Rotamer strain energy in protein helices - quantification of a major force opposing protein folding

It is widely believed that the dominant force opposing protein folding is the entropic cost of restricting internal rotations. The energetic changes from restricting side-chain torsional motion are more complex than simply a loss of conformational entropy, however. A second force opposing protein folding arises when a side-chain in the folded state is not in its lowest-energy rotamer, giving rotameric strain. chi strain energy results from a dihedral angle being shifted from the most stable conformation of a rotamer when a protein folds. We calculated the energy of a side-chain as a function of its dihedral angles in a poly(Ala) helix. Using these energy profiles, we quantify conformational entropy, rotameric strain energy and chi strain energy for all 17 amino acid residues with side-chains in alpha-helices. We can calculate these terms for any amino acid in a helix interior in a protein, as a function of its side-chain dihedral angles, and have implemented this algorithm on a web page. The mean change in rotameric strain energy on folding is 0.42 kcal mol-1 per residue and the mean chi strain energy is 0.64 kcal mol-1 per residue. Loss of conformational entropy opposes folding by a mean of 1.1 kcal mol-1 per residue, and the mean total force opposing restricting a side-chain into a helix is 2.2 kcal mol-1. Conformational entropy estimates alone therefore greatly underestimate the forces opposing protein folding. The introduction of strain when a protein folds should not be neglected when attempting to quantify the balance of forces affecting protein stability. Consideration of rotameric strain energy may help the use of rotamer libraries in protein design and rationalise the effects of mutations where side-chain conformations change.     

Advantages of fine-grained side chain conformer libraries

We compare the modelling accuracy of two common rotamer libraries, the Dunbrack-Cohen and the 'Penultimate' rotamer libraries, with that of a novel library of discrete side chain conformations extracted from the Protein Data Bank. These side chain conformer libraries are extracted automatically from high-quality protein structures using stringent filters and maintain crystallographic bond lengths and angles. This contrasts with traditional rotamer libraries defined in terms of chi angles under the assumption of idealized covalent geometry. We demonstrate that side chain modelling onto native and near-native main chain conformations is significantly more successful with the conformer libraries than with the rotamer libraries when solely considering excluded-volume interactions. The rotamer libraries are inadequate to model side chains without atomic clashes on over 20% of targets if the backbone is held fixed in the native conformation. An algorithm is described for simultaneously modelling both main chain and side chain atoms during discrete ab initio sampling. The resulting models have equivalent root mean square deviations from the experimentally determined protein loops as models from backbone-only ensembles, indicating that all-atom modelling does not detract from the accuracy of conformational sampling.     

IRECS: a new algorithm for the selection of most probable ensembles of side-chain conformations in protein models

We introduce a new algorithm, IRECS (Iterative REduction of Conformational Space), for identifying ensembles of most probable side-chain conformations for homology modeling. On the basis of a given rotamer library, IRECS ranks all side-chain rotamers of a protein according to the probability with which each side chain adopts the respective rotamer conformation. This ranking enables the user to select small rotamer sets that are most likely to contain a near-native rotamer for each side chain. IRECS can therefore act as a fast heuristic alternative to the Dead-End-Elimination algorithm (DEE). In contrast to DEE, IRECS allows for the selection of rotamer subsets of arbitrary size, thus being able to define structure ensembles for a protein. We show that the selection of more than one rotamer per side chain is generally meaningful, since the selected rotamers represent the conformational space of flexible side chains. A knowledge-based statistical potential ROTA was constructed for the IRECS algorithm. The potential was optimized to discriminate between side-chain conformations of native and rotameric decoys of protein structures. By restricting the number of rotamers per side chain to one, IRECS can optimize side chains for a single conformation model. The average accuracy of IRECS for the chi1 and chi1+2 dihedral angles amounts to 84.7% and 71.6%, respectively, using a 40 degrees cutoff. When we compared IRECS with SCWRL and SCAP, the performance of IRECS was comparable to that of both methods. IRECS and the ROTA potential are available for download from the URL http://irecs.bioinf.mpi-inf.mpg.de.     

Automated electron-density sampling reveals widespread conformational polymorphism in proteins

Although proteins populate large structural ensembles, X-ray diffraction data are traditionally interpreted using a single model. To search for evidence of alternate conformers, we developed a program, Ringer, which systematically samples electron density around the dihedral angles of protein side chains. In a diverse set of 402 structures, Ringer identified weak, nonrandom electron-density features that suggest of the presence of hidden, lowly populated conformations for >18% of uniquely modeled residues. Although these peaks occur at electron-density levels traditionally regarded as noise, statistically significant (P < 10⁻⁵) enrichment of peaks at successive rotameric χ angles validates the assignment of these features as unmodeled conformations. Weak electron density corresponding to alternate rotamers also was detected in an accurate electron density map free of model bias. Ringer analysis of the high-resolution structures of free and peptide-bound calmodulin identified shifts in ensembles and connected the alternate conformations to ligand recognition. These results show that the signal in high-resolution electron density maps extends below the traditional 1 σ cutoff, and crystalline proteins are more polymorphic than current crystallographic models. Ringer provides an objective, systematic method to identify previously undiscovered alternate conformations that can mediate protein folding and function.     

Rotamer libraries and probabilities of transition between rotamers for the side chains in protein-protein binding

Conformational changes in the side chains are essential for protein-protein binding. Rotameric states and unbound- to-bound conformational changes in the surface residues were systematically studied on a representative set of protein complexes. The side-chain conformations were mapped onto dihedral angles space. The variable threshold algorithm was developed to cluster the dihedral angle distributions and to derive rotamers, defined as the most probable conformation in a cluster. Six rotamer libraries were generated: full surface, surface noninterface, and surface interface-each for bound and unbound states. The libraries were used to calculate the probabilities of the rotamer transitions upon binding. The stability of amino acids was quantified based on the transition maps. The noninterface residues' stability was higher than that of the interface. Long side chains with three or four dihedral angles were less stable than the shorter ones. The transitions between the rotamers at the interface occurred more frequently than on the noninterface surface. Most side chains changed conformation within the same rotamer or moved to an adjacent rotamer. The highest percentage of the transitions was observed primarily between the two most occupied rotamers. The probability of the transition between rotamers increased with the decrease of the rotamer stability. The analysis revealed characteristics of the surface side-chain conformational transitions that can be utilized in flexible docking protocols.     

A smoothed backbone-dependent rotamer library for proteins derived from adaptive kernel density estimates and regressions

Rotamer libraries are used in protein structure determination, prediction, and design. The backbone-dependent rotamer library consists of rotamer frequencies, mean dihedral angles, and variances as?a function of the backbone dihedral angles. Structure prediction and design methods that employ backbone flexibility would strongly benefit from smoothly varying probabilities and angles. A new version of the?backbone-dependent rotamer library has been developed using adaptive kernel density estimates for the rotamer frequencies and adaptive kernel regression for the mean dihedral angles and variances. This formulation allows for evaluation of the rotamer probabilities, mean angles, and variances as?a smooth and continuous function of phi and psi. Continuous probability density estimates for the nonrotameric degrees of freedom of amides, carboxylates, and aromatic side chains have been modeled as a function of the backbone dihedrals and rotamers of the remaining degrees of freedom. New backbone-dependent rotamer libraries at varying levels of smoothing are available from http://dunbrack.fccc.edu.     

Side-chain conformations in 4-alpha-helical bundles.

The distribution of the chi(1), chi(2) dihedral angles in a dataset consisting of 12 unrelated 4-alpha-helical bundle proteins was determined and qualitatively compared with that observed in globular proteins. The analysis suggests that the 4-alpha-helical bundle motif could occasionally impose steric constraints on side chains: (i) the side-chain conformations are limited to only a subset of the conformations observed in globular proteins and for some amino acids they are sterically more constrained than those in helical regions of globular proteins; (ii) aspartic acid and asparagine occasionally adopt rotamers that have not been previously reported for globular or helical proteins; (iii) some rotamers of tyrosine and isoleucine are predominantly or exclusively associated with hydrophobic core positions (a, d); (iv) mutations in the hydrophobic core occur preferentially between residue types which among other physicochemical properties also share a predominant rotamer.     

Extending the accuracy limits of prediction for side-chain conformations

Current techniques for the prediction of side-chain conformations on a fixed backbone have an accuracy limit of about 1.0-1.5 A rmsd for core residues. We have carried out a detailed and systematic analysis of the factors that influence the prediction of side-chain conformation and, on this basis, have succeeded in extending the limits of side-chain prediction for core residues to about 0.7 A rmsd from native, and 94 % and 89 % of chi(1) and chi(1+2 ) dihedral angles correctly predicted to within 20 degrees of native, respectively. These results are obtained using a force-field that accounts for only van der Waals interactions and torsional potentials. Prediction accuracy is strongly dependent on the rotamer library used. That is, a complete and detailed rotamer library is essential. The greatest accuracy was obtained with an extensive rotamer library, containing over 7560 members, in which bond lengths and bond angles were taken from the database rather than simply assuming idealized values. Perhaps the most surprising finding is that the combinatorial problem normally associated with the prediction of the side-chain conformation does not appear to be important. This conclusion is based on the fact that the prediction of the conformation of a single side-chain with all others fixed in their native conformations is only slightly more accurate than the simultaneous prediction of all side-chain dihedral angles.     

Constructing side chains on near-native main chains for ab initio protein structure prediction

Is there value in constructing side chains while searching protein conformational space during an ab initio simulation? If so, what is the most computationally efficient method for constructing these side chains? To answer these questions, four published approaches were used to construct side chain conformations on a range of near-native main chains generated by ab initio protein structure prediction methods. The accuracy of these approaches was compared with a naive approach that selects the most frequently observed rotamer for a given amino acid to construct side chains. An all-atom conditional probability discriminatory function is useful at selecting conformations with overall low all-atom root mean square deviation (r.m.s.d.) and the discrimination improves on sets that are closer to the native conformation. In addition, the naive approach performs as well as more sophisticated methods in terms of the percentage of chi(1) angles built accurately and the all-atom r. m.s.d., between the native and near-native conformations. The results suggest that the naive method would be extremely useful for fast and efficient side chain construction on vast numbers of conformations for ab initio prediction of protein structure.     

Improved side-chain prediction accuracy using an ab initio potential energy function and a very large rotamer library

Accurate prediction of the placement and comformations of protein side chains given only the backbone trace has a wide range of uses in protein design, structure prediction, and functional analysis. Prediction has most often relied on discrete rotamer libraries so that rapid fitness of side-chain rotamers can be assessed against some scoring function. Scoring functions are generally based on experimental parameters from small-molecule studies or empirical parameters based on determined protein structures. Here, we describe the NCN algorithm for predicting the placement of side chains. A predominantly first-principles approach was taken to develop the potential energy function incorporating van der Waals and electrostatics based on the OPLS parameters, and a hydrogen bonding term. The only empirical knowledge used is the frequency of rotameric states from the PDB. The rotamer library includes nearly 50,000 rotamers, and is the most extensive discrete library used to date. Although the computational time tends to be longer than most other algorithms, the overall accuracy exceeds all algorithms in the literature when placing rotamers on an accurate backbone trace. Considering only the most buried residues, 80% of the total residues tested, the placement accuracy reaches 92% for chi(1), and 83% for chi(1 + 2), and an overall RMS deviation of 1 A. Additionally, we show that if information is available to restrict chi(1) to one rotamer well, then this algorithm can generate structures with an average RMS deviation of 1.0 A for all heavy side-chains atoms and a corresponding overall chi(1 + 2) accuracy of 85.0%.     

The Dynameomics rotamer library: amino acid side chain conformations and dynamics from comprehensive molecular dynamics simulations in water

We have recently completed systematic molecular dynamics simulations of 807 different proteins representing 95% of the known autonomous protein folds in an effort we refer to as Dynameomics. Here we focus on the analysis of side chain conformations and dynamics to create a dynamic rotamer library. Overall this library is derived from 31,000 occurrences of each of 86,217 different residues, or 2.7 × 10(9) rotamers. This dynamic library has 74% overlap of rotamer distributions with rotamer libraries derived from static high-resolution crystal structures. Seventy-five percent of the residues had an assignable primary conformation, and 68% of the residues had at least one significant alternate conformation. The average correlation time for switching between rotamers ranged from 22 ps for Met to over 8 ns for Cys; this time decreased 20-fold on the surface of the protein and modestly for dihedral angles further from the main chain. Side chain S(2) axis order parameters were calculated and they correlated well with those derived from NMR relaxation experiments (R = 0.9). Relationships relating the S(2) axis order parameters to rotamer occupancy were derived. Overall the Dynameomics rotamer library offers a comprehensive depiction of side chain rotamer preferences and dynamics in solution, and more realistic distributions for dynamic proteins in solution at ambient temperature than libraries derived from crystal structures, in particular charged surface residues are better represented. Details of the rotamer library are presented here and the library itself can be downloaded at http://www.dynameomics.org.     

The role of side chain conformational flexibility in surface recognition by Tenebrio molitor antifreeze protein

Two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy was used to investigate the flexibility of the threonine side chains in the beta-helical Tenebrio molitor antifreeze protein (TmAFP) at low temperatures. From measurement of the (3)J(alphabeta) (1)H-(1)H scalar coupling constants, the chi(1) angles and preferred rotamer populations can be calculated. It was determined that the threonines on the ice-binding face of the protein adopt a preferred rotameric conformation at near freezing temperatures, whereas the threonines not on the ice-binding face sample many rotameric states. This suggests that TmAFP maintains a preformed ice-binding conformation in solution, wherein the rigid array of threonines that form the AFP-ice interface matches the ice crystal lattice. A key factor in binding to the ice surface and inhibition of ice crystal growth appears to be the close surface-to-surface complementarity between the AFP and crystalline ice, and the lack of an entropic penalty associated with freezing out motions in a flexible ligand.     

Using quantum mechanics to improve estimates of amino acid side chain rotamer energies

Amino acid side chains adopt a discrete set of favorable conformations typically referred to as rotamers. The relative energies of rotamers partially determine which side chain conformations are more often observed in protein structures and accurate estimates of these energies are important for predicting protein structure and designing new proteins. Protein modelers typically calculate side chain rotamer energies by using molecular mechanics (MM) potentials or by converting rotamer probabilities from the protein database (PDB) into relative free energies. One limitation of the knowledge‐based energies is that rotamer preferences observed in the PDB can reflect internal side chain energies as well as longer‐range interactions with the rest of the protein. Here, we test an alternative approach for calculating rotamer energies. We use three different quantum mechanics (QM) methods (second order Møller‐Plesset (MP2), density functional theory (DFT) energy calculation using the B3LYP functional, and Hartree‐Fock) to calculate the energy of amino acid rotamers in a dipeptide model system, and then use these pre‐calculated values in side chain placement simulations. Energies were calculated for over 36,000 different conformations of leucine, isoleucine, and valine dipeptides with backbone torsion angles from the helical and strand regions of the Ramachandran plot. In a subset of cases these energies differ significantly from those calculated with standard molecular mechanics potentials or those derived from PDB statistics. We find that in these cases the energies from the QM methods result in more accurate placement of amino acid side chains in structure prediction tests. Proteins 2008. © 2007 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Excluded volume in protein side-chain packing

The excluded volume occupied by protein side-chains and the requirement of high packing density in the protein interior should severely limit the number of side-chain conformations compatible with a given native backbone. To examine the relationship between side-chain geometry and side-chain packing, we use an all-atom Monte Carlo simulation to sample the large space of side-chain conformations. We study three models of excluded volume and use umbrella sampling to effectively explore the entire space. We find that while excluded volume constraints reduce the size of conformational space by many orders of magnitude, the number of allowed conformations is still large. An average repacked conformation has 20 % of its chi angles in a non-native state, a marked reduction from the expected 67 % in the absence of excluded volume. Interestingly, well-packed conformations with up to 50 % non-native chi angles exist. The repacked conformations have native packing density as measured by a standard Voronoi procedure. Entropy is distributed non-uniformly over positions, and we partially explain the observed distribution using rotamer probabilities derived from the Protein Data Bank database. In several cases, native rotamers that occur infrequently in the database are seen with high probability in our simulation, indicating that sequence-specific excluded volume interactions can stabilize rotamers that are rare for a given backbone. In spite of our finding that 65 % of the native rotamers and 85 % of chi(1) angles can be predicted correctly on the basis of excluded volume only, 95 % of positions can accommodate more than one rotamer in simulation. We estimate that, in order to quench the side-chain entropy observed in the presence of excluded volume interactions, other interactions (hydrophobic, polar, electrostatic) must provide an additional stabilization of at least 0.6 kT per residue in order to single out the native state.     

Rotamer Dynamics: Analysis of Rotamers in Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Proteins

Given by χ torsional angles, rotamers describe the side-chain conformations of amino acid residues in a protein based on the rotational isomers (hence the word rotamer). Constructed rotamer libraries, based on either protein crystal structures or dynamics studies, are the tools for classifying rotamers (torsional angles) in a way that reflect their frequency in nature. Rotamer libraries are routinely used in structure modeling and evaluation. In this perspective article, we would like to encourage researchers to apply rotamer analyses beyond their traditional use. Molecular dynamics (MD) of proteins highlight the in silico behavior of molecules in solution and thus can identify favorable side-chain conformations. In this article, we used simple computational tools to study rotamer dynamics (RD) in MD simulations. First, we isolated each frame in the MD trajectories in separate Protein Data Bank files via the cpptraj module in AMBER. Then, we extracted torsional angles via the Bio3D module in R language. The classification of torsional angles was also done in R according to the penultimate rotamer library. RD analysis is useful for various applications such as protein folding, study of rotamer-rotamer relationship in protein-protein interaction, real-time correlation between secondary structures and rotamers, study of flexibility of side chains in binding site for molecular docking preparations, use of RD as guide in functional analysis and study of structural changes caused by mutations, providing parameters for improving coarse-grained MD accuracy and speed, and many others. Major challenges facing RD to emerge as a new scientific field involve the validation of results via easy, inexpensive wet-lab methods. This realm is yet to be explored.     

Bayesian statistical analysis of protein side-chain rotamer preferences.

We present a Bayesian statistical analysis of the conformations of side chains in proteins from the Protein Data Bank. This is an extension of the backbone-dependent rotamer library, and includes rotamer populations and average chi angles for a full range of phi, psi values. The Bayesian analysis used here provides a rigorous statistical method for taking account of varying amounts of data. Bayesian statistics requires the assumption of a prior distribution for parameters over their range of possible values. This prior distribution can be derived from previous data or from pooling some of the present data. The prior distribution is combined with the data to form the posterior distribution, which is a compromise between the prior distribution and the data. For the chi 2, chi 3, and chi 4 rotamer prior distributions, we assume that the probability of each rotamer type is dependent only on the previous chi rotamer in the chain. For the backbone-dependence of the chi 1 rotamers, we derive prior distributions from the product of the phi-dependent and psi-dependent probabilities. Molecular mechanics calculations with the CHARMM22 potential show a strong similarity with the experimental distributions, indicating that proteins attain their lowest energy rotamers with respect to local backbone-side-chain interactions. The new library is suitable for use in homology modeling, protein folding simulations, and the refinement of X-ray and NMR structures.     

Fast and simple Monte Carlo algorithm for side chain optimization in proteins: application to model building by homology.

An unknown protein structure can be predicted with fair accuracy once an evolutionary connection at the sequence level has been made to a protein of known 3-D structure. In model building by homology, one typically starts with a backbone framework, rebuilds new loop regions, and replaces nonconserved side chains. Here, we use an extremely efficient Monte Carlo algorithm in rotamer space with simulated annealing and simple potential energy functions to optimize the packing of side chains on given backbone models. Optimized models are generated within minutes on a workstation, with reasonable accuracy (average of 81% side chain chi 1 dihedral angles correct in the cores of proteins determined at better than 2.5 A resolution). As expected, the quality of the models decreases with decreasing accuracy of backbone coordinates. If the back-bone was taken from a homologous rather than the same protein, about 70% side chain chi 1 angles were modeled correctly in the core in a case of strong homology and about 60% in a case of medium homology. The algorithm can be used in automated, fast, and reproducible model building by homology.     

Statistical and energetic analysis of side-chain conformations in oligopeptides

The distributions of side-chain conformations in 258 crystal structures of oligopeptides have been analyzed. The sample contains 321 residues having side chains that extend beyond the C beta atom. Statistically observed preferences of side-chain dihedral angles are summarized and correlated with stereochemical and energetic constraints. The distributions are compared with observed distributions in proteins of known X-ray structures and with computed minimum-energy conformations of amino acid derivatives. The distributions are similar in all three sets of data, and they appear to be governed primarily by intraresidue interactions. In side chains with no beta-branching, the most important interactions that determine chi 1 are those between the C gamma H2 group and atoms of the neighboring peptide groups. As a result, the g- conformation (chi 1 congruent to -60 degrees) occurs most frequently for rotation around the C alpha-C beta bond in oligopeptides, followed by the t conformation (chi 1 congruent to 180 degrees), while the g+ conformation (chi 1 congruent to 60 degrees) is least favored. In residues with beta-branching, steric repulsions between the C gamma H2 or C gamma H3 groups and backbone atoms govern the distribution of chi 1. The extended (t) conformation is highly favored for rotation around the C beta-C gamma and C gamma-C delta bonds in unbranched side chains, because the t conformer has a lower energy than the g+ and g- conformers in hydrocarbon chains. This study of the observed side-chain conformations has led to a refinement of one of the energy parameters used in empirical conformational energy computations.     

The role of carbon-donor hydrogen bonds in stabilizing tryptophan conformations

Although most side-chain torsion angles correspond to low-energy rotameric positions, deviations occur with significant frequency. One striking example arises in Trp residues, which have an important role in stabilizing protein structures because of their size and mixed hydrophobic/hydrophilic character. Ten percent of Trp side-chains have unexplained conformations with chi(2) near 0 degrees instead of the expected 90 degrees. The current work is a structural and energetic analysis of these conformations. It is shown that many Trp residues with these orientations are stabilized by three-center carbon-donor hydrogen bonds of the form C-H...X...H-C, where X is a polar hydrogen-bond acceptor in the environment of the side-chain. The bridging hydrogen bonds occur both within the Trp side-chain and between the side-chain and the local protein backbone. Free energy maps of an isolated Trp residue in an explicit water environment show a minimum corresponding to the off-rotamer peak observed in the crystallographic data. Bridging carbon-donor hydrogen bonds are also shown to stabilize on-rotamer Trp conformations, and similar bridging hydrogen bonds also stabilize some off-rotamer Asp conformations. The present results suggest a previously unrecognized role for three-center carbon-donor hydrogen bonds in protein structures and support the view that the off-rotamer Trp side-chain orientations are real rather than artifacts of crystallographic refinements. Certain of the off-rotamer Trp conformations appear to have a functional role.