A model for the dynamics of human lymphatic filariasis

In this paper, Bryan Gren fell, Edwin Michael and David Denham review the appropriateness of feline filariasis as a model of the population dynamics of human lymphatic filarial infection and disease. Because of the longevity of infection and our inability to measure the adult parasite population in humans, research in filariasis is particularly dependent on the use of laboratory animal models. We demonstrate that Brugia pahangi infection patterns in the cat closely parallel those of Brugia and Wuchereria in humans. Although primary infections in 'susceptible' cats are long-lived, repeatedly infected animals show evidence of concomitant immunity which prevents the establishment of later cohorts of infective larvae. Furthermore, there is some evidence from macro filarial length distributions of 'stunting' of adult worms during long-term repeat infections. Cats can also show an 'acute' response that spontaneously eliminates infections, and this appears to be due to a combination of intrinsic and dynamic mechanisms. As in humans, pathology in cat filariasis develops as a sequel to the asymptomatic microfilaremic state, largely as a result of re-expression of immunity. The relationship between macro filarial burdens and microfilariae in blood is positive but portrays a high degree of variability. The cat model provides an important tool for elucidating the relationships between infection, immunity and disease dynamics in lymphatic filariasis, and we conclude by suggesting directions for further work in this area.     

The endemic normal in lymphatic filariasis: A static concept

Residents of areas endemic for lymphatic filariasis are continually exposed to infection with mosquito-transmitted infective larvae (L3), some of which survive to become adult worms and subsequently produce micro filarial (mf) transmission stages. The question of whether naturally acquired resistance occurs in adult residents of endemic areas has recently become of interest as the development of molecular vaccines against filarial parasites is being considered(1,2). There have been two epidemiological approaches to demonstrate acquired resistance to Filariasis in human populations. In this review Karen Day examines both approaches in the context of an immunoepidemiological study of bancroftian filariasis in Papua New Guinea (PNG). The merits of each as a conceptual framework for studies of protective immunity in lymphatic filariasis will be discussed.     

Isolation, purification and characterization of surface antigens of the bovine filarial parasite Setaria digitata for the immunodiagnosis of bancroftian filariasis

The surface antigens of the bovine filarial parasite Setaria digitata were isolated by EDTA extraction and purified by affinity chromatography using sepharose bound human filarial (Wuchereria bancrofti) antibodies obtained from chronic human filarial sera. The purified and crude antigens were used in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the detection of serum antibodies in bancroftian filariasis. The purified antigen showed sensitive and specific reactions in ELISA for the detection of antibodies in filarial sera and showed least cross reactivity with other parasitic infections. The crude and purified antigens showed about 18 and 6 peptide bands respectively in SDS-PAGE and about 11 and 6 antigenic bands respectively in enzyme-linked immunoelectrotransfer blot (EITB). The purified antigen was observed to be glycoprotein in nature. It was possible to identify the stage-specific infection in human filariasis by using the crude and purified antigens in EITB.     

Stage-specific and common antigens of Brugia malayi identified with monoclonal antibodies

To identify parasite antigens that trigger protective, pathogenic, and allergic immune responses during filarial infections, we generated a series of monoclonal antibodies to infective larvae, adult worms, and microfilariae of Brugia malayi, a human pathogen. Quantitative and qualitative analysis of the reaction patterns of these monoclonal antibodies indicates the existence of stage-specific antigens of B. malayi, as well as of antigens shared by different stages of this parasite and by other related and unrelated helminths. These antibodies should provide invaluable tools for the analysis of host-parasite interactions in filariasis at the molecular level.     

Does resistance to filarial reinfections become leaky over time?

Strategies for the control of human parasitic diseases such as onchocerciasis and lymphatic filariasis require an understanding of how the parasite successfully infects and persists in humans. Despite the fact that the vast majority of infective larvae are eliminated after infection, this 'protection' is far from being an all-or-nothing response. The hypothesis presented here, which is based on epidemiological observations, suggests that the resistance against filarial parasites includes a time-dependent component, probably caused by an early immune response with short-term memory. Validating this hypothesis requires experimental studies with a longitudinal component. Such experiments would help to clarify whether the infection can be controlled by vaccination strategies at all.     

Filarial infection induces protection against P. berghei liver stages in mice

Chronic helminth infections such as filariasis in human hosts can be life long, since parasites are equipped with a repertoire of immune evasion strategies. In many areas where helminths are prevalent, other infections such as malaria are co-endemic. It is still an ongoing debate, how one parasite alters immune responses against another. To dissect the relationships between two different parasites residing in the same host, we established a murine model of co-infection with the filarial nematode Litomosoides sigmodontis and the malaria parasite Plasmodium berghei (ANKA strain). We found that filarial infection of BALB/c mice leads to protection against a subsequent P. berghei sporozoite infection in one-third of co-infected mice, which did not develop blood-stage malaria. This finding did not correlate with adult worm loads, however it did correlate with the presence of microfilariae in blood. Interestingly, protection was abrogated in IL-10-deficient mice. Thus, murine filariasis, in particular when it is a patent infection, is able to modify the immunological balance to induce protection against an otherwise deadly Plasmodium infection and is therefore able to influence the course of malaria in favour of the host.     

Recombinant antigen-based antibody assays for the diagnosis and surveillance of lymphatic filariasis - a multicenter trial

The development of antifilarial antibody responses is a characteristic feature of infection with filarial parasites. It should be possible to exploit this fact to develop tools to monitor the progress of the global program to eliminate lymphatic filariasis (LF); however, assays based on parasite extracts suffer from a number of limitations, including the paucity of parasite material, the difficulty of assay standardization and problems with assay specificity. In principle, assays based on recombinant filarial antigens should address these limitations and provide useful tools for diagnosis and surveillance of LF. The present multicenter study was designed to compare the performance of antibody assays for filariasis based on recombinant antigens Bm14, WbSXP, and BmR1. Coded serum specimens were distributed to five participating laboratories where assays for each antigen were conducted in parallel. Assays based on Bm14, WbSXP, or BmR1 demonstrated good sensitivity (>90%) for field use and none of the assays demonstrated reactivity with specimens from persons with non-filarial helminth infections. Limitations of the assays are discussed. Well-designed field studies are now needed to assess sampling methodology and the application of antibody testing to the monitoring and surveillance of LF elimination programs.     

Recombinant antigen-based antibody assays for the diagnosis and surveillance of lymphatic filariasis – a multicenter trial

The development of antifilarial antibody responses is a characteristic feature of infection with filarial parasites. It should be possible to exploit this fact to develop tools to monitor the progress of the global program to eliminate lymphatic filariasis (LF); however, assays based on parasite extracts suffer from a number of limitations, including the paucity of parasite material, the difficulty of assay standardization and problems with assay specificity. In principle, assays based on recombinant filarial antigens should address these limitations and provide useful tools for diagnosis and surveillance of LF. The present multicenter study was designed to compare the performance of antibody assays for filariasis based on recombinant antigens Bm14, WbSXP, and BmR1. Coded serum specimens were distributed to five participating laboratories where assays for each antigen were conducted in parallel. Assays based on Bm14, WbSXP, or BmR1 demonstrated good sensitivity (>90%) for field use and none of the assays demonstrated reactivity with specimens from persons with non-filarial helminth infections. Limitations of the assays are discussed. Well-designed field studies are now needed to assess sampling methodology and the application of antibody testing to the monitoring and surveillance of LF elimination programs.     

Modelling variability in lymphatic filariasis: macrofilarial dynamics in the Brugia pahangi--cat model.

A striking feature of lymphatic filariasis is the considerable heterogeneity in infection burden observed between hosts, which greatly complicates the analysis of the population dynamics of the disease. Here, we describe the first application of the moment closure equation approach to model the sources and the impact of this heterogeneity for macrofilarial population dynamics. The analysis is based on the closest laboratory equivalent of the life cycle and immunology of infection in humans--cats chronically infected with the filarial nematode Brugia pahangi. Two sets of long-term experiments are analysed: hosts given either single primary infections or given repeat infections. We begin by quantifying changes in the mean and aggregation of adult parasites (inversely measured by the negative binomial parameter, kappa in cohorts of hosts using generalized linear models. We then apply simple stochastic models to interpret observed patterns. The models and empirical data indicate that parasite aggregation tracks the decline in the mean burden with host age in primary infections. Conversely, in repeat infections, aggregation increases as the worm burden declines with experience of infection. The results show that the primary infection variability is consistent with heterogeneities in parasite survival between hosts. By contrast, the models indicate that the reduction in parasite variability with time in repeat infections is most likely due to the ''filtering'' effect of a strong, acquired immune response, which gradually acts to remove the initial variability generated by heterogeneities in larval mortality. We discuss this result in terms of the homogenizing effect of host immunity-driven density-dependence on macrofilarial burden in older hosts.     

Failure of highly immunogenic filarial proteins to provide host-protective immunity

In areas that are endemic for lymphatic filariasis, there are individuals who are parasite free and who appear not to have experienced symptoms attributable to filarial infection. These "putatively immune" individuals may recognize immunogens that could be important in host protection. We have immunoscreened expression libraries expressing epitopes encoded by filarial open reading frames and have identified three antigens that are differentially recognized by the two polar clinical groups-endemic normals and asymptomatic microfilaremics. Pre-immunization of susceptible hosts (Meriones unguiculatus) with these antigens revealed that none was able to elicit consistent host protective immunity. Our data are consistent with Waksman's conjecture that highly immunogenic antigens of parasite origin may be inappropriate candidates for prophylactic immunization.     

Mathematical modelling of immunity to malaria

A comparison of two epidemiological models of immunity to malaria shows that different characterizations of immunity boosted by exposure to infection generate qualitatively different results. Attempts to control disease by reducing transmission or increasing the recovery rate can produce an increase in prevalence in the compartmental model with discrete epidemiological states. However, the parasite density always decreases in response to disease control in the model with continuous epidemiological variables. Each model accounts for some epidemiological patterns. The increase in prevalence seen in the compartmental model is in accord with observed effects of variation in transmission. Parasite suppression in areas of antimalarial drug use is consistent with the effect of an increased recovery rate in the density model. Future work should combine the two approaches, perhaps by using the compartmental model over the low to moderate range of infection rates and switching to the density model at high infection rates. In any case, the validation of models needs to take account of the usage of antimalarial drugs as well as the intensity of transmission.     

A contribution to the interpretation of immunological survey records

In certain infection types the use of official immunological survey figures expressed mathematically by means of exponential distribution or its distributional function may help assess the epidemiological trends in herd immunity levels. This approach to the evaluation of immunological survey records is primarily well applicable to infections that are uniform in exposure pattern, affect the entire population, and result in life-long immunity. The parameters characterizing the rise in the level of herd immunity can be determined by means of negative exponential regression. Applied to selected immunological survey data this essentially simple catalytic model of investigation may provide reliable information on the actual state of immunity in the general population, and may also help estimate its dynamics in the retrospect.     

Immunological tolerance: The key feature in human filariasis?

Filariasis is a widespread tropical disease caused by a group of nematode parasites that can survive for many years in immunocompetent hosts. The paradox of filariasis has always been the inverse association between parasite density, in terms of circulating microfilariae in the blood, and severe pathology. In this review, Rick Maizels and Rachel Lawrence argue that microfilariae and adult parasites induce a form of immunological tolerance which prevents both parasite elimination and progression to disease. The breakdown of this unresponsiveness is seen as the critical step towards pathogenesis. However, not every exposed individual progresses through infection to disease. The authors discuss evidence for protective immunity acting on antigens from the mosquito-borne infective larva, and propose that this stage represents a vulnerable target outside the scope of tolerance and pathogenesis. Stage-specific larval antigens, to which asymptomatic hosts are known to respond, may therefore represent the most effective and safe choice for an anti filarial vaccine.     

Neonatal tolerance and patent filarial infection

Lymphatic filariasis occurs in endemic pockets. Patent infections with long-term, high-grade microfilaremia do not develop in nonendemic individuals. It is tempting to speculate that individuals with intact immune responses to filarial antigens are capable of dealing with filarial exposure without developing persistent infection. There are published data that support the idea that only those individuals who are impaired in their immune defense against these parasites owing to neonatal tolerization become productively infected with the filarial parasites. If the model is correct, there are profound implications for global eradication.     

Detection of filarial antigen by inhibition enzyme linked immunosorbent assay using fractionatedBrugia malayi microfilarial excretory secretory antigen

Detection of filarial antigen in blood or urine samples would provide an accurate indication of active infection. The absence of a simple, well established animal model and limitations in getting the required amount of parasite material from human sources have been the main obstacles for the diagnosis ofWuchereria bancrofti infection. An inhibition ELISA has been developed for detection of filarial antigen using a partially purifiedBrugia malayi mf ES antigen (BmE DE1) and its affinity purified antibodies. Filarial antigen was detected in the sera of 88% of microfilaraemic, 60% of chronic filarial, 17% of endemic normal and none of the non- endemic normal subjects. The sensitivity and specificity of the assay were 88% and 89% respectively. Moreover, undiluted urine samples from 82% of microfilaraemic and 17% of endemic normal, but none of the non- endemic normal samples showed the presence of filarial antigen. With the limitations on the availability of sufficient homologous parasite materials, the inhibition ELISA using BmE DE1 and anti BmE DE1 antibodies shows promise for the detection of active infection in bancroftian filariasis in man. Moreover, its detection in urine makes it more possible to test patients in field areas.     

Mass Spectrometric and Glycan Microarray–Based Characterization of the Filarial Nematode Brugia malayi Glycome Reveals Anionic and Zwitterionic Glycan Antigens

Millions of people worldwide are infected with filarial nematodes, responsible for lymphatic filariasis (LF) and other diseases causing chronic disablement. Elimination programs have resulted in a substantial reduction of the rate of infection in certain areas creating a need for improved diagnostic tools to establish robust population surveillance and avoid LF resurgence. Glycans from parasitic helminths are emerging as potential antigens for use in diagnostic assays. However, despite its crucial role in host–parasite interactions, filarial glycosylation is still largely, structurally, and functionally uncharacterized. Therefore, we investigated the glycan repertoire of the filarial nematode Brugia malayi. Glycosphingolipid and N-linked glycans were extracted from several life-stages using enzymatic release and characterized using a combination of MALDI-TOF-MS and glycan sequencing techniques. Next, glycans were purified by HPLC and printed onto microarrays to assess the host anti-glycan antibody response. Comprehensive glycomic analysis of B. malayi revealed the presence of several putative antigenic motifs such as phosphorylcholine and terminal glucuronic acid. Glycan microarray screening showed a recognition of most B. malayi glycans by immunoglobulins from rhesus macaques at different time points after infection, which permitted the characterization of the dynamics of anti-glycan immunoglobulin G and M during the establishment of brugian filariasis. A significant level of IgG binding to the parasite glycans was also detected in infected human plasma, while IgG binding to glycans decreased after anthelmintic treatment. Altogether, our work identifies B. malayi glycan antigens and reveals antibody responses from the host that could be exploited as potential markers for LF.     

Geographic and ecologic heterogeneity in elimination thresholds for the major vector-borne helminthic disease,lymphatic filariasis

Background

Large-scale intervention programmes to control or eliminate several infectious diseases are currently underway worldwide. However, a major unresolved question remains: what are reasonable stopping points for these programmes? Recent theoretical work has highlighted how the ecological complexity and heterogeneity inherent in the transmission dynamics of macroparasites can result in elimination thresholds that vary between local communities. Here, we examine the empirical evidence for this hypothesis and its implications for the global elimination of the major macroparasitic disease, lymphatic filariasis, by applying a novel Bayesian computer simulation procedure to fit a dynamic model of the transmission of this parasitic disease to field data from nine villages with different ecological and geographical characteristics. Baseline lymphatic filariasis microfilarial age-prevalence data from three geographically distinct endemic regions, across which the major vector populations implicated in parasite transmission also differed, were used to fit and calibrate the relevant vector-specific filariasis transmission models. Ensembles of parasite elimination thresholds, generated using the Bayesian fitting procedure, were then examined in order to evaluate site-specific heterogeneity in the values of these thresholds and investigate the ecological factors that may underlie such variability

Results

We show that parameters of density-dependent functions relating to immunity, parasite establishment, as well as parasite aggregation, varied significantly between the nine different settings, contributing to locally varying filarial elimination thresholds. Parasite elimination thresholds predicted for the settings in which the mosquito vector is anopheline were, however, found to be higher than those in which the mosquito is culicine, substantiating our previous theoretical findings. The results also indicate that the probability that the parasite will be eliminated following six rounds of Mass Drug Administration with diethylcarbamazine and albendazole decreases markedly but non-linearly as the annual biting rate and parasite reproduction number increases.

Conclusions

This paper shows that specific ecological conditions in a community can lead to significant local differences in population dynamics and, consequently, elimination threshold estimates for lymphatic filariasis. These findings, and the difficulty of measuring the key local parameters (infection aggregation and acquired immunity) governing differences in transmission thresholds between communities, mean that it is necessary for us to rethink the utility of the current anticipatory approaches for achieving the elimination of filariasis both locally and globally.

     

Quinone analogue irrecoverably paralyses the filarial parasites in vitro

2,3-Dimethoxy-5-methyl-1,4-benzoquinone (Q0), an analogue of ubiquinone, irreversibly paralyses the adult and microfilariae of the cattle filarial parasite Setaria digitata. The same concentration of Q0 that paralyses the microfilariae of S. digitata also paralyses the microfilariae of the human filarial parasite Wuchereria bancrofti within the same duration. Thus the experiments done in the model S. digitata system can well be extended to the human filarial system. A drug at the level of the quinone-centered energy generating system, perhaps an analogue of quinone like Q0, can inactivate the filarial parasites and may prove to be an effective drug to control filariasis.     

Acquired immune heterogeneity and its sources in human helminth infection

Similarities in the immunobiology of different parasitic worm infections indicate that co-evolution of humans and helminths has shaped a common anti-helminth immune response. However, recent in vitro and immuno-epidemiological studies highlight fundamental differences and plasticity within host-helminth interactions. The 'trade-off' between immunity and immunopathology inherent in host immune responses occurs on a background of genetic polymorphism, variable exposure patterns and infection history. For the parasite, variation in life-cycle and antigen expression can influence the effector responses directed against them. This is particularly apparent when comparing gastrointestinal and tissue-dwelling helminths. Furthermore, insights into the impact of anti-helminthic treatment and co-infection on acquired immunity suggest that immune heterogeneity arises not from hosts and parasites in isolation, but also from the environment in which immune responses develop. Large-scale differences observed in the epidemiology of human helminthiases are a product of complex host-parasite-environment interactions which, given potential for exposure to parasite antigens in utero, can arise even before a parasite interacts with its human host. This review summarizes key differences identified in human acquired immune responses to nematode and trematode infections of public health importance and explores the factors contributing to these variations.