Survival strategy of photosynthetic organisms. 2. Experimental proof of the size variability of the unit building block of light-harvesting oligomeric antenna

The present series of papers is part of an integrated research program to understand the effective functional strategy of native light-harvesting molecular antennae in photosynthetic organisms. This work tackles the problem of the structural optimization of light-harvesting antennae of variable size. In vivo, the size responds to the illumination intensity, thus implying more sophisticated optimization strategies, since larger antenna size demands finer structural tuning. Earlier modeling experiments showed that the aggregation of the antenna pigments, apart from being itself a universal structural factor of functional antenna optimization with any (!) spatial lattice of light-harvesting molecules, determines the antenna performance provided that the degree of aggregation varies: the larger the unit building block, the higher the efficacy of the whole structure. It means that altering the degree of pigment aggregation in response to the antenna size is biologically expedient. In the case of the oligomeric chlorosomal antenna of green bacteria, the strategy of variable antenna structural optimization in response to the illumination intensity was demonstrated to take place in vivo and facilitate high antenna performance regardless of its size, thus allowing bacteria to survive in diverse illumination conditions.     

Survival Strategy of Photosynthetic Organisms. 1. Variability of the Extent of Light-Harvesting Pigment Aggregation as a Structural Factor Optimizing the Function of Oligomeric Photosynthetic Antenna. Model Calculations

In accordance with our concept of rigorous optimization of photosynthetic machinery by a functional criterion, this series of papers continues purposeful search in natural photosynthetic units (PSU) for the basic principles of their organization that we predicted theoretically for optimal model light-harvesting systems. This approach allowed us to determine the basic principles for the organization of a PSU of any fixed size. This series of papers deals with the problem of structure optimization for light-harvesting antennae of variable size controlled in vivo by the light intensity during the growth of organisms, which accentuates the problem of antenna structure optimization because optimization requirements become more stringent as the PSU increases in size. In this work, using mathematical modeling for the functioning of natural PSUs, we have shown that the aggregation of pigments of model light-harvesting antenna, being one of universal optimizing factors, furthermore allows controlling the antenna efficiency if the extent of pigment aggregation is a variable parameter. In this case, the efficiency of antenna increases with the size of the elementary antenna aggregate, thus ensuring the high efficiency of the PSU irrespective of its size; i.e., variation in the extent of pigment aggregation controlled by the size of light-harvesting antenna is biologically expedient.     

Survival strategy of photosynthetic organisms. 1. Variability of the extent of light-harvesting pigment aggregation as a structural factor optimizing the function of oligomeric photosynthetic antenna. Model calculations

In accordance with our concept of rigorous optimization of photosynthetic machinery by a functional criterion, this series of papers continues purposeful search in natural photosynthetic units (PSU) for the basic principles of their organization that we predicted theoretically for optimal model light-harvesting systems. This approach allowed us to determine the basic principles for the organization of a PSU of any fixed size. This series of papers deals with the problem of structural optimization of light-harvesting antenna of variable size controlled in vivo by the light intensity during the growth of organisms, which accentuates the problem of antenna structure optimization because optimization requirements become more stringent as the PSU increases in size. In this work, using mathematical modeling for the functioning of natural PSUs, we have shown that the aggregation of pigments of model light-harvesting antenna, being one of universal optimizing factors, furthermore allows controlling the antenna efficiency if the extent of pigment aggregation is a variable parameter. In this case, the efficiency of antenna increases with the size of the elementary antenna aggregate, thus ensuring the high efficiency of the PSU irrespective of its size; i.e., variation in the extent of pigment aggregation controlled by the size of light-harvesting antenna is biologically expedient.     

Size variability of the unit building block of peripheral light-harvesting antennas as a strategy for effective functioning of antennas of variable size that is controlled in vivo by light intensity

This work continuous a series of studies devoted to discovering principles of organization of natural antennas in photosynthetic microorganisms that generate in vivo large and highly effective light-harvesting structures. The largest antenna is observed in green photosynthesizing bacteria, which are able to grow over a wide range of light intensities and adapt to low intensities by increasing of size of peripheral BChl c/d/e antenna. However, increasing antenna size must inevitably cause structural changes needed to maintain high efficiency of its functioning. Our model calculations have demonstrated that aggregation of the light-harvesting antenna pigments represents one of the universal structural factors that optimize functioning of any antenna and manage antenna efficiency. If the degree of aggregation of antenna pigments is a variable parameter, then efficiency of the antenna increases with increasing size of a single aggregate of the antenna. This means that change in degree of pigment aggregation controlled by light-harvesting antenna size is biologically expedient. We showed in our previous work on the oligomeric chlorosomal BChl c superantenna of green bacteria of the Chloroflexaceae family that this principle of optimization of variable antenna structure, whose size is controlled by light intensity during growth of bacteria, is actually realized in vivo. Studies of this phenomenon are continued in the present work, expanding the number of studied biological materials and investigating optical linear and nonlinear spectra of chlorosomes having different structures. We show for oligomeric chlorosomal superantennas of green bacteria (from two different families, Chloroflexaceae and Oscillochloridaceae) that a single BChl c aggregate is of small size, and the degree of BChl c aggregation is a variable parameter, which is controlled by the size of the entire BChl c superantenna, and the latter, in turn, is controlled by light intensity in the course of cell culture growth.     

A kaleidoscope of photosynthetic antenna proteins and their emerging roles

Photosynthetic light-harvesting antennae are pigment-binding proteins that perform one of the most fundamental tasks on Earth, capturing light and transferring energy that enables life in our biosphere. Adaptation to different light environments led to the evolution of an astonishing diversity of light-harvesting systems. At the same time, several strategies have been developed to optimize the light energy input into photosynthetic membranes in response to fluctuating conditions. The basic feature of these prompt responses is the dynamic nature of antenna complexes, whose function readily adapts to the light available. High-resolution microscopy and spectroscopic studies on membrane dynamics demonstrate the crosstalk between antennae and other thylakoid membrane components. With the increased understanding of light-harvesting mechanisms and their regulation, efforts are focusing on the development of sustainable processes for effective conversion of sunlight into functional bio-products. The major challenge in this approach lies in the application of fundamental discoveries in light-harvesting systems for the improvement of plant or algal photosynthesis. Here, we underline some of the latest fundamental discoveries on the molecular mechanisms and regulation of light harvesting that can potentially be exploited for the optimization of photosynthesis.

The latest fundamental knowledge obtained on the light-harvesting mechanisms of the antenna proteins can be bridged to biotechnical optimization of photosynthesis.     

Characteristics of Photosystem I Complexes in the End Membranes of Pea Granal Thylakoids

Two fractions of the light fragments enriched in the photosystem I (PSI) complexes were obtained from pea (Pisum sativum L.) thylakoids by digitonin treatment and subsequent differential centrifugation. The ratio of chlorophyll a to chlorophyll b, chlorophyll/P700 spectra of low-temperature fluorescence, and excitation spectra of long-wave fluorescence were measured. These characteristics were shown to be different due to variation in the size and composition of the light-harvesting antenna of PSI complexes present in the particles obtained. The larger antenna size of one of the fractions was related to the incorporation of the pool of light-harvesting complex II (LHCII). A comparison with the data available allowed us to identify these particles as fragments of intergranal thylakoids and end membranes of granal thylakoids. The suggestion that an increase in the PSI light-harvesting antenna in intergranal thylakoids is related to the attachment of phosphorylated LHCII is discussed.     

Spectroscopy of the peridinin-chlorophyll-a protein: insight into light-harvesting strategy of marine algae

An important component of the photosynthetic apparatus is a light-harvesting system that captures light energy and transfers it efficiently to the reaction center. Depending on environmental conditions, photosynthetic antennae have adopted various strategies for this function. Peridinin-chlorophyll-a protein (PCP) represents a unique situation because, unlike other antenna systems which have a preponderance of chlorophyll, it has the carotenoid, peridinin, as its major pigment. The key structural feature of peridinin is a conjugated carbonyl group. Owing to the presence of this group, an intramolecular charge-transfer excited state is formed in peridinin which exhibits different excited state spectra and dynamics depending on the polarity of the environment. The charge-transfer state also facilitates energy transfer between peridinin and chlorophyll-a in PCP. This review summarizes results of spectroscopic investigations of PCP in the past few years, emphasizing the specific light-harvesting strategy developed by marine photosynthetic organisms utilizing carbonyl-containing carotenoids in their antenna complexes.     

Dynamics and diffusion in photosynthetic membranes from rhodospirillum photometricum

Photosynthetic organisms drive their metabolism by converting light energy into an electrochemical gradient with high efficiency. This conversion depends on the diffusion of quinones within the membrane. In purple photosynthetic bacteria, quinones reduced by the reaction center (RC) diffuse to the cytochrome bc(1) complex and then return once reoxidized to the RC. In Rhodospirillum photometricum the RC-containing core complexes are found in a disordered molecular environment, with fixed light-harvesting complex/core complex ratio but without a fixed architecture, whereas additional light-harvesting complexes synthesized under low-light conditions pack into large paracrystalline antenna domains. Here, we have analyzed, using time-lapse atomic force microscopy, the dynamics of the protein complexes in the different membrane domains and find that the disordered regions are dynamic whereas ordered antennae domains are static. Based on our observations we propose, and analyze using Monte Carlo simulations, a model for quinone diffusion in photosynthetic membranes. We show that the formation of large static antennae domains may represent a strategy for increasing electron transfer rates between distant complexes within the membrane and thus be important for photosynthetic efficiency.     

The Model of Pigment Aggregation in the Chlorosomal Antenna of the Green Bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus

Independent experimental and theoretical evaluation was performed for the adequacy of our previously proposed general molecular model of the structural organization of light-harvesting pigments in chlorosomal bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) /d/e-containing superantennae of different green bacteria. Measurement of the temperature dependence of steady-state fluorescence spectra of BChl c was accomplished in intact cells of a photosynthetic green bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus; this allows in vivodetermination of the structure of exciton levels of BChl c oligomers in this natural antenna. Experimental data confirm our model of organization of oligomeric pigments in chlorosomal BChl c antenna of green bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus. This model implies that the unit building block of the antenna is a cylindrical assembly containing six excitonically coupled linear pigment chains, whose exciton structure with intense upper levels provides for the optimal spectral properties of the light-harvesting antenna.     

SANS investigation of the photosynthetic machinery of Chloroflexus aurantiacus

Green photosynthetic bacteria harvest light and perform photosynthesis in low-light environments, and contain specialized antenna complexes to adapt to this condition. We performed small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) studies to obtain structural information about the photosynthetic apparatus, including the peripheral light-harvesting chlorosome complex, the integral membrane light-harvesting B808-866 complex, and the reaction center (RC) in the thermophilic green phototrophic bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus. Using contrast variation in SANS measurements, we found that the B808-866 complex is wrapped around the RC in Cfx. aurantiacus, and the overall size and conformation of the B808-866 complex of Cfx. aurantiacus is roughly comparable to the LH1 antenna complex of the purple bacteria. A similar size of the isolated B808-866 complex was suggested by dynamic light scattering measurements, and a smaller size of the RC of Cfx. aurantiacus compared to the RC of the purple bacteria was observed. Further, our SANS measurements indicate that the chlorosome is a lipid body with a rod-like shape, and that the self-assembly of bacteriochlorophylls, the major component of the chlorosome, is lipid-like. Finally, two populations of chlorosome particles are suggested in our SANS measurements.     

Distribution of bacteriochlorophyll between the pigment-protein complexes of the sulfur photosynthetic bacterium <Emphasis Type="Italic">Allochromatium minutissimum</Emphasis> depending on light intensity at different temperatures

Variation of the distribution of bacteriochlorophyll a (BChl a) between external antenna (LH2) and core complexes (LH1 + RC) of the photosynthetic membrane of the sulfur bacterium Allochromatium minutissimum was studied at light intensities of 5 and 90 Wt/m² in the temperature range of 12–43°C. The increase of light intensity was shown to result in a 1.5-to 2-times increase of a photosynthetic unit (PSU). PSU sizes pass through a maximum depending on growth temperature, and the increase of light intensity (5 and 90 Wt/m²) results in a shift of the maximal PSU size to higher temperatures (15 and 20°C, respectively). In the narrow temperature interval of ～14–17°C, the ratio of light intensity to PSU size is typical of phototrophs: lower light intensity corresponds to larger PSU size. The pattern of PSU size change depending on light intensity was shown to differ at extreme growth temperatures (12°C and over 35°C). The comparison of Alc. minutissimum PSU size with the data on Rhodobacter capsulatus and Rhodopseudomonas palustris by measuring the effective optical absorption cross-section for the reaction of photoinhibition of respiration shows a two to four times greater size of light-harvesting antenna for Alc. minutissimum, which seems to correspond to the maximum possible limit for purple bacteria.     

Small light-harvesting antenna does not protect from photoinhibition

High-light-induced decrease in photosystem II (PSII) electron transfer activity was studied in high- and low-light-grown pumpkin (Cucurbita pepo L.) plants in vivo and in vitro. The PSII light-harvesting antenna of the low-light leaves was estimated to be twice as big as that of the high-light leaves. The low-light leaves were more susceptible to photoinhibition in vivo. However, thylakoids isolated from these two plant materials were equally sensitive to photoinhibition when illuminated in the absence of external electron acceptors. Only the intensity of the photoinhibitory light and the chlorophyll concentration of the sample, not the size of the light-harvesting antenna, determined the rate of PSII photoinhibition in vitro. Because excitation of the reaction center and not only the antenna chlorophylls is a prerequisite for photoinhibition of PSII activity, independence of photoinhibition on antenna size provides support for the hypothesis (Schatz EH, Brock H, Holzwarth AR [1988] Biophys J 54: 397-405) that the excitations of the antenna chlorophylls are in equilibrium with the excitations of the reaction centers. Better tolerance of the high-light leaves in vivo was due to a more active repair process and more powerful protective mechanisms, including photosynthesis. Apparently, some protective mechanism of the high-light-grown plants is at least partially active at low temperature. The protective mechanisms do not appear to function in vitro.     

Structural and functional diversification of the light-harvesting complexes in photosynthetic eukaryotes

Eukaryotes acquired photosynthetic metabolism over a billion years ago, and during that time the light-harvesting antennae have undergone significant structural and functional divergence. The antenna systems are generally used to harvest and transfer excitation energy into the reaction centers to drive photosynthesis, but also have the dual role of energy dissipation. Phycobilisomes formed the first antenna system in oxygenic photoautotrophs, and this soluble protein complex continues to be the dominant antenna in extant cyanobacteria, glaucophytes, and red algae. However, phycobilisomes were lost multiple times during eukaryotic evolution in favor of a thylakoid membrane-integral light-harvesting complex (LHC) antenna system found in the majority of eukaryotic taxa. While photosynthesis spread across different eukaryotic kingdoms via endosymbiosis, the antenna systems underwent extensive modification as photosynthetic groups optimized their light-harvesting capacity and ability to acclimate to changing environmental conditions. This review discusses the different classes of LHCs within photosynthetic eukaryotes and examines LHC diversification in different groups in a structural and functional context.     

Photoprotective energy dissipation involves the reorganization of photosystem II light-harvesting complexes in the grana membranes of spinach chloroplasts

Plants must regulate their use of absorbed light energy on a minute-by-minute basis to maximize the efficiency of photosynthesis and to protect photosystem II (PSII) reaction centers from photooxidative damage. The regulation of light harvesting involves the photoprotective dissipation of excess absorbed light energy in the light-harvesting antenna complexes (LHCs) as heat. Here, we report an investigation into the structural basis of light-harvesting regulation in intact spinach (Spinacia oleracea) chloroplasts using freeze-fracture electron microscopy, combined with laser confocal microscopy employing the fluorescence recovery after photobleaching technique. The results demonstrate that formation of the photoprotective state requires a structural reorganization of the photosynthetic membrane involving dissociation of LHCII from PSII and its aggregation. The structural changes are manifested by a reduced mobility of LHC antenna chlorophyll proteins. It is demonstrated that these changes occur rapidly and reversibly within 5 min of illumination and dark relaxation, are dependent on ΔpH, and are enhanced by the deepoxidation of violaxanthin to zeaxanthin.     

Photophysics of the carotenoids associated with the xanthophyll cycle in photosynthesis

Green plants use the xanthophyll cycle to regulate the flow of energy to chlorophylla within photosynthetic proteins. Under conditions of low light intensity violaxanthin, a carotenoid possessing nine conjugated double bonds, functions as an antenna pigment by transferring energy from its lowest excited singlet state to that of chlorophylla within light-harvesting proteins. When the light intensity increases, violaxanthin is biochemically transformed into zeaxanthin, a carotenoid that possesses eleven conjugated double bonds. The results presented here show that extension of the conjugation of the polyene lowers the energy of the lowest excited singlet state of the carotenoid below that of chlorophylla. As a consequence zeaxanthin can act as a trap for the excess excitation energy on chlorophylla pigments within the protein, thus regulating the flow of energy within photosynthetic light-harvesting proteins.     

Photoinhibitory damage is modulated by the rate of photosynthesis and by the photosystem II light-harvesting chlorophyll antenna size

We investigated the effect of photosynthetic electron transport and of the photosystem II (PSII) chlorophyll (Chl) antenna size on the rate of PSII photoinhibitory damage. To modulate the rate of photosynthesis and the light-harvesting capacity in the unicellular chlorophyte Dunaliella salina Teod., we varied the amount of inorganic carbon in the culture medium. Cells were grown under high irradiance either with a limiting supply of inorganic carbon, provided by an initial concentration of 25 mM NaHCO₃, or with supplemental CO₂ bubbled in the form of 3% CO₂ in air. The NaHCO₃-grown cells displayed slow rates of photosynthesis and had a small PSII light-harvesting Chl antenna size (60 Chl molecules). The half-time of PSII photodamage was 40 min. When switched to supplemental CO₂ conditions, the rate of photodamage was retarded to a t_1/2 = 70 min. Conversely, CO₂-supplemented cells displayed faster rates of photosynthesis and a larger PSII light-harvesting Chl antenna size (500 Chl molecules). They also showed a rate of photodamage with t_1/2 = 40 min. When depleted of CO₂, the rate of photodamage was accelerated (t_1/2  = 20 min). These results indicate that the in-vivo susceptibility to photodamage is modulated by the rate of forward electron transport through PSII. Moreover, a large Chl antenna size enhances the rate of light absorption and photodamage and, therefore, counters the mitigating effect of forward electron transport. We propose that under steady-state photosynthesis, the rate of light absorption (determined by incident light intensity and PS Chl antenna size) and the rate of forward electron transport (determined by CO₂ availability) modulate the oxidation/reduction state of the primary PSII acceptor Q_A, which in turn defines the low/high probability for photodamage in the PSII reaction center. Received: 14 August 1997 / Accepted: 26 September 1997     

Model of aggregation of pigments in the chlorosomal antenna of the green bacteria Chloroflexus aurantiacus

Independent experimental and theoretical evaluation was performed for the adequacy of our previously proposed general molecular model of structural organization of light-harvesting pigments in chlorosomal bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) c/d/e-containing superantenna of different green bacteria. Simultaneous measurement of hole burning in the optical spectra of chlorosomal BChl c and temperature dependence of steady-state fluorescence spectra of BChl c was accomplished in intact cells of photosynthetic green bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus; this allows unambiguous determination of the structure of exciton levels of BChl c oligomers in this natural antenna, which is a fundamental criterion for adequacy of any molecular model for in vivo aggregation of antenna pigments. Experimental data were shown to confirm our model of organization of oligometric pigments in chlorosomal BChl c antenna of green bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus. This model, which is based on experimental data and our theory of spectroscopy of oligomeric pigments, implies that the unit building block of BChl c antenna is a cylindrical assembly containing six excitonically coupled linear pigment chains whose exciton structure with intense upper levels provides for the optimal spectral properties of the light-harvesting antenna.     

Tubular exciton models for BChl c antennae in chlorosomes from green photosynthetic bacteria

Exciton calculations on tubular pigment aggregates similar to recently proposed models for BChl c/d/e antennae in light-harvesting chlorosomes from green photosynthetic bacteria yield electronic absorption spectra that are super-impositions of linear J-aggregate spectra. While the electronic spectroscopy of such antennae differs considerably from that of linear J-aggregates, tubular exciton models (which may be viewed as cross-coupled J-aggregates) may be constructed to yield spectra that resemble that of the BChl c antenna in the green bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus. Highly symmetric tubular models yield absorption spectra with dipole strength distributions essentially identical to that of a J-aggregate; strong symmetry-breaking is needed to simulate the absorption spectrum of the BChl c antenna.Abbreviations BChl bacteriochlorophyll - [E,M] BChl c _S bacteriochlorophyll c with ethyl and methyl substituents in the 8- and 12-positions, and with stearol as the esterifying alcohol     

Consequences of the reduction of the Photosystem II antenna size on the light acclimation capacity of Arabidopsis thaliana

In several systems, from plant's canopy to algal bioreactors, the decrease of the antenna size has been proposed as a strategy to increase the photosynthetic efficiency. However, still little is known about possible secondary effects of such modifications. This is particularly relevant because the modulation of the antenna size is one of the most important light acclimation responses in photosynthetic organisms. In our study, we used an Arabidopsis thaliana mutant (dLhcb2), which has a 60% decrease of Lhcb1 and Lhcb2, the two main components of the major Photosystem II antenna complex. We show that the mutant maintains the photosynthetic and photoprotective capacity of the Wild Type (WT) and adapts to different light conditions by remodelling its photosynthetic apparatus, but the regulatory mechanism differs from that of the WT. Surprisingly, it does not compensate for the decreased light-harvesting capacity by increasing other pigment-protein complexes. Instead, it lowers the ratio of the cytochrome b₆f and ATP synthase to the photosystems, regulating linear electron flow and maintaining the photosynthetic control at the level of these complexes as in the WT. We show that targeting the reduction of two specific antenna proteins, Lhcb1 and Lhcb2, represents a viable solution to obtain plants with a truncated antenna size, which still maintain the capacity to acclimate to different light conditions.     

Identification of the Chromophores Involved in Aggregation-dependent Energy Quenching of the Monomeric Photosystem II Antenna Protein Lhcb5

Non-photochemical quenching (NPQ) of excess absorbed light energy is a fundamental process that regulates photosynthetic light harvesting in higher plants. Among several proposed NPQ mechanisms, aggregation-dependent quenching (ADQ) and charge transfer quenching have received the most attention. In vitro spectroscopic features of both mechanisms correlate with very similar signals detected in more intact systems and in vivo, where full NPQ can be observed. A major difference between the models is the proposed quenching site, which is predominantly the major trimeric light-harvesting complex II in ADQ and exclusively monomeric Lhcb proteins in charge transfer quenching. Here, we studied ADQ in both monomeric and trimeric Lhcb proteins, investigating the activities of each antenna subunit and their dependence on zeaxanthin, a major modulator of NPQ in vivo. We found that monomeric Lhcb proteins undergo stronger quenching than light-harvesting complex II during aggregation and that this is enhanced by binding to zeaxanthin, as occurs during NPQ in vivo. Finally, the analysis of Lhcb5 mutants showed that chlorophyll 612 and 613, in close contact with lutein bound at site L1, are important facilitators of ADQ.