Differential Interaction Between PAV-like Isolates of Barley Yellow Dwarf Virus and Barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) genotypes

Four PAV-like isolates of barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV) were identified as causing very severe (RG), severe (2t), moderately severe (3b) and mild symptoms (13t) in barley (Hordeum vulgare) cultivar Plaisant in a growth chamber at 25 days after inoculation. These isolates had different effects on a range of barley genotypes. Cultivar Vixen, which contains the Yd2 resistance gene, and 80-81 BQCB10 were not affected by any isolate. Five other genotypes were significantly affected by at, least one of the isolates. Line Ea52 (which is a mutant of the Japanese cultivar Chikurine Ibaraki) was more susceptible to BYDV-PAV than Chikurin Ibaraki 1. No serological differences were detected between the four isolates using monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies. Virus antigen concentration, estimated by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), was correlated with the decrease in the shoot fresh weight for all isolates and all genotypes except for Vixen and 80-81BQCB10. In field tests, the severity of symptoms induced by the BYDV-PAV isolates was in accordance with that estimated in the growth chamber. However isolate 2t was more severe on cultivar Vixen and overcame the partial resistance of Chikurin Ibaraki 1 to the three other isolates. The results show that virus antigen concentration not only contributes to characterizing the resistance levels of barley genotypes but also the severity of BYDV-PAV isolates.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">rym15</Emphasis> from the Japanese cultivar Chikurin Ibaraki 1 is a new barley mild mosaic virus (BaMMV) resistance gene mapped on chromosome 6H

Breeding for resistant cultivars is the only way to prevent high yield loss in barley caused by the soil-borne barley mild mosaic virus (BaMMV) complex. We have characterized the BaMMV resistance of barley cv. Chikurin Ibaraki 1. Doubled haploid lines were obtained from the F₁ between the susceptible six-rowed winter barley cultivar, Plaisant, and Chikurin Ibaraki 1. Each line was tested for reaction to BaMMV by mechanical inoculation followed by DAS-ELISA. Of 44 microsatellites that covered the genome, 22 polymorphic markers were tested on one susceptible and one resistant bulk, each comprising 30 lines. Differential markers and additional microsatellite markers in the same region were then tested on the whole population. A bootstrap analysis was used to compute confidence intervals of distances and to test the orders of the resistance gene and the closest markers. A segregation of 84 resistant/98 susceptible lines fitted a 1:1 ratio (²=1.08, P=0.30), which corresponds to a single gene in this DH lines population. The resistance gene was flanked by two markers near the centromeric region of chromosome 6HS—Bmag0173, at 0.6±1.2 cM, and EBmac0874, at 5.8 ± 3.4 cM. We propose to name this new resistance gene rym15. This resistance gene and associated markers will increase the possibilities to breed efficiently for new cultivars resistant to the barley mosaic disease.Communicated by P. Langridge     

Dissection of resistance to soil-borne yellow-mosaic-inducing viruses of barley (BaMMV,BaYMV, BaYMV-2) in a complex breeders' cross by means of SSRs and simultaneous mapping of BaYMV/BaYMV-2 resistance of var. 'Chikurin Ibaraki 1'

Ninety-three F(1)-derived doubled haploid (DH) lines from a complex breeders' cross involving the Japanese genotype 'Chikurin Ibaraki 1', which is resistant to barley mild mosaic virus (BaMMV) and two strains of barley yellow mosaic virus (BaYMV and BaYMV-2), three susceptible varieties ('Hamu', 'Julia' and a breeding line) and cv. 'Carola', which carries rym4 conferring resistance to BaMMV and BaYMV, were analysed for resistance to BaMMV, BaYMV and BaYMV-2. The DH lines fell into four phenotypic classes. In addition to completely resistant and susceptible genotypes, DHs were observed which were either resistant to BaMMV and BaYMV or to BaYMV and BaYMV-2. For BaMMV and BaYMV-2 resistance, segregation ratios approaching 1r:1s were observed, suggesting the presence of single resistance genes. In contrast, the segregation ratio for BaYMV fits a 3r:1s segregation ratio, suggesting the presence of two independently inherited genes. From the genetic analysis, we conclude that a resistance locus effective against BaYMV and BaYMV-2 originates from Chikurin Ibaraki 1 and segregates independently from the Carola-derived rym4 resistance that is effective against BaYMV and BaMMV. The BaMMV resistance in Chikurin Ibaraki 1 has probably been lost during population development. This hypothesis was tested using a simple-sequence repeat (SSR) marker (Bmac29) linked to rym4. All BaMMV-resistant DH lines supported amplification of the rym4-resistance diagnostic allele. To identify the genetic location of the Chikurin Ibaraki 1-derived resistance against BaYMV/BaYMV-2, bulked DNA samples were constructed from the four resistance classes, and bulked segregant analysis was performed using a genome-wide collection of SSRs. Differentiating alleles were observed at two linked SSRs on chromosome 5H. The location of this BaYMV/BaYMV-2 resistance locus was confirmed and further resolved by linkage analysis on the whole population using a total of five linked SSRs.     

QTL analysis of tolerance to a German strain of BYDV-PAV in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.)

One hundred and forty six barley doubled-haploid lines (DH lines) were tested for variation in grain yield, yield components, plant height, and heading date after artificial infection with a German isolate of barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV-PAV-Braunschweig). Of these 146 lines 76 were derived from the cross of the barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV) tolerant cultivar ’Post’ to cv ’Vixen’ (Ryd2) and 70 from the cross of Post to cv ’Nixe’. Phenotypic measurements were gathered on both non-infected plants and plants artificially inoculated with BYDV-PAV by viruliferous aphids in pot and field experiments for three years at two locations. For all traits a continuous variation was observed suggesting a quantitative mode of inheritance for tolerance against BYDV-PAV. Using skeleton maps constructed using SSRs, AFLPs and RAPDs, two QTLs for relative grain yield per plant after BYDV infection, explaining about 47% of the phenotypic variance, were identified in Post × Vixen at the telomeric region of chromosome 2HL and at a region containing the Ryd2 gene on chromosome 3HL. In Post × Nixe, a QTL was found in exactly the same chromosome 2HL marker interval. In this cross, additional QTL were mapped on chromosomes 7H and 4H and together these explained about 40% of the phenotypic variance. QTL for effects of BYDV infection on yield components, plant height, and heading date generally mapped to the same marker intervals, or in the vicinity of the QTL for relative grain yield, on chromosomes 2HL and 3HL, suggesting that these regions are of special importance for tolerance to the Braunschweig isolate of BYDV-PAV. Possible applications of marker-assisted selection for BYDV tolerance based on these results are discussed. Received: 1 December 2000 / Accepted: 9 March 2001     

Virulence of Septoria nodorum as Affected by Passage Through Detached Leaves of Wheat and Barley Cultivars1

Abstract Three genetically marked, single–spore isolates of Septoria nodorum from wheat were passed through detached leaves of wheat cvs Blueboy and Coker 747 and the barley cv. Boone to produce three sub–isolates per original isolate. Each sub–isolate was cultured for three pycnidiospore generations on its respective host. Virulence of each sub–isolate on detached leaves of Blueboy, Caldwell, Coker 747, and NK81W701 wheat, and Boone and Surry barley was compared with that of the original single–spore isolate from which it was derived. In most cases, sub–isolates passed through wheat were significantly more virulent than the originals on wheat cultivars. They also were more virulent to barley than the original isolates but they were less virulent to barley than to wheat cultivars. Isolate × cultivar interactions were statistically significant (P < .0001) for isolates passed through wheat or barley and were greater than isolate × cultivar interactions among the original isolates. In seven of eight isolates passed through wheat or barley, only the original genetic marker was recovered after three generations, indicating that cross–contamination could not account for the observed change of virulence. In the single case of apparent contamination, of a sub–isolate, virulence declined.     

Pathogenicity of three RPV isolates of Barley Yellow Dwarf Virus on barley, wheat and wheat alien addition lines

Barleys with and without the Yd₂ resistance factor, wheat alien addition stocks with other barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV) resistance factors and true wheats were challenged with three Australian isolates of BYDV-RPV. Yd₂ resistance was effective against two of the BYDV-RPV isolates and inoculated barleys which carry Yd₂ did not develop BYD symptoms and shoot growth was not affected. However, barleys with Yd₂ were susceptible to the third BYDV-RPV isolate. All barley lines inoculated with the third virus isolate developed typical BYD symptoms (yellowing), shoot growth was reduced compared to uninfected controls and virus titres determined by ELISA were high and similar in barleys with and without Yd₂. In contrast, resistances from Thinopyrum intermedium and Agropyron pulcherrimum in wheat backgrounds were effective against all three BYDV-RPV isolates. Shoot growth of inoculated plants with either of these resistance factors did not differ from uninfected controls and virus titres determined by ELISA were very low.     

Genetic Adaptation of Erysiphc graminis f. sp. Hordei to Barley with Partial Resistance

Ten Isolates of powdery mildew were tested on three spring barley cultivars known to express partial resistance and on Golden Promise. Measurements of colony lengths were made under several different environments and compared with similar data produced from several cultivars containing one of two major resistance genes. Significant isolate, cultivar and environment interactions were recorded and one isolate in particular showed adaptation to a partially resistant cultivar. Measurements of infection frequency were also made under two temperature regimes. Again significant isolate, cuitivar and temperature interactions were recorded and the same isolate showed adaptation to the same partially resistant cultivar. This indicates that adaptation to a source of partial resistance can be found amongst unselected isolates and that pleiotropically adapted genotypes may rapidly overcome such resistance in the field following its widespread deployment. Other genes for resistance were detected in the major gene cultivars, including partial resistance in the ml-v genotypes.     

The Yd2 resistance to barley yellow dwarf virus is effective in barley plants but not in their leaf protoplasts

The Yd2 gene for "resistance" to barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV) has been widely used in barley ( Hordeum vulgare ). We have tested Australian isolates of BYDV of varying severity against barley genotypes with and without the Yd2 gene and report here a positive relationship between symptoms and virus levels determined by ELISA. Cultivar Shannon is the result of backcrossing the resistant line CI 3208 to cultivar Proctor, a susceptible line. It appears to be intermediate in reaction to BYDV between Proctor and CI 3208, although it carries the major gene, Yd2. Unlike the whole plant studies, no significant differences were observed with regard to the ability of protoplasts derived from these various genotypes to support BYDV replication. It is therefore demonstrated for the first time that the Yd2 gene is not among the small number of resistance genes which are effective against virus replication in isolated protoplasts.     

Assessment of the Seedling Reactions of Turkish Barley Cultivars to Scald

The reactions of 37 cultivars and two candidate lines of barley to five isolates of Rhynchosporium secalis and their mixtures were determined in assays under greenhouse conditions. Fungal isolates were collected from Ankara province and surrounding areas in Turkey. There were clear differences in the reactions of the cultivars to the fungal isolates and isolates differed in pathogenicity for each cultivar. Of all genotypes tested, seven cultivars (cvs Erginel 90, ?ahin 91, K?ral 97, Akhisar 98, Çetin 2000, Çumra 2001, Avc? 2002) and one candidate line (candidate 4) were found to be resistant to all isolates and their mixtures. A5 was found to be the most virulent fungal isolate.     

Quantitative Differences in Powdery Mildew Resistance Among Spring Barley Cultivars

Quantitative powdery mildew resistance in compatible host-pathogen-combinations was measured by the number of pastules/cm² leaf area. Spring barley cultivar ‘Proctor’ was significantly less infected than ‘Golden Promise”. Using these two cultivars (having no effective major resistance gene) as controls, MO- and AR-resistant cultivars were inoculated with virulent mildew isolates. ‘Mona”, ‘Grit’ and ‘Nudinka’ had a higher or, at least, the same level of quantitative resistance as ‘Proctor”. None of the remaining cultivars showed the high susceptibility expressed by ‘Golden Promise”. Ranking of host genotypes was nearly constant while that of mildew isolates varied considerably. Only a small portion of the observed variance was due to interaction between host cultivars and pathogen isolates. ‘Triesdorfer Diva’ gave a resistant infection type after inoculation with different AR-virulent isolates, indicating that this cultivar has major resistance other than that conditioned by gene Ml-a12.     

Four QTL in Rice Associated with Broad Spectrum Resistance to Blast Isolates from Rice and Barley

Pyricularia grisea is the most destructive and cosmopolitan fungal pathogen of rice and it can also cause disease on other agriculturally important cereals. We determined the number, location and interaction of quantitative trait loci (QTL) associated with resistance to P. grisea isolates obtained from rice (THL142 and THL222) and barley (TH16 and THL80) grown in Thailand. The isolates showed a spectrum of virulence when used to inoculate a series of differentials. We used a reference blast resistance mapping population of rice (IR64 × Azucena). IR64 was highly resistant, and Azucena was highly susceptible, to all four isolates. The numbers of resistant vs. susceptible progeny suggest that the resistance of IR64 is determined by two or three genes with additive effects. The correlation coefficients for all pairwise comparisons of disease severity were high and highest between barley isolates and between rice isolates. Four QTL were detected, one on each of the following chromosomes 2, 8, 9 and 10. IR64 contributed resistance alleles at three of the QTL (chromosomes 2, 8 and 9). Azucena contributed the resistance allele at the QTL on chromosome 10 in response to inoculation with isolate THL142. The results of the QTL analysis support interpretation of the phenotypic frequency distributions regarding the number of genes determining resistance to the four isolates in this population. Our results are novel in adding blast isolates from barley to the catalogue of pathogen specificities to which a gene, or genes, from IR64 confer resistance.     

Seedling and adult stage resistance to net form of net blotch (NFNB) in spring barley and stability of adult stage resistance to NFNB in Morocco

This study was conducted to identify stable resistance to net form of net blotch (NFNB) in spring barley in Moroccan environments. Seedling resistance to NFNB was evaluated by inoculating 336 barley genotypes with two NFNB isolates LDNH04Ptt-19 and TD-10 in the greenhouse. These genotypes were evaluated for adult plant resistance to NFNB under seven environments in Morocco in 2015 and 2016. The disease severity was estimated at GS 77–87 on barley leaves using a double-digit scale. To investigate stability of resistance, 149 barley genotypes were subjected to AMMI analysis. At the seedling stage, differential responses of barley genotypes to different NFNB isolates were identified, whereas genotypes had variable stability to NFNB resistance at the adult stages. Five genotypes, AM-68, AM-95, AM-250, AM-267 and AM-322, were resistant to both NFNB isolates at the seedling stage. There were significant (p < .001) effects of genotype (G) and G × E interaction on NFNB severity for barley genotypes at the adult stage. The principal components, IPCA1 and IPCA2, accounted for 48.4% and 18.7% variation for NFNB severity, respectively. The AMMI stability values (ASVs) ranged from 0.01 to 15.5, and fifty-nine barley genotypes had stable responses (ASV ≤ 0.05) across all seven environments. Specifically, two stable genotypes, AM-187 and AM-244, had lower mean NFNB severities across all environments, suggesting a quantitative resistance in these genotypes. Divergent environmental responses of NFNB severity were measured in Sidi El Ayedi 2015 and Sidi Allal Tazi 2016, suggesting that these environments may be suitable to capture resistance to diverse pathotypes. These stable genotypes are valuable resources for introgression of both qualitative resistance and quantitative resistance to NFNB in future.     

Screening for Barley yellow dwarf virus-Resistant Barley Genotypes by Assessment of Virus Content in Inoculated Seedlings

The content of Barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV) in roots and leaves of barley seedling plants differing in their level of resistance was assessed by quantitative ELISA 1–42 days after inoculation with the strain of BYDV (PAV). High virus accumulation in roots and low concentration in leaves was characteristic of the period 9–15 days after inoculation. In leaves, the differences in virus content between resistant and susceptible genotypes became significant after 15 days and resistance to virus accumulation was better expressed 30–39 days after inoculation. Roots of resistant materials exhibited evident retardation of virus accumulation and the greatest difference in virus content between resistant and susceptible plants was detected 9 days after inoculation. By these criteria, the selected winter and spring barley cultivars and lines (in total 44 materials) fell in to five groups according to field reactions and the presence or absence of the Yd2 resistance gene. There were highly significant and positive relations between ELISA values and 5‐year field data on symptomatic reactions and grain‐yield reductions due to infection. Using the described method, resistant and moderately resistant genotypes (both Yd2 and non‐Yd2) were significantly differentiated from susceptible genotypes. The possible use of this method in screening for BYDV resistance is discussed.     

The Response of Lettuce Cultivars against Two Lettuce mosaic virus isolates,One Able to Systemically Infect the Resistant Cultivar Salinas 88

The response of seven lettuce cultivars to two geographically different Lettuce mosaic virus (LMV) isolates (LMV‐A, LMV‐T) was statistically evaluated based on infection rate, virus accumulation and symptom severity in different time trials. LMV‐A is characterized by the ability to systemically infect cv. Salinas 88 (mo1²‐carrying resistant cultivar), and inducing mild mosaic symptoms. Among lettuce cultivars, Varamin (a native cultivar) similar to cv. Salinas showed the most susceptibility to both LMV isolates, whereas another native cultivar, Varesh, was tolerant to the virus with minimal viral accumulation and symptom scores, significantly different from other cultivars at P < 0.05. LMV‐A systemically infects all susceptible lettuce cultivars more rapidly and at a higher rate than LMV‐T. This isolate accumulated in lettuce cultivars at a significantly higher level, determined by semiquantitative ELISA and induced more severe symptoms than LMV‐T isolate at 21 dpi. This is the first evidence for a LMV isolate with ability to systemically infect mo1²‐carrying resistant cultivar of lettuce from Iran. In this study, accumulation level of LMV showed statistically meaningful positive correlation with symptom severity on lettuce plants. Based on the results, three evaluated parameters differed considerably by lettuce cultivar and virus isolate.     

Sensitivity of Resistance to Net Blotch in Barley

The aim of this study was to demonstrate various methods of analysing terminal net blotch, Pyrenophora teres Drechs. f. teres Smedeg., severity data from 15 spring barleys, Hordeum vulgare L., grown in Finnish official variety trials in five environments. The analyses have been developed and used principally by plant breeders for assessing crop yield, but lend themselves to use by plant pathologists. Pyrenophora teres is the major barley phytopathogen in Finland and improved resistance to it is sought. Joint regression analysis (JRA) and an additive main effects and multiplicative interaction (AMMI) model were used to investigate the data. Statistically significant genotype by environment (GE) interaction for resistance was indicated, and this included qualitative (crossover) interactions among genotypes over environments. A stable, non-sensitive, response to net blotch over environments, combined with a low mean score for terminal severity of the disease characterized the six-row barley 'Thule' which showed statistically significant crossover interaction only with 'Tyra'. 'Kustaa' exhibited the lowest mean terminal net blotch severity, but was relatively sensitive to net blotch. 'Arve' exhibited severe terminal net blotch in all environments, was relatively sensitive to environment and exhibited no crossover interaction with other genotypes. AMMI analysis appeared to represent a useful method for analysing these disease severity data, facilitating the selection of useful sources of resistance. Plots of AMMI-adjusted mean net blotch severities against first principal component axis (PCA) scores were informative for differentiating genotype response over environments, and are therefore potentially useful to plant pathologists and barley breeders seeking to gauge and subsequently improve the resistance status of barley to net blotch.     

Interaction Between Root and Leaf Disease Development in Barley Cultivars after Inoculation with Different Isolates of Bipolaris sorokiniana

The relationship between root and leaf infection in 11 cultivars of barley ( Hordeum vulgare ) by different isolates of Bipolaris sorokiniana was investigated in young plants. Roots of 10-day-old seedlings, grown in filterpaper rolls, and the third leaf of 17-day-old seedlings were inoculated with the different isolates and a Disease Development Index (DDI) was calculated.
The rate of lesion development in leaves was higher than in roots, indicated by generally higher DDI after leaf inoculation than after root inoculation. Significant differences in resistance were found among the barley cultivars. Inoculation with different isolates of B. sorokiniana caused significant differences in DDI for both roots and leaves. In the leaves, but not in the roots, a significant cultivar–isolate interaction was found. No significant correlations, neither in isolate aggressiveness nor in cultivar reaction between root and leaf, were observed.     

Responses of some Asian and European barley cultivars to UK and Chinese isolates of soil-borne barley mosaic viruses

In field plots at Yancheng, Jiangsu, China, a range of European and Asian barley cultivars was grown in soil from three sites in China infested with barley yellow mosaic virus (BaYMV). Most of the cultivars resistant to the common European strain of BaYMV were susceptible to the Chinese isolates but cv. Energy remained disease-free. Barley mild mosaic virus (BaMMV) was also detected in one of these soils but affected only one Chinese cultivar and not those susceptible to BaMMV in Europe. This is the first report of BaMMV in China. Inoculation experiments confirmed the different cultivar response to UK and Chinese isolates of BaYMV and showed that resistance was to the virus and not to the vector. A range of Chinese cultivars selected for resistance to BaYMV were also resistant to a UK isolate of BaMMV.     

Screening for Barley Yellow Dwarf Luteovirus Resistance in Barley on the Basis of Virus Movement

The movement of barley yellow dwarf luteovirus (BYDV) was evaluated in susceptible and resistant barley and bread wheat genotypes. After leaf inoculation, the virus infected the root system and the growing point of susceptible earlier than resistant, barley genotypes. No difference in virus movement occurred in resistant and susceptible wheat genotypes. It was possible to reliably differentiate susceptible from resistant genotypes when root extracts of 41 barley genotypes were tested by DAS-ELISA 3 or 4 days after inoculation at the oneleaf stage. When barley plants inoculated at the two- or three-leaf stage were assayed by tissue-blot ELISA on nitrocellulose membrane, virus was detected in the phloem vessels of the growing points of the susceptible, but not of the resistant genotype, 4–6 days after inoculation. Our results thus suggest that screening for BYDV resistance in barley could be done quickly and cheaply especially when assays are made by the tissue-blot test.     

Serological and biological characterisation of isolates of barley yellow dwarf virus in Sweden in 1983

In 1983, cereal plants showing symptoms of barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV), collected from 15 localities in Sweden, were tested for BYDV using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Antisera against two Swedish isolates of BYDV were used, a mild isolate (27/77) transmitted specifically by Sitobion avenae and a severe one (39/78) transmitted mainly by Rhopalosiphum padi. No virus was detected in 57 of 607 plants of oats and barley tested. Of the 550 plants in which virus was detected, 366 were infected with viruses similar to isolate 27/77, 116 with viruses similar to 39/78 and the remaining 68 reacted strongly with both antisera. When tested, the latter isolates were shown to be mixtures. Thirty-nine selected samples were also tested with antisera against the USA isolates RPV, RMV, MAV and PAV, and for transmission by S. avenae and R. padi. Twenty-six of these samples were transmitted specifically by S. avenae, one was transmitted only by R. padi and the remaining 12 samples were shown to be infected with a mixture of an S. avenae-specific isolate and one transmitted mainly by R. padi. Antisera against PAV and MAV each detected all isolates tested and the results were very similar to those with the antisera to the 39/78 and 27/77 isolates, respectively. None of the field isolates reacted with antisera against RMV or RPV. It was concluded that 1983 was an epidemic year for BYDV in Sweden and that isolates specifically transmitted by S. avenae predominated. Symptoms of infection by these isolates on oat plants ranged from mild to severe.     

A single copy of a virus-derived transgene encoding hairpin RNA gives immunity to barley yellow dwarf virus

Barley yellow dwarf virus–PAV (BYDV-PAV) is the most serious and widespread virus of cereals worldwide. Natural resistance genes against this luteovirus give inadequate control, and previous attempts to introduce synthetic resistance into cereals have produced variable results. In an attempt to generate barley with protection against BYDV-PAV, plants were transformed with a transgene designed to produce hairpin (hp)RNA containing BYDV-PAV sequences. From 25 independent barley lines transformed with the BYDV-PAV hpRNA construct, nine lines showed extreme resistance to the virus and the majority of these contained a single transgene. In the progeny of two independent transgenic lines, inheritance of a single transgene consistently correlated with protection against BYDV-PAV. This protection was rated as immunity because the virus could not be detected in the challenged plants by ELISA nor recovered by aphid feeding experiments. In the field, BYDV-PAV is sometimes associated with the related luteovirus Cereal yellow dwarf virus-RPV (CYDV-RPV). When the transgenic plants were challenged with BYDV-PAV and CYDV-RPV together, the plants were susceptible to CYDV-RPV but immune to BYDV-PAV. This shows that the immunity is virus-specific and not broken down by the presence of CYDV. It suggests that CYDV-RPV does not encode a silencing-suppressor gene or that its product does not protect BYDV-PAV against the plant's RNAi-like defence mechanism. Either way, our results indicate that the BYDV-PAV immunity will be robust in the field and is potentially useful in minimizing losses in cereal production worldwide.