CHLOROPLAST DNA RESTRICTION SITE VARIATION AND THE PHYLOGENY OF COREOPSIS SECTION COREOPSIS (ASTERACEAE)

Restriction site variation in chloroplast DNAs (cpDNAs) of Coreopsis section Coreopsis was employed to assess divergence and phylogenetic relationships among the nine species of the section. A total of fourteen restriction site mutations and one length mutation was detected. Cladistic analysis of the cpDNA data produced a phylogeny that is different in several respects from previous hypotheses. CpDNA mutations divide the section into two groups, with the two perennial species C. auriculata and C. pubescens lacking any derived restriction site changes. The other seven species are united by five synapomorphic restriction site mutations and the one length mutation. These seven species fall into three unresolved clades consisting of 1) the remaining three perennial species, C. grandiflora, C. intermedia, and C. lanceolata; 2) three annual species, C. basalis, C. nuecensoides, and C. nuecensis; and 3) the remaining annual, C. wrightii. The cpDNA data suggest that, although the perennial habit is primitive within the section, the annual species of section Coreopsis have likely not originated from an extant perennial species. The estimated proportion of nucleotide differences per site (given as 100p) for the cpDNAs of species in the section ranges from 0.00 to 0.20, which is comparable to or lower than values reported for other congeneric species. The low level of cpDNA divergence is concordant with other data, including cross compatibility, interfertility and allozymes, in suggesting that species of the section are not highly divergent genetically.     

EVIDENCE FOR A CLOSE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN IOSTEPHANE AND VIGUIERA (ASTERACEAE: HELIANTHEAE)

The phylogenetic relationship of Iostephane is assessed using data from morphology, flavonoid chemistry, and chloroplast DNA and nuclear ribosomal DNA restriction fragment analysis. Morphological evidence supports placement of Iostephane in subtribe Helianthinae, but fails to clarify the placement of the genus within this assemblage. Further evidence for the placement of Iostephane in subtribe Helianthinae is provided by the presence in all species of the genus of floral flavonoids of the chalcone/aurone type, which provides a distinctive trait for the subtribe within the tribe Heliantheae. Analysis of chloroplast DNA from two species of Iostephane, I. heterophylla and I. madrensis, in comparison to Viguiera and related genera indicates that the restriction site patterns with 16 enzymes for the Iostephane species are virtually identical to one another as well as to those of Viguiera sect. Maculatae. Data from restriction fragment patterns of nuclear rDNA are concordant with the results from chloroplast DNA in suggesting a direct relationship between the two groups. The close phylogenetic relationship between Iostephane and Viguiera sect. Maculatae suggested by the DNA restriction fragment data was not suggested by any other set of data.     

PHYLOGENETIC IMPLICATIONS OF CHLOROPLAST DNA RESTRICTION SITE VARIATION IN THE MUTISIEAE (ASTERACEAE)

Phylogenetic relationships among 13 species in the tribe Mutisieae and a single species from each of three other tribes in the Asteraceae were assessed by chloroplast DNA restriction site mapping. Initially, 211 restriction site mutations were detected among 16 species using 10 restriction enzymes. Examination of 12 of these species using nine more enzymes revealed 179 additional restriction site mutations. Phylogenetic analyses of restriction site mutations were performed using both Dolio and Wagner parsimony, and the resulting monophyletic groups were statistically tested by the bootstrap method. The phylogenetic trees confirm an ancient evolutionary split in the Asteraceae that was previously suggested by the distribution of a chloroplast DNA inversion. The subtribe Barnadesiinae of the tribe Mutisieae is shown to be the ancestral group within the Asteraceae. The molecular phylogenies also confirm the paraphyly of the Mutisieae and provide statistical support for the monophyly of three of its four currently recognized subtribes (Barnadesiinae, Mutisiinae, and Nassauviinae). The fourth subtribe, Gochnatiinae, is shown to be paraphyletic. Within the subtribes, several closely related generic pairs are identified. Chloroplast DNA sequence divergence among genera of the Asteraceae ranges between 0.7 and 5.4%, which is relatively low in comparison to other angiosperm groups. This suggests that the Asteraceae is either a relatively young family or that its chloroplast DNA has evolved at a slower rate than in other families.     

TRIBAL PLACEMENT OF MARSHALLIA (ASTERACEAE) USING CHLOROPLAST DNA RESTRICTION SITE MAPPING

The examination of morphological traits has failed to resolve the tribal placement of Marshallia. Suggested relationships for this anomalous genus have, at various times, included Eupatorieae, Heliantheae, Vemonieae, and Inuleae. Chloroplast DNA restriction site mapping, using Bamadesiinae (Mutisieae) as the outgroup, revealed 981 restriction site mutations, 332 of which were phylogenetically informative, for 60 genera representing 15 tribes of Asteraceae. Wagner parsimony produced 36 equally parsimonious tress of 729 steps, and Dollo parsimony produced 34 equally parsimonious trees of 759 steps. Monophyletic groups, resulting from the Wagner analysis, were further tested with the bootstrap method. The placement of Marshallia in the Heliantheae-Tageteae-Coreopsideae-Eupatorieae complex was consistent for all trees produced. Tageteae and Coreopsideae form the sister group to paraphyletic Heliantheae, with Marshallia sharing its most recent common ancestor with Galinsoga, Palafoxia, and Bahia. The Eupatorieae form a monophyletic clade that is derived from helianthoid ancestors.     

AN OVERVIEW OF THE GENUS PYRRHOPAPPUS (ASTERACEAE: LACTUCEAE) WITH EMPHASIS ON CHLOROPLAST DNA RESTRICTION SITE DATA

The genus Pyrrhopappus in recent systematic treatments has comprised five taxa (four species, one with two varieties), which have now been studied anew using morphogeographical and chloroplast DNA restriction site data. Eight populations, representing all of the recognized taxa of Pyrrhopappus, were digested with 17 restriction enzymes. Only three restriction site differences were found from among 750 restriction sites and no length variations were observed. This contrasts with similar studies, using these same enzymes, on the closely related genus Krigia in which 173 mutation sites and 20 length variations were found among the seven species concerned. Nucleotide sequence divergence values among the species of Pyrrhopappus were extremely low (0.0012) compared to much higher values found in the closely related genus Krigia (0.1270). Three species of Pyrrhopappus are herein recognized: two diploids with 2n = 12 chromosomes, P. carolinianus and P. pauciflorus (including P. multicaulis, P. geiseri and P. rothrockii), and a tetraploid (2n = 24), P. grandiflorus. The tetraploid is partially sympatric with both diploids but is readily recognized by its perennial roots, which bear tuber-like enlargements. These three species presumably arose relatively recently, and the DNA data suggest that neither P. pauciflorus nor P. carolinianus gave rise to the tetraploid P. grandiflorus.     

COMPARATIVE MORPHOLOGY OF THE CAPITULUM OF ENCELIOPSIS (ASTERACEAE: HELIANTHEAE)

Features of the capitula of all four species of Enceliopsis were examined with light and scanning electron microscopy, measured, and subjected to univariate analysis. Differences were found in the complement, distribution, and density of trichomes, the size of the receptacle, ray ligule, and disk corolla tube, and the size and shape of the phyllaries, paleae, disk corolla throats, and achenes. Morphology of trichomes, phyllaries, and achenes, as well as other vegetative characteristics, show that E. nudicaulis, E. covillei and E. argophylla form a group separate from E. nutans. Features of the achene suggest affinity of the former group with Geraea, whereas features of the trichomes and achene of E. nutans support affinity with Encelia. Characters of the receptacle, paleae, ray and disk corollas, and achene clearly show that E. nudicaulis, E. covillei, and E. argophylla are distinct.     

CHLOROPLAST DNA VARIATION WITHIN AND AMONG GENERA OF THE HEUCHERA GROUP (SAXIFRAGACEAE): EVIDENCE FOR CHLOROPLAST TRANSFER AND PARAPHYLY

The Heuchera group (Saxifragaceae) comprises Bensoniella, Conimitella, Elmera, Heuchera, Lithophragma, Mitella, Tellima, Tiarella, and Totmiea. Earlier studies employing morphology, karyology, and flavonoid chemistry indicated that these genera form a natural group, but failed to resolve relationships among them. Restriction site analysis of chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) suggests that Bensoniella, Tolmiea, and Lithophragma are close allies and form the sister group of a large clade containing the remaining six genera. Mitella and Heuchera are both paraphyletic based on cpDNA data. cpDNA data, in conjunction with morphological and allozyme data, suggest at least four examples of intersectional hybridization and subsequent chloroplast capture in Heuchera. Several of these events may be explained via a stepping stone model in which the chloroplast genome of a species was captured by a second species, and then ultimately by a third taxon. Two well-differentiated groups of Tellima populations were detected: one group has a unique chloroplast genome characterized by nine autapomorphies, and the second group has a chloroplast genome identical to that found in M. trifida and M. diversifolia. cpDNA and allozyme data suggest that some Tellima populations probably obtained their chloroplast genome via intergeneric hybridization with M. trifida, M. diversifolia, or the ancestor of these taxa. The occurrence of intergeneric chloroplast transfer in some populations of Tellima, as well as extensive intersectional chloroplast capture in Heuchera, not only suggests caution in the use of cpDNA restriction site data in phylogenetic reconstruction, but also demonstrates again the importance of adequate sampling of conspecific populations. If the intergeneric relationships in the Heuchera group suggested by cpDNA analysis are accurate, fundamental questions arise regarding the validity of certain morphological traits as good taxonomic characters in Saxifragaceae. Furthermore, significant taxonomic changes at the generic level would be necessary.     

PHYLOGENETICS OF THE LISIANTHIUS SKINNERI (GENTIANACEAE) SPECIES COMPLEX IN PANAMA UTILIZING DNA RESTRICTION FRAGMENT ANALYSIS

The well-delimited and evolutionary interesting tropical shrub group, the Lisianthius skinneri (Gentianaceae) species complex, was analyzed for variation in nuclear ribosomal DNA and chloroplast DNA by restriction endonuclease fragment analysis. A most parsimonious tree using variations in both DNAs was constructed for seven populations in the group by including an appropriate outgroup. This phylogeny is significantly more compatible with the DNA data than most, but not all, less parsimonious phylogenies. At least two distinct lineages have independently evolved geographically restricted, cloud forest species from the putative ancestral, widespread, and lower elevation L. skinneri. Lisianthius skinneri itself is shown to be paraphyletic with populations derived separately from the two distinct lineages. Except for a switch in the placement of two populations, this DNA-based phylogeny is congruent with an isozyme-based Wagner network depicting relationships in the species complex. Relative rates of divergence, in terms of nuclear ribosomal DNA, chloroplast DNA, isozymes, and morphology, differ markedly within and between lineages. The non-transcribed spacer region of ribosomal DNA is shown to evolve in a manner that is not in accord with a molecular clock hypothesis. Small population sizes, restricted and isolated nature of populations, and probable founder events are suggested as instrumental in causing this lack of concerted divergence within and between lineages of the L. skinneri species complex.     

SYSTEMATIC IMPLICATIONS OF CHLOROPLAST DNA VARIATION IN THE SUBTRIBE MICROSERIDINAE (ASTERACEAE: LACTUCEAE)

Phylogenetic relationships among six of the seven currently recognized genera of the subtribe Microseridinae were examined using comparative restriction site mapping of the chloroplast genome. Complete cleavage maps of 17 enzymes were constructed for 35 of the 46 species in the subtribe and six representative outgroup species from four other subtribes of the Lactuceae. A total of 373 restriction site mutations was detected, 180 of which were phylogenetically informative. The chloroplast DNA mutations were used to generate phylogenetic trees using Dollo, Wagner, and weighted parsimony, and the resulting monophyletic groups were evaluated by the bootstrap method. The results indicate that the Microseridinae is paraphyletic because Stephanomeria is nested within the six core genera of the subtribe. Five of the genera of the Microseridinae are monophyletic, whereas Microseris is paraphyletic because one of its species, M. lindleyi, is more closely related to Agoseris and Nothocalais. The distant relationship of M. lindleyi to the rest of the species of Microseris is enigmatic, especially in view of its known involvement in the origin of two allotetraploid species, M. decipiens and M. heterocarpa. The taxonomic implications of these results lead to a revised classification of Microseris in which the genus Uropappus is revived to accommodate M. lindleyi, and a new genus, Stebbinsoseris, is described to include the allotetraploids. The cpDNA phylogeny is used to evaluate the patterns of character evolution within the Microseridinae, as well as to test previous hypotheses that differences in generation time result in unequal rates of chloroplast DNA evolution.     

PHYLOGENETIC SYSTEMATICS OF THE ULVACEAE (ULVALES,ULVOPHYCEAE) USING CHLOROPLAST AND NUCLEAR DNA SEQUENCES1

Systematic hypotheses for the Ulvaceae were tested using phylogenetic analysis of sequences for the gene encoding the large subunit of RUBISCO, small subunit rDNA and a combined data matrix. Representatives of eight putative ulvaceous genera and twelve additional taxa from the Ulvophyceae and Trebouxiophyceae were included in analyses using maximum parsimony and maximum likelihood criteria. Molecular data supported hypotheses for the Ulvaceae that are based on the early development of vegetative thalli and motile cell ultrastructure. Ulvaceae sensu Floyd and O'Kelly, including Percursaria Bory de Saint‐Vincent, Ulvaria Ruprecht and a complex of closely related species of Chloropelta Tanner, Enteromorpha Link and Ulva L. was supported; however, monophyly of Enteromorpha and Ulva was not supported. The Ulvales and Ulotrichales sensu Floyd and O'Kelly were monophyletic. Blidingia Kylin and Kornmannia Bliding were allied with the former and Capsosiphon Gobi with the latter, although relationships among these and other taxa in these orders remain uncertain. The Ulvales are characterized by an isomorphic life history pattern, gametangia and sporangia that are identical in structure and development, motile cells with bilobed terminal caps and proximal sheaths consisting of two equal subunits. Method of motile cell release and the gross morphology of vegetative thalli are not systematically reliable characters.     

A PRELIMINARY COMPARISON OF RESTRICTION FRAGMENT PATTERNS IN THE GENUS CAULERPA (CHLOROPHYTA) AND THE UNIQUE STRUCTURE OF THE CHLOROPLAST GENOME OF CAULERPA SERTULARIOIDES1

Comparisons of chloroplast DNA restriction fragments in four species of Caulerpa revealed that patterns between the species were different, with few and possibly no homologous bands. Two forms of Caulerpa sertularioides also revealed different patterns, and it is possible that the forms are separate species. The chloroplast genome in Caulerpa sertularioides f sertularioides (S. G. Gmelin) Howe is 131.4 kb in size and lacks large repeat units. The discovery of another green-algal chloroplast genome that lacks an inverted repeat indicates that this feature is either not ancestral to the Chlorophyceae or has been lost several times. Several gene clusters commonly found in chloroplast DNAs were found to occur in Caulerpa chloroplast DNA, for example, psbD/C, atpF/H, and psaA/B. The 16S and 23s rRNA, which are typically adjacent, contained in an inverted repeat, and cotranscribed, are over 40 kb apart. Genes rps12 and tufA, members of the str operon in eubacteria, are over 50 kb in distance from each other in Caulerpa. The gene order in Caulerpa is unlike any other chloroplast genome characterized to date.     

BIAS IN INHERITANCE OF CHLOROPLAST DNA AND MECHANISMS OF HYBRIDIZATION BETWEENWIND- AND INSECT-POLLINATED EUPATORIUM (ASTERACEAE)

Hybrids of the wind-pollinated E. capillifolium and the insect-pollinated E. serotinum were found to occur in the Coastal Plain of Louisiana, Mississippi, and southern Arkansas and on the Piedmont in three locations. Interspecific cross-pollination occurs when wind causes the flexible flowering branches of E. capillifolium to whisk over the stiff upright branches of E. serotinum plants. Interspecific pollen was found to be captured by E. serotinum more effectively than by E. capillifolium. However, analysis of cpDNA of natural field hybrids indicated that most were maternally descended from E. capillifolium. This latter bias can be explained by the far greater number of flowers, and thus greater seed producing capacity, of E. capillifolium relative to E. serotinum. Morphological variability observed among field hybrids suggests that backcrossing has occurred; however, field hybrids and progeny grown from field hybrid achenes generally had low pollen stainability, irregular meiosis, and reduced achene set. Furthermore, field hybrids were found to have a chromosome number of 2n = 20, like the parental species, whereas progeny grown from field hybrids had deficiencies and duplications of chromosome numbers. Because these chromosome number deviations were not seen in field hybrids it is logical to suggest that either they are F₁s, or that strong selective forces in the field eliminated the progeny of hybrids with deficiencies and duplications.     

山白树属及其近缘属聚类分析

运用系统聚类分析法,对山白树属及其近缘属进行定量分析,结果表明山白树属与牛鼻栓属亲缘关系密切,可组成一族,该族与蚊母树族有着较近的亲缘。     

ENZYME ELECTROPHORESIS AND EVOLUTIONARY RELATIONSHIPS AMONG THREE SPECIES OF LASTHENIA (ASTERACEAE: HELIANTHEAE)

Enzyme electrophoresis was used to examine variation at 18 gene loci in Lasthenia burkei, L. conjugens, and L. femontii. The species consist of diploid annuals restricted to vernal pools in California; a variety of data has indicated that they are closely related. Populations of the three species are similar at isozyme loci; L. conjugens and L. fremontii are most similar with a genetic identity of 0.965. Lasthenia conjugens and L. burkei are next most similar (0.934), while L. burkei and L. fremontii have an identity of 0.909. Lasthenia burkei and L. femontii each contain a different subset of the alleles found in L. conjugens. Electrophoretic data are concordant with the view that these three species are closely related, but do not support the hypothesis that L. burkei is a stabilized hybrid derivative of L. conjugens and L. fremontii because alleles unique to each of the latter two species are not combined in the former. Rather, distribution of alleles among the three species suggests two possible alternative hypotheses of evolutionary relationships. One hypothesis considers Lasthenia conjugens a hybrid derivative of L. burkei and L. fremontii while the alternative explanation views the latter two species as independent derivatives of the former. Neither of these hypotheses appears to be concordant with morphological data.     

VARIATION IN THE CHLOROPLAST GENES RPOC1 AND RPOC2 OF THE GENUS ASTRAGALUS (FABACEAE): EVIDENCE FROM RESTRICTION SITE MAPPING OF A PCR-AMPLIFIED FRAGMENT

A 4,100-base pair (bp) region of the chloroplast genome, amplified via the polymerase chain reaction, was obtained from 14 species of the genus Astragalus and mapped with 23 restriction enzymes. The amplified region encompassed the chloroplast genes RNA polymerase Cl (rpoCl; 90.8% of the gene) and RNA polymerase C2 (rpoC2; 32.7% of the gene) including the intron in rpoC1 and the intergenic spacer between the two genes. Approximately 144 sites (615 bp) were identified; 37 restriction site mutations and one 10-bp length mutation were detected. Estimated interspecific sequence divergence values ranged from 0.00% to 3.92%. Phylogenetic analysis with Wagner and Dollo parsimony both resulted in a single 41-step tree with a consistency index of 0.951. The relative positions of 115 restriction sites were mapped. The insertion and ten of the restriction site mutations mapped to the intron in rpoC1, 18 site mutations mapped to the rpoC1 exons, three site mutations mapped to rpoC2, three site changes mapped to the intergenic spacer, and four site changes were not mapped. This study demonstrates the utility of restriction site analysis of PCR-amplified chloroplast DNA to the study of plant phylogenetic relationships and molecular evolution.     

GENETIC DIVERGENCE AMONG MEDITERRANEAN AND MACARONESIAN GENERA OF THE SUBTRIBE CHRYSANTHEMINAE (ASTERACEAE)

Genetic variation at 17 isozyme loci was used to assess divergence among the four genera comprising subtribe Chrysantheminae (Anthemideae: Asteraceae). The Macaronesian endemic genus Argyranthemum is supported as monophyletic and is about equally divergent at isozyme loci from the other three genera of the Chrysantheminae, Chrysanthemum, Heteranthemis, and Ismelia. Chrysanthemum is native to the Mediterranean whereas Heteranthemis occurs in southern Iberia and Morocco, and Ismelia is endemic to Morocco. The genera Chrysanthemum and Ismelia have a genetic identity of 0.9283, which is comparable to values often seen for congeneric species and indicates that they should be treated as one genus. The isozyme data indicate that three lines consisting of Argyranthemum, Chrysanthemum-Ismelia, and Heteranthemis radiated rapidly from a common ancestor. Divergence times estimated from isozyme data suggest that the initial radiation of the three lines occurred 2.5–3.0 mya. If this is so, then Argyranthemum or its ancestor arrived in Macaronesia after all the islands except La Palma and El Hierro were formed. The evolutionary history of the subtribe is discussed in relation to the climatic and geological events that took place in the Western Mediterranean between the Tertiary and Quaternary, i.e., the first Northern Hemisphere glaciation and desertification of the Sahara region. The high mean genetic identities between species of Argyranthemum suggest that it might have subsequently undergone a second more recent radiation in the Macaronesian Islands. Also, the high mean identity (0.860) between populations in Chrysanthemum and Ismelia suggest that these continental genera might be in the early stages of secondary speciation.     

ORIGINS OF GENOTYPIC VARIATION IN NORTH AMERICAN DANDELIONS INFERRED FROM RIBOSOMAL DNA AND CHLOROPLAST DNA RESTRICTION ENZYME ANALYSIS

Restriction enzyme analysis of ribosomal DNA (rDNA) and chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) is used to assess the relative contribution of hybridization and mutation as sources of genotypic variation in weedy asexual dandelions, with focus on the dandelion flora of North America. Of 318 North American dandelions surveyed, 145 rDNA-cpDNA clones are detected. The combined rDNA-cpDNA genotypes show that most of the polymorphic rDNA and cpDNA restriction sites or lengths in these plants are also present in weedy asexual dandelions collected from natural populations in Europe and in asexual and diploid taxa (microspecies) chosen to represent diverse Eurasian members of the genus. However, of 222 combined rDNA-cpDNA genotypes found in 427 asexual plants surveyed, only 9 genotypes are found in both North American and Eurasian dandelions. Two rDNA and three cpDNA characters are unique to individual plants in North America and are consistent with mutational origins of genotypic variation in asexual lineages. But the array of genotypic diversity, characterized by different combinations of the rDNA and cpDNA characters, show that multiple hybridization events are a more important source of genotypic variation than mutation in the asexual polyploids. The rDNA and cpDNA data also indicate polyphyletic origin of several asexual Taraxacum taxa.     

CHLOROPLAST DNA SYSTEMATICS OF LILIOID MONOCOTS: RESOURCES,FEASIBILITY, AND AN EXAMPLE FROM THE ORCHIDACEAE

Although chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) analysis has been widely and successfully applied to systematic and evolutionary problems in a wide variety of dicots, its use in monocots has thus far been limited to the Poaceae. The cpDNAs of grasses are significantly altered in arrangement relative to the genomes of most vascular plants, and thus the available clone banks of grasses are not particularly useful in studying variation in the cpDNA of other monocots. In this report, we present mapping studies demonstrating that cpDNAs of four lilioid monocots (Allium cepa, Alliaceae; Asparagus sprengeri, Asparagaceae; Narcissus × hybridus, Amaryllidaceae; and Oncidium excavatum, Orchidaceae), which, while varying in size over as much as 18 kilobase pairs, conform to the genome arrangement typical of most vascular plants. A nearly complete (99.2%) clone bank was constructed from restriction fragments of the chloroplast genome of Oncidium excavatum; this bank should be useful in cpDNA analysis among the monocots and is available upon request. As an example of the utility of filter hybridization using this clone bank to detect systematically useful variation, we present a Wagner parsimony analysis of restriction site data from the controversial genus Trichocentrum and several sections of Oncidium, popularly known as the “mule ear” and “rat tail oncidiums.” Because of their vastly different floral morphology, the species of Trichocentrum have never been placed in Oncidium, although several authors have recently suggested a close relationship to this vegetatively modified group. The analysis of cpDNA presented here supports this affinity; in fact, it places Trichocentrum as a derivative of the mule ear oncidiums.