Irreversible barrier to the reprogramming of donor cells in cloning with mouse embryos and embryonic stem cells

Somatic cloning does not always result in ontogeny in mammals, and development is often associated with various abnormalities and embryo loss with a high frequency. This is considered to be due to aberrant gene expression resulting from epigenetic reprogramming errors. However, a fundamental question in this context is whether the developmental abnormalities reported to date are specific to somatic cloning. The aim of this study was to determine the stage of nuclear differentiation during development that leads to developmental abnormalities associated with embryo cloning. In order to address this issue, we reconstructed cloned embryos using four- and eight-cell embryos, morula embryos, inner cell mass (ICM) cells, and embryonic stem cells as donor nuclei and determined the occurrence of abnormalities such as developmental arrest and placentomegaly, which are common characteristics of all mouse somatic cell clones. The present analysis revealed that an acute decline in the full-term developmental competence of cloned embryos occurred with the use of four- and eight-cell donor nuclei (22.7% vs. 1.8%) in cases of standard embryo cloning and with morula and ICM donor nuclei (11.4% vs. 6.6%) in serial nuclear transfer. Histological observation showed abnormal differentiation and proliferation of trophoblastic giant cells in the placentae of cloned concepti derived from four-cell to ICM cell donor nuclei. Enlargement of placenta along with excessive proliferation of the spongiotrophoblast layer and glycogen cells was observed in the clones derived from morula embryos and ICM cells. These results revealed that irreversible epigenetic events had already started to occur at the four-cell stage. In addition, the expression of genes involved in placentomegaly is regulated at the blastocyst stage by irreversible epigenetic events, and it could not be reprogrammed by the fusion of nuclei with unfertilized oocytes. Hence, developmental abnormalities such as placentomegaly as well as embryo loss during development may occur even in cloned embryos reconstructed with nuclei from preimplantation-stage embryos, and these abnormalities are not specific to somatic cloning.     

Genomic potential in mammals

Embryos of amphibians, fish, sheep, cattle, swine and rabbits have been multiplied by nuclear transfer. Successful nuclear transfer in these species has been accomplished by transfer of a blastomere from a late stage embryo into an enucleated oocyte or egg with large scale multiplication achieved by serial repetition of the procedure using blastomeres from nuclear transfer embryos. This allows the production of clonal lines, which when appropriately selected for performance in a given trait, can be reproduced to capture in the offspring expression of both additive and nonadditive inheritance. The efficiency of producing offspring from nuclear transfer is low in mammals in both frequency of morula or blastocyst produced and maintenance of pregnancy after embryo transfer. In domestic animals the largest number of offspring from one embryo has been eight calves. Embryos as late as the 64-cell stage in cattle and 120-cell blastocyst in sheep have been used successfully as donors of blastomeres. Recloning has also been done in cattle. Potentially, nuclear transfer provides a mechanism for multiplication and production testing of clonal lines, a method for rapid genetic improvement and a means for rapid propagation of a selected genotype.     

The effect of donor cell serum starvation and oocyte activation compounds on the development of somatic cell cloned embryos

Two experiments, one comparing nuclear transfer (NT) embryo activation compounds, the other donor cell treatments, were conducted with a goal of identifying factors that improve the in vitro development of cloned bovine embryos. In experiment 1, 539 NT embryos were produced by combining serum starved bovine fetal fibroblasts with enucleated in vitro matured oocytes, activated with ionomycin, then randomly allocated to be incubated for 4 hours in either Butyrolactone-I (BL-I) or 6-dimethylaminopurine (DMAP). There was no significant difference in development to blastocyst or compact morula of fused embryos at Day 6.5 between BL-I and DMAP activated embryos (22.4% vs. 20.2%; p = 0.18). Karyotyping of 20 blastocysts and compact morula from each group determined that 65% of BL1 and 63% of DMAP embryos were diploid with the remainder mixoploid (2n + 4n). In Experiment 2, the development of 389 NT embryos reconstructed from either serum starved or serum fed fetal fibroblasts was assessed. More Day 7 blastocysts and compact morula developed in the serum starved group (34.5% vs. 18.8%; p = 0.008). To verify the viability of BL-I activated embryos, 10 blastocytes from experiment 2 were transferred into 4 recipient cows. Two morphologically normal fetuses, genetically identical to the original fetal cell line, were surgically recovered at day 45 of gestation. In summary, serum starvation of bovine fetal fibroblasts prior to NT significantly improved development to blastocyst. Additionally, we have shown that BL-I is a novel alternative compound for use in combination with ionomycin to activate NT embryos.     

Development of the techniques for nuclear transfer in pigs

Nuclear transfer in pigs was developed in the late 1980's. The techniques were based on previous studies in frogs, mice and cattle. Within stage nuclear transfer, pronuclear exchange, was followed by the transfer of nuclei from cleavage stage embryos. While these have resulted in term development, many problems remain. Recently progress on the problem of inadequate oocyte activation has been made and now there can be a refocus on the other aspects of the nuclear transfer procedure. The emphasis in developing the cloning/transgenic technology is easily justified, not so much by the ability to produce genetically identical animals for production agriculture, but for the potential to use a cell line that can be genetically engineered prior to the nuclear transfer. Pigs with specific genetic modifications will have a great impact on production agriculture as well as human medicine.     

克隆动物研究进展

本文介绍了世界上和中国采用细胞核移植技术克隆动物的研究历史。综述了细胞核移植的程序、方法和影响因素,包括受体卵母细胞的去核、供体细胞核的制备、核移植、激活、受体细胞与供体细胞的融合、重组胚的体内和体外培养以及胚胎移植产生克隆动物。对克隆动物研究和应用前景进行了讨论。近期的研究结果表明,多代克隆可产生大量遗传性相同的动物,不久的将来克隆技术在商业上的应用将成为现实。     

Mosaic gene expression in nuclear transfer-derived embryos and the production of cloned transgenic pigs from ear-derived fibroblasts

Genetically modified domestic animals have many potential applications ranging from basic research to production agriculture. One of the goals in transgenic animal production schemes is to reliably predict the expression pattern of the foreign gene. Establishing a method to screen genetically modified embryos for transgene expression before transfer to surrogates may improve the likelihood of producing offspring with the desired expression pattern. In order to determine how transgene expression may be regulated in the early embryo, we generated porcine embryos from two distinct genetically modified cell lines by using the nuclear transfer (NT) technique. Both cell lines expressed the enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP); the first was a fibroblast cell line derived from the skin of a newborn pig that expressed eGFP, whereas the second was a fetal derived fibroblast cell line into which the eGFP gene was introduced by a retroviral vector. The reconstructed embryos were activated by electrical pulses and cultured in NCSU23. Although the in vitro developmental ability of each group of NT embryos was not different, the eGFP expression pattern was different. All embryos produced from the transduced fetal cell line fluoresced, but only 26% of the embryos generated from the newborn cell line fluoresced, and among those that did express eGFP, more than half had a mosaic expression pattern. This was unexpected because the fetal cell line was not clonally selected, and each cell had potentially different sites of integration. Embryos generated from the newborn cell line were surgically transferred to five surrogate gilts. One gilt delivered four female piglets, all of which expressed eGFP, and all had microsatellites identical to the donor. Here we demonstrate that transgene expression in all the blastomeres of an NT embryo is not uniform. In addition, transgene expression in a genetically manipulated embryo may not be an accurate indicator of expression in the resulting offspring.     

Nuclear transfer of porcine embryos using cryopreserved delipated blastomeres as donor nuclei

Nuclear transfer protocol for the pig using cryopreserved delipated four- to eight-cell and morula stage embryos as nucleus donors was developed. Donor embryos, which had been delipated by micromanipulation following centrifugation for polarizing cytoplasmic lipid droplets, were cryopreserved with 1.5 M 1,2-propanediol and 0.1 M sucrose. Recipient cytoplasts were prepared from ovulated oocytes. Activation of oocytes could be induced more efficiently when electric stimulation was given 53 hr after the hCG injection or later (66–83%), compared with 52 hr or earlier (11–16%, P < 0.05), suggesting that aging after ovulation may be required for in vivo matured porcine oocytes to be activated by electric stimuli. Membrane fusion rates between donor blastomeres and enucleated oocytes were 88% (127/144) and 97% (56/58, P > 0.05) for the four- to eight-cell and morula stage embryos, respectively. In vitro developmental rates to the two-cell (53/100 vs. 35/65), four-cell (34/100 vs. 26/65), and morula stage (17/100 vs. 18/65) were the same between the nuclear transfer embryos with four- to eight-cell and morula nuclei. However, more embryos reconstituted with morula nuclei developed to blastocysts (15% vs. 6%, P < 0.05). These data demonstrated that blastomeres of cryopreserved, delipated porcine embryos can be used as donor nuclei for nuclear transfer. Frozen-thawed, delipated blastomeres can be efficiently isolated and fused, and therefore provide a useful source of donor nuclei. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 48:339–343, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

in vitro development of porcine enucleated oocytes reconstructed by the transfer of porcine fetal fibroblasts and cumulus cells

In the pig little information is available on cytoplasmic events during the reprogramming of oocytes reconstructed with somatic nuclei. The present study was conducted to determine the developmental potential of porcine cumulus cells (CC) and fetal fibroblasts (FF) after they were transferred into enucleated oocytes. Non-quiescent FF were fused to the enucleated oocytes using electrical pulse, whereas CC were directly injected into the oocytes. Transferred nuclei from both CC and FF underwent premature chromosome condensation (PCC), nuclear swelling and pronucleus formation. The remodeled oocytes developed to the mitotic and 2-cell stage at 18 to 24 h after nuclear transfer. The pattern of nuclear remodeling was similar regardless of the sources of karyoplasts or nuclear transfer methods. However, using FF, 24% of nuclear transferred embryos developed to the morula or blastocyst stage, whereas only 8% of those using CC developed to the morula or blastocyst stage. These results suggest that porcine oocyte cytoplasm can successfully reprogram somatic cell nuclei and support the development of nuclear transferred embryos to the blastocyst stage.     

Nuclear lamin antigens are developmentally regulated during porcine and bovine embryogenesis

The nuclear lamins, proteins that reside on the inner face of the nuclear envelope, are thought to provide attachment sites for anchoring the chromatin to the nuclear envelope, thus facilitating the overall organization of the nucleus. The composition of the nuclear lamin proteins changes during differentiation and development in a variety of mammalian and nonmammalian tissues. Bovine and porcine oocytes and early embryos were prepared for immunocytochemical detection of nuclear lamins using three different antibodies (recognizing lamin B, lamins A/B/C, or lamins A/C). In both species, germinal vesicle nuclei and early cleavage stage nuclei react positively with the antibodies. However, on nuclei of bovine embryos, the A/C epitope was not detectable at the 16-cell stage, compact morula, spherical blastocyst, or the chorionic cell nuclei of a Day 35 conceptus, but was detectable on both amniotic and embryonic ectodermal cell nuclei of a Day 35 conceptus. All three antibodies reacted with nuclei from two bovine tissue culture cell lines (bovine embryonic cells and Madin-Darby bovine kidney cells) and one porcine kidney cell line. Nuclei in porcine embryos followed a similar pattern, except the loss of the A/C epitope occurred at the 8-cell stage and the epitope was absent from compact morula and spherical blastocyst stage nuclei. All interphase nuclei in both species reacted with both anti-lamin A/B/C and anti-lamin B antibodies, whereas metaphase chromosomes did not react with any of the lamin antibodies tested. The change in recognizing the lamin epitope occurred one cell cycle after the expected transition from maternal control to zygotic control of development. Nuclear transplantation showed that 16-cell stage porcine nuclei, which are lamin A/C negative, acquired the A/C epitope after transfer to an enucleated metaphase II oocyte. These results suggest that the A/C epitope is developmentally regulated.     

Development of porcine embryos from the one-cell stage to blastocyst in mouse oviducts maintained in organ culture

Successful development of porcine embryos from the one-cell stage to the blastocyst stage has been accomplished using mouse oviducts in organ culture. One-cell embryos were transferred to mouse oviducts maintained in organ culture and were cultured for 6 days. Control embryos from each donor pig were cultured in a modified Krebs-Ringer bicarbonate medium. Thus control and experimental embryos obtained from the same individual pig could be directly compared. At the end of the culture period, all embryos were scored for the stage of development attained and stained to allow the cell number of each embryo to be counted. In medium alone, only 35.7% of the one-cell embryos reached the morula or blastocyst stage, whereas 78.1% of the one-cell embryos transferred to mouse oviducts reached the morula or blastocyst stage. Of those embryos reaching the morula or blastocyst stage, cell numbers were similar for the two treatments (medium alone vs. oviduct culture). The procedure described for mouse oviduct organ culture provides a simple method for culturing early-stage pig embryos to the morula or blastocyst stage prior to embryo transfer.     

In vitro development of ovine embryos in CZB medium

One- to four-cell embryos were collected from multiparous crossbred ewes and were cultured in vitro for 120 hours in CZB medium. A 2x2 factorial treatment arrangement was used to examine the effects of glucose and ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) on in vitro embryo development. The embryos were examined every 12 hours, and all of the embryos were stained with a DNA-specific fluorochrome after the 120-hour evaluation to enable the counting of cell nuclei. Embryo development was analyzed for cleavage beyond 16 cells as well as for cleavage to at least the compact morula stage based upon both the 120-hour morphological evaluation and nuclear counts. Forty-eight percent of the embryos passed through the in vitro developmental block (i.e., cleaved beyond 16 cells), and 26% developed to 30 or more cells. Neither EDTA nor glucose affected in vitro embryo development based on the nuclear counts.     

Nuclear transfer in the bovine embryo: a comparison of 5-day, 6-day, frozen-thawed, and nuclear transfer donor embryos

Micromanipulation and electrofusion were utilized for nuclear transfer in bovine embryos. Embryonic blastomeres from 5-day (estrus = day 0), 6-day, frozen-thawed 5-day, and first-generation nuclear transfer embryos (embryos were themselves a product of nuclear transfer with the original donor being a 5-day embryo) were transferred into bisected bovine oocytes by electrofusion. The percentage of donor cells fusing with the recipient oocytes was compared between different types of donor embryos. The percentage of embryos developing normally into morula or blastocysts following 6 days culture in the sheep oviduct was also recorded and compared between different donor embryo types. No significant differences were found between donor blastomeres for the percent successfully fused to oocytes: 5-day, 294 of 513 (57.3%); 6-day, 252 of 405 (62.2%); frozen-thawed 5-day, 111 of 144 (77.1%); nuclear transfer, 142 of 223 (63.7%); or the percent developing normally following nuclear transfer: 5-day, 92 of 444 (20.7%); 6-day, 84 of 357 (23.5%); frozen-thawed 5-day, 32 of 127 (25.2%); nuclear transfer, 31 of 199 (15.6%). These data suggest that a variety of donor embryos can successfully be utilized for bovine embryo cloning. Also, development of blastomeres from frozen-thawed 5-day donors and from donors that are themselves the product of nuclear transfer suggest that the production of multiple identical offspring is possible by frozen storage of seed stock and serial recloning.     

Allele‐specific expression of the MAOA gene and X chromosome inactivation in in vitro produced bovine embryos

During embryogenesis, one of the two X chromosomes is inactivated in embryos. The production of embryos in vitro may affect epigenetic mechanisms that could alter the expression of genes related to embryo development and X chromosome inactivation (XCI). The aim of this study was to understand XCI during in vitro, pre‐implantation bovine embryo development by characterizing the allele‐specific expression pattern of the X chromosome‐linked gene, monoamine oxidase A (MAOA). Two pools of ten embryos, comprised of the 4‐, 8‐ to 16‐cell, morula, blastocyst, and expanded blastocyst stages, were collected. Total RNA from embryos was isolated, and the RT‐PCR‐RFLP technique was used to observe expression of the MAOA gene. The DNA amplicons were also sequenced using the dideoxy sequencing method. MAOA mRNA was detected, and allele‐specific expression was identified in each pool of embryos. We showed the presence of both the maternal and paternal alleles in the 4‐, 8‐ to 16‐cell, blastocyst and expanded blastocyst embryos, but only the maternal allele was present in the morula stage. Therefore, we can affirm that the paternal X chromosome is totally inactivated at the morula stage and reactivated at the blastocyst stage. To our knowledge, this is the first report of allele‐specific expression of an X‐linked gene that is subject to XCI in in vitro bovine embryos from the 4‐cell to expanded blastocyst stages. We have established a pattern of XCI in our in vitro embryo production system that can be useful as a marker to assist the development of new protocols for in vitro embryo production. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 77: 615–621, 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Mouse fetuses by nuclear transfer from embryonic stem cells

At present, two methods for cloning mammals by nuclear transfer are employed. The first is based on cell fusion and has been applied to domestic animals, such as sheep, cows, and goats. While, nuclear microinjection has been used in mice only. Cloning by nuclear transfer has been reported mainly with cells from primary culture and freshly isolated cells. Here, using ES cell line TT2, we tried to produce clone mouse embryos by the two methods. With ES cell line TT2 (10-13 passaged), 16% of reconstructed oocytes microinjected with the nuclei developed in vitro to the morula/blastocycst stage, and 50% of these embryos developed to fetuses until 14 dpc when transferred to pseudopregnant females. At 20 dpc implanted sites were degenerated and absorbed. Also, in vitro development of embryos reconstructed by electrofusion shown similar results. But, when transferred to recipients, subsequent development of embryos showed lower rates, as compared with embryos microinjected and from recipients live-born pups could not be obtained.     

Asynchronous CDX2 expression and polarization of porcine trophoblast cells reflects a species‐specific trophoderm lineage determination progress model

Upregulation of Cdx2 expression in outer cells is a key event responsible for cell lineage segregation between the inner cell mass and the trophoderm (TE) in mouse morula‐stage embryos. In TE cells, polarization can regulate Hippo and Rho‐associated kinase (Rho‐ROCK) signaling to induce the nuclear location of YAP, which has been demonstrated to further induce the expression of Cdx2. However, we found that CDX2 expression could not be detected in the outer cells of porcine morula‐stage embryos but only in some TE cells at the early blastocyst stage. The biological significance and the regulation mechanism of this species‐specific CDX2 expression pattern have still not been determined. We show here that an asynchronous CDX2 expression pattern exists in porcine TE cells during the development of the blastocyst. We demonstrate that CDX2 expression in porcine TE cells depends on the nuclear localization of YAP and polarization of the embryo through Y27632 treatment. We found that the polarization process in the morula to the late blastocyst stage porcine embryos was asynchronous, which was revealed by the apical localization of phosphorylated EZRIN staining. Artificially enhancing the number of polarized blastomeres by culturing the separated blastomeres of four‐cell stage porcine embryos resulted in increased CDX2‐positive cell numbers. These results indicate that the mechanism of CDX2 expression regulation is conserved, but the polarization progress is not conserved between the pig and the mouse, and results in a species‐specific trophoblast determination progress model.     

Nuclear reprogramming in nuclear transplant rabbit embryos

The first six genetically verified nuclear transplant rabbits have been produced in this study. Individual eight-cell stage embryo blastomeres were transferred and fused with enucleated mature oocytes of which six full-term offspring were produced out of 164 manipulated eggs. The following efficiency rates were determined for the nuclear transplantation procedure: chromosomal removal from oocytes, 92%; fusion rate, 84%; activation rate, 46%; embryo transfer rate, 27%. Additional reasons for the low efficiency rate of nuclear transplant embryos may include limited development due to aging in recipient oocytes and asynchronous transfers of manipulated embryos to recipient females. The successful development to term may have been due to the ability of the mature oocyte to reprogram the eight-cell stage nuclei. The number of cells in blastocysts derived from isolated eight-cell blastomeres (18 +/- .08) was lower than that of nonmanipulated pronuclear (106 +/- 5.1) and nuclear transplant embryos derived from eight-cell stage nuclei (91 +/- 10.2) (p less than 0.001). This evidence along with the significant amount of nuclear swelling in nuclear transplant embryos and a delay in the time of blastocyst formation indicate that nuclear reprogramming had taken place in these embryos. Successful nuclear reprogramming indicates that serial transfers could result in the expanded multiplication of mammalian embryos.     

High in vitro development after somatic cell nuclear transfer and trichostatin A treatment of reconstructed porcine embryos

Abnormal epigenetic modification is supposed to be one of factors accounting for inefficient reprogramming of the donor cell nuclei in ooplasm after somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT). Trichostatin A (TSA) is an inhibitor of histone deacetylase, potentially enhancing cloning efficiency. The aim of our present study was to establish the optimal TSA treatment in order to improve the development of handmade cloned (HMC) porcine embryos and examine the effect of TSA on their development. The blastocyst percentage of HMC embryos treated with 37.5nM TSA for 22-24h after activation increased up to 80% (control group-54%; P<0.05). TSA mediated increase in histone acetylation was proved by immunofluorescence analysis of acH3K9 and acH4K16. 2-cell stage embryos derived from TSA treatment displayed significant increase in histone acetylation compared to control embryos, whereas no significant differences were observed at blastocyst stage. During time-lapse monitoring, no difference was observed in the kinetics of 2-cell stage embryos. Compact morula (CM) stage was reached 15h later in TSA treated embryos compared to the control. Blastocysts (Day 5 and 6) from HMC embryos treated with TSA were transferred to 2 recipients resulting in one pregnancy and birth of one live and five dead piglets. Our data demonstrate that TSA treatment after HMC in pigs may affect reprogramming of the somatic genome resulting in higher in vitro embryo development, and enable full-term in vivo development.