Programmed translational -1 frameshifting on hexanucleotide motifs and the wobble properties of tRNAs

Programmed -1 ribosomal frameshifting, involving tRNA re-pairing from an AAG codon to an AAA codon, has been reported to occur at the sequences CGA AAG and CAA AAG. In this study, using the recoding region of insertion sequence IS3, we have investigated the influence on frameshifting in Escherichia coli of the first codon of this type of motif by changing it to all other NNA codons. Two classes of NNA codons were distinguished, depending on whether they favor or limit frameshifting. Their degree of shiftiness is correlated with wobble propensity, and base 34 modification, of their decoding tRNAs. A more flexible anticodon loop very likely makes the tRNAs with extended wobble more prone to liberate the third codon base, A, for re-pairing of tRNALys in the -1 frame.     

Missense and nonsense suppressors can correct frameshift mutations

Missense and nonsense suppressor tRNAs, selected for their ability to read a new triplet codon, were observed to suppress one or more frameshift mutations in trpA of Escherichia coli. Two of the suppressible frameshift mutants, trpA8 and trpA46AspPR3, were cloned, sequenced, and found to be of the +1 type, resulting from the insertion of four nucleotides and one nucleotide, respectively. Twenty-two suppressor tRNAs were examined, 20 derived from one of the 3 glycine isoacceptor species, one from lysT, and one from trpT. The sequences of all but four of the mutant tRNAs are known, and two of those four were converted to suppressor tRNAs that were subsequently sequenced. Consideration of the coding specificities and anticodon sequences of the suppressor tRNAs does not suggest a unitary mechanism of frameshift suppression. Rather, the results indicate that different suppressors may shift frame according to different mechanisms. Examination of the suppression windows of the suppressible frameshift mutations indicates that some of the suppressors may work at cognate codons, either in the 0 frame or in the +1 frame, and others may act at noncognate codons (in either frame) by some as-yet-unspecified mechanism. Whatever the mechanisms, it is clear that some +1 frameshifting can occur at non-monotonous sequences. A striking example of a frameshifting missense suppressor is a mutant lysine tRNA that differs from wild-type lysine tRNA by only a single base in the amino acid acceptor stem, a C to U70 transition that results in a G.U base pair. It is suggested that when this mutant lysine tRNA reads its cognate codon, AAA, the presence of the G.U base pair sometimes leads either to a conformational change in the tRNA or to an altered interaction with some component of the translation machinery involved in translocation, resulting in a shift of reading frame. In general, the results indicate that translocation is not simply a function of anticodon loop size, that different frameshifting mechanisms may operate with different tRNAs, and that conformational features, some far removed from the anticodon region, are involved in maintaining fidelity in translocation.     

Special peptidyl-tRNA molecules can promote translational frameshifting without slippage.

Recently we described an unusual programmed +1 frameshift event in yeast retrotransposon Ty3. Frameshifting depends on the presence of peptidyl-tRNA(AlaCGC) on the GCG codon in the ribosomal P site and on a translational pause stimulated by the slowly decoded AGU codon. Frameshifting occurs on the sequence GCG-AGU-U by out-of-frame binding of a valyl-tRNA to GUU without slippage of peptidyl-tRNA(AlaCGC). This mechanism challenges the conventional understanding that frameshift efficiency must correlate with the ability of mRNA-bound tRNA to slip between cognate or near-cognate codons. Though frameshifting does not require slippery tRNAs, it does require special peptidyl-tRNAs. We show that overproducing a second isoacceptor whose anticodon had been changed to CGC eliminated frameshifting; peptidyl-tRNA(AlaCGC) must have a special capacity to induce +1 frameshifting in the adjacent ribosomal A site. In order to identify other special peptidyl-tRNAs, we tested the ability of each of the other 63 codons to replace GCG in the P site. We found no correlation between the ability to stimulate +1 frameshifting and the ability of the cognate tRNA to slip on the mRNA--several codons predicted to slip efficiently do not stimulate frameshifting, while several predicted not to slip do stimulate frameshifting. By inducing a severe translational pause, we identified eight tRNAs capable of inducing measurable +1 frameshifting, only four of which are predicted to slip on the mRNA. We conclude that in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, special peptidyl-tRNAs can induce frameshifting dependent on some characteristic(s) other than the ability to slip on the mRNA.     

Effects of a minor isoleucyl tRNA on heterologous protein translation in Escherichia coli.

In Escherichia coli, the isoleucine codon AUA occurs at a frequency of about 0.4% and is the fifth rarest codon in E. coli mRNA. Since there is a correlation between the frequency of codon usage and the level of its cognate tRNA, translational problems might be expected when the mRNA contains high levels of AUA codons. When a hemagglutinin from the influenza virus, a 304-amino-acid protein with 12 (3.9%) AUA codons and 1 tandem codon, and a mupirocin-resistant isoleucyl tRNA synthetase, a 1,024-amino-acid protein, with 33 (3.2%) AUA codons and 2 tandem codons, were expressed in E. coli, product accumulation was highly variable and dependent to some degree on the growth medium. In rich medium, the flu antigen represented about 16% of total cell protein, whereas in minimal medium, it was only 2 to 3% of total cell protein. In the presence of the cloned ileX, which encodes the cognate tRNA for AUA, however, the antigen was 25 to 30% of total cell protein in cells grown in minimal medium. Alternatively, the isoleucyl tRNA synthetase did not accumulate to detectable levels in cells grown in Luria broth unless the ileX tRNA was coexpressed when it accounted for 7 to 9% of total cell protein. These results indicate that the rare isoleucine AUA codon, like the rare arginine codons AGG and AGA, can interfere with the efficient expression of cloned proteins.     

Near-cognate peptidyl-tRNAs promote +1 programmed translational frameshifting in yeast

Translational frameshifting is a ubiquitous, if rare, form of alternative decoding in which ribosomes spontaneously shift reading frames during translation elongation. In studying +1 frameshifting in Ty retrotransposons of the yeast S. cerevisiae, we previously showed that unusual P site tRNAs induce frameshifting. The frameshift-inducing tRNAs we show here are near-cognates for the P site codon. Their abnormal decoding induces frameshifting in either of two ways: weak codon-anticodon pairing allows the tRNA to disengage from the mRNA and slip +1, or an unusual codon-anticodon structure interferes with cognate in-frame decoding allowing out-of-frame decoding in the A site. We draw parallels between this mechanism and a proposed mechanism of frameshift suppression by mutant tRNAs.     

Expanding the genetic code: selection of efficient suppressors of four-base codons and identification of "shifty" four-base codons with a library approach in Escherichia coli

Naturally occurring tRNA mutants are known that suppress +1 frameshift mutations by means of an extended anticodon loop, and a few have been used in protein mutagenesis. In an effort to expand the number of possible ways to uniquely and efficiently encode unnatural amino acids, we have devised a general strategy to select tRNAs with the ability to suppress four-base codons from a library of tRNAs with randomized 8 or 9 nt anticodon loops. Our selectants included both known and novel suppressible four-base codons and resulted in a set of very efficient, non-cross-reactive tRNA/four-base codon pairs for AGGA, UAGA, CCCU and CUAG. The most efficient four-base codon suppressors had Watson-Crick complementary anticodons, and the sequences of the anticodon loops outside of the anticodons varied with the anticodon. Additionally, four-base codon reporter libraries were used to identify "shifty" sites at which +1 frameshifting is most favorable in the absence of suppressor tRNAs in Escherichia coli. We intend to use these tRNAs to explore the limits of unnatural polypeptide biosynthesis, both in vitro and eventually in vivo. In addition, this selection strategy is being extended to identify novel five- and six-base codon suppressors.     

Codon pairs in the genome of Escherichia coli

MOTIVATION: The effect of two neighboring codons (codon pairs) on gene expression is mediated via the interaction of their cognate tRNAs occupying the two functional ribosomal sites during the translation elongation step. For steric reasons it is reasonable to assume that not all combinations of codons and therefore of tRNAs are equally favorable when situated on the ribosome surface. Aiming of identifying preferential and rare codon pairs, we have determined the frequency of occurrence of all possible combinations of codon pairs in the entire genome of Escherichia coli (E.coli). RESULTS: The frequency of occurrence of the 3904 codon pairs comprising both sense:sense and sense:stop codon pairs in the full set of E.coli 4289 ORFs was found to vary from zero to 4913 times. For most of the pairs we have observed a significant difference between the real and statistically predicted frequency of occurrence. The analysis of 334 highly expressed and 303 poorly expressed E.coli genes showed that codon pair usage is different for the two gene categories. Using an especially defined criterion (Delta(REG)), the codon pairs are classified as 'hypothetically attenuating' (HAP) and 'hypothetically non-attenuating' (HNAP) and their possible effect on translation is discussed. AVAILABILITY: The program used in this study is available at http://www.bio21.bas.bg/codonpairs/     

Rare codon clusters at 5'-end influence heterologous expression of archaeal gene in Escherichia coli

Proteins from hyperthermophilic microorganisms are attractive candidates for novel biocatalysts because of their high resistance to temperature extremes. However, archaeal genes are usually poorly expressed in Escherichia coli because of differences in codon usage. Genes from the thermoacidophilic archaea Sulfolobus solfataricus and Thermoplasma acidophilum contain high proportions of rare codons for arginine, isoleucine, and leucine, which are recognized by the tRNAs encoded by the argU, ileY, and leuW genes, respectively, and which are rarely used in E. coli. To examine the effects of these rare codons on heterologous expression, we expressed the Sso_gnaD and Tac_gnaD genes from S. solfataricus and T. acidophilum, respectively, in E. coli. The Sso_gnaD product was expressed at very low levels when the open reading frame (ORF) was cloned in pRSET and expressed in E. coli BL21(DE3), and was expressed at much higher levels in the E. coli BL21(DE3)-CodonPlus RIL strain, which contains extra copies of the argU, ileY, and leuW tRNA genes. In contrast, Tac_gnaD was expressed at similar levels in both E. coli strains. Comparison of the Sso_gnaD and Tac_gnaD gene sequences revealed that the 5'-end of the Sso_gnaD sequence was rich in AGA(arg) and ATA(Ile) codons. These codons were replaced with the codons commonly used in E. coli by polymerase chain reaction-mediated site-directed mutagenesis. The results of expression studies showed that a non-tandem repeat of rare codons is critical in the observed interference in heterologous expression of this gene. We concluded that the level of heterologous expression of Sso_gnaD in E. coli was limited by the clustering of the rare codons in the ORF, rather than on the rare codon frequency.     

Role of GC-biased mutation pressure on synonymous codon choice in Micrococcus luteus, a bacterium with a high genomic GC-content.

The GC (G + C, or G or C)-contents of codon silent positions in all two-codon sets and three codons AUY/A (IIe), and in most of the family boxes of Micrococcus luteus (genomic GC-content: 74%) are 95% to 100% in both the highly and weakly expressed genes. In some family boxes, there is a decrease in NNC codons and an increase in NNG codons from the highly expressed to weakly expressed genes without apparent involvement of NNU and NNA codons. From these observations, we conclude that the selective use of synonymous codons in M. luteus may be largely determined by GC-biased mutation pressure and that in the highly expressed genes tRNAs would act as a weak selection pressure in some family boxes. Available data suggest that the effect of selection pressure by tRNAs on the synonymous codon choice becomes more apparent in the highly expressed genes in eubacteria with intermediate GC-contents such as Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis, and that the U/C ratio of the codon third positions in NNU/C-type two-codon sets in the weakly expressed genes would represent the approximate magnitude of directional mutation pressure throughout eubacteria.     

Ribosome can resume the translation in both +1 or -1 frames after encountering an AGA cluster in Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli the rare codons AGG, AGA and CGA are reported to have a detrimental effect on protein synthesis, especially during the expression of heterologous proteins. In the present work, we have studied the impact of successive clusters of these rare codons on the accuracy of mRNA translation in E. coli. For this purpose, we have analyzed the expression of an mRNA which contains in its 3' region a triplet and a tandem of AGA codons. This mRNA is derived from the human hepatitis B virus (HBV) preC gene. Both in eukaryotic cells and in eukaryotic cell-free translation system, this mRNA, directs the synthesis of a single 25 kDa protein. However, in a conventional E. coli strain BL 21 (DE3), transformed with a plasmid expressing this protein the synthesis of four polypeptides ranging from 30 to 21.5 kDa can be observed. Using different approaches, notably expression of i) precore mutated proteins or ii) chimeric proteins containing HA- and Myc-tags downstream of the AGA clusters (respectively in the -1 or +1 frame), we have found that when the ribosome encounters the AGA clusters, it can then resume the translation in both +1 and -1 frames. This result is in agreement with the model proposed recently by Baranov et al. (Baranov, P.V., Gesteland, R.F., Atkins, J.F., 2004. P-site tRNA is a crucial initiator of ribosomal frameshifting. RNA 10, 221-230), thus confirming that AGA/AGG codons can serve as sites for -1 frameshifting events. Only +1 frameshifting was suggested previously to occur at the AGA/AGG clusters.     

Decoding with the A:I wobble pair is inefficient.

tRNAs with inosine (I) in the first position read three codons ending in U, C and A. However, A-ending codons read with I are rarely used. In Escherichia coli, CGA/U/C are all read solely by tRNAICGArg. CGU and CGC are very common codons, but CGA is very rare. Three independent in vivo assays show that translation of CGA is relatively inefficient. In the first, nine tandem CGA cause a strong rho-mediated polar effect on expression of a lacZ reporter gene. The inhibition is made more extreme by a mutation in ribosomal protein S12 (rpsL), which indicates that ribosomal binding by tRNAICGArg is slow and/or unstable in the CGA cluster. The second assay, in which codons are substituted for the regulatory UGA of the RF2 frameshift, confirms that aa-tRNA selection is slow and/or unstable at CGA. In the third assay, CGA is found to be a poor 5' context for amber suppression, which suggests that an A:I base pair in the P site can interfere with translation of a codon in the A site. Two possible errors, frameshifting and premature termination by RF2, are not significant causes for inefficiency at CGA. It is concluded that the A:I pair destabilizes codon:anticodon complexes during two successive ribosomal cycles, and it is suggested that these properties contribute to the rare usage of codons read with the A:I base pair.     

Imbalance of tRNAPro isoacceptors induces +1 frameshifting at near-cognate codons

Increased expression of the CCU/CCA/CCG-decoding tRNA^Pro₃ on a multicopy plasmid leads to suppression of several +1 frameshift mutations in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium. Systematic analysis of the site of frameshifting indicates that excess tRNA^Pro₃ promotes near-cognate decoding at CCC codons. Re-phasing of the reading frame can be achieved by a subsequent slippage of the tRNA onto a cognate codon in the +1 reading frame. Frameshifting appears to be due to an imbalance of CCC-cognate and near-cognate tRNAs, as the effect of excess tRNA^Pro₃ on reading frame maintenance can be reversed by increasing simultaneously the concentration of the cognate tRNA^Pro2. Finally, the cmo⁵U modification present at position 34 of tRNA^Pro₃, which allows this tRNA to decode CCU in addition to CCG and CCA, also affects frameshifting, indicating that the ability of the near-cognate tRNA to decode a cognate codon efficiently in the alternative reading frame is important for re-phasing of the reading frame.     

Ribosomal frameshifting in the yeast retrotransposon Ty: tRNAs induce slippage on a 7 nucleotide minimal site

Ribosomal frameshifting regulates expression of the TYB gene of yeast Ty retrotransposons. We previously demonstrated that a 14 nucleotide sequence conserved between two families of Ty elements was necessary and sufficient to support ribosomal frameshifting. This work demonstrates that only 7 of these 14 nucleotides are needed for normal levels of frameshifting. Any change to the sequence CUU-AGG-C drastically reduces frameshifting; this suggests that two specific tRNAs, tRNA(UAGLeu) and tRNA(CCUArg), are involved in the event. Our tRNA overproduction data suggest that a leucyl-tRNA, probably tRNA(UAGLeu), an unusual leucine isoacceptor that recognizes all six leucine codons, slips from CUU-Leu onto UUA-Leu (in the +1 reading frame) during a translational pause at the AGG-Arg codon induced by the low availability of tRNA(CCUArg), encoded by a single-copy essential gene. Frameshifting is also directional and reading frame specific. Interestingly, frameshifting is inhibited when the "slip" CUU codon is located three codons downstream, but not four or more codons downstream, of the translational initiation codon.     

Preferential codon usage in prokaryotic genes: the optimal codon-anticodon interaction energy and the selective codon usage in efficiently expressed genes

By considering the nucleotide sequence of several highly expressed coding regions in bacteriophage MS2 and mRNAs from Escherichia coli, it is possible to deduce some rules which govern the selection of the most appropriate synonymous codons NNU or NNC read by tRNAs having GNN, QNN or INN as anticodon. The rules fit with the general hypothesis that an efficient in-phase translation is facilitated by proper choice of degenerate codewords promoting a codon-anticodon interaction with intermediate strength (optimal energy) over those with very strong or very weak interaction energy. Moreover, codons corresponding to minor tRNAs are clearly avoided in these efficiently expressed genes. These correlations are clearcut in the normal reading frame but not in the corresponding frameshift sequences +1 and +2. We hypothesize that both the optimization of codon-anticodon interaction energy and the adaptation of the population to codon frequency or vice versa in highly expressed mRNAs of E. coli are part of a strategy that optimizes the efficiency of translation. Conversely, codon usage in weakly expressed genes such as repressor genes follows exactly the opposite rules. It may be concluded that, in addition to the need for coding an amino acid sequence, the energetic consideration for codon-anticodon pairing, as well as the adaptation of codons to the tRNA population, may have been important evolutionary constraints on the selection of the optimal nucleotide sequence.     

Mistranslational errors associated with the rare arginine codon CGG in Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli, CGG is a rare arginine codon occurring at a frequency of 0.54% in all E. coli mRNAs or 9.8% when an arginine residue is encoded for. When present in high numbers or in clusters in highly expressed recombinant mRNA, rare codons can cause expression problems compromising product yield and translational fidelity. The coding region for an N-terminally polyhistidine tagged p27 protease domain from Herpes Simplex Virus 2 (HSV-2) contains 11 of these rare arginine codons, with 3 occurring in tandem near the C-terminus of the protein. When expressed in E. coli, the majority of the recombinant material produced had an apparent molecular mass of 31 kDa by SDS-PAGE gels or 3 kDa higher than predicted. Detailed biochemical analysis was performed on chemical and enzymatic digests of the protein and peptide fragments were characterized by Edman and MS/MS sequencing approaches. Two major species were isolated comprising +1 frameshift events at both the second and third CGG codons in the triplet cluster. Translation proceeded in the missense frame to the next termination codon. In addition, significant levels of glutamine misincorporating for arginine were discovered, suggesting second base misreading of CGG as CAG. Coexpression of the argX gene, which encodes the cognate tRNA for CGG codons, largely eliminated both the frameshift and misincorporation events, and increased expression levels of authentic product by up to 7-fold. We conclude that supplementation of the rare arginyl tRNA(CGG) levels by coexpression of the argX gene can largely alleviate the CGG codon bias present in E. coli, allowing for efficient and accurate translation of heterologous gene products.     

P-site tRNA is a crucial initiator of ribosomal frameshifting

The expression of some genes requires a high proportion of ribosomes to shift at a specific site into one of the two alternative frames. This utilized frameshifting provides a unique tool for studying reading frame control. Peptidyl-tRNA slippage has been invoked to explain many cases of programmed frameshifting. The present work extends this to other cases. When the A-site is unoccupied, the P-site tRNA can be repositioned forward with respect to mRNA (although repositioning in the minus direction is also possible). A kinetic model is presented for the influence of both, the cognate tRNAs competing for overlapping codons in A-site, and the stabilities of P-site tRNA:mRNA complexes in the initial and new frames. When the A-site is occupied, the P-site tRNA can be repositioned backward. Whether frameshifting will happen depends on the ability of the A-site tRNA to subsequently be repositioned to maintain physical proximity of the tRNAs. This model offers an alternative explanation to previously published mechanisms of programmed frameshifting, such as out-of-frame tRNA binding, and a different perspective on simultaneous tandem tRNA slippage.     

Is the in-frame termination signal of the Escherichia coli release factor-2 frameshift site weakened by a particularly poor context?

The synthesis of release factor-2 (RF-2) in bacteria is regulated by a high efficiency +1 frameshifting event at an in-frame UGA stop codon. The stop codon does not specify the termination of synthesis efficiently because of several upstream stimulators for frameshifting. This study focusses on whether the particular context of the stop codon within the frameshift site of the Escherichia coli RF-2 mRNA contributes to the poor efficiency of termination. The context of UGA in this recoding site is rare at natural termination sites in E.coli genes. We have evaluated how the three nucleotides downstream from the stop codon (+4, +5 and +6 positions) in the native UGACUA sequence affect the competitiveness of the termination codon against the frameshifting event. Changing the C in the +4 position and, separately, the A in the +6 position significantly increase the termination signal strength at the frameshift site, whereas the nucleotide in the +5 position had little influence. The efficiency of particular termination signals as a function of the +4 or +6 nucleotides correlates with how often they occur at natural termination sites in E.coli; strong signals occur more frequently and weak signals are less common.     

Helix 69 in 23S rRNA modulates decoding by wild type and suppressor tRNAs

Helix 69 of 23S rRNA forms one of the major inter-subunit bridges of the 70S ribosome and interacts with A- and P-site tRNAs and translation factors. Despite the proximity of h69 to the decoding center and tRNAs, the contribution of h69 to the tRNA selection process is unclear: previous genetic analyses have shown that h69 mutations increase frameshifting and readthrough of stop codons. However, a complete deletion of h69 does not affect the selection of cognate tRNAs in vitro. To address these discrepancies, the in vivo effects of a range of single- and multi-base h69 mutations in Escherichia coli 23S rRNA on various translation errors have been determined. While a majority of the h69 mutations examined here affected readthrough of stop codons and frameshifting, the ΔA1916 single base deletion mutation uniquely influenced missense decoding. Different h69 mutants had either increased or decreased levels of stop codon readthrough. The h69 mutations that decreased UGA readthrough also decreased UGA reading by a mutant, near-cognate tRNA^Trp carrying a G24A substitution in the D arm, but had far less effect on UGA reading by a suppressor tRNA with a complementary anticodon. These results suggest that h69 interactions with release factors contribute significantly to termination efficiency and that interaction with the D arm of A-site tRNA is important for discrimination between cognate and near-cognate tRNAs.     

Simple and efficient method for heterologous expression of clostridial proteins

Many clostridial proteins are poorly produced in Escherichia coli. It has been suggested that this phenomena is due to the fact that several types of codons common in clostridial coding sequences are rarely used in E. coli and the quantities of the corresponding tRNAs in E. coli are not sufficient to ensure efficient translation of the corresponding clostridial sequences. To address this issue, we amplified three E. coli genes, ileX, argU, and leuW, in E. coli; these genes encode tRNAs that are rarely used in E. coli (the tRNAs for the ATA, AGA, and CTA codons, respectively). Our data demonstrate that amplification of ileX dramatically increased the level of production of most of the clostridial proteins tested, while amplification of argU had a moderate effect and amplification of leuW had no effect. Thus, amplification of certain tRNA genes for rare codons in E. coli improves the expression of clostridial genes in E. coli, while amplification of other tRNAs for rare codons might not be needed for improved expression. We also show that amplification of a particular tRNA gene might have different effects on the level of protein production depending on the prevalence and relative positions of the corresponding codons in the coding sequence. Finally, we describe a novel approach for improving expression of recombinant clostridial proteins that are usually expressed at a very low level in E. coli.