Mechanism of action of cysteine proteinases: oxyanion binding site is not essential in the hydrolysis of specific substrates

To study the possible stabilization of the oxyanion of the tetrahedral intermediate formed in the course of the catalyses by cysteine proteinases, papain, chymopapain, papaya peptidase A, and ficin, we synthesized N-(benzyloxycarbonyl)phenylalanylthioglycine O-ethyl ester and compared its hydrolysis with that of the corresponding oxygen ester, a highly specific substrate of the above enzymes. It was found that the substitution of sulfur for the carbonyl oxygen hardly affected the second-order rate constant of acylation and diminished catalytic activity by about 1 order of magnitude in deacylation. These results contrast with those obtained with serine proteinases [Asbóth, B., & Polgár, L. (1983) Biochemistry 22, 117-122], where the hydrolysis of thiono esters could not be detected. From the results the following conclusions can be drawn. Stabilization of the tetrahedral intermediate at an oxyanion binding site is not essential with cysteine proteinases. Therefore, and because of the lack of general base catalysis, cysteine proteinases have a less constrained transition-state structure than serine proteinases.     

A theoretical study of the active sites of papain and S195C rat trypsin: implications for the low reactivity of mutant serine proteinases.

The serine and cysteine proteinases represent two important classes of enzymes that use a catalytic triad to hydrolyze peptides and esters. The active site of the serine proteinases consists of three key residues, Asp...His...Ser. The hydroxyl group of serine functions as a nucleophile and the imidazole ring of histidine functions as a general acid/general base during catalysis. Similarly, the active site of the cysteine proteinases also involves three key residues: Asn, His, and Cys. The active site of the cysteine proteinases is generally believed to exist as a zwitterion (Asn...His+...Cys-) with the thiolate anion of the cysteine functioning as a nucleophile during the initial stages of catalysis. Curiously, the mutant serine proteinases, thiol subtilisin and thiol trypsin, which have the hybrid Asp...His...Cys triad, are almost catalytically inert. In this study, ab initio Hartree-Fock calculations have been performed on the active sites of papain and the mutant serine proteinase S195C rat trypsin. These calculations predict that the active site of papain exists predominately as a zwitterion (Cys-...His+...Asn). However, similar calculations on S195C rat trypsin demonstrate that the thiol mutant is unable to form a reactive thiolate anion prior to catalysis. Furthermore, structural comparisons between native papain and S195C rat trypsin have demonstrated that the spatial juxtapositions of the triad residues have been inverted in the serine and cysteine proteinases and, on this basis, I argue that it is impossible to convert a serine proteinase to a cysteine proteinase by site-directed mutagenesis.     

Transition-state stabilization at the oxyanion binding sites of serine and thiol proteinases: hydrolyses of thiono and oxygen esters

X-ray diffraction studies suggested that the tetrahedral intermediate formed during the catalysis by serine and thiol proteinases can be stabilized by hydrogen bonds from the protein to the oxyanion of the intermediate [cf. Kraut, J. (1977) Annu. Rev. Biochem. 46, 331-358; Drenth, J., Kalk, K.H., & Swen, H.M. (1976) Biochemistry 15, 3731-3738]. To obtain evidence in favor or against this hypothesis, we synthesized thiono substrates (the derivatives of N-benzoyl-glycine methyl ester and N-acetylphenylalanine ethyl ester) containing a sulfur in place of the carbonyl oxygen atom of the scissile ester bond. We anticipated that this relatively subtle structural change specifically directed to the oxyanion binding site should produce serious catalytic consequences owing to the different properties of oxygen and sulfur if transition-state stabilization in the oxyanion hole is indeed important. In fact, while in alkaline hydrolysis the chemical reactivities of oxygen esters and corresponding thiono esters proved to be similar, neither chymotrypsin nor subtilisin hydrolyzed the thiono esters at a measurable rate. This result substantiates the crucial role of the oxyanion binding site in serine proteinase catalysis. On the basis of the similar values of the binding constants found for oxygen esters and their thiono counterparts, it can be concluded that the substitution of sulfur for oxygen significantly influences transition state stabilization but not substrate binding. The thiol proteinases papain and chymopapain react with the oxygen and thiono esters of N-benzoylglycine at similar rates. Apparently, in these reactions the above stabilizing mechanism is absent or not important, which is a major mechanistic difference between the catalyses by serine and thiol proteinases.     

Minimal transition state charge stabilization of the oxyanion during peptide bond formation by the ribosome

Peptide bond formation during ribosomal protein synthesis involves an aminolysis reaction between the aminoacyl α-amino group and the carbonyl ester of the growing peptide via a transition state with a developing negative charge, the oxyanion. Structural and molecular dynamic studies have suggested that the ribosome may stabilize the oxyanion in the transition state of peptide bond formation via a highly ordered water molecule. To biochemically investigate this mechanistic hypothesis, we estimated the energetic contribution to catalytic charge stabilization of the oxyanion using a series of transition state mimics that contain different charge distributions and hydrogen bond potential on the functional group mimicking the oxyanion. Inhibitors containing an oxyanion mimic that carried a neutral charge and a mimic that preserved the negative charge but could not form hydrogen bonds had less than a 3-fold effect on inhibitor binding affinity. These observations argue that the ribosome provides minimal transition state charge stabilization to the oxyanion during peptide bond formation via the water molecule. This is in contrast to the substantial level of oxyanion stabilization provided by serine proteases. This suggests that the oxyanion may be neutralized via a proton shuttle, resulting in an uncharged transition state.     

Refined atomic model of wheat serine carboxypeptidase II at 2.2-A resolution.

The crystal structure of the homodimeric serine carboxypeptidase II from wheat (CPDW-II, M(r) 120K) has been determined and fully refined at 2.2-A resolution to a standard crystallographic R factor of 16.9% using synchrotron data collected at the Brookhaven National Laboratory. The model has an rms deviation from ideal bond lengths of 0.018 A and from bond angles of 2.8 degrees. The model supports the general conclusions of an earlier study at 3.5-A resolution and will form the basis for investigation into substrate binding and mechanistic studies. The enzyme has an alpha + beta fold, consisting of a central 11-stranded beta-sheet with a total of 15 helices on either side. The enzyme, like other serine proteinases, contains a "catalytic triad" Ser146-His397-Asp338 and a presumed "oxyanion hole" consisting of the backbone amides of Tyr147 and Gly53. The carboxylate of Asp338 and imidazole of His397 are not coplanar in contrast to the other serine proteinases. A comparison of the active site features of the three families of serine proteinases suggests that the "catalytic triad" should actually be regarded as two diads, a His-Asp diad and a His-Ser diad, and that the relative orientation of one diad with respect to the other is not particularly important. Four active site residues (52, 53, 65, and 146) have unfavorable backbone conformations but have well-defined electron density, suggesting that there is some strain in the active site region. The binding of the free amino acid arginine has been analyzed by difference Fourier methods, locating the binding site for the C-terminal carboxylate of the leaving group. The carboxylate makes hydrogen bonds to Glu145, Asn51, and the amide of Gly52. The carboxylate of Glu145 also makes a hydrogen bond with that of Glu65, suggesting that one or both may be protonated. Thus, the loss of peptidase activity at pH > 7 may in part be due to deprotonation of Glu145. The active site does not reveal exposed peptide amides and carbonyl oxygen atoms that could interact with substrate in an extended beta-sheet fashion. The fold of the polypeptide backbone is completely different than that of trypsin or subtilisin, suggesting that this is a third example of convergent molecular evolution to a common enzymatic activity. Furthermore, it is suggested that the active site sequence motif "G-X-S-X-G/A", often considered the hallmark of serine peptidase or esterase activity, is fortuitous and not the result of divergent evolution.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

New structural motifs on the chymotrypsin fold and their potential roles in complement factor B

Factor B and C2 are two central enzymes for complement activation. They are multidomain serine proteases and require cofactor binding for full expression of proteolytic activities. We present a 2.1 A crystal structure of the serine protease domain of factor B. It shows a number of structural motifs novel to the chymotrypsin fold, which by sequence homology are probably present in C2 as well. These motifs distribute characteristically on the protein surface. Six loops surround the active site, four of which shape substrate-binding pockets. Three loops next to the oxyanion hole, which typically mediate zymogen activation, are much shorter or absent. Three insertions including the linker to the preceding domain bulge from the side opposite to the active site. The catalytic triad and non-specific substrate-binding site display active conformations, but the oxyanion hole displays a zymogen-like conformation. The bottom of the S1 pocket has a negative charge at residue 226 instead of the typical 189 position. These unique structural features may play different roles in domain-domain interaction, cofactor binding and substrate binding.     

Comparison of protein electrostatic potential along the catalytic triad of serine proteinases

Intraproteic electrostatic potentials along the catalytic triad in serine proteinases are compared for eight enzymes for which three-dimensional co-ordinates are available. We used our bond-increment method to calculate the potential and we considered all protein atoms, including hydrogens. It was found that counter ions which may be located in the vicinity of charged surface side chains play a decisive role in determining enzymatic action. If ionizable side chains are neutralized the electrostatic potential curve across the catalytic triad is of minimum character in all investigated enzymes. It stabilizes the (-+-) charge distribution which models the Ser- -His+ -Asp- transition state structure which is formed during the catalytic process. Based on the close similarity of the electrostatic pattern in various enzymes we call attention to the possibility that convergent evolution produced not only the effective catalytic triad but also a minimum-type potential which accelerates the enzymatic reaction.     

Identification and analysis of a new family of bacterial serine proteinases

A family of hypothetical proteins, identified predominantly from archaeal genomes, has been analyzed in order to understand its functional characteristics. Using extensive sequence similarity searches it is inferred that this family is remotely related (best sequence identity is 19%) to ClpP proteinases that belongs to serine proteinase class. This family of hypothetical proteins is referred to as SDH proteinase family based on conserved sequential order of Ser, Asp and His residues and predicted serine proteinase activity. Results of fold recognition of SDH family sequences confirmed the remote relationship between SDH proteinases and Clp proteinases and revealed similar tertiary location of putative catalytic triad residues critical for serine proteinase function. However, the best sequence alignment we could obtain suggests that while catalytic Ser is conserved across Clp and SDH proteinases the location of the other catalytic triad residues, namely, His and Asp are swapped in their amino acid alignment positions and hence in 3-D structure. The evidence of conserved catalytic triad suggests that SDH could be a new family of serine proteinases with the fold of Clp proteinase, however sharing the catalytic triad order of carboxypeptidase clan. Signal peptide sequence identified at the N-terminus of some of the homologues suggests that these might be secretory serine proteinases involved in cleavage of extracellular proteins while the remote homologues, ClpP proteinases, are known to work in intracellular environment.     

Peptidoglycan inducible expression of a serine proteinase homologue from kuruma shrimp (Marsupenaeus japonicus)

A cDNA encoding a serine proteinase homologue of kuruma shrimp (Marsupenaeus japonicus) was cloned. The 1257 bp cDNA encodes a 339 amino acid putative peptide, with a signal sequence of 16 amino acid residues. The deduced amino acid sequence is 42-67% similar to the immune-related serine proteinases and serine proteinase homologues of arthropods. It contains catalytic triad residues in the putative catalytic domain except for one substitution of Ser by a Gly residue. The six cysteine residues that form three disulphide bridges in most serine proteinases were conserved. The M. japonicus serine proteinase homologue was mainly expressed in haemocytes, in which expression dramatically increased after 3 days feeding with peptidoglycan at 0.2 mg kg(-1) shrimp body weight per day.     

Crystal structure of the proenzyme domain of plasminogen.

We have solved the X-ray crystal structure of the proenzyme form of the catalytic domain of plasminogen, with the nonessential mutations M585Q, V673M, and M788L, to 2.0 A resolution. The structure presents an inactive protease characterized by Asp740 (chymotrypsinogen 194) hydrogen bonded to His586 (chymotrypsinogen 40), preventing proper formation of the oxyanion hole and S1 specificity pocket. In addition, the catalytic triad residues are misplaced relative to the active conformation adopted by serine proteases in the chymotrypsin family. Finally, a unique form of zymogen inactivation is observed, characterized by a "foot-in-mouth" mechanism in which Trp761 (chymotrypsinogen 215) is folded into the S1 specificity pocket preventing substrate binding.     

Human rhinovirus 3C protease: a cysteine protease showing the trypsin(ogen)-like fold

Viral-encoded proteases cleave precursor polyprotein(s) leading to maturation of infectious virions. Strikingly, human rhinovirus 3C protease shows the trypsin(ogen)-like serine protease fold based on two topologically equivalent six-stranded β-barrels, but displays residue Cys147 as the active site nucleophile. By contrast, papain, which is representative of most cysteine proteases, does not display the trypsin(ogen)-like fold. Remarkably, in human rhinovirus 3C cysteine protease, the catalytic residues Cys147, His40 and Glu71 are positioned as Ser195, His57 and Asp102, respectively, building up the catalytic triad of serine proteases in the chymotrypsin–trypsin–elastase family. However, as compared to trypsin-like serine proteases and their zymogens, residue His40 and the oxyanion hole of human rhinovirus 3C cysteine protease, both key structural components of the active site, are located closer to the protein core. Human rhinovirus 3C cysteine protease cleaves preferentially GlnGly peptide bonds or, less commonly, the GlnSer, GlnAla, GluSer or GluGly pairs. Finally, human rhinovirus 3C cysteine protease and the 3CD cysteine protease–polymerase covalent complex bind the 5′ non-coding region of rhinovirus genomic RNA, an essential function for replication of the viral genome.     

The alpha/beta hydrolase fold.

We have identified a new protein fold--the alpha/beta hydrolase fold--that is common to several hydrolytic enzymes of widely differing phylogenetic origin and catalytic function. The core of each enzyme is similar: an alpha/beta sheet, not barrel, of eight beta-sheets connected by alpha-helices. These enzymes have diverged from a common ancestor so as to preserve the arrangement of the catalytic residues, not the binding site. They all have a catalytic triad, the elements of which are borne on loops which are the best-conserved structural features in the fold. Only the histidine in the nucleophile-histidine-acid catalytic triad is completely conserved, with the nucleophile and acid loops accommodating more than one type of amino acid. The unique topological and sequence arrangement of the triad residues produces a catalytic triad which is, in a sense, a mirror-image of the serine protease catalytic triad. There are now four groups of enzymes which contain catalytic triads and which are related by convergent evolution towards a stable, useful active site: the eukaryotic serine proteases, the cysteine proteases, subtilisins and the alpha/beta hydrolase fold enzymes.     

Three-dimensional structure of the catalytic core of acetylxylan esterase from Trichoderma reesei: insights into the deacetylation mechanism

Acetylxylan esterase from Trichoderma reesei removes acetyl side groups from xylan. The crystal structure of the catalytic core of the enzyme was solved at 1.9 A resolution. The core has an alpha/beta/alpha sandwich fold, similar to that of homologous acetylxylan esterase from Penicillium purpurogenum and cutinase from Fusarium solani. All three enzymes belong to family 5 of the carbohydrate esterases and the superfamily of the alpha/beta hydrolase fold. Evidently, the enzymes have diverged from a common ancestor and they share the same catalytic mechanism. The catalytic machinery of acetylxylan esterase from T. reesei was studied by comparison with cutinase, the catalytic site of which is well known. Acetylxylan esterase is a pure serine esterase having a catalytic triad (Ser90, His187, and Asp175) and an oxyanion hole (Thr13 N, and Thr13 O gamma). Although the catalytic triad of acetylxylan esterase has been reported previously, there has been no mention of the oxyanion hole. A model for the binding of substrates is presented on the basis of the docking of xylose. Acetylxylan esterase from T. reesei is able to deacetylate both mono- and double-acetylated residues, but it is not able to remove acetyl groups located close to large side groups such as 4-O-methylglucuronic acid. If the xylopyranoside residue is double-acetylated, both acetyl groups are removed by the catalytic triad: first one acetyl group is removed and then the residue is reorientated so that the nucleophilic oxygen of serine can attack the second acetyl group.     

The unusual catalytic triad of poliovirus protease 3C

Picornaviruses are small pathogen RNA viruses, like poliovirus, hepatitis A virus, rhinovirus, and others. They produce a large polyprotein, which is cleaved by virally encoded cysteine peptidases, picornains 2A and 3C. Picornain 3C represents an intermediate between the serine peptidase chymotrypsin and the cysteine peptidase papain. Its steric structure resembles chymotrypsin, but its nucleophile is a thiol instead of the hydroxyl group. The histidine is a general base catalyst in chymotrypsin but forms a thiolate-imidazolium ion pair in papain. The third member of the catalytic triad is an acid (Glu71) as in chymotrypsin rather than an amide found in papain. Transformation of poliovirus 3C peptidase into a serine peptidase results in lower activity by a factor of 430, but the activity extends toward higher pH with the more basic hydroxyl group. The decrease in activity is caused by the less ordered active site, as supported by the unfavorable entropy of activation. At 25 degrees C the specificity rate constant for the thiol enzyme approaches k(1), the rate constant for the formation of the enzyme-substrate complex, but k(2), the acylation constant, becomes predominant with the increase in temperature. In contrast, for the serine peptidase the specificity constant is less than k(1) over the entire temperature range, and the transition state is controlled by both k(1) and k(2). The acidic component of the catalytic triad is essential for activity, but its negative charge does not influence the ionization of the thiol group.     

Structural and kinetic contributions of the oxyanion binding site to the catalytic activity of acylaminoacyl peptidase

It is widely accepted that the catalytic activity of serine proteases depends primarily on the Asp-His-Ser catalytic triad and other residues within the vicinity of this motif. Some of these residues form the oxyanion binding site that stabilizes the tetrahedral intermediate by hydrogen bonding to the negatively charged oxyanion. In acylaminoacyl peptidase from the thermophile Aeropyrum pernix, the main chain NH group of Gly369 is one of the hydrogen bond donors forming the oxyanion binding site. The side chain of His367, a conserved residue in acylaminoacyl peptidases across all species, fastens the loop holding Gly369. Determination of the crystal structure of the H367A mutant revealed that this loop, including Gly369, moves away considerably, accounting for the observed three orders of magnitude decrease in the specificity rate constant. For the wild-type enzyme ln(k(cat)/K(m)) vs. 1/T deviates from linearity indicating greater rate enhancement with increasing temperature for the dissociation of the enzyme-substrate complex compared with its decomposition to product. In contrast, the H367A variant provided a linear Arrhenius plot, and its reaction was associated with unfavourable entropy of activation. These results show that a residue relatively distant from the active site can significantly affect the catalytic activity of acylaminoacyl peptidase without changing the overall structure of the enzyme.     

Molecular cloning of trypsin-like cDNAs and comparison of proteinase activities in the salivary glands and gut of the tarnished plant bug Lygus lineolaris (Heteroptera: Miridae)

Using specific proteinase inhibitors, we demonstrated that serine proteinases in the tarnished plant bug, Lygus lineolaris, are major proteinases in both salivary glands and gut tissues. Gut proteinases were less sensitive to inhibition than proteinases from the salivary glands. Up to 80% azocaseinase and 90% of BApNAse activities in the salivary glands were inhibited by aprotinin, benzamidine, and PMSF, whereas only 46% azocaseinase and 60% BApNAse activities in the gut were suppressed by benzamidine, leupeptin, and TLCK. The pH optima for azocaseinase activity in salivary glands ranged from 6.2 to 10.6, whereas the pH optima for gut proteinases was acidic for general and alkaline for tryptic proteinases. Zymogram analysis demonstrated that approximately 26-kDa proteinases from salivary glands were active against both gelatin and casein substrates. Three trypsin-like cDNAs, LlSgP2-4, and one trypsin-like cDNA, L1GtP1, were cloned from salivary glands and gut, respectively. Putative trypsin precursors from all cloned cDNAs contained a signal peptide, activation peptide, and conserved N-termini (IVGG). Other structural features included His, Asp, and Ser residues for the catalytic amino acid triad of serine proteinase active sites, residues for the binding pocket, and four pairs of cysteine residues for disulfide bridges. Deduced trypsin-like proteins from LlSgP2, LlSgP3, and LlGtP1 cDNAs shared 98-99% sequence identity with a previously reported trypsin-like precursor, whereas the trypsin-like protein of LlSgP4 shared only 44% sequence identity with all other trypsin-like proteins, indicating multi-trypsin forms are present in L. lineolaris.     

Role of catalytic residues in the formation of a tetrahedral adduct in the acylation reaction of bovine β-trypsin: A molecular orbital study

In the acylation reaction of serine proteases the effect of amino acid residues on the geometrical change of the catalytic site from Michaelis to tetrahedral state was studied by using ab initio molecular orbital calculations. Amino acid residues in the catalytic site and the peptide substrate were calculated as a quantum mechanical region, and all the other amino acid residues and the calcium ion were included in the calculation as the electrostatic effects. The effects of Asp102, Asp194, N-terminus and the oxyanion binding site are large. The oxyanion binding site directly stabilizes the tetrahedral substrate. Asp102 stabilizes the enzyme intermediate, interacting with the protonated His57 residue. In order to elucidate the roles of Asp102 and the oxyanion binding site, energy decomposition analyses were done for the intermolecular interactions. The contribution of Asp102 and the oxyanion binding site to the decrease of energy in the geometrical change is due to the electrostatic effect. The energies of the proton shuttle from Ser195 O^γ to the leaving group of the substrate were calculated for amide and ester substrate models.     

How do serine proteases really work?

Recent advances in genetic engineering have led to a growing acceptance of the fact that enzymes work like other catalysts by reducing the activation barriers of the corresponding reactions. However, the key question about the action of enzymes is not related to the fact that they stabilize transition states but to the question to how they accomplish this task. This work considers the catalytic reaction of serine proteases and demonstrates how one can use a combination of calculations and experimental information to elucidate the key contributions to the catalytic free energy. Recent reports about genetic modifications of the buried aspartic group in serine proteases, which established the large effect of this group (but could not determine its origin), are analyzed. Two independent methods indicate that the buried aspartic group in serine proteases stabilizes the transition state by electrostatic interactions rather than by alternative mechanisms. Simple free energy considerations are used to eliminate the double proton-transfer mechanism (which is depicted in many textbooks as the key catalytic factor in serine proteases). The electrostatic stabilization of the oxyanion side of the transition state is also considered. It is argued that serine proteases and other enzymes work by providing electrostatic complementarity to the changes in charge distribution occurring during the reactions they catalyze.     

Unusual catalytic triad of Escherichia coli outer membrane phospholipase A

Escherichia coli outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) is an integral membrane enzyme. OMPLA is active as a homodimer and requires calcium as a cofactor. The crystal structures of the monomeric and the inhibited dimeric enzymes were recently determined [Snijder, H. J., et al. (1999) Nature 401, 717-721] and revealed that OMPLA monomers are folded into a 12-stranded antiparallel beta-barrel. The active site consists of previously identified essential residues Ser144 and His142 in an arrangement resembling the corresponding residues of a serine hydrolase catalytic triad. However, instead of an Asp or Glu that normally is present in the triad of serine hydrolases, a neutral asparagine (Asn156) was found in OMPLA. In this paper, the importance of the catalytic Asn156 is addressed by site-directed mutagenesis studies. All variants were purified at a 30 mg scale, and were shown to be properly folded using SDS-PAGE and circular dichroism spectroscopy. Using chemical cross-linking, it was shown that all variants were not affected in their calcium-dependent dimerization properties. The Asn156Asp variant exhibited a 2-fold lower activity than wild-type OMPLA at neutral pH. Interestingly, the activity of the variant is 1 order of magnitude higher than that of the wild type at pH >10. Modest residual activities (5 and 2.5%, respectively) were obtained for the Asn156Ala and Asn156Gln mutants, showing that the active site of OMPLA is more tolerant toward replacements of this third residue of the catalytic triad than other serine hydrolases, and that the serine and histidine residues are minimally required for catalysis. In the X-ray structure of dimeric OMPLA, the cofactor calcium is coordinating the putative oxyanion via two water molecules. We propose that this may lessen the importance for the asparagine in the catalytic triad of OMPLA.