On improved calibrations of unknowns in a system of quality-controlled assays

Two new estimators for calibrating unknowns from dose-response curves, in a system of quality-controlled assays, are examined. In contrast with the conventional estimator which uses only the results of the one assay in which the response of the unknown dose is measured, the new estimators also utilize the results of all other assays through the replications of the control samples in the system. The first estimator is based on maximizing the likelihood of the given system (with respect to the different dose-response parameters, the levels of the control samples and the levels of the unknowns) when response errors are normally distributed. The second estimator is a regression-like estimator obtained by subtracting from the conventional estimator its estimated regression on the deviation of the calibrated control levels in the given assay from their average values in the system. Evaluations of the reductions in bias and variance attained by the new estimators show when substantial reductions in mean square error can be expected. The new estimators are illustrated with a system of 22 hFSH radioimmunoassays.     

Comparison of 3 AT1 receptor binding assays: filtration assay, ScreenReady Target, and WGA Flashplate

In this article, the study of 3 different angiotensin II type 1 (AT(1)) receptor binding assays in terms of reproducibility, robustness, and feasibility for high-throughput screening (HTS) is described. The following methods were used: a nonhomogeneous filtration assay in a 96-well format using CHO-AT(1) cell membranes and 2 homogeneous assays, which include the commercially available ScreenReady Target for the AT(1) receptor and the wheat germ agglutinin (WGA) Flashplate, which was coated "in-house" with the CHO-AT(1) cell membranes. Receptors were labeled with [(125)I]-Sar(1)-Ile(8)-angiotensin II, and radioligand binding was displaced using the antagonist losartan and the natural agonist angiotensin II. Reproducible K(d), B(max), and K(i) values and good total binding/nonspecific binding (TB/NSB) ratios were obtained with both the ScreenReady Targets and the filtration assay, whereas the WGA Flashplates showed unacceptably high nonspecific binding and high variation when applied as a homogeneous assay. However, when applied as a heterogeneous assay (i.e., when a wash step at the end of the assay is included), the results were significantly better. Interestingly, ligand affinities were consistently lower in Flashplate-based assays than in the filtration assay. This may be due to the immobilization of the receptors onto the solid surface of the plate, affecting their conformation. In terms of reproducibility, robustness, and feasibility for HTS, the authors conclude that the ScreenReady Target plates are most suitable for AT(1) receptor binding screening.     

Improving Risk Assessment: Research Opportunities in Dose Response Modeling to Improve Risk Assessment

Substantial improvements in dose response modeling for risk assessment may result from recent and continuing advances in biological research, biochemical techniques, biostatistical/mathematical methods and computational power. This report provides a ranked set of recommendations for proposed research to advance the state of the art in dose response modeling. The report is the result of a meeting of invited workgroup participants charged with identifying five areas of research in dose response modeling that could be incorporated in a national agenda to improve risk assessment methods. Leading topics of emphasis are interindividual variability, injury risk assessment modeling, and procedures to incorporate distributional methods and mechanistic considerations into now-standard methods of deriving a reference dose (RfD), reference concentration (RfC), minimum risk level (MRL) or similar dose-response parameter estimates.     

Optimization of Salmonella Typhi biofilm assay on polypropylene microtiter plates using response surface methodology

The objective of this study was to develop an optimized assay for Salmonella Typhi biofilm that mimics the environment of the gallbladder as an experimental model for chronic typhoid fever. Multi-factorial assays are difficult to optimize using traditional one-factor-at-a-time optimization methods. Response surface methodology (RSM) was used to optimize six key variables involved in S. Typhi biofilm formation on cholesterol-coated polypropylene 96-well microtiter plates. The results showed that bile (1.22%), glucose (2%), cholesterol (0.05%) and potassium chloride (0.25%) were critical factors affecting the amount of biofilm produced, but agitation (275 rpm) and sodium chloride (0.5%) had antagonistic effects on each other. Under these optimum conditions the maximum OD reading for biofilm formation was 3.4 (λ_600 nm), and the coefficients of variation for intra-plate and inter-plate assays were 3% (n?=?20) and 5% (n?=?8), respectively. These results showed that RSM is an effective approach for biofilm assay optimization.     

In vivo transgenic mutation assays

Transgenic rodent gene-mutation models provide relatively quick and statistically reliable assays for gene mutations in the DNA from any tissue. This report summarizes those issues that have been agreed upon at a previous IWGT meeting [Environ. Mol. Mutagen. 35 (2000) 253], and discusses in depth those issues for which no consensus was reached before. It was previously agreed that for regulatory applications, assays should be based upon neutral genes, be generally available in several laboratories, and be readily transferable. For phage-based assays, five to ten animals per group should be analyzed, assuming a spontaneous mutant frequency (MF) of approximately 3x10(-5) mutants/locus and 125,000-300,000 plaque or colony forming units (pfu or cfu) per tissue per animal. A full set of data should be generated for a vehicle control and two dose groups. Concurrent positive control animals are only necessary during validation, but positive control DNA must be included in each plating. Tissues should be processed and analyzed in a blocked design, where samples from negative control, positive control and each treatment group are processed together. The total number of pfus or cfus and the MF for each tissue and animal are reported. Statistical tests should consider the animal as the experimental unit. Nonparametric statistical tests are recommended. A positive result is a statistically significant dose-response and/or statistically significant increase in any dose group compared to concurrent negative controls using an appropriate statistical model. A negative result is a statistically non-significant change, with all mean MFs within two standard deviations of the control. During the current workshop, a general protocol was agreed in which animals are treated daily for 28 consecutive days and tissues sampled 3 days after the final treatment. This recommendation could be modified by reducing or increasing the number of treatments or the length of the treatment period, when scientifically justified. Normally male animals alone are sufficient and normally at least one rapidly proliferating and one slowly proliferating tissue should be sampled. Although, as agreed previously, sequencing data are not normally required, they might provide useful additional information in specific circumstances, mainly to identify and correct for clonal expansion and in some cases to determine a mechanism associated with a positive response.     

Likelihood models for clustered binary and continuous outcomes: application to developmental toxicology

In developmental toxicology, methods based on dose response modeling and quantitative risk assessment are being actively pursued. Among live fetuses, the presence of malformations and reduction in fetal weight are of primary interest, but ordinarily, the dose-response relationships are characterized in each of the outcomes separately while appropriately accounting for clustering within litters. Jointly modeling the outcomes, allowing different relationships with dose while incorporating the correlation between the fetuses and the outcomes, may be more appropriate. We propose a likelihood-based model that is an extension of a correlated probit model to incorporate continuous outcomes. Our model maintains a marginal dose-response interpretation for the individual outcomes while taking into account both the correlations between outcomes on an individual fetus and those due to clustering. The joint risk of malformation and low birth weight can then be estimated directly. This approach is particularly well suited to estimating safe dose levels as part of quantitative risk assessment.     

A novel fluorescence-based array biosensor: principle and application to DNA hybridization assays

A novel fluorescence-based array biosensor targeted for field applications, such as environmental monitoring, has been developed, and successfully applied to DNA hybridization assays. The purpose was to meet the demand for automated, portable but easy-to-maintain systems allowing continuous flow monitoring of surface reactions. The biosensor presented here can be distinguished from the existing systems by the optical method used, which provides an enhanced simplicity and robustness, and enables a simple maintenance by potentially unskilled personnel. The system is based on a conventional microscope slide which acts both as transducer and biological array sensor. The excited fluorescence is guided by total internal reflection into the slide to the detector which is directly interfaced to the slide. Each region of the sensor array is successively optically interrogated, and the detection of the corresponding fluorescent emission synchronized. A real-time three-analyte analysis is thus feasible without any mechanical scanning movement or optical imaging systems as generally used in the existing instruments. The ability of the biosensor to operate in continuous flow for several tens of hours has been demonstrated. The biosensor has been assessed in terms of stability, and slide-to-slide reproducibility, which is found to be less than 3.7%, thus far below the standard biological reproducibility. DNA hybridization assays were performed to estimate a limit of detection, which was found to be 16 mol/microm(2), and to determine the reaction kinetics associated to the DNA model used. The developed biosensor is thus shown to be able to predict reaction kinetics, and to monitor in real time surface reactions between targets and probes.     

Effects of membrane partitioning and other physical chemical properties on the apparent potency of "membrane active" compounds evaluated using red blood cell lysis assays

The membrane-destabilizing properties of Amphotericin B and Zwittergent were used as benchmark compounds for examining in detail their membrane-altering effects in a series of human red blood cell lysis assays. The procedures included examining dose responses and the effects of different cell concentrations on potency in rbc lysis assays. In order to enhance detection of subtle membrane effects, we also used a range of NaCl concentrations to osmotically stress the rbc's. Using the benchmark compounds, a set of conditions was developed for examination of subtle membrane effects that may be applied to series of compounds with suspected membrane-perturbation activity. A group of experiments was defined that allow detection of the most important membrane-modifying behaviors among a diverse group of compounds. From an initial screen of bacterial growth inhibition over 150 compounds were examined for membrane-altering properties using the limited experimental protocols developed from the benchmark compounds. Several dose-response patterns were observed as useful for classifying compounds based on their tendency to alter membrane integrity and to partition into the lipids of membranes, as well as their propensity to form aggregates or precipitates. The methods may prove generally useful for distinguishing compounds whose primary activity is membrane destabilization from more interesting and useful pharmacological mechanisms of action.     

Selected biostatistical aspects of the validation of in vitro toxicological assays

An overview is presented on selected biostatistical aspects of the validation of in vitro toxicological assays. Primarily, the statistical analysis of single assays is discussed. Several approaches are compared for the possible non-monotonic dose-response relationship with a priori unknown shapes. The use of confidence intervals instead of p values for toxicologically appropriate decision making is explained. New methods are discussed for demonstrating interlaboratory similarity for dose-response designs are discussed. For validation, the inappropriateness of the concordance coefficient is shown, and sensitive and specificity as well as predictive values are proposed as alternatives. The problem of the missing gold standard is highlighted.     

Pseudomonas aeruginosa protease IV enzyme assays and comparison to other Pseudomonas proteases

Pseudomonas aeruginosa secretes multiple proteases that have been implicated as virulence factors and the detection of each specific enzyme can be difficult to determine. Unlike the three Pseudomonas enzymes that have been well characterized (elastase A, elastase B, and alkaline protease), the activity of protease IV in multiple assays has yet to be described. This study defines new assays for Pseudomonas proteases and compares protease IV activity to the activities of elastase A, elastase B, and alkaline protease. Six in vitro assays were studied: zymography, elastin congo red assay, staphylolytic assay, colorimetric peptide assay, solid-phase colorimetric peptide assay, and poly-l-lysine degradation. Casein zymography distinguished protease IV from elastase B and alkaline protease, and gelatin zymography differentiated all four proteases. The elastin congo red assay detected mainly elastase B while the staphylolytic assay was specific for elastase A. Protease IV activity was assayed specifically by the colorimetric assay and two new assays, the solid-phase colorimetric assay and degradation of poly-L-lysine in the presence of EDTA. Alkaline protease could be specifically assayed by poly-L-lysine degradation in the presence of N-alpha-p-tosyl-L-lysine chloromethyl ketone. The results identified three specific assays for protease IV, a new assay specific for alkaline protease, and showed that protease IV has a distinct enzymatic specificity relative to the three other Pseudomonas proteases.     

An evaluation of protein assays for quantitative determination of drugs

We have evaluated the response of six protein assays [the biuret, Lowry, bicinchoninic acid (BCA), Coomassie Brilliant Blue (CBB), Pyrogallol Red-Molybdate (PRM), and benzethonium chloride (BEC)] to 21 pharmaceutical drugs. The drugs evaluated were analgesics (acetaminophen, aspirin, codeine, methadone, morphine and pethidine), antibiotics (amoxicillin, ampicillin, gentamicin, neomycin, penicillin G and vancomycin), antipsychotics (chlorpromazine, fluphenazine, prochlorperazine, promazine and thioridazine) and water-soluble vitamins (ascorbic acid, niacinamide, pantothenic acid and pyridoxine). The biuret, Lowry and BCA assays responded strongly to most of the drugs tested. The PRM assay gave a sensitive response to the aminoglycoside antibiotics (gentamicin and neomycin) and the antipsychotic drugs. In contrast, the CBB assay showed little response to the aminoglycosides and gave a relatively poor response with the antipsychotics. The BEC assay did not respond significantly to the drugs tested. The response of the protein assays to the drugs was further evaluated by investigating the linearity of the response and the combined response of drug plus protein. The results are discussed with reference to drug interference in protein assays and the development of new methods for the quantification of drugs in protein-free solution.     

Modelling hydrolysis of leaf litter by digestive enzymes of the snail Melanopsis praemorsa: combination of response surface methodology and in vitro assays

The objective of the present study was to test the application of an in vitro assay simulating the digestive hydrolysis of leaf litter by the freshwater snail M. praemorsa, as well as to determine the possible influence of different factors in the efficiency of such process to release biologically available C and N under the forms of reducing sugars and amino acids from two different substrates. A novel approach to construct a model explaining the effect of three main factors (temperature, total reaction time and enzyme:substrate ratio) in the digestive hydrolysis of cellulose and protein present in leaf litter of different nutritive value is used. The methodology combines a factorial design based in the response surface methodology (RSM) and in vitro digestibility assays adapted to the physiology of both plant substrates used (alder and poplar leaves). The model revealed a different influence of the factors in the hydrolysis of two plant substrates, poplar and alder leaves and the main effect was produced by the time available for hydrolysis. A compensation response based in a longer gut retention time for the lower quality substrate was observed in the feeding assays. The use of in vitro assays and RSM provides a useful insight on the effect of factors and mechanisms underlying the observed differences in nutritional value of leaf litter for an aquatic invertebrate, being such differences linked to the whole bioavailability of carbon and nitrogen in headwater streams.     

The potency of tissue-type plasminogen activator (TPA) determined with chromogen and clot-lysis assays

An assessment was made of two methods for determining the potency of tissue-type plasminogen activator (TPA). A chromogenic microtitre plate assay was established which contained TPA, plasminogen, a synthetic plasmin substrate (H-D-valyl-L-leucyl-L-lysyl-p-nitroaniline dihydrochloride, S2251) and any one of the following stimulators: native fibrinogen, enzymatic and chemical digests of fibrinogen, poly-D-lysine (PDL) and chemical derivatives of the latter. The chromogen assay was compared with an automated clot-lysis (turbidimetric) assay for sensitivity, reproducibility and validity for potency determination. Reference preparations of TPA were titrated in both assays: in the chromogen assay the dose-response curves were non-parallel, whereas parallelism was observed in the clot-lysis assay. Thus, the chromogen assay was restricted in its applicability and disqualified from any routine regulatory use. The potency of individual lots of recombinant (r)TPA could only be estimated in International Units (IU) of TPA activity with the automated clot-lysis assay and the potency values obtained (IU/vial) were in remarkably close agreement with the manufacturers' values.     

Trojan horse lymphocytes: a vesicular stomatitis virus-specific T-cell clone lyses target cells by carrying virus

We have isolated a vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV)-specific CD4+ CD8- murine T-cell clone. This clone proliferates only in response to VSV and lyses infected tumor cells bearing class II major histocompatibility antigens in short-term chromium release assays. In addition, the cell has VSV antigens on its surface and is capable of killing uninfected tumor cells without major histocompatibility antigen restriction in a 2-day assay. This latter cytolytic activity is eliminated by anti-VSV antibody, indicating that its lytic activity is provided by the virus. [35S]methionine labeling and immunoprecipitation experiments demonstrated that viral protein translation is initiated after incubation of the clone with a tumor target cell, defining this as the mechanism of its cytolytic activity.     

Exploration of novel in vitro assays to study drugs against Trichuris spp

Though trichuriasis is a significant public health problem, few effective drugs are available underscoring the need for new drug therapies. For the evaluation of trichuricidal activity of test compounds in vitro an accurate, reliable, sensitive, fast and cheap drug sensitivity assay is essential. The aim of the present investigation was to evaluate the performance of different in vitro drug sensitivity assays in comparison to the standard motility assay. Trichuris muris L4 larvae or adult worms were isolated from the intestinal tract from infected female C57BL/10 mice and incubated in the presence of ivermectin, levamisole and nitazoxanide (200, 100 and 50 μg/ml) for 72 h. The health status of the worms was either evaluated microscopically using a motility scale from 0 to 3 (motility assay), by examination of absorbance or emission in response to metabolic activity (MTT (Thiazolyl Blue Tetrazolium Bromide) and Alamar Blue assay), through analysis of absorbance of an enzyme-substrate reaction (acid phosphatase activity assay), by measuring the noise amplitudes (isothermal microcalorimetry and xCELLigence System) or the heat flow (isothermal microcalorimetry) of T. muris. The Alamar Blue assay, xCELLigence and microcalorimetry compared favorably to the standard motility assay. These three assays precisely determined the trichuricidal activity of the three test drugs. The acid phosphatase and the MTT assays showed a poorer performance than the motility assay. In conclusion, the colorimetric Alamar Blue in vitro assay is a good alternative to the motility assay to study drug effects against T. muris L4 and adults, since it is easy to perform, precise and of low cost.     

Fluorescent coupled enzyme assays for D-alanine: application to penicillin-binding protein and vancomycin activity assays

D-Alanine (D-Ala) is a ubiquitous constituent of bacterial cell walls. Assays for D-Ala can be used to investigate several aspects of cell wall biosynthesis and the effects of antibiotics on this process. High-sensitivity fluorescent assays for D-Ala were developed in a microtiter plate format based on d-aminoacid oxidase/horseradish peroxidase (DAO/HRP)-coupled reactions. For comparative purposes the classic chromogenic (UV-vis) assay using o-phenylenediamine (OPD) was also adapted to microtiter plates. OPD gave a lower limit of sensitivity of 2 nmol and was linear up to 60 nmol. Two commercially available fluorogenic HRP substrates were then tested in this assay. Amplex Red (AR) gave a lower limit of sensitivity of 2 pmol and was linear up to 400 pmol d-Ala. QuantaBlu (QB) based assays exhibited a lag in their response to D-Ala corresponding to 50 pmol D-Ala. This lag complicated calibration, but could be eliminated by addition of 150 pmol D-Ala to all assays. The QB assays were linear up to 3000 pmol D-Ala and gave a lower limit of sensitivity of 10 pmol. These assays are demonstrated for the characterization of the dd-carboxypeptidase activity of a soluble form of Escherichia coli penicillin-binding protein 5 (PBP 5) against the classic PBP substrate diacetyl-L-Lys-D-Ala-D-Ala. AR and QB based assays gave identical v/E(T) profiles, whereas OPD based assays gave slightly (10%) higher activity. This is consistent with the loss of a small amount of E. coli PBP 5 activity during the dilution necessary prior to its use in the highly sensitive fluorescent assays. These assays were then demonstrated for characterization of vancomycin binding to a D-Ala-D-Ala-based substrate.     

The power and limitations of influenza virus hemagglutinin assays

Influenza virus hemagglutinins (HAs) are surface proteins that bind to sialic acid residues at the host cell surface and ensure further virus internalization. Development of methods for the inhibition of these processes drives progress in the design of new antiviral drugs. The state of the isolated HA (i.e. combining tertiary structure and extent of oligomerization) is defined by multiple factors, like the HA source and purification method, posttranslational modifications, pH, etc. The HA state affects HA functional activity and significantly impacts the results of numerous HA assays. In this review, we analyze the power and limitations of currently used HA assays regarding the state of HA.