Cellular aspects of tolerance. VII. Inheritance of the resistance to tolerance induction

The half-lives of elimination ($\text{T}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}$) of ¹³¹I-RGG from the body of normal A or Balb/c animals was much longer than the $\text{T}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}$ of SJL mice. At all ages, the $\text{T}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}$ of normal hybrids (A × SJL, SJL × A, Balb/c × SJL) was similar to or longer than that of the A or Balb/c parents. Thus, in terms of the $\text{T}\text{1}\text{2}$ of normal animals, the SJL responsiveness to ¹³¹I-RGG appeared to be a recessive trait. Tolerance could be induced in newborn animals and, in terms of $\text{T}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}$, the degree of unresponsiveness at the age of 6 weeks, was the same in A, Balb/c, A × SJL, and Balb/c × SJL animals but was much shorter in SJL mice. Thus, in neonatally induced tolerance, the duration of tolerance was recessive for the SJL type. The average $\text{T}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>built1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}$ after tolerance induction in 3-week-old hybrids (A × SJL, SJL × A, Balb/c × SJL) was similar to that of the A or Balb/c parent, but by the 8th and 12th week it approached the average $\text{T}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}$ of the SJL parent. Comparing 8-week-old hybrids, the average $\text{T}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}$ was longest in A × SJL hybrids and identical in SJL × A and Balb/c × SJL mice. An examination of $\text{T}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}$ distribution in various 8- and 12-week-old crosses and backcrosses revealed a fairly large proportion of individuals with a $\text{T}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}$ which was intermediate between SJL and the other parent. There was a tendency for this number to decrease in 12 weeks as compared to 8-week-old mice. In 8-week-old mice, the number of animals with intermediate $\text{T}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>built1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}$ was smallest when SJL was the maternal animal [(SJL × A); SJL × (A × SJL); SJL × (SJL × A)]. There was no link between $\text{T}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}$ of tolerant animals and either the immunoglobulin allotype (MuAl/MuA2) or the C5 eniotype (MuB1 positive/MuB1 negative).     

Cellular aspects of tolerance. III. The responsiveness of T cells from tolerant donors after exposure to a cross-reacting antigen

Mice, rendered tolerant to rabbit gamma globulin (RGG), were immunized with RGG or with dinitrophenylated RGG (DNP₄₀-RGG), incorporated in adjuvant. The resulting response was evaluated in terms of the half-life of trace labeled RGG (¹³¹I-RGG). An antibody response against the tolerance inducing macromolecule could be elicited with DNP₄₀-RGG, but not with RGG. Reconstitution experiments revealed that thymus derived (T) cells from tolerant donors could cooperate with bone marrow cells from normal donors in the response elicited by DNP₄₀-RGG, but could not effectively cooperate with bone marrow derived (B) cells from tolerant donors. Such B cells could cooperate with T cells from normal donors. The relative difference between native and chemically modified proteins played an important role in this tolerance circumvention, since analogous experiments with human instead of rabbit gamma globulin did not result in an effective response to determinants of the tolerance-inducing proteins. It was suggested that the number of effectively immunogenic determinants on DNP₄₀-RGG was low in B and in T cells of animals tolerant to RGG and that the probability of effective cooperation was consequently extremely low. If one of the two cell types came from a normal animal and thus could respond to a large number of determinants, the probability of effective cooperation increased so as to reveal the responsiveness of the “tolerant” cell population. There was no indication that the responsiveness of the tolerant T cell population was directed against tolerance-inducing determinants.     

Cellular events in tolerance. V. Detection, isolation and fate of lymphoid cells which bind fluoresccinated antigen in vivo.

The binding of tolerogen to specific receptors of lymphocytes and the subsequent fate of such cells was directly studied in Lewis rats injected with fluorescein-labeled sheep gamma globulin (F-SGG). This tolerogen produced unresponsiveness both in SGG-specific T cells (carrier tolerance) and F-specific antibody-forming cell precursors. The former (T-cell tolerance) was still significant more than 60 days after tolerogen whereas tolerance in the latter (B-cell tolerance) had waned by that time.Cells which have bound the tolerogen (antigen-binding cells, ABC) in vivo were detectable by direct immunofluorescence of washed spleen cell suspensions from rats injected with F-SGG up to 7 days previously. These cells were isolated using antifluorescein affinity columns, and shown to contain immunocompetent precursors for F- and SGG specific responses.The frequency of such ABC was between 30 and 80 per 10⁵ spleen, lymph node or bone marrow cells; no ABC were detected in the thymus. Both Ig positive and Ig negative cells were found to be ABC; Ig negative ABC usually showed a “capped” fluorescent pattern whereas Ig positive ABC generally were “spotted.”By 10 days after injection, ABC were not detectable in the spleen, lymph nodes, thymus or bone marrow of tolerant rats. Furthermore, reinjection of F-SGG after this time did not label any cells. This suggests that antigen-binding cells are not present at this time or that such cells, if available, lack receptors. In contrast, rats previously injected with a lower non-tolerogenic dose of F-SGG or an immunogenic form (F-SGG on bentonite) possessed cells at these later times which could be labeled with F-SGG. Thus, ABC remain detectable following immunogen or a subtolerogeic dose of F-SGG, but disappear in tolerant rats.By approximately 40 days after initial high dose tolerogen injection (when B cell tolerance has started to wane), cells capable of binding a second dose of F-SGG again became detectable. It is suggested that high doses of F-SGG are bound by specific lymphocytes (identifiable as ABC) and that these cells either fail to regenerate new receptors or die. As tolerance begins to wane, either new receptors or new cells are generated.     

Cellular events in tolerance IX: Maintenance of immunological tolerance in the presence of normal B-cell precursors and in the absence of demonstrable suppression

The cellular events involved in immunological tolerance to fluoresceinated sheep gammaglobulin (FL-SGG) were analyzed at the level of hapten-specific B cells. One single iv injection of FL-SGG induced tolerance as measured by challenge with thymus-dependent (FL-KLH) or thymus-independent (FL-Ficoll) antigens in vivo or thymus-independent (FL-LPS) antigen in vitro. As noted earlier, unresponsiveness was maintained until 6–8 weeks after tolerance induction. Limiting-dilution precursor analysis demonstrated a reduction in B-cell precursors on Day 7 after tolerogen treatment; precursor frequencies returned to control levels by 3–4 weeks. This recovery of precursors in the presence of stable tolerance was not due to suppressor activity. Rather, results show that tolerant hapten-specific B cells are clonally anergic and display a reduced burst size in response to antigen. Hence, unresponsiveness is maintained in the presence of apparently normal precursor levels by an intrinsic defect in antigen-specific B cells.     

Factor producing lysis of thymus-derived cells in vitro by specific antigen.

Lymph node cells of immunized mice were lysed by specific antigen in vitro. These cells were not lysed by antigen after washing them four times with Hanks' solution. The factor lysing lymph node cells and thymus cells of normal mice in the presence of the specific antigen was found in the supernatant of the lymph node cell suspension of immunized mice. Bone marrow cells were also lysed by the factor and specific antigen only after preincubating the cells in extracts of thymus or lymph nodes of normal mice. When active supernatants were fractionated by gel filtration on Sephadex G-200, the active material eluted with molecules of approximately 20,000–45,000 MW. This factor was homogeneous on electrophoreses in polyacrylamide gels and detected in the prealbumin zone.     

Cellular basis for a hapten-specific state of tolerance induced in vitro.

A hapten-specific unresponsive state was induced in vitro by the incubation of normal murine spleen cells with highly conjugated dinitrophenylated bovine gamma-globulin (DNP-BGG) or a dinitrophenylated copolymer of D-glutamic acid and D-lysine (DNP-D-GL) for 24 hr. After this incubation period spleen cells were washed and cultured for 4 days with the thymic-independent antigen dinitrophenylated polyacrylamide beads (DNP-PAA) or the thymic-dependent antigen trinitrophenylated burro the erythrocytes (TNP-BRBC). Preincubation with either DNP-BGG or DNP-D-GL led to a specific depression of the in vitro anti-hapten plaque-forming cell response. The degree of depression was dependent upon the concentration of the tolerogen and the duration of preincubation. The response to DNP-PAA or TNP-PAA beads was depressed to a greater degree than was the response to TNP-BRBC. The cellular basis of the immunologic unresponsiveness induced by DNP-BGG was attributable to an inhibition of B cell function whereas the unresponsive state induced with DNP-D-GL was due to both a specific inhibition of B cell function and the activation of antigen-specific suppressor T cells.     

Cellular events in protein-tolerant inbred rats. III. Antigen-reactive B cells in rats tolerant to human serum albumin.

Rats tolerant to human serum albumin (HSA) were injected with selected lymphocyte populations and challenged with HSA plus adjuvant to test for loss of tolerance. Thoracic duct lymphocytes (TDL) from normal or immune rats, either untreated or depleted of Ig-bearing cells or HSA-binding cells by affinity chromatography were all equally effective in restoring the HSA antibody response in previously tolerant recipients. In contrast, recirculating B cells (TDL from B rats) were not effective. The results indicated that unresponsiveness to HSA was a lesion of the T- but not the B-cell compartment. However, antibody affinity failed to mature to a high level in tolerant rats that were restored with T cells, and the response of transferred primed B cells into unresponsive recipients was inhibited, suggesting that the tolerant state was not merely due to a T-cell deletion.     

Maintenance of lymphocyte surface Ig by mitogen stimulation in vitro.

In 4 to 24 hr cultures of rabbit lymphoid cells in medium supplemented with autologous serum, most B cells lost their surface Ig as assayed by rosette formation with anti-Ig antibody-coated erythrocytes. This loss was prevented by adding selected mitogens such as streptococcal mitogen (SM), lipopolysaccharide, and concanavalin A or by supplementing the medium with fetal calf serum. When SM was added at various times to the cultures (1, 2, 3, and 4 hr), it was effective in maintaining the approximate level of Ig-bearing cells present at the time of its addition but was ineffective in restoring the level of Ig-bearing cells present at the time the cultures were intiated. Very small, submitogenic doses of SM were sufficient to maintain the level of Ig-bearing cells. The data suggest that lymphocytes require continuous stimulation to maintain their surface receptors.     

Pathophysiologic analysis of peripheral blood lymphocytes from patients with primary immunodeficiency. I. Ig synthesis by peripheral blood lymphocytes stimulated with either pokeweed mitogen or Epstein-Barr virus in vitro

In the present study 5 patients with common variable hypogammaglobulinemia (CVH) and 4 patients with selective IgA deficiency (IgA-D) were analyzed for the cellular defects responsible for impaired Ig synthesis with use of peripheral blood lymphocytes stimulated with either PWM or EBV in vitro. By the use of co-culture with PWM, all the patients examined had intrinsic B cell defects restricted to the synthesis of Ig class corresponding to the low or absent Ig class(es) in the sera. Two types of excessive suppressor T activity were found, which were abrogated by irradiation. One was isotype-nonspecific and the other was IgA-specific. Moreover, failure of IgA-specific helper T activity was demonstrated. The use of EBV as an agent that polyclonally activates B cells independently of T cells and monocytes should allow a clearer delineation of the level of the B cell defects. When co-cultured with EBV, B cells from 3 patients with CVH produced normal to subnormal quantities of IgM although they could produce no IgM upon co-culturing with normal T cells and PWM. B cells from 2 patients with CVH could produce IgM normally by stimulation with either PWM or EBV; however, there was no restoration to produce IgG or IgA in these patients. In addition, B cells from 2 patients with IgA-D produced not only IgG and IgM but also IgA almost normally at 4 days after in vitro stimulation with EBV.     

Suppressor T cells: presence in mice rendered tolerant by neonatal treatment with anti-receptor antibody or antigen.

Specific tolerance to phosphorylcholine (PC) was induced in BALB/c mice by two methods. Neonatal mice received a single injection of either: 1)PnC, the C-polysaccharide from S. pneumoniae, R36a vaccine which has PC as a major antigenic determinant or 2) ARA, an homologous antibody directed against the receptor for PC. Spleen cells from animals treated as neonates with either PnC or ARA were specifically suppressed for the response to PC antigens in vitro. In addition, cells from either group of unresponsive animals co-cultured with spleen cells of normal BALB/c mice markedly suppressed the response of the normal cells to PC. Greater than 90% inhibition of the plaque-forming cell response was obtained when unresponsive cells were mixed with normal cells in ratios of 1:1 or greater. Equal numbers of cells from animals made unresponsive by PnC or ARA produced an equivalent degree of suppression. Neither supernatants of cultures nor sera of animals of either unresponsive group suppressed the response of normal spleen cells to PC. Suppression by cells from both groups of tolerant mice was eliminated by treatment with anti-Thy 1.2 serum and C. Presumably, a common cell is responsible for suppression caused by cells from mice made unresponsive by either procedure.     

Cellular events in tolerance. VI. Neonatal vs adult B cell tolerance: differences in antigen-binding cell patterns and lipopolysaccharide stimulation.

The numbers and fate of antigen-binding cells (ABC) in neonatal and adult mice rendered tolerant to fluorescein (FL)-labeled heterologous gamma-globulins were studied. Similar numbers of FL-ABC were observed 1 day after tolerogen in both adult and neonatal mouse spleens: by 7 days after tolerization, no FL-ABC were observed in either case. Reinjection with FL-tolerogen at 7 days led to the detection of normal numbers of ABC in adult mice but significantly reduced numbers in neonates. This suggests that neonatal ABC either have been deleted or have failed to resynthesize surface receptors. Two weeks after tolerance induction, spleen cells from these tolerant mice were cultured with Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide (LPS), a polyclonal B cell mitogen, or with specific antigen. Tolerant adult spleen cells made an equivalent anti-FL response to that of the uninjected controls when stimulated with LPS, but were unresponsive to specific antigenic triggering. In contrast, spleen cells from neonatally tolerized mice were unresponsive to either specific or nonspecific (LPS) stimulation. Thus, these neonatally tolerized spleen cells lose sensitivity to polyclonal-stimulating agents (along with their receptors), or more simply, are deleted.     

Studies on tolerance induction in vitro. I. Production of immunologically tolerant rabbit spleen cells and the transfer of tolerance to untreated cells.

Tolerance was induced in rabbit spleen cells by incubation with solubilized T2 phage (S-T2)2 at 37degrees C. Spleen cells thus treated maintained normal responsiveness to an unrelated antigen, S-SP82. Transfer of tolerance was demonstrated in in vitro in that the addition of washed tolerant cells caused suppression of the response of untreated cells to an immunogenic dose of S-T2. Evidence is presented that this suppression is not due to the transfer of tolerogenic quantities of antigen. Spleen cell populations depleted of adherent cells were still capable of being made tolerant and of transferring tolerance.     

In vitro reactivity in allograft tolerance: persistence of mixed leukocyte culture reactivity in highly tolerant rats.

Mixed leukocyte culture reactivity was studied in adult W/Fu rats judged to be highly tolerant after the inoculation of (W/Fu X BN)F1 hybrid spleen and bone marrow cells at birth. Reactivity was observed in a majority of tolerant donors tested and documented by quantitative dose-response and kinetic studies. Allograft tolerance cannot be explained by a complete lack of specific immune reactivity to tolerated alloantigens.     

Immunoglobulin synthesis after HLA-identical marrow grafting. V. The role of peripheral blood monocytes in the regulation of in vitro immunoglobulin secretion stimulated by pokeweed mitogen

The ability of purified monocytes to regulate in vitro immunoglobulin (Ig) production was examined in 12 patients after HLA-identical marrow grafting. Five patients were studied less than 3 mo after grafting and seven more than 1 yr after grafting. One of the former had acute graft-vs-host disease and five of the latter had chronic graft-vs-host disease. Ficoll-Hypaque-separated peripheral blood mononuclear cells from patients, normal marrow donors, or healthy unrelated individuals were separated into T and non-T cells by sheep erythrocyte rosetting. Highly enriched monocyte and B cell subpopulations were obtained by placing the non-T cells over discontinuous Percoll gradients. Co-cultures of patient or normal monocyte populations with either normal or patient T and B cells with pokeweed mitogen were performed. A hemolytic plaque assay was used to assess Ig secretion after 6 days of culture. Co-culture of T and non-T cells from 10 of 12 patients failed to produce Ig. Monocyte-enriched fractions from all patients provided normal accessory cell functions when co-cultured with normal T and B cells. Two of five patients with chronic graft-vs-host disease had monocytes that suppressed Ig synthesis at high ratios of monocytes to normal T and B cells. Normal monocyte-enriched fractions did not restore Ig production to T and B cells of patients whose T and non-T cells failed to produce Ig. These data indicate that the observed defects in pokeweed mitogen-driven Ig secretion after marrow grafting are due primarily to defective T and B cell functions and that the monocyte accessory function is intact in most patients studied.     

Alloreactive cloned T cell lines. VII. Comparison of the kinetics of IL 2 release stimulated by alloantigen or Con A

Injection of poly(Glu50Tyr50)(GT) into B10.BR (H-2k) mice induces GT-specific suppressor T cells and a T cell-derived suppressor factor (TsF1), which in turn induces a second-order suppressor T cell (TS2). In the present study, we show that B10.BR GT-TSF1 is composed of separate I-Jk and idiotype-bearing chains linked by disulfide bond(s). Functional suppressive activity requires both chains to be in association. Neither chain alone can induce TS2, indicating that both chains must be seen in association and suggesting a single cellular target for the two chains. Experiments designed to interchange I-J-bearing chains of GT-TSF1 derived from different H-2 haplotypes indicate that only the homologous I-J and idiotype-bearing chains can reassociate into a suppressive moiety. These experiments may imply heterogeneity of I-J region gene products.