Modeling industrial centrifugation of mammalian cell culture using a capillary based scale-down system

Continuous-flow centrifugation is widely utilized as the primary clarification step in the recovery of biopharmaceuticals from cell culture. However, it is a challenging operation to develop and characterize due to the lack of easy to use, small-scale, systems that can be used to model industrial processes. As a result, pilot-scale continuous centrifugation is typically employed to model large-scale systems requiring a significant amount of resources. In an effort to reduce resource requirements and create a system which is easy to construct and utilize, a capillary shear device, capable of producing energy dissipation rates equivalent to those present in the feed zones of industrial disk stack centrifuges, was developed and evaluated. When coupled to a bench-top, batch centrifuge, the capillary device reduced centrate turbidity prediction error from 37% to 4% compared to using a bench-top centrifuge alone. Laboratory-scale parameters that are analogous to those routinely varied during industrial-scale continuous centrifugation were identified and evaluated for their utility in emulating disk stack centrifuge performance. The resulting relationships enable bench-scale process modeling of continuous disk stack centrifuges using an easily constructed, scalable, capillary shear device coupled to a typical bench-top centrifuge.     

The effect of antiapoptosis genes on clarification performance

Optimal bioreactor harvest time is typically determined based on maximizing product titer without compromising product quality. We suggest that ease of downstream purification should also be considered during harvest. In this view, we studied the effect of antiapoptosis genes on downstream performance. Our hypothesis was that more robust cells would exhibit less cell lysis and thus generate lower levels of cell debris and host‐cell contaminants. We focused on the clarification unit operation, measuring postclarification turbidity and host‐cell protein (HCP) concentration as a function of bioreactor harvest time/cell viability. In order to mimic primary clarification using disk‐stack centrifugation, a scale‐down model consisting of a rotating disk (to simulate shear in the inlet feed zone of the centrifuge) and a swinging‐bucket lab centrifuge was used. Our data suggest that in the absence of shear during primary clarification (typical of depth filters), a 20–50% reduction in HCP levels and 50–65% lower postcentrifugation turbidity was observed for cells with antiapoptosis genes compared to control cells. However, on exposing the cells to shear levels typical in a disk‐stack centrifuge, the reduction in HCP was 10–15% while no difference in postcentrifugation turbidity was observed. The maximum benefit of antiapoptosis genes is, therefore, realized using clarification options that involve low shear, <1 × 10⁶ W/m³ and minimal damage to the cells. © 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 30:100–107, 2014     

The use of laboratory centrifugation studies to predict performance of industrial machines: studies of shear-insensitive and shear-sensitive materials

A method for using a bench-top centrifuge is described in order to mimic the recovery performance of an industrial-scale centrifuge, in this case a continuous-flow disc stack separator. Recovery performance was determined for polyvinyl acetate particles and for biological process streams of yeast cell debris and protein precipitates. Recovery of polyvinyl acetate particles was found to be well predicted for these robust particles. The laboratory centrifugation scale-down technique again predicted the performance of the disc stack centrifuge for the recovery of yeast cell debris particles although there was some suggestion of over-prediction at high levels of debris recovery due to the nature of any cell debris aggregates present. The laboratory centrifuge scale-down technique also proved to be an important investigative probe into the extent of shear-induced breakup of shear-sensitive protein precipitate aggregates during recovery in continuous high speed centrifuges. Such breakup can lead to over 10-fold reduction in separator capacity.     

Assessment of a disc stack centrifuge for use in mammalian cell separation

A prototype disc stack centrifuge was tested for the separation of mammalian cell cultures from 80- and 2000-L fermentations. The clarification capacity for mammalian cells was excellent, but some smaller particles remained in the supernatant and reduced its usefulness for downstream processing. In order to identify the source of such particle formation, several parameters were assessed and minimum particle size for separation was calculated. An analysis of particle distribution was performed. Temperature and pressure effects inside the centrifuge bowl were measured. Some modifications of mechanical engineering can be suggested for the improvement of the use of standard disc stack centrifuges for mammalian cells. (c) 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Adapted ultra scale-down approach for predicting the centrifugal separation behavior of high cell density cultures

The work presented here describes an ultra scale-down (USD) methodology for predicting centrifugal clarification performance in the case of high cell density fermentation broths. Existing USD approaches generated for dilute systems led to a 5- to 10-fold overprediction of clarification performance when applied to such high cell density feeds. This is due to increased interparticle forces, leading to effects such as aggregation, flocculation, or even blanket sedimentation, occurring in the low shear environment of a laboratory centrifuge, which will not be apparent in the settling region of a continuous-flow industrial centrifuge. A USD methodology was created based upon the dilution of high solids feed material to approximately 2% wet wt/vol prior to the application of the clarification test. At this level of dilution cell-cell interactions are minimal. The dilution alters the level of hindered settling in the feed suspensions, and so mathematical corrections are applied to the resultant clarification curves to mimic the original feed accurately. The methodology was successfully verified: corrected USD curves accurately predicted pilot-scale clarification performance of high cell density broths of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Escherichia coli cells. The USD method allows for the rapid prediction of large-scale clarification of high solids density material using millilitre quantities of feed. The advantages of this method to the biochemical engineer, such as the enabling of rapid process design and scale-up, are discussed.     

Performance prediction of industrial centrifuges using scale-down models

Computational fluid dynamics was used to model the high flow forces found in the feed zone of a multichamber-bowl centrifuge and reproduce these in a small, high-speed rotating disc device. Linking the device to scale-down centrifugation, permitted good estimation of the performance of various continuous-flow centrifuges (disc stack, multichamber bowl, CARR Powerfuge) for shear-sensitive protein precipitates. Critically, the ultra scale-down centrifugation process proved to be a much more accurate predictor of production multichamber-bowl performance than was the pilot centrifuge.     

Prediction and verification of centrifugal dewatering of P. pastoris fermentation cultures using an ultra scale-down approach

Recent years have seen a dramatic rise in fermentation broth cell densities and a shift to extracellular product expression in microbial cells. As a result, dewatering characteristics during cell separation is of importance, as any liquor trapped in the sediment results in loss of product, and thus a decrease in product recovery. In this study, an ultra scale-down (USD) approach was developed to enable the rapid assessment of dewatering performance of pilot-scale centrifuges with intermittent solids discharge. The results were then verified at scale for two types of pilot-scale centrifuges: a tubular bowl equipment and a disk-stack centrifuge. Initial experiments showed that employing a laboratory-scale centrifugal mimic based on using a comparable feed concentration to that of the pilot-scale centrifuge, does not successfully predict the dewatering performance at scale (P-value <0.05). However, successful prediction of dewatering levels was achieved using the USD method (P-value ≥0.05), based on using a feed concentration at small-scale that mimicked the same height of solids as that in the pilot-scale centrifuge. Initial experiments used Baker's yeast feed suspensions followed by fresh Pichia pastoris fermentation cultures. This work presents a simple and novel USD approach to predict dewatering levels in two types of pilot-scale centrifuges using small quantities of feedstock (<50 mL). It is a useful tool to determine optimal conditions under which the pilot-scale centrifuge needs to be operated, reducing the need for repeated pilot-scale runs during early stages of process development.     

An automated laboratory‐scale methodology for the generation of sheared mammalian cell culture samples

Continuous disk‐stack centrifugation is typically used for the removal of cells and cellular debris from mammalian cell culture broths at manufacturing‐scale. The use of scale‐down methods to characterise disk‐stack centrifugation performance enables substantial reductions in material requirements and allows a much wider design space to be tested than is currently possible at pilot‐scale. The process of scaling down centrifugation has historically been challenging due to the difficulties in mimicking the Energy Dissipation Rates (EDRs) in typical machines. This paper describes an alternative and easy‐to‐assemble automated capillary‐based methodology to generate levels of EDRs consistent with those found in a continuous disk‐stack centrifuge. Variations in EDR were achieved through changes in capillary internal diameter and the flow rate of operation through the capillary. The EDRs found to match the levels of shear in the feed zone of a pilot‐scale centrifuge using the experimental method developed in this paper (2.4×10⁵ W/Kg) are consistent with those obtained through previously published computational fluid dynamic (CFD) studies (2.0×10⁵ W/Kg). Furthermore, this methodology can be incorporated into existing scale‐down methods to model the process performance of continuous disk‐stack centrifuges. This was demonstrated through the characterisation of culture hold time, culture temperature and EDRs on centrate quality.     

Ultra scale‐down prediction using microwell technology of the industrial scale clarification characteristics by centrifugation of mammalian cell broths

This article describes how a combination of an ultra scale‐down (USD) shear device feeding a microwell centrifugation plate may be used to provide a prediction of how mammalian cell broth will clarify at scale. In particular a method is described that is inherently adaptable to a robotic platform and may be used to predict how the flow rate and capacity (equivalent settling area) of a centrifuge and the choice of feed zone configuration may affect the solids carry over in the supernatant. This is an important consideration as the extent of solids carry over will determine the required size and lifetime of a subsequent filtration stage or the passage of fine particulates and colloidal material affecting the performance and lifetime of chromatography stages. The extent of solids removal observed in individual wells of a microwell plate during centrifugation is shown to correlate with the vertical and horizontal location of the well on the plate. Geometric adjustments to the evaluation of the equivalent settling area of individual wells (Σ_M) results in an improved prediction of solids removal as a function of centrifuge capacity. The USD centrifuge settling characteristics need to be as for a range of equivalent flow rates as may be experienced at an industrial scale for a machine of different shear characteristics in the entry feed zone. This was shown to be achievable with two microwell‐plate based measurements and the use of varying fill volumes in the microwells to allow the rapid study of a fivefold range of equivalent flow rates (i.e., at full scale for a particular industrial centrifuge) and the effect of a range of feed configurations. The microwell based USD method was used to examine the recovery of CHO‐S cells, prepared in a 5 L reactor, at different points of growth and for different levels of exposure to shear post reactor. The combination of particle size distribution measurements of the cells before and after shear and the effect of shear on the solids remaining after centrifugation rate provide insight into the state of the cells throughout the fermentation and the ease with which they and accumulated debris may be removed by continuous centrifugation. Hence bioprocess data are more readily available to help better integrate cell culture and cell removal stages and resolve key bioprocess design issues such as choice of time of harvesting and the impact on product yield and contaminant carry over. Operation at microwell scale allows data acquisition and bioprocess understanding over a wide range of operating conditions that might not normally be achieved during bioprocess development. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2009; 104: 321–331 © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Prediction of shear damage of plasmid DNA in pump and centrifuge operations using an ultra scale-down device

Supercoiled circular (SC) plasmid DNA is often subjected to fluid stress in large-scale manufacturing processes. It is thus important to characterize the engineering environment within a particular unit operation as well as within the associated ancillary equipment during process design for plasmid DNA manufacture so as to avoid shear-induced degradation of the SC isoform, which would compromise product efficacy in therapeutic applications. In the past few years, ultra scale-down (USD) tools were developed within our laboratory to mimic the engineering environments experienced by biomolecules within a range of manufacturing-scale ancillary, primary recovery, and purification operations, using milliliter quantities of material. Through the use of a USD shear device, the effect of elongational strain rate on SC plasmid DNA degradation was studied in this paper, and from that, the impact of a centrifugal pump, a Mono pump, and a disk-stack centrifuge feed zone on SC plasmid DNA degradation was predicted and experimentally verified at scale. Model predictions, over the range of conditions studied, were in good agreement with experimental values, demonstrating the potential of the USD approach as a decisional tool during bioprocess design.     

A methodology for centrifuge selection for the separation of high solids density cell broths by visualisation of performance using windows of operation

Expression systems capable of growing to high cell densities are now readily available and are popular due to the benefits of increased product concentration. However, such high solids density cultures pose a major challenge for bioprocess engineers as choosing the right separation equipment and operating it at optimal conditions is crucial for efficient recovery. This study proposes a methodology for the rapid determination of suitable operating conditions for the centrifugal recovery of high cell density fermentation broths. An ultra scale-down (USD) approach for the prediction of clarification and dewatering levels achieved in a range of typical high-speed centrifuges is presented. Together with a visualisation tool, a Window of Operation, this provides for the rapid analysis of separation performance and evaluation of the available operating conditions, as an aid in the selection of the centrifuge equipment most appropriate for a given process duty. A case study examining centrifuge selection for the processing of a high cell density Pichia pastoris culture demonstrates the method. The study examines semi-continuous disc-stack centrifuges and batch-operated machines such as multi-chamber bowls and Carr Powerfuges. Performance is assessed based on the variables of clarification, dewatering and product yield. Inclusion of limits imposed by the centrifuge type and design, and operation itself, serve to constrain the process and to define the Windows of Operation. The insight gained from the case study provides a useful indication of the utility of the methodology presented and illustrates the challenges of centrifuge selection for the demanding case of high solids concentration feed streams.     

Clarification of recombinant proteins from high cell density mammalian cell culture systems using new improved depth filters

Increasingly high cell density, high product titer cell cultures containing mammalian cells are being used for the production of recombinant proteins. These high productivity cultures are placing a larger burden on traditional downstream clarification and purification operations due to higher product and impurity levels. Controlled flocculation and precipitation of mammalian cell culture suspensions by acidification or using polymeric flocculants have been employed to enhance clarification throughput and downstream filtration operations. While flocculation is quite effective in agglomerating cell debris and process related impurities such as (host cell) proteins and DNA, the resulting suspension is generally not easily separable solely using conventional depth filtration techniques. As a result, centrifugation is often used for clarification of cells and cell debris before filtration, which can limit process configurations and flexibility due to the investment and fixed nature of a centrifuge. To address this challenge, novel depth filter designs were designed which results in improved primary and secondary direct depth filtration of flocculated high cell density mammalian cell cultures systems feeds, thereby providing single‐use clarification solution. A framework is presented here for optimizing the particle size distribution of the mammalian cell culture systems with the pore size distribution of the gradient depth filter using various pre‐treatment conditions resulting in increased depth filter media utilization and improved clarification capacity. Feed conditions were optimized either by acidification or by polymer flocculation which resulted in the increased average feed particle‐size and improvements in throughput with improved depth filters for several mammalian systems. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2013; 110: 1964–1972. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Ultra scale‐down approaches for clarification of mammalian cell culture broths in disc‐stack centrifuges

Ultra‐scale down (USD) methodology developed by University College London for cell broth clarification with industrial centrifuges was applied to two common cell lines (NS0 and GS‐CHO) expressing various therapeutic monoclonal antibodies. A number of centrifuges at various scales were used with shear devices operating either by high speed rotation or flow‐through narrow channels. The USD methodology was found effective in accounting for both gravitational and shear effects on clarification performance with three continuous centrifuges at pilot and manufacturing scales. Different shear responses were observed with the two different cell lines and even with the same cell line expressing different products. Separate particle size analysis of the treated broths seems consistent with the shear results. Filterability of the centrifuged solutions was also evaluated to assess the utility of the USD approach for this part of the clarification operation. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2009     

Lysis-free separation of hybridoma cells by continuous disc stack centrifugation

The non-destructive removal of hybridoma cells from fermentation broth with an improved disc stack centrifuge (CSA1, Westfalia Separator AG, Oelde, Germany) was investigated. The centrifuge was equipped with a hydrohermetic feed system, which allowed a gentle, shearless acceleration of the cells inside the bowl. No significant cell damage was observed during the separation of hybridoma cells from repeated batch fermentation in 100 liter scale. In the clarified liquid phase there was no increase in Lactate-Dehydrogenase (LDH) activity. Consequently, there was no increased exposure of the product to intracellular components.Due to continuous operation with a periodic and automatic discharge of sediment, a high throughput was achieved without any considerable loss of product. The clarification for mammalian cells was in the range of 99% to 99.9%, depending on the operating conditions. The content of cell debris and other small particles decreased about 30 to 50%, depending on the particle load in the feed stream. The centrifuge was fully contained; cleaning and sterilizing in place possible. Therefore, the decice could be integrated easily into the fermentation process.     

The biocontainment of a high speed disc bowl centrifuge

The containment of a high speed disc bowl centrifuge during normal operation has been examined using a mutant E. coli strain and a range of sampling devices to monitor the release of viable organisms. A discharge of a small amount of supernatant was used to provide a mimic of a release of a low number of organisms with a view to testing the sensitivity of the sampling systems used. Three sampling devices were used: settle plates, a slit sampler and an air filter sampler. These were all shown to be effective in the collection of viable organisms during the release under low pressure of 10 ml of supernatant (equivalent microbial count to 0.02 ml fermentation broth). Three runs carried out under normal operation of the centrifuge showed no release of viable organisms. The prevention of a second source of release during disassembly and cleaning of the bowl was demonstrated to be possible by the ability to clean and steam sterilize in place. The consequences of such operations are discussed in terms of the use of high speed disc bowl centrifuges for the processing of organisms under various levels of containment.     

The performance of a scaled down industrial disc stack centrifuge with a reduced feed material requirement

A method is described for the scale-down of a disc stack centrifuge which reduces the number of separating discs and also the liquid and solid hold-up of the centrifuge bowl. This is to enable a reduced volume of process material to be used for study of clarification. Scale-down is achieved in stages using a series of interlocking inserts to suit particular applications. Maximum scale-down gives a 76% reduction in the separation area and a bowl volume reduction of 70%. Separation performance of the full stack machine and scale-down variants is compared using the grade efficiency concept. Polyvinyl acetate and bakers' yeast homogenate particle suspensions are used for the comparison. The grade efficiency curves produced by the scale-down variants closely follow the curves for the full stack machine. This resulted in supernatants of the same volume size distribution and concentration when using scale-down methodology to mimic the full scale operation.

     

An ultra scale‐down characterization of low shear stress primary recovery stages to enhance selectivity of fusion protein recovery from its molecular variants

Fusion proteins offer the prospect of new therapeutic products with multiple functions. The primary recovery is investigated of a fusion protein consisting of modified E2 protein from hepatitis C virus fused to human IgG1 Fc and expressed in a Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell line. Fusion protein products inevitably pose increased challenge in preparation and purification. Of particular concerns are: (i) the impact of shear stress on product integrity and (ii) the presence of product‐related contaminants which could prove challenging to remove during the high resolution purification steps. This paper addresses the use of microwell‐based ultra scale‐down (USD) methods to develop a bioprocess strategy focused on the integration of cell culture and cell removal operations and where the focus is on the use of operations which impart low shear stress levels even when applied at eventual manufacturing scale. An USD shear device was used to demonstrate that cells exposed to high process stresses such as those that occur in the feed zone of a continuous non‐hermetic centrifuge resulted in the reduction of the fusion protein and also the release of glycosylated intracellular variants. In addition, extended cell culture resulted in release of such variants. USD mimics of low shear stress, hydrohermetic feed zone centrifugation and of depth filtration were used to demonstrate little to no release during recovery of these variants with both results verified at pilot scale. Furthermore, the USD studies were used to predict removal of contaminants such as lipids, nucleic acids, and cell debris with, for example, depth filtration delivering greater removal than for centrifugation but a small (～10%) decrease in yield of the fusion protein. These USD observations of product recovery and carryover of contaminants were also confirmed at pilot scale as was also the capacity or throughput achievable for continuous centrifugation or for depth filtration. The advantages are discussed of operating a lower yield cell culture and a low shear stress recovery process in return for a considerably less challenging purification demand. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2013; 110: 1973–1983. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

A comparison of two centrifuge techniques for constructing vulnerability curves: insight into the ‘open‐vessel’ artifact

A vulnerability curve (VC) describes the extent of xylem cavitation resistance. Centrifuges have been used to generate VCs for decades via static‐ and flow‐centrifuge methods. Recently, the validity of the centrifuge techniques has been questioned. Researchers have hypothesized that the centrifuge techniques might yield unreliable VCs due to the open‐vessel artifact. However, other researchers reject this hypothesis. The focus of the dispute is centered on whether exponential VCs are more reliable when the static‐centrifuge method is used rather than the flow‐centrifuge method. To further test the reliability of the centrifuge technique, two centrifuges were manufactured to simulate the static‐ and flow‐centrifuge methods. VCs of three species with open vessels of known lengths were constructed using the two centrifuges. The results showed that both centrifuge techniques produced invalid VCs for Robinia because the water flow through stems under mild tension in centrifuges led to an increasing loss of water conductivity. In addition, the injection of water in the flow‐centrifuge exacerbated the loss of water conductivity. However, both centrifuge techniques yielded reliable VCs for Prunus, regardless of the presence of open vessels in the tested samples. We conclude that centrifuge techniques can be used in species with open vessels only when the centrifuge produces a VC that matches the bench‐dehydration VC.     

Effects of solution environment on mammalian cell fermentation broth properties: Enhanced impurity removal and clarification performance

The processing of recombinant proteins from high cell density, high product titer cell cultures containing mammalian cells is commonly performed using tangential flow microfiltration (MF). However, the increased cellular debris present in these complex feed streams can prematurely foul the membrane, adversely impacting MF capacity and throughput. In addition, high cell density cell culture streams introduce elevated levels of process‐related impurities, which increase the burden on subsequent purification operations to remove these complex media components and impurities. To address this challenge, an evaluation of mammalian cell culture broth buffer properties was examined to determine if enhanced impurity removal and clarification performance could be achieved. A framework is presented here for establishing optimized mammalian cell culture buffer conditions, involving trade‐offs between product recovery and purification and improved clarification at manufacturing‐scale production. A reduction in cell culture broth pH to 4.7–5.0 induced flocculation and impurity precipitation which increased the average feed particle‐size. These conditions led to enhanced impurity removal and improved MF throughput and filter capacity for several mammalian systems. Feed conditions were further optimized by controlling ionic composition along with pH to improve product recovery from high cell density/high product titer cell cultures. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2011; 108:50–58. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

A scale‐down mimic for mapping the process performance of centrifugation,depth and sterile filtration

In the production of biopharmaceuticals disk‐stack centrifugation is widely used as a harvest step for the removal of cells and cellular debris. Depth filters followed by sterile filters are often then employed to remove residual solids remaining in the centrate. Process development of centrifugation is usually conducted at pilot‐scale so as to mimic the commercial scale equipment but this method requires large quantities of cell culture and significant levels of effort for successful characterization. A scale‐down approach based upon the use of a shear device and a bench‐top centrifuge has been extended in this work towards a preparative methodology that successfully predicts the performance of the continuous centrifuge and polishing filters. The use of this methodology allows the effects of cell culture conditions and large‐scale centrifugal process parameters on subsequent filtration performance to be assessed at an early stage of process development where material availability is limited. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2016;113: 1934–1941. © 2016 The Authors. Biotechnology and Bioengineering Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.