How to make a zone of polarizing activity: insights into limb development via the abnormality preaxial polydactyly

Early in vertebrate limb development, a program initiates that polarizes the limb along the antero-posterior axis. The mesenchyme at the posterior margin is ultimately responsible for the asymmetry due to a region called the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA). The ZPA produces and secretes the molecule SHH, which coordinates the patterning of the resulting digits. Preaxial polydactyly (PPD) is a commonly occurring limb abnormality; investigating the genetic basis of this defect has provided insights into our understanding of digit patterning. PPD disrupts limb asymmetry by producing an ectopic ZPA at the opposite margin of the limb bud. Mutations in the long-range, limb-specific regulatory element of the Shh gene are responsible for the defect. Genetic analysis of this limb abnormality provides an important approach in understanding the mechanisms that control digit patterning.     

Distance between AER and ZPA Is Defined by Feed-Forward Loop and Is Stabilized by their Feedback Loop in Vertebrate Limb Bud

In the development of organs, multiple morphogen sources are often involved, and interact with each other. For example, the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) and the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA) are major morphogen sources in the limb bud formation of vertebrates. Fgf expression in the AER and Shh expression in the ZPA are maintained by their positive feedback regulation mediated by diffusible molecules, FGF and SHH. A recent experimental observation suggests that the FGF-signal regulates the Shh expression in a feed-forward manner with activation and repression regulatory pathways. We study the coupled dynamics of Shh expression in the ZPA and Fgf expression in the AER, and the relationship of the relative position between AER and ZPA. We first show that with the feed-forward regulation only, the peak of ZPA activity can be formed distant from the AER as observed experimentally. Then, we clarify that the robustness of the ZPA spatial pattern to changes in system parameters is enhanced by adding the feedback regulation between the AER and the ZPA. Furthermore, sensitivity analysis shows that there exists the optimal feedback strength where the robustness is the most improved.     

Sonic hedgehog (SHH) specifies muscle pattern at tissue and cellular chick level, in the chick limb bud.

Development of the musculature in chick limbs involves tissue and cellular patterning. Patterning at the tissue level leads to the precise arrangement of specific muscles; at the cellular level patterning gives rise to the fibre type diversity in muscles. Although the data suggests that the information controlling muscle patterning is localised within the limb mesenchyme and not in the somitic myogenic precursor cells themselves, the mechanisms underlying muscle organisation have still to be elucidated. The anterior-posterior axis of the limb is specified by a group of cells in the posterior region of the limb mesenchyme, called the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA). When polarizing-region cells are grafted to the anterior margin of the bud, they cause mirror-image digit duplications to be produced. The effect of ZPA grafts can be reproduced by application of retinoic acid (RA) beads and by grafting sonic hedgehog (SHH)-expressing cells to the anterior margin of the limb. Although most previous studies have looked at changes of the skeletal patterning, ZPA and RA also affect muscle patterning. In this report, we investigated the role of SHH in tissue and cellular patterning of forearm wing muscles. Ectopic application of a localised source of SHH to the anterior margin of the wing, leading to complete digit duplication, is able to transform anterior forearm muscles into muscles with a posterior identity. Moreover, the ectopic source of SHH induces a mirror image duplication of the normal posterior muscles fibre types in the new posterior muscles. The reorganisation of the slow fibres can be detected before muscle mass cleavage has started; suggesting that the appropriate fibre type arrangement is in place before the splitting process can be observed.     

FGF signaling regulates mesenchymal differentiation and skeletal patterning along the limb bud proximodistal axis

Fibroblast growth factors (FGFs) are signals from the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) that are essential for limb pattern formation along the proximodistal (PD) axis. However, how patterning along the PD axis is regulated by AER-FGF signals remains controversial. To further explore the molecular mechanism of FGF functions during limb development, we conditionally inactivated fgf receptor 2 (Fgfr2) in the mouse AER to terminate all AER functions; for comparison, we inactivated both Fgfr1 and Fgfr2 in limb mesenchyme to block mesenchymal AER-FGF signaling. We also re-examined published data in which Fgf4 and Fgf8 were inactivated in the AER. We conclude that limb skeletal phenotypes resulting from loss of AER-FGF signals cannot simply be a consequence of excessive mesenchymal cell death, as suggested by previous studies, but also must be a consequence of reduced mesenchymal proliferation and a failure of mesenchymal differentiation, which occur following loss of both Fgf4 and Fgf8. We further conclude that chondrogenic primordia formation, marked by initial Sox9 expression in limb mesenchyme, is an essential component of the PD patterning process and that a key role for AER-FGF signaling is to facilitate SOX9 function and to ensure progressive establishment of chondrogenic primordia along the PD axis.     

Dual requirement of ectodermal Smad4 during AER formation and termination of feedback signaling in mouse limb buds

BMP signaling is pivotal for normal limb bud development in vertebrate embryos and genetic analysis of receptors and ligands in the mouse revealed their requirement in both mesenchymal and ectodermal limb bud compartments. In this study, we genetically assessed the potential essential functions of SMAD4, a mediator of canonical BMP/TGFß signal transduction, in the mouse limb bud ectoderm. Msx2‐Cre was used to conditionally inactivate Smad4 in the ectoderm of fore‐ and hindlimb buds. In hindlimb buds, the Smad4 inactivation disrupts the establishment and signaling by the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) from early limb bud stages onwards, which results in severe hypoplasia and/or aplasia of zeugo‐ and autopodal skeletal elements. In contrast, the developmentally later inactivation of Smad4 in forelimb buds does not alter AER formation and signaling, but prolongs epithelial‐mesenchymal feedback signaling in advanced limb buds. The late termination of SHH and AER‐FGF signaling delays distal progression of digit ray formation and inhibits interdigit apoptosis. In summary, our genetic analysis reveals the temporally and functionally distinct dual requirement of ectodermal Smad4 during initiation and termination of AER signaling. genesis 51:660–666. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Dynamic changes in the response of cells to positive hedgehog signaling during mouse limb patterning

In the vertebrate limb, the posteriorly located zone of polarizing activity (ZPA) regulates digit identity through the morphogen Sonic Hedgehog (Shh). By genetically marking Shh-responding cells in mice, we have addressed whether the cumulative influence of positive Shh signaling over time and space reflects a linear gradient of Shh responsiveness and whether Shh could play additional roles in limb patterning. Our results show that all posterior limb mesenchyme cells, as well as the ectoderm, respond to Shh from the ZPA and become the bone, muscle, and skin of the posterior limb. Further, the readout of Shh activator function integrated over time and space does not display a stable and linear gradient along the A-P axis, as in a classical morphogen view. Finally, by fate mapping Shh-responding cells in Gli2 and Gli3 mutant limbs, we demonstrate that a specific level of positive Hh signaling is not required to specify digit identities.     

The effect of the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA) on the anterior half of the chick wing bud

Removal of the posterior half of the chick wing bud between stages 17-22 results in failure of the anterior distal tissue to survive and differentiate. This observation has been interpreted in terms of a requirement by the anterior half of a factor supplied by the posterior half of the limb containing the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA). This relationship has been tested by grafting ZPA tissue to the posterior surface of the anterior half after posterior half removal. Grafts made proximally on the cut surface did not significantly improve survival and development, nor did the ZPA prevent the expansion of the cell death in the ANZ beyond its normal boundaries into the distal mesenchyme. However, when grafted distally the ZPA inhibited cell death in the apical mesenchyme and caused the anterior mesenchyme to change its normal prospective fate (radius and digit 2). In all these cases, in addition to digit 2, digit 3 and frequently also digit 4 differentiated. The anterior half went on to develop a full set of digits and zeugopod parts in almost 50% of cases, although no skeleton resulting from this regulation of the anterior half had totally size regulated. These results demonstrate a developmental 'rescue' effect by the ZPA, and further support the view that the ZPA has a central and unique function in normal limb bud development, controlling survival and differentiation of the mesenchyme along the anteroposterior axis.     

Patterning mechanisms controlling digit development

Vertebrate digits are essential structures for movement,feeding and communication.Specialized regions of the developing limb bud including the zone of polarizing activity(ZPA),the apical ectodermal ridge(AER),and the non-ridge ectoderm regulate the patterning of digits.Although a series of signaling molecules have been characterized as patterning signals from the organizing centers,the delicate cellular and molecular mechanisms that interpret how these patterning signals control the detailed digit anatomy remain unclear.Recent studies from model organisms and human hand malformations provide new insights into the mechanisms regulating this process.Here,we review the current understanding of the genetic networks governing digit morphogenesis.     

Targeted misexpression of constitutively active BMP receptor-IB causes bifurcation, duplication, and posterior transformation of digit in mouse limb

Members of bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) play important roles in many aspects of vertebrate embryogenesis. In developing limbs, BMPs have been implicated in control of anterior-posterior patterning, outgrowth, chondrogenesis, and apoptosis. These diverse roles of BMPs in limb development are apparently mediated by different BMP receptors (BMPR). To identify the developmental processes in mouse limb possibly contributed by BMP receptor-IB (BMPR-IB), we generated transgenic mice misexpressing a constitutively active Bmpr-IB (caBmpr-IB). The transgene driven by the mouse Hoxb-6 promoter was ectopically expressed in the posterior mesenchyme of the forelimb bud, the lateral plate mesoderm, and the whole mesenchyme of the hindlimb bud. While the forelimbs appeared normal, the transgenic hindlimbs exhibited several phenotypes, including bifurcation, preaxial polydactyly, and posterior transformation of the anterior digit. However, the size of bones in the transgenic limbs seemed unaltered. Defects in sternum and ribs were also found. The bifurcation in the transgenic hindlimb occurred early in the limb development (E10.5) and was associated with extensive cell death in the mesenchyme and occasionally in the apical ectodermal ridge (AER). Sonic hedgehog (Shh) and Patched (Ptc) expression appeared unaffected in the transgenic limb buds, suggesting that the BMPR-IB mediated signaling pathway is downstream from Shh. However, ectopic Fgf4 expression was found in the anterior AER, which may account for the duplication of the anterior digit. An ectopic expression of Gremlin found in the transgenic limb bud would be responsible for the ectopic Fgf4 expression. The observations that Hoxd-12 and Hoxd-13 expression patterns were extended anteriorly provide a molecular basis for the posterior transformation of the anterior digit. Together these results suggest that BMPR-IB is the endogenous receptor to mediate the role of BMPs in anterior-posterior patterning and apoptosis in mouse developing limb. In addition, BMPR-IB may represent a critical component in the Shh/FGF4 feedback loop by regulating Gremlin expression.