Death commitment point is advanced by axotomy in sympathetic neurons

Axotomized neurons have several characteristics that are different from intact neurons. Here we show that, unlike established cultures, the axotomized sympathetic neurons deprived of NGF become committed to die before caspase activation, since the same proportion of NGF-deprived neurons are rescued by NGF regardless of whether caspases are inhibited by the pan-caspase inhibitor Boc-Asp(O-methyl)-CH(2)F (BAF). Despite prolonged Akt and ERK signaling induced by NGF after BAF treatment has prevented death, the neurons fail to increase protein synthesis, recover ATP levels, or grow. Within 3 d, all the mitochondria disappear without apparent removal of any other organelles or loss of membrane integrity. Although NGF does rescue intact BAF-treated 6-d cultures after NGF deprivation, rescue by NGF fails when these neurons are axotomized before NGF deprivation and BAF treatment. Moreover, cytosolic cytochrome c rapidly kills axotomized neurons. We propose that axotomy induces signals that make sympathetic neurons competent to die prematurely. NGF cannot repair these NGF-deprived, BAF-treated neurons because receptor signaling (which is normal) is uncoupled from protein renewal, and the mitochondria (which are damaged) go on to be eliminated. Hence, the order of steps underlying neuronal death commitment is mutable and open to regulation.     

Biochemical characterization of programmed cell death in NGF-deprived sympathetic neurons.

Young sympathetic neurons die when deprived of nerve growth factor (NGF). Under such circumstances, cell death is appropriate to the developing nervous system and requires RNA and protein synthesis. We have hypothesized the existence of an endogenous death program within neurons that is suppressed by trophic factors. The extent and timing of required changes in the synthetic events that comprise the death program are unknown. In an effort to characterize the biochemical events that mediate the death program further, we performed several experiments on embryonic rat sympathetic neurons in vitro. The death program was blocked with cycloheximide when total protein synthesis was inhibited > or = 80%. When protein synthesis was inhibited within 22 +/- 4 h of NGF deprivation, death was prevented in half the neurons. Hence, we define the commitment point for protein synthesis to be 22 +/- 4 h. Analogously, the commitment point for RNA synthesis was 26 +/- 4 h and that for NGF rescue, 24 +/- 4 h. We tested the ability of a wide variety of chemicals to interfere with the death program. Most compounds tested were unable to prevent neuronal death. Some treatments, however, did save NGF-deprived neurons and were subsequently characterized. These included ultraviolet light and agents that raise intracellular concentrations of cAMP. Finally, we looked for the neuronal expression in vitro and in vivo of genes that have been associated with programmed death in other cell types, including TRPM-2/SGP-2, polyubiquitin, TGF beta-1, c-fos, and c-myc. None of these genes showed significant activation associated with neuronal death.     

Caspase inhibition extends the commitment to neuronal death beyond cytochrome c release to the point of mitochondrial depolarization

Nerve growth factor (NGF) deprivation induces a Bax-dependent, caspase-dependent programmed cell death in sympathetic neurons. We examined whether the release of cytochrome c was accompanied by the loss of mitochondrial membrane potential during sympathetic neuronal death. NGF- deprived, caspase inhibitor-treated mouse sympathetic neurons maintained mitochondrial membrane potential for 25-30 h after releasing cytochrome c. NGF- deprived sympathetic neurons became committed to die, as measured by the inability of cells to be rescued by NGF readdition, at the time of cytochrome c release. In the presence of caspase inhibitor, however, this commitment to death was extended beyond the point of cytochrome c release, but only up to the subsequent point of mitochondrial membrane potential loss. Caspase-9 deficiency also arrested NGF-deprived sympathetic neurons after release of cytochrome c, and permitted these neurons to be rescued with NGF readdition. Commitment to death in the NGF-deprived, caspase- 9-deficient sympathetic neurons was also coincident with the loss of mitochondrial membrane potential. Thus, caspase inhibition extended commitment to death in trophic factor-deprived sympathetic neurons and allowed recovery of neurons arrested after the loss of cytochrome c, but not beyond the subsequent loss of mitochondrial membrane potential.     

GDNF-deprived sympathetic neurons die via a novel nonmitochondrial pathway

The mitochondrial death pathway is triggered in cultured sympathetic neurons by deprivation of nerve growth factor (NGF), but the death mechanisms activated by deprivation of other neurotrophic factors are poorly studied. We compared sympathetic neurons deprived of NGF to those deprived of glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF). In contrast to NGF-deprived neurons, GDNF-deprived neurons did not die via the mitochondrial pathway. Indeed, cytochrome c was not released to the cytosol; Bax and caspase-9 and -3 were not involved; overexpressed Bcl-xL did not block the death; and the mitochondrial ultrastructure was not changed. Similarly to NGF-deprived neurons, the death induced by GDNF removal is associated with increased autophagy and requires multiple lineage kinases, c-Jun and caspase-2 and -7. Serine 73 of c-Jun was phosphorylated in both NGF- and GDNF-deprived neurons, whereas serine 63 was phosphorylated only in NGF-deprived neurons. In many NGF-deprived neurons, the ultrastructure of the mitochondria was changed. Thus, a novel nonmitochondrial caspase-dependent death pathway is activated in GDNF-deprived sympathetic neurons.     

Biochemical characterization of programmed cell death in NGF-deprived sympathetic neurons

Young sympathetic neurons die when deprived of nerve growth factor (NGF). Under such circumstances, cell death is appropriate to the developing nervous system and requires RNA and protein synthesis. We have hypothesized the existence of an endogenous death program within neurons that is suppressed by trophic factors. The extent and timing of required changes in the synthetic events that comprise the death program are unknown. In an effort to characterize the biochemical events that mediate the death program further, we performed several experiments on embryonic rat sympathetic neurons in vitro. The death program was blocked with cycloheximide when total protein synthesis was inhibited ≥80%. When protein synthesis was inhibited within 22 ± 4 h of NGF deprivation, death was prevented in half the neurons. Hence, we define the commitment point for protein synthesis to be 22 ± 4 h. Analogously, the commitment point for RNA synthesis was 26 ± 4 h and that for NGF rescue, 24 ± 4 h. We tested the ability of a wide variety of chemicals to interfere with the death program. Most compounds tested were unable to prevent neuronal death. Some treatments, however, did save NGF-deprived neurons and were subsequently characterized. These included ultraviolet light and agents that raise intracellular concentrations of cAMP. Finally, we looked for the neuronal expression in vitro and in vivo of genes that have been associated with programmed death in other cell types, including TRPM-2/SGP-2, polyubiquitin, TGFβ-1, c-fos, and c-myc. None of these genes showed significant activation associated with neuronal death. © 1992 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Pituitary Adenylyl Cyclase-Activating Polypeptide and Nerve Growth Factor Use the Proteasome to Rescue Nerve Growth Factor-Deprived Sympathetic Neurons Cultured From Chick Embryos

Abstract: Removal of nerve growth factor (NGF) from sympathetic neurons initiates a neuronal death program and apoptosis. We show that pituitary adenylyl cyclase-activating polypeptide (PACAP) prevents apoptosis in NGF-deprived sympathetic neurons. PACAP (100 nM) added to culture medium at the time of plating failed to support neuronal survival. However, in neurons grown for 2 days with NGF and then deprived of NGF, PACAP prevented cell death for the next 24–48 h. Uptake of [³H]norepinephrine ([³H]NE) was used as an index of survival and decreased >50% in NGF-deprived cultures within 24 h. PACAP (1–100 nM) restored [³H]NE uptake to 92 ± 8% of that of NGF-supported controls. Depolarization-induced [³H]NE release in neurons rescued by PACAP was the same as that in NGF-supported neurons. PACAP rescue was not mimicked by forskolin or 8-bromo-cyclic AMP and was not blocked by the protein kinase A inhibitor Rp-adenosine 3′,5′-cyclic monophosphothioate. Mobilization of phosphatidylinositol by muscarine failed to support NGF-deprived neurons. Thus, PACAP may use novel signaling to promote survival of sympathetic neurons. The apoptosis-associated caspase CPP32 activity increased approximately fourfold during 6 h of NGF withdrawal (145 ± 40 versus 38 ± 17 nmol of substrate cleaved/min/mg of protein) and returned to even below the control level in NGF-deprived, PACAP-rescued cultures (14 ± 7 nmol/min/mg of protein). Readdition of NGF or PACAP to NGF-deprived cultures reversed CPP32 activation, and this was blocked by lactacystin, a potent and specific inhibitor of the 20S proteasome, suggesting that NGF and PACAP target CPP32 for destruction by the proteasome. As PACAP is a preganglionic neurotransmitter in autonomic ganglia, we propose a novel function for this transmitter as an apoptotic rescuer of sympathetic neurons when the supply of NGF is compromised.     

Expression of the SM-20 Gene Promotes Death in Nerve Growth Factor-Dependent Sympathetic Neurons

Sympathetic neurons undergo apoptosis when deprived of nerve growth factor (NGF). Inhibitors of RNA or protein synthesis block this death, suggesting that gene expression is important for apoptosis in this system. We have identified SM-20 as a new gene that increases in expression in sympathetic neurons after NGF withdrawal. Expression of SM-20 also increases during neuronal death caused by cytosine arabinoside or the phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase inhibitor LY294002. In addition, SM-20 protein synthesis is elevated in NGF-deprived neurons compared with neurons maintained with NGF. Importantly, expression of SM-20 in sympathetic neurons causes cell death in the presence of NGF. These results suggest that SM-20 may function to regulate cell death in neurons.     

Inhibition of protein synthesis prevents cell death in sensory and parasympathetic neurons deprived of neurotrophic factor in vitro

Shortly after neurons begin to innervate their targets in the developing vertebrate nervous system they become dependent on the supply of a neurotrophic factor, such as nerve growth factor (NGF) for survival. Recently, Martin et al. (1988) have shown that inhibiting protein synthesis prevents the death of NGF-deprived sympathetic neurons, suggesting that NGF promotes neuronal survival by suppressing an active cell death program. To determine if other neurotrophic factors may regulate neuronal survival by a similar mechanism we examined the effects of inhibiting protein and RNA synthesis in other populations of embryonic neurons that require different neurotrophic factors, namely: 1) trigeminal mesencephalic neurons, a population of proprioceptive neurons that are supported by brain-derived neurotrophic factor; 2) dorsomedial trigeminal ganglion neurons, a population of cutaneous sensory neurons that are supported by NGF; 3) and ciliary ganglion neurons, a population of parasympathetic neurons that are supported by ciliary neuronotrophic factor. Blocking either protein or RNA synthesis rescued all three populations of neurons from cell death induced by neurotrophic factor deprivation in vitro. Thus, at least three different neurotrophic factors appear to promote survival by a similar mechanism that may involve the suppression of an endogenous cell death program.     

Characterization of apoptosis in cultured rat sympathetic neurons after nerve growth factor withdrawal

Sympathetic neurons depend on nerve growth factor (NGF) for their survival both in vivo and in vitro. In culture, the neurons die after NGF withdrawal by an autonomous cell death program but whether these neurons die by apoptosis is under debate. Using vital DNA stains and in situ nick translation, we show here that extensive chromatin condensation and DNA fragmentation occur before plasma membrane breakdown during the death of NGF-deprived rat sympathetic neurons in culture. Furthermore, kinetic analysis of chromatin condensation events within the cell population is consistent with a model which postulates that after NGF deprivation nearly all of the neurons die in this manner. Although the dying neurons display membrane blebbing, cell fragmentation into apoptotic bodies does not occur. Apoptotic events proceed rapidly at around the time neurons become committed to die, regardless of neuronal culture age. However the duration of NGF deprivation required to commit neurons to die, and the rate at which apoptosis occurs, increase with culture age. Thus, within the first week of culture, apoptosis is the predominant form of cell death in sympathetic neurons.     

Temporal analysis of events associated with programmed cell death (apoptosis) of sympathetic neurons deprived of nerve growth factor

The time course of molecular events that accompany degeneration and death after nerve growth factor (NGF) deprivation and neuroprotection by NGF and other agents was examined in cultures of NGF-dependent neonatal rat sympathetic neurons and compared to death by apoptosis. Within 12 h after onset of NGF deprivation, glucose uptake, protein synthesis, and RNA synthesis fell precipitously followed by a moderate decrease of mitochondrial function. The molecular mechanisms underlying the NGF deprivation-induced decrease of protein synthesis and neuronal death were compared and found to be different, demonstrating that this decrease of protein synthesis is insufficient to cause death subsequently. After these early changes and during the onset of neuronal atrophy, inhibition of protein synthesis ceased to halt neuronal degeneration while readdition of NGF or a cAMP analogue remained neuroprotective for 6 h. This suggests a model in which a putative killer protein reaches lethal levels several hours before the neurons cease to respond to readdition of NGF with survival and become committed to die. Preceding loss of viability by 5 h and concurrent with commitment to die, the neuronal DNA fragmented into oligonucleosomes. The temporal and pharmacological characteristics of DNA fragmentation is consistent with DNA fragmentation being part of the mechanism that commits the neuron to die. The antimitotic and neurotoxin cytosine arabinoside induced DNA fragmentation in the presence of NGF, supporting previous evidence that it mimicked NGF deprivation-induced death closely. Thus trophic factor deprivation- induced death occurs by apoptosis and is an example of programmed cell death.     

Ceramide selectively inhibits apoptosis-associated events in NGF-deprived sympathetic neurons

Ceramide manifests both neurotoxic and neuroprotective properties depending on the experimental system. Ito and Horigome previously reported that ceramide delays apoptosis in a classic model of developmental programmed cell death, i.e. sympathetic neurons undergoing NGF deprivation.1 Here, we investigated the actions of ceramide upon the biochemical and genetic changes that occur in NGF deprived neurons. We correlate ceramide's neuroprotective actions with the ability of ceramide to antagonize NGF deprivation-induced oxidative stress and c-jun induction, both of which contribute to apoptosis in this model. However, ceramide did not block NGF deprivation-induced declines in RNA and protein synthesis, suggesting that ceramide does not slow all apoptosis-related events. Overall, these results are significant in that they show that ceramide acts early in the death cascade to antagonize two events necessary for NGF-deprivation induced neuronal apoptosis. Moreover, these results dissociate declines in neuronal function, i.e. macromolecular synthesis, from the neuronal death cascade.     

Staurosporine-induced neuronal death: multiple mechanisms and methodological implications

To examine whether multiple pathways of cell death exist in sympathetic neurons, we studied the cell death pathway induced by staurosporine (STS) in sympathetic neurons and compared it with the well-characterized NGF deprivation-induced death pathway. Increasing concentrations of STS were found to induce sympathetic neuronal death with different biochemical and morphological characteristics. One hundred nM STS induced metabolic changes, loss of cytochrome c, and caspase-dependent morphological degeneration which closely resembled the apoptotic death induced by NGF deprivation. In contrast, sympathetic neurons treated with 1 microM STS showed no loss of cytochrome c but exhibited extensive, caspase-independent, chromatin changes that were not TUNEL positive. One microM STS-treated sympathetic neurons had greatly reduced metabolic activities and became committed to die rapidly, yet maintained soma structure and appeared viable by other criteria even up to 48 h after STS treatment, illustrating the need to assess cell death by multiple criteria. Lastly, in contrast to the cell death-inducing activities of 100 nM STS or 1 microM STS, very low concentrations of STS (1 nM STS) inhibited sympathetic neuronal death by acting either at or prior to c-jun phosphorylation in the NGF deprivation-induced PCD pathway.     

Viral proteins E1B19K and p35 protect sympathetic neurons from cell death induced by NGF deprivation

To study molecular mechanisms underlying neuronal cell death, we have used sympathetic neurons from superior cervical ganglia which undergo programmed cell death when deprived of nerve growth factor. These neurons have been microinjected with expression vectors containing cDNAs encoding selected proteins to test their regulatory influence over cell death. Using this procedure, we have shown previously that sympathetic neurons can be protected from NGF deprivation by the protooncogene Bcl-2. We now report that the E1B19K protein from adenovirus and the p35 protein from baculovirus also rescue neurons. Other adenoviral proteins, E1A and E1B55K, have no effect on neuronal survival. E1B55K, known to block apoptosis mediated by p53 in proliferative cells, failed to rescue sympathetic neurons suggesting that p53 is not involved in neuronal death induced by NGF deprivation. E1B19K and p35 were also coinjected with Bcl-Xs which blocks Bcl-2 function in lymphoid cells. Although Bcl-Xs blocked the ability of Bcl- 2 to rescue neurons, it had no effect on survival that was dependent upon expression of E1B19K or p35.     

Proliferative inhibition by dominant-negative Ras rescues naive and neuronally differentiated PC12 cells from apoptotic death.

We have used the nerve growth factor (NGF)-responsive PC12 cell line as a model to examine the role of cell cycle progression in apoptotic neuronal cell death triggered by withdrawal of trophic support. Because p21 Ras plays a key role in mitogenic signaling, we tested whether interference with the activity of this protein would affect cell cycle progression and thereby apoptotic death after trophic factor deprivation. For this purpose, we exploited PC12 cells transfected with an inducible form of dominant-inhibitory Ras. In contrast to non-transfected and uninduced cells, which continue to synthesize DNA when deprived of trophic support, PC12 cells induced to express dominant-inhibitory Ras showed little thymidine incorporation. When non-transfected and uninduced cells were deprived of trophic support, these underwent rapid apoptotic death that could be prevented by NGF. However, cells in which dominant-inhibitory Ras was induced and which were consequently quiescent did not die upon withdrawal of trophic support and showed long-term survival in the absence of NGF or other trophic factors. Moreover, induction of dominant-inhibitory Ras also rescued non-dividing, neuronally differentiated PC12 cells from death caused by NGF withdrawal. These findings suggest a relationship between proliferative capacity and neuronal apoptosis and raise the hypothesis that following withdrawal of trophic support, neurons undergo an unsuccessful and fatal attempt to re-enter the cell cycle.     

The Ability of Diphenylpiperazines to Prevent Neuronal Death in Dorsal Root Ganglion Neurons In Vitro After Nerve Growth Factor Deprivation and In Vivo After Axotomy

Abstract: The mechanism of neuroprotection by the calcium channel antagonist flunarizine against neuronal death is unknown. We investigated the ability of other calcium channel antagonists (cinnarizine, nimodipine, nicardipine, diltiazem, and verapamil), calmodulin antagonists, and calpain inhibitors to prevent neuronal death in rat dorsal root ganglion neurons in vitro after nerve growth factor (NGF) deprivation and the ability of cinnarizine and diltiazem to protect in vivo after axotomy. In vitro, only neurons treated with cinnarizine or flunarizine were protected from death after withdrawal. In vivo, cinnarizine, but not diltiazem, protected dorsal root ganglion neurons in rats after unilateral sciatic nerve crush. Intracellular calcium concentration ([Ca²⁺],) was evaluated with fura 2 after NGF deprivation In vitro. Neurons "committed to die" 24 h after NGF deprivation displayed a decline in [Ca^a+], before visible morphological deterioration consistent with cell death. The influx of extracellular calcium was not necessary to produce neuronal death. Neurons deprived of NGF gradually lost the ability to respond to elevated external potassium with an increase in [Ca²⁺], during the first 24 h after trophic factor deprivation. After 24 h, neurons deprived of NGF could not be rescued by readministration of NGF. Neurons protected from cell death with diphenylpiperazines maintained their response to high external potassium, suggesting continued membrane integrity. We speculate that diphenylpiperazines may protect sensory neurons via an unknown mechanism that stabilizes cell membranes.     

Interferon Suppresses Sympathetic Neuronal Cell Death Caused by Nerve Growth Factor Deprivation

Cultured rat sympathetic neurons die within 48 h after being deprived of nerve growth factor. Addition of interferons (IFN-alpha/beta or IFN-gamma) prevented the cell death in a dose-dependent manner. Upon longer periods of nerve growth factor deprivation, IFNs failed to maintain survival. Thus, IFNs retarded neuronal death, but did not prevent it. Ligand binding, autoradiography, and cross-linking experiments demonstrated the presence of specific IFN-gamma receptors on sympathetic neurons similar to those seen on other cell types. The possible relationships of the death-suppressing actions of IFNs are compared to the mechanisms of the antiviral or antiproliferative actions of IFNs.     

SM-20 is a novel mitochondrial protein that causes caspase-dependent cell death in nerve growth factor-dependent neurons

Sympathetic neurons undergo protein synthesis-dependent apoptosis when deprived of nerve growth factor (NGF). Expression of SM-20 is up-regulated in NGF-deprived sympathetic neurons, and ectopic SM-20 is sufficient to promote neuronal death in the presence of NGF. We now report that SM-20 is a mitochondrial protein that promotes cell death through a caspase-dependent mechanism. SM-20 immunofluorescence was present in the cytoplasm in a punctate pattern that colocalized with cytochrome oxidase I and with mitochondria-selective dyes. Analysis of SM-20/dihydrofolate reductase fusion proteins revealed that the first 25 amino acids of SM-20 contain a functional mitochondrial targeting sequence. An amino-terminal truncated form of SM-20 was not restricted to mitochondria but instead localized throughout the cytosol and nucleus. Nevertheless, the truncated SM-20 retained the ability to induce neuronal death, similar to the wild type protein. SM-20-induced death was accompanied by caspase-3 activation and was blocked by a general caspase inhibitor. Additionally, overexpression of SM-20, under conditions where cell death is blocked by a general caspase inhibitor, did not result in widespread release of cytochrome c from mitochondria. These results indicate that SM-20 is a novel mitochondrial protein that may be an important mediator of neurotrophin-withdrawal-mediated cell death.     

Genetic and metabolic status of NGF-deprived sympathetic neurons saved by an inhibitor of ICE family proteases

Sympathetic neurons undergo programmed cell death (PCD) when deprived of NGF. We used an inhibitor to examine the function of interleukin-1 beta-converting enzyme (ICE) family proteases during sympathetic neuronal death and to assess the metabolic and genetic status of neurons saved by such inhibition. Bocaspartyl(OMe)-fluoromethylketone (BAF), a cell-permeable inhibitor of the ICE family of cysteine proteases, inhibited ICE and CPP32 (IC50 approximately 4 microM) in vitro and blocked Fas-mediated apoptosis in thymocytes (EC50 approximately 10 microM). At similar concentrations, BAF also blocked the NGF deprivation-induced death of rat sympathetic neurons in culture. Compared to NGF-maintained neurons, BAF-saved neurons had markedly smaller somas and maintained only basal levels of protein synthesis; readdition of NGF restored growth and metabolism. Although BAF blocked apoptosis in sympathetic neurons, it did not prevent the fall in protein synthesis or the increase in the expression of c-jun, c- fos, and other mRNAs that occur during neuronal PCD, implying that the ICE-family proteases function downstream of these events during PCD.NGF and BAF rescued sympathetic neurons with an identical time course, suggesting that NGF, in addition to inhibiting metabolic and genetic events associated with neuronal PCD, can act posttranslationally to abort apoptosis at a time point indistinguishable from the activation of cysteine proteases. Both poly-(ADP ribose) polymerase and pro-ICE and Ced-3 homolog-1 (ICH-1) appear to be cleaved in a BAF-inhibitable manner, although the majority of pro-CPP32 appears unchanged, suggesting that ICH-1 is activated during neuronal PCD. Potential implications of these findings for anti-apoptotic therapies are discussed.     

The Death Programme in Cultured Sympathetic Neurones Can Be Suppressed at the Posttranslational Level by Nerve Growth Factor, Cyclic AMP, and Depolarization

We have examined whether sympathetic neurones that have lost the potential to be rescued by protein and RNA synthesis inhibitors after a period of nerve growth factor (NGF) deprivation are irreversibly committed to die. We found that 15 h after withdrawal of NGF from 7-day cultures of neonatal rat superior cervical ganglion neurones, 50% of the neurones lost the potential to be rescued by cycloheximide but that NGF rescued most of the neurones. By 22 h after NGF withdrawal, only 10% of the neurones were rescued by inhibition of macromolecular synthesis with cycloheximide, puromycin, or actinomycin D, but as many as 60-80% of the neurones were rescued by NGF. This is after the time at which a DNA "ladder," consistent with cell death by apoptosis, was first detected (18 h). As long as 27 h of NGF withdrawal was required before 50% of the neurones lost the potential to be rescued by NGF. The survival-promoting agent 8-(4-chlorophenylthio)cyclic AMP (CPTcAMP) or depolarization with 50 mM KCl (HK) rescued neurones with kinetics similar to those of NGF, and rescue by all three agents did not require protein synthesis. Thus, NGF, CPTcAMP, and HK can rescue neurones deprived of NGF at much later times than either protein or RNA synthesis inhibitors by acting at the posttranslational level, a finding suggesting that initiation of the cell death programme in sympathetic neurones is not an irreversible step.