreeze activity. Thus its role, if any, in the antifreeze function of this protein remains unknown. Smelt AFP was also shown to be a true intermolecular dimer composed of two separate subunits. This dimerization did not require the presence of N-linked oligosaccharide or bound Ca2+. Smelt AFP dimerization has implications for the effective solution concentration and measurement of its activity. This finding may also lead to new interpretation of the mechanism of ice-growth inhibition by this AFP.     

Ice nucleation inhibition: mechanism of antifreeze by antifreeze protein

The effect of antifreeze protein type III (one type of fish antifreeze protein) on ice crystallization was examined quantitatively based on a "micro-sized ice nucleation" technique. It was found for the first time that antifreeze proteins can inhibit the ice nucleation process by adsorbing onto both the surfaces of ice nuclei and dust particles. This leads to an increase of the ice nucleation barrier and the desolvation kink kinetics barrier, respectively. Based on the latest nucleation model, the increases in the ice nucleation barrier and the kink kinetics barrier were measured. This enables us to quantitatively examine the antifreeze mechanism of antifreeze proteins for the first time.     

A mechanism for stabilization of membranes at low temperatures by an antifreeze protein.

Polar fish, cold hardy plants, and overwintering insects produce antifreeze proteins (AFPs), which lower the freezing point of solutions noncolligatively and inhibit ice crystal growth. Fish AFPs have been shown to stabilize membranes and cells in vitro during hypothermic storage, probably by interacting with the plasma membrane, but the mechanism of this stabilization has not been clear. We show here that during chilling to nonfreezing temperatures the alpha-helical AFP type I from polar fish inhibits leakage across model membranes containing an unsaturated chloroplast galactolipid. The mechanism involves binding of the AFP to the bilayer, which increases the phase transition temperature of the membranes and alters the molecular packing of the acyl chains. We suggest that this change in acyl chain packing results in the reduced membrane permeability. The data suggest a hydrophobic interaction between the peptide and the bilayer. Further, we suggest that the expression of AFP type I in transgenic plants may be significant for thermal adaptation of chilling-sensitive plants.     

A leucine-rich repeat protein of carrot that exhibits antifreeze activity

A gene encoding an antifreeze protein (AFP) was isolated from carrot (Daucus carota) using sequence information derived from the purified protein. The carrot AFP is highly similar to the polygalacturonase inhibitor protein (PGIP) family of apoplastic plant leucine-rich repeat (LRR) proteins. Expression of the AFP gene is rapidly induced by low temperatures. Furthermore, expression of the AFP gene in transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana plants leads to an accumulation of antifreeze activity. Our findings suggest that a new type of plant antifreeze protein has recently evolved from PGIPs.     

Effect of a mutation on the structure and dynamics of an alpha-helical antifreeze protein in water and ice

One strategy of psychrophilic organisms to survive subzero temperature is to produce antifreeze protein (AFPs), which inhibit the growth of macromolecular ice. To better understand the binding mechanism, the structure and dynamics of several AFPs have been studied by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and X-ray crystallography. The results have shown that different organisms can use diverse structures (alpha-helix, beta-helix, or different globular folds) to achieve the same function. A number of studies have focused on understanding the relationship between the alpha-helical structure of fish type I AFP and its function as an inhibitor of ice growth. The results have not explained whether the 90% activity loss caused by the conservative mutation of two threonines to serines (Thr13Ser/Thr24Ser) is attributable to a change in protein structure in solution or in ice. We examine here the structure and dynamics of the winter flounder type I AFP and the mutant Thr13Ser/Thr24Ser in both solution and solid states using a wide range of NMR approaches. Both proteins remain fully alpha-helical at all temperatures and in ice, demonstrating that the activity change must therefore not be attributable to changes in the protein fold or dynamics but differences in surface properties.     

Fluorescence microscopy evidence for quasi-permanent attachment of antifreeze proteins to ice surfaces

Many organisms are protected from freezing by the presence of extracellular antifreeze proteins (AFPs), which bind to ice, modify its morphology, and prevent its further growth. These proteins have a wide range of applications including cryopreservation, frost protection, and as models in biomineralization research. However, understanding their mechanism of action remains an outstanding challenge. While the prevailing adsorption-inhibition hypothesis argues that AFPs must bind irreversibly to ice to arrest its growth, other theories suggest that there is exchange between the bound surface proteins and the free proteins in solution. By conjugating green fluorescence protein (GFP) to a fish AFP (Type III), we observed the binding of the AFP to ice. This was accomplished by monitoring the presence of GFP-AFP on the surface of ice crystals several microns in diameter using fluorescence microscopy. The lack of recovery of fluorescence after photobleaching of the GFP component of the surface-bound GFP-AFP shows that there is no equilibrium surface-solution exchange of GFP-AFP and thus supports the adsorption-inhibition mechanism for this type of AFP. Moreover, our study establishes the utility of fluorescently labeled AFPs as a research tool for investigating the mechanisms underlying the activity of this diverse group of proteins.     

Structure and evolutionary origin of Ca(2+)-dependent herring type II antifreeze protein

In order to survive under extremely cold environments, many organisms produce antifreeze proteins (AFPs). AFPs inhibit the growth of ice crystals and protect organisms from freezing damage. Fish AFPs can be classified into five distinct types based on their structures. Here we report the structure of herring AFP (hAFP), a Ca(2+)-dependent fish type II AFP. It exhibits a fold similar to the C-type (Ca(2+)-dependent) lectins with unique ice-binding features. The 1.7 A crystal structure of hAFP with bound Ca(2+) and site-directed mutagenesis reveal an ice-binding site consisting of Thr96, Thr98 and Ca(2+)-coordinating residues Asp94 and Glu99, which initiate hAFP adsorption onto the [10-10] prism plane of the ice lattice. The hAFP-ice interaction is further strengthened by the bound Ca(2+) through the coordination with a water molecule of the ice lattice. This Ca(2+)-coordinated ice-binding mechanism is distinct from previously proposed mechanisms for other AFPs. However, phylogenetic analysis suggests that all type II AFPs evolved from the common ancestor and developed different ice-binding modes. We clarify the evolutionary relationship of type II AFPs to sugar-binding lectins.     

A re-evaluation of the role of type IV antifreeze protein

A lipoprotein-like antifreeze protein (type IV AFP) has previously been isolated only from the blood plasma of the longhorn sculpin. However, the plasma antifreeze activity in all individuals of this species tested from Newfoundland and New Brunswick waters ranges from low to undetectable. A close relative of the longhorn sculpin, the shorthorn sculpin, does have appreciable antifreeze activity in its blood but this is virtually all accounted for by the α-helical, alanine-rich type I AFP, other isoforms of which are also present in the skin of both fishes. We have characterized a putative ortholog of type IV AFP in shorthorn sculpin by cDNA cloning. This 12.2-kDa Gln-rich protein is 87% identical to the longhorn sculpin’s type IV AFP. Recombinant versions of both orthologs were produced in bacteria and shown to have antifreeze activity. Immunoblotting with antibodies raised to type IV AFP shows this protein present in longhorn sculpin plasma at levels of less than 100 μg/mL, which are far too low to protect the blood from freezing at the temperature of icy seawater. This confirms the results of direct antifreeze assays on the plasmas. It appears that type IV AFP has the potential to develop as a functional antifreeze in these fishes but may not have been selected for this role because of the presence of type I AFP. Consistent with this hypothesis is the observation that the type IV AFP gene has not been amplified the way functional antifreeze protein genes have in all other species examined.     

Partitioning of fish and insect antifreeze proteins into ice suggests they bind with comparable affinity

Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) inhibit the growth of ice by binding to the surface of ice crystals, preventing the addition of water molecules to cause a local depression of the freezing point. AFPs from insects are much more effective at depressing the freezing point than fish AFPs. Here, we have investigated the possibility that insect AFPs bind more avidly to ice than fish AFPs. Because it is not possible to directly measure the affinity of an AFP for ice, we have assessed binding indirectly by examining the partitioning of proteins into a slowly growing ice hemisphere. AFP molecules adsorbed to the surface and became incorporated into the ice as they were overgrown. Solutes, including non-AFPs, were very efficiently excluded from ice, whereas AFPs became incorporated into ice at a concentration roughly equal to that of the original solution, and this was independent of the AFP concentration in the range (submillimolar) tested. Despite their >10-fold difference in antifreeze activity, fish and insect AFPs partitioned into ice to a similar degree, suggesting that insect AFPs do not bind to ice with appreciably higher affinity. Additionally, we have demonstrated that steric mutations on the ice binding surface that decrease the antifreeze activity of an AFP also reduce its inclusion into ice, supporting the validity of using partitioning measurements to assess a protein's affinity for ice.     

Type-IV Antifreeze Proteins are Essential for Epiboly and Convergence in Gastrulation of Zebrafish Embryos

Many organisms in extremely cold environments such as the Antarctic Pole have evolved antifreeze molecules to prevent ice formation. There are four types of antifreeze proteins (AFPs). Type-IV antifreeze proteins (AFP4s) are present also in certain temperate and even tropical fish, which has raised a question as to whether these AFP4s have important functions in addition to antifreeze activity. Here we report the identification and functional analyses of AFP4s in cyprinid fish. Two genes, namely afp4a and afp4b coding for AFP4s, were identified in gibel carp (Carassius auratus gibelio) and zebrafish (Danio rerio). In both species, afp4a and afp4b display a head-to-tail tandem arrangement and share a common 4-exonic gene structure. In zebrafish, both afp4a and afp4b were found to express specifically in the yolk syncytial layer (YSL). Interestingly, afp4a expression continues in YSL and digestive system from early embryos to adults, whereas afp4b expression is restricted to embryogenesis. Importantly, we have shown by using afp4a-specific and afp4b-specifc morpholino knockdown and cell lineage tracing approaches that AFP4a participates in epiboly progression by stabilizing yolk cytoplasmic layer microtubules, and AFP4b is primarily related to convergence movement. Therefore, both AFP4 proteins are essential for gastrulation of zebrafish embryos. Our current results provide first evidence that AFP such as AFP4 has important roles in regulating developmental processes besides its well-known function as antifreeze factors.     

Ordered surface carbons distinguish antifreeze proteins and their ice-binding regions

Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) are found in cold-adapted organisms and have the unusual ability to bind to and inhibit the growth of ice crystals. However, the underlying molecular basis of their ice-binding activity is unclear because of the difficulty of studying the AFP-ice interaction directly and the lack of a common motif, domain or fold among different AFPs. We have formulated a generic ice-binding model and incorporated it into a physicochemical pattern-recognition algorithm. It successfully recognizes ice-binding surfaces for a diverse range of AFPs, and clearly discriminates AFPs from other structures in the Protein Data Bank. The algorithm was used to identify a novel AFP from winter rye, and the antifreeze activity of this protein was subsequently confirmed. The presence of a common and distinct physicochemical pattern provides a structural basis for unifying AFPs from fish, insects and plants.     

A re-evaluation of the role of type IV antifreeze protein

A lipoprotein-like antifreeze protein (type IV AFP) has previously been isolated only from the blood plasma of the longhorn sculpin. However, the plasma antifreeze activity in all individuals of this species tested from Newfoundland and New Brunswick waters ranges from low to undetectable. A close relative of the longhorn sculpin, the shorthorn sculpin, does have appreciable antifreeze activity in its blood but this is virtually all accounted for by the α-helical, alanine-rich type I AFP, other isoforms of which are also present in the skin of both fishes. We have characterized a putative ortholog of type IV AFP in shorthorn sculpin by cDNA cloning. This 12.2-kDa Gln-rich protein is 87% identical to the longhorn sculpin’s type IV AFP. Recombinant versions of both orthologs were produced in bacteria and shown to have antifreeze activity. Immunoblotting with antibodies raised to type IV AFP shows this protein present in longhorn sculpin plasma at levels of less than 100 μg/mL, which are far too low to protect the blood from freezing at the temperature of icy seawater. This confirms the results of direct antifreeze assays on the plasmas. It appears that type IV AFP has the potential to develop as a functional antifreeze in these fishes but may not have been selected for this role because of the presence of type I AFP. Consistent with this hypothesis is the observation that the type IV AFP gene has not been amplified the way functional antifreeze protein genes have in all other species examined.     

Cooperative function of ammonium polyacrylate with antifreeze protein type I

Activity of antifreeze proteins (AFPs) and antifreeze glycoproteins (AFGPs) is often determined by thermal hysteresis, which is the difference between the melting temperature and the nonequilibrium freezing temperature of ice in AF(G)P solutions. In this study, we confirmed that thermal hysteresis of AFP type I is significantly enhanced by a cooperative function of ammonium polyacrylate (NH4PA). Thermal hysteresis of mixtures of AFP type I and NH4PA was much larger than the sum of each thermal hysteresis of AFP type I and NH4PA alone. In mixed solutions of AFP type I and NH4PA in the thermal hysteresis region, hexagonal pyramidal-shaped pits densely formed on ice surfaces close to the basal planes. The experimental results suggest that the cooperative function of NH4PA with AFP type I was caused either by the increase in adsorption sites of AFP type I on ice or by the adsorption of AFP type I aggregates on ice.     

Type I shorthorn sculpin antifreeze protein: recombinant synthesis, solution conformation, and ice growth inhibition studies

A number of structurally diverse classes of "antifreeze" proteins that allow fish to survive in sub-zero ice-laden waters have been isolated from the blood plasma of cold water teleosts. However, despite receiving a great deal of attention, the one or more mechanisms through which these proteins act are not fully understood. In this report we have synthesized a type I antifreeze polypeptide (AFP) from the shorthorn sculpin Myoxocephalus scorpius using recombinant methods. Construction of a synthetic gene with optimized codon usage and expression as a glutathione S-transferase fusion protein followed by purification yielded milligram amounts of polypeptide with two extra residues appended to the N terminus. Circular dichroism and NMR experiments, including residual dipolar coupling measurements on a 15N-labeled recombinant polypeptide, show that the polypeptides are alpha-helical with the first four residues being more flexible than the remainder of the sequence. Both the recombinant and synthetic polypeptides modify ice growth, forming facetted crystals just below the freezing point, but display negligible thermal hysteresis. Acetylation of Lys-10, Lys-20, and Lys-21 as well as the N terminus of the recombinant polypeptide gave a derivative that displays both thermal hysteresis (0.4 degrees C at 15 mg/ml) and ice crystal faceting. These results confirm that the N terminus of wild-type polypeptide is functionally important and support our previously proposed mechanism for all type I proteins, in which the hydrophobic face is oriented toward the ice at the ice/water interface.     

An open source cryostage and software analysis method for detection of antifreeze activity

The aim of this study is to provide the reader with a simple setup that can detect antifreeze proteins (AFP) by inhibition of ice recrystallisation in very small sample sizes. This includes an open source cryostage, a method for preparing and loading samples as well as a software analysis method. The entire setup was tested using hyperactive AFP from the cerambycid beetle, Rhagium mordax. Samples containing AFP were compared to buffer samples, and the results are visualised as crystal radius evolution over time and in absolute change over 30 min. Statistical analysis showed that samples containing AFP could reliably be told apart from controls after only two minutes of recrystallisation. The goal of providing a fast, cheap and easy method for detecting antifreeze proteins in solution was met, and further development of the system can be followed at https://github.com/pechano/cryostage.