Bi-site catalysis in F1-ATPase: does it exist?

The mechanism of action of F(1)F(0)-ATP synthase is controversial. Some favor a tri-site mechanism, where substrate must fill all three catalytic sites for activity, others a bi-site mechanism, where one of the three sites is always unoccupied. New approaches were applied to examine this question. First, ITP was used as hydrolysis substrate; lower binding affinities of ITP versus ATP enable more accurate assessment of sites occupancy. Second, distributions of all eight possible enzyme species (with zero, one, two or three sites filled) as fraction of total enzyme population at each ITP concentration were calculated, and compared with measured ITPase activity. Confirming data were obtained with ATP as substrate. Third, we performed a theoretical analysis of possible bi-site mechanisms. The results argue convincingly that bi-site hydrolysis activity is negligible, and may not even exist. Effectively, tri-site hydrolysis is the only mechanism. We argue that only tri-site hydrolysis drives subunit rotation. Theoretical analyses of possible bi-site mechanisms reveal serious flaws, not previously recognized. One is that, in bi-site catalysis, the predicted direction of subunit rotation is the same for both ATP synthesis and hydrolysis; a second is that infrequently occurring enzyme species are required.     

The mechanism of rotating proton pumping ATPases

Two proton pumps, the F-ATPase (ATP synthase, F_oF₁) and the V-ATPase (endomembrane proton pump), have different physiological functions, but are similar in subunit structure and mechanism. They are composed of a membrane extrinsic (F₁ or V₁) and a membrane intrinsic (F_o or V_o) sector, and couple catalysis of ATP synthesis or hydrolysis to proton transport by a rotational mechanism. The mechanism of rotation has been extensively studied by kinetic, thermodynamic and physiological approaches. Techniques for observing subunit rotation have been developed. Observations of micron-length actin filaments, or polystyrene or gold beads attached to rotor subunits have been highly informative of the rotational behavior of ATP hydrolysis-driven rotation. Single molecule FRET experiments between fluorescent probes attached to rotor and stator subunits have been used effectively in monitoring proton motive force-driven rotation in the ATP synthesis reaction. By using small gold beads with diameters of 40-60 nm, the E. coli F₁ sector was found to rotate at surprisingly high speeds (> 400 rps). This experimental system was used to assess the kinetics and thermodynamics of mutant enzymes. The results revealed that the enzymatic reaction steps and the timing of the domain interactions among the β subunits, or between the β and γ subunits, are coordinated in a manner that lowers the activation energy for all steps and avoids deep energy wells through the rotationally-coupled steady-state reaction. In this review, we focus on the mechanism of steady-state F₁-ATPase rotation, which maximizes the coupling efficiency between catalysis and rotation.     

Catalytic site occupancy during ATP hydrolysis by MF1-ATPase. Evidence for alternating high affinity sites during steady-state turnover

The mechanism of ATP hydrolysis by the solubilized mitochondrial ATPase (MF1) has been studied under conditions where catalytic turnover occurs at one site, uni-site catalysis (obtained when enzyme is in excess of substrate), or at two sites, bi-site catalysis (obtained when substrate is in excess of enzyme). Pulse-chase experiments support the conclusion that the sites which participate in bi-site catalysis are the same as those which participate in uni-site catalysis. Upon addition of ATP in molar excess to MF1, label that was bound under uni-site conditions dissociates at a rate equal to the rate of bi-site catalysis. Similarly, when medium ATP is removed, label that was bound under bi-site conditions dissociates at a rate equal to the rate of uni-site catalysis. Evidence that a high affinity catalytic site equivalent to the one observed under uni-site conditions participates as an intermediate in bi-site catalysis includes the demonstration of full occupancy of a catalytically competent site during steady-state turnover at nanomolar concentrations of ATP. Improved measurements of the interaction of ADP at a high affinity catalytic site have lead to the revision of several of the rate constants that define uni-site catalysis. The rate constant for unpromoted dissociation of ADP is equal to that for Pi (4 X 10(-3) s-1). The rate of binding ADP at a high affinity chaseable site (Kd = 1 nM) is equal to the rate of binding ATP (4 X 10(6) M-1 s-1). The rate of catalysis obtained when substrate binding at one site promotes product release from an adjacent site (bi-site catalysis) is up to 100,000-fold faster than unpromoted product release (uni-site catalysis).     

Kinetic analysis of proton translocation catalyzed by F0F1 ATPase

Kinetic analysis of both proton translocating and steady-state ATP hydrolytic activities catalyzed by F0F1 ATPase in submitochondrial particles were carried out over an ATP concentration range of 1-2000 microM. The results were examined in relation to the prediction based on the alternate binding change model proposed by Gresser et al. [(1982) J. Biol. Chem. 257, 12030-12038] in which energy transduction occurs only at the tri-site catalytic cycle. The present results essentially contrast with the model and rather indicate that if the alternate binding mechanism holds for the ATP hydrolytic reaction, the proton translocation should be coupled to at least both bi-site and tri-site cycles.     

Synthase (H(+) ATPase): coupling between catalysis, mechanical work, and proton translocation

Coupling with electrochemical proton gradient, ATP synthase (F(0)F(1)) synthesizes ATP from ADP and phosphate. Mutational studies on high-resolution structure have been useful in understanding this complicated membrane enzyme. We discuss mainly the mechanism of catalysis in the beta subunit of F(1) sector and roles of the gamma subunit in energy coupling. The gamma-subunit rotation during catalysis is also discussed.     

The rotor in the membrane of the ATP synthase and relatives

In recent years, structural information on the F(1) sector of the ATP synthase has provided an insight into the molecular mechanism of ATP catalysis. The structure strongly supports the proposal that the ATP synthase works as a rotary molecular motor. Insights into the membrane domain have just started to emerge but more detailed structural information is needed if the molecular mechanism of proton translocation coupled to ATP synthesis is to be understood. This review will focus mainly on the ion translocating rotor in the membrane domain of the F-type ATPase, and the related vacuolar and archaeal relatives.     

Active proton leak in mitochondria: A new way to regulate substrate oxidation

The main function of mitochondria is energy transduction, from substrate oxidation to the free energy of ATP synthesis, through oxidative phosphorylation. For physiological reasons, the degree of coupling between these two processes must be modulated in order to adapt redox potential and ATP turnover to cellular needs. Such a modulation leads to energy wastage. To this day, two energy wastage mechanisms have been described: the membrane passive proton conductance (proton leak) and the decrease in the coupling efficiency between electrons transfer and proton extrusion at the proton pumps level (redox or proton slipping). In this paper, we describe a new energy wastage mechanism of interest. We show that in isolated yeast mitochondria, the membrane proton conductance is strictly dependent on the external dehydrogenases activity. An increase in their activity leads to an increase in the membrane proton conductance. This proton permeability is independent of the respiratory chain and ATP synthase proton pumps. We propose to name this new mechanism “active proton leak.” Such a mechanism could allow a wide modulation of substrate oxidation in response to cellular redox constraints.     

Toward an Adequate Scheme for the ATP Synthase Catalysis

The suggestions from the author's group over the past 25 years for how steps in catalysis by ATP synthase occur are reviewed. Whether rapid ATP hydrolysis requires the binding of ATP to a second site (bi-site activation) or to a second and third site (tri-site activation) is considered. Present evidence is regarded as strongly favoring bi-site activation. Presence of nucleotides at three sites during rapid ATP hydrolysis can be largely accounted for by the retention of ADP formed and/or by the rebinding of ADP formed. Menz, Leslie and Walker ((2001) FEBS Lett., 494, 11-14) recently attained an X-ray structure of a partially closed enzyme form that binds ADP better than ATP. This accomplishment and other considerations form the base for a revised reaction sequence. Three types of catalytic sites are suggested, similar to those proposed before the X-ray data became available. During net ATP synthesis a partially closed site readily binds ADP and P_i but not ATP. At a closed site, tightly bound ADP and P_i are reversibly converted to tightly bound ATP. ATP is released from a partially closed site that can readily bind ATP or ADP. ATP hydrolysis when protonmotive force is low or lacking occurs simply by reversal of all steps with the opposite rotation of the subunit. Each type of site can exist in various conformations or forms as they are interconverted during a 120° rotation. The conformational changes with the ATP synthase, including the vital change when bound ADP and P_i are converted to bound ATP, are correlated with those that occur in enzyme catalysis in general, as illustrated by recent studies of Rose with fumarase. The _B structure of Walker's group is regarded as an unlikely, or only quite transient, intermediate. Other X-ray structures are regarded as closely resembling but not identical with certain forms participating in catalysis. Correlation of the suggested reaction scheme with other present information is considered.     

Biochemical properties of platelet microparticle membranes formed during exocytosis resemble organelles more than plasma membrane

An early proposal was that for rapid ATP synthesis by the rotational ATP synthase, a specific second site must bind ADP and P(i), and for rapid ATP hydrolysis a different second site must bind ATP. Such bi-site activation was considered to occur whether or not an ADP or ATP was at a third site. In contrast, a more recent proposal is that rapid ATP hydrolysis requires that all three sites have bound ADP or ATP present. However, discovery that one second site binds ADP better than ATP, together with other data and considerations support the earlier proposal. The retention or rebinding of ADP can explain why three sites fill during hydrolysis as ATP concentration is increased although bi-site activation still prevails.     

A perspective of the binding change mechanism for ATP synthesis

An overview of research in the field of bioenergetics that led to the development of the binding change mechanism for ATP synthesis is presented, with emphasis on research from the author's laboratory. The text follows closely the Rose Award Lecture given at the 1989 meeting of the American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology. Remarkable advances have revealed that the ubiquitous membrane-bound ATP synthase has unusual composition and properties. The enzyme complex has 1, 2, 3, or 9-12 copies of eight or more protein subunits. The catalytic sites are located on three copies of an approximately 55-kDa subunit. It has the strongest positive catalytic cooperativity known for any enzyme. Examples are given of selected experimental results that have provided insights into its mechanism. These include demonstration of the characteristics, location, and function of catalytic and noncatalytic adenine nucleotide binding sites and the incisive information provided by measurement of phosphate oxygen exchanges and distribution of 18(O) in ATP or Pi formed by catalysis. Research from various laboratories gives support to the binding change mechanism in which energy from proton translocation serves principally to promote release of tightly bound ATP, with sequential participation of three catalytic sites. Some speculative suggestions about a rotational catalysis and about the different forms assumed by the ATPase are included.     

Observation of calcium-dependent unidirectional rotational motion in recombinant photosynthetic F1-ATPase molecules

ATP hydrolysis and synthesis by the F(0)F(1)-ATP synthase are coupled to proton translocation across the membrane in the presence of magnesium. Calcium is known, however, to disrupt this coupling in the photosynthetic enzyme in a unique way: it does not support ATP synthesis, and CaATP hydrolysis is decoupled from any proton translocation, but the membrane does not become leaky to protons. Understanding the molecular basis of these calcium-dependent effects can shed light on the as yet unclear mechanism of coupling between proton transport and rotational catalysis. We show here, using an actin filament gamma-rotation assay, that CaATP is capable of sustaining rotational motion in a highly active hybrid photosynthetic F(1)-ATPase consisting of alpha and beta subunits from Rhodospirillum rubrum and gamma subunit from spinach chloroplasts (alpha(R)(3)beta(R)(3)gamma(C)). The rotation was found to be similar to that induced by MgATP in Escherichia coli F(1)-ATPase molecules. Our results suggest a possible long range pathway that enables the bound CaATP to induce full rotational motion of gamma but might block transmission of this rotational motion into proton translocation by the F(0) part of the ATP synthase.     

Pathogenesis of primary defects in mitochondrial ATP synthesis

Maternally inherited mutations in the mtDNA-encoded ATPase 6 subunit of complex V (ATP synthase) of the respiratory chain/oxidative phosphorylation system are responsible for a subgroup of severe and often-fatal disorders characterized predominantly by lesions in the brain, particularly in the striatum. These include NARP (neuropathy, ataxia, and retinitis pigmentosa), MILS (maternally inherited Leigh syndrome), and FBSN (familial bilateral striatal necrosis). Of the five known pathogenic mutations causing these disorders, four are located at two codons (156 and 217), each of which can suffer mutations converting a conserved leucine to either an arginine or a proline. Based on the accumulating data on both the structure of ATP synthase and the mechanism by which rotary catalysis couples proton flow to ATP synthesis, we propose a model that may help explain why mutations at codons 156 and 217 are pathogenic.     

The rotary mechanism of the ATP synthase

The F₀F₁ ATP synthase is a large complex of at least 22 subunits, more than half of which are in the membranous F₀ sector. This nearly ubiquitous transporter is responsible for the majority of ATP synthesis in oxidative and photo-phosphorylation, and its overall structure and mechanism have remained conserved throughout evolution. Most examples utilize the proton motive force to drive ATP synthesis except for a few bacteria, which use a sodium motive force. A remarkable feature of the complex is the rotary movement of an assembly of subunits that plays essential roles in both transport and catalytic mechanisms. This review addresses the role of rotation in catalysis of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis and the transport of protons or sodium.     

Stochastic proton pumping ATPases: from single molecules to diverse physiological roles

We discuss the most recent reports on two proton pumps, F-ATPase (ATP synthase) and V-ATPase (endomembrane proton pump). They are formed from similar extrinsic (F1 or V1) and intrinsic (Fo or Vo) membrane sectors, and couple chemistry and proton transport through subunit rotation for apparently different physiological roles. Emphasis is placed on the stochastic rotational catalysis of F-ATPase and isoforms of V-ATPase.     

Inefficient coupling between proton transport and ATP synthesis may be the pathogenic mechanism for NARP and Leigh syndrome resulting from the T8993G mutation in mtDNA

Mutations in the ATP6 gene of mtDNA (mitochondrial DNA) have been shown to cause several different neurological disorders. The product of this gene is ATPase 6, an essential component of the F1F0-ATPase. In the present study we show that the function of the F1F0-ATPase is impaired in lymphocytes from ten individuals harbouring the mtDNA T8993G point mutation associated with NARP (neuropathy, ataxia and retinitis pigmentosa) and Leigh syndrome. We show that the impaired function of both the ATP synthase and the proton transport activity of the enzyme correlates with the amount of the mtDNA that is mutated, ranging from 13-94%. The fluorescent dye RH-123 (Rhodamine-123) was used as a probe to determine whether or not passive proton flux (i.e. from the intermembrane space to the matrix) is affected by the mutation. Under state 3 respiratory conditions, a slight difference in RH-123 fluorescence quenching kinetics was observed between mutant and control mitochondria that suggests a marginally lower F0 proton flux capacity in cells from patients. Moreover, independent of the cellular mutant load the specific inhibitor oligomycin induced a marked enhancement of the RH-123 quenching rate, which is associated with a block in proton conductivity through F0 [Linnett and Beechey (1979) Inhibitors of the ATP synthethase system. Methods Enzymol. 55, 472-518]. Overall, the results rule out the previously proposed proton block as the basis of the pathogenicity of the mtDNA T8993G mutation. Since the ATP synthesis rate was decreased by 70% in NARP patients compared with controls, we suggest that the T8993G mutation affects the coupling between proton translocation through F0 and ATP synthesis on F1. We discuss our findings in view of the current knowledge regarding the rotary mechanism of catalysis of the enzyme.     

Mitochondrial F1FO ATP synthase determines the local proton motive force at cristae rims

The classical view of oxidative phosphorylation is that a proton motive force (PMF) generated by the respiratory chain complexes fuels ATP synthesis via ATP synthase. Yet, under glycolytic conditions, ATP synthase in its reverse mode also can contribute to the PMF. Here, we dissected these two functions of ATP synthase and the role of its inhibitory factor 1 (IF1) under different metabolic conditions. pH profiles of mitochondrial sub‐compartments were recorded with high spatial resolution in live mammalian cells by positioning a pH sensor directly at ATP synthase’s F₁ and F_O subunits, complex IV and in the matrix. Our results clearly show that ATP synthase activity substantially controls the PMF and that IF1 is essential under OXPHOS conditions to prevent reverse ATP synthase activity due to an almost negligible ΔpH. In addition, we show how this changes lateral, transmembrane, and radial pH gradients in glycolytic and respiratory cells.     

F(0) of ATP synthase is a rotary proton channel. Obligatory coupling of proton translocation with rotation of c-subunit ring

Coupling of proton flow and rotation in the F(0) motor of ATP synthase was investigated using the thermophilic Bacillus PS3 enzyme expressed functionally in Escherichia coli cells. Cysteine residues introduced into the N-terminal regions of subunits b and c of ATP synthase (bL2C/cS2C) were readily oxidized by treating the expressing cells with CuCl(2) to form predominantly a b-c cross-link with b-b and c-c cross-links being minor products. The oxidized ATP synthases, either in the inverted membrane vesicles or in the reconstituted proteoliposomes, showed drastically decreased proton pumping and ATPase activities compared with the reduced ones. Also, the oxidized F(0), either in the F(1)-stripped inverted vesicles or in the reconstituted F(0)-proteoliposomes, hardly mediated passive proton translocation through F(0). Careful analysis using single mutants (bL2C or cS2C) as controls indicated that the b-c cross-link was responsible for these defects. Thus, rotation of the c-oligomer ring relative to subunit b is obligatory for proton translocation; if there is no rotation of the c-ring there is no proton flow through F(0).     

Interaction between γC87 and γR242 residues participates in energy coupling between catalysis and proton translocation in Escherichia coli ATP synthase

Functioning as a nanomotor, ATP synthase plays a vital role in the cellular energy metabolism. Interactions at the rotor and stator interface are critical to the energy transmission in ATP synthase. From mutational studies, we found that the γC87K mutation impairs energy coupling between proton translocation and nucleotide synthesis/hydrolysis. An additional glutamine mutation at γR242 (γR242Q) can restore efficient energy coupling to the γC87K mutant. Arrhenius plots and molecular dynamics simulations suggest that an extra hydrogen bond could form between the side chains of γC87K and β_TPE381 in the γC87K mutant, thus impeding the free rotation of the rotor complex. In the enzyme with γC87K/γR242Q double mutations, the polar moiety of γR242Q side chain can form a hydrogen bond with γC87K, so that the amine group in the side chain of γC87K will not hydrogen-bond with βE381. As a conclusion, the intra-subunit interaction between positions γC87 and γR242 modulates the energy transmission in ATP synthase. This study should provide more information of residue interactions at the rotor and stator interface in order to further elucidate the energetic mechanism of ATP synthase.     

Studies on the relationship between ATP synthesis and transport and the proton electrochemical gradient in rat liver mitochondria

The effect of ATP synthesis on delta mu H in rat liver mitochondria has been analyzed by separating the steps of adenine nucleotide translocation and ATP synthesis in the matrix. Either exchange of ATP, synthesized by substrate level phosphorylation in the matrix of oligomycin-treated mitochondria, for external ADP, or activity of the membrane-bound ATP synthase complex results in delta mu H depression with respect to resting state levels. This depression appears to be more pronounced, under strictly comparable conditions, when arsenate is used to stimulate ATP synthase activity than when the ornithine-citrulline conversion reaction is used for the same purpose.     

Quantitative aspects of adenosine triphosphate-driven proton translocation in spinach chloroplast thylakoids

After illumination in the presence of dithiothreitol, chloroplast thylakoids catalyze ATP hydrolysis and an exchange between ATP and Pi in the dark. ATP hydrolysis is linked to inward proton translocation. The relationships between ATP hydrolysis, ATP-Pi exchange, and proton translocation during the steady state were examined. The internal proton concentration was found to be proportional to the rate of ATP hydrolysis when these parameters were varied by procedures that do not alter the proton permeability of the thylakoid membranes. A linear relationship between the internal proton concentration and the rate of nonphosphorylating electron flow was previously verified. By determining the constant relating internal proton concentration to both ATP hydrolysis and electron flow, the proton/ATP ratio for the chloroplast ATPase complex was calculated to be 3.4 +/- 0.3. The presence of Pi, which allows ATP-Pi exchange to occur, lowers the internal proton concentration, but does not alter the relationship between the net rate of ATP hydrolysis and internal proton concentration. ATP-Pi exchange shows a dependence on the proton activity gradient very similar to that of ATP synthesis in the light. These results suggest that ATP-Pi exchange resembles photophosphorylation. In agreement with this idea, it is nucleoside diphosphate from the medium that is phosphorylated during exchange. Moreover, the energy-linked incorporation of Pi and ADP into ATP during exchange occurs at a similar rate. Thus, ATP synthesis from medium ADP and Pi takes place at the expense of the pH gradient generated by ATP hydrolysis.