Understanding apparent DNA flexibility enhancement by HU and HMGB architectural proteins

Understanding and predicting the mechanical properties of protein/DNA complexes are challenging problems in biophysics. Certain architectural proteins bind DNA without sequence specificity and strongly distort the double helix. These proteins rapidly bind and unbind, seemingly enhancing the flexibility of DNA as measured by cyclization kinetics. The ability of architectural proteins to overcome DNA stiffness has important biological consequences, but the detailed mechanism of apparent DNA flexibility enhancement by these proteins has not been clear. Here, we apply a novel Monte Carlo approach that incorporates the precise effects of protein on DNA structure to interpret new experimental data for the bacterial histone-like HU protein and two eukaryotic high-mobility group class B (HMGB) proteins binding to ∼ 200-bp DNA molecules. These data (experimental measurement of protein-induced increase in DNA cyclization) are compared with simulated cyclization propensities to deduce the global structure and binding characteristics of the closed protein/DNA assemblies. The simulations account for all observed (chain length and concentration dependent) effects of protein on DNA behavior, including how the experimental cyclization maxima, observed at DNA lengths that are not an integral helical repeat, reflect the deformation of DNA by the architectural proteins and how random DNA binding by different proteins enhances DNA cyclization to different levels. This combination of experiment and simulation provides a powerful new approach to resolve a long-standing problem in the biophysics of protein/DNA interactions.     

Protein flexibility directs DNA recognition by the papillomavirus E2 proteins

Although DNA flexibility is known to play an important role in DNA-protein interactions, the importance of protein flexibility is less well understood. Here, we show that protein dynamics are important in DNA recognition using the well-characterized human papillomavirus (HPV) type 6 E2 protein as a model system. We have compared the DNA binding properties of the HPV 6 E2 DNA binding domain (DBD) and a mutant lacking two C-terminal leucine residues that form part of the hydrophobic core of the protein. Deletion of these residues results in increased specific and non-specific DNA binding and an overall decrease in DNA binding specificity. Using (15)N NMR relaxation and hydrogen/deuterium exchange, we demonstrate that the mutation results in increased flexibility within the hydrophobic core and loop regions that orient the DNA binding helices. Stopped-flow kinetic studies indicate that increased flexibility alters DNA binding by increasing initial interactions with DNA but has little or no effect on the structural rearrangements that follow this step. Taken together these data demonstrate that subtle changes in protein dynamics have a major influence on protein-DNA interactions.     

Structural organization of DNA complexes with proteins HMGB1 and HMGB1-(A+B)

The interaction between DNA and the nonhistone proteins HMGB1 and HMGB1-(A+B) has been studied using circular dichroism and scanning force microscopy. The recombinant protein HMGB1-(A+B) has no negatively charged C-terminal domain characteristic for HMGB1. Our earlier suggestion about the structural interaction of tandem HMGB1-domains of the recombinant protein with DNA was confirmed. It was shown that the C-terminal part modulates the interactions of HMGB1-domains with DNA. Without the C-terminal sequence, the HMGB1-(A+B) protein forms DNA-protein complexes with the ordered supramolecular structure.     

Involvement of HMGB1 and HMGB2 proteins in exogenous DNA integration reaction into the genome of HeLa S3 cells

Electrophoretic and Western blot studies were conducted on collagen fractions extracted from Sepia officinalis (cuttlefish) cartilage using a modified salt precipitation method developed for the isolation of vertebrate collagens. The antibodies used had been raised in rabbit against the following types of collagen: Sepia I-like; fish I; human I; chicken I, II, and IX; rat V; and calf IX and XI. The main finding was that various types of collagen are present in Sepia cartilage, as they are in vertebrate hyaline cartilage. However, the main component of Sepia cartilage is a heterochain collagen similar to vertebrate type I, and this is associated with minor forms similar to type V/XI and type IX. The cephalopod type I-like heterochain collagen can be considered a first step toward the evolutionary development of a collagen analogous to the typical collagen of vertebrate cartilage (type II homochain). The type V/XI collagen present in molluscs, and indeed all phyla from the Porifera upwards, may represent an ancestral collagen molecule conserved relatively unchanged throughout evolution. Type IX-like collagen seems to be essential for the formation of cartilaginous tissue.     

Basic N-terminus of yeast Nhp6A regulates the mechanism of its DNA flexibility enhancement

HMGB (high-mobility group box) proteins are members of a class of small proteins that are ubiquitous in eukaryotic cells and nonspecifically bind to DNA, inducing large-angle DNA bends, enhancing the flexibility of DNA, and likely facilitating numerous important biological interactions. To determine the nature of this behavior for different HMGB proteins, we used atomic force microscopy to quantitatively characterize the bend angle distributions of DNA complexes with human HMGB2(Box A), yeast Nhp6A, and two chimeric mutants of these proteins. While all of the HMGB proteins bend DNA to preferred angles, Nhp6A promoted the formation of higher-order oligomer structures and induced a significantly broader distribution of angles, suggesting that the mechanism of Nhp6A is like a flexible hinge more than that of HMGB2(Box A). To determine the structural origins of this behavior, we used portions of the cationic N-terminus of Nhp6A to replace corresponding HMGB2(Box A) sequences. We found that the oligomerization and broader angle distribution correlated directly with the length of the N-terminus incorporated into the HMGB2(Box A) construct. Therefore, the basic N-terminus of Nhp6A is responsible for its ability to act as a flexible hinge and to form high-order structures.     

Distorted DNA structures induced by HMGB2 possess a high affinity for HMGB2.

HMGB2 (HMG2) protein binds with DNA duplex in a sequence-nonspecific manner, then bends and unwinds the DNA. In DNA cyclization analyses for the bending activity of HMGB2, two unidentified bands, denoted alpha and beta, were observed in addition to monomer circular DNA (1C) on the gel. Re-electrophoresis and proteinase K digestion revealed that alpha and beta are complexes of circularized probe DNA (seeming 1C) with HMGB2 (K(d) approximately 10(-10) M). The DNA components of alpha and beta (alpha- and beta-DNA) showed higher affinities to HMGB2 than did the linear probe DNA (K(d) approximately 10(-7) M). The DNAs have distorted structures containing partial single-stranded regions. Nicked circular molecules presumably due to severe DNA distortion by HMGB2 were observed in alpha- and beta-DNA, in addition to closed circular double-stranded molecules. The alpha and beta bands were not formed in the presence of sole DNA binding regions which are necessary for DNA bending, indicating that the acidic C-tail in the HMGB2 molecule is necessary for inducing the peculiar distorted structures of higher affinity to HMGB2. HMGB2 binds with linker DNA and/or the entry and exit of nucleosomes fixed at both ends likewise mini-circles similar to alpha-DNA and beta-DNA. Thus, the distorted structures present in alpha-DNA and beta-DNA should be important in considering the functional mechanisms in which HMGB2 participates.     

Nucleosome linker proteins HMGB1 and histone H1 differentially enhance DNA ligation reactions

We previously reported that HMGB1, which originally binds to chromatin in a manner competitive with linker histone H1 to modulate chromatin structure, enhances both intra-molecular and inter-molecular ligations. In this paper, we found that histone H1 differentially enhances ligation reaction of DNA double-strand breaks (DSB). Histone H1 stimulated exclusively inter-molecular ligation reaction of DSB with DNA ligase IIIbeta and IV, whereas HMGB1 enhanced mainly intra-molecular ligation reaction. Electron microscopy of direct DNA-protein interaction without chemical cross-linking visualized that HMGB1 bends and loops linear DNA to form compact DNA structure and that histone H1 is capable of assembling DNA in tandem arrangement with occasional branches. These results suggest that differences in the enhancement of DNA ligation reaction are due to those in alteration of DNA configuration induced by these two linker proteins. HMGB1 and histone H1 may function in non-homologous end-joining of DSB repair and V(D)J recombination in different manners.     

Cofractionation of HMGB proteins with histone dimers

An effective and flexible method is presented that can be used to investigate cofractionation of groups of nuclear proteins. The method was used to analyze chromatin-related proteins, of which high-mobility group B (HMGB) proteins consistently cofractionated by cation-exchange chromatography with the histone dimer (H2A–H2B). This led to the hypothesis that the two form a complex, further suggested by gel filtration, in which the HMGBs with core histones eluted as a defined high-molecular-weight peak. A necessary requirement for further studying protein interactions is that the constituents are of the highest possible purity and the pure histone dimers and tetramers used in this study were derived from pure histone octamers with their native marks. There is a growing interest in protein–protein interactions and an increasing focus on protein-interaction domains: most frequently, pull-down assays are used to examine these. The technology presented here can provide an effective system that complements pull-down assays.     

Mechanism of amylin fibrillization enhancement by heparin

We characterized the interaction of amylin with heparin fragments of defined length, which model the glycosaminoglycan chains associated with amyloid deposits found in type 2 diabetes. Binding of heparin fragments to the positively charged N-terminal half of monomeric amylin depends on the concentration of negatively charged saccharides but is independent of oligosaccharide length. By contrast, amylin fibrillogenesis has a sigmoidal dependence on heparin fragment length, with an enhancement observed for oligosaccharides longer than four monomers and a leveling off of effects beyond 12 monomers. The length dependence suggests that the negatively charged helical structure of heparin electrostatically complements the positively charged surface of the fibrillar amylin cross-β structure. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer and total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy experiments indicate that heparin associates with amylin fibrils, rather than enhancing fibrillogenesis catalytically. Short heparin fragments containing two- or eight-saccharide monomers protect against amylin cytotoxicity toward a MIN6 mouse cell model of pancreatic β-cells.     

Functional significance of flexibility in proteins

The structural basis and the functional implications of large-scale flexibility are discussed for three systems: trypsin–trypsinogen, immunoglobulins, and citrate synthase. The trypsin–trypsinogen system provides an example in which an order–disorder transition is used as a means to regulate enzymatic activity. Immunoglobulins demonstrate how flexibly linked domains may be used to allow the binding of ligands with diverse arrangements. In citrate synthase, domain motion forms an active site that is shielded from solvent. Analogous large-scale flexibility has been observed in a number of other systems.     

Structural basis of DNA flexibility

It has been recently shown by us, on the basis of crystal structure database that the flexibility of B-DNA double helices depends significantly on their base sequence. Our model building studies further indicated that the existence of bifurcated cross-strand hydrogen bonds between successive base pairs is possibly the main factor behind the sequence directed DNA flexibility. These cross-strand hydrogen bonds are, of course, weaker than the usual Watson-Crick hydrogen bonds and their bond geometry is characterized by relatively larger bond lengths and smaller bond angles. We have tried to improve our model structures by incorporating non-planarity of the amino groups in DNA bases due to the presence of lone pair electrons at the nitrogen atoms. Energy minimization studies have been carried out by using different quantum chemical methods, whereby it is found that in all cases of N-H....O type cross-strand hydrogen bonds, the bond geometry improves significantly. In the cases of N-H....N type hydrogen bonds, however, no such consistent improvements can be noticed. Perhaps the true picture would emerge only if all the other interactions present in the DNA macromolecule could be appropriately taken into account.     

Recognition of DNA interstrand cross-link of antitumor cisplatin by HMGB1 protein

Several proteins that specifically bind to DNA modified by cisplatin, including those containing HMG-domains, mediate antitumor activity of this drug. Oligodeoxyribonucleotide duplexes containing a single, site-specific interstrand cross-link of cisplatin were probed for recognition by the rat chromosomal protein HMGB1 and its domains A and B using the electrophoretic mobility-shift assay. It has been found that the full-length HMGB1 protein and its domain B to which the lysine-rich region (seven amino acid residues) of the A/B linker is attached at the N-terminus (the domain HMGB1b7) specifically recognize DNA interstrand cross-linked by cisplatin. The affinity of these proteins to the interstrand cross-link of cisplatin is not very different from that to the major 1,2-GG intrastrand cross-link of this drug. In contrast, no recognition of the interstrand cross-link by the domain B lacking this region or by the domain A with or without this lysine-rich region attached to its C-terminus is noticed under conditions when these proteins readily bind to 1,2-GG intrastrand adduct. A structural model for the complex formed between the interstrand cross-linked DNA and the domain HMGB1b7 was constructed and refined using molecular mechanics and molecular dynamics techniques. The calculated accessible areas around the deoxyribose protons correlate well with the experimental hydroxyl radical footprint. The model suggests that the only major adaptation necessary for obtaining excellent surface complementarity is extra DNA unwinding (approximately 40 degrees ) at the site of the cross-link. The model structure is consistent with the hypothesis that the enhancement of binding affinity afforded by the basic lysine-rich A/B linker is a consequence of its tight binding to the sugar-phosphate backbone of both DNA strands.     

Phosphorylation of maize and Arabidopsis HMGB proteins by protein kinase CK2alpha

In plants, a variety of chromatin-associated high mobility group (HMG) proteins belonging to the HMGB family have been identified. We have examined the phosphorylation of the HMGB proteins from the monocotyledonous plant maize and the dicotyledonous plant Arabidopsis by protein kinase CK2alpha. Maize CK2alpha phosphorylates the maize HMGB1 and HMGB2/3 proteins and the Arabidopsis HMGB1, HMGB2/3, and HMGB4 proteins. Maize HMGB4 and HMGB5 and Arabidopsis HMGB5 are not phosphorylated by CK2alpha. Depending on the HMGB protein up to five amino acid residues are phosphorylated in the course of the phosphorylation reaction. The HMGB1 proteins from both plants are markedly more slowly phosphorylated by CK2alpha than the other HMGB substrate proteins, indicating that certain HMGB proteins are clearly preferred substrates for CK2alpha. The rate of the phosphorylation reaction appears to be related to the ease of interaction between CK2alpha and the HMGB proteins, as indicated by chemical cross-linking experiments. MALDI/TOF mass spectrometry analyses demonstrate that the HMGB1 and HMGB2/3 proteins occur in various phosphorylation states in immature maize kernels. Thus, HMGB1 exists as monophosphorylated, double-phosphorylated, triple-phosphorylated, and tetraphosphorylated protein in kernel tissue, and the tetraphosphorylated form is the most abundant version. The observed in vivo phosphorylation states indicate that protein kinase(s) other than CK2alpha contribute(s) to the modification of the plant HMGB proteins. The fact that the HMGB proteins are phosphorylated to various extents reveals that the existence of differentially modified forms increases the number of distinct HMGB protein variants in plant chromatin that may be adapted to certain functions.