Distinct immunologic specificity of tumor regression mediated by effector cells isolated from immunized and tumor-bearing mice

Sensitized T lymphocytes can mediate potent antitumor effects when transferred to tumor-bearing animals. Employing the MCA 105 and MCA 106 sarcomas, we were able to generate antitumor effector cells by immunization of syngeneic mice with tumor cells admixed with Corynebacterium parvum. These immune splenocytes could be further sensitized and expanded in culture by the in vitro sensitization (IVS) method utilizing tumor stimulator cells and IL-2. Adoptive immunotherapy of pulmonary metastases mediated by noncultured splenocytes from immunized mice or immune IVS cells showed exquisite specificity between the two sarcomas. These results demonstrate the presence of tumor-specific antigens on MCA 105 and MCA 106 tumor cells which can serve as target molecules for immunotherapy. Recently, we have generated therapeutic T lymphocytes from mice bearing progressively growing tumors by the IVS method. However, IVS cells from tumor-bearing mice showed cross-reactivity between the MCA 105 and 106 sarcomas in adoptive immunotherapy experiments. Since these IVS cells did not affect other control tumors, the limited cross-reactivity suggests the presence of common tumor-associated antigens on MCA 105 and MCA 106 tumor cells which can also serve as the target for tumor rejection. Therefore, immune responses to progressive tumor growth and to immunization are distinct with respect to antigen recognition by T lymphocytes.     

Generation of therapeutic T lymphocytes from tumor-bearing mice by in vitro sensitization. Culture requirements and characterization of immunologic specificity

We have previously established an in vitro sensitization (IVS) procedure with which lymphocytes from tumor-bearing mice could be expanded and sensitized to acquire antitumor reactivity capable of mediating the regression of established pulmonary metastases from the weakly immunogenic MCA 105 murine sarcoma. Culture conditions required for the optimal generation of therapeutic effector cells were evaluated in the current study. Generation of effector cells by IVS required stimulation by intact tumor cells. Tumor cells killed by heat or disrupted by sonication were ineffective, but the antigenicity of tumor cells was not affected by gamma-irradiation. Long term established tumor cell lines could also serve as antigenic stimulator cells albeit with lower efficiency than fresh tumor cells. IL-2 was essential for cellular proliferation during IVS. The concentration of 1000 U/ml of IL-2 also induced nonspecific lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) activity. However, cytotoxic cells were generated during IVS in response to a broad range of IL-2 concentrations. At low IL-2 concentrations (2 to 10 U/ml), IVS cells were generated which displayed little or no LAK activity, had a greater therapeutic efficacy than those generated with high concentrations of IL-2 (100 to 1000 U/ml). Despite having high LAK activity, IVS cells, from cultures where IL-2 was added 3 or more days after initiation, had no therapeutic effect. Thus, the generation of therapeutic cells occurred independently of LAK cell production. Adoptive immunotherapy with IVS cells from MCA 105 tumor-bearing mice demonstrated cross-reactivity with the immunologically distinct MCA 106 but not the nonimmunogenic MCA 102 tumor. In contrast, IVS cells from MCA 106 tumor-bearing mice exhibited specific in vivo reactivity. In vitro cytotoxicity analyses revealed that IVS cells from MCA 105 and MCA 106 tumor-bearing mice were able to lyse both MCA 105 and MCA 106 target cells, but the reactivity toward inoculating tumors was highest. Considering previous findings that the MCA 105 and MCA 106 sarcomas possessed distinct tumor-specific transplantation Ag, the cross-reactivity observed in this study suggests that the immune response during progressive tumor growth may be different from that elicited in response to active immunization.     

Immune reactivity in SL2 lymphoma-bearing mice compared with SL2-immunized mice

Summary We have studied the rather paradoxical phenomenon of the growth of an antigenic tumor in an immunocomponent host. This phenomenon was studied by comparing (a) the lymphocyte reactivity and (b) the macrophage cytotoxicity, during SL2 growth in DBA/2 mice (SL2-bearing mice) and in DBA/2 mice immunized against SL2 tumor cells (SL2-immune mice). Immune mice rejected a challenge of tumor cells. The immune T-lymphocytes rendered macrophages cytotoxic (arming) and were able to transfer tumor resistance to naive animals. Nonimmunized mice did not reject a challenge of SL2 cells. In these tumor-bearing mice various forms of immune reactivity were tested. Lymphocytes with the capacity to arm macrophages could not be found in the lymphoid organs. However, lymphocytes isolated from the tissue directly surrounding the subcutaneous SL2 tumor could arm macrophages in vitro.Shortly after subcutaneous tumor grafting cytotoxic macrophages were found in the peritoneal cavity. In the serum macrophage arming factors were detected that rendered macrophages cytotoxic in vitro. This cytotoxicity of the peritoneal macrophages and the presence of macrophage arming factors in the serum showed a similar biphasic pattern. The first phase of cytotoxicity between day 3 and 8 after tumor grafting was tumor (SL2) specific. The second phase from day 12 and onwards was not tumor specific. During the first 4 days after SL2 grafting the DBA/2 mice expressed a specific concomitant immunity to a second tumor graft. Then 7 or more days after grafting the first SL2 tumor, the concomitant immunity was nonspecific as the growth of a second SL2 tumor graft and a L5178Y (DBA/2) tumor graft were inhibited. In addition, the immune suppressive activity of serum and lymphocytes was tested. Neither serum nor lymphocytes from SL2-bearing mice suppressed the macrophage arming capacity of SL2 immune lymphocytes. Lymphocytes from tumor-bearing mice did not inhibit the capacity of SL2-immune lymphocytes to transfer resistance to naive animals. On the contrary, lymphocytes obtained from SL2-bearing mice 14 days after SL2 grafting transfered tumor resistance in a Winn-type assay. These data suggest that the growth of an antigenic tumor is due to the inability of the immune system to mount an effective antitumor effector cell population during tumor growth, rather than an immune suppression of the antitumor reactivity, as a limited immune reactivity could be detected in tumor-bearing mice, whereas immune suppression could not be detected.     

Adoptive immunotherapy of a newly induced sarcoma: immunologic characteristics of effector cells

A newly induced syngeneic transplantable sarcoma, MCA 105, was used for studies of the biologic characteristics of fresh noncultured and secondarily in vitro sensitized (IVS) cells with antitumor reactivity. Fresh spleen cells harvested from mice immunized to the MCA 105 tumor by a mixture of viable tumor cells and Corynebacterium parvum exhibited no detectable cytotoxic activity to MCA 105 tumor targets in a 4-hr chromium-release assay, and adoptive transfer of these cells mediated the specific regression of established MCA 105 tumors. Phenotypic analysis of fresh, noncultured immune cells revealed that the therapeutically effective cells expressed both the Lyt-1 and the Lyt-2 T cell differentiation antigens. The therapeutic efficacy of fresh noncultured immune cells was not augmented by the concomitant administration of exogeneous interleukin 2 (IL 2). Secondary IVS of fresh immune cells with irradiated MCA 105 tumor stimulator cells resulted in the generation of tumor-specific cytotoxic effector cells. The generation of cytotoxic effector cells required Lyt-1+, 2+ cytotoxic precursor cells. Effective adoptive immunotherapy with these IVS immune cells, unlike fresh noncultured immune cells, depended on the concomitant administration of IL 2. Furthermore, the generation of therapeutically effective cells did not require the specific stimulation by MCA 105 tumor cells, because cultures of MCA 105 immune spleen cells with FBL-3 lymphoma cells in vitro also contained in vivo functional immune effector cells. These cells, however, possessed no detectable MCA 105 cytotoxic activity in vitro. Although this observation suggests that a noncytotoxic cell population is sufficient to initiate tumor regression in vivo, it does not exclude the possibility that cytolytic cells are generated in vivo after adoptive transfer of these cells. As a whole, our results indicate that secondary IVS functional immune effector cells are characteristically distinct from freshly harvested immune cells.     

In vitro sensitization and expansion with viable tumor cells and interleukin 2 in the generation of specific therapeutic effector cells

We have investigated the efficacy and immunologic characteristics of immune effector cells generated from cultures containing large numbers of viable tumor cells and interleukin 2 (IL 2) in the adoptive immunotherapy of experimentally induced pulmonary metastases from the newly developed, weakly immunogenic MCA 105 sarcoma in mice. The current culture conditions allowed increases of either normal or MCA 105 immune spleen cells up to 94-fold in 15 days. The in vitro expanded normal and MCA 105 immune cells displayed nonspecific in vitro cytotoxicity against several syngeneic tumor targets. However, therapeutically effective cells could only be obtained from cultures initiated with MCA 105 immune spleen cells. Immunotherapy with expanded immune effector cells could lead to the reduction of established 3 day pulmonary metastases, prolongation of survival, and cure of tumor in the majority of animals. The generation and proliferation of therapeutic effector cells in vitro depended on the presence in cultures of specific tumor stimulator cells as well as the presence of IL 2. Although immunotherapy with either fresh noncultured or secondarily in vitro-sensitized (IVS) MCA 105 immune spleen cells was immunologically specific, the efficacy of the adoptive cellular therapy with cultured but not fresh immune cells could be improved by the administration to tumor-bearing hosts of exogenous IL 2. In addition to numerical expansion, the IVS immune cells, on a per cell basis, afforded an eightfold to 10-fold increase in therapeutic efficacy when compared with fresh noncultured MCA 105 immune cells. Our results indicate that the current culture procedure induced in vitro antigenic stimulation and expansion of tumor-specific immune effector cells that was otherwise not possible by conventional mixed lymphocyte-tumor cultures.     

Adoptive immunotherapy of a BALB/c lymphoma by syngeneic anti-DBA/2 immune lymphoid cells: Characterization of the effector population and evidence for the role of the host's non-T cells

Summary It has been previously shown that the BALB/c lymphoma YC8 is susceptible to lysis by syngeneic anti-DBA/2 lymphocytes and that YC8-bearing BALB/c mice can be cured by adoptive transfer of such immune effectors. In this study in vivo and in vitro functions of the curative immune lymphocytes have been evaluated together with the role of the host immune system in the mechanism of tumor eradication. It was found that the curative anti-DBA/2 lymphocytes were not directly cytotoxic to YC8 cells although they developed into YC8-lytic cells after in vitro restimulation with YC8. In vivo, the immune lymphocytes were able to mediate a tumor-specific delayed type hypersensitivity reaction against YC8 but had a low tumor-neutralizing activity in the Winn assay. Proliferation of infused BALB/c anti-DBA/2 lymphocytes was necessary for the in vivo therapeutic effect, since irradiation of effector cells or treatment of the donor immune lymphocytes with vinblastine abolished their curative capacity. Immunodepression of the T cell compartment of the prospective tumor-bearing animals by thymectomy plus irradiation or its abrogation in B mice (thymectomized, lethally irradiated, and reconstituted with fetal liver cells) did not interfere with the therapeutic effect of the transferred anti-DBA/2 lymphocytes. Blocking the macrophage functions of the host by carrageenan, however, abolished the therapeutic effect of immune lymphocytes. These data indicate that a radiation-resistant, non-T cell is involved in the tumor eradication induced by anti-DBA/2 lymphocytes. It was also shown that cured mice, tested 90 days after therapy, become resistant to 5×10³ LD₈₀ YC8 cells and that this resistance was due to the presence of memory cells derived from the transferred and not from the host lymphocyte population.     

The role of host lymphocytes and host macrophages in antitumor reactions after injection of sensitized lymphocytes and tumor target cells into naive mice

Summary DBA/2 mice were immunized i.p. against syngeneic SL2 lymphosarcoma cells. At various days after the last immunization peritoneal and spleen lymphocytes were collected. The lymphocyte suspensions were enriched for T-cells by nylon wool filtration.The peritoneal T-cells from immunized mice (a) expressed direct specific antitumor cytotoxicity in vitro, (b) induced macrophage cytotoxicity in vitro, and (c) exerted tumor neutralization measured in a Winn-type assay. Spleen T-cells from these immunized mice (a) expressed no direct specific antitumor cytotoxicity in vitro, (b) only induced moderate macrophage cytotoxicity in vitro, but (c) exerted tumor neutralization in a Winn assay.For effective tumor neutralization in vivo effector target cell ratios of 1000:1 were required. When the effector/target ratio of 1000:1 was maintained but the absolute numbers of effector and target cells were lowered from 10⁶ to 10⁵ lymphocytes and 10³ to 10² target cells respectively, no tumor neutralization was obtained.The major effect of the sensitized-transferred T-lymphocytes seemed to be the induction of cytotoxic macrophages in the (naive) recipient mice, as the peritoneal macrophages collected from the recipient mice 7 days after i.p. injection of a mixture of sensitized T-cells and tumor cells were cytotoxic. Purified peritoneal T-lymphocytes collected from these recipient mice were able to induce macrophage cytotoxicity in vitro but expressed no cytotoxic T-cell activity.In conclusion, our results show that in the tumor system used, tumor neutralization after transfer of sensitized lymphocytes is not dependent on the presence of cytotoxic T-lymphocytes. Lymphocytes with the strongest potency to render macrophages cytotoxic (in vitro and in vivo) also induce the best tumor neutralization in vivo, suggesting an important role for host macrophages as antitumor effector cells.     

Methods for amplifying the induction and expression of cytotoxic response in vitro to syngeneic and autologous freshly-isolated solid tumors of mice

Summary Spontaneously arising tumors are frequently poorly immunogenic and exhibit a limited capacity to induce cytotoxic effector lymphocytes. In the present study, various approaches have been used to amplify the induction and expression of cytotoxic responses in vitro toward freshly isolated, autologous, and syngeneic solid neoplasms of spontaneous origin in mice. Cytotoxic lymphocytes were generated in one-way mixed lymphocyte-tumor cell cultures (MLTC) consisting of splenocytes or lymph node cells from normal and from tumor-bearing mice co-cultured with inactivated tumor cells. Optimal culture conditions have been established for the number of responder (R) cells, the method of inactivation of the stimulating (S) tumor cells, the responder/stimulator (R/S) cell ratio, and the duration of sensitization. Under optimal sensitization conditions only weak cytotoxic responses, as measured by the ⁵¹Cr-release assay, were generated. The antitumor cytotoxic activity could be augmented 2- to 12-fold by using each of the following procedures: (a) addition of crude or of partially purified interleukin-2 (IL-2) to the sensitization cultures; (b) depletion of nylon-adherent cells from the responding cell population; (c) enrichment of large lymphoblasts from the sensitized effector cell population by Percoll density gradient; and (d) treatment of mice donating the responder lymphocytes with low doses of either cyclophosphamide, adriamycin, or indomethacin. Although the highly reactive effector cells generated under the improved conditions also reacted appreciably with unrelated tumor target cells, only low levels of cytotoxicity could be demonstrated against normal target cells. The antitumor cytotoxic cells in sensitized splenocyte cultures were exclusively Thy1⁺, Lyt1^–2⁺, whereas in lymph node cell cultures some cytotoxicity was also exerted by Thy1⁺, Lyt1⁺2⁺ cells.     

Modulation of the immune response to tumors by a novel synthetic compound, (4R)-3-benzoyl-N-[(1R)-1-phenylethyl]-4-thiazolidinecarboxamide (RS-0481)

Summary RS-0481, (4R)-3-benzoyl-N-[(1R)-phenylethyl]-4-thiazolidinecarboxamide, is a compound that can re-establish the function of certain lymphoid cell populations impaired by the presence of a growing tumor in an animal. The compound markedly augmented the tumorspecific cytotoxic T lymphocytes,Tdth (delayed-type hypersensitivity T cells), and the nonspecific lymphokine-activated-killer-cell-like cell responses. It also enhanced the tumor-inhibitory effect of macrophages in tumor-bearing mice, but not in normal mice, indicating that it enhances the antitumor immune responses. Lymphocytes from RS-0481-treated tumor-bearing mice released significantly higher amounts of macrophage-activating factor(s) (MAF) and interleukin-2(IL-2)-like factors in culture compared with lymphocytes from untreated animals. Also, sera from treated tumor bearers showed elevated colony-stimulating factor (CSF) activity. Although the compound did not influence the factor-producing activity in mice without tumor, it enhanced the responsiveness of their bone marrow cells, T cells, and macrophages to CSF, IL-2, and MAF. It seems therefore possible that the compound enhances the responsiveness of immunocompetent cells to cytokines, resulting in a marked augmentation of antitumor T cell responses in tumor-bearing mice. Consistently it inhibited the development of lymph node metastasis of transplanted X5563 plasmacytoma, and we showed that T cells play a decisive role in this inhibition. The compound also counteracted the development of suppressor T cell activity in the spleen of tumor-bearing mice.     

IL-4-transduced tumor cell vaccine induces immunoregulatory type 2 CD8 T lymphocytes that cure lung metastases upon adoptive transfer.

Vaccinations with tumor cells engineered to produce IL-4 prolonged survival and cured 30% of mice bearing pulmonary metastases, an effect abrogated by in vivo depletion of T cells. Vaccination induced type 2 T cell polarization in both CD4 and CD8 T lymphocyte subsets. We focused on the antitumor activity exerted by type 2 CD8+ T cells (Tc2) activated by IL-4 tumor cell vaccination. Tc2 lymphocytes lacked in vitro tumor cytotoxicity, but released IL-4 upon stimulation with tumor cells, as shown by limiting dilution analysis of the frequencies of tumor-specific pCTL and of CD8 cells producing the cytokine. In vivo fresh purified CD8+ T lymphocytes from IL-4-vaccinated mice eliminated 80-100% of lung metastases when transferred into tumor-bearing mice. CD8+ lymphocytes from IL-4-vaccinated IFN-gamma knockout (KO), but not from IL-4 KO, mice cured lung metastases, thus indicating that IL-4 produced by Tc2 cells was instrumental for tumor rejection. The antitumor effect of adoptively transferred Tc2 lymphocytes needed host CD8 T cells and AsGM1 leukocyte populations, and partially granulocytes. These data indicate that Tc2 CD8+ T cells exert immunoregulatory functions and induce tumor rejection through the cooperation of bystander lymphoid effector cells. Tumor eradication is thus not restricted to a type 1 response, but can also be mediated by a type 2 biased T cell response.     

Immunoregulation in cancer-bearing hosts. Down-regulation of gene expression and cytotoxic function in CD8+ T cells.

The causes of the decreased immune responsiveness in tumor-bearing hosts are incompletely understood. The impact of a decreased immune response in cancer patients on the clinical response in immunotherapy trials has not been evaluated. The present report demonstrates a marked decrease in the therapeutic efficacy of adoptively transferred T lymphocytes obtained from murine hosts bearing tumor for greater than 30 days [late tumor-bearing mice (TBM)] as compared with normal mice and mice bearing tumor for less than 21 days (early TBM). In vitro analysis of the functions of the T lymphocytes from late TBM showed an apparently normal proliferative response to anti-CD3 and IL-2 with adequate lymphokine production from CD4+ cells, but a significant decrease in the cytotoxic function of CD8+ cells. The decreased cytotoxicity was not because of cell-mediated suppression. The expression of granzyme B mRNA was significantly delayed and decreased in magnitude in CD8+ cells from late TBM. Culture supernatants from two unrelated tumor cell lines were able to inhibit the cytotoxic activity of normal CD8+ cells in vitro. The tumor-derived suppressive factor is not transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta), but it has not been further characterized. The data suggest that one potential mechanism responsible for immunologic defects in patients with large tumor burdens is a tumor-induced defect that compromises the function of CD8+ effector T cells.     

Mechanisms of leukemogenesis. I. Generation of autoreactive lymphocytes in response to a murine leukemia virus.

Examined in this paper is the capacity of 334C murine leukemia virus (MuLV) to stimulate the generation of virus-specific cytotoxic effector cells in mice of the C57BL/6 strain that are relatively resistant to Friend, Moloney, and Rauscher (FMR) MuLV-induced leukemia, and in BALB/c mice that are relatively susceptible to leukemia induced by FMR MuLV. Generation of cytotoxicity requires in vivo administration of the virus followed by in vitro culture of lymphoid cells from virus-injected animals. Lymphoid cells from MuLV-resistant C57BL/6 donors develop high levels of specific cytotoxicity after secondary in vitro stimulation with syngeneic MuLV-induced tumor cells. Cells derived from these same donors, cultured in the absence of MuLV-induced tumor cells, fail to exhibit cytotoxicity. Secondary in vitro stimulation of lymphocytes from MuLV-susceptible BALB/c animals results not only in generation of cytotoxic reactivity against syngeneic MuLV-induced tumor cells but also induces apparently autoreactive effector cells capable of lysing other H-2d tumor cells as well as normal peritoneal cells bearing H-2d antigens. Moreover, generation of cytotoxicity by BALB/c lymphocytes occurs whether or not MuLV-induced tumor cells are included in the secondary culture system.     

Feline cytotoxic immune mechanisms against virus-associated leukemia and fibrosarcoma

Humoral and cellular cytotoxic immune mechanisms of cats were compared against feline leukemia virus (FeLV)- and feline sarcoma virus (FeSV)-transformed cells. The groups of animals studied were nonexposed control cats; FeLV-infected immune or viremic tumor-bearing cats; FeSV-inoculated tumor progressor or regressor cats, and cats immunized with FeSV-transformed autochthonous fibroblasts (ATF). Sera containing complement-dependent antibodies (CDA), which lysed FeLV-producer lymphoma lines, had no cytotoxic effects when tested against FeLV-producer FeSV-transformed fibroblasts. Sera with lytic CDA activity were also tested for antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxic (ADCC) effects with peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from nonimmune cats. No ADCC activity was detected against either lymphoid or fibroblast target lines. To demonstrate that cat PBL contained ADCC effector cells, antibody-coated murine target cells were employed and positive results obtained. Natural killer (NK) assays were performed using PBL from normal and tumor-bearing cats. Cytotoxic effects were only detectable to FeLV-producer lymphomas, and comparable levels of NK activity were found in normal and lymphoid tumor-bearing animals. In cats immunized with ATF, a population of effector cells was found in peripheral blood which had functional characteristics of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). The killing of ATF by CTL-like cells was not inhibited by FeLV/FeSV immune sera or by sera from autochthonous immune cats. The comparative importance of humoral and cellular cytotoxic mechanisms against FeLV- and FeSV-induced tumors is discussed.     

Adoptive chemoimmunotherapy of a syngeneic murine lymphoma with long-term lymphoid cell lines expanded in T cell growth factor

Summary Recently techniques have been developed for the long-term growth of cytotoxic T-lymphoid cells in vitro with T cell growth factor (TCGF). We have investigated the use of these in vitro-expanded T cells for the immunotherapy of a disseminated syngeneic murine FBL-3 lymphoma. In this model, mice with disseminated tumor were treated on day 5 with 180 mg cytoxan/kg and then 5 h later were given lymphoid cells IP. In vivo-immunized lymphocytes resulted in significantly improved survival in three of three experiments, curing 52% of 38 animals, compared with treatment with cytoxan alone (0 of 31 cured) or cytoxan plus unimmunized cells (0 of 40 cured) (P<0.0005). In vivo-immunized lymphocytes were re-exposed to FBL-3 tumor in vitro for 5 days in complete medium (CM) or lectin-free TCGF (LF-TCGF). Both groups showed significantly improved survival in six of six experiments. Cytoxan cured 17% of 66 animals, while cytoxan plus normal lymphocytes after IVS cured 6% of 47 animals. In vivo-immunized cells resensitized in vitro to FBL-3 in CM or LF-TCGF cured 82% of 50 animals (P<0.001) and 72% of 61 animals (P<0.001), respectively. Cells from in vivo- and in vitro-sensitized lymphocytes exhibited no cytotoxicity in our in vitro ⁵¹Cr-release assay; expansion of these cells resulted in significant specific lysis of fresh FBL-3 targets. Adoptive transfer of immune lymphocytes resensitized to FBL-3 tumor in vitro and expanded in LF-TCGF conferred a significant survival benefit (P<0.001, curing 7 of 27 animals) compared with all controls. These expanded cells were then continuously grown in LF-TCGF for 2 1/2 months. Again, in vivo-immunized lymphocytes resensitized to FBL-3 tumor and expanded in LF-TCGF for 2 1/2 months cured 56% of the animals with disseminated tumor, significantly prolonging survival over that recorded in any control group (P<0.0002). Irradiation of these same cells totally abolished their efficacy. Clones were generated from IVS and continuously grown in LF-TCGF. Two of these clones were very cytotoxic for fresh FBL-3 (>4,000 lytic units/10⁶ cells). When adoptively transferred to mice in this chemoimmunotherapy model these cytotoxic clones significantly enhanced survival over that recorded following treatment with cytoxan alone (P<0.00001), though prolongation of survival was small. Implications of these results for application of these techniques to other less antigenic tumors and human cancers are discussed.     

Effects of isolated tumor lymphocytes alone and with adherent cells

Summary The effect on the growth of gradient-isolated mouse mammary tumor cells of different populations of lymphoid cells were evaluated in micrototoxicity assays. Variable effects were obtained with tumor-bearer lymph node and spleen cells: in some experiments growth stimulation occurred, whereas in others inhibition was observed. Mixed effector populations gave more regular results: adherent spleen cells added to lymph node or spleen lymphocytes inhibited tumor cell growth in six of nine experiments; inhibition occurred when either of the effector populations in the mixture was derived from the tumor-bearing mouse. Tumor-associated lymphoid cells (TAL) stimulated growth of the tumor cells in five of seven experiments. However, TAL inhibited tumor growth when combined with adherent spleen cells from tumor-bearing animals. In contrast with the peripheral lymphoid cells, admixture of control adherent cells from normal animals with TAL did not inhibit growth. No natural killer effect was seen in these growth inhibition assays. These data indicate that lymphoid populations capable of inhibiting tumor cell growth can be found in tumor-bearing animals, but such combination of active cells are not present at the tumor site.     

Suppression of antitumor immunity by macrophages in spleens of mice bearing a large MOPC-315 tumor

We had shown previously that progression of MOPC-315 plasmacytoma growth is associated with an increase in the percentage of macrophages in the spleen as well as a decrease in the ability of tumor-bearer spleen cells to mount an antitumor cytotoxic response upon in vitro immunization. Here we provide evidence that macrophages in the MOPC-315 tumor-bearer spleen are responsible at least in part for the suppression of the generation of antitumor cytotoxicity. Accordingly, removal of most macrophages by depletion of phagocytic cells or Sephadex G-10-adherent cells from spleens of mice bearing a large tumor resulted in augmented antitumor immune potential. Also, Sephadex G-10-adherent spleen cells from tumor-bearing (but not normal) mice drastically suppressed the in vitro generation of antitumor cytotoxicity by normal spleen cells. The suppressive activity of these adherent cells did not reside in contaminating suppressor T cells, since it was not reduced by treatment with monoclonal anti-Thy 1.2 antibody plus complement. The Sephadex G-10-adherent cell population from the tumor-bearer spleen suppressed the in vitro generation of antitumor cytotoxicity against autochthonous tumor cells but not against allogeneic EL4 tumor cells, and hence the suppression was apparently specific. The suppressive activity of the Sephadex G-10-adherent cell population from tumor-bearer spleens was overcome by treatment of the tumor-bearing mice with a low curative dose of cyclophosphamide. This immunomodulatory effect of a low dose of the drug in overcoming the suppression mediated by the Sephadex G-10-adherent cell population enables the effector arm of the immune system of tumor-bearing mice to cooperate effectively with the drug's tumoricidal activity in tumor eradication.     

Augmentation of the therapeutic efficacy of adoptive tumor immunotherapy by in vivo administration of slowly released recombinant interleukin 2

Summary Immunization of C57BL/6 mice with MMC-treated syngeneic lymphoma cells, MBL-2, caused the generation of antitumor effector cells in vivo and the immunized mice permanently rejected viable MBL-2 lymphoma cells. Both plastic nonadherent T cells and plastic adherent MØ obtained from MBL-2 immunized mouse peritoneal exudate cells revealed strong cytotoxic activity against MBL-2 lymphoma cells, whereas immune spleen cells were not highly active against MBL-2 lymphoma cells in vitro. However, systemic adoptive transfer of immune spleen cells into the MBL-2-bearing mice by i.v. infusion in conjunction with i.p. cyclophosphamide (100 mg/kg) treatment cured the mice of tumor. This therapeutic efficacy of immune spleen cells was reflected by the number of transferred effector cells and over 5×10⁷ immune spleen cells were required to cure the mice completely. The cells mediating in vivo rejection of MBL-2 lymphoma cells were Thy 1.2⁺ T cells. This ACIT was specific against MBL-2 lymphoma cells and had no effect on the growth of other syngeneic tumors, B16 melanoma or BMC6A fibrosarcoma. In vivo administration of recombinant interleukin 2 (r-IL 2) combined with ACIT greatly modulated the cure rate of tumor-bearing mice. In addition, we found that slowly released r-IL 2 administratered from an ALZET miniosmotic pump was more effective in augmenting the therapeutic efficacy of immune spleen cells in ACIT than a single injection of the same total dose of r-IL 2.     

Reduced tumorigenesis of EG7 after interleukin-10 gene transfer and enhanced efficacy in combination with intratumorally injection of adenovirus-mediated lymphotactin and the underlying mechanism

Although interleukin-10 (IL-10) is commonly regarded as an immunosuppressive cytokine, a wealth of evidence is accumulating that IL-10 also possesses some immunostimulating antitumor properties. Previous studies demonstrated that forced expression of the IL-10 gene in tumor cells could unexpectedly produce antitumor effects. In this study, we explored the tumorigenesis of EG7 cells transduced with IL-10 gene. In vivo, IL-10 gene transfer reduced tumorigenic capacity of EG7 cells and prolonged survival of the EG7 tumor-bearing mice. It was found that the cytotoxicities of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) and natural killer cells (NK cells) were enhanced. Assessment of the immune status of the animals showed prevalence of a systemic and tumor-specific Th2 response (high levels of IL-4 and IL-10). To improve the therapeutic efficacy, we combined with intratumoral injection of adenovirus-mediated lymphotactin (Ad-Lptn) into the overestablished EG7 tumor model. More significant inhibition of tumor growth were observed in EG7 tumor-bearing mice that received combined treatment with IL-10 and Lptn gene than those of mice treated with IL-10 or Lptn gene alone. The highest NK cells and CTL activity was induced in the combined therapy group, increasing the production of IL-2 and interferon-γ (IFN-γ) significantly but decreasing the expression of immune suppressive cells (CD4⁺Foxp3⁺ Treg cells and Gr1⁺CD11b⁺ MDSCs). The necrosis of tumor cells was markedly observed in the tumor tissues, accompanying with strongest expression of Mig (monokine induced by interferon-gamma) and IP-10 (interferon-inducible protein 10), weakest expression of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and matrix metalloproteinases-2 (MMP-2). In vivo, depletion analysis demonstrated that CD8⁺ T cells and NK cells were the predominant effector cell subset responsible for the antitumor effect of IL-10 or Lptn gene. These findings may provide a potential strategy to improve the antitumor efficacy of IL-10 and Lptn.     

Differential effects of BCNU on T cell,macrophage, natural killer and lymphokine-activated killer cell activities in mice bearing a syngeneic tumor

Summary Chloroethylnitrosoureas have been used widely to treat human and experimental animal tumors. We have earlier observed that >90% of the mice transplanted with syngeneic tumors survive following treatment with nitrosoureas such as 1,3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea (BCNU) and furthermore, they resist subsequent challenge with the same tumor. The present investigation was initiated to determine the mechanism by which BCNU brings about this effect. Treatment of tumor cell targets in vivo or in vitro with BCNU, increased their susceptibility to macrophage (MØ)-mediated cytotoxicity as measured in a direct cytotoxicity assay or in an antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) assay. In contrast, the antitumor cytotoxicity caused by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL), natural killer (NK) cells, or lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells, was not altered following BCNU treatment of tumor targets. Studies were also conducted to investigate the direct effect of BCNU in vivo on various cytotoxic effector cells. For this purpose, MØ, NK, LAK, and CTL activities from BCNU-treated-tumor-bearing mice were screened for cytotoxicity against untreated tumor targets in vitro. It was observed that tumor-specific CTL and LAK cell activity increased in BCNU-treated tumor-bearing mice when compared to untreated controls while the cytotoxic potential of NK cells and MØs was not altered. The present study suggests that antitumor drugs such as BCNU are not only tumoricidal but also selectively act in a variety of ways at both the effector and target cell level, leading to overall enhanced antitumor immunity and high rate of cures from the syngeneic tumor challenge.The work at Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University was supported by NIH grants CA45009 and CA45010 and by a Biomedical Research Support Grant. The work at University of Kentucky was supported by NIH grants CA34052 and CA33629 and by a grant from the Tobacco and Health Institute     

Suppression of antitumor immunity by macrophages in spleens of mice bearing a large MOPC-315 tumor

Summary We had shown previously that progression of MOPC-315 plasmacytoma growth is associated with an increase in the percentage of macrophages in the spleen as well as a decrease in the ability of tumor-bearer spleen cells to mount an antitumor cytotoxic response upon in vitro immunization. Here we provide evidence that macrophages in the MOPC-315 tumor-bearer spleen are responsible at least in part for the suppression of the generation of antitumor cytotoxicity. Accordingly, removal of most macrophages by depletion of phagocytic cells or Sephadex G-10-adherent cells from spleens of mice bearing a large tumor resulted in augmented antitumor immune potential. Also, Sephadex G-10-adherent spleen cells from tumor-bearing (but not normal) mice drastically suppressed the in vitro generation of antitumor cytotoxicity by normal spleen cells. The suppressive activity of these adherent cells did not reside in contaminating suppressor T cells, since it was not reduced by treatment with monoclonal anti-Thy 1.2 antibody plus complement. The Sephadex G-10-adherent cell population from the tumor-bearer spleen suppressed the in vitro generation of antitumor cytotoxicity against autochthonous tumor cells but not against allogeneic EL4 tumor cells, and hence the suppression was apparently specific. The suppressive activity of the Sephadex G-10-adherent cell population from tumor-bearer spleens was overcome by treatment of the tumor-bearing mice with a low curative dose of cyclophosphamide. This immunomodulatory effect of a low dose of the drug in overcoming the suppression mediated by the Sephadex G-10-adherent cell population enables the effector arm of the immune system of tumor-bearing mice to cooperate effectively with the drug's tumoricidal activity in tumor eradication.This paper was presented in part at the annual meeting of the American Association of Immunologists, Chicago, Illinois, 10–15 April 1983