Detergent-like actions of linear amphipathic cationic antimicrobial peptides

Antimicrobial peptides have raised much interest as pathogens become resistant against conventional antibiotics. We review biophysical studies that have been performed to better understand the interactions of linear amphipathic cationic peptides such as magainins, cecropins, dermaseptin, delta-lysin or melittin. The amphipathic character of these peptides and their interactions with membranes resemble the properties of detergent molecules and analogies between membrane-active peptide and detergents are presented. Several models have been suggested to explain the pore-forming, membrane-lytic and antibiotic activities of these peptides. Here we suggest that these might be 'special cases' within complicated phase diagrams describing the morphological plasticity of peptide/lipid supramolecular assemblies.     

Detergent-like actions of linear amphipathic cationic antimicrobial peptides

Antimicrobial peptides have raised much interest as pathogens become resistant against conventional antibiotics. We review biophysical studies that have been performed to better understand the interactions of linear amphipathic cationic peptides such as magainins, cecropins, dermaseptin, δ-lysin or melittin. The amphipathic character of these peptides and their interactions with membranes resemble the properties of detergent molecules and analogies between membrane-active peptide and detergents are presented. Several models have been suggested to explain the pore-forming, membrane-lytic and antibiotic activities of these peptides. Here we suggest that these might be ‘special cases’ within complicated phase diagrams describing the morphological plasticity of peptide/lipid supramolecular assemblies.     

Tuning the biological properties of amphipathic alpha-helical antimicrobial peptides: rational use of minimal amino acid substitutions

In nature, alpha-helical antimicrobial peptides present the small and flexible residue glycine at positions 7 or 14 with a significant frequency. Based on the sequence of the non-proteinogenic alpha-helical model peptide P1(Aib7), with a potent, broad spectrum antimicrobial activity, six peptides were designed by effecting a single amino acid substitution to investigate how tuning the structural characteristics at position 7 could lead to optimization of selectivity without affecting antimicrobial activity against a broad panel of multidrug resistant bacterial and yeast indicator strains. The relationship between structural features (size/hydrophobicity of the side chain as well as conformation and flexibility) and biological activity, in terms of minimum inhibitory concentration, membrane permeabilization kinetics and lysis of red blood cells are discussed. On conversion of the peptide to proteinogenic residues, these principles allowed development of a potent antimicrobial peptide with a reduced cytotoxicity. However, while results suggest that both hydrophobicity of residue 7 and chain flexibility at this position can be modulated to improve selectivity, position 14 is less tolerant of substitutions.     

Peptide-membrane interactions and mechanisms of membrane destruction by amphipathic alpha-helical antimicrobial peptides

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) have received considerable interest as a source of new antibiotics with the potential for treatment of multiple-drug resistant infections. An important class of AMPs is composed of linear, cationic peptides that form amphipathic alpha-helices. Among the most potent of these are the cecropins and synthetic peptides that are hybrids of cecropin and the bee venom peptide, mellitin. Both cecropins and cecropin-mellitin hybrids exist in solution as unstructured monomers, folding into predominantly alpha-helical structures upon membrane binding with their long helical axis parallel to the bilayer surface. Studies using model membranes have shown that these peptides intercalate into the lipid bilayer just below the level of the phospholipid glycerol backbone in a location that requires expansion of the outer leaflet of the bilayer, and evidence from a variety of experimental approaches indicates that expansion and thinning of the bilayer are common characteristics during the early stages of antimicrobial peptide-membrane interactions. Subsequent disruption of the membrane permeability barrier may occur by a variety of mechanisms, leading ultimately to loss of cytoplasmic membrane integrity and cell death.     

Structural determinants of antimicrobial and antiplasmodial activity and selectivity in histidine-rich amphipathic cationic peptides

Designed histidine-rich amphipathic cationic peptides, such as LAH4, have enhanced membrane disruption and antibiotic properties when the peptide adopts an alignment parallel to the membrane surface. Although this was previously achieved by lowering the pH, here we have designed a new generation of histidine-rich peptides that adopt a surface alignment at neutral pH. In vitro, this new generation of peptides are powerful antibiotics in terms of the concentrations required for antibiotic activity; the spectrum of target bacteria, fungi, and parasites; and the speed with which they kill. Further modifications to the peptides, including the addition of more hydrophobic residues at the N terminus, the inclusion of a helix-breaking proline residue or using D-amino acids as building blocks, modulated the biophysical properties of the peptides and led to substantial changes in toxicity to human and parasite cells but had only a minimal effect on the antibacterial and antifungal activity. Using a range of biophysical methods, in particular solid-state NMR, we show that the peptides are highly efficient at disrupting the anionic lipid component of model membranes. However, we also show that effective pore formation in such model membranes may be related to, but is not essential for, high antimicrobial activity by cationic amphipathic helical peptides. The information in this study comprises a new layer of detail in the understanding of the action of cationic helical antimicrobial peptides and shows that rational design is capable of producing potentially therapeutic membrane active peptides with properties tailored to their function.     

Influence of tryptophan on lipid binding of linear amphipathic cationic antimicrobial peptides

We recently demonstrated that a linear 18-residue peptide, (KIGAKI)(3)-NH(2), designed to form amphipathic beta-sheet structure when bound to lipid bilayers, possessed potent antimicrobial activity and low hemolytic activity. The ability of (KIGAKI)(3)-NH(2) to induce leakage from lipid vesicles was compared to that of the amphipathic alpha-helical peptide, (KIAGKIA)(3)-NH(2), which had equivalent antimicrobial activity. Significantly, the lytic properties of (KIGAKI)(3)-NH(2) were enhanced for mixed acidic-neutral lipid vesicles containing phosphatidylethanolamine instead of phosphatidylcholine as the neutral component, while the potency of (KIAGKIA)(3)-NH(2) was significantly reduced [Blazyk, J., et al. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 27899-27906]. In this paper, we measured the lytic properties of these peptides, as well as several fluorescent analogues containing a single tryptophan residue, by monitoring permeability changes in large unilamellar vesicles with varying lipid compositions and in Escherichia coli cells. The binding of these peptides to lipid bilayers with defined compositions was compared using surface plasmon resonance, circular dichroism, and fluorescence spectroscopy. Surprisingly large differences were observed in membrane binding properties, particularly in the case of KIGAKIKWGAKIKIGAKI-NH(2). Since all of these peptides possess the same charge and very similar mean hydrophobicities, the binding data cannot be explained merely in terms of electrostatic and/or hydrophobic interactions. In light of their equivalent antimicrobial and hemolytic potencies, some of these peptides may employ mechanisms beyond simply increasing plasma membrane permeability to exert their lethal effects.     

Effect of amphipathic peptides with different alpha-helical contents on liposome-fusion.

The peptide-induced fusion of neutral and acidic liposomes was studied in relation to the amphiphilicities evaluated by alpha-helical contents of peptides by means of a carboxyfluorescein leakage assay, light scattering, a membrane intermixing assay and electron microscopy. An amphipathic mother peptide, Ac-(Leu-Ala-Arg-Leu)3-NHCH3 (4(3], and its derivatives, [Pro6]4(3) (1), [Pro2,6]4(3) (2), and [Pro2,6,10]4(3) (3), which have very similar hydrophobic moments, caused a leakage of contents from small unilamellar vesicles composed of egg yolk phosphatidylcholine and egg yolk phosphatidic acid (3:1). The abilities of the peptides to induce the fusion of the acidic liposomes increased with increasing alpha-helical content: in acidic liposomes the helical contents were in the order of 4(3) greater than 1 greater than 2 greater than 3 (Lee et al. (1989) Chem. Lett., 599-602). Electron microscopic data showed that 1 caused a transformation of the small unilamellar vesicles (20-50 nm in diameter) to large ones (100-300 nm). Based on the fact that these peptides have very similar hydrophobic moments despite of decreasing in the mean residue hydrophobicities to some extent, it was concluded that the abilities of the peptides to induce the fusion of liposomes depend on the extent of amphiphilic conformation evaluated by alpha-helical contents of the peptides in the presence of liposomes. For neutral liposomes of egg yolk phosphatidylcholine, all the proline-containing peptides showed no fusogenic ability but weak leakage abilities, suggesting that the charge interaction between the basic peptides and acidic phospholipid is an important factor to induce the perturbation and fusion of the bilayer.     

Factors determining the efficacy of alpha-helical antimicrobial peptides

A database of alpha-helical antimicrobial peptides (AMP) was established and their minimum inhibitory concentrations (MIC) were compared with their physiochemical characteristics in an attempt to establish those features that determine efficacy. There is no significant difference in AMP sensitivity between Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria but fungi did require higher concentrations to achieve the same degree of growth inhibition. For antibacterial peptides there appears to be a positive correlation between MIC and hydrophobic arc size and a negative correlation between MIC and net charge.     

Interaction with phospholipid bilayers, ion channel formation, and antimicrobial activity of basic amphipathic alpha-helical model peptides of various chain lengths.

Basic amphipathic alpha-helical peptides Ac-(Leu-Ala-Arg-Leu)3 or 4-NHCH3 (4(3) or 4(4)) and H-(Leu-Ala-Arg-Leu)3-(Leu-Arg-Ala-Leu)2 or 3-OH (4(5) or 4(6)) were synthesized and studied in terms of their interactions with phospholipid membranes, biological activity, and ion channel-forming ability. CD study of the peptides showed that they form alpha-helical structures in the presence of phospholipid liposomes and thus they have amphipathic distribution of the side chains along the axis of the helix. A leakage study of carboxyfluorescein encapsulated in phospholipid vesicles indicated that the peptides possess a highly potent ability to perturb the membrane structure. Membrane current measurements using the planar lipid bilayer technique revealed that the peptide 4(6), which was long enough to span the lipid bilayer in the alpha-helical structure, formed cation-selective ion channels at a concentration of 0.5 microM in a planar diphytanoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer. In contrast, other shorter peptides failed to form discrete and stable channels though they occasionally induced an increase in the membrane current with erratic conductance levels. The probability of detecting a conductance increase was in the order of 4(6) greater than 4(5) greater than 4(4) greater than 4(3), which corresponds to the order of the peptide chain lengths. Furthermore, 4(6) but not 4(5) showed an antimicrobial activity against both Gram-positive and -negative bacteria. The structure of ion channels formed by 4(6) and the relationship between the peptide chain length and biological activity of the synthetic peptides are discussed.     

Analyses of dose-response curves to compare the antimicrobial activity of model cationic alpha-helical peptides highlights the necessity for a minimum of two activity parameters

To assess and compare different model Leu-Lys-containing cationic alpha-helical peptides, their antimicrobial activities were tested against Escherichia coli as target organism over a broad peptide concentration range. The natural cationic alpha-helical peptides magainin 2 and PGLa and the cyclic cationic peptide gramicidin S were also tested between comparison. The dose-response curves differed widely for these peptides, making it difficult to rank them into an activity order over the whole concentration range. We therefore compared five different inhibition parameters from dose-response curves: IC(min) (lowest concentration leading to growth inhibition), IC(50) (concentration that gives 50% growth inhibition), IC(max) (related to minimum inhibition concentration and minimum bactericidal concentration), inhibition concentration factor (IC(F); describing the increase in concentration of the peptide between minimum and maximum inhibition), and activity slope (A(S); related to the Hill coefficient). We found that these parameters were covariant: two of them sufficed to characterize the dose dependence and hence the activity of the peptides. This was corroborated by showing that the dose dependences followed the Hill equation, with a small, constant aberration. We propose that the activity of antimicrobial peptides can readily be characterized by both IC(50) and IC(F) (or A(S)) rather than by a single parameter and discuss how this may relate to investigations into their mechanisms of action.     

Roles of hydrophobicity and charge distribution of cationic antimicrobial peptides in peptide-membrane interactions

Cationic antimicrobial peptides (CAPs) occur as important innate immunity agents in many organisms, including humans, and offer a viable alternative to conventional antibiotics, as they physically disrupt the bacterial membranes, leading to membrane lysis and eventually cell death. In this work, we studied the biophysical and microbiological characteristics of designed CAPs varying in hydrophobicity levels and charge distributions by a variety of biophysical and biochemical approaches, including in-tandem atomic force microscopy, attenuated total reflection-FTIR, CD spectroscopy, and SDS-PAGE. Peptide structural properties were correlated with their membrane-disruptive abilities and antimicrobial activities. In bacterial lipid model membranes, a time-dependent increase in aggregated β-strand-type structure in CAPs with relatively high hydrophobicity (such as KKKKKKALFALWLAFLA-NH(2)) was essentially absent in CAPs with lower hydrophobicity (such as KKKKKKAAFAAWAAFAA-NH(2)). Redistribution of positive charges by placing three Lys residues at both termini while maintaining identical sequences minimized self-aggregation above the dimer level. Peptides containing four Leu residues were destructive to mammalian model membranes, whereas those with corresponding Ala residues were not. This finding was mirrored in hemolysis studies in human erythrocytes, where Ala-only peptides displayed virtually no hemolysis up to 320 μM, but the four-Leu peptides induced 40-80% hemolysis at the same concentration range. All peptides studied displayed strong antimicrobial activity against Pseudomonas aeruginosa (minimum inhibitory concentrations of 4-32 μM). The overall findings suggest optimum routes to balancing peptide hydrophobicity and charge distribution that allow efficient penetration and disruption of the bacterial membranes without damage to mammalian (host) membranes.     

Antibiotic activity of reversed peptides of alpha-helical antimicrobial peptide,P18

P18 (KWKLFKKIPKFLHLAKKF-NH(2)), an a-helical antimicrobial peptide designed from cecropin Amagainin 2 hybrid, was known to have potent antimicrobial activity against bacteria as well as fungi without hemolytic activity. To find the peptides comparable or superior to the antimicrobial activity of P18, the two reversed peptides (Rev-1 and Rev-2) of P18 were designed and synthesized. These peptides were found to have similar antimicrobial activity against bacterial and fungal cells without hemolytic activity as compared with P18. Furthermore, a reversed peptide, Rev-2 was shown to have a two-fold higher activity in killing some bacterial cells than P18. Therefore, these results suggested that Rev-2 peptide seems to be an excellent candidate for developing novel peptide antibiotics.     

Interaction of antimicrobial peptides with biological and model membranes: structural and charge requirements for activity

Species right across the evolutionary scale from insects to mammals use peptides as part of their host-defense system to counter microbial infection. The primary structures of a large number of these host-defense peptides have been determined. While there is no primary structure homology, the peptides are characterized by a preponderance of cationic and hydrophobic amino acids. The secondary structures of many of the host-defense peptides have been determined by a variety of techniques. The acyclic peptides tend to adopt helical conformation, especially in media of low dielectric constant, whereas peptides with more than one disulfide bridge adopt beta-structures. Detailed investigations have indicated that a majority of these host-defense peptides exert their action by permeabilizing microbial membranes. In this review, we discuss structural and charge requirements for the interaction of endogenous antimicrobial peptides and short peptides that have been derived from them, with membranes.     

The role of positively charged residues in CXCR4 recognition probed with synthetic peptides.

A high positive charge is the common characteristic shared by the beta-sheet region of stromal cell-derived factor-1 (SDF-1) and CXCR4 antagonists such as ALX40-4C consisting of nine D-arginines. This raises the question that the positively charged residues may play a role in recognition of CXCR4. To test this hypothesis, two studies were carried out using synthetic peptides. In the first study, peptide analogs possessing amino acid sequences from both the N-terminus and the beta-sheet region of SDF-1 were used as models to study the functional role of the beta-sheet region of SDF-1. The attachment of positively charged residues to the N-terminal peptide sequence of SDF-1 was found to enhance the ability of the peptides in CXCR4 binding and inhibiting CXCR4-mediated T-tropic HIV-1 entry. In the second study, two peptides containing nine arginines and the N-terminal signal sequence of SDF-1 were used as models to study the receptor binding mechanism of CXCR4 antagonists of high positive charges such as ALX40-4C. One peptide did not show signaling activity as indicated by the lack of calcium influx while another peptide induced unusual calcium influx distinct from that induced by the SDF-1 N-terminal peptide. In addition, the signal induced by the SDF-1 N-terminal peptide was inhibited by ALX40-4C. Therefore, the first study provides experimental support for the role of the highly positive beta-sheet region of SDF-1 in CXCR4 binding. The second study suggests that the binding site of ALX40-4C in CXCR4 may partially overlap with that of the SDF-1 N-terminal peptide. Both findings should be valuable for the design of SDF-1 agonists and antagonists.     

Sequence analysis and membrane partitioning energies of alpha-helical antimicrobial peptides

Sequences of 221 alpha-helical antimicrobial peptides (alphaAMPs) were compared and 63-166 of them were selected and analyzed using Perl programs. The results showed that aliphatic amino acids Gly, Leu, Ala, Ile and two positively charged amino acids Lys and Arg were composed of more than 63% of the first 20 residues of alphaAMPs. The weighed mean membrane partitioning energies at positions from 1 to 25 of alphaAMPs were calculated. Profile of the partitioning energies suggests oblique membrane insertion and an amphipathic alpha-helical structure of the N-terminus of alphaAMP (residues from 1 to 13), a bend structure at positions 13 and 14, and a less structured C-terminus that parallels the surface of the membrane. These structural features are in good agreement with the experimentally determined membrane structure of hemagglutinin fusion peptide from influenza virus. We hypothesize that this (N-terminal oblique alpha-helix)-central bend-(C-terminus) could be a common structural motif of membrane-disruptive peptides.     

The consequence of sequence alteration of an amphipathic alpha-helical antimicrobial peptide and its diastereomers

The search for antibiotics with a new mode of action led to numerous studies on antibacterial peptides. Most of the studies were carried out with l-amino acid peptides possessing amphipathic alpha-helix or beta-sheet structures, which are known to be important for biological activities. Here we compared the effect of significantly altering the sequence of an amphipathic alpha-helical peptide (15 amino acids long) and its diastereomer (composed of both l- and d-amino acids) regarding their structure, function, and interaction with model membranes and intact bacteria. Interestingly, the effect of sequence alteration on biological function was similar for the l-amino acid peptides and the diastereomers, despite some differences in their structure in the membrane as revealed by attenuated total reflectance Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy. However, whereas the all l-amino acid peptides were highly hemolytic, had low solubility, lost their activity in serum, and were fully cleaved by trypsin and proteinase K, the diastereomers were nonhemolytic and maintained full activity in serum. Furthermore, sequence alteration allowed making the diastereomers either fully, partially, or totally protected from degradation by the enzymes. Transmembrane potential depolarization experiments in model membranes and intact bacteria indicate that although the killing mechanism of the diastereomers is via membrane perturbation, it is also dependent on their ability to diffuse into the inner bacterial membrane. These data demonstrate the advantage of the diastereomers over their all l-amino acid counterparts as candidates for developing a repertoire of new target antibiotics with a potential for systemic use.     

Optimization of the antimicrobial activity of magainin peptides by modification of charge

Investigation of magainin II amide analogs with cationic charges ranging between +3 and +7 showed that enhancement of the peptide charge up to a threshold value of +5 and conservation of appropriate hydrophobic properties optimized the antimicrobial activity and selectivity. High selectivity was the result of both enhanced antimicrobial and reduced hemolytic activity. Charge increase beyond +5 with retention of other structural motifs led to a dramatic increase of hemolytic activity and loss of antimicrobial selectivity. Selectivity could be restored by reduction of the hydrophobicity of the hydrophobic helix surface (H(hd)), a structural parameter not previously considered to modulate activity. Dye release experiments with lipid vesicles revealed that the potential of peptide charge to modulate membrane activity is limited: on highly negatively charged 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidyl-DL-glycerol bilayers, reinforcement of electrostatic interactions had an activity-reducing effect. On neutral 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers, the high activity was determined by H(hd). H(hd) values above a certain threshold led to effective permeabilization of all lipid systems and even compensated for the activity-reducing effect of charge increase on highly negatively charged membranes.     

Aromatic residue position on the nonpolar face of class a amphipathic helical peptides determines biological activity

The apolipoprotein A-I mimetic peptide 4F (Ac-DWFKAFYDKVAEKFKEAF-NH(2)), with four Phe residues on the nonpolar face of the amphipathic alpha-helix, is strongly anti-inflammatory, whereas two 3F analogs (3F(3) and 3F(14)) are not. To understand how changes in helix nonpolar face structure affect function, two additional 3F analogs, Ac-DKLKAFYDKVFEWAKEAF-NH(2) (3F-1) and Ac-DKWKAVYDKFAEAFKEFL-NH(2) (3F-2), were designed using the same amino acid composition as 3F(3) and 3F(14). The aromatic residues in 3F-1 and 3F-2 are near the polar-nonpolar interface and at the center of the nonpolar face of the helix, respectively. Like 4F, but in contrast to 3F(3) and 3F(14), these peptides effectively inhibited lytic peptide-induced hemolysis, oxidized phospholipid-induced monocyte chemotaxis, and scavenged lipid hydroperoxides from low density lipoprotein. High pressure liquid chromatography retention times and monolayer exclusion pressures indicated that there is no direct correlation of peptide function with lipid affinity. Fluorescence studies suggested that, although the peptides bind phospholipids similarly, the Trp residue in 4F, 3F-1, and 3F-2 is less motionally restricted than in 3F(3) and 3F(14). Based on these results and molecular modeling studies, we propose that the arrangement of aromatic residues in class A amphipathic helical molecules regulates entry of reactive oxygen species into peptide-phospholipid complexes, thereby reducing the extent of monocyte chemotaxis, an important step in atherosclerosis.     

The effects of hydrophobic mismatch between phosphatidylcholine bilayers and transmembrane alpha-helical peptides depend on the nature of interfacially exposed aromatic and charged residues

In this study, we investigated the extent to which different aromatic and positively charged side chains, which often flank transmembrane segments of proteins, can influence lipid-peptide interactions. Model systems consisting of phosphatidylcholine and hydrophobic alpha-helical peptides with different flanking residues were investigated. The peptides were incorporated in relatively thick and in relatively thin lipid bilayers to create a peptide-bilayer hydrophobic mismatch, and the compensating effects on lipid structure were analyzed. When relatively long with respect to the thickness of the bilayer, the peptides that are flanked by the aromatic side chains, Trp, Tyr, and Phe, all induce a significant ordering of the lipid acyl chains, while the peptides flanked by the charged residues Lys, Arg, and His do not. However, when the peptides are relatively short with respect to the thickness of the bilayer, their effect on lipid organization does not depend primarily on their aromatic or charged character. Peptides flanked by Trp, Tyr, Lys, or (at low pH) His residues are effective in inducing mismatch-relieving cubic and inverted hexagonal phases, while analogues flanked by Phe, Arg, or (at neutral pH) His residues cannot induce an inverted hexagonal phase. The different responses to mismatch might reflect the different interfacial affinities of the residues that were investigated.     

Contribution of a central proline in model amphipathic alpha-helical peptides to self-association, interaction with phospholipids, and antimicrobial mode of action

Model amphipathic peptides have been widely used as a tool to determine the structural and biological properties that control the interaction of peptides with membranes. Here, we have focused on the role of a central Pro in membrane-active peptides. To determine the role of Pro in structure, antibiotic activity, and interaction with phospholipids, we generated a series of model amphipathic alpha-helical peptides with different chain lengths and containing or lacking a single central Pro. CD studies showed that Pro-free peptides (PFPs) formed stable alpha-helical structures even in aqueous buffer through self-association, whereas Pro-containing peptides (PCPs) had random coil structures. In contrast, in trifluoroethanol or SDS micelles, both PFPs and PCPs adopted highly ordered alpha-helical structures, although relatively lower helical contents were observed for the PCPs than the PFPs. This structural consequence indicates that a central Pro residue limits the formation of highly helical aggregates in aqueous buffer and causes a partial distortion of the stable alpha-helix in membrane-mimetic environments. With regard to antibiotic activity, PCPs had a 2-8-fold higher antibacterial activity and significantly reduced hemolytic activity compared with PFPs. In membrane depolarization assays, PCPs passed rapidly across the peptidoglycan layer and immediately dissipated the membrane potential in Staphylococcus aureus, whereas PFPs had a greatly reduced ability. Fluorescence studies indicated that, although PFPs had strong binding affinity for both zwitterionic and anionic liposomes, PCPs interacted weakly with zwitterionic liposomes and strongly with anionic liposomes. The selective membrane interaction of PCPs with negatively charged phospholipids may explain their antibacterial selectivity. The difference in mode of action between PCPs and PFPs was further supported by kinetic analysis of surface plasmon resonance data. The possible role of the increased local backbone distortion or flexibility introduced by the proline residue in the antimicrobial mode of action is discussed.