HIV-1 TAR as anchoring site for optimized catalytic RNAs

Ribozymes have a great potential for developing specific gene silencing molecules. One of the main limitations to ensure the efficient application of ribozymes is to achieve effective binding to the target. Stem-loop domains support efficient formation of the kissing complex between natural antisense molecules and their target sequence. We have characterized catalytic antisense RNA hybrid molecules composed of a hammerhead ribozyme and a stem-loop antisense domain. A series of artificial RNA substrates containing the TAR-RNA stem-loop and a target for the hammerhead ribozyme were constructed and challenged with a catalytic antisense RNA carrying the TAR complementary stem-loop. The catalytic antisense RNA cleaves each of these substrates significantly more efficiently than the parental hammerhead ribozyme. Deletion of the TAR domain in the substrate abolishes the positive effect. These results suggest that the enhancement is due to the interaction of both complementary stem-loop motifs. A similar improvement was corroborated when targeting the LTR region of HIV-1 with either hammerhead- and hairpin-based catalytic antisense RNAs. Our results indicate that the TAR domain can be used as an anchoring site to facilitate the access of ribozymes to their specific target sequences within TAR-containing RNAs. Finally, we propose the addition of stable stem-loop motifs to the ribozyme domain as a rational way for constructing catalytic antisense RNAs.     

The antisense sequence of the HIV-1 TAR stem-loop structure covalently linked to the hairpin ribozyme enhances its catalytic activity against two artificial substrates

This work is an in vitro study of the efficiency of catalytic antisense RNAs whose catalytic domain is the wild-type sequence of the hairpin ribozyme, derived from the minus strand of the tobacco ringspot virus satellite RNA. The sequence in the target RNA recognized by the antisense molecule was the stem-loop structure of the human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1) TAR region. This region was able to form a complex with its antisense RNA with a binding rate of 2 x 10(4) M(-1)s(-1). Any deletion of the antisense RNA comprising nucleotides of the stem-loop resulted in a decrease in binding rate. Sequences 3' of the stem in the sense RNA also contributed to binding. This stem-loop TAR-antisense segment, covalently linked to a hairpin ribozyme, enhanced its catalytic activity. The highest cleavage rate was obtained when the stem-loop structure was present in both ribozyme and substrate RNAs and they were complementary. Similarly, an extension at the 5'-end of the hairpin ribozyme increased the cleavage rate when its complementary sequence was present in the substrate. Inclusion of the stem-loop at the 3'-end and the extension at the 5'-end of the hairpin ribozyme abolished the positive effect of both antisense units independently. These results may help in the design of hairpin ribozymes for gene silencing.     

The many faces of the hairpin ribozyme: structural and functional variants of a small catalytic RNA

The hairpin ribozyme is a small catalytic RNA that has been reengineered resulting in a number of variants with extended or even new functions. Thus, manipulation of the hairpin ribozyme structure has allowed for activity control by external effectors, namely oligonucleotides, flavine mononucleotide, and adenine. Hairpin ribozyme-derived twin ribozymes that mediate RNA fragment exchange reactions as well as self-processing hairpin ribozymes were designed. Furthermore, several hairpin ribozyme variants have been engineered for knock down of specific RNA substrates by adapting the substrate-binding domain to the specific target sequence. This review will focus on hairpin ribozymes possessing structural extensions/variations and thus functionally differing from the parent hairpin ribozyme.     

Sensing complex regulatory networks by conformationally controlled hairpin ribozymes

The hairpin ribozyme catalyses RNA cleavage by a mechanism utilizing its conformational flexibility during the docking of two independently folded internal loop domains A and B. Based on this mechanism, we designed hairpin ribozyme variants that can be induced or repressed by external effector oligonucleotides influencing the docking process. We incorporated a third domain C to assimilate alternate stable RNA motifs such as a pseudo-half-knot or an internal stem-loop structure. Small sequence changes in domain C allowed targeted switching of ribozyme activity: the same effector oligonucleotide can either serve as an inducer or repressor. The ribozymes were applied to trp leader mRNA, the RNA sequence tightly bound by l-tryptophan-activated trp-RNA-binding attenuation protein (TRAP). When domain C is complementary to this mRNA, ribozyme activity can be altered by annealing trp leader mRNA, then specifically reverted by its TRAP/tryptophan-mediated sequestration. This approach allows to precisely sense the activity status of a protein controlled by its metabolite molecule.     

A two unit antisense RNA cassette test system for silencing of target genes.

This communication describes a two unit antisense RNA cassette system for use in gene silencing. Cassettes consist of a recognition unit and an inhibitory unit which are transcribed into a single RNA that carries sequences of non-contiguous complementarity to the chosen target RNA. The recognition unit is designed as a stem-loop for rapid formation of long- lived binding intermediates with target sequences and resembles the major stem-loop of a naturally occurring antisense RNA, CopA. The inhibitory unit consists of either a sequence complementary to a ribosome binding site or of a hairpin ribozyme targeted at a site within the chosen mRNA. The contributions of the individual units to inhibition was assessed using the lacI gene as a target. All possible combinations of recognition and inhibitory units were tested in either orientation. In general, inhibition of lacI expression was relatively low. Fifty per cent inhibition was obtained with the most effective of the constructs, carrying the recognition stem-loop in the antisense orientation and the inhibitory unit with an anti-RBS sequence. Several experiments were performed to assess activities of the RNAs in vitro and in vivo : antisense RNA binding assays, cleavage assays, secondary structure analysis as well as Northern blotting and primer extension analysis of antisense and target RNAs. The problems associated with this antisense RNA approach as well as its potential are discussed with respect to possible optimization strategies.     

Suppression of BCR-ABL mRNA by various ribozymes in HeLa cells.

Ribozymes are RNA molecules with enzymatic activity that can cleave target RNA molecules in a sequence specific manner. To date, various types of ribozyme have been constructed to cleave other RNAs and such trans-acting ribozymes include hammerhead, hairpin and HDV ribozymes. External guide sequence (EGS) can also induce the suppression of a gene-expression by taking advantage of cellular RNase P. Here we compared the activities of various functional RNA cleavers both in vitro and in vivo. The first purpose of this comparison was intended to determine the best ribozyme motif with the highest activity in cells. The second purpose is to know the correlation between the activities of ribozymes in vitro and in vivo. Our results indicated that the intrinsic cleavage activity of ribozymes is not the sole determinant that is responsible for the activity of a ribozyme in cultured cells.     

Expression of a chimeric ribozyme gene results in endonucleolytic cleavage of target mRNA and a concomitant reduction of gene expression in vivo.

The subclass of catalytic RNAs termed ribozymes cleave specific target RNA sequences in vitro. Only circumstantial evidence supports the idea that ribozymes may also act in vivo. In this study, ribozymes with a hammerhead motif directed against a target sequence within the mRNA of the neomycin phosphotransferase gene (npt) were embedded into a functional chimeric gene. Two genes, one containing the ribozyme and the other producing the target, were cotransfected into plant protoplasts. Following in vivo expression, a predefined cleavage product of the target mRNA was detected by ribonuclease protection. Expression of both the ribozyme gene and the target gene was driven by the CaMV 35S promoter. Concomitant with the endonucleolytic cleavage of the target mRNA, a complete reduction of NPT activity was observed. An A to G substitution within the ribozyme domain completely inactivates ribozyme-mediated hydrolysis but still shows a reduction in NPT activity, albeit less pronounced. Therefore, the reduction of NPT activity produced by the active ribozyme is best explained by both hydrolytic cleavage and an antisense effect. However, the mutant ribozyme--target complex was more stable than the wildtype ribozyme--target complex. This may result in an overestimation of the antisense effect contributing to the overall reduction of gene expression.     

The influence of imperfectly paired helices I and III on the catalytic activity of hammerhead ribozymes.

Several catalytic antisense RNAs directed against different regions of the genomic or antigenomic RNA of Sendai virus were constructed. All RNAs contained the same catalytic domain based on hammerhead ribozymes but some had deletions or mutations resulting in imperfect helices I and III. Pre-annealed substrate/ribozyme complexes were used to determine the rates of the cleavage process for the different ribozymes under single-turnover conditions. It was found that the sequence context surrounding the cleavable motif influenced the cleavage efficiencies. Deletions or mutations of nucleotides 2.1 or 15.1 and 15.2 according to the numbering system for hammerhead ribozymes of Hertel et al. destroyed catalytic activity. Deletions of nucleotide 2.2 or additional nucleotides in the helix I-forming region of the ribozyme did not destruct, but only reduced the cleavage efficiencies. Similar results were observed for a deletion of nucleotide 15.3. Simultaneous deletions within helices I and III resulted in alternative cleavage sites. The potential consequences for the specificity of the ribozyme reaction are discussed.     

Chimeric DNA-RNA hammerhead ribozymes have enhanced in vitro catalytic efficiency and increased stability in vivo.

Subsequent to the discovery that RNA can have site specific cleavage activity, there has been a great deal of interest in the design and testing of trans-acting catalytic RNAs as both surrogate genetic tools and as therapeutic agents. We have been developing catalytic RNAs or ribozymes with target specificity for HIV-1 RNA and have been exploring chemical synthesis as one method for their production. To this end, we have chemically synthesized and experimentally analyzed chimeric catalysts consisting of DNA in the non-enzymatic portions, and RNA in the enzymatic core of hammerhead type ribozymes. Substitutions of DNA for RNA in the various stems of a hammerhead ribozyme have been analyzed in vitro for kinetic efficiency. One of the chimeric ribozymes used in this study, which harbors 24 bases of DNA capable of base-pairing interactions with an HIV-1 gag target, but maintains RNA in the catalytic center and in stem-loop II, has a sixfold greater kcat value than the all RNA counterpart. This increased activity appears to be the direct result of enhanced product dissociation. Interestingly, a chimeric ribozyme in which stem-loop II (which divides the catalytic core) is comprised of DNA, exhibited a marked reduction in cleavage activity, suggesting that DNA in this region of the ribozyme can impart a negative effect on the catalytic function of the ribozyme. DNA-RNA chimeric ribozymes transfected by cationic liposomes into human T-lymphocytes are more stable than their all-RNA counterparts. Enhanced catalytic turnover and stability in the absence of a significant effect on Km make chimeric ribozymes favorable candidates for therapeutic agents.     

Effects of variations in length of hammerhead ribozyme antisense arms upon the cleavage of longer RNA substrates.

The efficacy of intracellular binding of hammerhead ribozyme to its cleavage site in target RNA is a major requirement for its use as a therapeutic agent. Such efficacy can be influenced by several factors, such as the length of the ribozyme antisense arms and mRNA secondary structures. Analysis of various IL-2 hammerhead ribozymes having different antisense arms but directed to the same site predicts that the hammerhead ribozyme target site is present within a double-stranded region that is flanked by single-stranded loops. Extension of the low cleaving hammerhead ribozyme antisense arms by nucleotides that base pair with the single-stranded regions facilitated the hammerhead ribozyme binding to longer RNA substrates (e.g. mRNA). In addition, a correlation between the in vitro and intracellular results was also found. Thus, the present study would facilitate the design of hammerhead ribozymes directed against higher order structured sites. Further, it emphasises the importance of detailed structural investigations of hammerhead ribozyme full-length target RNAs.     

A cis and trans adenine-dependent hairpin ribozyme against Tpl-2 target

Ribozymes are catalytic RNAs that possess the property of cutting an RNA target via site-specific cleavage after sequence-specific recognition. Ribozymes can moreover cleave multiple substrate molecules. An increasing number of studies show that ribozymes are particularly well adapted tools against cancer, silencing or down-regulating gene expression at the RNA level. We have constructed an adenine-dependent hairpin ribozyme that cleaves the sequence at nucleotides A(225)(downward arrow)G(226) relative to the start codon of translation of the Tpl-2 kinase mRNA; this serine/threonine kinase activates the mitogen-activated protein kinase pathway implicated in cell proliferation in breast cancer. An adenine-dependent hairpin ribozyme 1 (ADHR1) was previously isolated using the Systematic Evolution of Ligands by EXponential enrichment procedure. Switch on/switch off ribozymes are particularly useful since high amounts of stable ribozyme can be produced in the absence of adenine and the ribozyme specifically cleaves its target in the presence of adenine. The ADHR1 target sequence was replaced by a sequence derived from the Tpl-2 kinase mRNA. The resulting Tpl-2 ribozyme is active in cis cleavage: kinetic studies have been performed as a function of Mg2+ concentration, adenine concentration, as well as at different pH and with various cofactors. Finally, the Tpl-2 ribozyme was shown to cleave its target in trans successfully. These findings demonstrate that a potential therapeutic ribozyme can be produced by simple sequence modification.     

The effect of structure in a long target RNA on ribozyme cleavage efficiency.

Inhibition of gene expression by catalytic RNA (ribozymes) requires that ribozymes efficiently cleave specific sites within large target RNAs. However, the cleavage of long target RNAs by ribozymes is much less efficient than cleavage of short oligonucleotide substrates because of higher order structure in the long target RNA. To further study the effects of long target RNA structure on ribozyme cleavage efficiency, we determined the accessibility of seven hammerhead ribozyme cleavage sites in a target RNA that contained human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) vif - vpr . The base pairing-availability of individual nucleotides at each cleavage site was then assessed by chemical modification mapping. The ability of hammerhead ribozymes to cleave the long target RNA was most strongly correlated with the availability of nucleotides near the cleavage site for base pairing with the ribozyme. Moreover, the accessibility of the seven hammerhead ribozyme cleavage sites in the long target RNA varied by up to 400-fold but was directly determined by the availability of cleavage sites for base pairing with the ribozyme. It is therefore unlikely that steric interference affected hammerhead ribozyme cleavage. Chemical modification mapping of cleavage site structure may therefore provide a means to identify efficient hammerhead ribozyme cleavage sites in long target RNAs.     

Structure and function of the hairpin ribozyme

The hairpin ribozyme belongs to the family of small catalytic RNAs that cleave RNA substrates in a reversible reaction that generates 2',3'-cyclic phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl termini. The hairpin catalytic motif was discovered in the negative strand of the tobacco ringspot virus satellite RNA, where hairpin ribozyme-mediated self-cleavage and ligation reactions participate in processing RNA replication intermediates. The self-cleaving hairpin, hammerhead, hepatitis delta and Neurospora VS RNAs each adopt unique structures and exploit distinct kinetic and catalytic mechanisms despite catalyzing the same chemical reactions. Mechanistic studies of hairpin ribozyme reactions provided early evidence that, like protein enzymes, RNA enzymes are able to exploit a variety of catalytic strategies. In contrast to the hammerhead and Tetrahymena ribozyme reactions, hairpin-mediated cleavage and ligation proceed through a catalytic mechanism that does not require direct coordination of metal cations to phosphate or water oxygens. The hairpin ribozyme is a better ligase than it is a nuclease while the hammerhead reaction favors cleavage over ligation of bound products by nearly 200-fold. Recent structure-function studies have begun to yield insights into the molecular bases of these unique features of the hairpin ribozyme.     

RNA double cleavage by a hairpin-derived twin ribozyme

The hairpin ribozyme is a small catalytic RNA that catalyses reversible sequence-specific RNA hydrolysis in trans. It consists of two domains, which interact with each other by docking in an antiparallel fashion. There is a region between the two domains acting as a flexible hinge for interdomain interactions to occur. Hairpin ribozymes with reverse-joined domains have been constructed by dissecting the domains at the hinge and rejoining them in reverse order. We have used both the conventional and reverse-joined hairpin ribozymes for the design of a hairpin-derived twin ribozyme. We show that this twin ribozyme cleaves a suitable RNA substrate at two specific sites while maintaining the target specificity of the individual monoribozymes. For characterisation of the studied ribozymes we have evaluated a quantitative assay of sequence-specific ribozyme activity using fluorescently labelled RNA substrates in conjunction with an automated DNA sequencer. This assay was found to be applicable with hairpin and hairpin-derived ribozymes. The results demonstrate the potential of hairpin ribozymes for multi-target strategies of RNA cleavage and suggest the possibility for employing hairpin-derived twin ribozymes as powerful tools for RNA manipulation in vitro and in vivo.     

Interaction between hammerhead ribozyme and RNA substrates measured by a surface plasmon resonance biosensor

Dynamic interactions between hammerhead ribozymes and RNA substrates were measured using the surface plasmon resonance (SPR) technology. Two in vitro transcribed substrates (non-cleavable and cleavable) were immobilised on streptavidin-coated dextran matrices and subsequently challenged with non-related yeast tRNA or two hammerhead ribozymes, both of which had previously been shown to exhibit functional binding and cleavage of complementary target RNAs. The target-binding domain of one of the ribozymes was fully complementary to a 16-ribonucleotide stretch on the immobilised substrates, while the other ribozyme had a nine-ribonucleotide complementarity. The two ribozymes could readily be differentiated with regard to affinity. Cleavage could be measured, using the ribozyme with full target complementarity to the cleavable substrate. In contrast, the ribozyme with lower affinity lacked cleavage activity. We suggest that SPR will be useful for investigations of ribozyme-substrate interactions.     

Selective cleavage of bcr-abl chimeric RNAs by a ribozyme targeted to non-contiguous sequences.

Conventionally designed ribozymes may be unable to cleave RNA at sites which are inaccessible due to secondary structure. In addition, it may also be difficult to specifically target a conventionally designed ribozyme to some chimeric RNA molecules. Novel approaches for ribozyme targeting were developed by using the L6 bcr-abl fusion RNA as a model. Using one approach, we successfully directed ribozyme nucleation to a site on the bcr-abl RNA that is distant from the GUA cleavage site. These ribozymes bound to the L6 substrate RNA via an anchor sequence that was complementary to bcr sequences. The anchor was necessary for efficient cleavage as the anchor minus ribozyme, a conventionally designed ribozyme, was inefficient at catalyzing cleavage at this same site. The effect of anchor sequences on catalytic rates was determined for two of these ribozymes. Ribozymes generated by a second approach were designed to cleave at a CUU site in proximity to the bcr-abl junction. Both approaches have led to the development of a series of ribozymes specific for both the L6 and K28 bcr-abl chimeric RNAs, but not normal abl or bcr RNAs. The specificity of the ribozyme correlated in part with the ability of the ribozyme to bind substrate as demonstrated by gel shift analyses. Secondary structure predictions for the RNA substrate support the experimental results and may prove useful as a theoretical basis for the design of ribozymes.