Nucleo-cytoplasmic incompatibility in cybrid plants possessing an Atropa genome and a Nicotiana plastome.

Summary Twenty-nine cybrids possessing an Atropa belladonna nuclear genome and a Nicotiana tabacum plastome were selected from two independent protoplast fusion experiments. In contrast to the previously described reciprocal, green and fertile cybrids with a Nicotiana nuclear genome and an Atropa plastome (Kushnir et al. 1987), the plants obtained were totally chlorophyll-deficient. An Atropa nuclear genome and a Nicotiana plastome from these chlorophyll-deficient cybrids were combined with an Atropa or a Scopolia plastome and a Nicotiana nuclear genome, respectively, in control fusion experiments. All of these nuclear genome/plastome combinations gave rise to normal, green plants. Therefore, we conclude that an N. tabacum plastome is incompatible with an A. belladonna nuclear genome.     

Limited chloroplast gene transfer via recombination overcomes plastomegenome incompatibility between Nicotiana tabacum and Solanum tuberosum

Green cybrids with a new nucleus-chloroplast combination cannot be selected after protoplast fusion in the intersubfamilial Nicotiana-Solanum combination. As an approach to overcome the supposed plastomegenome incompatibility, a partial plastome transfer by genetic recombination has been considered. After fusions of protoplasts of a light-sensitive Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco) plastome mutant and lethally irradiated protoplasts of wild-type Solanum tuberosum (potato), a single green colony was recovered among 2.5×10⁴ colonies. The regenerated plants had tobacco-like (although abnormal) morphology, but were normally green, and sensitive to tentoxin, demonstrating chloroplast markers of the potato parent. Restriction enzyme analysis of the chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) revealed recombinant, nonparental patterns. A comparison with physical maps of the parental cpDNA demonstrated the presence of a considerable part of the potato plastome flanked by tobacco-specific regions. This potacco plastome proved to be stable in backcross and backfusion experiments, and normally functional in the presence solely of N. tabacum nucleus.     

Comparative studies on the structural gene for the ribosomal protein S1 in ten bacterial species

Summary Callus protoplasts of a plastome chlorophyll-deficient mutant of tobacco, Nicotiana tabacum, were fused with mesophyll protoplasts from one of the following five sources: cms-analogs of tobacco bearing the cytoplasms of N. suaveolens, N. undulata, N. repanda, and N. plumbaginifolia, respectively, and the wild species N. glauca. In the sixth experiment, callus cells of the tobacco chlorophyll-deficient genome mutant, homozygous for the Su gene, were hybridized with mesophyll protoplasts of the plastome chlorophyll-deficient mutant of tobacco. Individual dividing heteroplasmic fusion products were isolated mechanically and cloned in microdroplets of nutrient medium. Among the regenerants in all parental combinations, though not in all clones, besides pure green and pure chlorophyll-deficient plants, numerous variegated plant forms were obtained. The variegation of cybrid and hybrid plants was connected with their heterozygocity for chloroplast DNA composition, as demonstrated by restriction analysis. In analytical crosses, the variegation was inherited maternally by part of the sexual progeny, and variegated F₁ progeny were also heterozygous for chloroplast DNA composition. As demonstrated by electron microscopic studies, the variegation is connected with the presence of mixed, i.e., heteroplastidic cells in leaves. The results obtained demonstrate that (1) upon somatic cell fusion, plastome genes are inherited biparentally in most fusion products, and (2) despite an evident mitotic segregation process, heterozygosity for plastome genes is a relatively durable state and can be revealed in cell hybrids of different specific combinations of plasmons after a great number of cell generations. In this regard the plastome cytogetes obtained by somatic cell fusion do not differ qualitatively from the cytoplasmic heterozygotes that arise as a result of the mutation process.     

Cybridization in Nicotiana tabacum L. using double inactivation of parental protoplasts and post-fusion selection based on nuclear-encoded and chloroplast-encoded marker genes

An effective selection system preceded by double inactivation of parental protoplasts was used to transfer Nicotiana suaveolens Leh. cytoplasmic male sterility into a commercial tobacco (N. tabacum L.) breeding line. Mesophyll protoplasts from transformed plants of N. tabacum cultivar WZ2-3-1-1 possessing a neomycin phosphotransferase II gene were used as the nuclear donors, while those isolated from N. suaveolens plants carrying a chloroplast mutation for resistance to spectinomycin, induced using nitrosomethyl urea, were the cytoplasm donors in somatic cybridizations. Prior to fusion, nuclear donor protoplasts were inactivated with iodoacetamide or rhodamine 6G, while those of the cytoplasm donor were inactivated by X-irradiation. The resultant microcalli were cultured on a shoot regeneration medium containing both kanamycin and spectinomycin to select cybrids. Only regenerants that had typical characteristics of the N. tabacum cultivar were selected for transfer to the glasshouse. Four putative cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) plants, out of a total of 44 regenerated plants transferred to the glasshouse, were obtained. Intraspecific somatic transfers of the CMS trait between N. tabacum cultivars with distinctlydifferent morphologies using single inactivation and nonselective shoot regeneration medium were demonstrated. The implications of the results for practical tobacco breeding as a means of circumventing lengthy backcrossing procedures are discussed.     

Spontaneous extensive chromosome elimination in somatic hybrids between somatically congruent species Nicotiana tabacum L. and Atropa belladonna L.

Summary Mesophyll protoplasts of the kanamycin-resistant nightshade, Atropa belladonna, were fused with mesophyll protoplasts of the phosphinothricin resistant-tobacco, Nicotiana tabacum. A total of 447 colonies resistant to both inhibitors was selected. Most of them regenerated shoots with morphology similar to one of the earlier obtained and described symmetric somatic hybrids Nicotiana + Atropa. However, three colonies (0.2%) regenerated vigorously growing tobacco-like shoots; they readily rooted, and after transfer to soil, developed into normal, fertile plants. Unlike their tobacco parental line, BarD, the obtained plants are resistant to kanamycin [they root normally in the presence of kanamycin (200 mg/1)] and possess activity of neomycin phosphotransferase (NPT II) with the same electrophoretic mobility as the one of the nightshade line. According to Southern blot hybridization analysis carried out with the use of radioactively labeled cloned fragments of the Citrus lemon ribosomal DNA repeat, as well as with Nicotiana plumbaginifolia genus-specific, interspersed repeat Inp, the kanamycin-resistant plants under investigation have only species-specific hybridizing bands from tobacco. Cytological analysis of the chromosome sets shows that plants of all three lines possess 48 large chromosomes similar to Nicotiana tabacum ones (2n = 48), and one small extra chromosome (chromosome fragment) similar to Atropa belladonna ones (2n = 72). Available data allow the conclusion that highly asymmetric, normal fertile somatic hybrids with a whole diploid Nicotiana tabacum genome and only part (not more than 2.8%) of an Atropa belladonna genome have been obtained without any pretreatment of a donor genome, although both these species are somatically congruent.     

Transmission genetics of the somatic hybridization process in Nicotiana

Summary Callus protoplasts of a Nicotiana tabacum chlorophyll-deficient mutant were fused with mesophyll protoplasts from one of following five sources: 4 cmsanalogs of tobacco bearing the cytoplasms of N. plumbaginifolia, N. suaveolens, N. repanda, and N. undulata, respectively, as well as wild species N. glauca. In another series of experiments, callus protoplasts from the chlorophyll-deficient genome Su/Su mutant of tobacco were fused with mesophyll protoplasts of the wild species N. glauca and those of a plastome chlorophyll-deficient tobacco mutant. The screening of hybrids consisted of visual identification followed by mechanical isolation and cloning of heteroplasmic fusion products in microdroplets of nutrient medium. Studies of regenerated plants included the analyses of gross morphology of plants, leaf and flower morphology, analysis of chromosome size and morphology and chromosome numbers, studies of multiple molecular forms of esterase and amylase, analysis of chloroplast DNA restriction patterns and analyses of chlorophyll-deficiency controlled by Su and P ^– genes. The study of progeny of 41 clones representing all species' combinations demonstrated that regenarants of most (63%) clones from intraspecific (for nuclear genes) combinations were cybrid forms, whereas in the case of the fusion N. tabacum + N. glauca, the true nuclear hybrids prevailed and the proportion of cybrids did not exceed 26%. Clones regenerating both hybrid and cybrid plants from the same fusion product were also found.     

Alterations in chlorophyll a/b binding proteins in Solanaceae cybrids

In this study we have constructed a number of plants (cybrids), in which the nuclear genome of Nicotiana plumbaginifolia is combined with the plastome of Atropa belladonna, or the nuclear genome of N. tabacum with plastomes of Lycium barbarum, Scopolia carniolica, Physochlaine officinalis or Nolana paradoxa. Our biochemical and immunological analyses prove that in these cybrids the biogenesis of the chlorophyll a/b binding proteins (CAB) of the light harvesting complex II (LHCII) is altered. Besides normal sized CAB polypeptides of 27, 25.5 and 25 kDa, which become less abundant, the cybrids analyzed have additional polypeptides of 26, 24.5 and 24 kDa. Direct protein micro-sequencing showed that at least two truncated 26 kDa CAB polypeptides in plant cells containing a nucleus of N. plumbaginifolia and plastids of A. belladonna are encoded by the type 1 Lhcb genes. These polypeptides are 11–12 amino acids shorter at the N-terminus than the expected size. Based on the available data we conclude that the biogenesis of the LHCII in vivo may depend on plastome-encoded factor(s). These results suggest that plastome-encoded factors that cause specific protein degradation and/or abnormal processing might determine compartmental genetic incompatibility in plants.     

Introduction of transformed chloroplasts from tobacco into petunia by asymmetric cell fusion

Plastid engineering technique has been established only in Nicotiana tabacum, and the widespread application is severely limited so far. In order to exploit a method to transfer the genetically transformed plastomes already obtained in tobacco into other plant species, somatic cell fusion was conducted between a plastome transformant of tobacco and a cultivar of petunia (Petunia hybrida). A tobacco strain whose plastids had been transformed with aadA (a streptomycin/spectinomycin adenylyltransferase gene) and mdar [a gene for monodehydroascorbate reductase (MDAR)] and a petunia variety, ‘Telstar’, were used as cell fusion partners. An efficient regeneration system from the protoplasts of both the parents, and effectiveness of selection for the aadA gene with spectinomycin were established before the cell fusion. In addition, the influence of UV irradiation on the callus development from the protoplasts and shoot regeneration of tobacco was investigated. Protoplasts were cultured after cell fusion treatment with polyethylene glycol, and asymmetric somatic cybrids were selected using the aadA gene as a marker. Although many shoots of tobacco that had escaped the UV irradiation regenerated, several shoots possessing the morphology of petunia and the resistance to spectinomycin were obtained. Molecular analyses of the petunia type regenerants demonstrated that they had the nuclear and mitochondrial genomes derived from petunia besides the chloroplasts of tobacco transformed with aadA and mdar. Furthermore, it was ascertained that mdar was transcribed in the somatic cybrids. The results indicate the success in intergeneric transfer of transformed plastids of tobacco into petunia.     

Analysis of mitochondrial genomes amongCitrus plants produced by the interspecific somatic fusion of ‘Seminole’ tangelo with rough lemon

Interspecific somatic fusion was performed between Seminole tangelo (Citrus reticulata Blanco xC. paradisi Macf.) protoplasts isolated from embryogenic callus and rough lemon (C. jambhiri Lush.) mesophyll protoplasts. Eight plants out of ten randomly selected regenerants had 18 chromosomes and the same nuclear rDNA fragment patterns as that of the mesophyll parent. The remaining two plants showed rDNA fragment patterns from both parents and had 36 chromosomes. For the analysis of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA),rrn26 derived from pea was used to probeBamHI digests of the regenerants. All plants showed mtDNA band patterns identical to that of the callus parent, suggesting that eight plants were cybrids and the remaining two plants were somatic hybrids. In addition to the callus parent band patterns, additional fragments from the mesophyll parent and/or a novel band fragment were revealed in some of the putative cybrids by peaatpA probe after digestion withDraI andPstI. These results suggest the occurrence of mtDNA recombination/rearrangement inCitrus cybrids produced by somatic fusion in this interspecific combination.Abbreviations mtDNA Mitochondrial DNA     

Restoration of fertility in cytoplasmic male sterile (CMS) Nicotiana Sylvestris by fusion with X-irradiated N. tabacum protoplasts

Summary Restoration of male fertility was achieved by fusing protoplasts from male sterile (CMS) Nicotiana sylvestris plants with X-irradiated protoplasts derived from fertile N. tabacum plants. The CMS N. sylvestris plants were derived from a previous somatic hybridization experiment and contained alien (Line 92) cytoplasm. About one quarter of the regenerated plants were found to be cybrids. i.e. they consisted of N. sylvestris nuclei combined with all or some components of N. tabacum cytoplasm. In one half of these cybrids male fertility was restored to different levels. The chloroplasts of the two parental donors differ in respect to tentoxin sensitivity: chloroplasts of CMS N. sylvestris are sensitive while those of N. tabacum are insensitive. It could therefore be demonstrated that there was an independent segregation of chloroplast type and male fertility/sterility: several somatic cybrids were male fertile but tentoxin sensitive and others were tentoxin insensitive yet they were male sterile. Only in about one half of the somatic cybrids was male fertility restored together with restoration to tentoxin insensitivity.     

Self-fertile cybrids Nicotiana tabacum (+ Hyoscyamus aureus) with a nucleo-plastome incompatibility

Cytoplasmic hybrids (cybrids) in a novel inter-generic combination, Nicotiana tabacum (+ Hyoscyamus aureus), were generated by fusion of protoplasts from a plastome tobacco albino mutant (line R100a1) and gamma-irradiated green protoplasts of H. aureus. Cybrids possessed a plastome of H. aureus and a rearranged mitochondrial DNA. The cybrids displayed a syndrome of nucleo-plastome incompatibility expressed as a partial chlorophyll-deficiency of cotyledonary and true leaves at the early stage of vegetative development of plants grown from seeds in soil. During later development, the plants restored a normal green coloration. This character is phenotypically indistinguishable from the same syndrome in previously generated cybrids N. tabacum (+ H. nigrum). In contrast to the cybrids N. tabacum (+ H. nigrum), cybrids N. tabacum (+ H. aureus) were self-fertile, and did not manifest other features that were interpreted as nucleo-mitochondrial incompatibilities in N. tabacum (+ H. nigrum) plants. Therefore, the cybrids N. tabacum (+ H. aureus) present a self-propagating system of Nicotiana (+ Hyoscyamus) nucleo-plastome incompatibility in its pure form.     

A new CMS source in Nicotiana developed via somatic cybridization between N. tabacum and N. alata

 Cytoplasmic somatic hybrids (cybrids) between the two sexually incompatible species Nicotiana tabacum and Nicotiana alata were constructed. A total of 33 green regenerants were obtained after fusion of protoplasts from a tobacco cytoplasmic chlorophyll-deficient mutant and gamma irradiation-inactivated leaf protoplasts of N. alata. Twenty nine of them were male sterile and displayed an altered stamen morphology (formation of petaloid and stigmoid structures instead of stamens). Southern-blot analyses of eight CMS plants using N. alata-specific nuclear repetitive DNA and cpDNA probes revealed that they contained nuclear genetic material of N. tabacum and chloroplasts from N. alata. Restriction-enzyme analysis of mitochondrial DNAs of the cybrids in question showed different patterns consisting of an incomplete mix of mtDNA fragments from both parents, as well as new fragments. Southern-blot analysis of mtDNAs with a sunflower atpA probe gave the same recombinant hybridization pattern for all analyzed cybrids, indicating that high-frequency specific recombination occurs in the atpA region. Analysis of the progeny from three successive backcrosses of the studied cybrids with N. tabacum demonstrated a strict cytoplasmic inheritance of the male-sterile phenotype. Received: 10 May 1997 / Accepted: 31 March 1998     

Protoplast fusion mediated transfer of oligomycin resistance from Nicotiana sylvestris to Solanum tuberosum by intergeneric cybridization

Summary We have successfully bridged the intergeneric barriers between Nicotiana and Solanum with respect to chondriome transfer. To enable this transfer we utilized the donor-recipient protoplast-fusion procedure. Consequently protoplasts of a Nicotiana sylvestris line with putativly oligomycin-resistant mitochondria (line Oli ^R 38) were used as irradiated chondriome donors and iodoacetate-treated protoplasts of Solanum tuberosum cv. Desiree served as recipients. The plated fusion products as well as their derived colonies and calli were exposed to gradually increasing levels of oligomycin. The resulting plantlets had potato morphology and were analyzed with respect to their mitochondrial DNA and chloroplast DNA. Fifteen out of 50 regenerated plants were verified as true cybrids. Detailed analyses of one cybrid revealed chondriome components from the oligomycin-resistant donor line, Oli ^R 38, but retention of the plastome of potato. This cybrid was oligomycin-resistant as revealed by root-culture analysis. It was thus verified that due to selection, chondriome components could be transferred from a N. sylvestris donor into a cybrid having all the phenotypic features controlled by the nucleus of the recipient fusion partner (S. tuberosum).     

Cybrid production based on mutagenic innactivation of protoplasts and rescuing of mutant plastids in fusion products: Potato with a plastome fromS. bulbocastanum andS. pinnatisectum

A procedure for cybrid production, based on double treatment of donor protoplasts by physical and afterwards chemical mutagens at superlethal doses (-irradiation at a dose of 1000 Gy was applied for the inactivation of nuclei; 3–5 mMN-nitroso-N-methylurea was used for the efficient induction of plastome mutation) and the rescuing of mutant plastids after fusion with untreated recipient protoplasts, was developed. For identification of mutant donor-type plastids in fusion products a selection for streptomycin was performed. In two sets of experiments, in whichS. tuberosum served as the recipient of foreign cytoplasm with the wild tuber-bearing speciesS. bulbocastanum andS. pinnatisectum as donors, a total of about 40 streptomycin-resistant colonies was isolated. Eight regenerants from theS. tuberosum+S. bulbacastanum fusion combination and four fromS. tuberosum+S. pinnatisectum were further investigated using chromosome counting, analysis of esterase isoenzymes, restriction analysis of organelle DNA, and blot hybridization. All but one plant from both combinations were characterised as potato cybrids possessing exclusively foreign plastids and retaining a morphology typical of the recipient. Only in one line was rearranged mtDNA detected. The availability of potato cybrids facilitates the analysis of plastome-encoded breeding traits and the identification of the most valuable source of cytoplasm among the wild potato species. The described system for producing cybrids without genetic selectable markers in the parental material offers the possibility for the rescue of cytoplasmic mutations which are impossible to isolate by conventional approaches.     

Intertribal hybrid cell lines of Atropa belladonna (X) Nicotiana chinensis obtained by cloning individual protoplast fusion products

Summary After fusion of isolated mesophyll protoplasts of belladonna (Atropa belladonna) with callus protoplasts of Chinese tobacco (Nicotiana chinensis) followed by mechanical isolation and cloning of individual heteroplasmic fusion products, 13 cell clones were obtained. The hybrid nature of most of the clones has been confirmed by biochemical (studies of amylase isozymes), cytogenetic (size and morphology of chromosomes) and physiological (peculiarities of cell-growth in vitro) analyses. Study of chromosomes and isozyme patterns in the hybrid cell lines revealed the presence of both parental genomes, without an indication of chromosome elimination, six months after hybridization. In 4 cell lines shootlike structures and plantlets have been produced by means of transfer to organogenesis-inducing media. The data obtained are interpreted as new evidence for the possibility of using non-sexual hybridization for the production of intergeneric, intertribal plant hybrids which cannot be obtained by sexual crossing. From these results the potential of Atropa (X) Nicotiana hybrids as a model system for genetic studies of distantly related plant species is discussed.This work is part of a joint project between Institute of Botany of the Ukrainian Academy of Sciences, Kiev, USSR, and Institute of Pharmaceutical Biology, University of Munich, FRG     

Chloroplast transfer in Nicotiana based on metabolic complementation between irradiated and iodoacetate treated protoplasts

Protoplasts of a light sensitive plastome mutant of Nicotiana tabacum (2 n=48) were irradiated and fused with iodoacetate-treated Nicotiana plumbaginifolia (2 n=20) protoplasts. Treated parental protoplasts were unable to divide. Metabolic complementation, however, helped the recovery of interspecific fusion products which survived and formed calli. Altogether 40 clones were investigated. N. plumbaginifolia plants were obtained in 15 clones (38%), somatic hybrids in 23 clones, and both types of regenerates were found in 2 clones. Irradiation therefore significantly increased the frequency of segregant formation with the non-irradiated N. plumbaginifolia nuclei (the frequency was 1.4% in the absence of irradiation). Regenerated plants in most cases (31 out of 34) contained chloroplasts from the irradiated parent. In 6 clones plants were obtained with both types of chloroplast. Thus, irradiated N. tabacum chloroplasts had an improved chance of dominating the heterokaryonderived cells, many of which contained N. plumbaginifolia nucleus. The system described should be generally applicable for the transfer of chloroplasts without the use of selectable genetic markers.     

Electrofusion of protoplasts from Solanum tuberosum, S. nigrum and S. bulbocastanum

Leaf protoplasts of two wild species, Solanum nigrum var. gigantea (S. ngr gig) and S. bulbocastanum Dun. (S. blb), were electrofused with leaf protoplasts of two diploid potato clones, H-8105 and ZEL-1136, respectively, in order to confer the late blight-resistance from the wild species to the cultivated potato. The S. ngr gig mesophyll (+) H-8105 mesophyll combination resulted in regenerants of mostly normal ngr phenotype. Two regenerants from this combination were proved to be true hybrids by RAPD analysis but they rooted poorely in vitro and did not survive the transfer to soil. The S. ngr gig (+) H-8105 fusion combination was also performed with H-8105 cell suspension derived protoplasts enabling an easy identification of interspecific fusants on basis of their intermediate morphology. From the S. ngr gig mesophyll (+) H-8105 cultured cell combination, many abnormal shoots were regenerated. The two lines which survived had normal ngr phenotype but the presence of tuberosum (tbr) genome in those regenerants was not confirmed by RAPD analysis. No plants with tbr phenotype were obtained from both of S. ngr gig (+) H-8105 combinations. On the contrary, when S. blb mesophyll protoplasts were electrofused with ZEL-1136 mesophyll protoplasts, all regenerated plants had tbr phenotype, indicating much lower morphogenetic potential of S. bulbocastanum in comparison with that of S. nigrum var. gigantea. However, the hybridity of those regenerants has not been confirmed by RAPD analysis with two different primers. The efficiency of the applied fusion procedure and analysis of the regenerants is discussed.     

Combination of kanamycin resistance and nitrate reductase deficiency as selectable markers in one nuclear genome provides a universal somatic hybridizer in plants

Summary The combination in the nuclear genome of a dominant resistance marker (to select against unfused wild-type cells) and a recessive deficiency marker (to select against unfused mutant cells) in a cell line should provide a system for selecting fusion hybrids between the mutant line and any wild-type line. To test this idea, we fused protoplasts from a non-morphogenic cell line of Nicotiana tabacum which was kanamycin resistant (by transformation) and deficient in nitrate reductase (NR^-K⁺) with protoplasts from N. tabacum cv. Petit Havana clone SR1, which provided resistance against streptomycin as an additional selectable marker (NR⁺K^-SR⁺). Putative hybrids were selected using a culture medium containing no available reduced nitrogen source and 50 mg/l kanamycin sulphate. After regeneration into plants, the hybrid character was demonstrated from: (i) the morphological variation of the regenerants; (ii) the chromosome number; (iii) the ability to grow on medium without a reduced nitrogen source and containing kanamycin sulphate at 50 mg/l; (iv) the presence of nitrate reductase activity; (v) the presence of the gene coding for neomycin phosphotransferase, which provides resistance to kanamycin sulphate; (vi) callus formation from leaves on medium containing 1 g/l streptomycin or 50 mg/l kanamycin sulphate; (vii) F₁ plants containing nitrate reductase and the gene for neomycin phosphotransferase. Fusions between the mutant cell line (NR^-K⁺) and three wild-type tobacco species and subsequent cultivation on medium containing no available nitrogen source but 50 mg/l kanamycin sulphate resulted in callus formation with all combinations, while hybrid plants were only regenerated when N. sylvestris was the fusion partner.     

Transfer of defined numbers of chloroplasts into albino protoplasts using an improved subprotoplast/protoplast microfusion procedure: Transfer of only two chloroplasts leads to variegated progeny

Summary A procedure is described by which it is possible to perform controlled microfusion of microscopically selected protoplast fusion partners with high efficiencies. The procedure is applied to fusion of Nicotiana tabacum (line 92V37, N. undulata cytoplasm) plastid albino protoplasts as a recipient and spontaneously formed subprotoplasts of green N. tabacum (line SRI) as donor. Products of individual electrofusion events are cloned via single cell nurse culture and the derived cell lines are analysed for the occurrence of variegated or green regenerating shoots, which are indicative of the establishment of the transferred organelles in the cell progeny. The plastid population in green regenerants recovered after the transfer of only two chloroplasts was demonstrated to have originated from the donor subprotoplast organelles by restriction analysis of total DNA using a plastome-specific probe.Some of the results described in this paper have been presented as posters at scientific meetings (Eigel and Koop 1989b; Eigel and Koop 1990)