The value of gametoclonal variation in breeding for quantitative traits in flue-cured tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.)

Summary In tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.), anther-derived doubled haploid populations have been shown to exhibit large amounts of unexpected genetic variation and a severe depression in cured leaf yield when compared to conventionally inbred genotypes from comparable sources. A previous study had predicted that the yield depression observed in a doubled haploid population-derived from a near homozygous cultivar, NC95, might be overcome through a recurrent selection program. In the current study, progress from three cycles of full-sib family selection for improved yield in an anther-culture derived population of NC95 was measured, as well as the remaining genetic variation within the population. A design II experiment was conducted in the population following three cycles of selection. Results indicate that the NC95 yield level has been recovered in the third selection cycle population. Although most of the genetic variation in the population appears to be exhausted, the additive genetic variance among maternal half-sib families for yield is significant, and it appears that continued yield improvement can be made through recurrent selection. Significant additive-genetic variance for yield was found among maternal half-sib families but was essentially zero among the paternal half-sib families, suggesting that remaining genetic variation is not being transmitted through pollen. One possible explanation results from the phenomenon of DNA amplification that can occur during the anther culture process, and that may enable extraordinary recombinational events and reduce the viability of male gametes.     

Use of doubled haploid technology for development of stable drought tolerant bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) transgenics

Anther culture–derived haploid embryos were used as explants for Agrobacterium‐mediated genetic transformation of bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv CPAN1676) using barley HVA1 gene for drought tolerance. Regenerated plantlets were checked for transgene integration in T₀ generation, and positive transgenic haploid plants were doubled by colchicine treatment. Stable transgenic doubled haploid plants were obtained, and transgene expression was monitored till T₄ generation, and no transgene silencing was observed over the generations. Doubled haploid transgenic plants have faster seed germination and seedling establishment and show better drought tolerance in comparison with nontransgenic, doubled haploid plants, as measured by per cent germination, seedling growth and biomass accumulation. Physiological evaluation for abiotic stress by assessing nitrate reductase enzyme activity and plant yield under post‐anthesis water limitation revealed a better tolerance of the transgenics over the wild type. This is the first report on the production of double haploid transgenic wheat through anther culture technique in a commercial cultivar for a desirable trait. This method would also be useful in functional genomics of wheat and other allopolyploids of agronomic importance.     

Microspore embryogenesis and production of haploid and doubled haploid plants in carrot (Daucus carota L.)

Protocols were developed for the generation of haploid and doubled haploid plants from isolated microspores of carrot (Daucus carota L.). Forty-seven carrot accessions, including six inbred lines, 11 cultivars, 20 F₁s, two BC₁F₁s, four F₂s, one F₃, and three F₄s, were screened to evaluate the genotype influence on isolated microspore embryogenesis over 4 years. Twenty-eight accessions responded by producing embryos and/or calli. A cytological analysis showed that two modes of carrot microspore embryogenesis exist: an indirect route via calli (C mode), and a direct route via embryos (E mode). Eleven accessions were in the C mode, and 17 were in both modes. The highest production rates were in 10Y25 (a European Nantes cultivar) with 27 calli and 307 embryos, and 100Q6 (a semi-Nantes F₁ hybrid) with 176 calli and 114 embryos. The time period to produce embryos or calli differed significantly between 2 and 6 months. Cold and heat pretreatment generally had a negative impact on the induction of microspore embryogenesis, but a short pretreatment showed a positive influence on some accessions. Twenty-eight lines regenerated plants from the primary individual embryos or calli of three accessions were established to analyze the ploidy level. The percentage of spontaneous diploidization showed very wide differences among the accessions and lines. Differences in leaf color intensity, leaf size, and leaf dissection were found among haploid, doubled haploid, and triploid plants.     

Mapping QTLs for defective female gametophyte development in an inter-subspecific cross in Oryza sativa L.

The embryo-sac is an essential structure for angiosperm reproduction. The cytological and genetic characterization of embryo-sac sterility was examined in a cross between Oryza sativa ssp. indica cv. ZYQ8 and ssp. japonica cultivar, JX17. The arrest of embryo-sac development was manifested following meiosis in the F₁ hybrid. When the megaspore carried the lethal genotype, the nucleus either failed to divide or divided only once, and the immature embryo-sac degenerated. Abortion of the embryo-sac in the indica-japonica hybrid background was not observed in their original parents, and an effect of cytoplasmic gene(s) on embryo-sac sterility in the reciprocal F₁ hybrids was not detected. Using a rice molecular linkage map based on a doubled haploid (DH) population from the cross of ZYQ8 /JX17, we mapped quantitative trait loci (QTLs) for the defective development of the female gametophyte in backcross progenies from the DH lines. The result demonstrated that a polygenic system is involved in both megagametogenesis and postzygotic isolation in inter-subspecific hybrid rice. Received: 4 May 2000 / Accepted: 20 September 2000     

Cytological diploidization and rapid genome changes of the newly synthesized allotetraploids <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cucumis × hytivus</Emphasis>

We used a newly synthesized allotetraploid between C. sativus (2n = 2x = 14, n gametic chromosome number, x haploid chromosome number) and C. hystrix (2n = 2x = 24) to study the genomic events in its early generations. Results from cytological characterization of the F₁ and the allotetraploid progenies showed that the rate of bivalents in meiotic metaphase I of the F₁ was greatly improved by chromosome doubling, and further improved during the selfing process of allopolyploid resulting into relatively diploid-like meiosis. Extensive genomic changes were detected by amplified fragment length polymorphism analysis. The changes mainly involved loss of parental restriction fragments and gaining of novel fragments. The total detectable changes were from 11.1 to 32.1%, and the frequency of losing parental fragments was much higher than that of gaining novel fragments. Some of the changes were initiated as early as in the F₁ hybrid, whereas others occurred after chromosome doubling (polyploid formation). No significant differences were detected in the reciprocal F₁ hybrids and S₀ generations. But the data showed that the frequency of sequence losing in C. sativus was about two times higher than in the C. hystrix. Our results demonstrated that the sequence elimination was the major event of genomic changes, and it might provide the physical basis for the diploid-like meiotic behavior in the diploidization of the newly formed allopolyploids. Moreover, the results suggest that the sequence elimination was not caused by cytoplasmic factors, and might relate to genomic recombination and to the numbers of parental chromosome.     

Determination of ploidy and homozygosity of carrot plants obtained from anther cultures

The purpose of the present work was to evaluate carrot plants obtained from anther cultures with respect to their ploidy and homozygosity. Ploidy was determined using flow cytometry. Homozygosity of analyzed plants was determined using isoenzymes, glucose-6-phosphate isomerase (PGI) and aspartate aminotransferase (AAT). The cytometric tests revealed that more than 90% of the carrot plants obtained from anther cultures were doubled haploid. In the initial assessment of polymorphism of the two enzymatic systems in selected androgenetic carrot plants of the cultivars: Berjo, Kazan F₁, and Splendid F₁, it was proven that 100% of those plants were homozygotes in respect to PGI and also with respect to AAT. In the second experiment, the obtained androgenetic progeny of the heterozygous donor plant of cultivar Narbonne F₁ was found to be 94% homozygotic with respect to PGI and 100% homozygotic in the case of AAT. For the androgenetic plants of the cultivar Kazan F₁, 89% of them were homozygotic with respect to AAT but PGI enzyme system did not differentiate the homozygotic and heterozygotic androgenetic progeny. These results indicated that enzyme polymorphism depends on carrot genotype, therefore, analysis of some (more than one) isozymes was necessary to confirm homozygosity of plants. PGI and AAT can be a useful tool for determining homozygosity in androgenetic carrot plants.     

Anther cultures of Nicotiana tabacum L. mutants

Summary The theoretically expected and experimentally observed phenotypic ratios have been compared in populations of haploids derived from chlorophyll mutants of Nicotiana tabacum L. with a known genotypic constitution. The frequencies of mutant genotypes were significantly lower than the expected values, proving the existence of selection in a system of haploid embryoids developing in the anther.The anthers from M₁ plants of a diploidized Nicotiana tabacum haploid cv. Samsun, treated with various concentrations of N-nitroso-N-methylurea and n-butylmethane sulphonate, were cultivated in vitro. The number of anthers which gave rise to haploids (embryogenic anthers) was stimulated by lower concentrations of both the mutagens. The stimulation at the level of M₁ sporophyte is explained by internal genetic heterogeneity induced by adequate mutagen concentration. The average number of haploids per embryogenic anther decreased in all the treatments. The frequency of haploid plants of the mutant phenotypes increased with increasing mutagen concentration.     

Factors affecting anther culturability of recalcitrant barley genotypes

One major problem encountered with cereal anther culture is that some genotypes are low or non-responders to the technique. The objective of this study was to improve anther culture efficiency of recalcitrant barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) genotypes. Reciprocal F₁s between the two low responsive cultivars, Morex and Steptoe, were used. These were chosen because doubled haploids (DH) were required from these genotypes for the North American Barley Genome Mapping project. Ficoll 400 at 200 g l^–1 in the induction medium significantly increased green plant production compared to four other media formations containing different gelling/viscosity modifying agents. Cold pretreatment of donor spikes of 28 vs 14 d resulted in an increase in embryoid, total plant and green plant production. Anther culture response in these experiments was little influenced by donor plant growth conditions. Indole-3-acetic acid (1 mg l^–1) or 1-naphthaleneacetic acid (2 mg l^–1) in the induction medium did not affect anther culturability or plant regeneration. Based on this research, the negative genotypic effect for doubled haploid production could be diminished, which is desirable for practical application.Abbreviations BAP 6-benzylaminopurine - IAA Indole-3-acetic acid - LS Linsmaier & Skoog - NAA 1-naphthaleneacetic acid - DH doubled haploid     

Mechanisms of Meiotic Restitution and Their Genetic Regulation in Wheat–Rye Polyhaploids

Meiosis has been studied in partially fertile wheat–rye F₁ hybrids yielded by crosses Triticum aestivum (Saratovskaya 29 variety) × Secale cereale L. (Onokhoiskaya variety) (4x =28). Hybrid self-fertility proved to be caused by formation of restituted nuclei, which appear after equational segregation of univalent chromosome in AI and sister chromatid non-separation in AII of meiosis, as well as after AI blockage in three different ways. Both types of meiotic restitution were found in each hybrid plant. Expression of the meiotic restitution trait varied significantly in polyhaploids of the same genotype (ears of the same plants, anthers of the same ear, microsporocytes of the same anther). Chromatin condensation in prophase proved to be related to the division type and univalent segregation in AI. During reduction segregation of univalents in AI, sister chromatid cohesion and chromosome supercondensation remained unchanged. The results obtained suggest that in the remote hybrids with haploid karyotype of the parental origin (polyhaploids), the program of two-stage meiosis may be fundamentally transformed to ensure one instead of two divisions. We propose that meiotic restitution is a result of special genetic regulation of the kinetochore organization (both structural and functional) and chromatin condensation, i.e. of major meiotic mechanisms.     

Increased doubled haploid plant regeneration from rice (Oryza sativa L.) anthers cultured on colchicine-supplemented media

Plating rice anthers on a semisolid induction medium containing 250 or 500 mg/l colchicine for 24 or 48 h-incubations followed by transfer to colchicine-free medium and standard anther culture procedures resulted in overall 1.5- to 2.5- fold increases in doubled haploid green plant productions compared to control anther cultures. The addition of colchicine had no detrimental effects on the different anther culture efficiency parameters, but in some treatments led to significant enhancement of anther callusing frequency or callus green plant regenerating ability. The most efficient treatment raised doubled haploid plant recovery from 31% to 65.5%. These results suggest that post-plating colchicine treatment of anthers, since it was found to improve both anther culture efficiency and doubled haploid plant recovery frequency, could be integrated into rice doubled haploid plant production programmes.Abbreviations DH doubled haploid - NAA naphthalenacetic acid - PAS periodic acid Schiff     

Anther culture and Hordeum bulbosum-derived barley doubled haploids mutations and methylation

Anther culture and Hordeum bulbosum-derived doubled haploid (DH) lines of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) were analyzed for RFLP and RAPD polymorphisms. Polymorphisms were not detected in the anther culture-or H. bulbosum-derived DH lines among 273 RFLP and 89 polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-amplified DNA fragments assayed. It was calculated that base substitution or small deletion/insertion mutations had not been induced among 401 640 by screened. Large deletion/insertion mutations were not observed among 33 Mb screened. Polymorphisms were observed when DNA was digested with the methylation-sensitive restriction enzymes HpaII and MspI: these RFLPs originated primarily from the anther culture-derived doubled haploids. The data indicate that heritable DNA methylation changes had occurred during DH production, particularly with the anther culture method.     

The Effect of Lr19-Translocation on in Vitro Androgenesis and Inheritance of Leaf-Rust Resistance in DH3 Lines and F2 Hybrids of Common Wheat

Leaf-rust resistance and androgenesis were studied in the anther cultures of Triticum aestivum L., which included Saratovskaya 29 cultivar, the isogenic line Ps29, and three F₁ hybrids (L503/S55, L504/S58, ATS7/L1063) with 7DS-7DL-7Ae#1L translocation of Lr19 gene (Lr19 translocation) from Agropyron elongatum (Host.) P.B. The Lr19 translocation was shown to affect the induction of embryogenesis and green plant regeneration. The frequencies of Lr19 translocation differed in F₂ hybrids obtained by traditional hybridization and in sets of DH₃ lines obtained in F₁ anther cultures derived from the same combinations of T. aestivum parental forms. The number of leaf-rust resistant genotypes tended to decrease. The frequency of Lr19 translocation in the set of DH₃ lines derived from F₁ L504/S58 was significantly lower than in other sets of DH₃ lines and F₂ hybrid populations.     

Genotype-environment interaction effects on reproductive performance in Tribolium castaneum

Summary The genetical expectations of the means, variances and covariances of populations of doubled haploid lines derived from f₁, F₂, F₃ and intermated F₂ (S₃) generations are presented. These expectations are identical, regardless of genetical architecture, providing there is no linkage disequilibrium. In the presence of linkage disequilibrium differences will occur whose magnitude and direction will depend on the degree of disequilibrium, recombination frequency and the presence or absence of epistasis.Data from an experiment to detect linkage disequilibrium in a cross between two spring barley varieties are presented. This involved a comparison of means, variances and covariances of doubled haploid populations derived from the F₁ and F₂ generations using the H. bulbosum system. Linkage disequilibrium was detected for important agronomic characters and the effect of this disequilibrium on the choice of generation for doubled haploid production is discussed.     

Rapid attainment of a doubled haploid line from transgenic maize (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Zea mays</Emphasis> L.) plants by means of anther culture

Summary We present a strategy for establishing a transgenic doubled haploid maize line from heterozygous transgenic material by means of anther culture. Compared to conventional inbreeding, the in vitro androgenesis technique enables a faster generation of virtually fully homozygous lines. Since the androgenic response is highly genotype-dependent, we crossed transgenic, non-androgenic plants carrying a herbicide resistance marker gene (pat, encoding for phosphinothricin acetyl transferase) with a highly androgenic genotype. The transgenic progenies were used as donor plants for anther culture. One transgenic and three non-transgenic doubled haploid lines have been established within approximately 1 yr. The homozygosity of all four doubled haploid lines was tested by analysis of simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers at 19 different loci. Polymorphisms were found between the lines but not within the lines indicating the homozygous nature of the entire plant genome gained by anther culture. Southern blot analysis revealed that the transgenic donor plants and their doubled haploid progeny exhibited the same integration pattern of the pat gene. No segregation of the herbicide resistance trait has been observed among the progeny of the transgenic doubled haploid line.     

Effect of ploidy and homozygosity on transgene expression in primary tobacco transformants and their androgenetic progenies

Expression of a transgene is rarely analysed in the androgenetic progenies of the transgenic plants. Here, we report differential transgene expression in androgenetic haploid and doubled haploid (DH) tobacco plants as compared to the diploid parental lines, thus demonstrating a gene dosage effect. Using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation, and bacterial reporter genes encoding neomycin phosphotransferase (nptII) and β-glucuronidase (uidA/ GUS), driven respectively by the mas 1′ and mas 2′ promoters, we have generated more than 150 independent transgenic (R₀) Nicotiana tabacum plants containing one or more T-DNA copies. Transgene analyses of these R₀, their selfed R₁ lines and their corresponding haploid progenies showed an obvious position effect (site of T-DNA insertion on chromosome) on uidA expression. However, transgene (GUS) expression levels were not proportional to transgene copy number. More than 150 haploids and doubled haploids, induced by treatment with colchicine, were produced from 20 independent transgenic R₀ plants containing single and multiple copies of the uidA gene. We observed that homozygous DH plants expressed GUS at approximately 2.9-fold the level of the corresponding parental haploid plants. This increase in transgene expression may be attributed mainly to the increase (2-fold) in chromosome number. Based on this observation, we suggest a strong link between chromosome number (ploidy dosage effect) and transgene expression. In particular, we demonstrate the effect on its expression level of converting the transgene from the heterozygous (in R₀ plants) to the homozygous (DH) state: e.g. an increase of 50% was observed in the homozygous DH as compared to the original heterozygous diploid plants. We propose that ploidy coupled with homozygosity can result in a new type of gene activation, creating differences in gene expression patterns. Received: 27 April 1998 / Accepted: 12 August 1998     

Gametoclonal variation detected in the nuclear ribosomal DNA from doubled haploid lines of a spring wheat (Triticum aestivum L., cv. ‘César’)

Summary The organization of the nuclear ribosomal DNA from a parental line of wheat (Triticum aestivum L., cv. César) and its anther-derived first cycle and second cycle doubled haploid lines has been analyzed by DNA-DNA molecular hybridization. Restricted DNA has been probed by three subclones of wheat nuclear ribosomal DNA covering the entire repeat unit. No significant difference was detected in the extent of methylation of ribosomal DNA of the doubled haploid lines with respect to the parental line. On the other hand, a variation has been found in the organization of the nontranscribed spacer region of ribosomal DNA of the first cycle doubled haploid line. This variation remains stable after a second cycle of in vitro androgenesis. However, one out of five second cycle doubled haploid lines so far tested showed an additional hybridization band present in the parental line but lacking in the first cycle doubled haploid line.     

Agronomic performance of lines derived from anther culture, maize pollination and single-seed descent in a spring wheat cross

Anther culture and maize hybridization are two frequently used techniques for doubled haploid production in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Information on the field performance of lines derived from these techniques is limited. This study was conducted to compare the performance of F_4:6 lines obtained by single-seed descent with lines obtained by anther culture and maize (Zea mays L.) pollination from the same cross of spring wheat, ’Chris’/MN 7529. Thirty-three lines derived from each of those techniques were evaluated in six environments for grain yield, protein content, test weight, heading date, kernel weight and plant height. Mean performance of the single-seed descent lines exceeded performance of the anther culture lines for grain yield, kernel weight and plant height with no apparent differences for grain protein content, test weight and heading date. No differences between trait means for the single-seed descent and maize pollination lines were found except for plant height. The best 5 lines from each method for grain yield, protein content and test weight were similar in performance except that the protein content was higher for the maize pollination lines than for the single-seed descent lines. Acceptable levels of agronomic performance could be found among lines from each method. Wide acceptance of the doubled haploid technique for pure line production in breeding programs may, however, be limited by the often poor efficiency of doubled haploid line production, resulting in smaller population sizes for selection of desirable traits in comparison to the single-seed descent method. Received: 31 July 1998 / Accepted: 28 November 1998     

Inheritance and mapping of embryo sac abortion in hybrid between Indica and Japonica rice (Oryza sativa L.)

A doubled haploid (DH) population derived from anther culture of F₁’s between an Indica var. Zhai-Ye-Qing 8 and a Japonica var. Jing-Xi17 as well as two backcross populations derived from this DH population were used to investigate inheritance of the embryo sac abortion at early megagametogenesis occurring in Indica/Japonica rice crosses. Two major loci, dominant and complementaryesa-1 andesa-2, located on chromosomes 6 and 12 respectively, were detected. Genetic analysis indicated that embryo sac fertility is mainly regulated by the gametophytic genotype at these two loci.     

Meiotic studies of the F1 hybrid between rice bean (Vigna umbellata) and its wild relative V. minima

The interspecific F₁ hybrid V. umbellata x V. minima, together with the parental species was investigated cytogenetically. Both parents showed normal meiosis, with 11 bivalents at diakinesis. The hybrid was completely pollen sterile. The cytological causes underlying sterility in the hybrid include an array of meiotic abnormalities ranging from non-pairing of chromosomes through the presence of univalents, chain and ring multivalents and anaphase bridges to the formation of micronuclei, during microsporogenesis. The presence of chain and ring multivalents at diakinesis not only demonstrates the structural hybridity of the F₁ hybrid, but also suggests that small interchanges and inversions played a significant role in the speciation within the genus Vigna.     

Improvement of anther culture methods for doubled haploid production in barley breeding

There is potential to accelerate cultivar development with a doubled haploid system for breeding line production. Anther culture methodology was evaluated for U.S.A. spring barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) breeding applications. Gelrite was found to be an acceptable replacement for ficoll in the induction medium to reduce costs while maintaining embryoid and plant production levels. Beneficial effects of 28 d cold pretreatment of donor spikes for anther culture were confirmed with Pacific Northwest USA barley genotypes. A 3 d mannitol solution pretreatment of fresh anthers was shown to be less effective for green plant production compared to 28 d cold pretreatment of donor spikes. Extended donor spike cold pretreatment from 28 to 42 d did not reduce anther culture productivity. Based on this research, anther culture techniques show promise for economical and convenient application in spring barley breeding.Abbreviations DH doubled haploid - LS Linsmaier and Skoog basal medium - BAP benzylaminopurine - GLM Generalized Linear Model - SAS Statistical Analysis System