“The Instinct Concept of the Early Konrad Lorenz”

Peculiar to Konrad Lorenz’s view of instinctive behavior is his strong innate-learned dichotomy. He claimed that there are neither ontogenetic nor phylogenetic transitions between instinctive and experience-based behavior components, thus contradicting all former accounts of instinct. The present study discusses how Lorenz came to hold this controversial position by examining the history of Lorenz’s early theoretical development in the crucial period from 1931 to 1937, taking relevant influences into account. Lorenz’s intellectual development is viewed as being guided by four theoretical and practical commitments as to how to study and explain behavior. These four factors, which were part of the general approach of Lorenz but not of other animal psychologists, were crucial in bringing about his specific position on instinctive behavior.     

How to make oneself nature's spokesman? A latourian account of classification in eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century natural history

Classification in eighteenth-century natural history was marked by a battle of systems. The Linnaean approach to classification was severely criticized by those naturalists who aspired to a truly natural system. But how to make oneself nature's spokesman? In this article I seek to answer that question using the approach of the French anthropologist of science Bruno Latour in a discussion of the work of the French naturalists Buffon and Cuvier in the eighteenth and early nineteenth century. These naturalists followed very different strategies in creating and defending of what they believed to be a natural classification in zoology. Buffon failed, whereas Cuvier's work appeared to be very successful. My argument will be that, to explain Buffon's failure and Cuvier's success, we should not focus on the epistemological or theoretical concerns and justifications of these naturalists, but on the concrete and heterogeneous means or tools through which animals were mobilized, stabilized and combined into ever more comprehensive systems of classification.     

Response to the amoebocyte-producing organ of sensitized Biomphalaria glabrata after exposure to Echinostoma caproni miracidia

Stimulation by exposure to Echinostoma caproni miracidia triggered the activity of the amoebocyte-producing organ (APO) of sensitized Biomphalaria glabrata snails. This organ is the site of formation of cells which subsequently migrate to all parts of the body. Amoebocyte production started very soon after exposure, and was maximal at 3 or 4 days; it then declined very fast and, at 6–7 days, the organ had almost returned to its initial state.     

Place,Practice and Primatology: Clarence Ray Carpenter,Primate Communication and the Development of Field Methodology, 1931–1945

Place, practice and status have played significant and interacting roles in the complex history of primatology during the early to mid-twentieth century. This paper demonstrates that, within the emerging discipline of primatology, the field was understood as an essential supplement to laboratory work. Founders argued that only in the field could primates be studied in interaction with their natural social group and environment. Such field studies of primate behavior required the development of existing and new field techniques. The practices and sites developed by American primatologist Clarence Ray Carpenter were used to demonstrate that scientific standards could be successfully applied to the study of primates in the field. In an environment in which many field biologists fought for higher scientific status, Carpenter gradually adopted increasingly interventionist techniques. These techniques raised epistemological problems for studies whose value rested on the naturalness of the behaviors observed. Thus, issues of status shaped field practices and subsequently altered Carpenter’s criteria for what constituted natural primate behavior. This article is part of a doctoral dissertation (in progress). This research was supported in part by a Doctoral Dissertation Research Grant and Doctoral Dissertation Fellowship from the University of Minnesota. Georgina (Hoptroff) Montgomery presented earlier versions of this paper at the ISHPSSB conference held in Vienna in July 2003 and at the HSS conference in Boston in November 2003.