Muscle-Specific Splicing of a Heterologous Exon Mediated by a Single Muscle-Specific Splicing Enhancer from the Cardiac Troponin T Gene

The chicken cardiac troponin T (cTNT) gene contains a single 30-nucleotide alternative exon that is included in embryonic striated muscle and skipped in the adult. Transient-transfection analysis of cTNT minigenes in muscle and fibroblast cell cultures previously identified four muscle-specific splicing enhancers (MSEs) that promote exon inclusion specifically in embryonic striated muscle cultures. Three MSEs located in the intron downstream from the alternative exon were sufficient for muscle-specific exon inclusion. In the present study, the boundaries of these MSEs were defined by scanning mutagenesis, allowing analysis of individual elements in gain-of-function experiments. Concatamers of MSE2 were necessary and sufficient to promote muscle-specific inclusion of a heterologous exon, indicating that it is a target for muscle-specific regulation. Sequences present in MSE2 are also found in MSE4, suggesting that these two MSEs act in a similar manner. MSE3 appears to be different from MSE2 and MSE4 yet is able to functionally replace both of these elements, demonstrating functional redundancy of elements that are likely to bind different factors. MSE2 and MSE4 each contain a novel sequence motif that is found adjacent to a number of alternative exons that undergo regulated splicing in striated muscle, suggesting a common role for this element in muscle-specific regulation.     

The CELF family of RNA binding proteins is implicated in cell-specific and developmentally regulated alternative splicing

Alternative splicing of cardiac troponin T (cTNT) exon 5 undergoes a developmentally regulated switch such that exon inclusion predominates in embryonic, but not adult, striated muscle. We previously described four muscle-specific splicing enhancers (MSEs) within introns flanking exon 5 in chicken cTNT that are both necessary and sufficient for exon inclusion in embryonic muscle. We also demonstrated that CUG-binding protein (CUG-BP) binds a conserved CUG motif within a human cTNT MSE and positively regulates MSE-dependent exon inclusion. Here we report that CUG-BP is one of a novel family of developmentally regulated RNA binding proteins that includes embryonically lethal abnormal vision-type RNA binding protein 3 (ETR-3). This family, which we call CELF proteins for CUG-BP- and ETR-3-like factors, specifically bound MSE-containing RNAs in vitro and activated MSE-dependent exon inclusion of cTNT minigenes in vivo. The expression of two CELF proteins is highly restricted to brain. CUG-BP, ETR-3, and CELF4 are more broadly expressed, and expression is developmentally regulated in striated muscle and brain. Changes in the level of expression and isoforms of ETR-3 in two different developmental systems correlated with regulated changes in cTNT splicing. A switch from cTNT exon skipping to inclusion tightly correlated with induction of ETR-3 protein expression during differentiation of C2C12 myoblasts. During heart development, the switch in cTNT splicing correlated with a transition in ETR-3 protein isoforms. We propose that ETR-3 is a major regulator of cTNT alternative splicing and that the CELF family plays an important regulatory role in cell-specific alternative splicing during normal development and disease.     

Dynamic antagonism between ETR-3 and PTB regulates cell type-specific alternative splicing

Inclusion of cardiac troponin T (cTNT) exon 5 in embryonic muscle requires conserved flanking intronic elements (MSEs). ETR-3, a member of the CELF family, binds U/G motifs in two MSEs and directly activates exon inclusion in vitro. Binding and activation by ETR-3 are directly antagonized by polypyrimidine tract binding protein (PTB). We use dominant-negative mutants to demonstrate that endogenous CELF and PTB activities are required for MSE-dependent activation and repression in muscle and nonmuscle cells, respectively. Combined use of CELF and PTB dominant-negative mutants provides an in vivo demonstration that antagonistic splicing activities exist within the same cells. We conclude that cell-specific regulation results from the dominance of one among actively competing regulatory states rather than modulation of a nonregulated default state.     

Binding of PurH to a muscle-specific splicing enhancer functionally correlates with exon inclusion in vivo

Regulated alternative splicing of avian cardiac troponin T (cTNT) pre-mRNA requires multiple intronic elements called muscle-specific splicing enhancers (MSEs) that flank the alternative exon 5 and promote muscle-specific exon inclusion. To understand the function of the MSEs in muscle-specific splicing, we sought to identify trans-acting factors that bind to these elements. MSE3, which is located 66-81 nucleotides downstream of exon 5, assembles a complex that is both sequence- and muscle-specific. Purification and characterization of the MSE3 complex identified one component as 5-aminoimidazole-4-carboxamide ribonucleotideformyltransferase/IMP cyclohydrolase (PurH), an enzyme involved in de novo purine synthesis. Recombinant human PurH protein directly binds MSE3 RNA and PurH is the primary determinant of sequence-specific binding in the native complex. Furthermore, we show a direct correlation between the in vitro binding affinity of both the MSE3 complex and recombinant PurH with functional activation of exon inclusion in vivo. Together, these results strongly suggest that PurH performs a second function as a component of a complex that regulates MSE3-dependent exon inclusion.     

In vitro splicing of cardiac troponin T precursors. Exon mutations disrupt splicing of the upstream intron.

A single cardiac troponin T (cTNT) gene generates two mRNAs by including or excluding the 30-nucleotide exon 5 during pre-mRNA processing. Transfection analysis of cTNT minigenes has previously demonstrated that both mRNAs are expressed from unmodified minigenes, and mutations within exon 5 can lead to complete skipping of the exon. These results suggested a role for exon sequence in splice site recognition. To investigate this potential role, an in vitro splicing system using cTNT precursors has been established. Two-exon precursors containing the alternative exon and either the upstream exon or downstream exon were spliced accurately and efficiently in vitro. The mutations within the alternative exon that resulted in exon skipping in vivo specifically blocked splicing of the upstream intron in vitro and had no effect on removal of the downstream intron. In addition, the splicing intermediates of these two precursors have been characterized, and the branch sites utilized on the introns flanking the alternative exon have been determined. Potential roles of exon sequence in splice site selection are discussed. These results establish a system that will be useful for the biochemical characterization of the role of exon sequence in splice site selection.     

The cardiac troponin T alternative exon contains a novel purine-rich positive splicing element.

We have characterized a novel positive-acting splicing element within the developmentally regulated alternative exon (exon 5) of the cardiac troponin T (cTNT) gene. The exon splicing element (ESE) is internal to the exon portions of the splice sites and is required for splicing to the 3' splice site but not the 5' splice site flanking the exon. Sequence comparisons between cTNT exon 5 and other exons that contain regions required for splicing reveal a common purine-rich motif. Sequence within cTNT exon 5 or a synthetic purine-rich motif facilitates splicing of heterologous alternative and constitutive splice sites in vivo. Interestingly, the ESE is not required for the preferential inclusion of cTNT exon 5 observed in primary skeletal muscle cultures. Our results strongly suggest that the purine-rich ESE serves as a general splicing element that is recognized by the constitutive splicing machinery.     

Nucleotide substitutions within the cardiac troponin T alternative exon disrupt pre-mRNA alternative splicing.

The cardiac troponin T (cTNT) pre-mRNA contains a single alternative exon (exon 5) which is either included or excluded from the processed mRNA. Using transient transfection of cTNT minigenes, we have previously localized pre-mRNA cis elements required for exon 5 alternative splicing to three small regions of the pre-mRNA which include exons 4, 5, and 6. In the present study, nucleotide substitutions were introduced into the region containing exon 5 to begin to define specific nucleotides required for exon 5 alternative splicing. A mutation within the 5' splice site flanking the cTNT alternative exon that increases its homology to the consensus sequence improves splicing efficiency and leads to increased levels of mRNAs that include the alternative exon. Surprisingly, substitution of as few as four nucleotides within the alternative exon disrupts cTNT pre-mRNA alternative splicing and prevents recognition of exon 5 as a bona fide exon. These results establish that the cTNT alternative exon contains information in cis that is required for its recognition by the splicing machinery.     

Alternative splicing of Xenopus alphafast-tropomyosin pre-mRNA during development: identification of determining sequences

The Xenopus alphafast-tropomyosin gene contains in its central part a set of mutually exclusive exons, designated 6A and 6B, which are incorporated into mRNA encoding, respectively, nonmuscle and muscle tropomyosins. In this study, we show that usage of both exons is strictly regulated during development, exon 6A being used in the oocyte and nonmuscle tissues of the embryo, while exon 6B is used in muscle tissues. An approach of transient embryo transgenesis was developed to study the mechanisms involved in the splice site choice during development. We demonstrate that a-tropomyosin minigenes driven by tissue-specific promoters that target gene expression in nonmuscle and muscle tissues recapitulate the splicing pattern of the endogenous gene. A mutational analysis showed that regulation occurred at both exons 6A and 6B in muscle and nonmuscle tissues. In this context, we have identified an element located in the intron downstream of 6A that participates in the recognition of the weak 5' splice site of exon 6A and the repression of exon 6B in nonmuscle cells.     

Exon selection in alpha-tropomyosin mRNA is regulated by the antagonistic action of RBM4 and PTB

RNA-binding motif protein 4 (RBM4) has been implicated in the regulation of precursor mRNA splicing. Using differential display analysis, we identified mRNAs that associate with RBM4-containing messenger RNPs in vivo. Among these mRNAs, alpha-tropomyosin (alpha-TM) is known to exhibit a muscle cell type-specific splicing pattern. The level of the skeletal muscle-specific alpha-TM mRNA isoform partially correlated with that of RBM4 in human tissues examined and could be modulated by ectopic overexpression or suppression of RBM4. These results indicated that RBM4 directly influences the expression of the skeletal muscle-specific alpha-TM isoform. Using minigenes, we demonstrated that RBM4 can activate the selection of skeletal muscle-specific exons, possibly via binding to intronic pyrimidine-rich elements. By contrast, the splicing regulator polypyrimidine tract binding protein (PTB) excluded these exons; moreover, RBM4 antagonized this PTB-mediated exon exclusion likely by competing with PTB for binding to a CU-rich element. This study suggests a possible mechanism underlying the regulated alternative splicing of alpha-TM by the antagonistic splicing regulators RBM4 and PTB.     

cis-elements involved in alternative splicing in the rat beta-tropomyosin gene: the 3'-splice site of the skeletal muscle exon 7 is the major site of blockage in nonmuscle cells.

We have been using the rat beta-tropomyosin (beta-TM) gene as a model system to study the mechanism of alternative splicing. The beta-TM gene spans 10 kb with 11 exons and encodes two distinct isoforms, namely skeletal muscle beta-TM and fibroblast TM-1. Exons 1-5, 8, and 9 are common to all mRNAs expressed from this gene. Exons 6 and 11 are used in fibroblasts, as well as in smooth muscle cells, whereas exons 7 and 10 are used exclusively in skeletal muscle cells. Our previous studies localized the critical elements for regulated alternative splicing to sequences within exon 7 and the adjacent upstream intron. We also demonstrated that these sequences function, in part, to regulate splice-site selection in vivo by interacting with cellular factors that block the use of the skeletal muscle exon in nonmuscle cells (1). Here we have further characterized the critical cis-acting elements involved in alternative splice site selection. Our data demonstrate that exon 7 and its flanking intron sequences are sufficient to regulate the suppression of exon 7 in nonmuscle cells when flanked by heterologous exons derived from adenovirus. We have also shown by both in vivo and in vitro assays that the blockage of exon 7 in nonmuscle cells is primarily at its 3'-splice site. A model is presented for regulated alternative splicing in both skeletal muscle and nonmuscle cells.     

Differential regulation of exonic regulatory elements for muscle-specific alternative splicing during myogenesis and cardiogenesis

Muscle-specific isoform of the mitochondrial ATP synthase gamma subunit (F(1)gamma) was generated by alternative splicing, and exon 9 of the gene was found to be lacking particularly in skeletal muscle and heart tissue. Recently, we reported that alternative splicing of exon 9 was induced by low serum or acidic media in mouse myoblasts, and that this splicing required de novo protein synthesis of a negative regulatory factor (Ichida, M., Endo, H., Ikeda, U., Matsuda, C., Ueno, E., Shimada, K., and Kagawa, Y. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 8492-8501; Hayakawa, M., Endo, H., Hamamoto, T., and Kagawa, Y. (1998) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 251, 603-608). In the present report, we identified a cis-acting element on the muscle-specific alternatively spliced exon of F(1)gamma gene by an in vivo splicing system using cultured cells and transgenic mice. We constructed a F(1)gamma wild-type minigene, containing the full-length gene from exon 8 to exon 10, and two mutants; one mutant involved a pyrimidine-rich substitution on exon 9, whereas the other was a purine-rich substitution, abbreviated as F(1)gamma Pu-del and F(1)gamma Pu-rich mutants, respectively. Based on an in vivo splicing assay using low serum- or acid-stimulated splicing induction system in mouse myoblasts, Pu-del mutation inhibited exon inclusion, indicating that a Pu-del mutation would disrupt an exonic splicing enhancer. On the other hand, the Pu-rich mutation blocked muscle-specific exon exclusion following both inductions. Next, we produced transgenic mice bearing both mutant minigenes and analyzed their splicing patterns in tissues. Based on an analysis of F(1)gamma Pu-del minigene transgenic mice, the purine nucleotide of this element was shown to be necessary for exon inclusion in non-muscle tissue. In contrast, analysis of F(1)gamma Pu-rich minigene mice revealed that the F(1)gamma Pu-rich mutant exon had been excluded from heart and skeletal muscle of these transgenic mice, despite the fact mutation of the exon inhibited muscle-specific exon exclusion in myotubes of early embryonic stage. These results suggested that the splicing regulatory mechanism underlying F(1)gamma pre-mRNA differed between myotubes and myofibers during myogenesis and cardiogenesis.     

In vivo splicing of the beta tropomyosin pre-mRNA: a role for branch point and donor site competition.

The chicken beta tropomyosin gene contains two sets of alternatively spliced, mutually exclusive exons whose utilization is developmentally regulated. Exons 6A and 6B are used in nonmuscle cells (or undifferentiated muscle cells) and skeletal muscle cells, respectively. A complex arrangement of cis-acting sequence elements is involved in alternative splicing regulation. We have performed an extensive mutational analysis on the sequence spanning the region from exon 6A to the constitutive exon 7. A large number of mutant minigenes have been tested in transfection assays of cultured myogenic cells, and the splicing products have been analyzed by cDNA polymerase chain reaction. We demonstrate that in undifferentiated myoblasts, exon 6B is skipped as a result of a negative control on its selection, while exon 6A is spliced as a default choice. We provide evidence that the focal point of such a regulation is localized in the intron upstream of exon 6B and probably involves the blockage of its associated branch point. In differentiated myotubes, in contrast, both exons are accessible to the splicing machinery. We show that the preferential choice of exon 6B in this splicing environment depends on the existence of a competition between the two exons for the flanking constitutive splice sites. We demonstrate that both the donors and the branch points of the two exons are involved in this competition.     

Muscle-specific exonic splicing silencer for exon exclusion in human ATP synthase gamma-subunit pre-mRNA.

Mitochondrial ATP synthase gamma-subunit (F(1)gamma) pre-mRNA undergoes alternative splicing in a tissue- or cell type-specific manner. Exon 9 of F(1)gamma pre-mRNA is specifically excluded in heart and skeletal muscle tissues and in acid-stimulated human fibrosarcoma HT1080 cells, rhabdomyosarcoma KYM-1 cells, and mouse myoblast C2C12 cells. Recently, we found a purine-rich exonic splicing enhancer (ESE) element on exon 9 via transgenic mice bearing F(1)gamma mutant minigenes and demonstrated that this ESE functions ubiquitously with exception of muscle tissue (Ichida, M., Hakamata, Y., Hayakawa, M., Ueno E., Ikeda, U., Shimada, K., Hamamoto, T., Kagawa, Y., Endo, H. (2000) J. Biol. Chem. 275, 15992-16001). Here, we identified an exonic negative regulatory element responsible for muscle-specific exclusion of exon 9 using both in vitro and in vivo splicing systems. A supplementation assay with nuclear extracts from HeLa cells and acid-stimulated HT1080 cells was performed for an in vitro reaction of muscle-specific alternative splicing of F(1)gamma minigene and revealed that the splicing reaction between exons 8 and 9 was the key step for regulation of muscle-specific exon exclusion. Polypyrimidine tract in intron 8 requires ESE on exon 9 for constitutive splice site selection. Mutation analyses on the F(1)gammaEx8-9 minigene using a supplementation assay demonstrated that the muscle-specific negative regulatory element is positioned in the middle region of exon 9, immediately downstream from ESE. Detailed mutation analyses identified seven nucleotides (5'-AGUUCCA-3') as a negative regulatory element responsible for muscle-specific exon exclusion. This element was shown to cause exon skipping in in vivo splicing systems using acid-stimulated HT1080 cells after transient transfection of several mutant F(1)gammaEx8-9-10 minigenes. These results demonstrated that the 5'-AGUUCCA-3' immediately downstream from ESE is a muscle-specific exonic splicing silencer (MS-ESS) responsible for exclusion of exon 9 in vivo and in vitro.     

Cis requirements for alternative splicing of the cardiac troponin T pre-mRNA.

The cardiac troponin T (cTNT) pre-mRNA splices 17 exons contiguously but alternatively splices (includes or excludes) the fifth exon. Because both alternative splice products are processed from the same pre-mRNA species, the cTNT pre-mRNA must contain cis-acting sequences which specify exon 5 as an alternative exon. A cTNT minigene (SM-1) transfected into cultured cells produces mRNAs both including and excluding exon 5. The junctions of exons 4-5-6 and 4-6 in the cTNT minigene mRNAs are identical to those of endogenous cTNT mRNAs and no other exons are alternatively spliced. Thus, the SM-1 pre-mRNA is correctly alternatively spliced in transfected cells. To circumscribe the pre-mRNA regions which are required for the alternative nature of exon 5, we have constructed a systematic series of deletion mutants of SM-1. Transfection of this series demonstrates that a 1200 nt pre-mRNA region containing exons 4, 5, and 6 is sufficient to direct alternative splicing of exon 5. Within this region are two relatively large inverted repeats which potentially sequester the alternative exon via intramolecular base-pairing. Such sequestration of an alternative exon is consistent with models which propose pre-mRNA conformation as being determinative for alternative splicing of some pre-mRNAs. However, deletion mutants which remove the majority of each of the inverted repeats retain the ability to alternatively splice exon 5 demonstrating that neither is required for cTNT alternative splice site selection. Taken together, deletion analysis has limited cis elements required for alternative splicing to three small regions of the pre-mRNA containing exons 4, 5, and 6. In addition, the cTNT minigene pre-mRNA expresses both alternative splice products in a wide variety of cultured non-muscle cells as well as in cultured striated muscle cells, although expression of the cTNT pre-mRNA is normally restricted to striated muscle. This indicates that cis elements involved in defining the cTNT exon 5 as an alternative exon do not require muscle-specific factors in trans to function.     

Regulated splicing of an alternative exon of beta-tropomyosin pre-mRNAs in myogenic cells depends on the strength of pyrimidine-rich intronic enhancer elements.

Alternative splicing of chicken beta-tropomyosin (beta-TM) pre-mRNAs ensures that in nonmuscle cells, only exon 6A is expressed, whereas in skeletal muscle, exon 6B is utilized preferentially. We have previously shown that efficient splicing of the nonmuscle exon 6A requires two pyrimidine-rich splicing enhancers (S4 and I5Y) that are present in the introns flanking exon 6A. Here, we examined the function of the S4 and I5Y elements by replacing them within beta-TM minigenes by other pyrimidine- and purine-rich sequence elements and analyzing splicing in transfected quail nonmuscle and muscle cells. Several features of these splicing regulatory elements were revealed by this study. First, a wide variety of pyrimidine-rich sequences can replace the intronic S4 splicing enhancer, indicating that pyrimidine composition, rather than sequence specificity, determines activity for this element. Second, one type of purine-rich sequence (GARn), normally found within exons, can also replace the S4 splicing enhancer. Third, the diverse elements tested exhibit differential activation of the splice sites flanking exon 6A and different positional constraints. Fourth, the strength of the S4 splicing enhancer is appropriately set to obtain proper regulation of the transition from exon 6A splicing in myoblasts to exon 6B splicing in myotubes, but this splicing regulatory element is not the target for cell-type-specific splicing factors.     

An intron splicing enhancer containing a G-rich repeat facilitates inclusion of a vertebrate micro-exon.

The average length of a vertebrate axon is approximately 130 nt. Decreasing the size of an internal axon to less than 51 nt induces axon skipping, implying a minimal size for exons. A few constitutively included internal exons, however, are extremely small. To investigate if such micro-exons require special mechanisms for their inclusion, we studied the sequences necessary for inclusion of a 6-nt axon from chicken cardiac troponin T (cTNT). In vivo, the cTNT micro-exon was not included in mRNA unless accompanied by a 134-nt sequence located next to the micro-exon in the downstream intron. Increasing the length of the micro-exon alleviated the requirement for the intron element, indicating that the lack of inclusion of the micro-exon in the absence of a facilitating sequence was due to its small size, rather than suboptimal splice sites. The intron element contained six copies of a G-rich 7-nt sequence. Multimers of the repeat supported exon inclusion, indicating that the repeat sequence is an important part of the intron element. The entire intron element activated inclusion of a heterologous 7-nt exon, suggesting that the intron element is a general enhancer for the splicing of micro-exons. In vitro, the intron element and the repeated sequence facilitated splicing of a heterologous exon. Because of the ability of the cTNT intron element to facilitate the splicing of heterologous exons, we have termed the element an intron splicing enhancer (ISE). Interestingly, the ISE demonstrated position independence in that it facilitated inclusion of the heterologous micro-exon when placed either upstream or downstream of the micro-exon. In vitro, the ISE or copies of the ISE G-rich repeat stimulated splicing of an adjacent intron. The ISE thus becomes one of only a few characterized ISEs containing a G-rich repeat and the first to work both upstream and downstream of a target axon.     

Polypyrimidine tract-binding protein is involved in vivo in repression of a composite internal/3' -terminal exon of the Xenopus alpha-tropomyosin Pre-mRNA

The Xenopus alpha(fast)-tropomyosin gene contains, at its 3' -end, a composite internal/3' -terminal exon (exon 9A9'), which is subjected to three different patterns of splicing according to the cell type. Exon 9A9' is included as a terminal exon in the myotome and as an internal exon in adult striated muscles, whereas it is skipped in nonmuscle cells. We have developed an in vivo model based on transient expression of minigenes encompassing the regulated exon 9A9' in Xenopus oocytes and embryos. We first show that the different alpha-tropomyosin minigenes recapitulate the splicing pattern of the endogenous gene and constitute valuable tools to seek regulatory sequences involved in exon 9A9' usage. A mutational analysis led to the identification of an intronic element that is involved in the repression of exon 9A9' in nonmuscle cells. This element harbors four polypyrimidine track-binding protein (PTB) binding sites that are essential for the repression of exon 9A9'. We show using UV cross-linking and immunoprecipitation experiments that Xenopus PTB (XPTB) interacts with these PTB binding sites. Finally, we show that depletion of endogenous XPTB in Xenopus embryos using a morpholinobased translational inhibition strategy resulted in exon 9A9' inclusion in embryonic epidermal cells. These results demonstrate that XPTB is required in vivo to repress the terminal exon 9A9' and suggest that PTB could be a major actor in the repression of regulated 3' -terminal exon.